Loading...
237109 -� . : 23'��.09 . , _ . � � . . , � COUNClL FILE NO �"� CITY O�F ST. PAUL R�esoil�utian Ratifying A�sessment By— � File No. ��7� In the matter of the assessment of ►Mrfits,� !M� +�i r11�MNi � � a1Ml ��A� �tlr teiiwat�. .�e�t�l-�IN 1►� i�r. Nw►1�1 �te�t a �. i!t�t,. under Preliminary Order Mt�� ,approved � '�� 1'1� , Intermediary Order ��� ,approve� .�"��'.� �'� —_, Fina1 Order �3Ti!? ,$PProve� ���l.�l�3 . A public hearing having been had upon the assessment for the above improvement, and said asaess- ment having been further considered by the Council, and having been considered finally satisfactory, be it therefore RES(yLVED, That th�e said asaessment be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified, and the same is hereby ordered to be submitted to the District Court of the County of Ramsey for canfirmation. BE IT FURTHER RIESQLVE�D, That the said assessment be and it is hereby determined to be payable in � � equal installments. ,.;.�. COUNCILMEN Y� cG���. r , Na�� F EB 1 �� 19G� �., , _ :� Adopted by the Council i:� . l �E� 1 a ���� �;e. ,.� Fe, , n A rov�i Ter.. _ o �u `� L—In Favor ` Mayor � A gainst Fo�, x-z zn� io-sa a� P4�BLISHE� ��B 1 '� 196b � .� N' ^ , ,� _ . . �� CITY OF ST. PAUL (�O9 . 2�s2.�9 OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONE'R OF FINANGE Report of Completipn of Ass�ess�me�►t File No. �� In the matter of the assesament of #M��ls� MNq MM MI�MiA �[ � �It i�'�i� �rl�M 1ria�dsr�rr r� M� �� �ar t�i fs�wt �a► iwar� R�.• under Preliminaxy Order ��� ,approve� �'� '�s �� , Internaediary Order !�' ! ,approvecL�!� f�, �!� , Final Order m'�f ,agprove� ,� Z• �-� • To the Council of the G�ty of St. Paul: The Commiasioner of Finance hereby repo�ts to the Council the following as a statement o�the ex- penditurea necessarily incurred for and in cannection with th�e making of the above impxro�vement, viz: Total consbruction costa . .. .. . . . . ... .. .. .. .. .. .. . $ 11_3 52 3 9 Engineering . .. .. .. .. . . .. . . .. .. .. . ... ..... .. .. . . . $ 1�158 ]�_ - Inspection . .. .. .. .. . . .. .. . ..... .. ..... .. .. .. .. ... $ 59 �_ Posta� cards . . . .. .. . . .. .. . . .. .. .... . . . . . .. .. .... . $ 2 -Z� Publioations . .. . . ... . .. .. . . .. .... ..... ...... .. .. . $ 27 �� Collection costa . ... . .. . . . . .. . . .. ...... .... .... .. . $ 54 9�_ Court coats for co�nfirmation . .. .. .... .. .. .. ...... . $ 2 �_ Comptroller cost 27 00 TOTAL EXPF�I,TURES . .... . . .... . ... . . ...... . $ 12�684 QL Chargeto . . . .......... .. .... .. . . .... . .. .. . . .. ... $ � 12.684 07 NetAssesamen.t . .. ...... .. .. .. . . . . .... .. .. . . ..... $ Said Commissioner further reports that he has a.ssessed and levied the total amount as above ascer- tained, tawit: the aum of $+_.12,684.07 upon each and every lot, part or parcel af land deemed benefited by the sa.id improvement, and in the case of each lot,part or paxcel of land in accordance with the benefits conferred thereon; that the sa,id asseasment has been completed, and that hereto attached, identified by the signature of the said Co�mmissioner, and made a part hereof, ia the sa.id assessment as com�leted by him, and which is herewith submitted to the Council for such action therean as may be considered proper. ,,, , � _ > ; December 19, 1967 " �� �,}�d issione 'of F"inan • Form B.E 8M 10.88 8� - - -.s 1*:.si��.7�iY �'�a-e.