229145M
CITY OF ST. PAUL
Resolution Ratifying and Confirming
Condemnation and Awards of Damages
and Assessment Therefor
_ � 2�2�1�5; •l.
COUNCIL FILE NO
By
File No.--i7096 S
In the matter of 6oadmllng . iind taKng an ea.eement iin the lnd Aecess4ry for alopee.. cuts
temporary ccastructlon easomat$;, all Including the right of? removal of
and f'ila.8 �aud _
3ate►ral .support from subject land or ruder' therd0f s ,49- shgV4 by DMVJ,ng- loo. 1897,
81opa Drawer .2p on file in, the DsPwtm=t of Public Works$ occOiwed by construction
work both within aria 'beyond, or outside of tha ,$txeet bouaftry Unes for widening and
resurfacing of AIlk P SZ= fram. Ottawa Avenue to Oak. e• Avenue i and.. further..
providing therefor end authorizingt where .1 yproWi tie= avoft to compensate abutting
turners for an tsldag -or damaging of private. property resulting to stibJect properties
and incorporating, 01-such .campensatiou to which an Abutting ovneza be or become
entitled lf.any! into ii. single ,award.vith respect to each psreel of abutting property.
under Preliminary Order 2224 , approved XLicember Q3. 1965
Intermediary Order , approved, Apr11 its 1966 ,
Final Order }70 , approved May l.Q. 1966
A public hearing having been had upon the taking and condemnation of the lands or easements
therein, for the above improvement, and the award of damages therefor, and also upon the assessment
of benefits therefor, and the Council having duly considered the same, now therefore be it
Resolved, That the taking and condemnation of the lands described in the annexed assessment roll,
identified by the signature of the Commissioner of Finance, and made a part hereof, and the awards of
damages to the owners of such lands for",said taking and condemnation as set forth in said assessment
roll, be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified and confirmed.
Resolved further, thatrthe said assessment of benefits, be and the same is hereby in all respects
ratified, and the same is hereby ordered to be-submitted to the District Court for confirmation.
f %liat the Said —Assess
-eqital instalim nts as .�.+ eaek par -eels 4 _ln�.rl`�1
COUNCILMEN
Yeas OAA&07_�Nays
Dalglish
.l�lollarrd— •- -
Meredith
P_etersov�,'
iWMt"r
Form R -3 ° es
�R
JUN 2 11966
Adopted by the Cou _
2
Approve
n Favor
+ - � Mayor
Against
.PUBLISHED JUN 25 1966 �-
r�
M
CITY OF ST. PAUL
Resolution Ratifying and Confirming
Condemnation and Awards of Damages
and Assessment Therefor
_ � 2�2�1�5; •l.
COUNCIL FILE NO
By
File No.--i7096 S
In the matter of 6oadmllng . iind taKng an ea.eement iin the lnd Aecess4ry for alopee.. cuts
temporary ccastructlon easomat$;, all Including the right of? removal of
and f'ila.8 �aud _
3ate►ral .support from subject land or ruder' therd0f s ,49- shgV4 by DMVJ,ng- loo. 1897,
81opa Drawer .2p on file in, the DsPwtm=t of Public Works$ occOiwed by construction
work both within aria 'beyond, or outside of tha ,$txeet bouaftry Unes for widening and
resurfacing of AIlk P SZ= fram. Ottawa Avenue to Oak. e• Avenue i and.. further..
providing therefor end authorizingt where .1 yproWi tie= avoft to compensate abutting
turners for an tsldag -or damaging of private. property resulting to stibJect properties
and incorporating, 01-such .campensatiou to which an Abutting ovneza be or become
entitled lf.any! into ii. single ,award.vith respect to each psreel of abutting property.
under Preliminary Order 2224 , approved XLicember Q3. 1965
Intermediary Order , approved, Apr11 its 1966 ,
Final Order }70 , approved May l.Q. 1966
A public hearing having been had upon the taking and condemnation of the lands or easements
therein, for the above improvement, and the award of damages therefor, and also upon the assessment
of benefits therefor, and the Council having duly considered the same, now therefore be it
Resolved, That the taking and condemnation of the lands described in the annexed assessment roll,
identified by the signature of the Commissioner of Finance, and made a part hereof, and the awards of
damages to the owners of such lands for",said taking and condemnation as set forth in said assessment
roll, be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified and confirmed.
