06-475Council File # �
Green Sheet # a�oZ-
Presented
Referred To
�I
Cox�mmittee Date
WfIEREAS, Hoyt Avenue and Hamline Avenue, previously Ramsey County roadways, have been "turned
back" to the cities, and
WHEREAS, the segments of Hoyt Avenue from Fulham Street to Cleveland Avenue and from Snelling
Avenue to Hamline Avenue, and the segment of Hamline Avenue from Hoyt Avenue to Larpenteur Avenue, are
border streets shared by Saint Paul and Falcon Heights, and
WHEREAS, responsibility for maintenance of the shared street and sewer utilty systems and authority for
joint use of the storm and sanitary sewer systems must be established; now therefore be it
RESOLVED, that we hereby authorize the proper City officials to sign the Agreement.
Yeas Nays Absent
Benanav �
Bostrom ,/
Hazris y
Aelgen J
Lanhy ,�
Montgomery �
Thune �
Adopted by Council: Date /� dO
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
BY� //ilG� oi `L.C�Sdn
%
Approved by M r: e " Zy ��
By: ���'d�
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAtNT PAUL, MINNESOTA
J ��
Requested by Depaztrnent of:
Public Works
; / /
, � .
�
Form App d by Ciry Attomey
By
Appzoved by for Submission to Council
By. (///%�7A4a$¢� c.iLSe�v`` ��. '
� f�!!
� Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet G�een Sheet Green Sheet �
- . - -- . � ��'� 7�
p�15/ - PubticWorks
CoMact Person & Phone:
Larty Lueth
266-6083
ContractType:
RE-RESOLlST10i3
21-APR-O6
� ,
Assign
by (Date): Number
Foc
Routing
Order
Green Sheet NO: 3030482
1 61ic Wor De arlment 'rec
5 Ctiro Cl ck G titv Q erk
ToUI # of Signature Pages _(Clip NI Locations for Signature)
Approve a Council Resolution authorizing proper City o�cials to enter into a Join[ Powers Agreemen[ with Falcon Heights, which
establishes maintenance responsibilities for border sneecs between Saint Paul and Falcon Heights and for joint use of the storm and
sanitary sewer systems in those border streeu.
Recommendations: Appro�e (A) or Reject
Planning Commission
CIB Commi[tee
Citil Senice Commission
1. Has this persoNfirtn e�er vrorked under a cont2ct for this department?
Yes No
2. Has this persoNfirm e�er been a city employee?
Yes No
3. Does this persoNfirm possess a skill not nortnally possessed by any
current city employee?
Yes No
Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet
Initiating Problem, tssues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
Hoyt Avenue and Hamline Avenue, previously Ramsey County roadways, have been "turned back to ihe cities. Segments of these
two roadways fali on the border between Saint Paul and Faicon Heights. Shazed responsibility for maintaining the street and sewer
facili[ies in these roadway segments must be assigned.
AdvantageslfApproved: I
Responsibilities for maintaining segments of Aoyt and Hamline, shared border streets of Saint Paul and Falcon Heigh[s, will be clarified ��
Use of 5ain[ Paul's s[orm and sanitary sewers by Falcon Heights in these same sVeet segments will be authori� �, ���� � �,
Disadvanta9es IfApproved:
None
�i��s� � c�i LUYild i
E�
MAY 0 5 2006
, ���� .���������
DisadvanWqeslfNotApproved:
Shazed maintenance responsibilities for street and sewer facilities in the stree[ segments along the border of Saint Paul and Falcon �
Heigh[s remains unassigned. �,
Transaction:
Funding Source: N/q
CosURevenue Budgeted: y
Activity Number. rJ/A
Financial information: Falcon Heights wiil reimburse Sain[ Paul for maintenance work performed per terms of the Agreement.
(Explain) >�--':--�-"�- �.: � ----�_ ---: —�-- -> -- ----
—�� ���--��—�t
aprii z�, �oos �z:zs Pn� Pa � �'� 0 $ � �������;�
rr ������ �
�lo'�f ��
JOINT POWERS AGREEMENT BY AND BETWEEN
THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL AND THE CITY OF FALCON HEIGHTS
RELATING TO MAINTENANCE OF STR,EET AND SEWER FACILITIES
AND TO JOINT USE OF SAINT PAUL'S SAIVITARY AND STORM SEWERS
IN HAMI�INE AVENUE AND HOYT AVENUE
This Joint Powers Agreement (the "Agreement") made and entered into this
day of , 2006, (the "Effective Date") by and between the City of
Saint Paul, a Minnesota municipal corporation, hereinafter referred to as S.P. and
the City of Falcon Heights, a Minnesota municipal corporation, hereinafter referred
to as F.H. Based on the representations, covenants and provisions hereinafter
contained, the parties do hereby agree as follows�
AR.TICLE 1.
