06-49Council File # �Q,�� \
Ordinance #
Green Sheet # 3029031
RESOLUTION
Presented By
Referred To
PAUL, MINNESOTA
mittee
ty
i
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Registered Land Survey and Adjustment of Common Boundaries for x�oc 5'" Street East
WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Housing and Redevelopment Authority and the City of Saint Paul Parks
Department, Zoning File # 05-183-851, has submitted for City Council approval the attached adjustment of
common boundaries and subdivision (RLS) dividing RLS #570 into north and south tracts to be tied to
newly reconfigured Parks parcel (PIN # 32-29-22-33-0260) and HRA property/Markethouse parking lot
(PIN # 32-29-22-33-0256), at the xxx 5th Street East, between Broadway and Olive; and
WHEREAS, the appropriate City departments have reviewed the RLS and adjustment of common
boundaries and found, subject to the recommended condition, that it meets the requirements of Chapter 69
of the Zoning Code; and
WHEREAS, notice of public hearing before the City Councii was duly published in the official newspaper of
the City on November 21, 2005, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and
property situated wholly or partiy within 350 feet of the subject property; and
WHEREAS, the City Council held a public hearing on the proposed RLS and adjustment of common
boundaries and on December 7, 2005, at which all interested parties were given an opportunity to be heard,
the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the RLS and adjustment of
common boundaries;
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council accepts and approves the attached RLS and
adjustment of common boundaries for the Saint Paul Housing and Redevelopment Authority and the City of
Saint Paul Parks Department dividing RLS #570 into north and south tracts to be tied to the newly
reconfigured Parks parcel (PIN # 32-29-22-33-0260) and HRA property/Markethouse parking lot (PIN # 32-
29-2233-0256), subject to the condition that the applicant shall file a copy of the Council Resolution
approving the RLS and adjustment of common boundaries with the Ramsey County Recorder's Office.
Requested by Department of:
Planning & Economic De�vel_o�
Adopted by Council:
Adoption Certified by Council Secreta�
By: �
Approved b ayor: Date: � !�7 (�
By:
��
Form Approved by City Attomey �
� GreemSheet GreemSheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet �
Departmentloifice/council: Dafe Initiated: `� `r ��
PE — p��g&EconomicDevelapmem �� Green Sheet NO: 3029031
Contact Person & Phone:
Emity Ulmer
Z6G-6591
Must Be on Council Ayen�
Contrad Type:
AR-f2ESOLU710N W/$ 7R4NSACTION
� '
Total # of SignaW re Pages _(Clip NI Locations for SignaW re)
Action Requested:
Adopt a resolurion memorializing City Councii action approving the RLS and Adjustment of Common Boundaries for the property
located at �ac Sth Sheet, between Broadway and Olive. The public hearing was held on December 7, 2005.
Planning Commission
CIB Committee
CiHI Service Commission
Personal5ervice Gontracts MustMSwerthe Following Questions:
1. Has this persoNfirtn e�er wwked under a contract for this department?
Yes No
2. Has this persoMfirtn eaer been a city employee?
Yes No
3. Does this persoNfirm possess a skill rat nortnally possessed by any
cufrent city employee?
Yes No
Explain all yes answers on sepa2te sheetand atfach to green sheet
ASSign 1 lao ' &EconomicDevelo De ar[mentD'vec[or
Numper 2 oaucial Semcet Rjce Ftinancial Servi
For 3 . � �1•4
Routing
pbe� 4 a or•s Office Ma or/A sis[ant
5 ooncil (titv ('nuncil
6 i Clerk Gti erk
Initiating Probiem, Issues, Opportuniry (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
The Saint Paul HRA has applied for an adjustment of common boundry including a Registered Land Survey no. 570 adjusting the
common boundazies of the property owned by the Saint Paul Housing and Redevelopment Authority (fIliA) and the Pazks Departlnent.
The 1'roposed RLS and adjustment of common boundaries will transfer ownership from Pazks to the HRA to allow for a parking lc
owned by Mazket Lofts Condominiums. The City Couucil approved the RLS and adjustment of common boundry on December 8, 200:
after a public hearing.
Advantages IfApproved:
The RLS and adjustment of common boundty will be adopted per City Council intent.
Disadvantages MApproved:
None.
