05-146CITY OF ST. PAUI,
FINAL ORDER
COUNCIL FILE NO. �'�� �p
$Y 1�����' 34
File No.
Voting Ward 6 & 7
In the Matter of constructing public improvements for Phalen Boulevard Phase
III from Arcade Street to Johnson Parkwa� to include construction of sanitary
sewer, storm sewer, water main, concrete curb and gutter, a new bituminous
surfaced roadway, a retaining wall, sidewalks, a pedestrianjbicycle trail,
landscaping, street lighting, two storm water sedimentation ponds, water and
sewer service connections where appropriate and doing all other necessary
work to complete said project.
under Preliminary
The Council of the City of Sa
upon the above improvement, due
prescribed by the Cit� Charter; and
nt Paul has conducted a public hearing
notice thereof having been given as
WHEREAS, The Council has heard all persons, objections and
recommendations pertaining to said proposed improvement and has fully
considered the same; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby order
that the above-described improvement be made, and the proper City officers
are hereby directed and authorized to proceed with the improvement; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That upon the completion of said improvement, the
proper City officers shall calculate all expenses incurred therein and shall
report the same to the City Council in accordance with Chapter 14 of the City
Charter.
Adopted by the Council: Date: ,/� /1p�"
Certified Passed by the Council Secretary
� Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet C�reen Sheet �
c� 2�1 � 1 vs p5-t�l�e
� DepartmenUoffice/councii: � Date Initiated: �
` Pw -P�b,,�Wm� 0 ��� -05 � Green Sheet NO: 3024822
Contact Person 8 Phone � � Deoartrnent Sent To Person Initial/Date
, Lisa Falk i � ; 0 �ublic Wort:s Lisa Falk
Z66{��� i Assign ' 1 'Council MarvErickson -
� Must Be on Council Agenda by (Date): � Number '
2&JAN-05 i For ,
: Routing
' Order
Total # of Signature Pages _(Clip All Locations for Signature)
� Action Requested: �
Set date of public hearing to approve the order for construcrion of the Phalen Boulevazd Phase III project from Arcade Street to
Johnson Pazkway.
File No. 19010
� Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personal Service Contrects Must Answer the Foltowing Questions:
Planning Commission
CIB Committee
Civil Service Commission
1. Has this person/firm ever worked under a contract for this department7
Yes No
2. Has this person/firm ever been a city employee?
Yes No
3. Does this person/firm possess a skill not normaliy possessed by any
current city employee?
Yes No
Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet
Initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
This project is the third and final phase of the planned construction of Phalen Boulevard between I-35E and Johnson Parkway.
'� Advantages If Approved:
Construction of this phase of the project will complete the roadway. The Eastside will have a more direct connection to I-35E and there
will be serveral pazcels opened up for possible redevelopment . In additon, contaminarion on the forzner Budget Towing site will be
cleaned up for a storm water management pond and for future tenants.
DisadvantaqeslfApproved:
None.
, � �QSPaTrh (`.n.
�; DisadvanWpes if Not Approved:
Project will not proceed. � A � o c
fl U � 3
Total Amoant of
Transaction: 19530000 CosVRevenue Budgeted: y
Fundinq Source: TEA 21, State Bonding, Activitv Number:
Pinancia� Information: MSA, CIB
(Explain)
�5
SUMMARY OP ENGINEERIPIG RECOMMENDATfONS
Phalen Boulevard Phase 111 -- Construction
Arcade Street to Johnson Parkway
Report Prepared —12-21-04
Public Hearing - to be scheduled
PROJECT
This project is to construct public improvements for Phalen Boulevard Phase III from
Arcade Street to Johnson Parkway. Improvements planned include construction of
sanitary sewer, storm sewer, water main, concrete curb and gutter, a new bituminous
surfaced roadway, a retaining wall, sidewalks, a pedestrian/bicycle trail, landscaping,
street lighting, two storm water sedimentation ponds, and water and sewer service
connections where appropriate. See attached map for preliminary layout.