€.a-����--,s ,°"�'�.,":�.°'°'��:t' �'�c�tlX-�'`"":�a�'��""�z.r^'a�*. .... ...., .,,d ,., .. . , . . .. .,.v .> . .. ...,z . .. , �, ... . ^;n r_.,.ti . .. , _ , .. . . � . . , - _ � �a = yr a _. � . �. ._._ • - , . � ,. - �. � _ r ,,_„ ; ., , � ., -: , ,� : � l61t� .4� ,._. ���� ��� �� : �}a�•�.Q� pt '� �';�'8��1 �t?t��B#R�. C�'�* �}� �'�. �"� �ri7'�''t �� �t,�P�l, �I�. ��� 'G� , �+as t�r�3� �' Fct�ss ��« Cc�ua�l�1 �'�.� �'4. �''� ID+�t�. czF �'i:ra� ��3.� �o. 16� ��.�� ._ �h�s �s '� �dv3�r� t�at a�zr � .3+o�tr�d �� � �'er�l� �t.r ��« Pa�1, �S�rr�. _ �s bo� ��d ae � d�ar's�� ��� a�' 'C� t���1� +�3 garadir� sat � �., �. �., ��. es e�rd+�*3 �d+eo� #h� �ba���t. � +►�+�� t� Cit� a� 9t. P�iul or �be +r��fca� aar b��Z � p� �c�r �+r da� ��d � �t�s r� ... ; a�t�3� e►�+�ar� tr�t� s�e 3�d r�o �cua�al. �a Ti"x.�� ��s�u�� Cc. � �r�arb��► d�t,�d t�t �� � � �t ��.t� � r�► � � ia �r bou�ut►. R�w�rv�oc, !.� �s nQ� y+�� b�a �+t��d � �r �t �s t�� � b� ��`�� +� �e bs�r�� io f�d ar� va �va b�nea� �►3� n+�� ts� t�er d� �r s�' �t�ue 3.�s� ��am�t �� s� '�►LI► �'�. �►I�I�d o1r'+� ��e o�t` �et� �aa � f�oo C���.1 Ca. '1� 1�r � �::.:�. C�4 �t 3�►1�«�bb +t� 3p►�.1�►. Alsa �� �e a� �o�" �+�r�t�e !� �s � - �rM33. Co. �c► � ��+r�re�'�e 1�! �pr. t�o. ���!��i�md s e� ead' ��r #�s t� F'ir�et��s �d Iz�:�� C,�. ta �;� D, ���� dsla� �-1�"a but � ve d3d n�t r�i� �1�l1 �.��i6�6. �� �au�► � �ao�#�'�cl �, �ts c� �me�g� te� - t� ��v � J�� 1"5�►� � d3a� �ot ��+ '�tto �a�� `�c b�.tt 3�t'� � �rt�. A�ril, 1.9b�. : W� waulcA i�2� liS�� �a a�t,��a #�t '� ��a� ��av�d t� �t�#r� �� a'�.o� tho e�3�lv aY ttie hc�u��r �3 �cat� ��'L t�t �a�C� �Cii+t�t� a� � � ��a _ t�u �r�u c! Vt�.tu��l.+rrr�a #`c�t`�rd�llt3 t� t�3. � �� � � s�+ed �ur� ��tesr:� F�e�i. �To�a�1�d ye� gl�e �`cz�''rr�t�d tas � oc�y a#` #�� A��d. �� vt�t ��°, a �. �77�•�d �s �A� _ �. �, ' ��'24• ' � ' t�� �i'�t t� �c�gt� ��`� Cr��t:�:t ���.or, - In�� � y�: �� '�t� �a ��� �1 � ��a�d m�'tgagO c� t�� ��'�' � aa� a��+�o�a� � � � � �'� � �_ ' : tcs b�t� fi�t�m �_ �+�tcu�� t� 3fi� e�,'i�:ls� . . .;_ � ... _ � �r.-e . . . . .._ . _ - _ � _ . . - : : _ ;u - �. , .__ , ._ _ ..�, ... � .h.t.. . _,.r _. _�_... ,�e � ..�...,. _ "� _. .-s a' , �r 4 - �r� r � •: a�q^'-f`' —vy�';}'t", � Y .gXZh'"'�� s.�.. 7+3Y.'- �°'.., ' �"- - •v-., .�e�- r _ 'k "Ttf'..'� T _ '-1�b .5�?`� _ - k _ „Jx� �'.,"�' �z. ..(. �.. ,�,��f . ' a �.'F,,.::, "nf':'ewns�1I�' - . . '.". ya' p.; �'�'+"'' \�� e • f z LLy � � � . � ��, '. • ,. ;. . .� j .e•'_.. , ... � � . ._� .. _ . .,. ' .. . .. . .� ,�: � . _ � : r ., - � ..� . . . � " . . �.p . ->. . . �. . .� � . - � l�X.li/L'�1�'�`'�''���'' � � � � ! � J +��i..'t�`� �.�� ��'.' - �� ;; . ,, . .• -` - �s i�a �`�,QQt��'�i"K��ia� �va . - " �.7w� �lE�is ��� ����i ��is �+ �t ��:ffi+l J�l,�.i�' t�i�.�.,�m+�s < . �* 4�g�.�Fot,�e� 3s� �+ aPt`�SO er�r� � � �t �i�.��lv�� �i�.3,�S�. �� I�izuavr�t�t� 8� � ��. � tu� b��. � a1�3��� h� �, t�' tt�k�r !� #�e p��t� �� b�ti�e► ��+�t. _.�`�1�+e� ��� c�` '�' i �r�ditic�n �a s�`+�d,�u�t9r.� �'�� �ad . , : ;- � �� a'��'��t �` �t � �' �i'�'�ed fi�# '� ::c�r ��� �tt���� ��.3. ����� ��� � . �'�ab�3.3;� � �.t +r�`:�'�h"��� d� � tho �� �� �c� ��' : 8 . +��� ��aC+�+��► .:� �� � �t�#� � �� +��a��ss 4�3�3. . . . ;. . � " ���.