RECITALS
1.1 Status of Parties. S.P. and F.H. are municipal corporations under the laws of
the State of Minnesota. The cities adjoin each other.
12 Statutory Authorit� This Agreement is entered into pursuant to Minnesota
Statutes Section 471.59.
1.3 Street Utility and Sewer Utility Maintenance. S.P. and F.H. have noted that
Hamline Avenue from Hoyt Avenue to Larpenteur Avenue, and Hoyt Avenue
from Fulham Street to Cleveland Avenue, and from Snelling Avenue to
Hamline Avenue, are border streets and thus located within the corporate
limits of S.P. and F.A. The street utility and sewer utility facilities must be
appropriately maintained to service the citizens of the two communities.
l.4 Purpose of Agreement. The purpose of this Agreement is to assign facility
maintenance responsibilities, to allocate the appropriate compensation due
S.P. by F.H. for maintenance services, and to establish joint use of S.P.'s
storm and sanitary sewer by F.H.
ARTICLE 2.
DEFINITIONS
2.1 Terms. The following terms, unless elsewhere defined specifically in this
Joint Powers Agreement, shall have the meanings as set forth below.
2.2 S S.P. means the City of Saint Paul, a Minnesota Charter City.
2.3 F_H. FH means the City of Falcon Heights, a Minnesota Statutory City.
-1-
ro6 -��.�
2.4 Street Utilitv. Includes pavement and curb, sidewalk, street lighting, street
striping, street signs, and traffic signals.
2.5 Sewer Utilitv. Includes storm main, catch basins, catch basin leads, storm
manholes, sanitary main, and sanitary manholes.
2.6 Roadwavs. For intent of this agreement, "roadways" shall be defined as the
segment of Hamline Avenue from Aoyt Avenue to Larpenteur Avenue, and
the two segments of Hoyt Avenue from Fulham Street to Cleveland Avenue
and from Snelling Avenue to Hamline Avenue.
2.7 Winter Maintenance/Snow & Ice Control. Roadway shall be kept reasonably
free and clear of ice and snow, curb face to curb face. Sand and/or salt shall
be applied as necessary. Vehicle tagging and towing as needed.
2.8 Routine Road Maintenance. Maintain roadway so as to keep them reasonably
smooth and in reasonably good repair for the passage of vehicular traffic and
reasonably free of all obstructions and impediments to traffic. This
maintenance shall include such preventive maintenance services as may be
reasonably required to preserve the roadway in its present operating
condition including proper and timely patching� seal coating Hoyt in 2007
and on an eight (8) year cycle thereafter; sweeping of Hoyt twice per year
(spring and fall), and of Hamline at least 13 times per year; and debris
removal.
2.9 Routine Traffic Maintenance �Strining�Siens. Lights. Signals). Maintain
pavement marking (paint twice per year) and traf�c signs in accordance with
S.P. practices. Street lighting system shall be maintained on an "as needed"
basis. Traffic signal maintenance is governed by a separate agreement.
2.10 Routine Sewer Utility Maintenance. Maintain storm and sanitary sewer
systems in a condition such that sewer flows are conducted efficiently.
Maintain catch basins so that existing sumps function adequately to capture
signif"icant sediment and so that storm flows are efficiently conducted to the
main line. Replace structure castings that are cracked or broken.
2.11 Rieht-of-W� Management. Includes reviewing private utility construction
proposals, issuing permits for such work, monitoring traffic control efforts,
and assuring quality street restoration per specifications.
2.12 S.P. Representative. S.P. representative shall mean the S.P. City Engineer.
-2-
�� -y �.�
2.13 F.H. Representative. F.H. representative shall mean the F.H. Public Works
Director.
2.14 Uncontrollable Circumstances Uncontrollable Circumstances shall mean the
occurrence or non-occurrence of acts or events beyond the control of the party
relying thereon, and not the result of willful or negligent action or inaction of
the party claiming the event as Uncontrollable Circumstances that
materially adversely affects the performance of the party claiming the event
as an Uncontrollable Circumstance including, but not limited to, the
following�
(1) Acts of God including, but not limited to floods, ice storms, blizzards,
tornadoes, landslides, lightning and earthquakes (but not including
reasonably anticipated weather conditions for the geographic area),
riots, insurrections, wars or civil disorder affecting the performance of
work, blockades, power or other utility failure, and fires or explosions.
