The URL can be used to link to this page

04-583Council File # �Y—��3 Resolution # 3017575 Green Sheet # RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 1 2 3 4 5 6 Presented By Committee: Date 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 Referred To WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes §462.357 and §64.400 of the Legislative Code, R& N Corporation (Saxon Ford) duly petitioned to rezone 250 & 262 Sherbume Ave. being legally described as PIN 36-29-23-14-0110, 36-29023-13-0216, Robertson & Van Etten Addition to St. Paul ex S 8 Ft for Alley Lot 12 Blk 28, Robertson & Van Etten Addition to St. Paul ex S 20 Ft; Lot 1 Blk 2 Chambers Addition & in Sd Robertson & Van Etten Addition Lots 9& Lot 10 Blk 28 from RT-1 Two-family Residential to B-3 General Business to expand the existing business and add parking, the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on February 27, 2004, as having been consented to by at least 67 percent of the owners of the area to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 400 feet of the total contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on April 1, 2004, for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to §107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Pianning Commission for approval; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting heid on April 9, 2004, and recommended approval to the City Council; and WHEREAS, notice of public hearing before the City Council on said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on April 29, 2004, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and Requested by Department of: PlanIlin & �� onomiC Develo meRt !i By: Approved by Financial S ices By: AdoptioII CeT By Approved by By: Form Approved by City Attorney �vl��.m� s _ 28_ o � Mayor for Submission to Council D�-��T.3 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 WHEREAS, a public hearing before the City Council having been conducted on May 26, 2004, at which all interested parties were given an opportunity to be heard, the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations conceming the petition, voted to deny the rezoning for the following reasons: 1. The proposed rezoning to B-3 is in conflict with the District 7 Plan policy that supports only P-1 zoning on the south side of Sherbume, 2. The proposed business zoning does not fit in with the character of the neighborhood, and 3. Future land use problems are likely to result if the use changes from storage/parking of vehicles and/or this property is sold separately from the rest of the Saxon Ford property. The B-3 district allows uses that frequently generate a great deal of traffic, which would be harmful to the residential character of the neighborhood; therefore, the Saint Paul City Council does hereby RESOLVE, that the petition of R& N Corporation to rezone property legaliy described as Robertson & Van Etten Addition to St. Paul ex S 8 Ft for Alley Lot 12 Blk 28, Robertson & Van Etten Addition to St. Paul, ex S 20 Ft; Lot 1 Blk 2 Chambers Addition & in Sd Robertson & Van Etten Addition Lots 9& Lot 10 Bik 28, commonly known as 250 & 262 Sherburne Ave., from RT-1 Two-family Residential to B-3 General Business is hereby denied. � Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet � �� SQ'� Deparhne'rtloffice/wuncil: Date Initiated: � - --- ! PE -P�� 2�_�,Y-� Green Sheet NO: 3017575 Confact Person 8 Phone• Deoartment SeM To Person Initial/Date � PahiciaJarties � 0 lannin Econo icDevlo �Z'�OQ 6-6639 � A55ign 1 IanninE �c000mic Develo� Department DirecMr _� t{ Must Be on Council Agenda by (Date): Number 2 1 Attorne 02JUSd-04 For Routing 3 or•s ffice Ma odAssistaot � OrdeY 4 ouncil 5 'tv Clerk Ctitv Clerk Total # of Signature Pages �_ (Clip All Locations for Signature) Action Requested: Approve resolution memorializiug City Council ac6on to deny rezoning from RT-1 Two-family Residenrial to B-3 General Business to elcpand e�sting business and add pazking. Public hearing held Mayb 2004. RESOLI7'I'ION MI7ST BE ADOPT'ED AT 1VEXT CITY COUNCIL MEETING OR THE REZONING IS APPROVED. � Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personai Service Contracts Must Answer the Following Questions: Planning Commission 1. Has this person/firtn ever worked under a contract for this department? CIB Committee Yes No Civil Service Commission 2. Has this person/firtn ever been a city employee? Yes No 3. Does this personffirtn passess a skill not normally possessed by any I current city employee? I Yes No Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why): R& N Corporarion peritioned to rezone 250 & 262 Sherburne Ave. to expand their auto sales business (Sazcon Ford). Advantanes If Approvetl: � City Council intent to deny is fmalized. Disaiivantapes If Approved: None Disadvantages If Not Approved: � City Commcil action will be overtnrned and rezoning wiil be approved. �' � � �'�k�� 4 �� Total Amount of Transaction: CwNRevenue Budgeted: „�, �, Fundinst Source: Activiry Number: � � ; ��"� � �� Financial Infortnation: (Explain) DEPARTMENT OF PLANNaVG & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Manha G. Fuller, Director CITY OF SAINT PAUL Randy C Kel[y, Mayor May 4, 2004 Ms. Mary Erickson City Council Research Office Room 310 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Ms. Erickson: 25 West FouKh Street Saini Pnul, MN55702 � D�-583 Telephone: 657-266-6700 Facsimile: 651-228-3220 I would like to confirm that a public hearing before the City Council is scheduled for Wednesday, May 26, 2004 for the following zoning case. Zoning File Number: Applicant: Address: Purpose: Previous Action: 04-045-912 R & N Corporation (Saxon Ford) 250 & 262 Sherburne Ave., beiween Farrington and Galtier Rezoning from RT-1 Two-family Residential to B-3 General Business to expand existing business and add parking Zoning Committee Recommendation: Approval, 6- 0 Planning Commission Recommendation: Approval, unanimous, April 9, 2004 I have confirmed this day with Councifinember Montgomery's office. My understanding is that this public hearing request will appear on the agenda for the May 19, 2004 City Council meeting and that you will publish notice of the hearing in the Saint Paul Legal Ledger. Please call me at 266-6639 if you have any questions. �� ' -� � Patricia James City Planner cc: File #: 04-048-912 Applicant: R& N Corporation (Saxon Ford) Jim Saxon Paul Dubruiel Wendy Lane Carol Martineau Allan Torstenson NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING The Saiat Paul City Gouncil will� con- duct a publie hearing on wedne.sday, May 26, 2004, at 5:30 p.m. in the City Cuoncil Chambers, Tlvrd FRoor, City Hall to coa- sider the applicationofR & N Coiporation (Saxon Ford) to resone property at 250 & 262 Avenue, tie£ween Farrington and Galtier, from RT-1 (1\vo-Family Residential) to B-3 (General Business) to eapand the exiating business and add parldng. CChe public hearing was rescheduled from May 