220958!OM%INAL TO CITY CLERK -1
CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL NO
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE
COUNCIL RESOLUTION — GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSION►
e-kn _0
.4r
i
I
RESOLVED, upon the pertinent appeal of the Housing
and Redevelopment Authority of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota,
under the Zoning Code, for relaxation of the 1 to 1 off - street
parking ratio requirement with respect to the high -rise housing
for senior citizens on property described as follows:
"Lots 1 through 5, Block l; Lots 1 through 4, Block 4;
Lots 2 through 7 Block 5, Lots 1 throigh 9, Block 6;
Lots 1 through 3, Block 13; and all of Lots 4 and 5,
Block 13, except part taken for highway; all in
Prospect Plateau Addition to St. Paul;
Lots 1 through 12, Lineau, Peters and Minea's
Rearrangement of Block 12, Bell's Addition to
West St. Paul;
All of Block 11, Bell's Addition to West St. Paul;
Lot "A" Bell's second addition to West St. Paul,
together with Isabel Street as vacated from the
east line of State Street to the west line of
Lot "All B-e11' -s second addition to West St. Paul;-- '
Lots l and 2, Block 2, Bell's second addition to
West St. Paul and Lots 1 and 2, Block 47, West St.
Paul Proper, except that portion of said lots lying
westerly of the east line of State Street as indicated
by granite monuments set by City Engineer of City
of St. Paul during the month of May, 1887, one of
which is upon south line of Isabel Street and the
other upon north line of Congress Street, same having
been conveyed to said City for uses and purposes of
public highway or street only; .i
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays
Dalglish
Holland
Loss
t Meredith
} Peterson
+ Rosen
Nlr, Vice President (Rosen)
loaf 6-62
4
i
Lots 3 and 4 and 5, Block
and Lots 3, 4 and 5, Block
to West St. Paul according
that part of said addition
Adopted by the Council 19—
47, West St. Paul Proper,
2, Bell's second addition
to the plat the reof , except
lying westerly of east line
Approved 19—
l'1 Tn Favor Al]��
D Against
4Bting Mayor
OiMGINAL TO CITY CLERK t . 0() V
CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL NO
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
COUNCIL RESOLUTION — GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSION
fi
t
i,
a
r
Yeas
4
i
Page 2.
of State Street as indicated by granite monuments
set up by City Engineer of City of St. Paul during
the month of May, 1887, one of which is upon south line
of Isabel Street and the other upon north line of
Congress Street;"
that the provisions of said Zoning Code are hereby determined
and varied, in their application, as and to the extent necessary
therefor, to relax the 1 to 1 off - street parkng ratio requirement
to a 1 to 3 off - street parking ratio with respect to said
housing project; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Housing and Redevelopment
Authority of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, be permitted
to install and operate a 139 -car off - street parking facility
on the above described real estate, in accordance with final
plans dated May 27, 1964, subject to the condition that said
appellant - applicant, and its successors and assigns, otherwise,
shall make due compliance- with -all applicable provisions of
municipal ordinances, State statutes and rules and regulations
of public authorities having cognizance.
COUNCILMEN
Nays
Dalglish
Holland
Loss
Tn Favor
Meredith
Peterson
o'�i s- �r—
..... �jY� ?ire S`1 e4 r::�:i1 d5iki
.. .......... ...I...................
11 o 1 vi2 President (Rosen)
(,L> Against
DEC 81964
Adopted by the Council 19—
Approved DEC 8 1' 19—
Acting Mayor
pulausla DEC 121964
r
r
<;:RD OF ZON -ING, CITY OF SAIN -T PAUL
••••• . •r? kt .INti W 251 -232 -253 1013 CITY HALL-AND COURT HOUSE - SAINT PAUL :!, MINNESOTA {
r,
t
F
1'
i
L
x
I
t
i
P
1
L
Mr. Robert B. Gerber Jr.