���tiir' � �tii �ik�.�� t�t �'r�� �a� �+�'�� . : �� � ��� � 1� � '�ew ��� e��, w� �e �tk� '�� yo� ��� t�t '� � ���1 �.3ab�.i�y �rie� �c ti�� v� m� �� t�t�It on � �:la�� t��. �a �t�l� �It���'�+� � `+'ww1�`�'��'�'�� . _ _ 1c�r� �h9� '�'�,y, . (� ('� �w�� ���L�� � . � . � . . . � . � �l.'.�5 i.•��A1.� d. V'r.'1�� axr`-� .. . . . . . .. . �t� �;��3�3�$�. : DClpW . , _ � � -�, ; � . �# � � � �. .� . n.,x > ,, , , :, � . .� ._ , , ., � r _ . - . ., --- �.._,,,.� -}..« . , •' � , ' � _4. R.'j3a�nit�rt: RFSIDENT ViCE PRESIDENT ' . .�/ FIREMAN'S ;�. , �'UND � { �� ��lERICAN MINIVEAPOLIS BHANCH UFFICE: POS1 OfFICE BOX 985 • ��NNEAP�LIS. MINNESOTA 554»G � INSURANCE COI�4PANIES er+oNE� �Rnn�k�in a so3� May 19, 1966 �. �,_. Mr. Geor�e I7. Fiothe 814 Hazelwood St. Paul, Minnesota Our file 359 L I1I979 f3ur Insured - Walter 3. Ebertz D/B/A : W. J. Ebertz Company Date or loss - Fall of 1965 Dear Sir: This is to inform you that we have completed our investigation on the above-eaptioned claim and our investigation reveals th�t our insured performed �his job in the accepted standard pracedure ror his industry and we can find no negligence on his part. I must , therefore , respectfnlly deny any and all claim� for damages re- sulting from the above-captioned lss. �incerelya � � � � ' �,��-• , ;r_� � ��ti�l�,I � t Thomas H. Otley �:, C�sim� R�presentative THQIns J. WILLIAM DONOVAN � `��� O� 223-5317 Valuation Engineer ROY E. BREDAHL, 1r. C I T Y O F S A I N T P A U L Ass't Valuation Engineer BUREAU OF VALUATIONS 286 City Heil Saint Paul, Mienssota 55102 � February 9, 1968 To the Honorable Mayor and City Council City of Saint Paul Gentlemen: Re: Condemn and take slopes, and grade and surface with bituminous material, Ross Ave. from Hazelwood St, to Germa�n St; also construct public sewer in Ross Ave, from a point 125 ft. , more or less, west of Germain St. , to Hazelwood St. This report is prepared pursuant to the request of the City Council on January 17, 1968, at the hearing on the ratification of the assessment for the grading and sewer orders in Ross Avenue. The first portion contains a history of the proceedings followed by the recommendations of the Department of Finance and the Department of Public Works. The hearings on the above subject improvements were before the City Council on May 4, 1965, on the basis of established formulas and policy for assessments with estimated rates as follows: Grading Ross Avenue - $17.00 per assessable foot Sewer - Ross Avenue - $ 9.30 per assessable foot A report to the Commissioner of Finance (copy attached) was presen- ted to the City Council on that date of May 4 recommending a depart- ure from the usual formulas for assessing this particular improve- ment and that the following formulas apply: l. That the corner lots whose long sides abut the pro- posed improvement be assessed 40% of the actual frontage instead of the usual formula of 50% of the actual frontage, restricted to a depth of 125 feet. 2. That where the sewer abuts the corner lot, said corner lots be assessed a maximum of $75�..00, without restriction as to the depth of the lot. � -z- 3. That all other lots and parcels of land