RECEIVEQ
r.. F3e.��reh
InitiaUDate
Disadvantages It Not Approved:
City Council acrion will not be completed.
fiv1AY�JR'S OFFii,E �EC 2 9 20�
TransaMion:
Funtling Source:
Financial Information:
(Explain)
�QOZ c ? ���
�����f��4..J I
. � �r voos � �
Cosi/Revenue BudgeMd:
ActivityNumber. ��A1�� 8 �'6.9 ����
a� i v
December9, 200512:41 PM Page 1
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNlNG
& ECONOMICDEVELOPMENT
Susan Kimberly, DireCtor
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Randy C. Kelly, Mayor
November 17, 2005
Ms. Mary Erickson
City Council Research Office
Room 310 City Hall
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
Dear Ms. Erickson:
L=1
a,Q \
25 West Fourlh Street Telephone: 651-266-6700
SaintPaul,MN55/02 Facsimile:65/-218-3120
FOTiCE OF POBIdC HEAHING
I would like to confirm that a public hearing before the City Council
Wednesday, December 7, 2005, for the following zoning case:
� 1Le Saint Paul (9ty Cwna1 cvffi conduct a
public hearing on Wednesday, December
7, 2005 at 5:30 p.m. m thr (,9ry Co�mcll
CLambers, 1liird F1oor City Hall, 15 West
Kellogg Boulevazd, St. Paul, MN, to
cronsider the application of the Housing
and RcdevelopmentAuthortty of the Ctty of
SainY Paul for a Subdivlsiori Registered
land Suxvey (RI.S) divIding RLS 570 into
north and south �acts at aQac 5th Street,
between ,Broadway and Olive Street.
(Zoning File No. 05-1S3-S51)
Dated: November 17, 2005
MARY ERICKSON
Assistant City Council Secretary
(Nwember 21)
81: PAUL IEGAL L�fiER
2R106908
is scheduled for
Zoning File Number: 05-183-851
Applicant: Housing and Redevelopment Authority of the City of Saint Paul
Address: xxx 5`" Street, between Broadway and Olive Street
Purpose: Subdivision Registered Land Survey (RLS) dividing RLS 570 into
north and south tracts.
Previous Action:
City staff has reviewed the Registered Land Survey for the property located at xxx 5` Street,
and now recommend approval. The City Council has until February 17, 2005, to adopt a
resolution either approving or disapproving the final RLS. A staff report will be prepared and
provided to the Council the week prior to the public hearing.
I have confirmed this day with Councilmember Thune's office. My understanding is that this
public hearing request will appear on the agenda for the December 7, 2005, City Council
meeting and that you will publish notice of the hearing in the Saint Paul Legal Ledger at least 10
days in advance of the public hearing. Please call me at 266-6591 if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
��I� lll��-_
Emily Ulmer
City Planner
cc: File #: 05-183-851
Applicant: Housing and Redevelopment Authority of the City of Saint Paul
Markethouse Condominiums
City of Saint Paul Parks Department Att: Don Ganje
Paul Dubruiel
Wendy Lane
Carol Martineau
Allan Torstenson
SUBDIVISION STAFF REPORT
FILE # 05-183-851
HEARING DATE: December 7, 2005
1. APPLICANT: Housing and Redevelopment Authority of the City of Saint Paul, MN
2. TYPE OF APPLICATION: Preliminary and Finai Registered Land Survey and Adjustments of
Common Boundaries
3. LOCATION: xxx 5"' Street, between Broadway and Olive Street
�
�
4. PIN AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION: 32-29-22-33-0256 and 32-29-22-33-0256; SECTION 32 TOWN
29 RANGE 22 TRACT A RLS NO 570 & IN SD SEC 32 TN 29 RN 22; PART OF VACATED
PORTIONS OF BLKS 43 AND BLK 44 AND VACATED STS & ALLEYS OF KITTSON'S ADD TO
ST PAUL DESC AS COM AT NWLY COR OF LOT 5 BLK 44 TH N 55 DEG 02 MIN 47 SEC E
ALONG SLY LI
5. PLANNING DISTRICT: 17
6. ZONING CODE REFERENCE: §69.705; §69.406; §69.304; §69.303
7. STAFF REPORT DATE: November 23, 2005
PRESENT ZONING: 65
BY: Emily Ulmer
8. DATE RECEIVED: October 20, 2005 DEADLINE FOR ACTION: February 17, 2006
PURPOSE: Adjustment of common boundry including a Registered Land Survey no. 570 adjusting
the common boundaries of the property owned by the Saint Paul Housing and Redevelopment
Authority (HRA) and the Parks Department. The Proposed RLS and adjustment of common
boundaries will transfer ownership from Parks to the HRA to ailow for a parking lot owned by
Market Lofts Condominiums. In exchange, the HRA will convey to the City a portion of the property
it owns immediatly adjacent to the park property, which would be of equivalent area and value.
