236164 r �
ORIGIN�I TS CITY CLERK
�C.9��.�
;�' ' CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCa
' OFFIC OF THE CITY CLERK FILE NO. _
� O N L ��b TION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY �
COMMISSIONE w DATF
SOL D, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul
hereby authorizes settlement of the clai.m of Herman Illions and
Helen R. Illions, 1308 Edgecumbe Road, Saint Paul, Minnesota, in
the amount of $135.00, in accordance with the recommendation of the
,
Valuation Engineer i.n his letter of September 11, 1967, directed
to the City Council, upon receipt of a release of the City by the
above-named claimants, in form satisfactory to the Corporation
Counsel of the City of Saint Paul. " �
FORM APPROVED �
Asst. Corporation ounsel
DEC� 319�7.
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Nays
Carlson ��(',13 19��
Dalglish Approved 1 19.^
Holland �
Meredith �n Favor
Peterson Mayor
Tedesco A ga�gt
Mr. President, Byrne P�;g��� p�� �i, � �����
� •. �22
µ '_
ti ,
1. �
�:I. WILLhAM DONOVAN , 223-5317
UValuation Engineer
� ,-
ROY E. BREDAHL, ��. C I T Y O F S A I N T PA U L
Ass't Valuation Engineer BUREAU OF VALUATIONS
286 City Hell ����_�
Saint Paul, Minnesote 55102
°�°�
September 11, 1967 �
To the Mayor and Council
of the City of Saint Pa.ul
Gentlemen:
Attached hereto is a copy of a letter
from Mr. Ja,mes H. Levy, attorney representing Mr. Herman Il-
lions, 1308 EdgcuQnbe Road, in connection with dama.ges to the
Illions' property because of the grading of the ad�acent al-
ley in the Howaxd Greene Addition.
Alsv attached hereto is an esti.mate in
the a.mount of$�35, representing the ftii.l.l cost of repairing
the claimed damages. I have reviewed this estimate and, i.n
my opinion, the amount is a fair and equitable request for
settlement of Mr. Illions' claim.
I, therefore, recommend that this claim
be settled for the requested amount of $135 as full settlement
of said claim and that this matter be referred to the Corpora-
tion Cov.nsel for appropriate action.
Very truly yo
� �.t/.��'��ut.�.--� �'��
'J. Willia.m Donovan
Valuation Engineer
JWD��t
X ��
l �
� V
,:..► t , , . . . . .
� �' • u . . C7 • • ' ' � � •
:
JQJt" v r� • . , � .
�� � `' , , . • • s]C��� ,� .
' D � ' �� .
. . •JA�MES� H . LEVY , . �- � _ � �
. � � �,
ATTORNEY AT'LAW • . , �
. • • � 310 NORTHWESTERN BANK BUILDING _
' ' . � • • . • . ST.PAUL,MINN.55101 PHONE: 227�8209
• • ' . � September 5, 1967 �
. . . �
City�Valuation Engineer � � •
La,nd Commissioner�s Office • � • • • '
• Court House ' �
St.�, Pau.l, Minn. 5 5102 • ,� : , ' ; '
. , � •
, ,4tt: Mr. Dpnovan • ti�,��� ' . . :
. , . ,rT .
• � , . In re: 3�Ierman�Illions - 130g Edgcumbe '
• • l�ear Mr. Donovan: � , . �. • '
• � � Followi.ng ouv recent conversation concerning the problem �f the. fence •
. . • at •1308 Ecigcumbe; part of which wa's dau�.aged by the action of the City
at tlle tjme the alley was gr�,ded and paved, I am enclosing herewith a
duplicate copy oi an estima�e whic� Mr. .Illions obtained from Highland .
Nurs°ery for the cost of repairing aY�d extending the side dry wall and ,
• • the fence'along the alle�. This was in accordance� with your suggestion ,
�haL the most eff'�e�ti�re and least expensive of cuxing the problem was. �
- t•o extend tra+� portion• of tl�e V�all, and backfill Yt .in order to make a •
• sa,lid base. for the fence. If' you will note, t}ie total cost of the esti-
mate was'$135.00. , • � •, ' '
• While I did not appear• pe•rsonally,� �1��. I11.ions� informs me that he did
. , • .�.gpear •before the Cour.cil at the time of the hearing on the approval of ' . '
' ' � the' final assessment. I gather• that he was •unsuccessful in getting the ' '
- Council �o do a,nything about redtzcing tYie ainount of,his assessment. I ' '
' , ' understand `the Co�ncil d�d agree to pa� the damages per.d`ing the recei�t•
• of� this. estimate. � , ' . '
,. .Assi;ming that 'this is corr•Cct, will you pleas•e• consider the enclo5�ed • • ,
, estimate and, if you find it reasonable,, inform me in what• way the'City ' •
: �rill. reimburse Mr. Illions for ttiiis expense. The amount is not 'large and
. ' . I believe that his ac�ual damages �,•rould e�ceed this amount, although, if
. the City would pay for .the work, I believe he would be sa�tisfied', without ' .
