232007 OR�GINAL TO CITY CLERK �v^o���
_ - CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL N�. � �" � ;�
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK � 'I,
�, �cE r�sE c o i��i� C O U N C I O L U T O N—G E NERAL FORM �
PRESENTED BY � � I
COMMISSIONE DAT February �� 1 r6? R � �
� T - - (
I � 4:
��`HEREAS; Mary I,nbianker was issued Grocery, Off Sale Malt Beverage and Ci - ' ette ;
;
� License rro. 1�522, expiring November 12, 1967, for 165 PJorth Dun1a,� and =
f ��
k1HEREAS; Within a month of receiving said license, she met ��ith an acciden�� and • ;,
� ' � I � ,.
� is una�hle to operate sa3.d business� and requests a pro-rated refu i of �� '
i the fee for the unused portion of the license� therefore� be it ; y '
. �
OLVED: 2'hat the proper city officers be and they are hereby authorized t � i �
, . � .
, � ref'und to P4ary Lubianker the pro-rated fee of � 66.00� deducting � ,
$ 6.00 from the ori.ginal fee of � 72.00 �osted. for the period she � - :
.,
operated� wh ich will c�ancel said license in her name at this loca iori.�
i _ t
�
� : !
- ' e
I
C,A,PIC�LATIOI� T,ICEN,SE
{partial.Refund) �
� _
(Letter of appn. from Atty. Royal C. Orren attached to city �'lerk�s Oopy of Reso ut�n�-
. ;
i i, .
Residence Ad.dress: 590 S� Snelling Ave. Apt. 6� St. Paul; I�.inn. � ��
I � -
7
� Item Posted Qperated Ref�znd - • i R t
I � -
]. Mo. 11 Mo. � ,
Grocer�,T – – – �– ��� – – – $ 3,75 – – – � –��� r -
off�i1.e Malt . 15.00 . 1.25 • 13.75 t -
Ci,�arette _ _ 12_QO _ _ _ l�pp 11„�pp 1 _ .
Totals $ 72.00 $- -6�00 - - $ 6�.00 i '
1 . i "' -
� ��� �, � �.� , k
• �COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council '. Yg_��
Yeas Nays � -•
� Carlson ,, (��� 1 4 1��� ; � � ,
� Dalglish � Approve �19� "
; w
� '
�O�land._:,_ �' ,
� i - Favor '
� Meredith � � � = �
� � � . . - Mayor -
f �.
��9� A gainst
� ,
Mr.�President, Byrne � _.
.
'' PUBLISH�ED FE� 18196fi � n � �
�� - �
�. ��, / j � �� �' i c
_' • �
-�' � �� a, '
• � .� �.�. �, �� r �•
i -` '�, , . '
f � � � 3�2: ;.
. . . . , ��� ;:
� - . � �,
� RlJT7'ENBERQ, ORREN� GRISWDLD & COHEN , � ;r
• � AT70RNEYB AT LAW , • �' "
� 1001 NEW YGRK BUILDIN� . . a- P
� ' BAINT PAUL, MINNEBOTA SS101 �. � , I�
. �* �-
HAqOID L RUTT[NB[RO • ' F� .� p
ROYAL R ORR[H � ` I•
� J�anuary 9, 1967 . � ` � �
K[NN[TH R OR�/WOLD , ' , i-
LAWIItNQ['0. COH[N • ' � � � ' ''14�1•384 "
, ' • f • • - �; II
' . • � , ; , . �* �
. License 'Committee ' . � � ': �
City of Saint Paul'. � , ; . � �: ��
. ' ' 202 Public Safety Bldg. � �:` `
• ;" 101 East lOth Street � • , . . • " � �;' ;
St . Paul, Minn. 55101 ' , - �' ;
. , ,
.. �.
_ , , � Attn: Daniel McLaughlin - • y� f
. , �, , ;.
; . � .� �:
- Gentlemen: • ' �_ �'
„ �:
�� �
� - This is to advise you that I represent Mary Lubianker , 4'
, - 590 South Snelling, Apt . 6 , St. Paul, Minnesota , who formerly ' i� : �
, operated a small dairy store at 165 North Dunlap under the name � �, �
, . of Paul s Aairy Store. On December 2nd , 1966 , you issued license � , `
No. A4522 for� grocery, off-sale malt and cigarette. _ a;
. � � Q.
- Mrs . Lubianker is a divorced woman who ran the store asa� ,, ��-
' ' an, individual with no other help . .Last month while going down � �;� � k
' to the store �she fell and broke her knee . She was forced to sell #;
• to the first buyer at a small fraction of the true worth of the�'� � ;
, ' - . , store. , � = i
r f s
,�1 : I:
• She is receiving no alimony, and the store was her so '�es , � ��
' � � means of support . . - . 1F - M
, ' ' _ ' �, � ;' ��
. , ` �� ' � Inasmuch as this is a very recen't license , I would �'
• : . . greatly appreciate it if the Committee would consider refunding . �� � i�
� t h e $7 2 . 0 0 f e e t h a t w a s p a i d. by her . �t ' �tr
. • �
-' • • � I unde"rstand that the new owner , Ambrose, Garske , has i
. � " �lready applied for and obtained a new license. ��
. , , ,; a �
> � , • 1 Ys
' -. Your consideration of �this extreme hardship case would' �� �
,� be greatly appreciated . . t
' � . , �. . , „ , . ' � � , .., . , � � Yours very truly, • . . �t �;
• ` ' , . • . , �+ i9
, ' - . � � ' - ,�. RUTTENBERG, ORREN, GRISWOLD & COHEN �' �'
: _ . : . � , . , , � }1 ' �
, . . � - , ._ . C��.�, l �_ �' .
� ,.
:
� ' � ' � Royal C. Orren � . �� �'
, ;. . �
� , � , �+ l;
RCO:nl . • � • =� ��
S
- , i-
. , . . ' � � i,
" . � • . - � ' _.. � ; , � , "' , ,i i4 � °
� r ' � �
� • . . � � I � ' i
' � i�
� .
I
_—__._.__._. . �' I.