City Clerk
£ - August 25, 1964
- 9
t `
_._- .S
Building
Dear Sir:
This is in the matter of the application and appeal of the St. Paul
Housing and Redevelopment Authority for 1) a permit for a 139 car
off - street parking facility, and 2) relax the l to 1 off - street parking
ratio requirement to 1 to 3 with respect to the high -rise housing for
senior citizens on property known as the Dunedin Terrace Public Housing
Site. The legal description of the ,property is,attached. This pro-
perty was rezoned to a "C" residence district May 9, 1964 for this-,
specific development.
The Board of Zoning considered this matter at its regular meeting on
July 1, 1964. The staff reported that it is proposed to erect 22 four-
unit residences (88units) and one high -rise, 145 unit apartment structure
for senior citizens comprising a total of 233 units with off - street park-
ing for 139 cars.- The off - street parking lot plan meets all of the stand-
ards for-this type of facility, and has been approved by the Traffic
Engineer and staff.. The requested relaxation of the off - street parking
ratio appears reasonable and in keeping with similar relaxations granted
for residences for senior citizens. The Housing Authority reported that
the 1 - 3 off - street parking provided for its other facilities for Senior
Citizens is adequate.
Based on these findings, the Board of Zoning recommends the granting of
the appeal as outlined above, and the application for a 139 car off -
street parking facility on the above described property in accordance
with final plans May 27, 1964. It should be noted - that the City Council
granted an informal approval of this proposal on May 26, 1964.
Sincerely,
B. R. Teig A I.P.
Recording Secretary
BRT:FGI
Encl.
Z. F. 5421 -22 _
CC: Mr. Janes
:, cic' ^;'L.�•�_ -; - s--
.f*vs� -ve* °� "•,.w'�... - ..- ....�- ^^.�.-
- -•-T� +run "nr-- cw: -. -^ = T1^.nf _ °x +rr -= 'TC:'r.w- „w'R,. .a _, - ., - - .., -... ...: -n ._.... ,__�...., __.__. --•_ _.�_ -_� .
Viol" I Hie B 0 'd D a 2 d 110 11 b ; it if
•
'{SSw.r 'F 3
• _
r "
.:
_
;� .y ;i
,�, is •� ;ate N'y
•Dunedisa • orraco Site
Y L iT�{7 i r'� i r. i •.
I is i thru 3, Black l;
lute i tom' C A04_ 4- lots 2 thru 7. BlocU 5,
!
y •
- %ats 1 thru 9. Bwck 8;
Lts i the .�;jaloi* 13.; and gall of Dots 4 and '5,
3
Block 13 . part taken for rfi "'d, f:lli in pros pact Plateau Addition to
Ste raule
Ws i tbru 1 i
#s
, i aa,
Peto c. gid zavAa ao rr 8ioc3t , ll'a Addition
to West St. Pascal,
All of Block ll r.. Bell's Addition 68 vast Satint Psul.-
� a
lot W Bell* 9' l C0034 .4M. to Blest St.Puul togetbar vith dsabol Stradt ate
k t -vacated from the east UAO ref Sta Street tea thO UVOt line at Lot "A7
� .+ �,
f3$11'8 4 ition to West salat Pace...
Lots I =d 2,, Slack 2$ RQIII'sCiat Add.)t* &feat St.Paul and Lots l and 2,
Sdoab 47, rest Saint Paul prapora exWpt that portion of stud lots 'lying
_ Mara Of 06 m�asi
: °,'.. •, y line of State Street as indicated by ll;;ratalts »wanta set
_ by City Estlizoor of City of St.Paul durix' tho m=tb of may 1887,$ *L%e of which
x :f its uga» south JiM of Iaeaadsvl Stmt and the othor Upson anrth liar -of--co iis St.
same having bwa o=vqyW to Mid City for, as aacl = Purposw o.t gblua hil�;h>Aep�r
' > stmt only.
