The URL can be used to link to this page

224565 ORIGINAL TO CITY CLHWK �� ' CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK ' COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM �RESENTED dY COMMISSIONE ; DA� ! � � , RESOLVED� upon the pertinent appeal of James R. Troje� . under the Zoning Code� for a waiver of lot size for a single- family dwelling in "A" Residence District� for property on the northwest corner of Annapolis Street and Livingston .Avenue, more particularly described as Lots 5 and 6, Block 3� St. Pierre and Lawtonts Addition to St Paul, that the general provisions of said 'Zoning Code� as they apply to area require- ments for single-family dwellings in "A" Residence District, are hereby determined �to the extent necessary therefor and the applieant be and hereby is permitted to construct a private single-family dwellin�g on the west 56 1/2 feet of Lots 5 and 6, Block 3� St. Pierre and Lawtonts Addition to St Paul; subject to the condition that said applicant-permittee� and his successors and assigns� shall make due compliance with all applicable provisions of municipal ordinances, State statutes and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance. , � .. � - ___�___--! — —�---� � ZONII`G API�EAL t Nutice fp hereby �iven that a public ge�ing vvlll be heId before the City Councll at 10 A.M. on MaY 13, 1965, in the City Council Chamber in the City FIall and ��$mes�R.T oie, under of the app Cha ters 60 to 64 inclusive, St. Paul Leg�slative Code, Zoning Code, for per- mission to divide a lot to permit two �antages onnI.ots tb tandt8,8Block 3 the northwe�st corn�er of Annapolis�and I,ivingston. Dated Aprll 29. 1985. y� F PPROVED ROBERT B. GERC��erk. (May 1, 1965) . Corpor n ns — � � � � ��11� CO CILIVIEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays J�� Dalglish �1' Holland A proved 19— Loss , � Tn FSVOr ` Meredith � ' l� Mayor Petetson • A gainst Rosen ' ' '•� � Mr. President, Vavoulis PUBI.ISHED J�� 20� �� ions e-aa , � , • ; - � � � : • 1 + �' • i ♦ �:;�:::�;::��:::�.��:RD OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT PAUL """ ..•:�XZfiN.SI0I1:�SI-]S4-4SS 1�I5 CITY HALL AND COURT HOUSi SAINT�AUL 2,MIHNISOTA ................... � June 8, 1965 `; - . �. � - �r , � ~ ��4:�?J'Sd' � . . � _ r Mr.Robert B. Gerber. Jr. • � - - � City Clerk ' '- �`�. � Building • �• • � - ; Dear Sir: . - . , J ' �' i This is in the matter of the appeal of James R�. Troje requesting authorization to r�divide two platted. lots now developed in part with a single-family house, for the purpose of constructing a second residence thereon. The subject property=is located at the northwest corner of Annapolis Street and Livingston Avenue and is described as Lots 5 •and 6, 'Block 3; St.Pierre & Law.ton'_s �Addition. The property is zoned "A" residence. _ � ` " - . Y The Board of Zoning at its June 4th meeting reconsidered this matter as requested by the City Council. ,, The Planning�Board staff reported that the �roposed redivision would create a lot of 3,783 square feet which is approximately 24.3qo below the minimum Iot area requirement of 5,000 square feet. There is •no way: of reducing this deficiency because the rear yard requirements o� the Building Code must be applied. - � After considerable deliberation by the Board., it was pointed out that had the two subject lots remained vacant, ea�ch lot could be . developed as.platted with a single;�family residence. It was the • Board of Zoning's conclusion that the request was reasonable, and, - therefore, it is recommended that the appeal to permit a single- family residence to be constructed on the westerly