. . further del'ay or expense. • . . '
I would�appreciate�hearir_g f'rorr� you as �soon as possible afte� you have had •
• a chance to consia:er 'the matter. • � � , .� ' . . •
' • in erely, �
. . � � � ' • . • �
� • ' James H. Levy � . .
. . . . ,
- . J�L�J - ' • ' . •
e
�,�^�� ,�St .,' ��`�� `y , . _-�fn'�r- . . , ` M1 4 f L _•�a..{(�.--�'.• - -- , � v F. -� .
/ 1 �y r �.�' . Rr"'"
F , E�'. S• . . �.� �i � � ��',i�x" !
��'r�-'��' _ , � , � . , � y_,., '�-. .. Na° :��29 2.7�
1 e � ' 'V�� f.�.y%�' �
. � Y I' F ��,l a�_ F �M"Y.� .�1.,'+:'N r ` + J�,1�y��af•��h•;� .
�r ' , . . � . ,`�*�''' °�`y�,.`�j`'Y}�"�' , T y1��*a.�:� .Y r '� -��! µ�' .
'� .7.iy ;• �{Y •Ja d) [l��iX* }L
�' � � !f� ,ti,U `Y.'..:�1<�•y�� F�.f
/ • F, , - t^ ,f• • , ,� �� x 1 ii/'�j��y4j"�- 1"` '.-1 '
. . � .. - :� � �l �!:r- ��,y�,�� `,�.�, . .� ._ � .
,`.I: J4,5
. , +ti..T e.'w_� _ _ -- �Id'�.'.�ti ��°. }._+y .
. .� � '.- ' .i t � :�� ��;.�,� ;r.+iS a ,.� YA��i:_'. �? '.��'�I.tr'^µ�w* T a •�
� :�'"-4COIdPLET¢ LING.OF NURSLRY BTOCK,y LANOSCAF �D�Si6t� � 4:�1'M: WtINQ �"�:�'' � '
� •. .� .. -; ,. -� . • ..F ; - , ��,, � ;� ..., k��� '',_.f i:. .
• � Y t � ; �yi,�' �•��•T t,����'s*��k Z
••.r� r� ,2� �-•
�. - ,r. ,�� :6�7�,5.'.,C4: VEL�INQ :�1/E. +� - ." `�.-9�.�'•,rt��iCEI:,. ,A�iI�iTQ��,��$:i�{f'.'•' t .
�s. � �� . <-; � .: i� ,,. -. . r
�„ �'r ',,: ; .�'_„ �,� • 'P �ssa.:iio t::�.� K t ;• �,��,�;. r,;r'�.�.�::�-y�-._. i:
� ' r t '}j�r; �,� f. .'R'�+ -'� n,.�yS�-`�*� t':'< <,�, L;�:: t':�. "_
}� .6'.
r:• , . �, - -�49" �• - , , s�.,� 4: s:�j�,' "._-�y_t,�,.-1 "�,,
;4' . � -,. �'�. � j ''�: :=+:,.��Y_ 4= -r�.�� '' #` ���
, . + � _���t_ .. -i i _ ,f.. "��__""-�1��'�fi� �`�Y.�r..�,-'��`�;�;�;•3.��t3 T��::,�.
�'� `� ="�� S T " '� . � oi1� 1til�tM �i s� t; '-�s 1.� r��',R,. �,;`�.`, � ;�~
r s�. +:: . i ;
< <. . . . .,a �� ; ' f,.: .L��_�.���e,c�, , ,�
. r . . ;�:��.• �� 'h: - i ��4 '. .. ��t/�W!+RO acel�G�(YS.d
.. ' , � • _ : � . , r ., '+ _ �"i`�� `\
•�` ��' 4`:�4,�ik., �. :s.x 6.' �-
'�y ` " - - ) � ` ' � ;���' �- .':' ` � : � . .
`�-' � Q 6'� :c�•"•-.:••', �i~ . '- -:+ ' � ,.�.
