The URL can be used to link to this page

216733 ./ r, S a-� 9`, l7 I Ia1��r�V� ORIGINAL TO CITY GLERK � IlED " _ �;.: ' . ,.. . '. CITY OF STp�� couNCi� NO. _._" OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK f��E � OUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM ,9 File No. 216733—By Frank L. / ' , p. ' - ;'.ved, Upon the pertinent appeal, PRESENT6D BY �, � ,;�• • rhe Zoning Co�3P by G �' COMMISSIONE DATF ,:K,; �,3 owner oP t11��•�+bjv,;t prF;;3� - rs �tu�'�:�'.011'_th� �A•� r .I^�:.�t_ _ 'ZYffB,`i?i ?y3;TiiLt2�'YS""eia,.0 �ii� – " ' �c'iu3!s"•�� 9�dr•..��,ftit 3 '`br,-- ` �� RESOLVED, upon the pertinent appeal� under the Zoning Code� by G.R. Struck� as owner ae the sub�ect premises situate in the City of Saint Paul on the West side of Lynnhurst Avenue between Feronia and Oakley Avenues� more particularly described as follows: All of Lots 115? 116� 117 118� 119, and all that part of L-ot 114 described as fo�lows: beginning at a point where the boundary line between Lots 114 & 115 intersect Lynnhurst Avenue W. thence SWly �0 feet on the west line of said Lynnhurst Avenue W. � thence NW1y to a point 2.83 feet east of the NW corner of said Lot 114� thence Ely 11.17 feet on the rear line of said Lot 114 to the NE corner of said Lot 114� thence SEly along the Nly line of said Lot 114 to the point of beginning; Union Park Addition� tha� the provisions of said Zoning Code hereby are determined and varied in application� as necessary therefor� and the building set- back line applicable to said premises in respect of the west line of Lynnhu.rst Avenue upon which a part of the same abuts� hereby is established as a line drawn across said premises parallel thereto and 12 feet distant from the west li�.e of said Lynnhurst Avenue� and that a special permit hereby is granted unto said appellant- � applicant and his successors and assigns� for the erection;; - maintenance� and operation of 34 apartment units � together with a 37-car capacity �off-street parking facility in conjunction there- with in accordance with plans dated February lg, 1g64, on the hereinabove described premises� provided that� otherwise� said appellant-applieant and his successors and �ssigns" shall make due comp]ia,nce with pertinent requirements of applicable ordinances� statutes, and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance. FORM PPROV��- 'sst. poratio� Counse( �EB 2 5 19�4 COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays Dalglish �FB 2� �� Holland proved 19— I'Ogg Tn Favor Mortinson /l _ Peterson V Mayor A gainst _D"_=_� i�avv'.�---- Mr. President, Vavoulis lODi 8-82 .. _ -r;• �` . � � ^yr. et , . :� Q�t F I G E O�F C I T Y C L E R K MRS. AGNES H. O'CONNELL City Clerk BUREAU OF RECORDS �� HAROLD J. RIORDAN 386 C�ity Hall and Court House � � Couneil Recorder St. Paul 2, Minnesota February 20� 196�+ � � �� C F�� 20 �g64 r�. �n��a L. ��S oRPORar10N cU Corporation Cour�sel IljvsE� Building Dear Sir: • The City Council requested that you prepare a resolution or resolutions granting the following; 1. Appeal of G. R. Struck -to establish a 12 ft. building line setba.ck froan W. Lynnhuxst Ave. 2. Appeal of G. R. Struck to relax the density sta.ndards to permit 3�+ apartment units to be constructed on a site having an area of 33,00o sq. . ft. ' 3. Appl3.cation of G. R. Struck for 37-car off-street parking lot � on property located on the west side of W. Lynnhurst Ave. betwee�a Feronia ��3 and 6akley Aves. as more fully described in the attached file� in accordance with pl.a.n� dated Februa,ry 19, 1g6�+. 1` � Ve t 1y yours, �•�. - � , � ��/ ,�u��N► C y Clerk ... ....• �.t ... a.• �. � � ... .�. �:.. I ... �. • N � 1111h. �� "" Illf ��1 ' � �� ' � � �� Y /� �` i? � p, ' ' � �� i t � / CITY UF SAINT PAUL - MINNESOTA 8� V1� • ....�.....,:A.•:::::•.•:L ,�� r j�:�.��.�':.:':.�........��. . a ti••:.•:::::. � .:..::::xr:.... •R::4 - ':•: :.t.;:;::r:i... ..... ...... .:....:•:•::... •:iii•�... r.:.