The URL can be used to link to this page

240167 ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK ��0�� , CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO. OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK OUN itESOLUT N—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY ' COMMISSIONE � DATF RESOLVED, That upon and pursuant to the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning Code, by Sam Winnick, own.er of the subject real estate, situate in the City of Saint Paul and described as: Lot 5, Block l, Brenner� Addition; that the provisions of said Zoning Code hereby are determined and varied as and to the extent necessary therefor and the building line setback �or said premises is hereby relaged so as to permit installation of a non—flashing advertising sign at the property line, subject to the condition that said appellant, and his successors and assigns, otherwise, shall make due compliance with all applicable provisions of mun.icipal ordinances, state statutes and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance. • �� F APP - Ass� Corporation Counsei , �Ep i 1 196$ COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays Carlson ��P' 1 1 1968 Dalglish /� Approved 19— � Meredith � Tn Favor � �etersaa� � Sprafk� � ��, Mayor A gainst Tedesco �' ' ":�:�"i p61�.LISHE� S E P 14 1968 �Mr. Vice Preaident (Peterson) �°� �� ,_ t ' , f �1� • � ' � � � � �7 BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151' September 3, 1968 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Dear Sir: This is written in response to the appeal of Sam Winnick to relax the building line setback on property located at the IdE corner of Clarence Street and Maryland Avenue and described as Lot 5, Block 1, Brenner Add.ition. The appellant wishes to install a 26 foot high, 10 foot by 12 foot, non-flashing advertising sign at the property line. (A request to relax the setbaek to allow a flashing sign on the property was denied by the City Council in April of 1968.) This matter was considered by the Board of Zoning at a publ�c �?earing on August 15, 1968. The staff reported that the area zoning includes "C" Residence to the west, "C-1" Residence to the north, "B" Residence to the east, and Commercial to the south. Existing area uses include ' residential to the north of Maryland Avenue and commercial uses to the south of Maryland Avenue. The residential development to the west observes a setback of approximately 30' to 35' from Maryland Avenue. The residential development to the east observes a setback of at least 20' . Mr. Richard Garmaker, an owner of the apartments to the west, spoke i.n opposition to the relaxation. - It was the findings of the Boar,d_ that it would be reasonable to grant the relaxation. Therefore, the Board of Zoning recommends approval of the relaxation of the setback requirement. Very truly yours, ��/� . � , Genrge G. McPartlin , Secretary GGM:cv RWR Z.F. #6559 �� v � � � '� , . . . � . . �� 224-4345 JOHN E. DAUBNEY ATTORNEY AT LAW 73B MINNESOTA BLJILDING � ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55701 ` June lg, 1g68 `b The Honorable The City Council City of Saint Paul � Court House � St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 , Dear Mayor Byrne a.nd Gentlemen: Please be advised that Mr. Sam Winnick, whose telephone number is 6gg-18�+8, is the owner of: Lot 5, Block 1, Brenner Addition, Ramsey County, Minnesota, which property is located at the northeast corner of Clarence Street and Mary- land Avenue in the City of St. Paul. The property is zoned for co�ercial usage and is presently improved with a commercial type building, including a.n off-sale liquor store owned by application, and a dry gleaning