PARCEL SIZE: 56,662 sq. ft.
� C. EXISTING LAND USE: Parking lot and dog walk
D. SURROUNDING LAND USE:
North: Parking lot and Diamond Products factory (B5 and 11)
East: Parking lot and freeway ramps (65)
South: Highway 94 and 35W entrance ramps (B5)
West: Commercial buildings and multi-family housing (B5)
E. ZONING CODE CITATION: §69.705 states that "all registered land surveys that constitute a
subdivision as defined in this chapter shall be subject to the provisions herein contained". §69.406
provides criteria for review of subdivision applications. §69.304 lists the conditions for lots splits
and adjustments of common boundaries as set forth in §69.303.
F. HISTORY/DISCUSSION: The City Code requires that conveyance of park land must be reviewed
by the Parks and Recreation Commission. An exchange between the Saint Paul HRA and the
Parks Department is needed so that there will be no net loss of park land. After reviewing the
proposal, the Commission submitted a resolution to City Councii that recommended approval of
the land transfer (Resolution 04-20). On September 22, 2004, the City Council passed a resolution
that allowed the City to dispose of a portion of park land in order to provide additional parking for
downtown residents. With this resolution, the City Council accepted the adjacent HRA property on
the western portion of the site as a repiacement for the transferred park property, and authorized
the City to dispose of the park property to the HRA (Resolution 04-913). The Saint Paul HRA has
applied for an adjustment of common boundary including an RLS that will convey land to Market
House Condominiums for a parking lot. Currently, the parking lot straddles Parks and HRA land. In
• March of 2005, City Council approved vacation of the alley on the south side of the site, and
Market House Condominiums already owns part of the alley. Park land at the eastern corner of the
site wiil require an easement across from the HRA parcel to allow parks access to the site; a
maintenance agreement for this property will also be established.
Zoning File OS-183-851
City Council Staff Report
Page 2
G. DISTRICT COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION: The District 17 Community Councii had not
commented at the time this staff report was prepared.
H. REQUIRED FINDINGS:
1. §69.406 of the Zoning Code requires that all of the following findings shall be made prior to
approval of a subdivision:
(1) AI! the applicable provisions of the Legislafive Code are comp(ied with. This finding is met.
City staff have reviewed the proposed subdivision and have determined that all applicable
provisions of the City Code are met.
(2) The proposed subdivision will not be defrimental fo the present and potential surrounding
land uses. This finding is met. The proposed RLS and adjustment of a common boundaries
wili not be detrimental to present and future use of the surrounding land. The area
surrounding this site is fully developed to include parking lots, commercial buildings and
freeway ramps. The continued use of this site as a parking lot and park land will be
consistent with the way the area has developed and will not be detrimental to the
surrounding land uses.
(3) The area surrounding the subdivision can be planned and developed in coordination and
compatibility with the proposed subdivision. This finding is met. The site and the area
surrounding the proposed RLS and adjustment of common boundaries is aiready developed
as a parking lot and dog walk.
(4) The subdivision is in conformance with the Comprehensive Plan. This finding is met. The
Transportation Plan states that the City should work to provide an adequate supply of
parking in downtown by ensuring parking availability to attract new tenants (Policy 61). The
Parks and Recreation Plan "encourages protection, preservation, and regeneration of the
City's open space..." (Objective 1, pg. 9}.
(5) The subdivision preserves and incorporates the site's important existing natural features
whenever possible. This finding is met. This site is developed as a parking lot on the south
side of the site and a dog walk on the north end of the parcel. The dog wa�k area is flat and
covered with grass and evergreen trees. There are no other remaining naturai features on
this site that will be disturbed by the RLS and the adjustment of common boundaries.
(6)
(�)
All land infended for building sites can be used safely without endangering residents by peril
from floods, erosion, confinuously fligh water table, severe soil conditions or other menace.
This finding is met. The site is flat with stable soil conditions, and there is already a parking
lot on this site. The proposed RLS and adjustment of common boundaries can be used
safely without endangering residents in the surrounding area.
