225811 -- - � + ' - ' - � �s ��',f,'zi�'�;-i�;. � ,r
. � r,-i �� i�.-!'>�'
v)P
_ . I `}' •` s , " ��;L `��!
�_ � e°`;, �' , COUNCIL FILE N0. ���� � -
_ _ ., - CITY OF ST. PAUL - �
_ ` 'i . By r �_
i Resolution Ratifying and Confirming ti
� Condemnadon and Awards of Damages File No. �'��
and Assessment 'Y'herefor �
� �
In the matter of ���FSa ���� �d� p-�.'��"--�f� "�he �ho�'.t �te �t'�d i'�t Ju�st
Avenue to Js��'erson �venu� '�y�ec�a.� 8nd �ing ithe �ol�c�'ing' 8e�c�3bed pQrce�
oF 3�n�:' �cegt -the �Iest �i4 :�t.,� t� ,Zr�3�owingf 3aot 8,, e�cept t.2�t �c�L tbereof
tak�en �or �e��'Srson,Ave�ue, 3�ots 9 and .10:� and� �Iia� � si� �t 11, �xxg Aorth-
wes�ter3y o�.a strbS:$ht .3'Lu� e�teac�g �rc� #,J�e �o�e�st carn.er s�' �vt 11, tq a
pof.nt on � �ouf,h �3.ne oP sa�c� �o� 3.3:x �±0 ��. e�et of the �aou�wast: eorYter tbereo��:
a]3 in B1.ack 17, I�3c�rood.�ark���#t�ri #o t�a C3.�� Q�` S�nt Pau�, �amsey, �oun��,
Mi.nne�ot,�: _
�, _
�
, under Preliminary 0�•der 2��'j71: -- , approved �tme .T�9.�,5 ,
�
Inteimediary Order ���$ , approved ���- ��s ��&�
,
Final Order �2��6 , approved ����x` �.� �965 ,
A l�ublic hearing having been had upon the taking and condemnation of the lands or easements
therein, for the above improvement, and the award of damages therefor, and also upon the assessment
of benefits therefor, and the Council having duly considered the same, now therefore be it -
• �
+ Resolved, That the taking and condemnation of the lands described in the annexed assessment roll,
identified by the signature of the Commissioner of Finance, and made a part hereof, and the awards of
damages to the owners of such lands for said taking and condemnation as set forth in said assessment
roll, be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified and confirmed.
_ P�esolved further, that the said assessment of benefits, be and the same is hereby in all respects
' ratified, and the same is hereby ordered to be submitted to the District CoLirt for confirmation.
�� �e�i�-f e , a e sai assessmen e an i is ere y e er
� men .
I
_ � . , .
;. . _
i
COUNCILNlEN
Yeas Nays n 1..- " �O� 3 ��6�J
Dalgiish .
- - � i Holland � \ Adopted by the Co xncil
i ' �OSS "' �"
JVleredith . Appr v 3 ���
�Peterson �
Rosen In Favor
fd f
, �/avouFis ! � , ayor
Against
- � Form R-S �bs
, _ � ;PUBUS�E� NOV 6 ���
,�,� - . �
� � _ � � � - - - �
� �
/v ._ --� G .�-..._, _
�� _ � ' '
; � .: '
�-- ` � �� CITY OF ST. PAUL � ������
" �y_�
� '/ Report of Commissioner of Finance �
• on Condemnadon of Lands File No. �'�
. , - ��
In the matter,of ��# �t�� �Bitt�.�,� $��� ;�ifsi�:�f,� �,.�T��
,At�'� �ts ���?��a ��ezau� �y +�c3z�� ea� � '�he �c���S" 'da�r,�'6� ���
�' �: �� � �� � ��y �� ���.��s '�►� �, ��c tt�a�, � �z�o�'
t�n .��rr J�J.`�����v�cn�;�a,� �Ca� � ��::�,� �i� �Sti� � �':�� �:i �;y3�.':za�h�.
