225636 ORIGINAL' TO CITY GIERK '" � y
� CITY OF ST. PAUL �o�NC�� 22��3�
• OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK F��E NO _
OUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
�RESENTED CY
COMMISSIONE DATF
RE�OLVED� upon the pertinent appeal under the Zoning Code
by Mr. and Mrs. Arfield Lecy, as owners of the sub�ect property
situate in the City of Saint Paul� described as Lot 9 and the
east 2.5 feet of Lot 10� Bloak 2, Holcombets Addition to Saint
Paul located on the south side of Marshall Avenue between Grotto
and S�t. Albans Streets� that the provisions of said Zoning Code
hereby are determined and varied in application so that the premises
may contain separate accommodations for several� not more than four
families, provided that the continuance of such four-family dwelling
be for the remaining life of the structure now on said premises�
and provided further� that the appellants comply with the changes
set forth in the B ureau of Public Buildings and Housing Code
Division report dated August 3� 1965, and provided further, that
snch permission shall lapse ipso facto unless the appellants are
in full compliance with the above report� dated August 3� 1965�
� �t�.�htn one year from the date of this resolution� and provided
further, that the appellants provide a total of four off-street
;�: parking spaces for said dwelling in the rear of the lot upon which
o• �'y` the structure is located by removing the present garage and allowing
access for perpendicular parking from the alley, acceptan.ce of this
� � resolution and terms to be made by the appellants, and subject to
o compliance with said provisions, the Cour�cil expresslp finds that such
relief will be consistent with the pubTic health and general welfare�
�- �,; and that said relief and permission herein granted is subject to
• the further condi-Gion that the appellants and their successors
� and assigns otherwise shall make due compliance with all applicable
o provisions of Municipal Ordinances, State Statutes, rules and
regulations of public authorities having cognizance; further, that
a �opy of this Resolution be filed with the Reg3.ster of Deeds in
and for Ra.msey County, Minnesota.
_ ZONING P AL �
�
� �ti Notice is hereby gi e v�hat a public
hearing wlll be hefcl� before the City
Council at 10 A.M. on September 30,
1965, in the City Council Chamber in.
the City Hall and Co}�rt House, in the
Amr&�eld Lecy e unde Chapte s 60 to 84 O rjT �j O �9�5
inclusive, St. Paul Legislative Code,
COiTNCILMEN zor►�g Code, for continuation o� 8 Adopted by the Council 19—
I four-plex in a "B" Re�idence District
;on the east 2.50 ft. of Lot 10 and all
Yeas . Nays�on the�ou�h s�eoof Marshall iAve.
Dalglish �between Grotto and St. Albans sts. oC� 2 � �96�
i Dated September 16, 1985. �
Holland ROBER�B. GERBER, aT., Appro e 19—
� City Clerk.
Loss � (September 18, 19&5) �
- - - - - - - _ or ^
cNfere'dith-�-
Peterson � ��t�� N�YOr
A gainst
n ,
t: r:�°�oa•••� s' s i6'i?
�:�����'��°���`� ':' PUBLISHED OCT �� �� '
Mr. Vice President (Rosen)
lont �s
� .t � .
. ,�--°
Robert B. Gerbe�, Jr. � ��``t* '"y Albert B. Olsoe
City Clerk and � '� Council Recorder
Commissioner of Registration � , ���
. ,. - - � �36
�, :�..o �.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
, BUREAU OF RECORDS
886 City Hall
St.Paul,Minnesota 5510E
September 30, 1965
�
Mr. Stephen L. Maxwell
Corporation Counsel
Building
Dear Sir: "
The City Council requested• that you prepare a resolution granting
the attached appeal of Mr. & Mrs. Arfield Lecy to legalize and
continue an existing four-plex in a "B" Residence District on
property on the south side of Marshall Ave. between Grotto and
St. Albans Sts. , described as Lot 9 and the east 2.5 feet of
' Lot 10, Block 2, Holcombe's Addition, subject to the terms and
conditions as set out in the attached letter of the Zoning Board,
and subject further to the appellants' providing 4 off-street
parking spaces.
ery truly yours,
, u-��J""�C.J�-- � �
City Clerk
ng �
{� � ,
�`��0 �;
S�p 3d t965 �:
CDRPORI4�ION � .
