237427 . ((''��
_ ORI6INAL TO CITY CL6RK 'J���
. CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL �
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK F'LE N�� N
OU CI��FSOLU N-GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE DATF
RESOLVED, Upon the pertinent appeal , under the Zoning
Code, by Capital City State Bank, own.er of the subject real
estate, situate in the City of Saint Paul, located at the
northeast corner of Rice and Lawson. Streets, more particularly
described as Lots 13, 14, 15, 16, Block 3, J. F. Eisen.mengers
Addition to St. Paul, partially zoned in "B" Residence Dis—
trict and partially zoned in Commercial District, under said
Zoning Code, that the provisions of said Zoning Gode hereby
are determined and varied in their application to said real
estate, as and to the extent necessary therefor, and that a
special permit hereby is gran.ted for the extension of the
Commercial District use presently permitted on a portion of
said herein.above described real estate to all of the same; be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That upon and pursuant to the pertinent
appeal, under the Zoning Code, by Capital City State Bank,
own.er of the subject real estate, situate in the City of Saint
Paul and described as:
Lots 13, 14, 15, 16, Block 3, J. F.
Eisenmengers Addition to St. Paul;
that the provisions of said Zoning Code hereby are determined
and varied as and to the extent necessary therefor and the
requirement for an eight foot buffer between a parking facility
and a residential lot at the northeast corner of Rice Street and
Lawson Street is hereby relaxed; subject to the condition that
said appellant—applicant, and its successors and assigns, shall
make due compliance with all applicable provisions of municipal
ordinances, state statutes and rules and regulations of public
authorities having cognizance.
� zoxn�a wr�ewz. F A P P h
Notice is hereb, �iven that a Rublic ��
�ea will be Iteld before the Ci t y �s�, Corporation Counsei
C�o n n o�i l a t l fl A.M. o n F e b r u a r y �i,
1988, in the City Council G7iamber oi.
the LYty Hali and Coui}�t House, in the
matter oi Lhe eal of Capital City
$tate. Bank i�d Atlam), under �
Legislatfve Code,Zoning�C'odesfo rex lylf'� -� ���"�
tens�on of Coaimercial use to entire
COUNCILMEN �o�n�{hed��ve�r�l�r�ui�o��e'`�i Adopted by the Council 19—
ia� le Blobeck 3 d F�yE e�i�men8er s
Yeas Nayf A�dition and proposed alley to be va- � �.(�'r�j�
cated between Lots 13, 14, 18 and 16,
Carlson ;o�ar�a at r,n� northeaei corner of Rice
3t. and I.awaoa Ave.
Dalglish Datea Feb�a., iees. pprove� 19—
H,�RRY E. `��*3.�m�►�:+.
Holland
CitY Clerk. ;
cr+e�rwry io, i9ee� � or
Meredith -- - ,l
Peterson V Mayor
Tedesco A gainst
Mr. President, Byrne Pd�L��E� MAR 9 1968
��
,Harry l�. Marshbll ��TY ,�, Albert B. Olson
� City/Clerk and Raw �� Council Recorder
Commissioner of Reeiatration a � x
o �
i _�'� �b
��, �o
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
CITY OF SAINT PAUL ,���,��
BUREAU OF RECORDS
386 City Hall
St.Paul,Minnesota 55102
Feb, 21, 1g68
Mr. Joseph P. Su�ners,
Corporation Counsel.
Dear Sir:
The City Council requests that you prepare a resolution
granting the appeal of Capital City State Ba.nk for (1) an extension
of Commercial use and (2) a relagation of the required 8' buffer
between a parkin� facility a,nd a residential lot at the northeast
corner of Rice and Lawson Streets.
Very truly yours
L� ���
�.ti 1
Cit - Clerk
hP (���.