5). Dated:May 6, 2004 � - MARY ERICKSON. Assistant City Council Secretary �- (May 10) —_—= S'1: PAilf. LBGAI. rr.nr_cx =�_ 22080938 - . LWnanda�Zoning\CCdocs\0A-OA8-912ma}2604ccm.wpd AA-ADA-EEOEmployer DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MaKha G. Futter, Director � �� Z�/-5'�'3 CITY OF SAINT PAUL Rartdy G Ke11y, Mayor Apri123, 2004 Ms. Mary Erickson City Council Reseazch Office Room 310 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Zoning File #: 04-048-912 Applicant: R & N Corporation (Sason �ord) Address: 250 & 262 Sherbume Ave., between Farrington and Galtier Purpose: Rezoning from RT-1 Two-family Residenfial to B-3 General Business to expand elcisting business and add pazldng � City Council Aearing: May 5, 2004, 530 p.m., City Council Chambers Staff Recommendation: Dishict Council: 25 GGest Fourth SYreet Telephone: 65I-266-6700 SaintPauZ,MN55702 P¢camrZe:6i1-228-322Q Approval Denial Zoning Committee Recommendation: Approval, vote: 6- 0 Support: 0 people sgoke, 1 letter was received Opposirion: 1 person spoke, O letters were received Planning Commission Recommendation: Approval vote: unanimous Staff Assigned: Patricia James, 266-6639 Attachments: Planning Commission resolution Planning Commission minutes, Apri19, 2004 Zoning Committee minutes, April 1, 2004 Correspondence received Staff Report packet cc: Applicant: R& N Corporation (Saxon Ford) City Council Membezs District Council: 7 Wendy Lane Larry Soderholm Allan Torstenson Peter Wamer • AA-ADA-EEO Employer �y-58 3 city of saint paul � planning commission resolution file number 04-32 date April 9 , Zoo4 WHEREAS, R& N Corporation (Saxon Ford), File #04-048-912, has applied for a rezoning from RT-1 Two-family Residential to B-3 General Business to expand an ewsting husi�ess and add parking under the provisions of §60.560 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, on property located at 250 & 262 Sherburne Ave., Parcel Identification Number (PIN) 36-29-23-14-0110, 36-29023-13-0216, legally described as Robertson & Van Etten Addition to St. Paul ex S 8 Ft for Alley Lot 12 Blk 28, Robertson & Van Eiten Addition to St. Paul ex S 20 Ft; Lot 1 Blk 2 Chambers Addition & in Sd Robertson & Van Etten Addition Lots 9& Lot 10 Blk 28; and WHEREAS, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission, on April 1, 2004, held a public hearing at which all persons present were given an opportunity to be heard pursuant to said application in accordance with the requirements of §64.300 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Planning Commission, based on the evidence presented to its Zoning Committee at the public hearing as substantially reflected in the minutes, made the fol lowing findings offar.t• -- _---- ------- 1. The applicant owns Ron Saxon Ford, a large auto dealership on University Avenue. The applicant � wishes to expand the business to the west along Sherburne, using these lots for parking of employee cars and/or vehicles for sale. If the rezoning is approved, they will need to meet futther zoning code requirements through site plan review and, depending on the future use of the property, a conditional use permit. 2. The south side of Sherburne has been a transition zone for a number of years, with many businesses along University Avenue expanding north, mainly to provide additiona] off-street parking. 7his expansion is consistent with how the area has developed recent!y. 3. The property can be developed in a way that will not have an adverse impact on the surroundirtg area through the site plan review process that will require buffering of the use from adjacent residential uses. 4. The current RT-1 zoning permits low density residential uses. Given the increasing commercial uses on University Avenue, single family and duplex development is not as reasonable a use as the parking/outdoor auto sales uses proposed by the applicant. 5. Comprehensive Plan policies support business development and continued investment in the University Avenue Corridor (GP16). They also support making land that has business potential availabte for deve{opment. The District 7 Plan (adopted in 1979) states that the District Council moved by Field seconded by in favor Unanimous � against 0 � 583 Zoning File # 04-048-912 Planning Commission Resolution page 2 wiil consider rezonings on the south side of Sherburne on a case by case basis, but supports only rezonings to P-1. In this case, the applicant wishes to have the flexibility to use the lots for parking andlor oufdoor sales area. The P-1 zoning district oniy permits accessory off-street parking of private passenger vehicles. For this reason, the applicant is requesting B-3 zoning. The proposed use is generally consistent with the parking use supported by the bistrict 7 Plan, but could not be restricted oniy to off-street employee or customer parking. 6. if the properfy is rezoned to B-3, a variety of commercial uses potentiaily could be located on these lots. However, given the lack of visibility from University Avenue, the main thoroughfare, it is unlikely that separate commercial development would occur here. 7. The consent petition was determined to be sufficient on February 27, 2004. Parcels eligible; 39; parcels required: 26; parcels signed: 26. NOW, i FiERCt=OhE, BE IT hESOLVtt�, that the Saint Paul Pianning Commission, recommends to City Council, that the application of R& N Corporation (Saxon Ford) for a rezoning from RT-1 Two- family Residential to B-3 General Business fo expand an existing business and add parking for property at 250 & 262 Sherburne Ave. be approved. C� u � � J � • Saint Paul Planning Commission City Hall Conference Center 15 Kellogg Boulevard West Minutes of April 9, 2004 d5�-583 A meeting of the Planning Commission of the City of Saint Paul was held Friday, Apri19, 2004, at 830 a.m. in the Conference Center of Cify Hall. Commissioners Mmes. Donnelly-Cohen, Faricy, Zimmer Lonetti, McCall, Morton, Shortridge, Present: and Trevino; and Messrs. Alexander, Coletta, Field, Fotsch, Gordon, 7ohnson, Kong, Kramer, Mazdeli, Mejia, and Scott. Commissioners Messrs. *Alton, *Anfang, and *Dandrea. Absent: , *Excused � � Also Present: Larry Soderholm, Planning Administrator; Allan Torstenson, Allen Lovejoy, Nancy Homans, Joel Spoonheim, Patricia 7ames, Casey MacCallum (Intem), and Mary Bruton, Depaztment of Planning and Economic Development staff. I. Approval of �utes of March 26, 2004 � � MOTION: Coritmissioner Field moved approval of the minutes of March 26, 2004. Commissioner ponnelly-Cohen seconded the molion. The rrcotion carried unanimously on a voice vote. Chair's Announcements Chair Johnson stated he received correspondence from the Ciry Council concerning the River Corridor Zoning Task Force and said he is looldng for a Planning Commissioner to volunteei to be on that task force. He reminded ihe Commissioners about the Millard Fillmore dinner on May 13, 2004. The deadline for reservations is May 23�., Plauning