abutting only on Ross Street be assessed on the basis of their full frontage with no allowance given because of the propertyTs elevation being below the grade of the future Ross Street. These formulas would result in the following estimated assessment rates: Grading Ross Avenue - $14.25 per assessable foot Sewer - Ross Avenue - $ 7.28 per assessable foot The Council adopted the report and laid over or continued the hear- ing to June l, 1965, with new notices to all abutting owners advising of the proposed basis of assessment. On June 1 the Council approved the final orders for all of the subject improvements. The slope order was processed and the ratification of the awards for slope damages was approved by the Council on August 4, 1965. Slope awards were paid to two property owners for improvements in place within the easement areas. The total expenditures on this order amounted to $180.60. The grading and surfacing and sewer construction work was completed during the 1967 conatruction season. Public Works has reported final costs and the assessment rolls were processed for hearing of January 17, 1968, with an additional four-week lay-over to February 14, 1968. New notices of the revised hearing date were sent to all abutting owners. Objections have been made concerning damages for slopes. As previ- ously stated, the City Council ratified the award of damages for slopes August 4, 1965,, prior to performing the work. Slope awards are based on the value of, or damage to the existing in-place improve- ments. It is often difficult to anticipate all elements of damage prior to the construction work. Should the property owner conclude there were inequities in the award, I would recommend a letter be filed with the Council as a elaim for damages to be processed and investigated further by the Corporation CounselTs Office and the Bureau of Valuations. The various engineers' estimates and final costs, as furnished by Public Works, are as shown on the attached sheet. As shown, the final cost reported for sewer exceeds the (preliminary) engineer's estimate by approximately 23 percent. This was a combined project, however, as bid by the contractor including the rough grading and sewer under one contract with City Forces performing the fine grading and surfacing work. Although the separate rep orted final costs for sewer exceeds the original estimate by approximately 23 per cent, the combined total expenditures on this project exceeded the combined estimates (preliminary) by only 6.14 per cent. It must be emphasized that the � -3- preliminary rates are only estimates and not guaranteed rates. It is policy where a contractor's bid exceeds the preliminary estimate by more than 10/, a hearing on the award of contract is held so as to notify the affected owners. Since the combined increase was approximately 6%, no notices were sent. The assessments for sewer and grading have been processed in accordance with recommended pro- cedure stated above, with final assessable rates as follows: Grading Ross Avenue - $14.03 per assessable foot Sewer - Ross Avenue - $ 8.972 per assessable foot The assessment for sewer on long side properties is $75 with full assessment on the interior lots. An additional charge of $6.30 per parcel of