C�llN5Et
�22 �
. : , �
�» y_ ,. M; ,
�::. :.r. ' �.,,,. . .
�'. .�� ' ' ,
::.�::�� ���JARD OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�.�'I�ti�23•4151 Room 20 CITY HALL � COURT HOUSE SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102
- ' " � � ' Septem'ber 28, 1965
_ , � r .
f , _ • , • •
Mr. Rober�. B. Gerber, Jr. - �' � •
City Clerk ' _ � � � .�, - '_ ' _ ,
r �~
Buildirig . - -� '
� • ~ - . �,
Dear Sir: , . • � 4 - ' _
� �- '
�� ' This is in response to the referral of the appeal of Mr. & Mrs. Arfield
� Lecy to legalize and continue an existing four-plex located in a "B"
� residence district on property 1'ocated-on the south side of Marshall � �
Avenue between Grotto and St. Albans Streets. The property is described
as Lot 9 and the east 2.5tifeet of�Lot 10,;Block 2, Holcomb's Addition.
In 1888 the subject property was developed1with the existing structure
which was built as a two family residence. At some unknown date, the �
use of the structure was extended to that of a four family dwelling.
Because the property is classified "B"' residence district, the applicant
is filing an appeal to secure Council authorization to continue the use
of the property as a four-plex. _ ,± � . �` ,
�
The Board of Zoning heard this matter on August 19, 1965. The staff
reported that there is one off-street parking space presently being
provided in the front yard of' Marshall Avenue. Sufficient off-street .
parking can be provided by removing the present garage and by providing
parking perpendicular off the alley at the rear of the site. If is the
Board's recommendation that the appeal to continue the four-family
dwelling for the life of the structure be granted subject to compliance
with the changes set forth in the Bureau of Public Buildings � Housing
Code Division report dated August 3, 1965, a copy of which is attached,
and subject to the applicant providing a total of four off-street parking
spaces. It is also recommended that, should the Council grant the appeal, .
a copy of the resolution be filed with the deed in the Register of Deeds
. office. � �
_ Sin cerely,
, �� . `
Ng��� N. R. Heiden -
Encl. ' � . _ �
Z.F. # 5723 , '
, � � G
. ��
��
Y • - .. ` �� . � � 1��.�.r�
• ��'
_� ° �
i�_ � ��'�- .
�- ��
�- -- _- - - - _ -- _-- _ _�� _
� - - . �� -- --- _� _ _ _�
. j � ���� � ,� ��� ` .
� � ___ . ._ __ _
� ,
.
�°�-� -- � _� ~
--.._ — ---- - - - • - ---- ---G�"�--�/�-'_ ���'�-�-�__���?�� _�D - -- - -, -- - ---- -
-- ___-_____ �.�- �� - - -_ -- � ,
. ��,_ _ _ . _ __.__
- _ _____ � _ �_ �-� _ _ _ v � �_z� __ _�____
� -
_ -__ - - � _ ' .�_ - -- ��:�..--
- --_ - _ - - - � .- �_� . _ - �_
- - - - ����� . � L • __
- -- _ _ - ���.�. _�� � a�� ' � �� -
. �
_ ��� _ _�=� _��� ��-�--
- - - - -=- - � --� .- -�- ' w -
c�- �-`-� -- - - � �z� _ _
, _
-- - -
-- -.-----� _. . _ _�_ �C���� �_�._. �- -
- --
�- - -- -- -.-. __�.__ �-- - � <�
-------- -- �� � . -- -- �o- - - - --- -_-; - -- - - --- - --
- - --- --- - - - � - -l4 - - -- �- - - � -. _ _
__- ----- — L�C��-1_�__- -- - i---- ._ _. .._ �—��-— - -._.� _�,. __��'��j�.
-- -- --- -- - i�� _,�,e� - � - . � _ - �--- -- - —-----
---- - --- - --��� __ --- � - -- -- - - �-- - - - - - - _ . �__ _ _
- - `` _. ��
' - -- —
__ �____ - - -... _- __ _ . __ _ __
- �'- --- -- - - - - -- - _ _ �_`-?�-2_.__ .C�i_ __ �c..�_ _ _----
a � � � ' .
