225986ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK
CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL NO
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE
COUNCIL RESOLUTION— GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONER G
2z5 98
RESOLVED, upon the pertinent appeal under the Zoning Code
by Harry Gutowich and Helen Gutowich, as owners of the subject
property situate in the City of Saint Paul, described as Lot 15,
Block 2, Palace Addition to St. Paul, located on the southeast
corner of Ashland Avenue and Avon Street, that the provisions
of said Zoning Code hereby are determined and varied in applica-
tion so that the premises may contain separate accommodations for
several, not in excess of three families, provided that the con-
tinuance of such thre6- family dwelling be for the remaining life
of-the structure now on said premises, and provided further,
that the appellants comply with the changes set forth in the
Bureau of Public Buildings and Housing Code Division report
dated July 22, 1965, and provide off street parking for three
.vehicles, and -provided further, that such,permission shall lapse
ipso facto-unless the appellants are in full compliance with the
above report, dated July 22, 1965, within one year from the date
of this resolution, acceptance of which fesolution and terms to
be made-by the appellants, and - subject to compliance with said
provisions the Council expressly finds that such relief will be
consistent with the public health and general welfare, and that
said relief and permission herein granted is subject to the
further condition that the appellants and their successors and
assigns otherwise shall make due compliance with all applicable
provisions of Municipal-Ordinances, State Statutes, rules and
regulations of public authorities having cognizance; further,
-that a copy of this Resolution be filed with the Register of
Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota.
FO ROVED
Asst. Corporatioh Counsel
Nov 9, 31965
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Nays
NOV 2 31
eu
Holland pproved 19—
Loss Tn Favor
Meredith
Peterson Mayor
Against
... ........::..........A.........: PUBLISHED NOV 2 7 1965
° Z:cep'aesic�ent _ a�oiYl'Y :.4
Mr, Vice President (Rosen)
10M ads
ZONING APPEAL
Notice is h peby, given that a public
hearing will be held before the City
Councll at 1Q A.M. on September 16,
1965, in the City Council Chamber in
the City Hall and Court House, in the
matter of the appeal of Harry and
Elelen Gutowich, under Chapters 60 to
34 inclusive, St. Paul Legislative Code,
Zoning Code, to continue a three -
family use in a "B" Residence Zone
Dn Lot 15, Block 2, Palace Addition,
located on the southeast corner of
Ashland Avenue and Avon Street,
Dated September 1, 1%5
ROBERT $, �z4
�
In.
The Honorable Mayor and City
Council of the City of Saint Paul
-2- September 15, 1964
purchase. The fact that there were two rental units plus
our living unit was one of the factors that induced us that
we could afford to purchase this property. The Contract for
Deed balance was paid up on August 8, 1963, and a Warranty
Deed was then delivered to us and subsequently recorded.
Only one unit is being rented at this time, and we under-
stand that we cannot rent the other unit until such time as
proper action is taken by your body to allow three family use.
Your early consideration will be appreciated inasmuch as the
additional income is sorely needed.
Would you please send copies of any notices or corres-
pondence with reference to our appeal to Robert F. Wille Jr,,
Attorney at Law, 817 Pioneer Building, au , inneso a 101.
ZONING APPEAL
Notice is hereby, given that a public I
hearing will be held before the City
Council at 1 A.M. on September 16,
1965, in the City Council Chamber in
the City all and Court House, in the
matter of the appeal of Harry and
Helen Gutowich, under Chapters 60 to
64 inclusive, St. Paul Legislative Code,
Zoning Code, to continue a three -
family use in a "B" Residence Zone
on Lot 15, Block 2, Palace Addition,
Ashland Avenhue and An Street. of
Dated September a, 1965.
ROBERT B. GERBER, Jr.,
City Clerk
(September 4, 1965)
Very truly yours,
j',�o
HARRY GUTOWICH
HELEN GUTOWICH
796 Ashland Avenue
St. Paul, Minnesota 55101
�a�j
September 15, 1961
The Honorable Mayor and City Council
of the City of Saint Paul
c/o City Clerk
3$6 City Hall and Court House
St. Paul, Minnesota 55102
Gentlemen:
We, the undersigned owners of the hereinafter described
property, hereby appeal the ruling of the City Architect of
the City of Saint Paul with reference to the use of the
premises under the Zoning Ordinance. The following informa-
tion is submitted:
a. Name of Applicants: Harry Gutowich and
Helen Gutowich
s '
b. Legal Description of property: Lot 15,
Block 2, Palace Addition to Saint Paul
Ramsey County, Minnesota
C. Street, Location: 796 Ashland Avenue -.
Southeast corner of Ashland and Avon
d. Present use of propert Duplex (previously
used as a three -plexT
e. Proposed use of property:,-_Three -plex
f. Purpose of appeal: to permit throe family
use
r
g. Need of appeal: Presentlyf zoned "B" `
Residential
h. Section of Ordinance appealing under:
Legislative Code, Chapter 64.03,
Section "o", Paragraph �r2tt.
0
We purchased this property under Contract for Deed on
July 27, 1957, with the understanding that it was proper for
three family use because that was the use at the time of
BUREAU OF PUBLIC BUILDINGS ROBERT L. AMES, City Architect 445 City Hall, 55102
c •`t
July 22, 1965
TO: City Planning and Zoning Board
FROM: Bureau of Public Buildings and the
Housing Code Division of the Bureau.of Public Health
RE: Appeal for authorization of a three -plex in a "B" residence
district located at 796 Ashland
Zoning File #5631
Filed by: Harry Cutowich
The'following is a list of items requiring alteration, repair or re-
moval in order to meet the minimum requirements of the Housing Code
and the Building Code:
BASEMENT:
1ST FLOOR,:
1.. Provide an enclosed room for the boiler room,
having at least a fire rating of one hour.