The subdivision can be economically served with public facilities and services. This finding
is met. The site could be economically served with pubiic facilities from surrounding streets.
2. §69.304 states that lot splits and adjustments of common boundaries are permitted without
platting, provided the following conditions are met:
(1) The lot or lots have fronfage on an existing improved street and access to municipal
services. The spirit and intent of this condition is met. Land owned by the HRA would have
frontage on Pine. The land owned by the Parks Department at the eastem tip of the site
would have no frontage on an improved street but would be covered by an access
easement and maintenance agreement. The proposed adjustment of common boundaries
and RLS would not require municipal services; the site will continue to be used as a dog
walk and parking lot.
(2) The lot or lots to be divided are previously platted land. This condition is met with the portion
of the site covered by the RLS meeting all requirements for City Council approval.
(3) The lof or lots meet the. minimum standards for lot width and area for fhe zoning disfrict in
which they are located. This condition is met. The area is currentiy zoned 65 Central
Business - Service District, and the lots meet ail minimum standards.
u
� '
u
r �
�_J
Zoning File 05-183-851
City Council Staff Report
Page 3
• (4) The division of the lots shall not cause a remaining parf of a lof to become a sepa�ately
described tract which does not meet fhe minimum sfandards of the zoning district in which it
is located or which does not have sfreet frontage and access to municipal services. The
spirt and intent of this condition is met. Parks land at the eastern tip of the site will be
covered by an access easement and maintenance agreement; it will continue to be used
simply for open space and does not need access to municipal services.
(5) The division does not result in a split zoning classification on a srngle lot. This condition is
met. The entire parcel is in the 65 Central Business - Service District.
(6) The division does not result in the creation of a nonconforming structure or use. This
condition is met. The site will continue to be used a parking lot and park land, both of which
are permitted in the 65 district.
(7) No !ot sha(1 be created where the building pad area for the principal structure has an
existing slope steeper than eighteen (18) percent or where a driveway steeper than fwenty
(20) percent is required to reach the building site. However, the planning administrator may
approve the creation of a steeper lot, as an exception to thrs regulation, whe�e the steeper
lot is specifrcally consistent with a city-approved neighborhood plan or redevelopment
project. This condition is met. The site is flat, and currently developed as a parking lot and
dog walk.
I. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on required findings staff recommends approval of the final
RLS and adjustment of common boundaries subject to the following conditions:
1. The applicant shall file a copy of the Counci� Resolution approving the RLS and adjustment of
• common boundaries with the Ramsey County Recorder's Office.
2. An access easement and maintenance agreement for Parks land at the eastern tip of the site
shall be signed between the Saint Paul Housing and Redevelopment Authority and the Saint
Paul Parks and Recreation Department.
Attachments:
Application
Preliminary RLS (reduction)
Final RLS (reduction)
Resolutions
Site Photos
Site Maps
•
SUBDIVISION REVIEW APPLICATION
Department ofPlanning and Economic Development
Zoning Section
1400 Ciry Hall Annex
25 West Fourth Street
Saint Paul, MN 55102-1634
(65l) 266-6589
APPLICANT
PROPERTY
LOCATION
ApplicanYs
Address! Location
tNa�
Zoning
A !„_ .. �'fh
Le al Description J3P- t�TI�fM
� 3 2 29 ZZ33ozS � -e
(attach additional sheet if necessary)
I� -�.o-o�
TYPE OF SUBDIVISION:
� Lot Split � Lot Split with Variance � Reg. Land Survey •
� Preliminary Plat � Final Plat � Combined Plat
_€e � •, . i� Z
: �� dg ai � _ . / - Q
b � _ t, ♦ // Q
L `: _ - d ° `\`\ � � •- J
t:'- � _ „ � y •' z 'e � C (�
� � 6 es.'� '_ °' -_ ' ry 4 - - i / L
f' � £ N £�' � w P . _ C
�' � - 6 � ``\ _
' �� ' � d � s. ^� y F K '_a 4 Ss � .
r -� €X" �o ` g:'� ��, - �- _ - � e�,.,
... ., e . . fi' e'es e - l' � '
' �
�� ��
._
� _ � �
�
_ �
♦
� ��
O � '_ ��
Z ai -
� i
j g='� � -
� -�= i
� �z��� ,�.�.R>A,��„�„�m,,�.-.
.