Note• it is reasonable to expect a rainfall greater than what the storm
sewer is designed for — a five year storm. When that happens, local
flooding will occur.
(2) The adoption of or change in any federal, state, or local laws, rules,
regulations, ordinances, permits or licenses, or changes in the
interpretation of such laws, rules, regulations, ordinances, permits or
licenses by a court or public agency having appropriate jurisdiction
after the date of the execution of this Joint Powers Agreement.
(3) A suspension, termination, interruption, denial or failure of renewal of
any permit, license, consent, authorization or approval essential to the
maintenance effort.
(4) Orders and/or judgment of any federal, state or local court,
administrative agency or governmental body, provided, however, that
the contesting in good faith by such party of any such order andlor
judgment shall not constitute or be construed to constitute a willful or
negligent action or inaction of such party.
(5) Strikes or other such labor disputes shall not be considered
Uncontrollable Circumstances, unless such strike or labor dispute
involves persons with whom the parties have no employment
relationship; and the parties, or either of them cannot, using best
efforts, obtain substitute performance.
-3-
/
D� �� 75
AR7'ICLE 3
ASSIGNMENT OF MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITIES
3.1 Winter Maintenance/Snow Ice Control, as described in 2.6, shall be the
responsibility of F.H.
3.2 Routine Road Maintenance, as described in 2.7, shall be the responsibility of
S.P.
3.3 R.outine Traffic Maintenance, as described in 2.8 and £urther described in
Attachment "A", shall be performed by S.P. Cost for services provided for/on
the Falcon Heights half of the three (3) street segments and for any
additional services requested by F.H. will be invoiced to F.H.
3.4 Routine Sewer Utility Maintenance, as described in 2.9 and as further
described in Attachment "B", shall be performed by S.P. Cost for services
provided forlon the behalf of F.H. will be invoiced to F.H. Note� S.P. Sewer
Maintenance will not bill for cost of service directly — services will be billed
annually based on the method found in Section 42 and Attachment "C".
3.5 Ri.ght-of-Wa� shall be managed and permits issued by the City that controls
that portion of the right-of-way in which the permitted activity is planned.
When permits are issued or cuts planned in street segments governed by this
agreement, the permitting City shall notify the other of the planned activity.
AIZTICLE 4
MAINTENANCE EXPENSE AND BILLINGS
4.1 Services performed by S.P., as described in Section 3.3 on behalf of F.H., shall
be invoiced as herein described�
S.P. will bill F.H. for services rendered hereunder on a monthly basis
detailing a description of the work involved, the labor and equipment used in
the performance thereof, and the parts and materials furnished.
Lahor charges will be billed by S.P. at the wage it has established as
adjusted, via collective bargaining with the various occupational groups who
actually perform the work. Such wage rates will also be adjusted to reflect
the cost of fringe benefits paid by S.P, to those occupational groups who
actually perform the work.
�
06-��.�
Further, the wage rates and/or fringe benefits will be adjusted if the
occupational groups are working holidays, are on overtime status, or have
been subject to callback as the case may be and as determined by the time
when work is performed hereunder. The labor chaxges referenced shall
commence at the time travel begins and terminate when travel ends for any
task performed for F.H. hereunder. S.P. shall provide to F.H. the most
current billing rates for labor for each occupational group performing the
work. S.P. shall also provide to F.H., the most current equipment billing
rates.
F.H. shall be billed for parts and materials in S.P.'s actual cost plus a
markup of twenty percent (20%) to cover the costs of restocking, handling,
and operating expenses.
F.H. will remit the sum payable to S.P. within thirty (30) days after its
receipt of same.
42 Services performed by S.P. as described in Section 3.4 on behalf of F.H., shall
be invoiced as herein described. S.P. will bill F.H. annually for services
rendered hereunder.
4.2a For sanitary sewers connected to Hoyt Avenue between Snelling
Avenue and Hamline Avenue, F.H. agrees to annually reimburse S.P. an
amount equal to the distance of the joint-use sewer segment, times the
percentage of flow originating within F.H. to the total sewer flow, times an
annual sanitary sewer maintenance cost per mile as established herein.