Admivish•ator's Announcements Mr. Lany Soderholm reported on Ciry Council business. City Council business on 4/7(04: - Adoprion of the new TN Zones and Reformatted Zoning Code on a vote of 7-0. Mr. Soderholm and Chair Johnson congratulated Mr. Allan Torstenson on his hard work over the last couple of years to rewrite the Zoning Code. - Received the lawsuit by the Summit Avenue Residential Preservation Association (SARPA) alleging that the City's was wrong in deciding that the University of St. Thomas EAVJ was / 0`� Comnvssioner Field stated District 8 recommends approval. No one spoke in supgort. No one • spoke in opposition; i letter was received in opposition. The public heazing was closed. The Zoning Committee recommended approval with conditions on a vote of 6-�. � M01TON: Commissioner Field moved the Zoning Committee's recommendation to approve the enlargement of nonconforncing use and height variance. The motion carried unanimously on ¢ voice vote. #04-047-129 Mazlin Brober - Rezoning from RM-2 Multi-family Residenfial to I-1 Indusuial to provide off-street pazldng and storage of equipment and supplies. 337 Atwater St., between Farrington & Western. (Allen Lovejoy, 65I/266-6576) Commissioner Field stated that District 6 racommends approval. No one spoke in support, 1 letter was received. No one spoke in opposition. The public heazing was closed. The Zoning Committee recommended approval on a vote of 5-0. M01TON: Commissioner Field moved the Zoning Committee's recommenda[ion to approve the rezonirzg. The rrzotion carried unanimously on a voice vote. NEW BUSIlVESS � #04048-9121Z & N Comoration (Sason Ford) - Rezoning from RT-1 Two-family Residential to B 3 General Business to expand er>isting business and add pazldng. 250 & 262 Sherburne Ave., between Farrington and Gaiter. (Patricia J¢mes, 65I/266-6639), � Commissioner Field stated District 7 recommeads denial. No one spoke in support; 1 letter was received. One party spoke in opposition. The Zonina Committee recommended approval on a vote of 6-0. M01TON: Com�nissioner Field moved the Zoning Committee's recommendaiion to approve the rezoning. The motion carried unanimously on a voice vote. #Q4-032-410 Alfred & Hoyoko Yahanda - Rezoning from RM-i Multiple-faznily Residential to B-2 Community Business. 1435 Cleveland Ave. N., SW corner at Buford. (Patricia James, 65I/266-6639) Commissioner Field stated District 12 recommends denial. No one spoke in support. No one spoke in opposition; 2 letters were received. The public hearing was closed. The Zoning Committee recommended approvaI on a vote of 42 (Morton, Alton). MOTTON: Commissioner Field moved the Zoning Committee's recommeralation to approve the reZOning. Conunissioner Morton stated she voted in opposition to this because she fliinks it is spot zoning. She said this one strip will be B-2 and there isn't any othez B-2 in that azea. r � L_J �� • � Recorded and prepazed by Mary Bruton, Planning Commission Secretary Planning and Economic Development Department, City of Saint Pau1 Respectfully submitted, I��g" Larry S rholm Planuing Administrator PED�Bruton�Minutes�Apri19, 2004 O�- 583 Approved �^ �� i /�� v�` � (Date) � ��! " Sue M 1 Secretary of the Planning Commission � �, 583 MiNUTES OF THE ZONWG COMMITTEE Thursday, April 1, 2004 - 3:30 p.m. • City Council Chambers, 3rd Fioor City Hail and Court House 15 West Kelfogg Soulevard PRESENT: ABSENT: STAFF: ALSO PRESENT: Alton, Faricy, Field, Kramer, Mejia, and Morton Anfang and Gordon Pafricia James, Mary Bruton, Allen Torstenson and Peter Wamer Commissioner Johnson The meeting was chaired by Commissioner Fiefd. Affred & Hoyoko Yahanda - 04-052-410 - Rezoning from RM-1 Multiple-family 4tesidential to S-2 Community Business. 1435 Cleveland Ave. N., SW corner at Buford. Patricra James presented the staff report with a recommendation of approval for the Rezoning. Ms. James stated District 12 recommends denial. Commissioner Morton questioned whether this was spot zoning and Ms. James said it is a recommendation of the adopted District 12 Plan, which is part of the Comprehensive Plan. If a rezoning is in conformance with the Comprehensive Plan, it is not spot zoning. City Attorney Peter Warner stated that give that the District �an calls for B-2, it is consistent with zoning principles and is not spot zoning. Commissioner Kramer asked why the nonconforming use permit won't work, as suggested in letters received. Uls. James stated it was not what the applicant applied for. She afso explained that some of the uses the appiicant wants to put into the building would not be permitted with a nonconforming use permit. Mahmoud Shahin, is the appficant and purchaser of the building at 1435 Cleveland Ave. N. Mr. Shahin stated that Mr. Yahanda sold the property to him o� a contract for deed. He said there are so many names on the petition pages he submitted because the names are people who frequent Lori's Coffee Shop, a business he owns that is in the building. He said the petition pages show there is a need for a restaurant. Mr. Shahin stated he would have to apply for 5 nonconforming use permits for what he wants to do to improve the bui(ding and move uses around. He has already spent $120,000 in repairs and is planning on spending another $80,000 to give it a face lift. it should be zoned for what it is. No one spoke in support or opposition. The public hearing was closed. Commissioner Kramer moved approvaf of the Rezoning. Commissioner Faricy seconded the motion. Adopted Yeas - 4 Nays - 2(Mo�ton, Alton) Drafted by: Caroi Marti au (Mary Bruton) Recording Secretary Submitted by: Approved by: Patricia James Litton Fi Zoning Section Chair 04�- 583 ZONWG COMMITTEE STAFF REPORT � FILE # 04-048-912 1. APPLICANT: R& N Corporation (Saxon Ford) HEARING DATE: April 1, 2004 2. TYPE OF APPLICATION: Rezoning 3. LOCATION: 250 & 262 Sherbume Ave., between Farrington and Galtier 4. PIN 8� LEGAL DESCRIPTION: 36-29-23-14-0110, 36-29-23-13-0216; Robertson & Van Etten Addition to St. Paul ex S 8 Ft for Alley Lot 12 Blk 28; Robertson & Van Etten Addition to St. Paul ex S 20 Ft Lot 1 Btk 2 Chambers Addition & in Sd IZobertson & Van Etten Addition Lots 9& lot 10 Blk 28 5. PLA{dNING DISTRICT: 7 6. ZONING CODE REFERENCE: §60.560; §64.400(b) 7. STAFF REPORT DATE: March 25, 2004 EXISTING ZONiNG: RT-1 BY: Patricia James 8. DATE RECEIVED: Fehruary 27, 2004 DEADLINE FOR ACTION: Apri( 27, 2004 A. PURPOSE: Rezoning from F2T-1 Two-family 42esidential to B-3 Genera! Business to expand existing business and add parking. B. PAi2CEi. SiZE: 250 Sherburne: 50 ft. (Sherburne) x 100 ft. (Galtier) = 5000 sq. ft. 262 Sherburne: 130 ft. (Sherburne) x 107 ft. = 15,036 sq. ft. Total area: 20,306 sq. ft. C. EXISTING LAND USE: vacant D. SURROUNDING LAND USE: Commercial uses (B-3) are found south and east of the lots. 70 the nort4� and west is a m+xed density residential neighborhood (RT-1). A fegal nonconforming 4- � plex is located between the two parcels. E. ZONING CODE CiTAT10N: §60.560 lists uses permitted in the 8-3 zoning district; §64.400(b) provides for changes to the zoning of property initiated by the property owner. • F. HISTORY/DISCUSSION: Demolition permits were issued for these lots in 1995. G. DISTRICT COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION: District 7 had not commented at the time this staff report was written. H. FINDINGS: 1. The applicant owns Ron Saxon Ford, a large auto dealership on University Avenue. The appiicant wishes to expand the business to the west along Sherburne, using these lots for parking of employee cars and/or vehicles for sale. If the rezoning is approved, they will need to meet further zoning code requirements through site plan review and, depending on the future use of the property, a conditional use permit. 