228659 ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK /r�Q�h�1
� CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL '�_ � _-'�
'''y' ' OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE NO.�
OUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE DATF —
RE�OLYED upon the pertinent appeal� �nder the Zoning
Code� by Gera�ld E. Frisch� as owner of the sub�t real
estat�� situ,ate in the City of Saint Paul� and described
as Lots 1� 2� 3, �+, 5, 6, in Bloek 1, Larkin� s Subdivision
of Zots 1 and 2, B1ock 30rSuburban Hills �ddition to St Paul�
except therefrom that part taken for truck highway to w3.t:
�ill tY�at part of said Lots 3� 4, and 5 whieh lies Northerly
of the following. described line: Beginning at the Northeast
corner of Lot 1� of Block 1� King�s �ddition to St Paul Mir�n. � '
thence rur�ning Easterlp to the Nor�Y�east corner of Lot 3 of
Block 1� Larkint s S�zbdivision of Lots 1 and 2� Bloek 30�
Suburban Hills Additi on to St Paul� and located at the
nor�hwest corner of Pacific Street and �riffith Stree�G� that
the provisions of s�,id Zonin Cg hereby are determined and
�aried as and to the exte$�����i���or, and the building set—
baak line of said real estate� in respect of the north line
of Pacific Street upor� which the same abuts hereby i� estab-
lished to accommodate th� construction of pillars as per
plans� and where said pillars are lo�ated the build3ng line
shall be parallel to the north line of Pacifia Street and
17 feet distant from sai� line of Pacifie Street; except forh
said pillars� building line shall be as reqt�ired by ordinance:'""�
- - - % - - -
P VED
Asst. Corporation Counsel
Y � q 1��
MA
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Nays �Y 1919��
�Tglt�h�
Holland A.pproved 19—
Loss .
n Favor
Meredith , 1
D„ �J Mayor
- -'==`=-"` Against
��vs�err
�:.�;�'�,a,�.,�,������:�� MAX 21196�
Mr. Vice Pzesident (Rosen� pUBL1SHED
, r 4 . . .
�,
r , � � ,
•�~:: '�_�?•ilSwr,iw�+w.� u 1 . . ' ` ,.r ,{ . ,- I ������
� •r�u���P
:::::::<: � ��ARD OF ZONING; CITY OF SAINT PAUL
��� ,�I�ti�223-4151 Room20 CITY HALL Q�COURT HOUSE SAINT PAUL, MI_NNESOTA 55102
. , w
� -
� - � April 18, 1966 �
" Mr. Robert B. Gerber, Jr. � -
City Clerk -
Buildi.ng . '
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to the Appeal of Gerald E. Frisch
to relax the setback requirement on property located at the
northwest corner of Pacific Street and Griffith Street des-
cribed as Lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, in Block 1, in Larkin's Sub-
. division of Lots 1 and 2, Block 30 in Suburban Hills, except
therefrom that part taken for truck highway to wit: All that
part of said Lots 3, 4, � 5 which lies Northerly of the
' following described line: Beginning at the Northeast corner
of Lot 12 of Block 1, King's Addition, thence running Easterly
to the Northeast corner of Lot 3 of Block l, Larkin's Subdivi-
sion.
This matter was considered� at the March 17, 1966 Board of
Zoning meeting. The staff reported that the applicant wishes
to construct some pillars in line with the outside edge of the �
two foot roof overhang on the front of the apartment building
_ , being constructed on the property. The pi'llars would encroach
two feet on the setback. It was. the findings of the Board �
that the proposed relaxation would have no detrimental effect
upon adjoining properties and, therefore, the Board recom- _
mends approval of the Appeal. �
_ � � � Very truly yours,
: , / � r
�\/ �.R�
NRH/mm N. R. Heiden
Encl. � Secretary � .
Z. F. # 6014
- � { , - _ �
_ � � , � - . A . .
_ � , } - . �'� �
�"'
- � - ,.. _ . . , .
.ti . _ , -
_ , :` , , . . _ �
. i
. . ;
r , r
.� „ J v �� -
` � � ��y �
, V " V
NILVA, SHAW AND FRISCH /
ATTORNEYS AT LAW ['1�l' ,
2380 WEST SfiVENTH 9TREET `� �
SAIxT P,airL, MI�rNESOTn 55116
ALLEN 1. NILVA March 3 1 BaQ��s97
IRVING SHAW , 966
�646-.7901
GERALD E. FRISGH
Honorable Mayor and City Council
City of Saint Paul
Court House �
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Re: Request for Variance
Gentlemen:
This is to advise that there is presently under construction
14 unit apartment building at 1195 Pacific Street, Saint Paul, and that
I have heretofore obtained all necessary municipal approvals including
building permit. The building has been located 19 feet from the front
line of the property in conformance with the approved plot plan, etc.,
and required front yard setback. The roof of the premises has a 2 foot
overhang and I propose to have pillars located in the front of the build- ,
ing from the grade to the roof ineeting the outside edge of this overhang.