Lots 3 erd 4 OvA 5, SlOck 47, West St -F =l Pauper, and Lots 3, 4, aW 3 Blooms
>3ell�<21nd &Witioa) to West St.Pa:ul Aac:ordiM to the plat thereof, a =ept Matt
part of said addition lyl.ug uesterly of east line of ;Mats Stmt as indicated
E' by $rw4to rs aumemts sect up by City RjUjwer of City of St.Prcul during the
M=tb of UGy, 1887, Ons of WbAc t 19 upon South lines of Isabel St and the
otdor uoon north liu+e of Congrvsa:i atrwt." -
. d
I V1
1312 CI11A H f( d!1 on 6i HO 2 2 I l b of 3` NLN $1 2Cti1'9'
Viol" I Hie B 0 'd D a 2 d 110 11 b ; it if
City Clerk
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
224 -4612
+22
August 14, 1964
File 16528, 16529, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the
Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House at 10:00 a.m. on
August 27, 1964, on the application of the Housing & Redevelopment
Authority for:
(1) A permit to install and operate a 139 -car off - street parking
facility accessory to low -cost housing project.
(2) An appeal to relax the off - street parking requirements to one
to three for the proposed high -rise building for senior citizens.
The property is described as Lots 1 thru 5, Block 1; Lots 1 thru 4,
Block 4; Lots 2 thru 71 Block 5, Lots 1 thru 9, Block 6; Lots 1 thru
3, Block 13; and all of Lots 4 and 5, Block 13 ex. part taken for
Highway; all in Prospect Plateau Addition to St. Paul.
Lots 1 thru 12, Lienau, Peters and Minea's Rear. Block 12, Bell's
Addition to West St. Paul..
All of Block 11, Bell's Addition of West Saint Paul.
Lot "A" Bell's Second Add. to West St. Paul together with Isabel St.
as vacated from the east line of State St. to the west line of Lot
"A" Bell's Second Addition to West Saint Paul.
Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Bell's 2nd Add. to West St. Paul and Lots 1
and 2, Block 47, West Saint Paul Proper, except that portion of said
lots lying westerly of the east line of State St. as indicated by
granite monuments set by City Engineer of City of St. Paul during the
month of May 1887, one of which is upon south line of Isabel St. and
the other upon, north line of Congress St. same having been conveyed to
said City for uses and purposes of public highway or street only.
Lots 3 and 4, and 5, Block 47, West St. Paul Proper, and Lots 3, 4,
and 5, Block 2, Bells 2nd Add. to West St. Paul according to the plat
thereof, except that part of said addition lying westerly of east line
of State Street as indicated by granite monuments set up by City
Engineer *of City of St. Paul during the month of May, 1887, one of
which is upon south line of Isabel Street and the other upon north
line of Congress Street. The property is located in the vicinity
of Dunedin Terrace.
For further information call at Room 1315, Court House or phone
224 -4612, Extension 251.
JAMES J. DALGLISH
Commissioner of Finance
APPEAL REQUESTING RELAXATION OF
THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 60.23,
SUBDIVISION 3, OF THE ZONING CODE
OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Honorable Mayor and City Council
c/o City Clerk
4 City Hall and Court House
fi Saint Paul, Minnesota
r
u
Gentlemen:
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 64.03, Subsection "t ",
the Housing and
r
Redevelopment Authority of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota in connection with the
construction of Dunedin Terrace Low Rent Housing Project, Minn. 1 -9,
located in the
City of Saint Paul, County of Ramsey, State of Minnesota on those certain
tracts of
land more fully described as follows:
u Lots 1 thru 5, Block 1; Lots 1 thru 4, Block 4;
Lots 2 thru 7, Block 5; Lots 1 thru 9, Block 6;
Lots 1 thru 3, Block 13; and all of Lots 4 and
5, Block 13 except that part taken for Highway;
` all in Prospect Plateau Addition to Saint Paul.
FLots 1 thru 12, Lineau, Peter's and Minea's
Rearrangement of Block 12, Bell's Addition to
i West St. Paul.
h
U
All of Block 11, Bell's Addition to West Saint
4 Paul together with Isabel Street as vacated from
the East line of State Street to the West line
i of Lot "A" Bell's Addition to West Saint Paul.