R � � E � vE �
�Eg � 1196a
�r,.;*!;F_�,
�(�3l�'�,, ,�t•., ,
� n,7 � �
�
• � l •
, t , � v
BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
1010 COMMERCE BUtLDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
February 19, 1968
I�r. Harry E. Marshall
City Clerk
Courthause
i�ar Sir:
This is in reference to th� appeal of Ca�ital City State Bank for
1) an extension of Commercial us� and 2) a relaxation of the r�quired
8' buffer between a parking facility and a residential lot at the
northeast corner of Rice Street and Lawson Street. This property is
further described as Lots 13, 14, 15, 16, Block 3, J. F. Eisenmenger's
Addition and the uacated •alley w�st of lot 16. The applicant proposes
to va.cate that portion of the alley west of Lot 16 and to use the
vacated alley and Lot 16 for additional customer narking for commercial
uses in the area.
This matter was considered by the Board of Zoning on October 19, 1967.
At that time, the staff reported that the area zoning consisted of
Commercial on the Rice Street frontage and "B" Residence for the remainin�
area. North and east of Lot 16, which is proposed for the parking lot
expansion, are single-family residences. South are one and two family
residences and a bank. tdest is a clinic and an off-street parking
facility. At the time of the Board of Zoning meeting, Lot 16 was occupied
by a relatively old duplex which was approximately 4' higher than the
existing parking lot. This structure has since been removed. Mr. Gerald
Swanson, of the Corporation Counsel's office, states that if a lot is
divided by a public alley it is not a lot to which a use can be extended
under Section 64.03 (a) of the Zoning Code. Therefore, before such an
extension of use can be granted, the alley would have to be vacated and be
in conti�na�s ownershi� with the adjacent property.
It was the findings of the board�that the extension of use as
proposed and the waiver of the 8' buffer along the East property line of
Lot 16 would not be detrimental to the neighborhood.
Therefore, the Board of Zoning recommends approval of the extension
of commercial use to include Lot 16 and the waiver of the 8' buffer,
provided that the alley adjacent to the west line of Lot 16 be vacated.
Very truly yours,
^
� ( ,„ � °,�T� �
r . I{,�'r�� . i p� ,�.`�`.. ..
�
Noland R. Heiden ' �y r, �
Secretar � �_w-.��Y ' . a.�¢�."�,:.�
Y r �
NRH:cv ;;,"�
GMK Bo � ��
Z.F. #6380
" . _� , , <
' -
,: r �
vU�(tD Ol�' IUPdINU RI;I'OR'i' ANU AC1'lON _ -���#;�-�3-, _ _ Plat 141ap 2�1 _ _
Actit��; uncici• Le�;islative Code Cha�>t�.i� GU tbru G�1 Filc No. ^
passcd Aui;usi; 22, 1922 as amended to Au�;u�t 2�1 , 19G4 �'3`;r ---
Also �'»2
1. APPLiC�1Ni''S NE1hIL • Ca��ital Cit•i Stat� I3��nk
2. CL.4SSIFICA'1'ION � Amendment � tlppcal ❑Permit u Othcr �
;.
3. IyUItPOS� • 1) ��t. of Co�r�'l. Use ?.) ;:al�ix 3' i.�urf-�r
4. LOCATION • :I.I:. Cor:��r of R?c� & I.�a•;�son Stra-�ts
5. I�G�'1L DESCRIPTION � Lots 13, 1�F, 15, 1.6, i3lcck 3, J.F. Fis�nm�n-�r's Addn.
� vacat:;d a.11�v.
6. PRESE�IT ZONING . ���;�� � Co-arn=�rcial
7. PURSUANT TO 2onin� Code Chaptcr: ��E.03 Section: Paragraph: a
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION 8:, FiEPORT: Date: 10/15/67 BY� G;�I'cC
A. HISTORY: Infor:�al a�?roval 9/25/57
B. Z0:1Ii�;G r".D::I:dISTRATIO`J: 'do Action
C. PROPOSED USE: Exoansion of off=str��t narkin; facilities
D. i1EtD FOR APPEAL: 1) parkin� lots accassory to comm�rcial us� r�quire comm�rcial
zonin� or an aop�al of the �};tznsion of said us� to th� adjoinin� property. 2)
parking facilitzes r��uira an 8' buff�r T•�t7en they are adjac�nt to residzntially
used or zoned aroperty.