• � �_--_�_—__—_—______ �"___
Z -
Q
�
0
U..�
�
� _ '- _ __
/R - _ ' °e<
W _'_= ve"
� ' � ;3 - ve�
_ _ r�
:°E "Ec
�E
�� _ mE
�?o �F a ia£ u �..�u
� 6
i`, o ' /
_ Ly ° R ^ \ � -. / `
/�� ``_`"_ �"`` � '� � �>; ` � �
� __, v 6- 6 � �.r' , '=:, _
� 4 _
v6 _ . , , - -
` ,°r° e . ��.a
b � �8•`'R�°` � '`� - ,��,
- - ,;��,�;;�°, ,,
_ , ,
;
ro � xqn,�.v ' �
/
��, ;; _. �£
��. -,�
�;�
\ aag
__—_—_"—__ e ________—' �
�.3:,..� ___—_'—__—_'—______y
� E E
` a
E
c n.. i � m u cw ic¢ ¢�� i �c
W
�
�..�
�
�.�..f
U
W
�
I.S'3
�
�
L'e�{
�
��
�
C�
Z
r _ �:
1
�S`. F _ 3
n � ��� b
_ : /`:= ll✓ F a3
�qo
6a _ -
sV g3 F ?n � GS `�� 't' = _
`Cv 5. � b_ II -`� _
'£ 3. � � � V . .
� ;n � `\\.
_ _ $ _� m ♦
9 � � s � :�.�;
9a .•% a �;p� �.:
�EPS ._ -_ •� .
�
�$
�
/
:� �
/
/
•/
� .�.
��\ __
�.\
' �h ( ��
lY \\ /
�� � � ' �-- �! .
i � \ -- �
, �
�
�
O `_ �
Z
g ��� _
W "� i�i
� g /
"`.$:
�
�
,. j': �' �l� ' T
c` 6 �� ��,.
6 - - ,, a;,. -
�! _ ,�aao�, s „'
- - •�'�v.ta ,
� xn, •'
4M
,. . _ .
. � .t � , t .
- � .rt�:' \`; � `
�. � �.; a �:
��� __ `\;
�
� / :� . _�. -m ,a <.n k M, <,+..:,.. .
r^ �
vJ � �
'—____'—"'—_" "____—"___"—__—_:.: _ __"_ .i
Q ��� - +�_a n,.c¢.m.r
Q
J
�
W
�
rj = _::� _ _ --
� _ _- �Ee
W - :°-_ - eEa
� 'i3 iEc
° 3a _
- v;
>E�
c _
�E �
�_ _ mE
�3v _t p i¢£ � �....s
E
d
;:
E �E
� �E
� ii
a �._.1 �
gE
���
��s
:S:
�i
•
•
�
w�
�_
oz
��
Y �
S¢ �
• � V
� L7
�.1J �
7 �
� C'�g .
�
� �
� �
= -- ____ Se- __ °
' a ` t ' '8= ' z e: z:�:_ _--_
- - _ -�g"`�� '- o�
_= a _-_ - - °S
� Ea 32� =2 "_9�°yYfi�`�i':
- �! �YE�
E _ � s�t ����"��
s`� _ .s . m': y � y.
_ _ cL: E:e.� ' 6 i�a3C'x`v�FoS:
^ ; p•••�. • � E'n'-a��^.°'.{°-_M1r
u z'F O 2�°- _ �i> E'x�F.'^.m=i��==:e
a��_' i _
O F �iCS`Bi $o�^.°=^
w
0
� " ' pv�= - -¢„ � � `r_fi-°.�fi__..�ea
. . o�z �. � �YB�v = �L�tl:= •._��
. . � __ �es� , yScrB : YY�aC '6
. , EtY. i _ " : ...,
. ., . - - S rd`aY i :,°
. '_ �^s' gE�=, £ yac:;va�_:ec�y'
. `° 6-�a ;S s �
, yE 8ay: ..-d°'.. �va_ea3:2_'§_s
a_ �,�. ?
1 L�
�� - �-
� _ . ������
���.=
� � �� , a �
� • � � � �� • � � � �
.: �%
\ Y� \ , o �
:,.m `� a
�: `��� >
K� �' - ' � ` - '
Y 3
`�b��, x a � f
� 3
. � 5� a �j °,� `,
` �'9 x a. 'a q �� 8
• �� ` : ,.' ya 6��'
` ;�S � � � � � - , � * ��, c ^ , p
� � �-. � 5dY ' �A �� 4
- � ..., \-�a 4 . ..