o�-�. - - --. -- ,-- ---- --__- - --. ------ - --- --- --- --- ---- .- -
�i � =� - = - - - - '��--� �-�- - - - - --_ --_�, - _ _ _
�a� h
2'! �C ��3. �f�C-d�- -�� GZ�_ `7_ �- ---e-�""�--- __ -
�__ � �'.� _ � -- --- --- --- -- J -
� -��" , _ - - - - .-� � -� -- . -� -_
- - ---�--- ---- -- - - � -- - -���� -- --_ �- . - - ---- ---
,j � n A
_ _��_'_ _ di�,�/���.-'� . '. __ _ ' _ _ _' ___ _ ___ _._�_ _
J
.
-- -- - - - -��- �- - _- - - �? _�
- - - - - - - . 2-. --- - ----
� • , , • , .
, '��� �, � � � � � � � �
�
• AU G 3 1965
August 3�, 1965
�����„�,�Aial���VlinneSQfi����
TOs City Planning and Zoning Board
FROM: Bureau of Public Buildings and the
Housing Code Division of the Bureau of Public Health
REs Appeal for authorization of a four-plex in a "B"
residential district at 708-710 Marshall Avenue�
Zoning File No 723
Filed by: Arfiel and Beverly Lecy, 1466 Ashland Avenue
The following is a list of items requiring alteration, repair or removal
to meet the minimum requirements of the Housing Code and Building Code.
..
708 Marshall � ' '
Basement: The water heater has an excessively long run ori'�tYie 'vent
pipe and it has sagged to the extent that the� fume`s are
trapped. Install the proper traps and venting to the
sinks and lavatories throughout the building.
Electric: Stairway light is in illegal extension cord and brass sock-- �
et. There are illegal brass sockets used in the basement
and one illegal BX run and other extension cords in use.
These must be replaced with wiring that meets the require-
ments of the St. Paul Electric Code.
Apt. ls Remove the illegal wall outlet in the living room.
Remove the illegal wall outlet in the bathroom and replace
with one that meets the Code requirements .
�. ` . Remove the two illegal wall outlets in the kitchen and
� install one additional legal outlet and remove the exten-
sion cords. ,
Apt. 2s Install a wall outlet in the bathroom.
710 Marshall °
Basements Repair the plastered walls and ceilings in the basement
where they are cracked�'falling.
Install a one-hour rated enclosure around and over the
boiler room.
Install a proper drain in the basement ,of 710 Marshall.
Presently� a cover of a backwater valve has been opened
and is being used as a floor drain. �
Provide vent for the laundry tubs .
Electric: Remove the extension cords and brass sockets and replace
with a wiring that meets the requirements of the St. Paul
Electric Code.
Install a new "service that is adequate for a four-plex.
At present, the branch circuits are overfused.
r i •
� ��M w ` u 1� y` ` �
i
' Apt. ls Provide one wall outlet in the front bedroom. Provide
one wall outlet in the rear bedroom.
Remove the brass socket from the bathroom and install one
wall outlet.
•Remove the illegal outlet from the kitchen and install one
� additional outlet and remove th.e extension cords .
Apt. 2s . Remove the brass socket from �he bathroom and the extension
cords from the front bedroom. '�
Also the additional improvements should be mades " �
(1) Increase the windo� .area to at least 10� of the floor area
in the bedroom of Unit 2 on $ie second floor at 708 to pro-
, vide proper light and ventilation.
�2) Repair plaster in the southwest bedroom of Unit 2 at 708.
Secure loose paper in the north bedroom of �Unit 1 at 710.
Repair scaling paint in the bathroom of Unit 1 �at 708 and in
the south bedroom of Unit 1 at 710.
' �3� Replace window panes in the dining room Qf Unit Y, in the
north and southbedrooms of Unit 2 ,at 708 and in the liying
room of Unit 1 at 710. Replace sash .cords in the south
bedroom of Unit 2 at 708 and in the north bedroom of Unit 1
at 710.., . �
`44) Replaee the interior door of Unit 2 at 708. Replace the torn
� - screen mesh in the kitchen of Unit 1 at 708. Dwelling Unit
2 at 708 has a broken screen frame in the kitchen andz�place
kitchen shades .