•.T.:•::...... ... ....... :::�:;:::'��::8:�:�:;�c:R D O F Z O N I N G, C I T Y O F S A I N T P A U L �: ..... ;::.::.:.;.:� :x: �.... ....: """' '•:•i•:�iXIFN.Si.QRIi 431-]S]-439 1J13 CITY HALL AND COURT HOUSi SAINT�AUL 4,MINNIbOTA February 19, 1964 Mr. Harold J. Riordan • City Clerk Building Dear Sir: This is in the matter of the appeal of G. R.� Struck to 1) establish a 12 foot building line setback f rom W. Lynnhurst Avenue and 2) to relax the density standards to permit 34 apartment units to be constructed on a site having an area of 33,000 square feet, and 3) his application for a 37 car off-street parking lot in conjunction with the proposed apartment development which was referred to the Board of Zoning for re- commendation. The subject property is located on the west side of W. . Lynnhurst Avenue between Feronia and Oakley Avenues and iscbscribed as follows; all of Lots 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, and all that part of Lot 114 described as follows: beginning at a point where the boundary line between Lots 114 & 115 intersect Lynnhurst Avenue W. thence SWly 40 feet on the west line of said Lynnhurst Ave. W., thence NWIy to a point 2.83 feet east of the NW corner of said Lot 114, thence Ely 11.17 feet on the rear line of said Lot 114 to the NE corner of said Lot 114, thence SEly along the Nly line of said Lot 114 to the point of beginning; Union Park Addition. A .part of the subject property has recently been developed with an 18 unit apartment building and thereis also a large, old residence which will ' be removed for the purpose of erecting the second apartment building. (16 units) . The two buildings will be provided with off-street parking for 37 cars. This is an irregularly shaped tract of land having a combined f rontage of approximately 283.5 feet along the NWIy side of W. Lynnhurst . avenue and results in a total site area of approximately 33,000 square feet. Chapter 60.24 of the Legislative Zoning Code requires that 1,000 square feet of ground area be provided for each apartment unit, and inasmuch as the applicant is short of tbis requirement, he is required to secure Council authorization to build 34 units. He does qualify for a 33 unit development. He is also requesting a 12 foot building line setback for the proposed build- ing which would apply in this case to Lot 115. The Board of Zoning, at its regular meeting on January 9, 1964 after hearing a favorable report by the Planning Board staff and Traffic Engineer.*;s office, recommended to concur in the finding to grant the appeals as requested and the off-street parking facility for 37 cars as reflected in the applicant's plan dated received February 19, 1964. � �� , Sincerely, B. �t. Teig A.I.P. Z. F. 5317-57 _ Recording Secretary Encl. � Approved; " Member, of Zoning 1 � _ ._, � ..5. ` ♦ � ' . V ' , . f' + ' , . . NILVA, SHAW AND FRISCH • ATTORNEYS AT LAW > WEST 886 FIRST NATIONAL BANK BLDG. ST.PAUL 1,MINNESOTA ALLEN I.NILVA 227-8266 IRVING SHAW , GERALD E.FRISCH January 9, 1964 646-7901 Hon. Mayor and City Council City of Saint Pau1 Court House Saint Paul 1� Minnesota Re: Applications of Gordon R. Struck (James R. Riley Construction Co.) Gentlemen: There is presently pending certain applications of Gordon R. Struck (James R. Riley Construction Co.) for off-street parking permit and variances respecting proposed construction of apartment building on Lynhurst Avenue, which applications are now being re- viewed by the Zoning Board. These applications have been reviewed by members of the staff of the Planning Board and such review has resulted in changes in the proposed development. These changes re- quire request for amendment of the pending applications as follows; � (a) The legal description of the Teal property involved is to be amended to read as follows, � �� All of Lots 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, and