portion of � Lots 5 and 6, Block 3, St.Pierre & Lawton's Addition be .granted. • , - Sincerely, . _• . - . � i ` � . � ` B. R. Teig _ BRT:FGI h . Z. F. 5776 ' �� - . ' �� aa :;�';�:::.:;.;:��:<�;;�,R D O F Z O N I N G, C I T Y O F S A I N T PA U L . ��•• ::��•:#7iirN,si;pN�:ssi-sss-sss 1713 CITT HALL AND COURT HOUS! SAINT�AUL 9�MINNESOTA • - � May 21, 1965 . Mr.Robert B. Gerber Jr. - � ,_ r City Clerk _ _ � - Building ' � Dsar Sir: � � . On May 13, 1965, the City Council referred the matter of the appeal . of James R. Troje back to the Board ofZoning for further consideration. The subject property is situated at the northwest corner of Annapolis - - Street and Livingston Avenue described as Lots 5 �and 6, Block 3, St.Pierre��. �,awton's Addition.� �r,Z,, �� - 6"`"�_ � ' - The Board of Zoning did reconsider this matter at its regular meeting on Thursday May 20. After hearirig the staff:;s report, the applicant's . attorney, Mr.Thomas Burke, requested that the matter be continued so that he could familiarize himself with the technicalities pointed out ' by the- Staff. " - �' - In consideration of tlis request, the Board of Zoning continued the - � ' ,matter until June 3, 1964 and therefore as no finding to report at � this time. "1 - , - . � ' ' • Siricerely, � _ . �,, �. �}-�<<d�,�.. - _ . _ �,`,t , - � , , , N. R: Heiden � , • ?. • Recording Secretary � . - � � - � ,� , • � ' , � . � - '. � - � � . . - . . ,. _ -_ , ' - NRH:FGI ' . � � Z. F. 5776 . , y ` _ - . � . .4 i . • � _ Y . .. � _� a �• F J _ . � . 'r . F . . �� - , _. _ � , $. ` - � • ( J� ` � _� # e ` .� • _ - . . ' �-_ �� . _ -� - . • . 'Y -• s ` ' � � ' ' L - 6 � - � _ 3` ti . � � �' 1 . 1 - C ` . � R i :::� i:<<: � ' ` ;::;:�:�;:;::�:�::;::.:+ . . :��i�i:i�f:�i•i.'�';:;:i'.• .. , ' . :::::::'..;.�::.::�:::��;�:RD OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT PAUL - _ "" �•�;�}CT�,►{SI.O►�F:]31-434-4'.i.1 1713 C�TY HALL AND COURT HOUS� SAINT�AUL 4,MINNISOTA _ - _ ' , , � , ; ' • . - . . � . . - - • - •Ma� il, 1965 _ < < , - ` .` _ _. . _ - ,� - _ ,� _- , Mr. Robert B. Gerber Jr, a' _ , " s- `� City Clerk , � ,- , � � - Building ' � : Dear Sir: • , ' . . � , ' . This is in the matter of the appeal of James R. Troje requesting author- ization. to redivide two platted lots now developed in part with a single- , family house for the purpose of constructing a second residence thereon. The subject property is located� at the northwest corner of Annapolis . Street and Livingston Avenue and is ciescribed as Lots 5 and 6, Block 3, St.Pierre & Lawton's Addition. . - - r- The Board of Zoning considered this matter at its regular meeting on April 1, 1965. The Planning Board staff:reported that the subject pro- pArty consists of. two 39 foot wide platted lots fronting on Livingston Street and having a total area of 8,814 square feet. The requested re- division would be ��or the purpose of constructing a residence on the west • 74 feet of said lots which would have sufficient lot frontage and area. The proposed division would place the existing residence one foot below � the minimum 1ot width requirement of 40 feet, and approxim�ely 1,642 square feet short of the minimum lot �area requirement of 5,000 square feet. � It was the Board's finding that the requested relaxation was too substantial . and therefore would not be reasonable or in keeping with the purpose and ' intent of the minimum lot area requirements. The Board also concluded that . the denial of this request would not cause hardship ,on the applicant as he - may continue to enjoy the present single-family use of the land. � In consideration of these findings, the Board of Zoning recommends that the appeal to permit a redivision of Lots 5 and 6 so as to permit a second residence to be constructed thereon be denied. � Sincerely, - • - ` � . � � B. R. Teig A.I.P. " Recording Secretary BRT:FTI - Encl. � � • Z.F. 5776 � - . : - • \ - � • ' • . . � - � �-I �- � ' . .