� I am advised by the Building Department that the location of
the pillars would constitute an encroachment of 2 feet into the front
yard setback and that their Department is not able to approve the same
without Council approval to variance.
Accordingly, request is hereby made for° a variance permitting
the location of pillars on the front of these building premises extending
2 feet into the front yard setback and to be constructed in line with the
outside edge of the 2 foot roof line overhang. In connection with this
request there is forwarded to you enclosed copies of the approved plot
plan and front building elevation. �
In that these premises are presently under construction I will
appreciate your early attention to processing of this rec{uest.
Yours very truly
' _ NILVA�SHAW AND FRISCH
� � ��.�c�.�c--.
- erald E. Frisch
GEF:ls
Encls.
� � � � � �
� �
� Z��� NG F�LE --- ., �AR 9 1966
�1�X �',l,,A��I�v�iv�,. �ut�►,�,
. Sai.qk �8u�. M�IIIAEQOt$
� . �
, ' .. . , �„
CITY OF SAINT PAUL �
MINNESOTA
� DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court Hou:e 55102
a�22
1�_ Apr31 8, 1�66
City Clerk ,
File X83, Pags
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the�
Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court �iouse in the Ci+y ef
St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on April 21� 19G6, on the app.lication of
C,�rald E, I'risch for apneal, under the zoning code, to establish
a new building-line setback on the following property: Lots 1� 2a,
3, �t� 5, a.nd 6� Block la Lar�ins Subdivision, The property is
located on Pacific Street at Pt. Douglas Road.
For flirther inforn:ation contact Planning Board� Room 20� Court
House or phone 223-I�151...
JAMES J. DALGLISH
Commissioner of Finance
rt��� � '��iSP '� - '.'_, • ��2w} _ �. . F.. ` � - , . � �. , ,1ry - '
N�' �.�..• ' � , • • ` + � '� - c -. • , ' 1. ( , •
. ',°,p�cn„ra..1��n;qw..+:a:��K%..ti-W�ur�wr.:+:r.?►i:•ae.a�.n'�:atatlnw4w:i�Tfw.•..;s�nYd:ati.ans.y.wtMS>:�w1r'-..r:',:-+."'___v.itito�:WotiiTd+'sM.h'+.srrin:�*P)+.ur��aja�9+wc•rs'tv_:.v,wi��.a�rtvtvta�r.'+;--%�r-.,�_,.:a!rtrA'<n"ir�•.:.-.»..*..��.+,,,...}�x�d.,:-�...,.�... .....>.,.:.w.,..,....�..
�2 � , y , r � � . . . ` . .
T � . , ' .
�� � � , � ,� , � � : �� �
. . ,._ ; : .4 � � � � , .
�
r . �� _ � � , - �� � o
ti ._____ _ .�._ !�' � , • /i f � 9 ��4�' ' �^ '— ?�, .
� - * . ' ��r7 J � _A C .'i` L—=.� � � d
���� ..�. , .
J �
�"�:�.
. r, ,� �, � � � �a .
� �.�
/ �- � _J � `u �a�
� _ � �� d ` � . ''
N Q r C� � ..,
�' � � � `Jr Y
�� _� � ~ �� � � ��G��,C01 � • I~ � 1
-..l - =�xn ..�,.��."7�.�_'~�.,_._y..�.�_��_.�_ K_ •�n� �i�..__'���....._�_1t`�._. Y .�.�M' ]C��..x.�•l � /
� (� , �t * / Z ' � �p f ' [ .; I 'i �'
�� i ." ` 1 '•`s` f i i ' I
' ' � , � _ � ;� 7 + �, j } °�� : 12 1 I
-F ...,�� ,. .,..-,.. ;
- - -._, _._L_P:.�L�__. ,
• �o � � /�l� . � \�(v� � � �
I Y'•^ I ,r 4 " ''e{�)r' � \" 4' (
.� ' r^ �
�. ! � �•—v� {1 . 'C •.2�-•.� � .`XJ U
`f �ti .1 � • 4Y �� ir�
� ; ' �� ` '7 � �f.tc• ' ' ��yIR�
� ��y � � - .. _ . . i . �., '�`„J�
� �. , :s'�---_ �� Z � ! , � '�� j �
• � •�� � � ; � f� .,`i �
- � 1� "�. 1�,. � � { ��� i , � .�_...
� '�l--^-- „ . ir , �
(� ' (� �-- t:�: � I. _.. _ _ ,.. . .. , _. _...... � ' ; � .