s' all of that part of �Lot 114 desc�ibed as � ��'� follows: Beginning at a point where the � O�� boundary line between Lots 114 and 115 � �. �� .g° intersect Lynnhurst Ave. West, thence South- <�? P� �ti�� westerly 40 feet on the �West line of said >� ' ti~�• � Lynnhurst Av . West, thence Northwesterly V�� $�" �� to a point 2 5 feet East of the Northwes ` �=�. �4 '� ZP�3---� rner of said Lot 114, thence Easterly 1 1 6 I 1� �"� • G ti� � �'�,� feet on the rear line of said Lot 114 to the ��. � Northeast corner of said Lot 114, thence � Southeasterly along the Northerly•line of said � Lot 114 to the point of beginning, containing ' � 33,OOO.square feet. (b) Request for off-street parking permit for 37 off-street parking stalls in connection with existing 18-unit apartment building and the addition of a 16-unit apartment building on part of said des- cribed tract. � � . ; � �� _ . • . •a• � .., - � � . ` . . . � , - . Hon. Mayor and City Council. � " Page =2- `. _ January 9, 1964 _ ,.� . _ � . _ � . � (c),_ =T}iat permission be granted� for 'variance intensity re- " quirement to permit addition of said 16-unit apartment building upon said tract upon which there then will exist a total of 34 apartment � . units, which tract contains a total square foot area of .approximately . 33,000 square� feet. -_- -� � -'� _ (d) That the front yard set-back at the closest point of - ' - said proposed structure of 12 feet be permitted as a variance of the • front yard set-back requirement. • ' �' _ - � (e) That the requested permits include the alternative that' the proposed structure may contain 17 units provided at least an additional 1,000 square feet of adjoining property is acquired and becomes part of said total tract. - _ � . ' Copies of the revised Plot Plan have been submitted to members of the Planning staff and any further information that may • be required will also be submitted. We will appreciate your causing � the pending applications to be amended accordingly and are hopeful that �the revised plan will meet with the favorable consideration of _ the Zoning Board and City Council. - _ Respectfully submitted, �, . . _�� M�� Irving aw� " � . � � Attor y for Gordon R. Struck � • °�'�� (James R. Riley Construction Co.) ` �� _ � .____ _�- - _ r �— , � �j O � ZONING APPEAL �� \� v - � \�„ Notice is herebye-�ivbeforetthe City ,1� �j r� hearing will be h Id �t1 r V "�� Council at 10 A.M. on February 20, � � �U' O �� ti nr 1964, in the City Council Chamber in . � _` 1 ��- the City FIall and Court House, in the J matter of the appeal of G. R. Struck, IS:1 as �\`� `�`�y �,,�tir' paul Legis ltive Code,Zoning aode,for .. . �t'�t� �* permit for the establishment of a . . a] � aa��\• building line setback of 12 feet and for relaxaUon of density standard tor ��Sa?ttt � � multi-residence development for_34j - _ apartment upits on a tract oP property{ • having 33.000 square feet on the fol-f lowin8 described property: All of I.ots I - 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, and all of that part of Lot 114 described as follows:l � Beginning at a point where t h e t - - bqundary llne of I.ots 114 and 115 in-,� . teYsect Lynnhurst Ave. W., thence � southwesterly 40 feet on the west line� - ' of said Lynnhurst Ave. West, thence; " northwesterly to a point 2.83 feet east 4 - of the northwest corner of said Lot! ` 114, thence easterly 11.17 feet on the; ' rear line of said I.ot 114 to the north-', � east corner of said e°northerly linej � • southeasteriy along th, � � � ' of said Lot 114 to the point of begin- � . ning, Union Park Addition, on the , west side of Lynntiurst between Oakley - _ � ; and Feronia. ! Dated February B, 1964. { - AGNES Ii. O'CONNELL, � _ , , City Clerk. . • " - (February 8, 1964) . -,�- - . CITY OF SAINT PAUL � � MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 224-4612 �� February 7, 196l� City Clerk 386 City Ha11 St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 File 1629h, Page 1 � You are hereby notified tl�at the Council of the Cit� of St. Paul will consider the matter of the apnlicat�on of G. ?