The URL can be used to link to this page

239006 r � ' � ' �� e ! 4 ' 239006 ORI6INAL TOtCITY CLERK ' � ,, ° . CITY OF ST. PAUL � 'couNCi� NO. �OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE C UN IL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM < PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONE ATF -`r �'' RESOLVED, That Archie �Givens be and hereby is permitted to construct and oper:ate a nursing home on property located on the so_uth side of Marshall Avenue between. Western Avenue and Arun.del Street, more particularly described as Lots 4, 5, 6 and 7 , and the east 1'� feet of Lots 8 and 11, Block l, Kern''s Addition; the west 40 feet of Lot 3, Block l, Kern' s Addition, and the west 40 feet of the east 350 feet of the north 165 feet of the Northwest 1/4 of Section 1, Town.ship 28 North, Range 23 West, except the north 33 feet for Marshall Avenue, in accordance with plans dated Received � May 8, 1968; subject to compliance with all applicable city ordinances , state statutes::and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance. ' � i ' F M AP OV AssL CorEaa 'Qn Counsel � r . _ � _ - z 7 � fi ' �UN�i � 196t COTJNCILMEN Adopted by the Counci� 19�. ; Yeas Nays c� . :�i� •i �� - � Approved • 19—_ Meredith � Tn Favor Peterson - ' � Mayor Sprafka Tedesco A gainst Mr. President, Byrne , � PtiBLISHE� �uN �5 196� . . , �O . _ L� ,, . z .�,. ._ -. � � � BOARD OI' ZONING R.�PORT AND ACTION 5/16/68 Plat Map 6 Actin� under Legislative Code Chapter 60 'thru 64 File No. passed August 22, 1922 as amended to August 24, 1964 6501 ' � Also 1. APPLICANT'S NAN� • Archie Givens � 2. CLASSIFICATION • � Amendment D Appeal ❑Permit ❑ Other _ I ' �- 3. PURPOSE . Permission to construct nursing home � 4. LOCATION • So. side of Marshall bet. Western � Arundel• 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION � See attached 6. PRESENT ZONING . "�" Residence 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter; 60.15 Section: Paragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 5/8/68 By; GMK A. ZONING ADMINISTRATOR: No action B. HISTORY: None for the site - Liberty Plaza north. C. PROPOSED USE: Construct 150 bed nursing home, four stories high. D. NEED FOR APPEAL: Section 60.15 requires public hearing for �sta.blishment of � nursing home in "C" Residence district. � E. AREA ZONIrIG: North, south and west is "C" Residence, east fronting on Western Avenue is zone�l Commercial F. SITE CONDITION: Site is occupied by a single-family residence, a duplex and an 11 unit building. It is level and approximately 2' above street �grade. � G. AREA CONDITIONS: This is in the Summit-Univsrsity renewal area. The sidewalks , are in ponr condition. The residences are deteriorating or dilapidated. H. FRONTAGE AND AREA: 215.6 along t4arshall Avenu� with an area of approximately ' 38,232 square feet. �eneraj I.. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: Recommends the�,area for residential with densities allowed I� under R-6, R-7, � R-8 classification. I J. RENE6dAL PROJECT: This site is located within the Summit-University R�newal Project. � A letter was sent to ths Director of the Housing Authority for his rsview on I May .8, 1968. Th� Director of the Summit-University Rsnewa�l Project, Mr. David � Cooper, in a May 14, 1968 conversation has stated that thp uss fits in with the � land use character of the area as anticipated. Hs also noted the ,importance of the future visual character of propsrties along Marshall Avenue and suggssted that the visual amenity of the nursing home would be much greater if the parking lot would be locatsd to the rsar of the structure. � 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend Ox Approval � Denial Council Lt. ! � � Dated � Moved by: Gadler Yeas Nays ; � Ames ; x ' Seconded by: Maietta " Cohen ' Date of Hearing �� - Janes,Chmn. � � McPartlin Council Action Secretary's remarks: X Haarstick - Alt, • Subject to proper landscaping x Gadler Date ; x Maietta Gauger ' LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET ,� ' I -' , l I f :. +� C� R �oI� L v° U I I_\ �+�,••r'��' `��`�''+t• �l�`;`�''tJ�rl ��:I,•'��, 1,'f•Z�•�` , • . • � � _ ..�.o o.'�lf�L.-a: ! ` ( l I �� I�'r� ." ��,�' � � � ; � _1�.�__�� -[_I�_�; � ! �' �� O O w � . -T,---�._, -.-I-��—E I . , -T---- 1 O . �� r--p--r � � .. ` � � � �-�. . --�-!.-.�_.. - --- r . . � i� . , � � I : �',-,�C,', �, ,1_'L��S'DL��C�� I ,� � �� C~ 1 �� ' `� ' '� ��" ��.�'�� j��5;�;;�:��; c> � � � . 5'��E . 1 . � 1GL.��l�AY �RRV � ,� ' �3 .. �2 0 a� i � �- � . � , :) ; 1 '. ► � � � , � , - t�1 � � .• ,. � – j ' �r�j�' � �C' S,iv�G'c�:�tC� 15�' � " • � �-�• ; � ` �� < <� ; , �� -,� � � � .• . �; +� ---�; ... ; :.�:_ '� I � � i � � %�� t � �z � �.� ; �"' � }—' `r ! � -.- .�._..:�_..��. � ( i � � I� ( �z � �. � � i ! a, ' , i ' ' I '--�---- -""' � t O _ '�� a � �----1 �.� f ' t '�"' '_ " — r ,� � . r j �- � � I � 4 G — — —. .a� 1 , � � �+ � �.. � � �I-�;i(J;.�'��;�•�!l i,�l^, �,ft (1� � . �O •��. •• J g�5.q. � '� i Ps ,,7 / � ,I 7 I ! � �: �, .��t o��,+ r- I`r ,5 O ��'A. . I :�L � I ; .. � � � � � : •��$�A L'b._ ._--_'1�V�• -----__________ � � ;8 �' � ► � � � � �, f � j��;-'��} �� 5�, , ; 'u ;� -�-� t , � — _ �� ST.� ✓O��f?�/S� -- �� i �'`.� ' '�� - --- -� • ;; �_ �I 20 `121� �C ✓� y • ��^ ' � AD , L � � :� � � � � � Y,� �i4� -� � 1 -� � I � � �'-�� '_ �r�— � � i � C� I a�.s�wa. �4�1�' I i << � �-._r�J -1{�. ' � ' I y t � I �-�-� -;.'--r--~- � '`' - -- ��-•L��-N_i �_1 ' � L � j'� i --�� - ��1:`�rr;y+��i•3'---_r-"`�"� --� ► ' i I -'-L' ' +� 6 1 � � �� -I I �' � � ! . _ - � �;�� N � i � . r T i ��'�1� � i � � I �; (3�;�F j ✓; ►�'!";�,;,-�'� j - � ��, ,� r I 7 ` .'�.�; � �� ; i �L1� ! �-. ; :.,'C i ``i i i � r� � � � - - l-�„I- J��Cj' m r � j ►`� � ► �� ; �.;,_�i \_f� �� r � `�I � t�. � �J � N ��.� �l�. �-6--� �; ! 1 n ,7 I �0 i CI.r i O��j. �.J'�. � I � --r---�� j� . �`i � " �� ' � f � I 5 9 �� 1 � a r~�,,l�r--'�;_1 '"`� �. ' _��'�L �`:, cDi � � 5 +�I i2 32. �' ' _. 1 � , `, �� ;,•jv ; � y'9-� � za � � i --�-=—.0_ , ,,.. _.. .,.� • • , .;�_ �� 1 �! �l._� ; 1 � ��I �� +�- �� 6 ��I 5 �0(�`�i `r•.,+�"~ �r��'1 •�\�� ---1_' -�-�.-�._-�.r� i i I � �v� i � ;� :a ` �-= I � � . ,5��. �NlL: ��.\•I , r � � � ' �a`/` r I� � � � , I t'– --t t rJ� � I.� � ,� ` ' j�,� 1 i�`°-,�. �� ,,_.(, '`�R i(` i ' I� �-� r � � . x ��I G�� j•-' . � � � - _� �� I �1 i � I:;��I �--j--i l ;L, '� - �. ��`jr s- ( i;� � I �A �8 � �}�� .'