�", �. ; z���� . d
' . y'p�'. %: r�� 4 .. ..
_ �% .\.r �;% �� / " .� .
'x';;:,�F..- .� ,_,�' �,
_ � �
_ " { �,�r ±`\ .t .,..,.-� Y r.'? � %z'��� -
�-- � � x��a
. . � s � � � "�' � �� '3 ' •
, ' *�, � �3,.,. � ..
� � s.�' ' , / �'� r��'` "t .
, . ' y /� t „ i '� .
. '. � ' :P d / L� k. . 1� 4' .
i
3 ' '- y . y C .
'•� \�/ •s � ��. `� g . . a °; � `i ; y,
_ .. ".`r �! ��-z4C`...h4 i,� �.� �V,�h,k'o '� °. :r.� y
� `.`.:, �_„ �' „� �-;:. - ;�.f' i
�,„ �..,,, � _. � °-�:� _ :
� * ~ `` � _ ".l. '�� 9' �
r�� .:� �
���� �
y s 4 ; �`� �, ,�'',
� - �'
�
3, .
DEPARTMEN'I OF PLANNING &
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Susan Kimberly, Dirnclor
CI`TY OF SAIIV'T PAUL
Randy C. Kel(y, Mayor
MEMORANDUM
To: Emily Ulmer
From: Dan Smith
Date: November 14, 2005
Subject: Mazket House Lot Split
25 Wesi Fowth Street
SaintPaul, MN55/OZ
.Q
Telephorse:651-266-6565
Facsin�il e: 651-228-3261
As promised, I am writing with further informa6on about the requested lot split and RLS
for the Mazket House condominium project. This lot split is necessary to accommodate a
land swap between the Saint Paul HRA ("the HRA") and the City of Saint Paul Parks and
Recreation Depamnent ("Pazks"). The HRA will be conveying land that is currenfly used
as a parking lot to Parks for land that is currently used as a dog walk azea.
As required by City code for any conveyance of Parks land, this proposed land swap was
reviewed by the Parks and Recreation Commission in September 2004. The Commission
recommended approval of this land swap. The City Council approved the swap on
September 22, 20d4.
Attached is a copy of the City Council resolution. This resolution includes a copy of the
Pazks and Recreafion Commission's resolufion on the same matter.
I hope you find this informafion helpful. If you need more informafion, please let me
know.
•
u
AA-ADA-EEO EMPIAYER
D�- 9t3
�
�
C
�.
S P�� Parks ana Recreation Commission
300 CiFy Hall Avnex, 25 W. 4th S¢xt, Saiat PauI, 2vL�t 55102 -{651)266-&70Q
RESOLUT10N0420
WF�REAS, the Saint Paul Pazks and Recreation Commission is an appointed body established to advise
the Mayor and City Council on long-range and city-wide matters related io Parks and Recrearion; and
WHEREAS, Section 13.011 of the City Charter requires tt}at the Co�mnission review any diversion or
disposal of park property and present a recommendation to the City Coimcil, and
WFLEREAS, the City of Saint Paul owns certain park praperty in the vicinity of Sth Street and
Broadway Sireet, as shown on the attached exhibit "A", and said properry is under the
jurisdiction of the Pazks and Recreation Division, and
WFIEREAS, the Housing And Redevelopment Authoriry( HRA) the owner of property
immed'sately adjacent to the City Park Property proposes a trade wluch will result in more
usable shaped parcels as shown on the attached exhibit "A", and
WfTBREAS, the areas fo be traded are approlcimately equai in size and equivalent in value as
determined by an independent appraisat, and `
WHEREAS, the properiy to be haded to Parks and Recreation will he sodded and fenced by the
F�2A in a condition acceptabie to Pazks and Recreation, and
WITEREAS, the City Parks and Recreation staff recommend the approval of the proposed trade,
and
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, The Saint Paul Pazks and Recreation Cornmission,
under the provisions of Secrion 13.011 of the Saint Paul City Charter, recommends to the City
Council the approval of the proposed properiy trade.
Adopted by the Saint Paul Parks and Recreation Commission on September 8, 2004:
Approved:
Resolurion 0420
Yeas ,�
Nays �
Absent: �2
Attested to by:
��� F �
Staff to the P s d Recreation Commission
g.kIiv�wp\pazkscommission�resolufions�2004\0420dogpark
>��.!c�2cae �e:zs isa s2� �sz2
. +.�=..