(5) Replace the broken door pane in the kitchen of Unit 2 at 710.
� �
��6) Repair hand .rail on the front stairway to the second floor
at 708 and clean and paint the front ,hallway. Install a
hand rail on the front and rear interior stairways to the
� second floor at 710. "
�7) . Repair the garage roof, install a hand rail �on the front
exterior steps , enclose the open area under the porch and
repair� csreplace the front porch deck.
�(8) Replace the screen windows in the cellar. These windows
must be operiable to pravide ventilation.
(9) Rat infestation in and around garage and also at the rear
of the house.
SB:vo •
.. 2 ..
i :� • �
, a � o
y� r
►
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
�
September 17, 19�5
City �lerk
File 16950, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing wi).l be held in the
Council Chambers of the City Hall and Cour� House in the City of
St. Paul at ].0:00 a.m. on September 30� 1965� on the �,pplication of
Nlr. and MrQ. Arfield Lecy for an appeal for continuation of a !�-plex
in ��B�� Residence District on the following property: east 2.5 feet
of Lot 10 and a11 Lot 9, Block 2, Holcombes Addition. The property
is located on the south side of Marshall Avenue between Grotto and
St. Alban� Streets.
For flirther information ca11 at Room 20, Court House or phone 223-l�151.
JAMES J. I14LGLISH
C6Ynmissioner of Finance
' --__•¢�f, 1 ... . . %� - ' " -o � .` Y- . . ' r.� � . .. � _ __
°� _ ., ' _ +„ ' ` ' . . - • �_
. T, T , _ _ ,_ % - . • -_ '. � ,
� - _ ' : ' ' � _ ;� � � ' . � ' . . - - . .�+.
*. _ . .. ` -- - - ` ry , ` . • ` ' F � . . Y
i- . -- _ - " ' -- . -- �- . . � _ - � , \" . ��� '� ' . - - , • .
_ -'� ' ' r _ . • ' C " _ , � . __ ` ._ .. _
_ , _ ,. -- . - . _- ' �Oatober 20, 1965 = - `� _. , ' - _
� . � , - - - . _ - } . • ' : � � - • . • T -
` Mr. & Mra: As�ffelc� Leayr , � .- ' . . ^ _ _ - �
� � - . 1�+66 Ashle�nd Ave, �, _ - -- ,
_ ' . ,. 8�. Paul� Minne�ota ` ' � • • � . __ � - -,
• - - - - . . .
; • , ,� Dee�r Mr. da Mra. Lec3rt : . � _ � . �� ` . Y . _ . " ' '
' , - Eneloaed ia a aop� o� � remoluti 6 Y�u. permieeion to _- = _
_� � ,Qorit9.rine �he p�eeent use of o r�t e► desari'bed-therein� - _ ' �
� . "_ 9'o+i�ii�. note that the aqluti equi the a,ppellante� '�o . . - .
-, - - • �.ec�p� itQ�tGrms e�,nd ditions� aldeed is a, form ot' ncceptence -�
- � � e►nd v�e ask '�hat yov� g and ret� it to-thie office. - • � -
_ . _ .. , --
. , 1.. . . . - VeY'Y tru7,Y Yo'�'�� ° `- �.
- .. - ._ . _ � .�.Y . �_ _-. � :_. .� ` � _ f . - . - -
- , � . _ . � � _ .� � _ . , , ...City Clerk ` ` - � �
- - , ���ng � . 3 _ . - _ _ , _ , -
T ' - J , •.. - I J _ a� M . � . � ' • - � , � • Y
` . , ` . __ - , '- n + � _ - f J � - �
• � ' ' ` � • • h � - -` • ` ' i
� • � � � - � 4 • , � � _ • , � � , `r _
, ' ""' . _ . ^ _ 3� , � - _ � - ' `'
` '' ` ' ' " t d " " � , ' • � _ � _
'� � � - , ` Y S � • J� .\�� Y 1 . ,� , , _ M1_ ' ` ( ._. - ` T� .
