Loading...
216427 � t= .�i ' ,� ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK Council File No. 218427—By Bernard T. ►� FIolland— ���6/�� r� _ __..� � CITY OF ST:,;�ereas. Curtis A. LaPre, an em- IL NO. � �loyee of the Boazd of Water Commis- < OFFICE OF THE ��ne=S of the City aP Saint Paul wes � iured during the course of his em- � � C�UNC� RESOLUTION-h'ai?*s�r�k���n c rtainl Workmen's Comh � �. � a;�; � / � �SsH��r,Yl��%��ift� and �'�T _'i � r�, PRESENTED BY � � •!II r r.�� � �nF1•�yf:� flled a claim �---�`�', . COMMISSIONE � �F p' 7 �� • •al beneflts _ - � �a :a�•���'��—Y1 y .7r�. teP+ _ � ' . ' .IT:x.:��f;..._ fi� i- q�'�,r .�•r. . , WHEREAS, Curtis A. La Pri, an employee of the Board of Water Commissioners of the City of iaint Paul was injured during the course of his employment on April 10, 1961 for which he was paid certain Workmen's Compensatiol benefits and WHEREAS, said employee fi�led a claim petition for certain additional benefits which the City disputes, and ' , WHEREAS, the�e has been negotiated as between employee, � counse°1 for said employee and the office of the Corporation � Counsel,a copy of Stipulation £or said Settlement being attached � hereto marked Exhibit A and made a part hereof by reference. N � - 0 o NOW THEREFORE BE IT , o �-':'-_. " - - - - - _ �' o � �RESOLVED, that the Counci�l hereby ratifies said Stipulation � � n for Settlement and authorizes �the proper City officers to make d 0 U ' � N payment in compliance with th� AwaYd of the Industrial Commission �' tA � a issued in conformance therewith, paymerns to be made thereunder as follows: $1, 170.00 representing 26 weeks of temporary total \ disability at $45.00� a week, COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays Dalglish Holland � A rov d Loss •� Tn Favor Mortinson ` ' Peterson V A gainst Rosen Mr. President, Vavoulis ionz s-sz ORIGINAL TO CITY GLERK r–� i• - • . CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCi� ����� 9 �� , . , OFFICE OF� THE CITY CLERK FILE NO. � � ' COUNC RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COM M I551 O N E DATF — 1 _� $42. 00 to Dr. Gerhard E. Knutson, St. Paul, Minnesota� for medical care, ! $25 .00 to Martin Ambulanc1 , $25 .00 to Dr. Shirley Mink, said payments when made tl constitute full and final settlement of all claims for disability resulting from personal injury sustained April 10, 1961, while in the employ of the above named employer, pro- vided that said employer from the sum of �1,170.00 shall pay to Messrs . Hansen and Hazen, St. Paul, stipulated attorney's £ees in the sum of $292.50, which when paid shall constitute complete satis- faction for a11 legal services rendered herein. �... ---� � " - 2 - ' . JAN 3 U 1964 COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Y�s Nayg J;4N 3 01964 Dalglish Holland Approved , 19— �gg 1 � Tn Favor I Mortinson 1 Peterson (1 � Mayor v I gainst Mr. President, Vavoulis lOD4 8-82 f • a I � . . i r ;�t, �} . , ' - . a,.