2. The south side of Sherburne has been a transition zone for a number of years, with many businesses along University Avenue expanding north, mainly to provide additional off-street parking. This expansion is consistent with how the area has developed recently. 3. The property can be developed in a way that wiil not have an adverse impact on the surrounding area through the site plan review process that will require bufFering of the use from adjacent residential uses. 4. The current RT-1 zoning permits low density residential uses. Given the increasing commerciai uses on University Ave�ue, single family and duplex development is not as reasonable a use as the parking/outdoor auto sales uses proposed by the aQplicant. 5. Comprehensive Pian policies support business development and continued investment in the University Avenue Corridor (GP16). They also support making tand that has business potential available for development. The District 7 Pian (adopted in 1979) states that the 0 �-583 Zoning File # 04-048-912 Zoning Committee Staff Report � page 2 District Councii wili consider rezonings on the south side o€ Sherbume on a case by case basis, but supports only rezonings to P-1. In this case, the applicant wishes to have the flexibility to use the lots for parking and/or outdoor sales area. The P-1 zoning district only permits accessory off-street parking of private passenger vehicles. For this reason, the applicant is requesting B-3 zoning. The proposed use is generally consistent with the parking use supported by the District 7 Plan, but could not be restricted only to off-street employee or customer parking. 6. If the properly is rezoned to B-3, a variery of commercial uses potentially could be located on these lots. However, given the lack of visibility from University Avenue, tfie main thoroughfare, it is unlikely that separate commercial development would occur here. 7. The consent petition was defermined to be sufficient on February 27, 2004. Parcels eligible; 39; parcels required: 26; parcels signed: 26. I. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the above findings, staff recommends approval of the rezoning from RT-1 Two-family Residential to B-3 General Business to expand the existing business and add parking. � • PETITION TO AMEND THE 20NING CODE Departrnent of Planning and Economic Dwelopment Zonir�g Section 1400 City Hall Annex 25 West FourUs Sbeet Saint PauG MN SSIO2-1634 (651) 266-6589 APPLICANT Property Owner City r`� , F�2u Contact Person (if I Address / Location PROPERTY LOCATION Legat Descr�tion � (attach additional sheet if 1- .i � Zoning _ R I � � TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL: to of the Saint Paui Zoning Ordinance and to Section 462.357(5) of Minnesota Statues, t�� '�" /U �� r�3 fJ_JN , o of land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions you to ez'F one the above described property from a IZ /� zoning district to a �.3 zoning district, for the purpose of: p� " _� � �� , � � '�.�� J dd�. O� � �Ct �� ►'L� � u�.t rye SS - (attach additional sheeCs if oecessary) AtEachments as required: ❑ Site Plan Subscribed and sworn to before me this �'` � day of ' i��..Q� , 20 D.� . � i�%�'�/ Notary Public � Consent Petition �� e� "S�itIM11PAULSON sy a s - FpGiR7AIF91G-l�Fff�A �--� ��<"°" . �JI�Ei.Jm�.31,2035 �� to �l'��i� � Affidavit ��-� �,-�'°�%�,.. a 6— Fee Owner of Property Title: �• �• Page 1 of _ ��-S 83 o�f-s8� C�TY OF SAINT PAUL CONS'r,�;T OF ADJ�31��'�?� pROPERTY OWNERS FOR A D��n.I�ii� <^ We, the undersio ed, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contio ous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by. THE PEITTIONER cvithin one year preceding the date of this peti[ion acknowledge that we have been presented with the following: I. A copy of the petition of Saxon Ford (name of petitioner) ' to rezone the property located at �5_0 to_ 262 Sherburne Avenue from a RTl zoning district to a B3 zoning district; and 2. A copy of sections 60. 560 through 60.565 inciusive of the Sair.; PaLi Zoning Code. �Je acknowledge that we aze aware of all of the uszs permii:ed in a,_g3 zoning district, and we are aware that any of these uses can be estabiished upott City CounciI approval of the Rezoning. We hereby consent [o the rezoning of the property in the petition of Saxon Ford to a $3 zoning district. (name of petitioaer) • We consent fo the approva] of fhis rezonin; as it �vas explained to us bp the app(icant or • his/her representative. ADDRESS OR PfY RECORD OWNER SIGNANRE pp� 191 Sherbuzne Ave. 3ti-29-23-14-0051 Teresa K. Paxton g�� o�C_ 193 Sherburne Ave. Joseph E. Duchene 36-29-23-14-0050 Lorraine C. Duchene i' _�, 199 Sherburne Ave. 203 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0048 208 Sherburne Ave. 209 Sherburae Ave. 215 Sherburae Ave. 229 Sherburne Ave, 233 Sherbume Ave, 36-29-23-14-0074 235 Sherburne Ave.�`i Gary Emory Johnson 36-29-23-14-0073 � Henrietta C. Johnson Gary A. Roen Jvanna M. Roen Terryl A. Gordon Austin Fang Lou M. Eang Ste11a Whitney West James G. Sampson Karen Sue Sampson Pao Yang Chad Lee Blia Vue %one Lee n �' / �-D.� �� n , � �jt.x.TS,.� Y` � `'�d'�.4�j* M��'7 �-e. � This peticiott shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of seven (7) working days after it is received by the Planning Division. Any signator of this pecicion may withdraw his/hzr name therefrom 6y written reqaest withia th�t time. CITY OF SAINT PAIJL ` • CONSEN'i ��'.ADJC�it:'?'=u^ PROPER�'Y OWNERS FOR-A : �.'� i CXf - 583 - We, the undeisigned, owners of properry within lOd feet of the total contio ous description of real estate owned, purchazed, or sold by. THE PET'ITIONER within one year preceding the date of this petition acknowledge that we have been piesented with the foIlowing: 1. A copy af the petition of Saxon Ford (name of petitioner) to tezone the property located at z50 to 262 -Sherburne Avenue from a RT 1 zoning district to a B3 - zonino district; and 2. A copy of sections 60. 