�;. AREA ZO'1I;dG: The fro�ta�;� alon? Rice Str�et is zoned commercial. Tha r�st of
the ar�a is zon�d "B" Resid�nc�.
F. SITE COi;DITIO:�tS: Tnat portion of tha pron�rty in "B" R�sidenca zonin� is
occupied by a relatively old dunl�x and is approximat�].y 4' nigher than th_
existin� parkinff lot w�iicn occupies th� portion conriercially zon�d. Th� allay
b2tw_en is un�raded.
G. ARcA C0:IDITIO:dS: .Iorth and East ar� one & t,ro family residenc�s. South are
one and t:•ro fanily r�sidencns and a bank. �•Test is a clinic and an off-�tr�et
parkin� facil.ity�.
� —
9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend � Approval ❑ Denial Council Lt.
Dated
Moved by: 1•icPartlia Yeas Nays
Ames
Seconded by: Conen x Cohen Date of Hearing
X Janes,Chmn.
x b4cPartlin Council Action
Secretary's remarks; x Haarstick - Alt, �
_� -r , ;� x Gadler � Date
�>�il` ,t�, �t '�:J�t� �� �� ��' � �'�' 1� . ;
� s . , . ��r j�,, 1�Taietta � ----
�.�i i j ������ti'�` �� G•1� �t�J� ��.:t� o'{�
{ LEGAL P;OTICFS ON TH.r. I3aCK OF'' THIS SHEET
; �.`.l j ; ;" . �! ..,Y� v; �„���/ �
,�, � s � i•� ";., � , i , ; �`� �'
:�~-�--'`�---� � - ";� �M - �;'�'' �.r L.`= � �. �, ",�1'''�� j j , � � � ; ! � I
... �
, -i�,. � - ... . J � ...� ; . � ,^ -� �---_, ,.. : ,.. __., -- -- -1__ _
_�._. .__ . - � � :r.� �, , .. . � . � ,
X �� �.� :T , -
o — —_ Y� l� '� .� -�i�:--,,-- i:, ,:.� ,�,�;:-::,�;,.� i— i � � �J
O p ,�: � N) - . ..i•,r..��-r,•;� , � � � � I
1-' ��� r Rp�-Yi��• :: I
.�_O O �_�' O_�I�W�t ,,t h,pO �• , ,� ��4 9�. � Q'O O�OIO G�O '¢ ��O�QI�
_.. _�.. � �Q �7:..r.�m __ ",-_` �►r''t •`�' fs\`.\�� ��'� ' Y r
U -Q � .0--�� �e}F�l^ �"'---rtJ i h-��1:1 j��'�°j'�""""""""""'..`„�. '� .
�. __._. _..
.._ ---- ---__
U O - ..0- ...�__. ..,, . _...� r /';�..r�,..::. �U�T � I r� �
,
� p. �_ o�.. � r p.p; 6 !pi�`��G�O ' �pi plp
r' O I � ' Y
�,'�PO ' .�.`� j � !
-=�= ..Q__ __.S? � .�. � �� � I i `' I
:�,..��_ _� � __ _ .__ - �1-1_�.___ _ � 1--
. i � �� . .. _ . _ _
� �L A L t�1� \\\�9�\ ,i.�� "I" .�T,�
�� f
; _ �o , p , , ;
?� >-�_ i �
SH � �r.�` c'� �;4 �� F, r�' <`3 L` �; E,. ' ; �� '�; u� � Q�¢I� � C� � � Q 1 D j 0 Q 0
66 • . .s t- �.� ,�. �t., �'� "
" �'` ��A,
' �,� f', r f..'� � !�f f:� t�� �� � { P�{�.;eiNC�V O � O .�Keu;.�� }�fn
� � • L;;s�v. �!:�;� �; 't C, �%�, ^. �� Nr17in.,;�
. �. � �f1 c , i
'i..— �! �� �„� � K^ �.'•1 ' S • �'+ � ,8\ 1 � 1 � �.F �� 1 I
�.