property is made to cover costs of notices, publications, court costs, etc. The processing of the orders has been performed in conformance with the previously recommended and adopted procedures. I would, therefore, recommend ratification of these orders. However, since the amounts of the assessments are a burden on some property owners, I would also recommend that the assessment be placed on a ten year installment basis. Yours very truly, �(1'.l:����; "�-- 3 J. William Donovan � Eug e V. Avery ec: G. Beckett r� - � . -� �. � � � � . Q A � G� �� � �� � n �' x �1 0 ` . I �-- `� "' �' U� L� _ � + I � ± ; ' � N , j Kq�r1 �rn � p � � . �- � v J� N -U'-° � � � 7 � �m � �, � � p f'! .r�a 5 n Ui ' R= cp . h--I ., � , • �'. � � �CJt �Cr� � � r�' b� ! �-m � ��„ ��1 J 0� �.� ��'� C � U1 �� �r:. U7 � u-� n� 6� O CTl � 6� �n � `� � ' �,� � � �' N M W C9 ' ,.,n � �`' ' .� • ; -f� '`� p w . t� _ N o �v �� h, N � _n. ; rc- m V� N o a I.,a ln o ___,. _�� . � • � ^� I � � N D v� �� � �� � � � � � � ..CTt '� .vr �N � � � (�n ... a° s �v b` -t� ° _�I � � � n1 r� � � c;o c,, p cn . � -c � 3. � rv W l� � s� N ._._ o � � N � N Q � t,a � � O � ; O � ' �.{- t.� � � Cfl (J� G1 �J'1 -t � N 1 (P �"� �'� W G1 61 (,� W o � W -� -� � = � (�J' ; p � � � �` _i Q.. � N W � � 61 O � �' O , �.._ �..- - - - � � ' I �*.t ' Q n.� ��. �J � `n�' /� � ` W V� � .. v'> �� � � u� V1 `� �• CA N � 6ti UO � �� �,�w (� l,3 � � O � . � � , �1- , W � � . � ` �, p o o � V` ' �_ '~, Q � � o - \� N ^� � � .� � ' • . � � \ p`.\� e ♦ / � �� p � � � , . . �T, � � , � �'° � � � �, , �, �\ �� �\' r � `� � � �. � � � �, � .s . � � }• R c,, C1'1 �`) f �°�` :;� �. � ' l � `� `-4 � �,� �,.� .� � � q 3�, �. `;. v� ����' � �^''� �h'�� ' :�, ��. �_. . _. ' y - � , f � -+� ��;�� ���'��� , � ��+r���'�� � ���'�'� ._ , ° . �` ���� �` . . , . . , , . „ . �!� �-_ � � , . . #��rr�i� �r� � "` ��a�r�`����r ��r�r�. _ �,� �� �����..��� ��;;' ��� yj• ��� F '�b' ' � . f . . � ��1�r`�t.ail$�iIQIM��#�r�wl �' _ � � '` ���_ � _; �-���► � . . . ��ui:� �:�.: . . . . . . .. ��.. . _..`� . . . . �. . . . . . !°.. . . � - . � . . . .. ., . . . ,t �� w ����� . � �� p . � � . .- . ' . . ,�,�.� � �wt+�c���; �tr ,M�, �� �w '�� �'� '���s .�� s � - i � "� ' � .. ' � � } :�� '� _ _ �- �� ,� r � � � '��' F �� 5; ' �� , � ,, . ; �� � � - . f � . '� �:�' � �� f ,# } �� �� y� �. �l k _.� .'����, `�. � } . ..' ,...��. t . .-.'� . ... .�� i, � �� :� . � . , �l t1� ., ":- '^��� , : •, � , �• 0. � .. . '�'' IS' F yi Y . ., .. . 1' _ � ..� , . . � ... .. � . � , .. "lv . _. . '�`. � �� !��" .;, , � ����� �. , ��"r�,�> , � ��� �,` F���< � � �� - r���� � �` �$ � � �;� ���5` � _� '� � � �`" � ,�`' � " ::�i�`: � ���=��,��'�� ... ���,�,,.�„ ��,J� . � . � . . . . : . . . . . . . . . ... . .� ,. . . . . . . . i,: �1 ,� .� . � � � . ..�� � �'�Y� �`r.. r �. :�"��•� , . . . �. , � �5 _ � ,� .�,y� �- ' . ... �A�� � � � �-� b � �9�,�' . . _ ! �'�':� �► � �'' , � , : ...� . �,... ' � . h.l. � � ' . � '!� �, .'� � �� � . �« 1� �Iw�rrr iMw:�r � � , :����, � ������,�-���'����� ��� �.�.�lp�►;+�;�+1i��'� 'i�t���- . � , � � �� � ����:�� �� ��a3u� �.�.�� ''�_ ����' _ ��'' �`�. �`x ���; , � '����'+���� �'� �?� ��'����'-��� i�l.�'�`,�' ` ` , , � . � � '���,�` '�;�I,MM���� ���, >'�lt#�`` ;�'�.:� �'��I����. ;, �':� ����'�' ��: '� � �•�' '� �1 ? _, . � - ��T .i `a F�'��`��.'