F
Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Bell's Addition to West
St. Paul, and Lots 1 and 2, Block 47, West Saint
Paul Proper, except that portion of said lots
lying Westerly of the East line of State Street
as indicated by granite monuments set by City
Engineer of City of St. Paul during the month of
T May, 1887, one of which is upon the South line
of Isabel Street and the other upon North line
of Congress Street; same having been conveyed
to said City for uses and purposes of public
highway or street only.•dG
" Lots 3 and 4 and 5, Block 47, West St. Paul Proper,
and Lots 3, 4 and 5, Block 2, Bell's Second Addition
to West Saint Paul, according to the plat thereof,
except that part of said addition lying Westerly of
�
++ East line of State Street as indicated by granite
1r
monuments set up by City Engineer of City of St. Paul,
during the month of May, 1887, one of which is upon
South line of Isabel Street and other upon North
line of Congress Street.
trequests variance of Section 60.23, Subsection 3 of the Zoning Code
to permit one
off - street parking space for each three dwelling units in the high
rise building
for the elderly to be located in that block-of said project bounded
by State Street,
L Winifred Street, Congress Street and Ada Street.
t
t
5521
-
i
r.
r.
i
i,
f
i•
M
T
r
Y
E
The Authority has made application for offstreet parking permit for 139
vehicle spaces for the Dunedin Terrace Project on the basis of 88 spaces for the
88 family units proposed for the project and 51 spaces for the 145 units for the
elderly. On the basis of need surveys heretofor conducted by the Authority at the
Mt. Airy Hi -Rise Building for the elderly a 1 to 3 ratio has been deemed more than
sufficient to handle parking for the residents and their visitors. A 1 to 3 ratio
has been approved by your Honorable Body for the Valley Apartments, Neill Apartments
and Central Apartments and has likewise proved sufficient to adequately handle the
parking needs of these projects for the elderly. The Authority therefore requests
relaxation of the offstreet parking requirements of the Zoning Code to provide 51
vehicle spaces for the 145 units in the Dunedin Hi -Rise Building.
Respectfully submitted,
ZONING APPEAL
Notice is hereby given that a public
HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
hearing will be held benre the City
Council at 10 A.M. on August 27, 1964,
OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA
,
in the City Council Chamber in the
City Hall and Court House, in the
matter of the appeal of Housing and
Redevelopment Authority, under Chap-
ters 60 to 64 inclusive, St. Paul Leg-
islative Code, Zoning Code, to relax
y
the off -street parking requirements for
Executive Dirt r
ec
one to three for the proposed high -rise
building for senior citizens on the fol-
lowing described property:
Lots 1 through 5, Block 1; Lots 1
through 4, Block 4; Lots 2 through
7, Block 5; Lots 1 through 9, Block
6; Lots 1 through 3, Block 13; and
all of Lots 4 and. 5, Block 13, ex-
cept part taken for Highway; all
in Prospect Plateau Addition to St.
Paul.
Lots 1 through 12, Lienau, Peter's
and Minea's, Rearrangement of
Block 12 Bell's Addition to West
St. Paul.
All of Block 11, Bell's Addition to
West Saint Paul.
Lot 'A" Bell's Second Addition to
West St. Paul together with Isabel
Street as vacated from the east line
of State Street to the west line of
Lot "A ", Bell's Second Addition to
West St. Paul.
Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Bell's Second
Addition to West St. Paul, and Lots
1 and a, Block 47, West Saint Paul
Proper, except that portion of said
lots lying westerly of the east line
of State St, as indicated by granite
monuments set by City Engineer of
City of Saint Paul during the month
of May, 1887, one of which is upon
south line of Isabel St. and the
other upon north line of Congress
St., same having been conveyed tow
said City for uses and purposes of
Public highway or street only.
Lots 3 and 4 and 5, Block 47, West
St. Paul Proper, and Lots 3, 4 and
5, Block 2, Bell's Second Addition
to West St. Paul, according to the
Plat thereof, except that part of
said addition lying westerly of east
line of State Street as indicated by
Enginee
of City Of St. Paul during
the• month' of May, 1887, one of
which is upon south line of Isabel
Street and the other upon north
line of Congress Street. The prop-
erty is located in the vicinity of
Dunedin Terrace.
Dated August 13, 1964.
ROBERT B. GERBER, Jr.,
City Clerk.
(August 15, 1984)
-2-