560 �� 60.565 inclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. We acknowledge tha: we aze aware of alt of the uses permitted i� a R3 zonino distcici, and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Councii approva] of the Rezoning. We hereby consent to the rezoning of the property in the peti[ion of . axon Fora to a x� zoning discrict. (name of petitioner) We corisent to the approval of_this rezoning as it was explained to us br• the applicant or � his/her representative. ADDRESS OR PtN • 190 Sherburne Ave. I85 University Ave 145 University Ave. 36-29-23-14-0.127 192 Sherburne Ave. 255 University Ave. 277 University A 36-29-23-13-0215 271 University Ave. 36-29-23-13-0213 259 University Ave. 516 Galtier St. 519 Galtier St. 36-29-23-14-0079 �; F'• c Q 9 �'l Ji 9 .i' 4' c Y�' ; � League of MN City B'ldg. Co., Inc. League of MN Cities Research Foundati League of MN Cities Research Foundation Housing and Redev. ai.c James C. Toner Carol A. Toner Carol A. Toner Hoang D. Pham Vang Neng Yang Shoua Lee Xang S IGNA1URg � � O -� f DA'IE �( 6 � o �� G63 0 � �!lY�a3 a /� �/tyl3 a� A �f � `�� '�G� 2�" [ 1�� 1 ��..� This petition shal! not be considered as officially filed until the ]apse of seven (7) working days after it is received by the Planning Division. Any signator of this petition may withdraw his/her name therefrom by vrri[ten request within that time. , �%s5r� � �- � OK� ay , _. , CITY OF SAI�VT PAUI� CONSEN'� ��.ADJt3i3�.L•�E^ pROPERTY QWN$RS POR A �.?fal�i'v� . ;. We, the undersigned, owners of propetty within 100 feet of the total contio ous description of real estate owned, purchued, or sold by THE PETITIONER within one year preceding the date of this petition acicnowiedge that we have been presented with the foltowing: 1. A copy of the petiflon of Saxon Ford (name of petitioner) to rezone the pcoperty tocated at 250 to- 262 Sherburne Avenue from a RTl zoning district to a$3 zoning district; and 2. A copy of secdons 6D. 560 �h 60. 565 inclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. We acknowledge tha: we are aware of aIl of ihe uses permitted in a�3 zoning district, and we aze awaze that aay of these uses ca� be established upon City Couttcil approval of the Razoning. We hereby consent to ihe rezoning of the properiy in the petition of _ Saxon Ford [O 3_ R 3 zonine dtStliCt. (name of petitioner) We consenf fo the approval of_this rezoning as it was explained to us bp the applicant or hislher representativ.e. ADDRESS OR P[Y 190 Shetburne Ave. 185 University Ave. 36-29-23-14-0128 145 University Ave. 192 Sherburne Ave. 255 University Ave. 277 University Ave 36-29-23-13-Q215 271 University Ave. 36-29-23-13-0213 259 University Ave. 516 Galtier St. 519 Galtier St. 36-29-23-14-0074 This petition shafl not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of seven (7) working days aftec it is received by the Planning Division. Any signator of Ihis petition may withdraw his/her name therefrom by written request within that time. RECORD OWNER League of MN City B1dg. Co., Inc. League of MN Cities Research Foundation League of MN Cities Research Foundation Housing and Redev, Authoritv ALC Financial Corp. James C, Toner Carol A. Toner Carol A, Toner FIoang D. Pham Trang L. Nguyen Vang Neng Yang Shocca Lee Yang SIGNAlURg �'- - DATE ��zi�a �/�le� ��lY�a3 �/!�`3 • r� L� d K o� 0 /G a� �i5sr'�j D�' b;ss� �� L ""'Y OF SAINT PAUL CONSENT OF ADJC3�'�>�?s i;;y;� ^?? TY OWNERS FOR A ;. REZO1�i�i'��;. - 0�-583 We, the undersip ed, owners of property within 100 feet of t6e total contio ous description of reai esta[e owned, purchased, or sold by THE PETTI'IONER within one yeaz preceding the date of this petition acknowledge that we have been presented with the following: 1. A copy of the petition of Saxon Ford (nanie of petitioner) ' to rezone the property located at �sn to 2( 2 Sherburne Avenue from a RTl zoning district to a B3 zoning district• and ' 2. A copy of sections 60. 560 through 60. Sb5 inclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. We acknowledge that we aze aware of all of the uses permitted in a B3 zoning district, and we are awaze that any'of these uses can be established upon City Council apQrovaI of the Rzzoning. We hereby consent to the rezoning of the property in the petition of Saxon Ford to a B zoning district. (name of petitioner) We consent to the approval of fhis rezoning as it �vas explained to us bp the appiicant or his/her representative. ADDRESS OR PIN 241 Sherburne Ave 36-29-14-0072 259 Sherburne Ave 263 Sherburne 265 Sherburne Ave 271 Sherburne Ave 275 Sherburne Ave 36-29-23-13-0134 276 Sherburne Ave 277 Shezhutne Ave. 256 Shetburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0116 Jose V. Veley � RECORD OWNER Yee Thao Bao Yang �e� Annc�'r Blanca 0. �gudo Richard L. Holland Carla S. Holland Chue Long Yang Mo�a I,ee ShenQ Lee �Teng Stephen Her S[GNATURE pp� C3�i / > � � �,•ss,..� ar-� O,,�G°Q A*in : t , Cn;� P•� C�� This petition shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of seven (7) working days afcer it is received by Ihe Planning Division. Any signa[or o£ this pe[ition may withdraw his/her name thecefrom by written request within [hat time. a y°5 S 3 CITY OF SAINT PAUL CONS'r,id�' OF ADJC_ii�:5��'�r� PROPERTI' OWNERS POR A _ r-��?��.�` :. We, the undersid ed, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contio ous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by, THE PETITTONER �vithin one yeaz preceding the date of this petition acknowledge tha[ we have been presented with the foIiowing: 1. A copy of the petition of Sa�con Ford (name of petitioner) to rezone the property located at to ' Sherburne Avenue from a RTl zoning district to a$3 zoning district; and 2. A copy of sections 60: 560 through 60.565 inclusive of the Saint Pavt Zoning Code. We acknowledge that we are awaze of all of the uses pemutted in a_ R are aware that any'of these uses can:be esta6lished upon City Council pproval of the R zon pg. We he by consent to the rezoning of che property in the petition of Saxon Ford to a B3 zonin� (name of petitioner} o district: We codsent to fhe approval of this rezoning as it was expIained.fo us bp the appiicanf or his/her-representative. ADDRESS OR PIY 141 Sherburne Ave. 3ti-29-23-14-0051 193 Sheiburne Ave. 199 Shezburne Ave 203 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0048 208 Sherburne Ave 209 Sherb�rne Ave. 215 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-I4-0046 229 Sherburne Ave 233 Sherburne Ave 36-29-23-14-0074 RECORD OWNER R. Paxton Joseph E. Duchene Lorraine C. Duchene Gary A. Roen Joanna M. Roen A. Gordon Austin Fang Ste11a Wfiitney West James G. Sampson Karen Sue Sampson Pao Yang Blia Vue %ong Lee 235 Sherbarne Ave.F+ Gary Emory Sohnson 36-29-23-14-0073 � Aenrietta C. Johns SIGNANRE � �� • • %��j o)� r _��-p �. � � _ �'' � pu.SSin-� � � � � ro��7 ��c�� • This petition shait not be considered as officially filed until the ]apse of seven (7) working days after it is received by ttie Planning Division. Any sio ator of this petition may withdraw his/her name therefcom by written reqaest within that time. i ... . ... .......... .. .... . .