' ', r. " � - - . ` _ 1 • . '• � . .. . _ ` s
, , / V V
\
�
�
11°J STATE OF MINNESOTA
`t'°I co,��u �ue rro. z�ss3s—sy F=�x L• County of Ramsey ea.
� Loss— "
P^ solv�d,.upon the pertinent appeal CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�.+ under the Zoning Code by Mr,and Mrs.
� Arfleld Lecy,as owners of the subject
property situate in the City oE Saint
Paul, des.cribed as Lot 9 and the east
2.5 feet of �t �o, sio�k 2, Iiolcombe's Robert B. Gerber, Jr., City Clerk
Additionto Saint Paul, located on the I�--------°-------------------°-----------------------°•-°---°-...--^
� south side of Marshall Avenue between
Grotto and_St. Albans Streets, that the
� provisions o� said Zoning Code hereby •• Of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota do hereby certify that I have
are determined and varied in applica-
!"'� tion so that the premi�es may contain 225636
� separate accommodations for several,
not more ttian tour fam�lies, provided compared the attached copy of Council File No....._.___.._.__________________________
uQ.., that th�e continuance of such four-
family Hwelling be 4or the remaining
life of �he structure now on said pre- October 20 65
6.C`� �ses, �,d,Provided further, that the as adopted by the City Council...__.._.__________________________________?_______.19._.____.___..___
� appellants comply with the changes
T set forth in the Bureail of Public
�✓ Buildings and Housing Code Division October 20� 65
� report dated August 3, �ss5, �a nTO- and approved by the Mayor_.........•--------------------------------------------------19.-----•---------
� Yx vided further, that' such permission
o all lapse ipso facto unless the ap-
� ellants are in fitll compllance with
�° ^ the above report, dated'August 3, 1985, with the original thereof on file in my o$ice.
� ithin one year from the date of this
n�� �esolution, and provided further, that
—"Ithe appellants provide a total of four
�!�i8-street Parking sPaces for said dwell- ----------°--°------------------------------------°------------------°-------------------------------------°°--°--°-------------
Nng in the rear of the.lot upon which
�the structure is located by removing
(''r�the present garage and allowing access ________.
Vfor perpendicular Parking from the °------------------------------°------------------------------------------.._....._....------....----------°-------------°-
alley, acceptance of this resolution and
��terms to be made by the appellants,
cyandsubject to compliance with� said --°----°------------------°°°---°°----••---------------------°----------------------------------------------------------------•-
�provisions, the Cauncil expressly flnds
that such rellef will be consistent with�
the public heelth and general welfare,
-. �,� , and that said relief and Permisison ..------°-----°------------------------°--------°•---------------.....•--.....-------------------------°---------°-°-------------
� herein grented is subject to the further
conditlon that the appellants and their
successors'and assigns otherwise shall
makedue complia3ice with all applic- -----------°--°--...°----------------------°-----°--------°---------°°......----°--°----°-°-----°---°---------------...---
able prodisions:of Municipal Ordin-
ances, .State Statutes, rules and reg-
�- ulations of publlc authorities having
cognizance: further� that 'a copY o= -----------------------------------------------------------°°------.......---------------------------------------------------°-------
this Resolution be filed with the Reg-
' ister oi Deeds in and for Ramsey
, County. Minnesota. ---------°----•----------_.
AdoPted bY the Councll October 20� ....---._..--------°•------------°-----------------------------•---°--°----------.._�...------------
,� 1965. •
Approved Octobe; 20, 1985.
� (October 23, 1985) �_____
-----------------------°-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------°�----•-
�wyk�"`,G�•�, ,
p`w a;"�'S ������`��t�_...
�"������:������:�'`;'!► ----•----------------------•-------••---•-•---........_._..-------------------------------------------------------•----
,�'b �. .�,{�'� ,..r._�r.�' e• T, ' �1,
^• • � •; •' c"�''•,t� €�yi;ther certify that said copy is a trt:e aad conQCt copy of
1 �/j !l1%.f ci�:"ry%
�--�g. '' ` � r
'} �� �';�`��.��, r``'�eaid'�p igiri'� and the whole thereof.