��: . DUr4G�TE TO rRINTlR ' • � � ������ CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCi� �'" ' � . . OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE NO. _ COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONER DATF WHEREAS, Curt3,s A� La Pre� an employee of the Board of Wat�r Commissioners of the City of Sa �'nt Paul was injured during the , � i course of his ewployraent on April 10, 1961 for which he was paid � certain Work�en's Compensation b�enefits and � I � WHEREAS, said employee f3.le`d a claim petition for certain � additional benef3.ts which the City disputes, and WHEREAS, these has been negot3ated as between e�ployee, counsel for said c��p].oyee and the office of the Corporat�on Counsel,a copy of Stipulation for said Setfilement being a�Ctached � , hereto marked Exhibit A and made'� a part hereof by reference. NOW THBREFORE BE IT ' RESOLVBD, that the Council hereby rat�fies said Stipulation ' for Settlement and authorizes the proper City officers to make , payTaent in compliance with the Award of the Tndustrial Com�nission issued in conformance �therewith, payrnerts to be made thereunder , as follows: � �1,170. i 00 representing 26 weeks of temporary total di�abilit�r at $45.00 a iweek, ' � COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays � Dalglish Holland Approved 1g_ , �ss In Favor Mortinson Peterson Mayor A gainst Rosen � Mr. President, Vavoulis ioaz s-sa DUrLIC�TE TO rRIN7ER ' , ��`J��� . �-' � • CITY OF ST. PAUL FILENCIL NO. _ . . OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONER ' DATE �42.00 to Dr. Gerhard E. Kn,utson, St. Paul, Minnesota for med�cal ca�ce, �25.00 to Martin Ambulance,� �25.00 tv Dr. Shirley Mink,i � said payments when made ta constitute full and final settlement of all claims for disability resul�ing fram personal injury sus�ained � April 10, 1961, while in the employ of the above named e�ployer� pro- � vided that said employer from the sum of $1,170.00 shall pay to � , Messrs. Hansen and Hazen, St. Pa�l, stipulated attorney's fees in ' the sum of �292.50, which when paid shall constitute complete satis- faction for all legal services re�ndered herein. � a ' ; - 2 - � � �Ar� 3 � �'�� � COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays ' Dalglish �� ,,y ; � ���� Holland � Approved 1g_ � Losa In Favor Mortinson ' � Mayor � Peterson R�Q� o��' Against I I Mr. President, Vavoulis � iont e-s2 � • • , ... ' , ��:.. (,� -.--� ._.__.�__.�- - r__.___._ �; L�.__�. .�.....:._.�..._.__. �� _ _ � _ Lc.�' � �ur�Y _ IAdO��', AdOD+°- J...�.�.• '.•. ..,�.- . . ~ 1AdOJV �Jrl.i y� , . ;,Oa3� ,, S `. _ 02f3X 1 !OLi7X • h� . ;: ��.� �. �' � '. R y �i.��• .I� 'A�� il..\..%rlr.i'ry ' ,i � . ' ` �� lY � • ��� ' STATE�OF MINNESOTA - . ���,�.� INDUS�RIAL COMMI55fOPi � DIV1910N OF WORKMEN'3 COMPENSATION � w ST. PAUL 1 ' File No. 277223 EXHIBIT ' A' � . Record. No. 8048C STIPUL9TION FOR SETTLEP�IENT Curtis Ao Za Pre, , �nployee, -vs- � City of St. Paul (St. Paul !Wat er Department ) , Employer, a.nd , , . Self, � Insurer. s The folloVring stipulation for settlement ��aas diotated into the record before George Hottinger, Rezeree for the Industrial �ommission, on the 13�h day of January, 1�64, at St. Pau1. �•tayne P. DordeZl# appeared as attorney for the- employee and Rober� E. Faricy appeared as attorney for the employ� and insurer. ' BY THE 1�FEP�EE: . For the record. The paxties hereto in lieu of formal hearing stipulate a.nd agree as follows: , � � , , ' .