�. Struclt for a nermit , to instal.l and operate a 37-car off-street parking lot accessory to an existin�; 18-unit a�artment and a ?�ronosed 16-unit a�artment building on attached described _�ronerty: all of Lots 115, 116, 117� 118, 119, and all of that nart of Lot 111� rlescribed a..G, 1011OT,�?S: beginning at a point t�ahere the boundary line between Lots 114 and 115 intersect Lynnhurst lvenue ?��est, thence southti,resterly 40 feet on the taest line � of said Lynnhurst l�venue West, thence northtaesterly to a point 2.83 feet east of tlze northwest corner of said Lot 11LG, thence easterly 11.17 feet on the rear line of said Lot 11l� to the northeast corner of said Lot 17.la.� thence southeasterly along tne northerly line of said Lot 114 to the point of beg�nning; Union Park Addition. The �ronerty i s located on the west side of Lynnhurst bett•reen Oaltle� and Feronia Streets. A public hearing �rill be held in th� Council ChamUers of the Court Hou s� and City FIall in the City of St. Paul, at 10:00 a.m. on February 20� 19b4. JAi?�S J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance ., . r • � CITY OF SAINT PAUL � . MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 224-4612 �� February 7, 1961� City Clerk 386 �ity Ha11 St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 File 16295, Page 1 � You are hereby notified that the Council of the City of St. Paul will con�ider the matter of the application of G. R. Struck for a permit to establish a building line setback of 12 feet ancl relax the density standard for multi-residence development to •pe�mit a total of 31� apart- ment units on a tract having 33,000 square feet on attached described property: all of Lots 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, and all of that part of Lot 111� described as follows; beginning at a poirit where the boundary line between lots lll�. and 115 interaect Lynnh�irst Avenue West, thence southwesterly 40 feet on the westline of said Lynnhurst Avenue �Jest, thence northwesterly to a point 2.83 feet east of� the northwest corner of said lot 114, thence Easterly 11.17 feet on the rear line of said lot 114 to the northeast corner of said lot 1]1�.,^ thence southeasterly -- al.ong the xtortllerly line of said lot 111a. to the point of beginning; Union Parlt Addition. The property is located on the west side of Lynnhurst bet�aeen Oakley and Feronia Streets. A public hearin� %rill be held in the Counci]. Chambers of the �ou rt House and City Ha11 in the City of St. Paul, at 10:00 a.m. on February 20, 196l�. JAMr.,S J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance ,-- � `Y . ,,,,;, �.� . . � . . . - �3y � 7 �'� � � r ,-==. City of Saint Paul, Minnesota - ' ' APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT !� 2'� 6� • (Please print or type) � �- TO THE RUNORABLE MAYOR AND CITY (30UN�CIL " � the City Clerk City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Application is hereb made to remodel or reconstruct an existing y install and operate a new (cross one out) � FILLING STATION No. of islands and pumps : - No. of tanks and capacity: � PARKING LOT for (c�Q��g) (�� (Private use) (��caczr�� (p�b�x) (indicate type) Capacity of parking lot 17 off-street parkinq stalls To be used in connection with: 17 unit apartment building � MISCELI�ANEOUS: (indicate type such as Drive-in Refreshment Stand, Used Car Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 3tation, Ice Vendor, etc.) , Capacity of parking area: *Locatioa : 441 �`lest Lynnhurst Averiue Legal Description : Lot (See Legal Descriptia8lock Addition on attached rider) Applicant's Name � G• R. Struck Home or Office Address: 461 �Jest Lynnhurst Avenue Phone Number : 644 - 7162 FOR/�d36c TI3E APPLICAIV'T, NILV " AND