.�� �. . . . 1 5�:. �.� � * iJ{ � � ��. a ,.� ��N����iM��� • � ;����� ' ����t����� �����` � : - ' , �� �� ,� ._ � . . . . . . -�. DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL INTRA-DEPARTMENTAL COMMUNICATIOfJ O T0: James J. Dalglish FROM: J. William Donovan DATE: �'anuary 23, 1968 SUBJECT: Orders to ratify assessment for gradir� and surfacin� of Ross Avenue and sewer in Ross Avenue between Hazel- wood and Germain. , On January 17, 1968, the Council laid over the heaxings on the above referenced improv�aents for two weeks to Januaxy 31. Upon preliminary review of the circumstances involved, this office would appreciate two additional weeks for stuc�y, re- view, and reporting on these matters. I, therefore, recommend th�.t the Council consider layin� these orders over to Wednesday, February 14, 1968, with no�ices to all abutting owners to advise of �he revised hearir.� date. 1 . _,_.,�,�'` � /,: � � �r': REB�jt � ���_ �=� b � � ..,� ._ _ _ . -r �, WILLIAM DONOVAN � � � � 223-5317 Valuation Engineer Q � ROYE. BREDAHL, ��. CITY OF SAINT PAUL as5�� Valuation Engineer BUREAU OF VALUATIONS 286 Ciiy Hell $eint Paui, Minneso4e 55102 ,_ ':�:� February 9, 1968 To the Honorable Mayor and City Council City of Saint Paul Gentlemen: Re: Condemn and take slopes, and grade and surface v�ith bituminous material, Ross Ave. from Hazelwood St. to Germain St; also construct public sewer in Ross Ave, from a point 125 ft. , more or less, west of Germain St. , to Hazelwood St. This report is prepared pursuant to the request of the City Council on January 17, 1968, at the hearing on the ratification of the assessment for the grading and sewer orders in Ross Avenue. The f irst �,�rtion contains a history of the proceedings followed by the recorr��dations of the Department of Finance and the Department of Publ�c Works. The hearings on the above subject improvements were befor� �the City Council on May 4, 1965, on the basis of es�Cablished formulas and policy for assessments with estimated rates as follows: Grading Ross Avenue - $17.00 per assessable foot ' Sewer - Ross Avenue - $ 9.30 per assessable foot � A report to the Commissioner of Finance (copy attached) was presen- ted to the City Council on that date of May 4 recommending a depart- ure from the usual formulas for assessing this particular improve- ment and that the following formulas apply: l. That the corner lots whose long sides abut the pro- posed improvement be assessed 40% of the actual frontage instead of the usual formula of 50% of the actual frontage, restricted to a depth of 125 feet. 2 . That where the sewer abuts the corner lot, said corner lots be assessed a maximum of $7�.00, without restriction as to the depth of the lot, ' -z- 3. Tl�a t all other lots aiid parcels of land abutting only on P�oss Stree-t l�e ass�ssed on the basis of their fu1]_ f'rontage with no al7_owance given because of the property 's elevation ]�ein� be]_ow the ;rade of the future Ross Street. These formulas would result in the following estimated assessment rates: Gr_ading Ross Avenue - $14.25 per assessable foot Sewer - Ross Avenue - $ 7.28 per assessable foot The Council adopted the report and laid over or continued the hear- ing to June