�I. . � , , That on and prior to the lOth day of Lpril, 1g61, Gurtis A. La Pre was in the employ� of the Board of Water Commissioners, City of St . tau7., in. the capacity of a Water meter repairman, under a Minne�ota contract of hire, at a monthly wa�e of �44-6.00, � being a five-da� week. ' - • SI . That on said date this employee suffered a personal - in�ury arising out of and i� the cour.se of his emplo�rment . � III . � That the respondenis had statutory notice a.n�. knowledge . of said in�ury. � IV. � That as a result of said in�ury the employer paid to the petitioner �the sum of �351.00, �representing 7 4/5 weeks of temporary � total disability at �45.00 a week and medical and hospital egpense ' in the total sum of �1,683.50. BY YdR. DO RDELI,: . V. 'f " It is the conte�tion and position of the �em�ployee that - � � n� - ..� � . � • , �,.'� s:,::; � ,�. � , ',��`�,, � ' . ry'`;�{r-•+;y�r�r'.x :s't,:_ . :�..� � � � _ ,.. ' - � . �s' rb�h : -..s • . .:� ' + ' • .t'i•'F . • ' '�+. •.I � �i1.�i , x .� ' ��t�uM � 1�' . .�X , . �' y . �•..�'' �:� - . _ ,. . • ' , �-,��jT� «,,d..i : .�tiy��'.}., sT �.+�. � ��.��`:•�+s'�,."t,t'"�` .. . „ . .. ' -Y. 4`i3a.j�:� ,". k�r. � . . �,i. ' , '� _.t '�i'�'• S-.{itr,.S..'}��1isy'•y�;�w.��.-� � ' t+,+ � ' ' . , r�:heC�Sr.i � ._,�4- • �.�� I 7�� 4 .. R'�� �L.i+�;f�:-1�3'T�!�,'�^ati • . ��r...i -�--�._ .__.__.� _.._.._._ � ' -' ,...� -__�_.___..._---- - � �- . ..__ .. ta r i � � . l,lf�'��- ,�Ad00 ' , . '.+AdOD�, i AdODF�i -. .�r1.1%�. . 'OLf3X�., � :�OL13X �OLI7a H Yr °� ..a,y,� ^g�- . t , L.'„ .I.I+�9 }•f r'fr'.a� , t'`.r r'�'#' .^.r,t_'ri�i � r � after returning to work on� June 5, 1961, he eontinued to have difficulty per�orm�ng his �wor� as a result of said in�ury and subsequently �cras asked to �resign, said resignatiori to be effect3.ve on August 3, 1961. VI• It is further the contention of said employee that he has been temporarily totally d3.sabled as a resuit of said in.�ury from September 4, 1961, to November 7, 1961, from June 22, 1962, � to �eptiember 26, 1962, axid �rom Niarch 49 1963, to �ugust 4, 1963, for a �ot a3 period of 45 weeks. - �JII . . It is further the�con.tention of said emplo;�ee that he � has incurred the following expenses as a result of said in�ury. Dr. Gerhard E. S��nutson ------------- .-------�?�`�•00 T�artin Ambul�,n.ce� ------------�---�--___f--------�25*00 ' Miller Hospi�Gal __..------____�--------------.-�.�96,20 Dr. Shirely .N�ink ----------------�________----�25.00 That these expenses are unpaido ' BY MR, FARICY: � VIII. ' It is the contention of the employer herein that the' • disability of the employee from and after �eptember 4, 1961, does not arise out of the in�uries sust ained in his industrial accident of Apr.il 10, 19;61, and that the medical egpenses enunciated by the emnlo�ee a,re furt�her n.ot connected with the claimed dis- . abilities resulting fro�� said industrial accidento � (discussion off� the record) , BY MR. DORDEI,Z: ' On �he record. IX. • � " �ow, therefore, the parties have agreed upon a settlement sub�ect to the appraval �of the Industrial �or�miss�.on as folloj�s: ' The Board of Tr�ater Comm.issioners of the C�ity of St . Paui agrees to pa� the sum of °�1,170.00 representing 26 weeks of -temporary ' tot al disability at the sum of �45.00 per week. - X. � • It is further agreed �hat �25.00 sha11 be paid directly to l�7artin Ambulance, �25000 sha7.1 be gaid directly to Dr. Shirely ' i�link and ���.00 shall � paid di.rectly to Dr. Knutson. � . � _. 2 � . . r ' , ' . :• ; . .. , . - ,� ' . ., _ .��•�W'� . . • . , � ��i , . .� ( ...'�t . _ _. _....._...._ .._w� _. t..i ___, .. ---------_.__.�._- - �..,. �. _ .. _ ._. .. L�q 5 � i.uJ:Y � �.kAdOD i�' . AdOO�rJ 'alAdODt,J rrrl:f/'� OL13X�, F �OLf3X �OLi3% _ . . n.r�r "'�� �� ,�,,,r �. - " s F, �.;� �. , ih�' r`'S �y _, • , 'i.r_M;.i:.^t ' �ti,`.�`'i'�?•`I . . BY THE RE�'EREEt , , • • . , . . . , , , i , , ` ' • , . Xi,. ' . , • Sa,�.d pa�n�nt when made and approved by the Industrial Cornmission, shall constitute a full, final a.n.d complete settlement of all elaims for disability ariain.g out of personal in�ur� suatained by the emp].oyee on the lOth da� of' 9.pril, 196I., while in the enploy of the a�ove named. empioysr. . . ' ; BY r7R. DORDELI,: . , . �. •. � � . • �, . � . , , . . . � ' ' XII. ` ` It is further agreed by and� between the said employee � ' a.nd his attor�.ey I,awren.ce Hazen that the reasonable and a�reed , fee for the services rendered by said attorney to the emplo,yee , herein is' �292.50. ' ' BY MR. FARIC�: • . . ` . , . . , . . • ' XIII ... , . , .. „ . , ... . . . � Ihis may be paird directl'y� to �the attorneys for �petitioner by the emplo�rer from sai.d compensation. .; , BY T� RFFFRE�: � , . . You �ight add this sentence. Said. payment when. made, ; shall constitute comple-�e satisfaction for legal servi�ces reno�red herein. r � Il I5 FU�`iHER QRDERED that the petitior� filed herein ,be dismissed. � , , , � , THE REFEREE; Tkf you will raise your right hand, Curtis, , ' - and b e swo rn. , � . � CIIRfCIS A. LA PRE , , , Ca1�.ed and sworn in his awn. behalf, testified as follows: EXAi�i?NAS.'ION � ' � BY THE RFFEP�E: , , • ` � . . ` . ' Q You are Curtia La Pre, the employee in this preceeding here •. today? , . , � `. A Yes. ' ' . .;. . � ' Q You u�cierstand that the employer had paid oompensation in the �,�� sum of �351.Q0 to�-dateY . , ;, A Y�s. . j � . . • � � • • • Q Representing 7� 4/5 jeeks of temporary total disab�.l3.ty at �45.00 ��� ' a t�e,ek? !� '�0p. . . . ' ` • � . . . r .�. .r - � :;��M:;,,.i',r' " .Y..l�.•�' .�t•.�i'�F (� . ��n � ��••l.. r' ' • .. . .�LI.y'�jy A•'a . . ' .'� ,� , .�.. � . . • . . •ti;}�, • • ..k�� . "5-• :;' .�. � ' . �, , ' • � ' � � • ,� ' � • � . , , , � .RJ;J , r 1� •. ' , :�{��a , . . .. . ,• , • , y . . . , . . ' . .� �� _ � � � Q And the� have also paid medical a.nc� hospi-tal expense o�' �i,683.Go� g Xese Q Now, the only issue in this matter is the disability resuZtin�, from your in�ury that you sustainea o�. 