Attachment "C" tabulates the F.H. flow to total flow percentage for the
various segments of the jointuse sewers based on calculated Residential
Equivalent Connection (REC) units. Should the use of these percentages be
unsatisfactory as basis of maintenance cost apportionment to either party,
then they may be superseded by a revised determination of REC units or field
checks of actual flow rates. Attachment "C" also tabulates the proportionate
mileage of joint-use sanitary sewer on which F.H: s annual reimbursement to
S.P. is based.
4.2b For the sanitary sewers connected to Hoyt Avenue between Fulham
Street and Cleveland Avenue, F.H. agrees to annually reimburse S.P. an
amount equal to the charge as calculated in Section 42a above, divided by
the number of F.H's. REC units established in Attachxnent "C," times the
number of F.H.'s REC units for this area which has been determined to be
111 REC units. Should the established number of REC units be
unsatisfactory as basis of maintenance cost apportionment to either party,
then they may be superseded by a revised determination of REC units or field
checks of actual flow rates.
-5-
06-��.�
42c For the storm water portion, F.H. agrees to annually reimburse S.P. an
amount equal F.H.'s land area contributing flow to S.P.'s storm sewer �0.119
sq. mi.) divided by the total land area in S.P. �52.8 sq. mi.) times S.P.'s
previous year spending in their Storm Water Management Program. For
2005, that program's spending was $292,806. It is noted that F.H.'s storm
water between Fulham Street and Cleveland Avenue flows north and does
not enter the S.P.'s storm sewer system.
42d On or before February 1 of each year, S.P. shall submit to F.H., an
invoice and documentation of the Saint Paul Department of Public Works
Sewer Maintenance Annual Budget, the prior year's spending for storm water
management, and a summation of mileage of sewer, irrespective of size or
type. The annual sanitary sewer maintenance cost utilized for the purposes
of this agreement, shall be the annual Saint Paul Department of Public
Works Sewer Maintenance budget ($5,770,568 for 2006), divided by the
mileage of sewer within S.P. (1,254 miles in 2006) times 110 percent to
account for other administrative, depreciation, and related overhead
expenses not included within the Sewer Maintenance Division budget. For
2006, the annual sanitary sewer maintenance cost per mile is agreed to be
$5,062.
4.2e F.H. shall make payment to S.P. within thirty (30) days of receipt o£
invoice for the maintenance cost sharing amount as determined by the basis
set forth in this agreement for the current calendar year.
4.2f In the event that it is necessary to reconstruct, reline or replace part or
all of the existing joint-use sewer in Hoyt Avenue, F.H. will recompense S.P.
based on the percentages of F.H.'s flow as shown in Attachment "C" for the
segments to be reconstructed or replaced. If replacement is needed because
F.H.'s wishes to convey additional flow, that cost will be paid by F.H.
ARTICLE 5
JOINT USE OF SAINT PAUL'S SAIVITAR,Y AND STORM SEWERS
5.1 S.P. does hereby grant permission to F.H. to allow F.H.'s sanitary and storm
sewers that currently drain into the Hoyt and Hamline Avenue sewers at the
locations shown in Attachment "B", Exhibits "A" and "B", to continue to do so
in exchange for F.Ei.'s sharing of maintenance and replacement costs of the
sewers.
�
o�-���
52 The F.H. sanitary sewer system connected to the S.P. sewer system shall be
used solely for the purpose of conveying sanitary sewage. F.H. shall not
permit storm water, clear water, or inflow and infiltration exceeding
standards set by the Metropolitan Council Environmental Services to be
connected to S.P. sanitary sewers.
5.3 The F.H. storm sewer system connected to the S.P. sewer system shall be
used solely for the purpose of conveying municipal storm water. F.H. shall
prevent non-storm water discharges as currently defined by the Minnesota
Pollution Control Agency and Saint Paul's National Pollutant Discharge
Elimination System Permit from being discharged into S.P.'s storm sewers.
5.4 F.H. shall save S.P. harmless from any damage, cost or expense> and fully
indemnify S.P. against any and all liability sustained by reason of the
connections, or the maintenance of connections hereunder, between the
public sewer system of F.H. and the public sewer system of S.P., by reason of
any damage, cost, expense or loss that may be sustained by F.H., its
inhabitants or any other person or persons connected with the use of F.H.'s
public sewer system, or by diversion into F.H.'s public sewer system of
prohibited discharges as outlined in Sections 5.2 and 5.3. This agreement is
entered into pursuant to all of the terms, provisions, and conditions of
Chapter 80 (Sewer Contracts, Suburbs) of the Legislative Code of S.P. F.H.
does not waive, and expressly retains, any and all defenses and immunities
pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 466, et.al.