FR C B : , � 6 Irving S a w re (date 8 6 Firs t Na tiona l Bank Bldg., Addreas : aint Paul 1, Minnesota. Phone No.: 2� _ 8266 When completed: �ile three copies of this application form and three priats of the preliminary lay-out plans of the proposed facilitq with the City Clerk, Room 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota Z-3 6/11/56 *EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St. 2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St. � E,�1 . `'. Ty � • v-� ' � • � • , � ' . � " LEGAL DESCRIPTION: , • All that part of Lots 116 and 117 Union Park lying Southerly of the ° , following described lines beginning at a point on the W9est line of said Lot 116 distant 10.2 feet �outherly of the Northwest corner of said Lot 117, thence Easterly on a straight line' to a point on tYie Easterly line of - said Lot 117 distant 29.3 feet Southerly of the Northeastrcorner of said Lot 117; all of Lot 115 Union Park; all that part of Lot 114 Union Park ` described as follows: beginning at a point where tYie boundary line,between Lots 114 and 115 in Union Park intersect Lynnhurst"Avenue ZNest�' ,thence Southerly to the 3Nest line of said Lynnhurst Avenue �iest, thence Northwest- erly to a point 2 5�6 feet East of the Northwest corner of said,Lot 114, thence East 11 1�6 feet on the rear line. of said Lot 114�to the Northeast corner of said Lot 114, thence Southeastexly along the Northerly line of said Lot 114 to point of beginning; and all that part of Lot 116 and 117 Union Park lying Southerly of the following described line; beginning at a point on the �➢est line of said Lot 117 _distant 20.2 fee� Southerly to the Northwest corner of said Lot 117, thence�Easterly on a straight line to a point on the Easterly line of said Lot 117 distant 6.3 feet Southerly of � the Northeast corner of said Lot 117 and lying Northerly of the following described lines beginning at a point on the �9est line of saicl Lot 116 dis- - tant 10.2 feet Southerly to the Northwest corner of said Lot 117, thence Easterly on a straight line to a point on the Easterly line of said Lot - 117 distant 29.3 feet Southerly of the Northeast corner of said Lot 117, all according to the recorded plat thereof on file and of record in the , office of the Register of Deeds in and ,for Ramsey County, Minnesota. .� . . . - 3 ' � . ' , . LAW OFFICES . ,' . FIORI L. PALARINE " 824 NEW YORK BLDd. . ST. PAUL 1, MINN. CAPITAL 4-2144 February I8,1964 � �, - ' To: � � TIze City Clerk Court House St. Paul, Minnes.ota Dear Dsr. Riordan: In Re: � Ob,jections of Erwin T. ancl Elmer E. Steffan 8c The General Home Improvement Company to the Application of G. .R. Struck �or a Permit to Install and operate a Parking Lot etc. , I�m enclosing herewith Ob�jections in the a�ove entitled matter in behal� o� said parties containing the grounds thereof. Copies of the same have been mailed to the Mayor and members of t he Council . ,_ I have personally viev�ed the premises arid can state that unless the condition comp].ained o3 therein is corrected s,aid par�ties will sustain subs�tantial damagea. . I believe thra.t their request is reasonable and should be granted. Res}� tfully yours, P/e . L. Pal arine . :�, . . . � ADVF...R3',ISING .DUPLICATING PRINTING ADVERTISING DUPLICATING PRIIVTII3G PRII�TI G�R��UUPL .-. IN .��L-�I. � �� ADVERTISING DUPLICATING PFtiNTING ADVERTI5ING DUPLIGATING PRWTING DUPLiCATING PRINTING ADVERTISING DUPLICATING PRINTING ADVERTISiNG To the Honorable Mayor and City Council , City of St. Paul � We should like to go on record in opposition to the application of G. R. Struck, your File 16295. We are opposing his application for the following reasons: Since the construction of an apartment house by G. R. Struck directly opposite our property, we have not i ced a f lood i ng cand i t ion onto our property that had never existed before, and we have continuously occupied this property since