2. Remove the extension cords used in the basement
and replace the brass sockets with sockets that
meet the`requirements of the Building Code.
Remove extension cords and provide additional wall
outlets.
2ND FLOOR:
Provide an outlet in the bathroom, two new wall out-
lets in the rear kitchen and remove the one illegal
outlet. Add one wall outlet to the front kitchen.
SB:mll
R E 'D E � V E [L)
JUL Z2 1965
CITY PLANNING BOAR
Saint Paul, Minnesota
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
September 3, 1965
City Clerk
File 16938, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the
Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of
St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on September 16, 1965, on the application
of Harry and Helen Gutowich for appeal to continue a three family
use in a "Bn Residence zone on the following property: Lot 15,
Block 2, Palace Addition. The property is located on the southeast
corner of Ashland Avenue and Avon Street.
For further information call at Room 20, Court House or phone 223 - 1151.
JAMES J. DALGLISH
Commissioner of Finance
Saint Paul, Minnesota
November 29, 1965
To the Honorable, the City Council
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Gentlemen:
We, the undersigned, do hereby accept and agree to abide by all
the terms and conditions of Council File No. 225986, adopted by
the Council on November 23, 1965.
Harry Gutowich
Helen Gutowich
CD
Council File No. 225966 —By Frank L.
LOSS-
Resolved, Upon the pertinent appeal
under the Zoning Code by Harry
Gutowich and Helen Gutowich, as
owners of the subject property situate
In the City of Saint Paul, described
as Lot 15, Block 2, Palace Addition
to St. Paul, located on the southeast
corner of Ashland Avenue and Avon
Street, that the provisions of said
oning Code hereby are determined
nd varied in application so that the
..- premises may contain separate accom- _
odations for several, not in excess
f three families, provided that the
ontinunce of such three-family
welling be for the remaining life
►r f -the structure now on said premises,
and provided further, that the appel-
ts comply with the changes set forth
the Bureau of Public Buildings and
Housing Code Division report dated
Julyy 22, 1965, and provide off street
arking for three vehicles, and pro -
ded further, that such permission
shall, lapse ipso facto unless the appel-
ants are in full compliance with the
ve report, dated July 22, 1965,
within one year from the date of
this resolution, acceptance of which
resolution and terms to be made by
the plinceappellants, with aid nprovW subject
nsthe Coun-
cil expressly finds that such relief
1 - will be consistent with the public
health and -general welfare, and that
W said relief and permission herein
C.0 granted is subject to -the further condi-
tion that the appellants and their
successors and assigns otherwise shall
make due compliance with all appllc-
O able provisions of Municipal Or-
dinances, State Statutes, rules and
regulations of public authorities having
O cognizance; further, that a copy of
this Resolution be filed with the
Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey
Y County, Minnesota.
Adopted by the Council November
p 23, 1965.
co Approved November 23, 1965.
— (November 27, 1965) —
1
i
STATE OF MINNESOTA
County of Ramsey ss.
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
I, Robert B. Gerber Jr.
City Clerk
of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota do hereby certify that I have
compared the attached copy of Council File No ....... �25gs6
as adopted by the City Council.- . . . .. . November 23, ............... 19.65_.___..___
and approved by the Mayor_______ ________ November 23- ------------ - - - - -- -19.65
_ ___ __ ____ __ ________ _
with the original thereof on file in my office.
rdit;kz- certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of
> q/
E -"said original' ad e whole thereof.
and and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minn.,
of-.... rs_ A. D 19-- - -65..
' # , • +;�- ./.."
��` "2x City Clerk.
BOARD
�Litilil2 23-4151
OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT. PAUL
Room 20 CITY HALL & COURT HOUSE - SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102
September 9; 1965
Mr. Robert B. Gerber
City Clerk
Building
Dear Sir:
This is in the matter of the appeal of Harry and Helen Gutowich to legalize
a three - family use in a "B" residence district for property located at the
southeast corner of Ashland-Avenue and -Avon Street which is described as
Lot 15, Block 2, Palace Addition'.
In 1897 the subject property was,developed•with the existing structure con-
structed as a single or two - family =residence. At some unknown date the use
of the structure was extended to a three - family dwelling which did not
necessitate an enlargement of the original structure. Because the property
is classified as "B" residence which limits it to a two - family use, the
applicant must secure Council authorization to continue the use of the
property as a three-p!6-x.
The Board of Zoning heard this request on August 5, 1965. It was the
Board's finding that inasmuch as off - street parking for three cars can be
provided_, that the appeal to "continue the three- amily use be granted sub-
ject to compliance with the changes set forth in the Bureau of Public
Buildings and Housing Code Division report „dated July 22, 1965 a copy of
which is attached.
It is therefore, the Board of Zoning's recommendation that the use of the
`subject property be continued as a three -plex for the life of the structure
subject to the above. conditions. It is also recommended that, should the
Council grant the appeal, that a copy of the resolution be filed with the
deed in the Register of Deed's officer
Sincerely,
t
NRH /mm /.RCHeiden
Encl.
Z.F.# 5631
_P - Q)