�s�x��� q� � �t.�.�� � ear�f� �t: � :aa�a�a� +�c�� �' �� 13., �a �:
��u� c�t �a �t�_h 3�O �� ��. ,�'� `�:� �t3 ��. �� �� #�r �mu��� �r�er �r��at�
�: it� �!e3� .�.'�,� ��a�i �It +�s����� � ��. ��"t�r �of ��� �t��. ��� �u��3r�
�?�1ni].�i3f1'�t*
...
under Preliminary Order �,�.�. , approved .;`j��, �.���. ,
�i Intermediaiy Order �� , approved ��t t1� ���: �.�� ,
Final Order �� , approved ��'��� �:# l��i ' ,
TO THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL:
The Commissioner of Finance hereby reports: �
That he has fixed and determined the value of the land, lands or easements therein taken and a�-
propriated for the above improvement and the amounts of the awards of dainages therefor to the own-
ers thereof, and the persons to whom such awards are payable; that he has also fixed and determined
the amount of benefits to property, from the making of said improvement, not exceeding the cost
thereof, and that attached is an assessment roll entitled as above and identified with the signature of
the undersigned, containing the undersigned's finding on said matters.
� `
. _ ; -
.l�jL�d P
� Co issioner inanc
. . - .. i �' �'����
- . ,
_.� ,
• J
� JEROME E. FRANKE
ATTORNEY AT LAW
7255 WEST LARPENTEUR AVENUE
SAINT PAUL� �INNESOTA 55113
645-4539
November 2, 1965
The Honorable City Council ;
C ity of St. Paul
Court House �
St. Paul 1; Minnesota �
Re: Lot 9, Block 17, Ridgewood Park Addition
to the City of St. Paul
Gentlemen: '
This is to advise you that the Star of Bethlehem Home, Inc. , fee owner
of the above described property herebg �gives notice that it ob�ects and
takes exception to the amount awarded for damages in the taking of the
abone property for the opening, widening and extending of the �hort �ine
(�oad from Julie� Avenue to Jefferson Avenue. In a letter dated September
1,1965 from J. William Donovan, the assistant paluation engineer for
the city of $t. Paul, the owner of the above property was advised that
the damages to be awarded would be in the amount of $500. The owner feels
that these damages are ina`dequate to compensate it for the loss of the
property taken in the aboae condemnation proceedings.
The Star of Bethlehem Home, Inc. , received a Written offer to purchase
the above lot for $2,500 from Mr. Lloyd J. Stranskg on April 28, �965.
, Mr. Stransky orally renewed this offer in August, 1965. A photocopy of
this offer is attached hereto. On the basis of this offer by Mr. Stransky,
the owner feels that the award set forth in Mr. Donovan�s letter does not
adequately refc�ect the valae of the property involved.
y truly your , /
i a f
. �
I
erome E. Franke
� �'i� €'� �
JEF:kc I "' �
Enclosure
�
' 965 l�ov 2 Pt� 2 �1��+
�
' c�TY c.�-�=.<<�°� 5:��i►vi
- :S���N°f P���.�: ��,i:i t��,a.
. •, ,
i
_ : ,
1�4 'ni:�+ •^�' '
t♦ :j . .
� -
� I � , �::r:...A[�- '-'.d..'�.1L..�i.:a.i.'_.. _........- -.i`.l.....'_� j - '.y - �. ' ` -. �
. .I � � �7 • �/w�+"W � :
' � � 29 � f �h��
, . - .� � �R _ ��9/��a � /9 �� � . .
/ ' �
� . ,� . � '=� � ��2- ��/L � . .
_ � ,� , -
' - . . J �C.,�� .
- ; i0/j '/��:���r� �i�,� �r>
� ' - . - /� � T O GL'/I'�c� f�7 E- �57�/��CZ. �-���'z%7�-n
. .� �- _
�� ,1
:f ; ' . ��, ��?'Y� ��-j��7 � �y 1 �� G .5 � ��
. j � � ,, /
, - ;,,, - e� 7`: /"r¢�=--W '1 G� z�CC.I.< ���,� �GCC�`i' • ._ _ _ _ -
� � /�G l �j.