5.5 It is agreed between the parties hereto, that the Metropolitan Council
Environmental Services (MCES) shall estimate the amount of sanitary
sewage attributable to the F.H. properties hereby authorized to be connected
to the S.P. sanitary sewer, and shall accordingly, charge F.H. for its
proportionate cost of sewage treatment, conveyance in MCES interceptors,
and related costs in its annual billings. F.H. and S.P. shall cooperate with,
and provide all necessary information to the Metropolitan Council
Environmental Services so as to permit the proper billing to F.H. and credit
to S.P. for its sewage.
-7-
o�-��.�
AR,TICLE 6
INDENINIF'ICATION
6.1 Indemnification. Each party to this agreement shall be liable for its own acts
and its officers, employees, or agents and the results thereof to the extent
authorized by law and shall not be responsible for the acts of any party, its
officers, employees or agents.
AR,TICLE 7
GENER,AL PROVISIONS
7.1 Governine Law. This Agreement shall be construed and interpreted
according to the laws of the State of Minnesota.
72 Amendment. This agreement may be amended by the parties, but only by a
written instrument.
7.3 Notices. All notices or communications required or permitted pursuant to
this Joint Powers Agreement, shall be either hand delivered or mailed to F.H.
and S.P. by certified mail, return receipt requested, at the following address�
F.H. Greg Hoag
Director of Public Works
2077 West Larpenteur Avenue
Falcon Heights, Minnesota 55113
S.P. John Maczko
City Engineer
Department of Public Works
15 West Kellogg Boulevard
140 City Hall
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
Either party may change its address or authorized representative by written
notice delivered to the other party pursuant to this Section.
�
��-���
7.4
Service Calls. Requests for Service shall be initiated by and requested of
those authorized persons listed below. This list of authorized representatives
is to be updated as necessary.
S.P. Authorized R.epresentatives
Street Maintenance�
Gary Erichson
Tom Scaramuzzo
Jeff Sanchez
Jim Crudo
Traffic Maintenance�
Tom Stadsklev
John McNamara
Michael Miller
Sewer Maintenance�
Greg Galloway
Rich Rowan
24-hour Phone #651-292-6600
Street Maintenance Engineer
Sweeping, Mowing, Litter
Patching, Sealcoating
Patching
7�00 a.m.-4�00 p.m. Phone #651-487-7200
After Hours — Phone #651
Traf�c Maintenance Engineer
General Lead Electrician
Pavement Markings and Signing
7�00 a.m. — 4�00 p.m. Phone #651-558-2277
After Hours — Telephone #651�292-6600
Sewer Maintenance Supervisor
Dispatcher
F.H. Authorized Representatives�
Winter Street Maintenance by Ramsey County
Pam Thompson @ County. 7�00 a.m. — 3�30 p.m. 651-266-7100
Night Crew @ County 3�30 p.m. — 12�00 p.m. 651-266-7100
Sheriff's Office @ County 12�00 p.m. — 7�00 a.m. 651-484-3366
Sewer Maintenance by Saint Paul
Greg Hoag
Dave Tretsven
Collin Callahan
�O£fice) 651-792-7600 (Cell) 651-248-9318 (Home) 651
�O�ce) 651-792-7600 (Cel� 651-248-9410 �Home) 651
�Office) 651-792-7600 (Cell) 651-248-9437) tHome) 651
Traffic Maintenance by Saint Paul
Falcon Heights contacts as listed above.
�'➢
o�-��.�
7.5 Counternarts. This Joint Powers Agreement may be executed more than one
counterpart, each of which shall be deemed to be an original but, all of which
taken together, shall be deemed a single instrument.
7.6 Survival of Itepresentations and Warranties. The representations, covenants,
warranties, and agreements of the parties under this Joint Powers
Agreement, and the remedies of either party for the breach of such
representations, warranties, covenants and agreements by the other party,
shall survive the execution and termination of this Joint Powers Agreement.
7.7 Non Neither F.H. nor S.P. shall assign any interest in this
Joint Powers Agreement nor shall transfer any interest in the same, whether
by subcontract, assignment or novation, without the prior written consent of
the other party. Such consent shall not be unreasonably withheld.
7.8 Severabilitv. The provisions of this Joint Powers Agreement are severable.
If any paragraph, section, subdivision, sentence, clause or phase of this Joint
Powers Agreement is, for any reason, held to be contrary to law or contrary to
any rule or regulation having the force and effect of law, such decision shall
not affect the remaining portions of the Joint Powers Agreement.