establishment. � Applicant wishes to erect a separate standing advertising sign at the south�west corner of the sub�ect premises, as the building is set back a considerable distance from the street so as to provide off-street paxking, and identification is needed, as this is a newly constructed co�ercial area. It is difficult for east-west traffic on Maryland to be�aware of the commercial building without identification through the median of an advertising sign located on the Maryland side of the premises. This application is similiar to an application previously 'filed with �our Honorab�e Body, but differs in that the previous application was for a flashing sign and that this application is for a non-flashing type of sign. This appeal is necessitated by reason of the fact that the premises to the east of the subject premises are zoned and used for single family residential purposes, although the area is predominately multi-residences an.d commercial in its development. This appeal is under St. Paul Legislative Code Chapter 64.03, Paxagraph J. I am enclosing Mr. Winnick's check in the sum of $30.00 as and for his filing fee so as to permit the construction of a free standing advertising sign as shown in the attached plan. Ve tru s, JO E. DAUBNEY At orney for Sam Winnick JED:pr Eac. ��NI I�G � '��} �..�� r � . ; � . ° ., BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION August 15, 1968 Plat Map 33 Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 File No. passed August 22, 1922 as amended to August 24, 1964 6559 Also 6454 1. APPLICANT'S NAME • Sam�Winnick 6344 . . 6155 2. CLASSIFICATION • � Amendment � Appeal �Permit ❑ Other I5443 ' 3. PURPOSE • Relax building line setback , 4. LOCATION • NE Corner of Clarence Street and Maryland Avenue 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION � Lot 5, Block 1, Brenner Addition 6. PRESENT ZONING . Commercial • 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64� Section: •03 Paragraph: j 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: By: A. ZONING ADi�1INISTRATIO`i: No action , B. HISTORY: Property rezoned from "A" to "C" Residence for boarding care facility on 9/19/64. Rezoned ta Commercial 12/24/66, 39 car parking lot permit issasd 11/18/67. Appeal to relax building line setback to front propsrty line for fre� C. standing sign, was denied on 4/16/68. C. PROPOSED USE: Install a free standing advertising sign at the front property line. The sign would be 26' high and the main sur�ace would be 10' by 12' although additional area would be added to the sign at a future date. The sign will be non-flashing. D. NEED FOR APPEAL: A setback is requirsd and the proposed sign, over 3'6" in height would be located in this setback area. The required setback is 22' . E. AREA ZONING: This property is zoned Commercial, north is zoned "C-1" Residence, . east is "A" Residence, south is zoned Commercial and west is zoned "C" Residence; Fe SITE CONDITIONS: Site is developed with a Commercial building divic�ed into six stores and a parking lot, lesel and at street grade. G. AREA CONDITIONS: North is vacant land, east and west residential development with setback of approximately 30 - 35' ; south is d�veloped with a filling station and a drive-in restaurant. Maryland Avenue is rolling and approacliing . from the east the Commercial property is not visible until within 3/4 of a block. From the west the sight distance is slightly greater. 90 BOARD ACTION: To Recommend � Approval � Denial Council Lt. ' � Dated Moved by: Cohen _ Yeas Nays Ames x Seconded by: McPartlin ' X Cohen Date of Hearing Janes,Chmn. x McPartlin Council Action Secretary's remarks: Haarstick - Alt. Gadler x Date . X Maietta LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET ' ::r-------�-- `'- .' - Q . v �j 4 ' `��:�,� ?