.•--- ,M.+'�. ':� ��. ' , �''. 4,• . � ���- ` .� °�"�,�� --� O'O�O Y,O O O� O G'O�O,O
�p ,„ �.j���' C�?L,A s�''�'G1.r//,?ll�' � ' �r'� _ � I
�....___ ,�.; �,� 7`►.> �., .�� �:,? ' �� �• � O � O !
• r� „ �' . :.;� 4� �, �:;� . _.�__.I. . �__.�.. .__. .I_ .L . . _.�--
�""�_� `.: �' �� �,.f �'.ti � �� 3: ,�� ��''� De����� ,� <.:_ I - - � � I i �..
• ' .� �: � K ' ;' w' ��� . " .�=,' �"'y' O�a � pr • � � --r v O ! I �f
.� .^' f � • �I � • � /� � 1
i_'_'_....._ i, ' � ' /'r` (._n �� . ��� (.� �
- - -- r~ ` �% E. l,�.p°_,t�0 G�`' t„ � �<: �'.,� �` O O O O " � O O;4 E�i 4'�
� r�-- -_ .���- � - ::_,.�_'-������ � '
d 1��J � .��•,.. �9
._ _(j _-O. --�- � _ Q ~_ � A ' \�, �� � Q��i � la � � i� I i
-0.. - ---- �� � � f i i¢ � ;�`�i���l�.��'
�
� '�' � O � ��i �,:\�\� `' I i � i � I ' ' I
� o --�> �.� � 24.�� � --I-�--J_1_.�_.: _��� ; I. � I _f ( �
---- -�- --�. ��:� . ��=� I
.��: - -� � F� ���. . •:.;\;j7� ; i
G - - �� `o��„ ��,,��� �i-�-..�--r �-T-T-�•�-- ._r
-�;.� � Q " � L 5�.. ALIs:;�- lvCa �� � , i ' � � ' i i j ,
, -` 1-� o o ��q :;14: R�,,�, �,,o o;o,o;o;o;o�a� o; o � �' � �, -�� c:
�- . ,, ,�.� �,,
...� -� -�-- \��.. '� � ; ' � ` ' �'
. ._ _--- .. . . .L..__.�� � -
---
_ _ . . _..__..._____. . h .. ;�,s,�.��
_____..__.. ..�._._._._. .�f��;,, � u��-c��
� �, � �� �. �
.
_ ._� _ - - - ---U� ;�; ---- :SS L _ � �_ � ���!Qi�'���' �..3 (QiQIQi�' � ' 'O
, -- 0� _ :,' e _Q _ � � _ I � I , � � � � t i , I � •
- --•- ' .
� O � Q � '� � ' I � ! � ' � :
ea i i , �
�.�_.. . ...---� ---- -- �°E -� � O - .�- _� _1_ . �_,.. ._ .
----- ..