7.9 Termination. This maintenance and joint-use agreement shall be
permanently binding on both parties unless it is terminated by mutual
consent, or in the event that sewage facilities that allow a connection to the
Metropolitan Council Environmental Services Interceptor System within
F.H. become available and obviates the state purpose of the joint sewer use
aspects of this agreement.
L[1j
b��y�,�
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement, the date and
year first set forth above.
CITY OF SAINT PAUI. Approved as to Form�
$
Mayor
$
:
City Attorney
Director of Public Works
:
Director, Financial Services
CITY OF FALCON HEIGHTS
I�
Susan Gehrz, Its Mayor
$
Heather Worthington
Its City Administrator
-11-
o�-���
STATE OF NIINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNZ`Y OF RAMSEY )
On this day of 2006, before me a Notary
Public within and for said County, personally appeared
>
and to me personally
known, who being each by me duly sworn, each did say that they are respectively
the Mayor, Director of Public Works, and Financial Services Director of the City of
Saint Paul, the municipality named in the foregoing instxument, and that the seal
affised to said instrument was signed and sealed on behalf of said municipality by
authority of its City Council and said Mayor, Director of Public Works, and
Financial Services Director acknowledged said instrument to be the free act and
deed of said municipality.
Notary Public
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY )
On this day of 2006, before me a Notary
Public within and for said County, personally appeared
,
and to me personally known, who being each by me
duly sworn, each did say that they are respectively the Mayor and City
Administrator of the City of Falcon Heights, the municipality named in the
foregoing instrument, and that the seal af�xed to said instrument was signed and
sealed on behalf of said municipality by authority of its City Council and said Mayor
and City Administrator acknowledged said instrument to be the free act and deed o£
said municipality.
Notary Public
12-
o�-���''
ATTACHMENT "A"
ROUTINE TRAFFIC MAINTENANCE
Routine Traffic Maintenance on Hamline Avenue from Hoyt to Larpenteur, Hoyt
Avenue from Fulham Street to Cleveland and Hoyt Avenue from Snelling Avenue to
Hamline Avenue will be completed as follows�
• Signs within S.P. will be maintained by S.P.
• Signs within F.H. will be maintained by F.H.
• Pavement markings within S.P. and F.H. will be maintained by S.P. The
cost of services provided for maintaining pavement markings in F.H. will
be billed to F.H. by S.P.
• Street lighting within S.P. will be maintained by S.P.
• Street lighting in F.H. on the north side of Hoyt from Fulham Street to
Cleveland Avenue will be maintained by S.P. and costs of services will be
billed to F.H.
• There is no street lighting in F.H. on Hamline Avenue from Hoyt to
Larpenteur and Hoyt Avenue from Snelling Avenue to Hamline.
At sometime in the future, F.H. may desire that S.P. complete additional routine
traffic maintenance services on above referenced streets or at other locations
within F.H. city limits. Attachment "A" may be amended by F.H. at any time,
providing such amendment is in writing and specifically describes the nature
and type of such matter, its location and effective date of change. Such
amendment shall be sent to the Traffic Operations Engineer, 899 North Dale
Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55103. Amendments to Attachment "A" can
include on-going or short-term requests for services for street lighting
maintenance, traffic signal maintenance, pavement marking installation, sign
manufacturing, repair or installation or other traf�c infrastructure installation,
maintenance or repair.
1. Said services shall include repair of malfunctions and knockdowns as they
occur. Painting of poles may be arranged through the City of Saint Paul, or
its contractor, which will be paid directly by Falcon Heights. Services
contemplated herein do not include energy costs.
2. Electrical work performed by S.P. will be in conformance with the national
electric code and in a neat and workmanlike manner. Further, traf£ic
control during any maintenance performed by S.P., shall be structured
according to Appendis "B" of the Manual of Uniform Traffic Control
Devices.
-13-
o� ��S
3. Any construction work, excavation work and concrete work needed for the
effective installation, repair of maintenance of the infrastructure serviced
by S.P. shall be done by F.H. or agreed upon prior to commencement of
work.
4. Damaged materials removed by S.P., pursuant to this agreement, shall be
turned over to F.H. for inspection and disposal.
5. F.H, shall furnish to S.P., a copy of any and all repair and maintenance
manuals and revisions of the same for any and all equipment.
6. S. P. shall immediately dispatch qualified personnel to repair and correct
emergency or dangerous situations, on a priority basis, considering all
traffic infrastructure maintained by S.P., taking care of the most
dangerous situations �rst.