�"t'(�}..�0 � I I I f J � � ' z-oi r��-� ^`�,_�.1, r .., !� }�y�- �- i 1 1 � �O. �. � � "'��w . ►� 5 � � o -�r� � F� ; , � �, � ;; �;r � ��,,1 ; ,�. . � 7 � �J -_..._ ,G . G _ � I � l...� ;�� : :a O � '"�f O � F� .n�� $` � � I '--I-� � �'�4 . �'�Q ��) � . - f��b�� v � i '� ti..:<��,� 7'; Cj•,•� ��.`„ t , j ?�,! y �•i�~:_�I i n,:" ^,..�.-.��, � �V�:rD � �O J� � '� , j � .L.,. � , �,;�;�,�.v; •�� .•,�. � ,� ,.�:-�--�---�-.--- t�. ��;,G11�b ._� , , . .. .,� . . � _� , � � � I °. - Y�'� I ��` .- ��:�:,�za `I _ i"'��i '� �'��i� R F W; . =�-, , , ! ,! il n; _ \ . \ .. \ ,, �` ' �� i � � t r�R.'ri�:; '1 .� li�cai , ( _`� �- � �Pi�L l C��lT ARCHIE GIVENS , L��1 V D 4 . ' • , 1rU1�1-�J� Permission to construct a ,Tursing Home ��1tV� VS� � . � ' � ' � O ON�-�A':�lLY f P1?�Si�..1�17 ZO(VI�1G �� Residence . -d- Tti�JO-f-�1tiiILY ► " �� TMR�E-F�1PJiILY P�1°ITIOiV S1G�1�RS , . . - � FOU�- F�11�lLY � - � . . � � ,MUL�"I-rp.,�V11LY . o � nC0��1�j1�F;ClAL FILE No. NORTH , � n INDUS"�'�IAL � 6soi � - v � V�1C�1N� � _ . _ . , Sfi. Paul Pl�nninc� Bocrd, DatQ: . May� 7, 1968 �:.'�!-�� Fro�erfiy under co�si�ar��ia� _ _ . . i . -- • M14i�y , - s - • .. " - -" �(/ ' ' • !y - , _4a ,, , - l - � . _ " . •. " . . '- T c i - ` y , , ��." ' • . ' • , . — - ` - . . = , • • . _' ' - � � ' = ' •��; _ ` . ` �. - � ..' ' . _ •e • ` • • ` Y ... " - , • I � �� - " . - � , �- . , �- �° .� __ � _ - ' � - � . " � �pril�9, 1968 �� - � ` : -- ' - " � � � - - .� - . _ � � �� . ,_ - ._ _ � Honorable Mayor_and City Council : _ ._ . " � - . , � - ° - - � � � _ � � _ . City of St. Paul � ' _ - . - . � - '. - ° : • . ' c% City,�Clerk• . - � � � ., r , . � _ _. , � - - . . - Room 386, City-Ha1l-and Court House - _ - _ � � � - - • � ' - -. ' ° St.' Paul, Minnesota� . _ . , � _� _ . � ; _: � � ' - - - � -. . , . - _ _ � ' � _ � � . _ � ,- . `�entiemen: � " - , - - _ - . - -� � � ' - - . . � " . � _ The following is "an app]3cation=�or Zoning Appeal for the Constru.ction- _. � • . of �a- 150-Bed Nursing Home, l�08-l122 Marsha7l Avenne, St. Pa�J.,. Minrie- '-_ - � - .. ' - sota: ` - , - =, _ :_ - _ - - - , _.. . � .. _ . . • � . - - . - - ' �• � . ; . � � _ - - �� Name of Applicant: . .- -� ` - _ . '. . � . .r= " ' � � - . . - _.. - Archie Givens � _ . - . , � -- . _ . : , - � - . _� � ` . � . - - 6130 Lyndale Averiue Sonth` , - . . � _ . ' . � . - _ � �• Minneapolis; Minnesota �� - � ' - - •- _ _" ._` _ .. ' .. Telephone: 866-3095 � , ' � � - � ` . - � � � - - � � ' Le a1 Descri tions: - . - � " ' •,', , ' � - � - - � � . � � 0 Marshall Avenue: _ ._ -, ' � • � . .- ` � ' - :_ ' � � --- - West 1�0 feet of �ot 3, Kerns Addition� and West - - - `. - � _ � � 1�0 feet of East 350 feet of North 265�feet of the . � ..` . - - ' - • `. - � Northwest -quarter of Section 1; Towrish3p 28, Range .� � � �._ - - � . � . � � 23; except the North 33 �feet for Marshall Avenue. -_ , . . - •r.1�.7-8 Maxshall Avenue: . - . � - � . . ° J�ots 1� and 5, �lock 1, Rerns 9ddition�. � . - '. � - , - .t _ l�22 Marshall Avenue:- ' � - - - - _ _ ' . � � - - . . . - .I,ots.._6 and� 7;" and East 17.