04-727������ �/ ��
RESOLUTION
C1TY OF �S`A1NT PAUL, MINNESOTA
1
2
3
4
5
0
�
9
l0
ll
l2
L3
l4
1$
L6
l7
l8
l9
Presented by
Referred To
IZ
Council File # D� 7�. 9
Green Sheet # 202424
Committee Date
WHEREAS, Encroachment Permit #04-0384, dated June 24, 2004, was issued by Public Works to allow
construction of a retaining wall and carriage walk in the boulevard abutting 208 Mississippi River Boulevazd
South, and
WI�REAS,theEncroachmentPermitwasissu the c it in. errorewallhadcommencedass�g�ke
��
, >
,'�'� •M\ Nin]�IItti3`l.n��.sa�� - n1��'�aG� - ���isn � �_ _� _ �
4Vf IEREAS, the Encroachment Pemrit was emantly issued without adequately considering the impact of Chapter
13 of the Saint Paul Administrarive Code regarding Diversion of Park Properiy, and
WHEREAS, the Director of Public Works, per Secfion 134.10 Permit Revocation of the Saint Paul
Administrative Code, requests that the City Council revoke the permit, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Saint Paul City Council hereby revokes said permit.
eas sen
Benanau si
Bostrom ,i
Hatris ✓
Helgen �
Lantry i/
Montgomery r
Thune �/
� �
>� AdoptedbyCouncil: Aate: ///�/i� �� �/flJ�
� 1 Adoprion Certified by Council Secrebry
�2 By: d�J
.
Req este b epa t Pub ' ks
By: irector
Fonn Approved by City Attorney
DEPARTMEM/OFFICFlCOUNCIL DATEINfIlATEO GREE �H�ET r,o. 202424
Public Works Department ,� '7 ^ „„�
COMACTPERSONBPHONE � " � 4 CINGOUNdL O� /
Larry H. Lueth 651-266-6083
MUST BE ON COUNCILNGENDA BY (DATE)
Ju1y 28, 2004
nsswx � cmanowuEr �t v �cmc�.ewc
NUMBERFOR
���' ❑FlNANCIALSERVICESDIR ❑FINANCIAISEftV/FLCTG
ORUER ❑
- � MAYOR(ORASSISTAM)
� HllII13II R1�11S �
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES 1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
acnoN aEOUESreo ' � � � .
�pproval of Resolution to Revoke Eneroachment Permit 04-�384, dated 7une 24, 2004, issued by Public Works
�llowing construcrion of a retaining wa11 and carriage walk in the boulevazd abutting 208 Mississippi River Boulevazd.
RECOMMENDATIONS'Approve (A) w Reject (R)
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB COMMRtEE
_ CNIISERVICECOMMISS(ON
A S�aff
PERSONAL SERVICE COMRACTS MUST ANSW ERTHE FOLLOWING QUESYIONS:
1. Nas this pe5�im everworketl uiMera w�Uacl fa Na departmenl?
YES NO
2 Hasthispersmlf(meverbeenadtyemployee�
YES NO
3 Daes this pers�rm possess a sk"II not namalty possessed by anycurtent uty employee?
VES NO
4 Is this persoNfirm a targeted ventlM
VES NO
E�pWln all yes answers on separata shee! anA adaeh to green sheat
INITIATiNG FROBIEM, l$SUE, OPPORSUNIlY �WHO, W HAT, WH'eN, W WeRE,
W HV)
Public Works issued an Encroachment Pernut based on incomplete documentafion, misunderstood verbal
communication, and without adequately considering the impact of Chapter 13 of the Saint Paul Administrative Code
regarding Diversion of Pazk Property.
\DVAMAGES IF APPROVE�: ,
The retaining wall built to an unauthorized height will be removed. The extended carriaige walk will not be
authorized. The abutting property owner, Pernuttee, will be required to follow the steps laid out in Chapter 13 to
seek permission to conshuct the requested improvement in the public right-of-way of Mississippi River Boulevard.
DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVE�:
Resident will be extremely upset when required to remove the unauthorized construcrion in public right-of-way.
3E5IP NOT APPROUED
complete retaining wall, steps, and carriage walk will remain in the boulevard of 208 Mississippi River
-d south.
TOTAL AMOUN7 OF TRANSACTION $ N/A
FUNOING SOURCE N/A
COSTIREVENUE BUUGETED (CIRCLE ONE) re5 No
ACTIVIlY NUMBER N!A
FtNANC1Al MfORMATiON (EXYWN)
a�!-��.�
Interdepartmental Memorandum
CIT'Y OF SAINT PAUL RECENED
JUL 2 2 2004
MAYOR'S OFF(CE
TO: Mayor Randy Kelly
Councilmember Jay Benanav
FROM: Bob Sandquist �c� ���/�v�s �
Director of Public Works ���{
SUBJECT: Resolution to Revoke Encroachment Permit
DATE: July 21, 2004
Please pxocess the attached Resolution revoldng the Encroactunent Permit issued for the retaining wall and carriage
walkconstnicted at208 Mississippi RiverBoulevard South. Iwouldverymuchappreciatehauingit scheduled on
the July 28`" Council Agenda.
If you ha�e questions regarding this issue, please contact Lany Lueth at 266-6083.
BS:LHL:mf
c: Tim Agness, Parks & Recreation
Peter White, Rea1 Estate
Linda Murphy, Public Works
A1 Czaia, Public Works
Larry Lueth, PublicWorks
Mary McIntyre