�✓ .-. . . ...y.. a'.�.. .,ccc' r . qCi YJJ _ .. "*'Y�O£'SAZIVT PAUL U�f,583 CONSENT �F ADJ01;��3 �.�;;; ^�?'jy OWNERS FOR A . . :. REZON�di�. � - � � . We, the undeesigned, owners of propetty within 100 feet of tiie total contid ous description of real estatc owned, putchased, oc sold� by. THE PETTTIONER within one year preceding t6e date of chis peiition acicnowlcdoe that we have been presented with the foliowing: i. A copy of the peti6on of Sa�:oa Ford (name of petitioner) to rezone che prope�cy located.at to hezburne Avenue from a RTl zoning d'utrict to a B3 zonin; district; and • 2. A copy of secaons 60. 560 through 60.565 inelus;ve of the Saint Paut Zoni�g Code. We ac�cnowledge thac we are awa�e of all of the uses pem�itted ia a B3 zoning dist�cG and we are awace that any �f chese uses can be atablished upon City Council approval of the Rezoning. We hereby eortsent to the rezo�ingof the,propeRy in the petidon of Ssxon Ford to a B3 zoning distcict. (name of petitioner) , We consent W the approval of this rezoning as it tvas explained •to us bs the appticant oc his/her representative. ADDRESS OR PtN 241 Sherburne Ave 259 Sherburne Ave 263 Sherburne 36-29-23-13-0137 265 Sherburne Ave. RECORD OWNER Yee Thao Bao Yang ^� acer AnneG� Blanea 0. qgudo- Richard L. Hollaad CarSa J. Holland 271 Sherburne Ave. Chue Long Yang 36-29-23-13-0135 Shoua Yang 275 Sherburne Ave. Mona Lee 36-29-23-13-OI34 Sheng Lee 276 Sherburne Ave. - Teng Stephen Her 277 Sherburne Ave. 256 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0116 Jose V, Vele S[GNATURE pq� ��//. v. • This petition shall not be considered as officially filed unti( the lapse oF seven (�) working days after it is received by tlie P�anning Division. Any signatoc of this petition may withdraw his/her name thereFrom by written request within that time. � L�/C�I�J Z/� /o � n��Ys�� o+�-t �r ie-oi D �� 5 � 3 �``"'Y O£�SAINT PAUL CONSENT OF ADJOli��'�?.i i:;i;� ^uTY OWNERS FOR A . . REZOT�� - - . We, the undersigned, owners of propecty within I00 feet of the totaI contiguous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by TEIE pET'TflpNER within one year preceding the date of this petition aclmowledge tha[ we have been presented with the following: 1. A copy of the petition of Saxon Ford (name of petitioner) to rezone the property located.at to Sherburne Avenue � from a RTl zoning disttict to a$3 zoning district; aad 2. A copy of sections 6D.560 through 60.565 inctusive of the Saint Paul Zo�ing Code. We acjaowledge that we are aware of atl of the uses permitted in a B3 zoning district, and we are aware that any of these uses can be estabtished upon City Counci7 approva! of the Rezoning. We hereby conseai to the rezoning af ihe property in ihe petieion of Sa�con Ford to a B zoning district. (name of petitioner) We consenf to fhe approval of this rezoning as it was explained.to us bp the applicant or his/her representative. ADDRESS OR PIN RECORD OWNER Yee Thao Bao Yang ace�r� f-E'� n S[GNATURE DA7E 241 Sherburne Ave 259 Sherburne Ave. 263 Sherburne 265 Sherburne Ave. 271 Sherburne Ave. 275 Sherburne Ave 36-29-23-13-0134 276 Sherburne Ave 277 Sherhurne Ave. 256 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0116 Blanca 0. tagud� Richard L. Holland Carla J. Holland Chue Long Yang Shoua Yan¢ Moua Lee ShenQ I,ee Teng Stephen Her �_} �� ,� � g ja� � oC.�/... Jose V. Velez This petition shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of seven ('7) working days after it is received by the Planning Division. Any signator of this petition may withdraw his/her name therefrom by written reqaest within that time, • • � iu-oi � ""'Y OF'S�,�NT PAUL • d�-583 � CONSENT OF ADJG�z �.?�i i:<<;�-^T_?Ty OWNF.RS FOR A . ;.:REZOT�tAf�� - : We, the undersigned, owners of properry within 100 feet of the total contio ous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by TF� pETiTjpNER within one year preceding the date of this petition acknowiedge that we have been presented with tfie foltowing: l. A copy of the petition of Sason Ford (name of pedtioner) t0 teZOne the property loc3ted at �Se• to 762 Sherburne Avenue from a RTl zoning district to a B3 zoning district; and • 2. A copy of sections 60.560 through 60.565 inclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. We acJcnowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted in a B3 zoning district, and we are awaze that any of these uses can be established upon Ciry Council approval of the Rezoning. We hereby consent to the rezoning of che property in the peti[ion of Saxon Ford to a B zoniao dutrict. (name of petitioner) We corisent fo fhe approval of this rezoning as if was explained to us bp fhe applicant or his/her represeatative. ADDRESS OR PIN 241 Sherburne Ave. RECORD OWNER Yee Thao SIGNAI'URE DATE 254 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-13-0138 263 Sherburne 265 Sherburne Ave. 271 Sherburne Ave. 275 Shexburne Ave. 36-29-23-13-0134 Homes, Inc. Blanca 0. Agudo Richard L. Holland Carla J. Holland Chue Long Yang Shoua Yane a.•-? il-� -b� Mona Lee Sheng Lee 276 Sherburne Ave. �`Teng Stephen Her 276 Charles Ave. 277 Sherburne Ave. M. 256 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-011b Jose V. Velez ♦ � I . • This petition shall not be considered as official(y fi(ed until the iapse of seven (7) working days aC[er it is received by tfie P�anning Division. Any signator of this petition may withdraw his/her name thecefrom by written request within that time. ,o-oi 05�- 5'83 � `�'Y O��SAINT P�-�.UL CONSENT OF ADJC3� ��?G i:;;�-;???TY OWNERS FOR A REZOT�1�� - We, t6e undersigned, owners of properry within lOQ feet of the total contio ous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by. THE PETI1IpNER within one yeac preceding the date of this petition acknowledae that we have been presented with the following: 1. A copy of the petition of Saxon Ford (name of peti6oner) to reZOne the property IoCaied at _ 25� to ?6 � Gherburne Avenue , from a RTl zoning distdct to a$3 zonine district; and 2. A copy of sections 60.560 through 60.565 inclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. We acknowledge that we aze awue of all of the uses pemutted in a B3 zoning district, and we are awaze tha[ any af these uses can be establis6ed upon City Council approval of the Rezoning. We hereby conseat to the rezoning of the pcoperty in the petiCion of Saxon Eord to a$ zoning district. (name of petitioner) We consenf to the approval oP this rezoning as it ivas explained.to us b� the applicant or his/her representative. ADDRESS OR PIiY 241 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-14-0072 259 Sherburne Ave. 263 Shezburne 265 Sherburne Ave. 271 Sherburne Ave. 275 Sherburne Ave 36-29-23-13-0134 RECORD OWNER Yee Thao Bao Yang aee � , 4nne6'n f-� n S[GNATURE �� DATE f � Blanca 0. Qgudo Richard L_ Holland Carla J. Ho2land Chue Long Yang Shoua Yane Moua Lee ShenQ Lee 276 Sherburne Ave. �'Teng Stephen Her 277 Sherhurne