INITIATING ACTION
Phalen Boulevard is a new roadway to be constructed on the city's East Side between I-
35E on the west and Johnson Parkway on the east. This new roadway will support an
initiative by the City and area businesses and residents to encourage redevelopment of
vacant and underutilized land in the corridor. The project will also significantly enhance
access to the East Side by providing a better connection to the regional roadway
system at I-35E, and by providing a direct route from the Phalen Village area to I-35E
north of downtown Saint Paui.
The proposed construction of Phalen Boulevard is considered a Federal Class I Action
because of the potential for significant impact on the natural and physical environment.
An Environmental Impact Study (EIS) has been completed for Phalen Boulevard. After
consideration and review of the analysis presented in the Draft EIS and the comments
receiveci from agencies, organizations, and citizens during the 45-day Draft EIS public
comment period, the Saint Paul City Council, in a resolution dated February 24, 1999,
selected segments W-2D, C-4, and E-1 from the Draft EIS as the Preferred Alternative
for Phalen Boulevard. The Record of Decision was approved by the Federai Highway
Administration on November 19, 1999.
The project is being constructed in phases. Phase I of the Phalen Boulevard Project is
the section between I-35E and Payne Avenue, which was constructed in 2003. Phase II
is the section between Payne Avenue and Arcade Street, which was constructed in
2004. Phase III is the section from Arcade Street to Johnson Parkway.
EXISTING CONDITIONS
The west half of the proposed alignment of Phalen Boulevard runs north of and parallel
to the Union Pacific Railroad, within the Ramsey County Regional Railroad Authority
(RCRRA) right of way. The eastern half of the proposed alignment follows the RCRRA
p5- t�l�
right of way, and curves north away from the Union Pacific Railroad property to meet
Johnson Parkway at the existing intersection with what used to be called Prosperity
Avenue but is now Phalen Boulevard also.
The existing asphalt Bruce Vento Regional BicyclelPedestrian Trail is located on
RCRRA properly, where Phalen Boulevard will be built.
Two existing streets will be extended to connect in to Phalen Boulevard: Frank Street
from the north and Atlantic Street from the south. The new connection for Frank Street
will run across properly the City has acquired from Budget Towing. The new connection
for Atlantic Street will run across a small portion of the Ray Anderson and Son's
property that was acquired for this project. In addition, provisions are being made to
allow for the future connection of Duchess Street If and when this connection is made,
the road will run across land that is currently owned by 3M.
PROPOSEDIMPROVEMENTS
The Phalen Boulevard Phase III project includes construction of Phalen Boulevard from
Arcade Street to Johnson Parkway. Under Preferred Alternative E-1 in the EIS, Phalen
Boulevard will be a two lane roadway from Arcade Street to Frank Street. It will be a
divided two lane roadway from Frank Street to Johnson Parkway. The alignment runs
north of and parallel to the Union Pacific Railroad line from the Arcade Street area east
to approximately Frank Street. East from Frank, Phalen Boulevard curves off to the
north, and pulls away from the railroad tracks. Phase III will meet Johnson Parkway at
the existing intersection of Johnson Parkway and Phalen Boulevard to the east, which
was built in 1998.
The project also includes construction of Frank Street from York Street to Phalen
Boulevard as a two lane roadway, 32' wide; and Atlantic Street from East Seventh
Street to Phalen Boulevard as a two lane roadway, 36' wide.
On the west end, Phalen Boulevard will connect into the existing Phalen Boulevard
(constructed as Phase 11) just to the east of Neid Lane.
The majority of Phalen Boulevard will be constructed in an easement on property owned
by RCRRA. Under the terms of the easement agreement, the City shall complete any
necessary grading work to maintain a 39' wide corridor for future Light Rail Transit as
part of this project.
To allow for grading for future Light Rail Transit, there wifl be a retaining wall
constructed adjacent to the Seegar Square property just to the east of Arcade Street.
The wall will be approximately 600' long, and will vary in height from 12.5' to 4'.
A new 12 foot wide pedestrian/bicycle path will be constructed along the north side of
Phalen Boulevard between Arcade Street and Johnson Parkway. This will take the
2
�
place of the existing Bruce Vento Trait that wi11 be removed to allow for the roadway
construction.