� i
.� ��� ��, � _ � � �
. � / , _c , .� I i ,
�E , . , _.�^� , ♦ I _
,� � ��� � o -�- � "-'- �Q� �
' o
� J d � � "'i • - - - � � C,i - 3 � �1 � -
, .� a � -- .� � �9 ro ►
.F^• � ..>- � O ;j'"`�'r�'�T�' ' ��...1 � ! ; ,�
`U _ �,J `` �
C7 i � ;
- '�° i�.,l 1 (� � r E i U
, � � ` �F.� � � • - e� � • i ; �-- - ._- - --
:.� ,.a- � ' - �, .,. � . .4b
�s.� • a d-„' �' := 4� ' cJ „' ti, � '
� �1 U_t � :��:-.e. � � •� _ ;�_' - :C ,�' � ,
' v....� v ►� ._L �,y � 5� 1 j � t; ��'� : � G� � - �
' ` `+K..�. , '��'-y -fl �Y L) �,,� � ,.. ' V � � "` . • � U � �ic- �
;_, : � - �� . _,,,;� .,�, a o�� ,a,.� � nt �' ;�� � � ' • -:1' -� . �y I ' a -
� . _ ''~� �':.=-� „%'� n_IS`J �1 0, L.' � . , .�; �_ __ _ � _ ,�, . _ �� _ ..._._ .. �.�,..._ ,
},.'' ' , �1- " .: .t,/.. � . �- � .' � . � 4 � • .. �� ` ) _._.- ��.� .
� Y,� •�-x,��T„�_1J�-,�"�_-� ��.'�^--t-_ '/{• ui4Y�'� I' . . W.JtA-��`-=rLwew...'.���r."i.�.,-�..�L'F��++� .:�C-}� ����,-a ..
Y p, ��� C f� L 1
.�..*�r.�x. ' •'4 Q O O7 � , ,�`. , I1�' r ,Y j �� � -
_ • � �� • �- G � p� �' � � . � •• � . � Z ' ' 3
'� . . T�. r., ,�� � �j� � . '� ��L ; �� � � ! i
. • ' � ��..�..� : 6 _.� � 1 � , � . , - f 4 � ` � _ ' � ;
. �E � �-o ���- .
, , � � � � � (l�" .� . _--�---�- �� I � ,� i
_ ,�y, P l�, Q��.`�O r y�n'� ` - �� ---------._......J,_ .- .--_-----...� . -_i} ` �
, , i«.J -'ri.�-` �.�.}-�T , T �_. ,Zu ...._.�_..,.�z.�-� a;ol � 7 � ��% ;;� ��I � �
.. , �_ - -�U- Q � � � I.oi�°�`— . �-*� -i--_--�--- ..,.t. � .__,� i
:� 4� � �� � F ��'r , ;
� 6 '� �. (J � '
_ � ' ' tp
l.J .-� ` �` .I � �� 1
.. . �. E �` �r $ � .{
. � , `e,
. ' � � �v �' � 'r � .
. . � '� � . �.' . �� ".;
.:, � �
, , �,� � -b; � , :�"�i� i M
,� : ,�I m
• , � , . � p �'�:�
� � �� - ��*. -� ` f�G ��` t
�A �.� i
, ��1 A ' I, •�• .
; - • � �3 I '� �-
� _, - -,����a�-�-- - ,a-�.' � ; `�►
�.-..- . �..-.�.<..._ ... ..___._._ _.. __.�,-V a,�•y..,-� ,.,,,...�,._,.�,-_-.- - . - i
J i ,_�. � . �^,ti�� � ,,.��.Te��,a �
,
' r --" '1 �� �,/'� ---•— �-- � .._--—"� {.70JV'�'� �'-�L13'�. I.----"• '
• --_' _ dc��'�� ;� i i-�•.---.._.�__ � � � _
� ' . � " °, l p�19 � ,,,� i ,
,
� '�:�� f ( , .
, . , � � ' �
�/ \ � � . � �
------- '�,_^'- ---- — ^-'- -- ��-�_.aVt j �an7_._��-____.....�_._ _._., • ''� ' - -
'��-__ _$:L�--�-----�---�---Q-tiE-------..�� _..I:.__1��oE�`-----�.__� Yo;yz�._ ..,..�..�
:' � _ ,
i` i
�-` ,
�' ' • - '
..
�' ➢ _ . - • -
- ...--^"�-.^_--'_-. - C �:�.�"5 pa```�� �„'� ���.�� ��i� �•=ii
'�'J..T..!7a�..'-�_.' - . -' '. ._ t^�'r'G.�'�'".^.''^�'�M..r-..•.r;.y.�...-+^_rr.r_^rq`.sa.te�e!•ww..,n�.».-...e..N.+..,..r..nrtr.n�-W-.a+.cmc..wt�G-..�.r.r�-,�.w.R�n...�s.....um•...t<.•N-�wr1•rt'�yt�.,sa,S.x.e,...._,.r. _ ..,.n..�.n...�....�r..�.......--rtnnw -
a , � + • •
i .
r , • •
' r . ' %
� , ' x . -
r � _ f � ' � _ �
� . .. ' p . , � • L . Y . - •
i� - . _ . . . - e i . _ . . . , . -