9.pri1 Z0, 1g61 . I-� � is your• claim that .you have h�.d a.total o� 45 ��reeks of tem�orary total aisability from September 4, 1.9�1, to Alz�;ust 4th af' 1963, broken dosti7n as fol�laws: Temporary total dis�.bility �rom September �-, 1961, to November 7s 1961, Jvne 22, '62, ,to , September 26, �62,�� and from t�arch 4, , '63, to Av�ust 4, 19b3, a.nd the follo�ing �items. �e�ain unpaid: �re kn.utson ��17.00, r�laz�G�n �,ribularice �25.00 a.n.d Dr. l�iink �25.00, and this ite� with the ��Illler �o1spital of �g6,20 -- A That's right . � , , , _ Q ' -- whicb, as I unders±,a,nd, �ras' incurred for �creatment that was � not related to the� particular in�ury and efiec�s thereo�', is th�,t right 2 � That 's righ-t e , Yes�. r A, �tell -- • � . A Yes, sorrye � . � , , Q ��pell, I don.'t know egcept -- whereas the employer the Board • of ��ater Com�issioners, City of St . Paul, elaim that any disability that you svffered after 5ep-�enber 4, 1961, and any nedical or other expense incurred thereafter was not the• resul-t of the injury, sustained on April 10, 1961, thatts � �� their claim? Zf you t�lll say yes or no, so she can take it �� doS�rn. • � Oh, I e� sorry. , , , . , Q - Is that correc�? � A ' Yes, - Q You unders-�andY . � , 'A � I underst and, yes: . � ' � Q ., H�Svever, noti•r�.°thstand.ing ,you� claim in this matt er a.nd the City's claim the Cit�* has agr�eed to pay to you and you have agreed to accept as follows: In addition. to the compensation aid of ` ' p �3��.00 the �s�am of �1,170.00 t�hich is due a.nd payable, � Yes. . Q And that .represents; 2�6 weeks at ��-5.00 a s;reek, . , A Yese . . i , pay the� sum of ' � / Q �di31 ��+2.00 to Dr: Rnutson, 3�artin, .dmbulance ' �25.00, to Dr. IvTinkk �25.00. • • , A Yes. Q �In the ev�nt of� approval by the Commission, this settlemen� � �•ri1Z constitute a cor�p�.ete ad�ustne�t aud set�lement of your , claim �or disability resulting fron the in�ury that you sustained on April 10, lg6io � � , . • , � A ; i understand. � . . ., � ,:.. . . i Q gnd do you or da you not wish the Com�issi.on to approve thi,s ' settle�aent? _ A I do, yes. �;` ' .- ,•„ . .` , . .- , Q You have a�reecl:;to pay to your attorn�ys Hansen an�d. Hazen the XCRO ��XEFO r/� :�XERO 7,, �/�5+�� �COP��' S�� �� .��COPY��I•„1 a,,,S fees fo� serv3ces ��o�Yr.�'ed in �il��J natte_r, : ����;-, , E� . ._ - -_w . - a, • _ , e� -- - _,_ ° . - ,_ .�..... -. -;� . ._ . . . .__..__ .._ . . �. � . ' . � ( � •.yl _ .... _...__�_._.�_,,..._ �'..; ` .. __._.______�__._.--. _ 6`-. .� . .._._. _. L.. 1�!t��` ��jAdOJ� . ' �R, AdOJ�'.:= AdOJJ ��'f��i�4 :Oli3X�� ' �.f e� ;.�OL13X �O`J7X _ , . � . '-��c:- _ y �+"_ . YS_ • '� 1,� ,+iG , � 1.�.,. �-.t irir,_+.a�...fd and is that ,aggeeable with you?, � , • �. Yes. , • � . THE t�EFEREE; Any qtzestions, Gentlemen? � ' I�ZR.� F.�RICi: No. : ' ' � . . � , . , . , ' g2t�. �ORD�LL: • �No . . ' . , ' , . , � . • . , •. . • , , - , - � . . , , . , . , • . . . , , • . . �, � . . . , , • � . ,r. ' , , ' • , - � � , , , . • ;4 � . ,. . • � , . , , , , � ' � , � , • . . . r • ' $'s 9'c • , �if� , . � • . . '� ' �� . � . • � � • ' � � o t,'' o ' � �. ; . � . .