231730 � 1
.i
��' (��J n 1
• ' 'F���y�� �I
ORIGINAL TO CITY�CERK f
� CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK `�
C UN I RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM � .�
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE DATF �
!II �
.�
. �
�
!
�
i
_�
1
RESOLVED� Upor� the pertinent appeal� under the Zoning Code� �
. �
by Nikolas and Lillian G. Scherer� owners of the subject real estate� � ; f
� ,i
situate in the City of Saint Paul� located on the north side of St,. �
. t
Clair between Milton and Victoria Streets, more partieularly � f
, ,
� �
dESCribed as Lot 17� Block 4, Kidd' s Rearrangement of Blocks 5 & 6 i �'
�
Haldemants Addition to the City of StoPaul�Ramsey Co,,Minn, that said � � �
appellants are hereby granted permission to build an extension to a � �
,
t
legal non-conforming building to be used as a bakery� pursuant to � ;
�
Chapter 64.03 of the Zoning Code of the City of Saint Paul, and � �
�
subject to the condition that said appellants and their successors
and assigns shall make due compliance with all applicable provi-
sions of municipal ordinances, state s_tatutes and r�.les and regulations, �
of public authorities having cognizance. � � j
. i �� a
� i
� " .-. i
! - F M AP D ' :� � ��
I ' '
,
r q��t. Carporafion Counsel ��� �
i
t
JA� �6 l9�_7- � �
COUNCILMEN '
Adopted by the Councit 19— '
�
Yeas ; Nays �
Carlson ��� �6 a��� ' �
Dalglish � �
Approved 19— �
Holland � ,f
k Mexedith � Tn Favor ' �
� � ;
Peterson �} . Mayor' �
v ,
Tedesco A gainst � �
�
Mr. President, Byrne . �
�UBLISH�ED JAN 2 81q��' ��� '
,
�22 ��
_ �If i
` � .
. . ; �
. ., ►
• ._;�� .
::'::::: � 6CJ�4RD OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�����������#!!i� 223•4151 Room 20 CITY HALL & COURT HOUSE SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 +
I
�
�i
I
_!�
�y ��3 �
Jaauary 16, 1967 �
I
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
City Clerk
Building
;{
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to the Appeal of Nikolas and
LilLian G. Scherer to make an addition to a legal non-
conformi.ng building. The building is located on Lot 17,
Block 4, Kidd's Rearrangement of Blocks 5 and 6, Haldeman's
Addition.
i
t
This matter was considered at the December 15, 1966 Board �
of Zoning meeting. The appellant wishes to make an
addition to an existing commercial building for living �
quarters. � � '
- 'f
The Board found it would be reasonable to grant the Appeal ��
and, therefore, recommends the Appeal be �granted.
Very truly yours,
� `
NRH/mm N. R. Heiden
Encl. . Secretary �
Z.F. 6203
��v' I�
v
,�
� • � • ua33. «.,.-..,�" �YJ�:; ^�
b �, • ' .��' � � ' ,r
. ' � .
BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION �cember 15, 1966 � Plat Ma 9 ' fi.y,
� p � _
�';
Acting under Legislative Code Cha ter 60 thru 64 [ ` �
p File No. 6203 r�' '.
passed August 22, 1922 as amended to August 24, 1964 ; �
� - Also , E ,
1. APPLICANT'S NAME • Nickolas R. � Lillian G. Scherer t' ,�r';
F 1� ti.,
2. CLASSIFICATION • � Amendment � Appeal �Permit ❑ Other � �� �
�,z#�,:
nonconforming `- '1 ::
�� 3. PURPOSE • Build an extension to an ex�ax�xA�xbu.i,iding to be used as a ��'
. bakery �x ���.�.r,.
4. IACATTON . �, .r ''•/
� North side of � �� -� '
Sto Clair btwn. Milton � Victoria Streets i' :.�
� + '
i �. LEGAL DESCRIPTION � �t 17, H1ock 4, Kidd�s rearrangement of Blocks 5 � 6,
i .� �-.
Haldeman's Addition t '_�
� , .
"B" Residence � �'
6. PRESENT ZONING . � �
g. p 64.03 ' ,�� 1-
7. PURSUANT TO Zonin Code Cha ter: Section: Paragraph: b #' �;
,
8. STAFF IDIVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date• 1�/12/66 gY: ATB .F '
. }
A. ZONING AD�IINISTRATOR: No action " . � � �.,�
B. HISTORY: None ,
C. PROPOSED USE: 'Qonstruct an addition to an existing non-conforming buildi.ng. � �
D. NEED FOR APPEAL: Chapter 60, Sec. 12 states that no existing building designed and "� '
i
devoted to a non-conforming use shall be enlarged or extended unless such use is j ��, �
changed to a use p�ermitted in the district in which such building is located.