�
.. �..
. : �
.—,�..
� —,.I
�
�_' �
. � ,
. =_ / �'/ '0.
.\
�
�\\ .
� R
� ` ,'
�.. �,
�
�
��
� ��
�
-- _
"�.'
�►►
��
�'... ��
z .
�,�'� •
:,...� .
s
.� �
�
�;
C
� 8
� io�cks AWsociz±e3
o E„
o y
.�
k
a��� � < z
z
a
e
o �
`V
. �"n
.�
<cacc c.0O2/002
� ;} �' 1 Dt!-9t3
Eghibi ��A"
a �� w
� a4 > i
.� �>5
#gg�
0
o , J Oo
<
c+a o�
S<��
E? �
t'.
� � y�. � ��
�.� ���
�'o -�-�?! „ g � �,
� v~
� �h��
� i, �t � `
o ��� � �
. c�.. �.
� ` �
Q`` \ .
. ,r( � / / % \\ l - ,'`.
� i-,��-- �
� `'_' _��
/ `
.�� � .., ��� :
�� .�,: �
� � �- :
� "�y - s
%� � J � ,
., � �r
,� ; :� P _
� a � �� �� � �A �
��f U
� C �
1 ".: � ./F
`a � �•
�Sl
"tll y; �
., �� ; `,�" €
. , A �
?F3' ,. .. ' " : ; ' ` � � . 9
:. . . . -' � � �.��
a . : � : �.,'ti =: �- ' ,�•
- tx• � ' :�a ., j. :-' �, '� :�
-� `
��' `� ; r§ � �.•: i � �° �' ��\
' ` ' � b � -,r .s / m `',�
_ . . . ' _ - ..:.:� �.\ i...:.m.� � � . :
'r• --- -.-` .�_
• :,. ...�.���:x„�,�, •,
�� /
s �,� i
/
3
� � �
� � �
� � q
�� i
� S
9� �e
�� s3�
a �;
1�a�
m
�
Q
v
. O
�
�
����
} egg<
4.� � W �
3
o�o°
o���
M 0 0 0-
�� �
d�a
�°s�a
_��_
� J
u
•
Return copy fo: BJE
eai Estafe Dirision
40 Cify $ail
RESOLU3iON
SAtNT PAUL, MiNNESOTA
Coancii �'ile # � 1 � ! J �
Green Sheet# 3022363
J�O
Presented By
Re£erred To
�
Comtnittee: Date
1 WfIEREAS, the City of Saint Paul ("CYt}�') owns property located northeasterly of the intersection of
2 Broadway Sh'eet and Fifth Sh in Saint Paul, for use as park land, specifically, a mm�ing area for pets
3 of downtown residents; and �
4
5 WHEREAS, the Parks and Recreation J�ivision ("Parks") finds that disposal of a portion of said park
6 property is in the best interest of the public in order fo provide additional pazking for downtown
7 zesidents, and fiuther, that replacement land is available immediately adjacent to said park properry; and
9 WHEREAS, Chapter 13 of fhe Saint Paul City Charter requires that land acquired foz pazk purposes
� cannot be diverted to other uses or disposed of except in accordance with the provisions of Chapter
13.01_l;and
12
13 WFIEREAS, in accordance with said Chapter 13, the Saint Paul Pazks Commission has reviewed the
14 proposed disposal of said property ar3d has recommended that the City Council approve such disposal
15 (via Resolution Numbered 0420, adopted September 8, 2004, a copy of which is ateached hereto); and
16
17 WHEREAS, an appraisal of said property has been performed by a quaIified independent appzaiser and
18 an appraised mazket value of the property has been determined; and
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
•
WtIEREAS, in accordance with Chapter 51 of the Saint Paul Administrative Code, the Saint Paul
Housing aad Redevelopment Authority ("FIRA"� has submitted to the City a proposal to exchange said
park properry with IIRA-owned property ]ocated immediately adjacent to and southeasterly of said park
property, and determined by the Ciry's Valuation & Assessment Engineer to be of equaI value to said
park property; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Saint Paul City Councii hereby accepts the adjacent HRA property as replacement
for said pazk property and authorizes the praper city officials to dispose of said pazk property to the I312A
upon final transfer of said FiRA properiy to the City.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
lI
12
I3
14
15
16
17
18
I9
20
21
22
23
24
Council �1e # � ` � ` �>
Green Sheet # 3022363
.