� , • , ,f(i i � �• . , �" �l �" � . � � �r� March 19, 1965 The Honorahle Mayor and City Council c�o City Clerk , Room 386 City Ha.11 and Cou�t House .� Dear Sirs, • , TYte undersigned appTica.nt and owner of property legally described as Lots 5 and 6 st. Pierre aa:d La.wton�s Addition, Ramsey County M�nnesota� located o� the north west corner og East �apolis and Zivi.ngston hereby appe�,l for a varia.nce in the code cited in Chapter 6403 ParagTaph 1 . Many years ago this home was built on two lots. Whea� we purchased this property we figure� tfiat some day � when we could afford it� we would build a ne�H�ethe west side of the old home . We thought this was,possible because there are two lots here and the existing ol'der home where we live is locatedi orn the egtreme elsd of d;he �ast end, thus leavirng tFiis large open area to the West. The area on which we would like to build is of no value to us presently and,we are ira great r�eed of a larger home a.rsd do not wish to leave this axea. We thank you very kindly for �our con:sidering this and hope that we will be able to commence building this spring. Sincerely Yours� James R. Troj;e y . � ''�� o��. . �s � - --�1•/ � � D „ • , .. � ��N`�� ■ �; ■■ ��■■� ■ ■�■■ �■ . ` � � � ■ '�. . .._ - �1�, �� .� • �. d .. . ' ■ � � t� .� ,. � �� ► �� .�� r[I�■ ■ �+, ■. i ■ ■. ■ ■■ . - ■■�� .■ .■ ■ , .�■ ■�■■■� ._.._�� ` � .�� ■ �� \ �� . '� ■■■■■■ �� _ ...�� .. �� •� + � `.. +� � .s � s �a �� , � � �� ; � Y. � - �� . �e �� : . � �� `.A iiiii�� '� � � r � ■� � � �. ., � . � ■■■ i . . �■■ . . ; ��s�e� ■ � � - ■ _ �� ■�� ■ ; p :.fi ' �■■.■�'�a�� i��i.. ■. � �■■ '� �� `� . . . � � � � �',_,� �. ' fi.f. ' �� ' • ■� � . � ■ � � �� ■� ', ' ■ �■ �. ■� ■■��.5.■� , ■� . �� :� ■ ` y. �� ■ �� ■� ■ ...�... ��■�� . . . . � .�■ . � � �1 . �'; . ■ �.. .• ■ ■i !� � ��r �� , ■ ■ , ,, ■■ ■ ■��i�, i� � � . ■ � � 0 ; � ■� , � � ■�� i ■ � ■ � t.: ■�O � �i �� . O �; ■ .�� ■ ;� ■ ��■ �= �_ � , ■ ,iiii .�.. , ; � �■ �� ■��■�■��. . ■ • y . �, ,� 1 ■■ � �■�■�■� •; � ` �1� ■ . ! ■ . . t \ ■■ !ii ` ■■■■■�■ . ` !� ■ ' �. ■ � � ■■ �� ■ ,,�u� ` ■ � ■ 3 � ■ � � rr .��i =::u�. .� �� :� � .�; ; � � � ��e��■� � . �� H i �. >, ■ ■ ■ �O�r�� ■ �� ■ � ;:� � = ■ � ■ . ■ � �� i� �� °.. �� ■ �, ; ,.�� ■ � �. : : i�� ■ � �� ■ � . �i�� ■ : ��:. ��,�..�_. .� . !�� : � ;3 . � ,�s� ��:� .��. . , � � ■ �-��.� = �-� �.:�..�� ■ . , � ■ � ■ ■ ■�� ■ � �� ■�� ; � �. �� ■�� ■ �r��■�� : : � �■��■ � �� ■�■�� .� �� ■■��■ ; .: . ��■�■■ :� ��e��■��■�� ,, �� -�■��■ ��■�� .� ��s��o■� �i ; �: �� . ■ �� . " .. ' • � � �, P CITY OF SAINT PAUL � MINNESOTA \- DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 �� April 30, 1965 City Clerk 386 City Hall • '. � File 16818 Page �1� You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in th� ' Council Chambera of the City Aall and CourC House in the City of Saint Paul at 10:00 a.m. on May 13, 1965, on the application of James R. Troje for appeal to divide a lot to permit two dwellings on inaufficient area and frontage on the followin� described pro- perty: Lots S and 6, Block 3, St. Pierre and Lawton's Addition. The property is located on the northwest corner of Annapolis Street and Livin�ston Avenue. Fc-r further information call at Room 1315 Court House or phone 223-4151. - JAME S J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance �� ► r