Ave. 256 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0116 Jose V. Velez� i � � i This peti[ion sE�a(I not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of seven (7) working days after it is received by the Planning Division. Any sio ator of this petition may withdraw his/her name therefrom by written request within that time. � � U • L,-oi • �. ""'Y OF�S�LNT PAUL O�{=5d'3 CONSENT OF ADJCir3 s.T� i�._�;�-_'RTY OWNE}�S F'OR A . . REZOT�I��x - . We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contib ous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Tf� PETITIONER within one year preceding the date of this petition acknowledge that we have been presented with the following: l. A copy of the petition of Saxon (name of petitioner) to rezone the p[operty loCated at _ 25[2. to ?h9 Sherburne Avenue from a RTl zoning district to a B3 zoning district; and �� • 2. A copy of sections 60.560 through 60.565 inclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. We acknowiedge that we aze aware of all of the uses peanitted in a B3 zonina district, and we are aware that any'of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of the Rzzoning. We hereby consent to ihe rezoning of the propecty in the petition of Saxon Ford to a B zoning district. (name of petitioner) We consent to the approval of this rezoning as it �vas explained to us bp the applicaat or his/her represenfative. ADDRESS OR PIN 241 Sherburne Ave. 259 Shetburne Ave. 2b3 Sherburne 265 Sherburne Ave. 271 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-13-0135 275 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-13-0134 276 Sherburne Ave. 27T Sherburne Ave. 276 Charles Ave. 256 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0116 RECORD OWNE(t Yee Thao Bao Yan¢ Cullen Homes, Inc. Blanca 0. Riehard L_ Holland Carla J. Holland Chue Long Yang SIGNATURE DATE � Mona Lee Shen� Lee - Teng Stephen Aer Lori M Jose V. Velez This petition shail not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of seven (7) working days after it is received by the Planning Division. Any signator of this petition may withdraw his/hzr name therefrom by written request within that time. io-oi a�- 58 3 COI��ENT OF ADJOI'r;.��=^ pRpgERTY OWNERS FOR A '. , . . - ��TVii°�� - .. .. . �� :_;,. We, the undeisigtted, owners of property within 10(? feet of the total contisuous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by_ THE PETITTONER withln one yeaz. pceceding the date of tfiis petition acknowledb that we have been presented with the following: 1. A copy of the petition of Sason Ford (name of petitioner) to rezoae the property located at 250 to 262 Sherburne Avenue from a RTI zoning district to a_ B3 zonino district; and 2. A copy of secdons 60. 560 through 60. 565 inclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code, We ac�owledge that we aze aware of atl of the uses pemucted in a B3 zonino district, and we are awaze tfiat any af these uses can-be established upon City Council approval of the Rezoning. V4Ve hereby consent to the rezoning oE the property in the petition of -- Saxon Fnrd t08 R4 20nIQodUtnCf: (name of petitioner) -.... . _. . . ., CITY OF SA�NT PAUL ` We consent-to the approval of rezoning as it was explained.to�us by the applicant or his/her representafive. ADDRESS R OWNE2 Leagtie of M[�1I City Bldg. Co., Inc. League nf MN Cities Research Foundatiod League of MN Cities Research Eoundation SICNAlUl2E pq� -� .,/!n • n n 190 Sherburne Ave. I85 University Ave. 145 Uni.versity Ave. 192 Sherbume Ave. 36-99-94-14-0093 255 Universitv Ave. 277 University Ave 36-Z9-23-13-0215 271 IIniversitv Ave. 259 IIniversity Ave. 516 Galtier St. 519 Galtier St. 36-29-23-14-0079 Housing and Redev. James C. Toner A. Toner Carol A. Toner Hoang D. Pham Vang Neng Yang Sfioua I.ee Yang � This peiition shal! not be considered as oFFcially filed until the lapse of seven (7) working days after it is received by the Planning Division. Any sio ator of this petition may withdraw hislher name therefrom by xvritten reqaest within that time. ��.G 3 � � • CITY OF SAINT PAUL CONSENT OF ADJ011�u ;^ pROPERTY OWNERS FOR A REZONliy:� . b5�-583 We, the undersio ed, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contio ous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Tf� PETTfIONER wiEhin one yeaz preceding the date of this petition acknowledge that we have been presented with the following: 1. A copy of the petition of Saxon Ford (name of to rezone the property located at 250 & 262 Sherburne Avenue from a RT-1 yoning district [o a B zoning district and Saxon Ford to a B-3 zoning district. (name of petitioner) • • -___, 2. A copy of sections 60.560 through 60.565 �nclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. We acknowledge that we are awaze of all of the uses peanitted ia a B � 3 zoning distdct, and we are awaze that any of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of the Rezoning. We hereby coasent to ihe rezoning of the propercy in the petition of We consent to the approva] of this rezoning as it was expiained to us b} the appticant or his/her representative. ADDRESS OR PIN RECORD OWNER 190 Sherburne Ave. League of MN City 36-29-23-14-0092 Sldg. Co., Inc. I85 University Ave. League of MN Cities 36-29-23-14-0128 Research Foundation 145 University Ave. League of MN Cities 36-29-23-14-0127 Research Foundation 192 Sherburne Ave 255 University Ave. 277 University Ave. 36-29-23-13-0215 271 University Ave. - 36-29-23-13-0213 259 University Ave. 36-29-23-13-0213 516 Galtier St 519 Galtier St. 3b-29-23-14-0079 Housing and Re Authoritv ALC Financial James C. Toner Carol A. Toner, Carol A. Toner Hoang D. Pham � Trang L. Nguyen Vang Neng Yang Shoua Lee Yan�! DATE _ � -�,d3 /, - ��_ � � This petition shal! not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of seven (7) working days after it is received by the Planning Division. Any signator of this petition may withdraw his/hzr name therefrom by written request within that time. ie-�i ��-f-5S3 -CITY OF SAiNT PAUL CONSEi�i ��.ADJt3�d�:iiE • PROPERTY OWNERS FOR A ��?�?