7. S.P. shall, for non or non situations, respond to calls
for service within twenty-four (24) hours if such calls are received between
7�00 a.m. and 5�30 p.m., Monday through Friday, excluding legal holidays.
A call for service at any other time shall be responded to within seventy-
two (72) hours.
8. To the extent possible, depending on S.P.'s complement of available staff
and available parts, any infrastructure covered hereunder shall be restored
to normal operation within seventy-two (72) hours from the time the call
for sexvice is received.
14-
0�-�7�
ATTACHMENT "B"
ROUTINE SEWER UTILITY MAINTENANCE
1. Catch basins and catch basin leads within S.P. will be maintained by S.P.
Catch basins and catch basin leads within F.H. will be maintained by F.H.
2. Storm sewer and sanitary sewer main lines in Hoyt from Fulham to
Cleveland and in Hoyt from Snelling to Aamline shall be maintained by
S.P. Costs for services provided for on behalf of F.H. will be invoiced to
F.H.
3. Storm sewer in Hamline from Hoyt to Larpenteur , will be maintained by
S.P. Costs for serviced provided for on behalf of F.H. will be invoiced to
F.H.
4. Sanitarv Sewer in Hamline — S.P. and F.H. have, for the most part,
separate systems. Each city will be responsible to maintain their own
system.
5. Attached Exhibit "A" identifies location of joint use sanitary sewer.
6. Attached Exhibit "S" identifies location of joint use storm sewer.
7. Frequencv of Routine Maintenance — Sewer main blockages shall be
deemed an emergency and resolved as soon as possible. For the most part,
Sewer Maintenance Services will be complaint driven. Sewer mains in
these three (3) street segments were inspected and televised in 2005;
hereafter these mains will be inspected and televised on a ten cycle.
-15-
�b "�f 7�
ATTACHMENT "8"
EXHIBIT A
LOCATION OF JOINT USE SANITARY SEWER:
HOYT AVENUE FROM SNELLING TO HAMLINE AVENUES
c�
J j
� m
2 h
y Q
�I � 1 ,��a
LARPENTEUR --; , ' �
CAUf'ORNlA
e
IDANO ,�
/OWA �,
HDYT
ti-
$�
� �,
NEBAASXA "
�
2 � Z r. o Z
ai y Q O � O . p 2
" h C Z Q y _?.. ...._._
; � � N.
� r.'�
;'n .
�' I ! s
t
�.
i
' O)Ji '
S�
-16-
06 -���
EXHIBIT A (CONTINUED)
LOCATION OF JOINT USE SANITARY SEWER:
HOYT AVENUE FROM FULHAM STREET TO CLEVELAND
AVENUE
2
Q
W
y
W
�
��� �'�� _ ,ti�� . _. . '�' _ � �
U OF M I —� r
,OL F COURSE � 0 N I'
�aG
i W J p �
,, Cf Z � g UNI ✓EHSIT Y v '
l�, � � j 0 GROVE ElJST 4� d
� � � m �, 3 :
� � J
- a z �, �ti k � p �
��� l� �� �it"� 9' :- 3� .. S _ Zo� ' j� • a � I
�,���7, � ,�_�— - --�._!� - F'p�u; 4
. ;Z _ `.,_.'' /iz \*. 4� � � 2.� ;-'`-�. ��� , ,�
� j�� �= µ� \ �. � � (� �/� .� � ,.�
\ i•� � v 0�1� w G j�_ �
• �.M1 `' � � ��' o
�� h� �� i..: � � � w . S ` i
,� ,� o� � �� 1 1 ' ' � `�,�.i � i �' �L �� is':onf ,y�
� ��_'l2�CT.�_�1 IY _,._I 4 �0"-a� � i _ b'a8s�� ix'�a.:. �.i I � �Z_�fA �
� 'i r---- { -----:� � � ------- -- -� ... �- �. � HDYT ��I�
. a. y, � `
� 1 Y N v p � �' _� Q {7
Y n I y �? '� �Sc-�.�Y�� N•-/• �/r'9'.Sx �'vs.n.. �.�t!� �i� �'1
a
; ' li�Y.ta�. � ���� 1 _•--••—�� .� �� � ----�
� ir
"�-- 3,Ir'�� :1 .t z �,� ! , m D EY i
Figure 1
-17-
o�-� 7�
ATTACHMENT "B"
EXHIBIT B
LOCATION OF JOINT USE STORD'I SEWERS:
HOYT AVENUE FROM SNELLING TO PASCAL AVENUES,
HOYT AVENUE FROM ALBERT STREET TO HAMLINE AVENUE
AND HAMLINE AVENUE FROM CALIFORNIA TO IOWA
AVENUES
i '-
J j
W m
Z Q
y
I p �
LARP£NTEUR --� . "
� ;;
CALIFORN/A
/DAHO '
/OWQ �
NOYT ti :,
$'�
J ��
� �
V t
�'
�
N£BRASXA '
0
Q
�
y
�
Q
y
a
0
�
O
Z
�
ti
m
�
x
° o
Z
�
t�i.w
tfj9' f
R
<
i
f' d
I,
�, f L:N
r�
�
� �
e�
ATTACHMENT "C"
JOIIVT USE SANITARX SE`VERS AND PERCENTAGE OF FLOW
The following table shows the percentage in 2005 of Falcon Heights's sanitary sewer flow
entering the sanitary sewer in Hoyt Avenue. Flow from Falcon Heights includes part of the area
bounded by Larpenteur, Snelling, Hoyt and Hamline Avenues (see Exhibit D). It also includes
Hollywood Court and the S W comer of Larpenteur and Snelling Avenues. The Equivalent Falcon
Heights Mileage is calculated as a factor in determining Falcon Heights's annual cost for using
these sections of St. Paul's sanitary sewer.