Sanitary sewer, storm sewer, water main and private ufilities witl be instalied in the
roadways to serve future development in the adjacent areas.
Two storm water sedimentation ponds will be constructed as part of this Phase of
Phalen Boulevard. One will be on the former Budget Towing site, just to the east of Earl
Street in the north east corner. The other pond will be at the intersection of Phalen
Boulevard with Johnson Parkway, in the south west corner.
New lantern style street lighting and landscaping will be installed on Phalen Boulevard
and the Frank Street and Atlantic Street connections. In addition, existing bent straw
lighting on Phalen Boulevard between Johnson Parkway and Maryland Avenue will be
reptaced with lantern style ►ighting.
NOISE WALL
Public Works is investigating the appropriateness of a noise wall as was suggested in
the Phalen Boulevard Final EIS. If a noise wall were to be built, it would be in the area
just to the west of the intersection with Johnson Parkway. Preliminary design suggests
that the wa�l should be 10' high, and might stretch up to 1600' along the north property
line of Phalen Boulevard and the Light Rail corridor.
Public Works does not plan to construct a noise wall at this time. We will work with the
community during the construction phase, to look at options and to assess the need for
noise mitigation. If the community decides that a noise wall is what they want in that
area, Public Works will come back to the City Council for a final decision regarding the
design, location, and cost of the noise wall.
POSITIVE BENEFITS
The construction of Phalen Boulevard is a project that has a number of interlocking
economic, social, and transportation goals. The overall purpose is to support and
enhance the Lower East Side neighborhood through which the roadway passes. This
support and enhancement will be achieved in several ways which are considered to be
the goals of the project. These include the following.
Provide access to otherwise undevelopable industrial sites
Generate economic growth in the community
Develop vacant brownfield sites
Enhance local and regional accessibility for residents, businesses, and visitors
Improve regional access to the Phalen Corridor
Provide local and regional recreational and bicycle/pedestrian facilities
3
45- ��lt�
ADVERSE EFFECTS
Construction of Phalen Boulevard as proposed will require the City to purchase
additional right of way. There is a possibility of soil contamination in the right of way,
likely then requiring remediation. The project will remove the Bruce Vento Regional
Trail from use for the construction season. There will also be the normal problems
associated with construction such as noise, dust, temporarily reduced access to the
neighborhood, and general disruption.
TIME SCHEDULE
The project is planned to begin in the spring of 2005 and be substantially complete and
open to traffic in the fall of 2005.
COSTS AND FUNDING
COST ESTIMATE
Construction $10,980,000
Engineering and Inspection $2,250,000
* ROW Acquisition and Remediation $6,300,000
-------------------
PROJECT TOTAL $19,530,000
* ROW Acquisition and Remediation was approved as part of
Counci! File No. 04-493
ESTIMATED FINANCING
Federal TEA 21 Funds
FY2004 State Bonding
FY2005 Proposed State Bonding (requested)
CIB Funds
Municipal State Aid Funds
PROJECT TOTAL
$8,070,000
$3,200,000
$4,000,000
$1,800,000
$2,460,000
$19,530,000
SOURCE OF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
For additional information, contact the Project Engineer Lisa Falk, at 266-6117.
SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION
The Department of Public Works feels that this is a necessary and worthwhile project
and the Engineering Recommendation is for approval of the project and financing.
If
4
�
0
� noaao �
ooa o
] 0o mo G
°�°° w
o[ �
�C
�
��
05- l�l�
^-+� _�_
�
�i
�= i
� ;
� !
_ �
- �
i ■
.'
� �
�
g
J u,l,� Ji.UULL �U� +� o � U ou �au uu a
r
■�.`�� _ ��� 1
.. . I
• �� il'��i �
� 1� I. I
---- r . . _
� +r ������
� ` .J
_ � -
-- � _ — �1�'� '
s�
g
ec
� �`'
�----�—�
� �
�!
�
�
. ���
, �
� �� .
..�
,.
�.:,
f
� � � F
� . I �
, �,
. �
..
� �-
:�
_� _ �� ' � .
• . T • � I
� � * : �
'� ■�� ���� �� � ��_.
+'� �� M� _' — � "
/ � �\° °