� �
�J
Requested by Division of:
Parks & Recreation
By: �t y�-�
DirecEor
Form Approved by City Attomey
Adopted by Couucii: Date Cl-<7� O�
Adoption Ce •' ed by Counci] 3ecretary
$y: '
Approv b or. l�ate '
B 4�yC�LG�'!dQ %. � � /7 �r
r
IvFayor €or S�nigs}ap to
•
•
�
C
Zoning File OS-183-851
Dog walk on the southwest side of the site.
•
�
•
Zoning File OS-183-851
Pazking lot on the south side of the site owned by the Saint Paul HRA.
/•
�•
C�
Zoning File OS-183-851
The triangle shaped parcel on the east side of the site will continue to be owned by Parks.
•
L_J
•
Zoning File OS-183-851
Freeway ramps on the northeast side of the site.
•
�
U
❑
Zoning File OS-193-851
Diamond Products parking lot on the south side of the site.
a
e
CE7IZ�F1 PARTICIPATI(kN PLANNING DISTRICTS
1.SUNRAY=BkT�LEC&�EK�-HIGHWOOD -
2.6REATER EAST S.IDE
3.WEST SIDE
4.DAYTON'S BLUFF
S:PAYNE-PHkLEN. �
6.NORTH END '
7.THOMAS=DALE
8,SUMMIT-UNIVERSITY � Qr' ,�3�5 �
9:41ESt� SEVENTN
1Q.CON10 .. .
11.HAMLINE-MIDWAY
12_ ST. AMTNOt�Y
. 13.MERRIAM PK.-LEXI�#GTON NAMLINE .
14..GROVELANO�MACAL�STER
� 15.HIGHLAND
' � SUMMIt HILL
WNT�WN
ti .
,
CITIZEN PA TICIPAT K1 DIS RICTS'
•
■1
-� :
�� 1
■�
� ,�
.� :.,
l/��
�---�
�� fi ,
� . ����
,, .;
�0 Sf R � V
�.� _ ,,.=
� � ...
.-- .�
,,,�,:
- � ;-�
, �,� S.
r;,. ���
DOWNTOWN
v ��� t � � ,
DISTRICT 17 �N m '� �� ,�
�
s� �� ��
� �)'• I$3��1
❑
_ ��
_ ��° � � � �.
�� � f �
` -�� , l / -' � - f _ ¢ .. � ' _ ���
, ` � "
� � $ � ��
� , �� _ ��°`-?-�. :�� � .�'
, � : ���- : �� � . � : �
� : ��.rt .� : _ � - �
= : � . �
_ �-=�' -� � .= . _ � =:
�, � �
� ���,� �
� �� � � �
� L �
� _ �
�� ���� .
` _ �-'''--�`'� ' �
>.
� " .> � - � ' �
�• � � � � � � �
� � �'�,�
[ � � ���/ '� � �''�, �'S � � '�r�.�
/ � " 3 �' � � �'" \ 5 ` _� '.. � z �'� � �'M� %s� .
. �i , �1�� �$-' � - -�1. � �"` ��
i: - t ' - i : ,�.
<
j t � � .� Y �
� k : � , ,� k�� z � � �
! ��' � . �- w
y � y � jjJ �' .
4 y =� � -Y^` , \ \ � ��.. � . '
� ; � ��_ ,
, � � / '� r � �
� 1 � � I�M � _ �'
. � � � � �
, � ` �
���,.`��
� V c
� . V � .. - ��� ��.-��„-
. q ��� � �� � � ��
� � : z �'
� � .�- - `�=='�_� ` "";
�- � ' °�� ,�-� - ;:��:: :- .'
��" t � v . � � �� ����
_ ' .� �..:.�,-` �
'? /�, � �: � ,,,�
`:_- ;�I � � ,- �� � ._ _.� , _ �_ '�".�''
FP?LICANT � � �� ' `' ` LEGEND �
s
PU °OSE ��' (�� �Q� � � `� zoning dislricl toundzry
"���'��� DATE �V `�Ya"Or ���-.�/JJ- /� suSj=�i prop=,�y �-C a;,h`
?i,tdG. D;ST ►�_ P,IAP ;:- �, � o on_ (zmily • a � comm=:ciz'
� �d� ¢ h:;otamily 4 �.o industria! I