�feet of I�ots 8 and 11, - -- , � ' � • .' - z - �Block l; Kerns Additi;on._ � - � ' � � _ _ _, . _ . : . , . _ . • �- . - - -Location: _ _ - - ' ' ' - - - � _ _ � - - � - _ Sou�h side of Marshall Avenue between Western and Arundel. � ' . _ - - _ � Present Use of Pro ,ert : �� - ` � � � - - . . � . . - - . Res den ' - �. , _ � _ - - � _ , - . - _ , ,_ . . . . - _ _�: . - � , ' '�� . - - . _ - . � - � - ' P"roposed IIse of Propertys� t ` : ' _- � . ' . .. ; ' � - Nursing, Home :• - . _ - - ` - - - _ - " � � Legislative Codes: ` .-° �' ,- ; �"� - ' - -- ' - � - � 't - . . � , - _Ch�ter 70, Section'15 _' , < < ; "�� -�';, a ' - - _ . . '. , ___ .. ' - Vexy truly yours, - ' - . � • tw � ' = � ` - _ �`�� - � . - - - - � ° _ � .� . - �� — - — .- � � - " . - - . _ Archie Givens- - , . - _ .. • � . . _ . _ i ,i _ _ - � - -,� - -'� , � - . . _. _ s- _ . , ..._ ' � � - . - � -- . ' .* �--x_,� - � -- i�,�'(�'s?""' � - . -. - - .� - _ - . , - -� , Will J. e er, Jr. - � - � � � : � • ' �- - - , . , - " , , . , . - - � , _ �� - ,� ' - _} - � ; _. _ ; -i , ' . . _ � � � - . _ �`rk,r'�� a -*.,.�»�� . _ -- , , _ . .. _ . - . � _ . . .. . - - - • ,,.:` , ' .,�, � � r= • CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 May 24, 1968 � City Clerk File XS1Z, Page I You are hereby notified that a public hearin� will be held in the Council ChamUers of the City Hall and Court House in the City ot I St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. , on June 6, 1968, on the appeal of Archie Givens for permission to construct a nursin� home on the following property: Lots 4, 5, 6 and 7 and the east 17 feet of Lots 8 and 11, Block 1, Kern's Addition and the west 40 feet of the east 350 feet of the north lu5 feet of the northwest 1/4 af Section 1, Township 28, . North, Range 23 West, except the north 33 feet for Marshall Avenue4 The property is located on the souCh side of Marshall Avenue between Western Avenue and Arundel Street. � For further information contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Co�erce Buildin; or phone 223-4151. JAMES J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance � I , �O I I � ` 1 i � � � �: -r -. � I iZ � � �'� CITY OF SAINT PAUL I MINNESOTA i DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 , May 3, 1968 City Clerk i I File X511, Page � . . I You are hereby notified that the Board of Zoning will hold a public hearing in Room 356 of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 2:00 P. M. on May 16, 1968, on the appeal. of Archie Givens for permission to construct a nursing home on the folZowing proner ty: ; LoCs 4, 5, 6 and 7 and the east 17 feet of Lots 8 and 11, Block 1, •�,Kern's Addition. The west 40 feet of Lot 3, Block 1, Kern's Addition � and the west 40 feet of the east 350 feet of the north 165 feet of the northwest 1/4 of Section 1, Township 28 north, Range 23 west, I except the north 33 feet for Marshall Avenue. The property is locate3 on the south side of Marshall Avenue between Western Avenue and Arundel Street. For £urther information contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Co�erce Building or phone 223-4151. JAMES J. DALGLISH Coixanissioner of Finance � �O i [ .., . ; r i± ' � � � 239�� ✓ � . � � � BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL ; f 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151' k � { June 5, 1968 � � � ` � Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk ' � �' Room 386 � Dear Sir: � This is in reference to the appeal of Mr. Archie Givens for permission to construct a nursing home on the south side of Marshall Avenue between Western Avenue and Arundel Street. (See attached legal descripfi.on:) This matter was considered �g the Board of Zoning at a public hearing held on May 16, 1968. �The staff reported that the appelant proposed to eonstruct' a 150-bed nursing home whieh will be four ,(4) stories in height. Section 60.15 of the Zoning Code requires a public 'hearing for establishment of a nursing home in a "C"• Residence district. Existing area zoning consists of primarily "C" Residence with Commercial zoning on the Western and Selby Avenue frontages. The site in question is within the Summit-University Renewal Project. The Comprehensive Plan recommends the area for residential � uses of inedium and high density nature. . It was the findings of the Board that a nursing home as proposed would be compatible with multiple family uses as proposed in the Comprehensive � Plan. The Director of the Summit-University Renewal Projeet has stated that ! the use fits in with the land use character of the area as anticipated. ', Therefore, the Board of Zoning recommends approval of the application to establish a nursing home provided that special attention be paid to the � �.r1tE5.1� landscape design treatment on the Marshall Avenue frontage of the property. , Very truly yours, �� Gz-�G�� George G. McPartl�� Secretary � • GGM:cv GMK i Z.F. #6501 Attachment � � � � _� � � � � ,. . - . . , , , � , 4 - � � ' � � � Q � �.-•_ , . a _ �:.... ,.._ . _ ' ' . . _ - • --:L , ; 4�.1 WaUasha Streei, Saint Paul, PJlinnesota 551 02. Edward N.Helfeld,executive direcior. pf�one 223 52 i8 , , ; , . . , ' c � � � I-lOUSING AND REDEUELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA The Honorable Mayor Thomas Byrne and City Council June 5, 1968 1715 City Hall and Court House Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 • " • � Re: File X 511, Pages 8, 9, and 10 Appeal of Archie Gi.ver_s for permission to construct a nursing hane Gentlemen: Regarding said application, the staff of the Saint Paul Housing and Redevelopment Auth- ority is unopposed to the proposed use, and wishes to encourage a11 efforts which wil� assist in establishing a beneficial environment within the Summit-Univer�ity area. A nursing home is compatible e�ith and has a desirable relationship to existing and future developmen� of the immediate nezghborhood. • However, the Authority is concerned regarding the location of parking in the fron� yard along Marshall Avenue. The parking areas for this facility would be better located ae the rear of the property. Yot�rs truly, . � ��ti�f�9 d� �� .,, :�,:.�w�.�� . E� Edward N. Helfeld , Executive Director . �'}� '1,s,.t.��` l�s�_� , . .P...,....--^"'"�-, """°_'_'_` ..�..�--�"°",.. Lawrence J Hayes, Harry P. Strong, Jr., Orvil{e � Anderson, Herry R. Tfiomas, Kennetn ,;. Lynch, James J. D�Igiis{�, Victor J. Tedescu • Ch,aiimx.n �3 � • r' - '