E. AREA ZONING: The frontage along St. Clair Ave. is zoned "B" Residence, the rest of � ,� �,
the area is zoned "A" Residence. Three lots adjoining to the east are zoned "C" '
Reidence (in 1947). � •
� F. SITE CONDITIONS: The property is developed with a 25 X 50 commercial building on a � ,� =
40 X 125 ft. lot with an area of 5,000 sq. ft. '
. �,,.
G. AREA CONDITIONS: Adjoining to the west a con-conforming retail food store; north, { !-
mixed one � two-family residences; east, a 10-unit apartment building; south, a � �,,
large apartment and one, two � three family uses. ,�
, ' ,3
. f
. � . -
I�
. � ,
( " . , � �
�
,{
, � ,;
� � �
i 'r
� 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend XQ Approval ❑ Denial Council Lt. ; ��'�'
� Dated ��_� _�'
I Moved by: Klein Yeas Nays ,.,;?°�
f ' Ames 1/],9/67 � , ,
Seconded by: Haarstick x Cohen Date of Hearing ��� .
x Klein �'� ,
x Janes,Chmn. � ,
McPartlin Council Action � �� �
Secretary's remarks; x Ha�rstick - Alt. � i ``
' ' Gadler Date j ���•
�
Maietta {
, �- � ��i•
LEGAL NOTICES 'ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET , ' . r' �,�.
��
�' A
- • � r-n ..� — W.. � �_ ♦ J .h.-H�.'''wRV`:lM�lY{�v/�'M.�w�lf'eh'C.J°�t�4�Y'1�'Mi.}j�MM�Th�r4�11� ��
Y . . ', . ', '� .
° � . ,
•' 1 v 1 E__ _ �T ;I• Jl. d II I� i I_' '� i I T _i:. -I- --I �...._.� • I i_ � •i i 1 _t_.. a �_�_. � i � ., ,J_'_ i 1 v1� j �rt
' , ' � . I�
, : � , ��-,�- � , -�, . � � � -,� - . . ..__ � � f
� � ' ' ; ' I � �� '� i ' r � ' � � , ' � ' ' . •
, ; u " , ' �; ; , '! ; � '� ,, _ , ; � , I; , , , ; ; -1 r .�_ � �� j�,
)� � � n, I i, ! I � '�� ' '! ; ; , � � �; i . I , ; ; � � ; ° � �
� ' 2s � �� �����0: O O �c:����„ �'�, O O� , i � � i , �
� � �, ,,O. O � O O ° Q O � � #
� - �• � � � #
� .� , i ; � � � . �� ; � i � � � f :�;:��p, � ;�
� - � � OSCEOL A ' ; , ; � V � � ��
� _ , AVE. � � � �; � q , ;�
� i-�- � � ' � , ; � , , � ��I� ��� �.
0 0:o o i � � � � � � r�--,-=--r ,'�
? f^'�- � ...J._.a ...1���� ���+ ���� � ' � � �'�� �°�°,°!°�°;°�° ° o �° = �.�`,o, ' � :
. � _.�_. , _ I i � I � � � i
(n T 1� �_r r�� —r—,i � � � � 'I-- �—_.i I�T.__ � �i �' .�
,; �; ,. , o � ; , � ! � �-�-� , . o , ,r
i , ,
� �-- �� ,�: ��, ,_ :o, o o; � o; o:o o � o���c ��: '����!o! ` � ' _o . ; -�
, � 7 � � • i ) �..� �� � ' �� ��� J �O'O��iO�O!� � ;�
;'���!,� ;�� Lt1NVl/OOD AVE. -- cb ; ;� � �.
� i � ' � � , T ��' QC
�.. i ..� _i_ V �� vi,^v10�0! O �O ' O O� C�� O10 - C� �•O !O O O ;�, t�,�'I` .p � ' '� ' �� , f _
� '� _ •__�_ � .i , t f ._I.__ i � I_ _,i.___ � , , � 7� t � /'V�1,�
�. `�I _ j � ! _ . . '_. • , i ' . I I —
'J �J � ,� • �t � � � ^ �-y; ' , ' �.