�t'h ` '"''�°��`°�'� •= „� �
�, �: ,g n;,,...;,���;.: ���'d�l�/
'r�.�_ ar�
�"`' '�,�=�����.'r'� � `1��` y�,I�,,��.'�1�T�SS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minn.,
�r��,,;C�i=-fa �ly,�-!!'P`7•-,�,i�,�y"�'�i�1
fi��='r(.�i�� ��"i • 6
� s_ rt .�. ^''aa '�����i c ober
'���`:�'j I .• °tliis': day of--------•- -•--- ^ ..� .._ D. a9----5�'----
'�.:.7��j�'�.yr�,'.rA .��r.»..""""'"""
'7������ ��rl� ,`� � ,�' �(�_ �/�y�
� � � 1
' y�.' "' """ "" """''�L-•.:-•.--..•.•--- -•
��"y��. '�;%.��-��' ��'2 City lerk.
�- ;:�;�p�. .:�. �
�r,�i,.s.+,�hr�-.
. �
� 3 5 9 8 , ' �$.� Q��d�� �,ra�� -� =�
:� / ' : �' ._
r �
I
� Saint Paul, Minnesota
October 20, 1965
h
— F� LEI� „
To the Honorable, the City Council
'65 ��o� a Pt� 12 :�.�+
Saint Paul, Minnesota
CITY CI.tE:�'S �.��::�aU�
Gentlemen: . ' �A�1�7 �-'�'+1�!. ����+•
We, the undersigned, do hereby accept and a.gree to abide by all
the terms and conditions of Council File No. 225636, adopted by
the Council on October 20, 1965•
f
/ '
Arfield cy
�
Mrs. field Lecy
! i � � I I I � j + . � � �
? I � j _ �� _1 : � + � �
:� � � li / 1 � , I (
r �i `! I (O V � � I I i � I
� o � �.3 � ; � i �
�
i � w � � ' f � ' i � ; �
I , � � � i � ; f � i
� i � � r i
iJ ! ' � i ` f i f I �
I ' � � I � � ` �
1 � j `� � + I
� � ( � I ,
� i � I � f � j � t� f
� � � ti �' i � I I 1
� � 1 I � �
� I _ � , � � � , � � � I �
�� � '' � ' ' ' , �a �� � '
� � i , �
, , ; j � , � � ; , i � � ;
� � � , � , � ; ; �
, ' � � . • � ,
�- ' I � ' i f I i � i � � ,
. { � � � � � � ; - �
� ' I i � � ! � � i
i
� i ' ' , F , �
` ! j � ; i ' ` ,' i ! � ; '
: � ; i � ` ; � ; ' ! � i I
, I { ;
, � i , � � �
i ; � � ' � i ' i i � I �
� ; �
; i � I j � � , � ! � � �i I
� ,� �, ; ; ; � ; ; � ; ;�. �; a � �
� ; i � i � l � ; I ;
; I
� ;
� l 1 � j j I i i ! �
j � i i � � � ., ; �
! I I i � .a � � i i
' ' � ! � .,� I
• , I i - i � � i � i { � '
. �� �� N i i � � 4 . t i I � ,
� , { i � � � �
i � � i ' I , I - I I I � �
' 4 ii j i i � ' i ! i i
� i i j , I � � � I i I '
� I � I � �
� ` ! 1 � i r i ! � � �
; , � ; 3a a , ,
� � ; � , , ; ; , , � � � ;
i I i i � , � ; i � ,
, ; ; ' i � � I ; i � , ;
� I ; �
� ' � 4 i � � j , I
{ �
i � � � � � I � I i � I i
' I I ' , �
4 � � ` � � I 1 i 1
� �
( � 1 I � � ` � ( � i � F
i � � j � � � i I � , �
1 � M i �
I • ` � I 1 � I I I I : �
� , 1 f � � !
,I � � i ' ! � I ! I � ;
� � j � I i t I { � I� j
i I � ' ; } ' II ` ' � ! �
, I i I , '
! I � , � � � 1 � : i