� �' a o �, -- _ . ;��:. 1 , `� � ,c� . .o_ o . o �:�� - ��f� .°_ o o � � � �t�� ,y �� ►� � Q _ � , _�.. . O � O . � . s..�n �. :� __�y�_ _ < O � O — i '�� .. `("q—_ �:+� : . � ' < p . . � � � , Q_-- .� � � . < � O ,� a � � . ': . < � O � � . � . � . 0 . O w � ' > � � �F < • � O . J ':� - > w s,p � � _ � ? � � d .� <, z . O O � - , � �� =' w .,,-�' � , � � '� _>_E o � � � _`� � ;:'� . - — � �t ;�-� ? � - ' . , `� �O � u w �� a �> > �.N G� � U � � �N �'— � � � �'` W G R�S �l� � ? .. 22 � � O__ � �' `�� z :�� . � < � �� e � V ': > � ��1-- j � , c � � � � � I' � _ � -v,—� > �-- � �� . ) �� i i. �i �r.%;%,I ? � -_ -- (� v Q�' �� I �"•"�!_C - ,"� �y l � r •o ` \\ • �� _' j J > Q O ' � Q� .�— ' �' .., ��L. - �� Y�(, � -:_ � ��- � -,�-- . . . Q� - .;� ��_ �:: i,,' . ._ �:�� ,� � i I _.� �' � U �, � 22 - � � �' � � � � v�y/ I I . z2 i '. � {� v c - v , � � . , . � , �3�l �. '� :, � �� ..s,! C� � . 'y v� �� a �� .� �o � �� , , �. , p � � , r � ...: , , � . , �� .j _ ; �.-, � ,��S,AE��, � �,-�-��..� ��°-�,f��-`��A �-t� - ' � - . ___ .-�-��W.�..-� -��,�-� � . , CaNI MERC/�-1 L r-^�--°"� ,,.,��,...,;� _�_ .;��;r .� �:. ..AG�.. ._,� �.°-�°�'�- O O � O � � I 0 Cj �C� �'��.,I �� I � i ,Q I O � �� . . � , � � ' � �� , �j � � � I �� 6 1 ;s;� 3 � . . :� � � . .,. ,.� . . �::� �� s � ` � �u �. � � � . --..._ -:- � �' I . . �- -- , � :.:tc�.. rs�.7 F*� �-� aro+. c-.m t.'�.:� � /� 1�J �u.. —{—' (-)` � Q� O � V •�. 1 ( _ 1 � _�� ; °R ., oR � ,Q�� .; . nq ► R�s1 �:.N� v . ;N �rvvvvv ,� . � �+� � . � � �, . _ _ __ i !.'r•1 � `� �� ` � . • . i _ �,. � � �'v , �� . � �: . � �:� � Q � � � ��Uy ��vnvs�- �� , � o . _ - - � .. . .. � . �- :�.:`� , � , � . �'�-��.. � �°-.-� . . _ . .. �a �:.. � . . . - . . ��_ . ��. `��±�f�1�1�1�1!:_�� : � - - ,� -. - . - . �� ----�- ==�- � � / . -. . . _ : � _. ._ . . : . .. .. . . . _ . . . � f�,i��,rF1�� Sam Sdinnick , • ` ��J�� . _ � . � :, � . � �- . � PlJt�1�� Relax building line setb:ack �� r— . � i ' . . � _ . _ . . _ . _ ._ . � - O ONE-F�1�ILY � . PRES�:iU I �OI�IING Commercial , _ -a- �'1,�'1Q--F�-1M1LY � - �Y TH{��E- �'APJIILY � PE i!"�"I�N SIGN��S . - ' - FOUf�-FA[�iLY � . . . . - - - . � . � ��ULi�!° FA�r11LY j � o enC0�1�JI�RCIAL �� . FILE No. #�6559 • n1�� -' �1 /, INDUST�I.!1L � � � � - V VAC�INT �� l �'} f�rv��l G�lnnninn Rnnrrl T1ri�F�t .Tt,1�r q _ 19fiR C.�./_aR� �fO��Y�1/ laS'!f`ZE?Y �ns��rirrr+fi+� .. ` .. � � ' . t • � CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 Au�ust 23, 1968 City Clerk � File X555, Page You are hereby notified that a public hear3.ng will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on September 5, 1968, on the appeal of Sam Winnick tio relax building line setback on the followin� property: Lot 5, Block 1, Brenner Addition. The property is located on the northeast corner o£ Clarence Street and Maryland Avenne. For further information contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Commerce Building or phone 223-4151. JAMLS J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance �O � ,. r°' " � . CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE . 113 Court House 55102 August 2, 1968 Citq Clerk File X555, Page You are hereby notified that the $oard of Zoning will hold a public hearin� in Roan 356 of the City Hall and CourC Aouse in the City of St. Paul at 2:00 P. M. on August 15, 1968 on Che appeal of Sam Winnick • to relax building liae setback on the following property: Lot 5, Block 1, Breriner Addition. The property is located on the northeast corner o£ Clarence SCreet and Maryland Avenue. , For further information contacC Planniag Board, Room 1010 Commerce �uilding or phone 223-4151. JAI�;S J. DALGLISH Cotmnissioner of Finance �O