�� � . �`'""_ .. :::. ' `-..- .r=,.:. �
1 � � .. . �_ `N` "- .,- 1� ..�. 1 ;��.1i�''G 5"'s
i . . , . , ".�,i.r a�s �=T��}��.; ,�.� , i�`��'�'.. • '` ;.,Kt
� �' '"�t _ — � _ . •�G:._,:''+i�;;�"'••: ,y• �•,,�y •
, , .t,R,,� ; -?s.". ,�
, r w � . '., y _ , , ,�':�� `'s;i:s.',s.;_�.��,5.�^ �' ^'t
:'�~ V<' 'Y....,a
. �' ' '� �.stt . . - 4�' �ki: i�I." .i:.-:�:'`' .
'� - -�,.• �� . . �" 0��� . -f�i• t. • ..��:N^.Y,rr-� �=�'Tr;4- 'i�`b
� F . �- . ' ..� ,..' . 't:. :�. ._
- r. • - .� ���=�,� _ _i; .,. . .,.�� �: ,;__ .�
, , , -���'-.L��.x; -WV ^ �3� �
� , - . .�e. . ���'�J�� � �� � d� ,`� - •�? „�^`,.+j, -r�.,�,.�. ; . .
!„ ..�.,Y, ,w.4r':
. � : �('"! a �� G� �;,� � � "'' . " � .�:, .
�r. . � -� �, . ��,._.,
-� >
. f � � - �� �r- - ��. ,,��.�' �,�� ���; - .� �
� � ":�''� t" S� �, , .a�:.. ¢. � �> r:;��;,�`°! - - ' _ , . �
� ,- - � •-d. :�� i? . _ :;':3 �. .
f . . . "'`
• . . {_ �„ •�.-, � �
� f i . . - . .��"� `� " 'kt� �•T. ,
. - , � �- � ''r, _ `�,•{. :� . .
. „ , _ . : -_
. • • .- - . }, _ ��
. � � r. � - • .tk- _ - fj • � "
• � ^ .• - � . • ' F • ~ �
_ " . • . " .� .+": 1 .
� a� �.� � . , . .�.��.s��� � � �
� �e. ;, , • . . f�4- #�;:H :�,. j
� • � , • '' `"� �:'� �' ,�` ; � + .
, r ,• �"- : ' , = '',�. ' r`':-- `�7 .
. _�_ . . - 'r ' ?4: � , . •
� � ''• � . ' r -t , ' - . . :f .
, ' ' . • ' � ' , • • , � .. ,-,� . .� � ,
. . . . .:# • • � ,
. r ' ' ' ' , ' `' ;�` ' , }#
� " ., ' jy ':' _, .� ' i, . . + y � .
, - . � , i •
l �° . . '
; r� S/'►LESMIAN � • GUARANTE� AND CONDITIONS • .�`�� -- ." ' . -j ;�``'�' ;
y �.t• �,.'=' ,.. �
� ' ' ,�,Aq�maierial failina to Rro�v wiil be ee-eoAP1��d ai once at onrh�tf'the oitgind t9�c 4Ethe s�t►�k .>� , • , ,
i � ' `- Qro�ided paymenf is made prompd�,and-we are in(ormed of sach Tii rir �' /� . � .
follo�vjns rchase. P 1 �4�:,�ti��+=:1�t,a,
��� __�,., �O landtl6,charses eztra. ° , s ,*• ; 4' A�� ' .
- '�� - =a.� . _ . � .. . _. . . _ � -�. w.. �,,•'���. '�•f ,.e..�"..; s r ';�,
- -� ,.. =L..:.s._. _..''��,.. � . •
. - . . }
• , . � ' .
. !
• �t-��� �`�i
DUrLICATE TO rRINTER
CITY OF ST. PAUL FIOENCIL NO.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
, COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMI551 ONER DATF
RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul
hereby authorizes settlement o� the claim of Herman Illions and
Helen R. Illions, 1308 Edgecumbe Road, 3aint Paul, Minnesota, in
the amount of $135.00, in accordance with the reconunendation of the
Valuation Engineer in his letter of September 11, 1967, directed
to the City Council, upon =ece�.pt of a release of the City by the
above-named claimanta, in form satisfaatory to the Corporation
Counael of the City of Saint Paul.
��� 131��
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—,
Yeas Nays
Carlson
Dalglish Appr�oved l � ���i� 19—
Holland
n Favor
Meredith
Peterson � MaYor
A gainst
Tedesco
Mr. President, Byrne
�22