' � .( ' ' ' � � �' `liO vl T � O� � /J O O I �j� j s
• . F i�0 I O � � O I � i �
� -.-�-==�=S`f. CL�I�2 AV� .�.� . .._g °�-,� t,� � , � � �� � N :
i � . - . . . � -:�:.���.�, '�
' t� � I 0��i �� � � �� � � I ! J� g , c. •i,�''-;'�''�, z,,.� ,�� . ", � �I� d
` i , ' ' ��� �;�� T � O � � O ' ,£' � L.Y�' � '� I ��' ,� �c � -
I � � i I ' � � � � I J - �F �� � � �1 ,.. .
1 �J �J 1 �
1 � � 1 O� Q. ��� �J � �l/< f•..7 �,�" 4u �./ � f •
' ; , • ..�._._,�.� tiCv��. �.'<..��3. �". �'� } C� �t,t Yv'
: � � . � � Q _ --�• •.',r t.i ,!:.�"1 .�i.:•, �- y � �'
II� ' I ;J —1 _ __ ' 4"t c, '• t;� ''+, .•�I L,; '-�'' �
�. O � O ; QjQ � .� Q ` ( � . 3 ; �
I I � ��,:Q.�i.�;�l��(���� , � C'� 4i tJ � �-f 1� ^'. 4�'°�
� ! � I, � —�' �, "-:� Y;✓ � .1 ��:� , .F�.�1 .
LO�BARD � � - � - � t�.�G i � � �� ` -� .
;___, �AV E. , , o� o � ��� � � � �4 ,
.� I i� � � � 1 . �"� _� W '�,:� �'.:7 �.�V� �.�. �� •, ;,} , }: a�.
._�, it'J ; p Q �pi ip;p, �l � ; .z �;� � � st-,,J �`" ,��I i -� ,
i i � I I- ' ; � � I , i Y � �O lO O . L�J� T Y. '" • '��'� {��. � ��' ,J�f '}.
,� � I � � w � i. �''� i' � �0_ w (t� r1 L:i � .� �� � ��? �
i ^ � � .i f•.. v i
' , ° L� I � I � ` � � � ' � i N I �' �J m �;f , `+• i,�� ' '�:� 1 f #, ..
.. . , 1.�_�. .1__L__�._1 � .� �- �. _i�_ �--► �� � �;�� �� �:3 ��,,�.� ��� ; ��
O ". I '(" - -�•-;�- '— ' • ``�� i O c: ~� ~ „i �;t � j ,
Q I ! i 7 I' ' � - � I.F—. L.L�i y� � � E;t � . ..:
� ; � °'� � � � T i � '' ; �-, �-___� � � � �—�9�`'�;��3�� �:.f .f�-,', �;�`
� � i i r � � i i ! � �,,1 I ; � p�� �O � � `� ' �1: - ',
O � � : � i -"-��
'� (� � � I . � �Q' � -.--.�...<-. � �::::.::::''.:`;:':°::•.:': ��.
- '' , T � ` O IO O Q i — r._.,�–. :.., � ...:.::��:•:..;:;;;;i��.
� "� ::�a��:�:,�:.:::.;;� �.
� :'���r �:�:��:;`.
..:.....:;..:: � , , r:_. : . :.:}.::
;�. ....... •.��..:�::;:�;.:.;::
, , � .....:;�::::::::•::.
:����:�:�;;:��'.::s=::�,::�`�%`�`��. '�:�::s:� .
�� �:,r.-..::.:::�::•....•....,.; :r,
..:.. .....
� '':�:ii:�:�e:'iii�S:i':'{�f'•ti��'.�y;;}:i::'�:::�::=•r,:l�.: • r
� • ..�-<...... <,;....:e:•r::•:;•.:.:'r:::::�.;::..: }�{^}:#:
......:::::::
� •�•.:....:......
'•.':�..-�;'!•.• l
......:...•.....:....... .. .
�;.:::o-... .. •.::,:::�::�:::o-:••^...............:.... •
.r.�:......... ...�. :�... ••.:•.;...;.�.°:•.•::::............ . - ...;......,r,�::;.y;..?
..,....,...,
'^�:".�::�'�:::��'::
� ... ........ � .. ........ '.��t:.�':•��'.: ti'
.. ... . _ 4"1.
..•'..:............ .....��.•..... •
.. .. ... . . .:.......:...:...::::....i::�:.........;....c:�F. '`%i�".'
-- .� , _ . . . , .... .... .... .. ........ .. . .......:::J::� �! ..���'� -�.'�i:� �� ,
�����H�S�� 6 � ��wCOLAS R. & LILLIA*I G. SCF�ERER� . � • . . _ L���l�� . ' ; , '�. .
• � ' ; ' ;.