Resolved further, thatrthe said assessment of benefits, be and the same is hereby in all respects
ratified, and the same is hereby ordered to be-submitted to the District Court for confirmation.
f %liat the Said —Assess
-eqital instalim nts as .�.+ eaek par -eels 4 _ln�.rl`�1
COUNCILMEN
Yeas OAA&07_�Nays
Dalglish
.l�lollarrd— •- -
Meredith
P_etersov�,'
iWMt"r
Form R -3 ° es
�R
JUN 2 11966
Adopted by the Cou _
2
Approve
n Favor
+ - � Mayor
Against
.PUBLISHED JUN 25 1966 �-
- -- `I .'}.IL N'1� ` VP' .. . _ � _ J `• .Y• _ ��: 1.. ',U .�,� .1• '�' �� �Y4 ♦ Y .` r y _ � , ! � � 'Y.�;-��'.e�4.i �� -f
45 IV .
,-
-�--�' CITY OF ST. PAUL {280
Report of Commissioner of Finance r '
on Condemnation of Lands y File No.
In the matter of _ "a uldze, OL axwaftlt 14.,_ tbo U14 WM 1 $ for •0203pa,.$ oq
ft io pXU1 -cif POUa ,$, lquo by omstmotVa
Votk �,_ tit � � v1�; fta Ott
m smutting
,r � t err 4 � . t ,9 � e
x ►+ a u
oaut dj* -it UYA• 14t*64 WWA VM,taVeat to ftth pivtj. vf abuts *Wty*
under Preliminary Order , approved :fir 9j* X$6 ,
Intermediary Order V+1"1 , approved . 19W ,
Final Order 900 , approved io Is X .
TO THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL:
The Commissioner of Finance hereby reports:
That he has fixed and determined the value of the land, lands or easements therein taken and ap-
propriated for the above improvement and the amounts of the awards of damages therefor to the own-
ers thereof, and the persons to whom such awards are payable; that he has also fixed and determined
the amount of benefits to property, from the making of said improvement, not exceeding the cost
thereof, and that attached is an assessment roll entitled as above and identified with the signature of
the undersigned, containing the undersigned's finding on said matters.
r
Co issioner Finan r
June 3, 1966
Honorable T. Byrne
Mayor of St. Paul
& St. Paul City Council
& St. Paul City Clerk
Gentlemen:
REClEI' ;
SAINT PAUL. 1
AM JUN - 9 1966
P�
TIMV1X111 -2111'21 8A ai6 i
In regard to the condemnation proceedings and specifically File No. 17026 S,
I am objecting to the award of none as stated by Mr. J. William Donovan in
a letter dated April 22; 1966.
I have contacted a professional appraiser and although I do not have a formal
appraisal, it is his opinion that the damages are substantial.
It is my opinion that the fair market value of my property has been reduced and
just compensation be awarded for the following:
1. The area acquired for S.E. be paid for at market value.
2. The acquiring of part of the picket fence be considered.
3. The value of the retaining wall be considered.
4. The loss in value to the property by the reduced area of the back
yard and difficulty of maintenance and mowing of the slopes.
5. The increased noise and traffic nearer the house.
6. The encroachment to the garage and shortening of the driveway creating
a danger when backing onto Anapolis Street.
7. The loss of privacy and beauty to the rear of the property by the tree
removal.
In view of the above, I am of the opinion that the damages are in the neighborhood
Of $2,000.00.
Sincerely, j /Q
M.M. Danmeier
875 Winslow
St. Paul 79 Minnesota
Iv
-.,
June. 1966
Honorable T. Byrne
Mayor of St. Paul.
& St. Paul. City Council
& St. Paul City Clerk
Gentlemen:
In regard to the eor�datio�n groceedings�_�pd_ specifically File No. 17026 S_,;
I am objecting to the award of none as stated by Nor. J. William noriovan in - -
a letter dated April 22, 1966.
` I have, contacted a professional appraiser and 'although I 'do not have a formal
appraisal, it is his opinion that the damages are substantial. x ;
It is my opinion that the fair market value of my property has been - reduced and
just compensation be awarded for the tollowing:
1. The-area acquired for S.E. be paid for-at market value.
` 2. The acquiring of part of _the picket fonce -be considered.
3+ The -value of the retaining wall be considered. "
. 4. The loss in value to the property . by -the reduced area of the back
yard.and difficulty of maintenance and mowing of the slopes.
5• The increased noise and traffic nearer the house.
6,. The encroachment -to the garage and shortening of the driveway creating
4zen backitg onto Anapolis Street: - _ - -• - - - - _ - - -__. _.-
06 loss of privacy and beauty t6'the rear of the property by the tree
In vier Qf.=thq, above, I n of the opinion that the dam -ges are in the neigh6 8d
Of $21,000:90,.*
Sincere3.y,,j A
= p�- '66 JUN 9 -Am 9 os
M.M. Danmeier
875 Winslow C I T Y C L r
St. Paul. 7, Minnesota � SAINT r���