��i�•;� We, the undersigned, owners of propeRy wit[iin 100 feet of the total contiguous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by THE PETTTIONER within one year preceding the date of this petition acknowledge that we have been presented with the following: 1. A copy of the petition of Saxon Ford (name of petitioner) to rezone the praperty located at Z50 to 262 Sherburne Avenue from a RTL zoning district to a B3 zoning district; and 2. A copy of sections 60.560 through 60.565 inclusive of the Saint Paut Zoning Code. We acknowledge that we are aware of all of the use5 pemutted in a s3 zonino district, and we aze aware that any vf these vses can be established upon Ciry Council approval of the Rezoning. We hereby consent to ihe rezoning of the proparty in the petition of _— Saxon Ford L02 R4 ZO[lt[IodiStRC[. (name of petitioner) We consenE to the approval of_this rezoning as it was explained to us bp the applica�rt or his/her representative. ADDRFSS OR P(N 190 Sherburne Ave. I85 University Ave. 145 University Ave 192 Sherburne Ave. 255 University Ave. 277 University A 36-29-23-13-0215 271 University Ave. 36-29-23-13-0213 259 University Ave. 516 Galtier St 519 Galtier St. 36-29-23-14-0079 RECOi2D O WNER SIGNATURE DA7E Leagae of MN City Bldg. Co., Inc. League of MN Cities Researc Foundation League of MN Cities Research Foundation • • Housing and Redev. James C. Toner Carol A. Toner Carol A. Toner Hoang D. Pham Trang L. Nguye: Vang Neng Yang Shoua Lee Yang r-- - n ��G63 �l�Y�a� 8 �lf� 3 _ ��, �63 r �' u This petition shatl not be considered u officially filed until the lapse of seven (7) working days after it is received by the P(anning Division. Any signator of this petition may withdraw his/hzr name thereFrom by written request within that time. CITY OF SAINT PAUL � OS�- 5�'3 CONS��;'!' OF ADJui�� '�T� PROPERTY OWNERS POR A ?�21_�i� :'�' �� , _ We, the undersigned, owners of property within iQ0 feet of the total contia ous description of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by. Tf� PETITIONER within one yeaz preceding the date of this petition acknowledge that we have been presented witb the following: I. A copy of the petition of Sazcon Ford (name of petitioner) to rezone the ptoperty located at 950 to �69 Sherburne Avenue from a RTl zoning district to a B3 zoning district; and 2. A copy of sections 60. 560 through 60.565 inclusive of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. We acknowledge that we aze awaze of all of the uses pemutted in a�3 zoning district, and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of the Rezoning. We hereby consent to the rezoning of the property in the petition of Saxon Ford to a B3 Zoning district. (nama of petitioner) We consent to fhe approval of this rezoning as it was explained to us bp the applicant or • his/her representative. ADDRESS OR PLN RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE DA'I'E 191 Sherburne Ave. � � /� � 36-29-23-14-0051 Teresa K. Paxton LS l 193 Sherburne Ave C� 199 Sherbuxne Ave 203 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0048 208 Sherburne Ave. 209 Sherburne Ave. 215 Sherburne Ave 36-29-23-14-OOG6 229 Sherburne Ave 233 Sherburne Ave. 36-29-23-14-0074 235 Sherburne Ave. Joseph E. Duchene Lorraine C. Duchene Gary A. Roen Joanna M. Roen Terryl A. Gordon Austin Fang Ste11a Whitney West James G. Sampson Karen Sue Sampson Pao Yang Chad Lee Blia Vue Xone Lee Gary Emory Johnson Henrietta C. Johnson q �'-1 8-0.� �'' / P' �0� ''' D ' C� J • This petition shall not be considered as officially £led until the lapse of seven (7) working days after it is received by the Planning Division. Any signator of this peticion may wichdraw his(her name therefrom by written request within that time. .. . , � Patriaa James - File #04-048 912 � � � � � Page 1 O �f- 583 • From: To: Date: SubjecE: � Caria Holland <chofland5@yahoo.com> <patricia.james@ci.sfpaul.m n.us> 3/23/04 3:41 PM File #04-048-912 Rezoning properties from residential to business on Sherbume Avenue between Farrington and Galtier. Hearing Date: April 1, 2004 Applicant: R & N Corporation To W hom It May Concern: We would like to go on record in favor of the proposed changes for these properties. Owning property accross the street from a responsibie business may finally stabalize the value of ous home. Do not insult us with proposais for the need for low-income housing. That is not what this block needs. Thanks, by the way, for drug ring bust at the 256 Sherburne property, this past Sunday. W ell done. If you could level that building as well, we'd finally be moving in the right direction. Regards, Richard and Carla Holland 265 Sherburne Ave. (since 1976) St. Paul, MN 55103 Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Finance Tax Center - File online. File on time. http:/(taxes.yahoo.comffil ing.htm l \ I i � �� _ � ._; r � �� . �' �, .,; �=�_ �_ <<,�; - � � x , ..� ,�; , . = ? -�:..,.� �'; � , �:�� `��: F, � � � P k x� ,�' : N . � �' � � �iM`�,` { � � � ". � � .� � � '� ` � 7 °�,' *,�,�."�2="'` s ` a ;� : , 4 `�'� } t . � - R � s�' ".- � � ��. . �� i � � - ��, . , � =� �. : . � � 's � 5 �� . � �'�b � �� y � r� #+� .A � �`�' ' � ' � ' S n .. _ ' �q ��6: " � ` a : 1' � v, . �' ? '�. 4�.�: ' �s� �3�� ; � � � si �d :�"� ' .; '� ° � � ,..�i�u.. d � "s � 3� "S"��. ' ° „r . � ` , . 3y k`` � �-' 4n v'*..: ��[�� n Y� S" +� ��r �� fMe�,`k �,'x. " � r n� ��r � � ' �.; ' a, i ; • t�-�� ,. uv,.�. '�° . � _ �� . � � 4� c �..� iv�„:. � . y ��"' .. � � e, �' J€`�'�'t�.�"+' _ . � '� ` S�i �g i ° �^ � . �;. 3 �a � w . �; � �`�� ,� � a�� `t� p k � � � �� re s � � � ' � s� �h� � �Fx 4�c�A' � }` R . Y � ¢� L x { � 4�u �'"��y'�Si. � �;,=�"' � _ `�_ . �a�� !_ t �Y� �� '�� ' , � ��n� �. �"'� '�� ' , k � � � � � �� x I _ ,� t � :"� " � ., r � ��`��'��rr i��. �� q� � � �'� ^�i� £ y g � a: �� . +�"� � M c. � � y�� 'K � ,� ,� �' ' � �' r r ��' c... � � f t � � s k�': �� if� � g S ,� `g : '�x x 1 � � p �»� �� ynn a f S� 1�� _ �� -. . �� -; e' ...ix �,�h�'l'r; r r.� _ m ,. . i i . , ,. � �._ �. - - ry# � �� , . -� ;�� - - south of 250 Sherburne Zoning file # 04-048-912 O�1-583 C � Oy-�3'3 across Sherbume to eas� Zoning file # 04-048-912 � • • � Zoning file # 04-048-912 0�1-5�3 Oy-583 across Sherbume Zoning file # 04-048-912 C� � � u west of sites Zoning file # 04-048-912 a�-s�3 �"� �; , �.�: ,�� _ � :�>%:� ; � �,` ��-- , . � . -- -- , = ' � � �/- S 83 � � � a �; + ' S ' .. . ' � '� uCiwtlCfl SI.IDj@CI SII2S Zoning file # 04-048-912 ....-�..xie"'�'��-��,.:y` _. O�f- 5 �3 Site at 250 Sherburne Zoning file # 04-048-912 � i �� -583 E CI �1 14 CiTIZEN PARTICIPATIO DIS RICTS 1fl �� ii �� `��. ° ��A�� ' 3 5 0 r � u �" �4! � �.. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLAFtNING DI57RICTS l.SUNRAY-BkT7L€CREEK-HIGHWOOD 2.GREATER EAST SIDE 3.WES7 SIDE 4.DAY70N'S BLUFF 5.PAYNE-PHALEN ORTH END 7. OMAS-DAL� .SUMMIT-UNIVERSITY 9.tJEST SEVENTH lO.COMO 11.HAMLINE-MIDWAY 12_ST. ANTHONY 13.MERRIAM PK.-LEXINGTON HAMLINE 14..GROVELAND-MACALESTER 15.NI6HLAND 16.SUMMIT HILL 17.�OWNTOWN � 0 � . � y— �'a�&-�! � 0�� 5 8 3 � THOMF(S-pALE DISTRICT 7 N� �^ ,b,� ,, . � Z �� !-t,y�`--Q/1 • �.. € ; � , ., � ! _ a ` € ��.—� .��'s` � . �. .. _ � € �. �-----=.. __.�._.____.._____ ,. --------- � r �` 3 s�� 9 � � � � ��! e � � �� #Jl�t��,v�;�j-- -- � � _ � � �� ,' � t � � � � t 4 �� , � — a � �� i �� .�� Ti � � � - , �` C� �' �� Lr $ � � `� �`�i `�+ � � ��j'� ' � � k fi�t � ��'� � 1� � �, � � � „� E �i� �i� .��'��' � �ii��l�s �� •�• '♦l�� , � � ' ,��'� ,,.� �� I ��i�Q�� - 6 � i ' � � # � �� . . .. � . � L � { �� , � �' � � ./� � ��• �" � � 1 �� LEGEND � ,�, r � � r�c.� zoning di5Uic1 t�JUnd=_ry � 'URPOSG ? ' ��' � Zs(17� �l%7 s��5j�� p� no,� i ' _A � p r\r E "—� � aO o on: tamily b� comr�::=�z' 'l . DIST f,lA°:' — • � ¢ F:;o(3mify o d.= induzuiz� �� c:.^� ,� (� fTlUlfi�l? (d;Tlily V V2C2�: � _:: — � l r f �