Sewer 5egment (Falcon Aeiahts' REC) Falcon Heights's Segment Equivalent
(Total REC) Share % Miles Falcon
Heights
Mileage
Hoyt Ave. from 231 59.5% 0.499 0.297
Snelling Ave to 388
Hamline Ave.
i otai r atcon rieignts iviiieage = u.ay �
Note: The Metropolitan Council Environmental Services defines a REC as the sanitary sewer
volume (80,000 gallons per year) generated by a typical residential connection.
-19-
o�-���
ATTACHMENT "C"
EXHIBIT D
NUMBER OF HOMES AND OTAER PROPERTIES CONNECTED
TO THE HOYT AVEN UE SEWER
For St. Paul
Asbury St. from Nebraska Ave. to Hoyt Ave.
Twenty-eight homes 28 REC
Arona St. from Nebraska Ave. to Hoyt Ave.
Twenty-eight homes 28 REC
Simpson St. from Nebraska Ave. to Hoyt Ave.
Twenty-seven homes 27 REC
Pascal St. from Nebraska Ave. to Hoyt Ave.
Twenty-eight homes 28 REC
Hoiton St. from Nebraska Ave. to Hoyt Ave.
Twenty-eight homes 28 REC
Sheldon St. from Nebraska Ave. to Hoyt Ave.
Sixteen homes plus Como Lutheran Church
18 REC
In 2005 the church used 127,160 gallons of water.
This amounts to 127,160 �al = 2 REC
8Q000 gaUREC
Total: 157 REC
-20-
o�
ATTACHMENT "C"
EXHIBIT D (CONTINUED)
For Falcon HeiQhts:
Part of the area of Falcon Heights' sanitary sewer system drainin� to the Hoyt Ave, sewer can be
described as follows: It is the area bounded by a line beginning at the intersection of Snelling
Ave. and Hoyt Ave., then north to the intersection of Snelling Ave. and Larpenteur Ave., then
east to Arona Ave. then south to the alley between Larpenteur Ave. and California Ave. then east '
along the alley to Pascal St. then south on Pascal St. to the intersection of the alley beriveen
Califomia Ave. and Idaho Ave. then west along the alley to the mid block point then south to the
intersection of the alley between Idaho Ave. and Iowa Ave., then east along the alley to the
midpoint of the alley between Pascal St. and Albert St. then south to the intersection of the alley
beriveen Iowa Ave. and Hoyt Ave. then east to the commercial properties fronting Hamline Ave.,
then south to Hoyt Ave.
This atea contains 134 homes or 134 REC
The Hollywood Court development contains 18 homes or 18 REC
During the past twelve months, 1550 W. Larpenteur used 2,724,216 gallons of water. This
amounts to: 2.724,216 = 34 REC
80,000 gaUREC
During the past twelve months, 1530 W. Larpenteur used 1,279,828 gallons of water. This
amounts to: 1,279,828 = 16 REC
80,000 gaUREC
During the past twelve months, 1667 N. Snelling Ave. used 2,303,840 gallons of water. This
amounts to: 2.303,840 = 29 REC
80,000 gaVREC
Therefore the total contribution of Falcon Heights sanitary flow to the Hoyt Ave. sewer is
231 REC.
-21-