. � � . �
� �+ ��.[-�!C/C., �� _��C� , ^.i' L �J �_` �1-f-�G.�c' f /�_ .
'•i , r /
' � � '� ����o�b CG�.l��/��U Cx�1 F.-S .
� �Y �/Y7 �"S GG�/l�c C c c--x/- �9/3'� t�' .
� 7
• A a�! !
1 T �f/�/�, �7 � �t
�� WU Q Ca/G LC ��0��'G ��.0��' G C�l�X��a�'1
a •
, ' �,o �2�, C'��,_Sc.�. �c�� �f S�; . .
� . f� �
, - � �. � ��1�� � � .
- � ��
� . / � ` � /� /�/y� ,
- � � . `✓ �/C /v/ i ��� I
�� ,� � .
_ : ��o � � ,������ �-�.
_ � .-. �_ �__ ��_ __ _ �/ � _ . _ ���._.� � �_ �___.y__.._._._ �- _ _ _ _
' , , i �l ,��QGC� c�ztic -�,5��'iG� Y �
� � . .� / _ � , ,
. ' . /J �� r�a � D��
� Y
, � � � � �0 � � � . � ,
- � � . �
� � ���-- ,....
-� - ;_ - .,- �_ � 4� .
, � . +. �
. . � d ., -
_ - *� rw+r�r+.�.r+�r�o .�..Y �e•_. . � - + • - ..rr.s+aTe+T^1""' '^'."1!+'Y, ..4� �,_ ± '°i - r • =
. . � _ ' �, , . } ' - ' �_ ` t _� ' �� .
. � y . , . ,.7, 'r
. � . -
_ . . _ - , `�, , ' ,
� _
r , � r } .
` . _ , ` ' • - �ri -
. ' - . t ��• -� -
' , _ , ' ` ,' _�
. - r '
., . .. r i
" I .•-
� � ��� �/
. BUNDLIE, KELLEY AND TORRISON
GERHARD BUNDLIE I
JAMES E.KELLEY ATTO R N EYS AT LAW
� MANDT TORRISON 10430 II
JAMES C.O NEILL
JOHN J.CONNELLY
� H.BLAIR KLEIN �
� 425 HAMM BUILDING
JOSEPH W.FINLEY SAI NT PAU L, M I N N ESOTA 55102
1896-1953 i 222-7463
2 November 1965
� City Council of Saint Paul �
Court Hous e
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55IO2 �
Attention Mr. James J. Dalglish, Commissioner of Finance
Mr. Thomas J. Kelley, Deputy Commissioner
Re: Objection to awarding of damages on File No. 16894,
Parcel Nos. 1 and 3. I
�23�5�TB� In the matter of opening, widening and extending the
�"S � .h � Short Line Road from Juliet Avenue to Jefferson Avenue
� ���°.•'•'`O � by condemning and taking the following described par-
.c, � ��� - +� cels of land: Except the VPest 40 ft. , the following:
"� �£C, Lh� � Lot 8, except that part thereof taken for Jefferson
�, ��' G�, � avenue, Lots 9 and I0, and that part of Lot 11, lying
s'� � � �,t'' northwesterly of a straight line extending from the
`��'� � ��,�� northeast corner of Lot 11, �to a point on the south •
� � l 0 6� line of said Lot 11, 40 ft, east of the southwest cor-
ner thereof, all in Block 17, Ridgewood Park Addition
to the City of Saint Paul, Ramsey County, Minnesota.