�'URPOSE� ��er.sion of. non-conformin� � - � L,qND� USE� l � � ,'
building • . • • � � , ; ;�
PRESEfVT Z0�!!NG�' ��B'� Resictence . . � . O -ONE FAMILY . � ` ' ` -
� . . . . . �Q i VUO FAMlLY .� _ _� . �
. �J: THREE FAMILY� �. � � i ' � �
PETlT�ON SIGNERS� � . :� :. . � , . � FOUR . FAMILY� �. � �. � , '�.
FILE No. �2a3. . � �- . . . � ��'�1UL'�I-FANiILY , . � - , ' ' i :��
. � ,�, , � � , o �, rl •CON4N9ERCIAL . . ' � � -►
. � . . � • ' ' .n n I�IDUSTRIAL . � ' � ' '#
- � .. , NORTN � . , ' • ' . ' . � a� .
.. �,, .�
� Sf. Paui i'lanni�g Board, Oate Dec. 9; 1966 e� PROPERTY_. IM .QUESTIOf� .....�._.�: �
--.__.__--�.�.__.___—__�__�_______ _.._,� �_-�-�.__4__�.�.._ ' ---�-^-�-�--�� ,�
� � � � � . � � �
�
' " �I
�- � ' �[
J"� 1 •
r e •
i�
II
�
KEMP� & MURPHY ' 2p,
' ATTORTV EYS AT LA1N �y�J I
�� ��
ARNOLD E.KEMPE � CAPITAL2-BBBB �
t
THOMAS M.MURPHY 47 SIGNAL HILLS
WE8T 9AINT PAUL,MINNE30Tq
December 1, 1966
,.
, �
� � ��
� � 1'� � � � � j�
. The Honorable- Mayor & 1�
c�ty cou���i B�� � 196� ��
c/o the �ity Clerk '
Room 3 8 6, City JEIalI & • C���t��a;��ANliwa�s�e��� '�
Court House -
St. Paul, Minne�ota
I�
Gentlemen�:
Please be advi�ed that we represent Nickolas R. Scherer and Lillian G.
:Scherer, huspand and wife, who reside at 1477 Lincoln Avenue, St. Paul, �
Minnesota, and whose telephone number is. 699=2673.
1VIr. & IVIrs. :Scherer are the fee owners of a certain building located at �!
915 St. Clair Avenue, �t,. Paul, Minnesota; and �urther described as.; Lot ',;
17, Block 4, Kidd's Rearrangement of Blocks 5 and 6, Haldeman's Addition
to the City_ of St.. Paul, R�amsey County, Minneso.ta.
At the present ti.me the building is vacant. Recently, it has been occupied
by a T.V. repair store a,nd a coin shop. The propert� is to be used for a
small bakery, .specializing in the retail sale of bread. �
,
�,
��
The property is presently, zoned for residential and the building Xocated thereon �
is a legal non conforming� use. The proposed new c.oristruction would be an
entirely, new living quarters.. Z am enclosing herewith a pla.t or sight plan
and also-the lay;out of th� proposed n.ew construction. '
�The purpose of this appeal is therefore to obtain variance to a17.ow the addition
to the building. I belieye that this would be allowed under the City Ordinance;
Legislatiye Code Ch.apter 64. 03, Paragraph B.
�
�Pe are enclosing herewith our check in the amount of $20, 00 to cover the �`
filing fee in this matter. Thank you for your consideration in this matter.
yery truly yours, "
,
:
MP & MURP
�
��
�
Thomas M. rphy
TMM:cl ������ ��� �
�nc.. 1 check � ---Q� `,�
ii
�: e i � �
i'
„� °•' Y' �
I�
I,
�
li
CITY OF SAINT PAUL �i
MINNESOTA
�
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102 �E
:)
�2� f
�?
, danuary 6, 1g67 '�
�
��
City Clerk
Fi1e x2lt6, 1'age
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the �
Council Chambers of the City Hall and Caurt House in the City of I�
St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on January 19� 1967, on the appeal under �
the zoni.ng code of Nicolas R. and Lillian Q. Scherer for the ' -_
extension of a non-conforming building on the following property: !�
Lot 17, Block 1t� Kidd�s Rearrangement of Blocks 5 and 6, Haldemanfs u
Addition. The �roperty is commonly known as 915 St. Clai.r Anenue.
For�flirther 3nformation contact Planning Board, Room 20� Court
Housp or phone 223-l�151.
,
�
JA1��S J. DALGLISH
Commissioner of Finance '
�E
��
k
i
, ''r
i
k
t
��
i
t
Is
if
u