p � � .I � ;�, � � - �)r�.,,„. _-�___ ._t-_ -- -- -�-
. .... ` , � f. .L A � f '.1_..T.. -i
�(` _ Q � r � �� `51�� _Ti1' .� � ' �t� � I ! i i i� A � � ; , �
.� _� _ ;, � p ; Q ¢ a,o �
��°� � o 0 0'0 F
� � .O . ... ` �� �/�� .:�- --��A, ,Ff'`�., �'.Fi �� i I I. �;
C I ` - — o -,- r - -� - ' r',,�
. ,� - �G
r. . '
r � {�'�
� ilttir�-�.l .�f � � ��'"� ��ofV
�«--.--�-� ------��'_�.�.,�o^�'r^..T°_�7------'-__-._._.--'-•—°. . _----}�f--� ` OA/ •�ti�• � . �-1 `-� �, �
/� , f �•-• r "_7"'1 •C�""""'� �: .���� .�•�.I O i�!� � . � � !v I � NI Yl � Il./'�C
!-1�������ai� � ' C'�PZTA�, �ITY STATE :3A^?K L_��7�:.j�;�
�1����cj�:kppe�]_ extension of �o.n�n�l iJse � L��VD USE�
PhESC"n►T ZOPi�IC�G � ���" Resicience CJ -ONE� F=l-�C��II_Y
. 'O. �r tiv o F�n rv�i�_�r
. �. Ti-tF-�r_r_ r-n M i�Y
p�:�r���o�v s���vCf�s� , � - `�-- FC1UR f=nf�,�i�Y
FILE �la. 6 �o � � �i��tlLTI-- FAMILY
3 � � n co r��n���c tr���
' � n I I�1 i�U S'�(�f;I A!_
. NOS�Tl; ---- �
�fi, f'e�ur f-��c�ns��:�;� �oryc•c� , bc�,��,�;to}���- ?-1� l�s? f'b��J��:�'f Y !N C��1�:�'�10���
. . . �
a CAPITA:.L C IT Y PROPEftTIES ��.�
�
1020 RICE STREET � ��
SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA 117 ��
, 55
September 26, 1967
Zoning Board
City of Saint Paul
Commerce Building
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Gentlemen:
Lots 13, 11�. and 15 B�ock 3 J. F. Eisenmen�er's addition face
Rice at the Cor�ner o� La.wson.
Lot 16 Block 3 J. F. Eisenmenger�s addition is separated by
an UNGR.ADED ALLEY which is to be vacated. Lot 16 faces Lawson
Avenue and is Zoned "B" classification.
We s�sk favorable action on "Extension of Use" to this Zoned B
property for customer parking. There u3.11 be 2!{. cars parked
on this lot.
We further ask elimination of the 8 foot set back requirement.
In liew thereof we will 3.nstall a 4 foot wide� 8 inch h3.gh curb
a.nd. install a t�ire fence meeting the requests of the adjacent
property owner. The adjacent property owner does not want a
wood fence. His reason for wanting a wi.re fenae is th�t he can
enjoy the view and. traffic of Rice 9treet �►ith a wixe fence but
he is den3.ed this view with a vood fence.
Favor�ble �ction on this application will result in elearing
the narro� residential streets of employ�ee park3.rig although
the use of the lot is N(7r intended to be employ+�e parking only.
We are also the City Cauncil to v�cate the �lley separating th3�
1ot from the Rice Street property. After v�cating this �.11.ey -
the property owners in the entire block will still ha.ve the use
of a gr�ded and b�].ack topped �L" alley.
Yours truly, ,
� :� /
✓ ` �'�'
;
Dr. Gilbert P. Wenzel, Par er f �,� ;_
� �����
� �
.Alfred Ada,m, i ner
The above request mseta w;ith � approval. I own the ad�acent property
lrnown As 119 W. I�awson Street.
���-Y✓�,�x��'"'e'r'"� `
1�1'i tneSs: � � '
i G /:�.--'"
� ������
� �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
February 9, 1958
City Clerk
File R426, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be heid i.a the
Council Chambers of the Citp Hall and Court House in the City of
St. Pau1 at 10:80 a.m. on Februazy 21, 1968, on the appeal of
Capital City State Bank (A1£red Adam) to extend the com�Qarci�tl usa
to entire site and waiver of required 8 foot buffer on the east
boundary �ine of the fol2owing property: I.ots 13, 14, 15 and 16,
Block 3, J. F. Lisern�enger's Addition and �.t�ey groposed to be
vacated between Lots 13, I4, 15 and 16. The property is located
on the aortbeast corner of Rice Street and Lawsoa Av�enue.
Fox furCher i,aformaticn contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Co4mnerce
Building or phone 223-4151.
JAt�II�S J. DALGLISH
Coffiniesioner of Finance
55