September of 1951 a The reason for this flooding condition in our opinion, is that the contour of the � land was changed in the process of construction to provide a slope in the direction of our property. This matter was called to the attention of the Department of . Streets and Alleys and Mr, Struck was brdered to provide a curbing on his property and to leave the alley in the same condition as it was before construction opera- tions began. The curbing was installed, but the level of the grade of the alley was not restored to its previously existing condition. In spite of the fact that we have had relatively little moisture thus far this winter, we notice that far more water has collected on our property than has been there in other seasons. If we have only an average amount of moisture �in the Spring, we wi I I have a situation where a warehouse on our property wi I I be under several feet of water. Tliis will either ruin the cbntents of the warehouse or will force us to spend in excess of $2,000.00 to raise the level of this warehouse above the level � of the wciter that wi I I col lect there. Therefore, we respectfully request that the application be denied unless the applicant agrees to remedy the condition above referred to within d reasonable time, which condition to be conta i ned i n the order. � Yours truly, � � DUPLICATING PRINTING ADYEATISINC DUPLICATING PRINTING ADVERTISINC PRINTING ADYERTIStNG DUPLICATING PRINTiNG ADVERTISING DUPLICATINC 448 north prior • saint paul 4, minnesota • midwa�r 8-7308 ADVERTISING DUPLICATING PRINTING ADVE TISING DUPLICATING PRINTINC DUPLICATING PRINTING ADVERTISiNG DUPLICATING PRINTING ADVERTIS[NC �, °; . +, . �... _ , y . 1 . . . - •a . I . . NILVA, SHAW AND FRISCH - ATTORNEYS AT LAW ' I W EST 686 FIRST NATIONAL BANK BLDG. ST.PAUL 1,MINNESOTA ALLEN I.NILVA I 227-8266 IRVING SHAW ; GERALD E.FRISCH � JaC1UaTy 9� 1964 646-7901 Hon. Mayor and City Council City of Saint Pau1 Court House Saint Paul 1, Minnesota Re: Applications of Gordon R. Struck (James R. Riley Construction Co.) Gentlemen: There is presently pending certain applications of Gordon R. Struck (James R. Riley Construction Co.) for off-street parking permit and variances respecting proposed construction of apartment building on Lynhurst Avenue, which applications are now being re- viewed by the Zoning Board. These applications have been reviewed by members of the staff of the Planning Board and such review has resulted in changes in the proposed development. These changes re- quire request for amendment of the pending applications as follows: (a) The legal description of the real property involved ��\is to be amended to read as follows, �V All of Lots 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, and � all of that part of -Lot 114 described as �O �� {� follows: Beginning at a point where the O �� ,� boundary line between Lots 114 and 115 a i Qe.g° intersect Lynnhurst Ave. West, thence South- � P�� `ti � ' westerly 40 feet on the 'West line of said � ' �ti �� Lynnhurst Av . West, thence Northwesterly � g.�"' � to a point 2 5 . feet East of the Northwes ,��, •,� ` ''� �p$3�---� rner of said Lot 114, thence Easterly 1 1 6 ► j,, ('7 G� �Q a',a feet on the rear line of said Lot 114 to the �� Northeast corner of said Lot 114, thence �� Southeasterly along the Northerly line of said � Lot 114 to the point of beginning, containing • � 33,OOO.square feet. (b) Request for off-street parking permit for 37 off-street parking stalls in connection with existing 18-unit apartment building and the addition of a 16-unit apartment building on part of said des- cribed tract. r .'� - � - LAW OFFICES , ' �KA �� .�J'� f� ?� - ,v 2 F 1 O R 1 L. P A L A R 1 N E � � 9G �°"°"`� 7� �,? Fc8 18 r 'r"°'"�,�� _ ',�. 929 NffW YORK BLDC3. �� - F �'�w �'1�� . w�•�a.,,,a� �` , n 1r� 8T. PAUL 1, MINN. I�� ' ' E � - ��, ' M i N�' �? �',�.� Cit� Clerk �i � Court House St. Paul , Minnesota