. �
I
Gentlemen: � '
�
Pursuant to the Notice of Hearing in condemnation proceedings dated
5 October I9 65, s ent to Mrs. Jos eph J.: (Ilma S. ) Ermatinger, 36 2
South Lexington Parkway,. Saint Paul, Minnesota, the owner of Lots
8 and 10, Block 17, Ridgewood Park Addition, the undersigned, act-
ing as counsel for Mrs. Ermatinger, does hereby file this objection
to the proposed award of damages. �
i
The proposed award of damages was : i
PartofLot8 - - - - - - - -� - - - - $ 500. 00
Partof L 10 - - - - - - - = - - - -
ot 500. 00
The basis for this objection is the opinion of Mr. E. Vincent Dolan,
realtor and appraiser, dated 25 October' 1965, that the damages due
Mrs. Ermatinger from the taking is the sum of $1,200.00.
Very truly yours,
BUNDL � , KELLEY AND TORRISON
/ . _
JCO'N:ar By
Jame s C. O'Neill
CC: City Clerk '
J
.. zzJ� l ` .
; /
, BUNDLIE, KELLEY AND TORRISON
GERHARO BUNDLIE
JAMES E.KELLEY ATTO R N EYS AT{LAW
MANDT TORRISON p
, JAMES C.ONEILL ' IO�JO I
` JOHN J.CONNELLY
N.BLAIR KLEIN I
i 42b HAMM BUILDING
� SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102
JOSEPH W.FINLEY !
18H6-1953 , � 222-7463
2 Noverriber I965
� 1'l�.� l� �
City Council of Saint Paul
Court Hous e
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55IO2 �
Attention Mr. James J. Dalglish, Commissioner of Finance
'65 ��Ol� 2 p�I � :5�1
Mr. Thomas J. Kelley, Deputy Commissioner
CITY G�,:��;c��":��:'yi;i��w�:
Re: Objection to awarding of damages on File No. I6894, �(,�,��`�. .��1��� ;�����,p�
Parcel Nos. I and 3. ;
In the matter of opening, widening and extenc�ing the
, Short Line Road from Juliet Avenue to Jefferson Avenue
, by condemning and taking the following described par-
cels of land: Except the West 40 ft. , the following:
Lot 8, except that part thereof taken for Jefferson
avenue, Lots 9 and I0, and that part of Lot I1, lying
northwesterly of a straight line extending from the
northeast corner of Lot I1, to a point on the south •
line of said Lot I1, 40 ft. east of the southwest cor-
ner thereof, all in Block 17, Ridgewood Park Addition
to the City of Saint Paul, Ramsey County, Minnesota.
Gentlemen: '
Pursuant to the Notice of Hearing in condemnation proceedings dated
� 5 October I965, sent to Mrs. Joseph J. (Ilma S. ) Ermatinger, 362
South Lexington Parkway, Sa?nt ?aul, R�innesota, the owner of Lots
8 and 10, Block I7, Ridgewood Park Addition, the undersigned, act-
ing as counsel for Mrs . Ermatinger, does hereby file this objection �y L�D
to the proposed award of damages . ' -
The proposed award of damages was : , �
PartofLot8 - - - - - - - - - - - - $ 500. 00 9 2 e� d
Partof Lot IO - - - - - - - = - - - - 500. 00 65 �aod .. �
,
The basis for this objection is the opinion of Mr. E. Vincent Dolan, ����K�S U
realtor and appraiser, dated 25 October 1965, that the dama es due C1��
" Mrs . Ermatinger from the taking is the sum of $1,200.00, g � SAtN� ����"' !'
• Very truly yours,
BUNI?L , KELLEY AND TORRISON� .
�
JCO'N:ar Ey
� •
CC: City Clerk Jame s .C. O'Neill
� � 1
♦ 1
�
JAMES J. DALGLISH
COMMIBSIONER OF FINANCE
CITY OF ST. PAUL �
118 CITY HALL �
� � i
i
�
�
1
November 3, 1965 I
i
_ �
� Mr. Robert Gerber
City Clerk �
BUILDING �
i
Dear Sir: -
�
Will you please have the attached letter read -
at the council hearing on ttie matter today,
November 3, 1965. '
Thank you. '
Sincerely yours, :
t �
�
ames Dalgl sh F
�
�
�
i
;
�az !
;