l, 1965, with new notices to all abutting owners advising of the proposed basis of assessment. On June 1 the Council approved the final orders for all of the subject improvements. The slope order was processed and the ratification of the awards for slope damages was approved by the Council on August 4, 1965. Slope awards were paid to two property owners for improvements in place within the easement areas. The total expenditures on this order amounted to $180.60. The grading and surfacing and sewer construction work was completed during the 1967 conatruction season. Public Works has reported final costs and the assessment rolls were processed for hearing of January 17, 1968 , with an additional four-week lay-over to February 14, 1968 . New notices of the revised hearing date were sent to all abutting owners. Objections have been made concerning damages for slopes. As previ- ously stated, the City Council ratified the award of damages for slopes Au�ust 4, 1965, prior to performing the work. Slope awards are based on the value of, or damage to the existing in-place improve- ments. It is often difficult to anticipate all elements of damage prior to the construction work. Should the property owner conclude . there were inequities in the award, I would recommend a letter be f iled with the Council as a claim for damages to be processed and , investigated further by the Corporation Counsel's Office and the Bureau of Valuations. The various engineers' estimates and final costs, as furnished by Public Works, are as shown on the attached sheet. As shown, the final cost reported i'or sewer exceeds the (preliminary) engineer's estimate by approximately 23 percent. This was a combined project, however, as bid by the contractor including the rough grading and sewer under one contract with City Forces performing the fine grading and surfacing work. Although the sep,arate reported final costs for sewer exceeds the original estimate by approximately 23 per cent, the combined total expenditures on this project exceeded the combined estimates (preliminary) by only 6.14 per cent. It must be emphasized that the � __,_ preliminary rates are only estimates and not guaranteed rates. It is policy where a contractorTs bid exceeds the preliminary estimate Uy more than 10/, a hearing on the award of contract is held so as to notify the affected owners. Since the combined increase was approximately 6/, no notices were sent. The assessments for sewer and grading have been processed in accordance with recommended pro- cedure stated above, with final assessable rates as follows: Grading Ross Avenue - $14.03 per assessable foot Sewer - Ross Avenue - $ 8.97z per assessable foot The assessment for sewer on long side properties is $75 with full assessment on the interior lots. An additional charge of $6.30 per parcel of property is made to cover costs of notices, publications, court costs, etc. The processing of the orders has been performed in conformance with the previously recommended and adopted procedures. I would, therefore, recommend ratification of these orders. However, since the amounts of the assessments are a burden on some property owners, I would also recommend that the assessment be placed on a ten year installment basis. Yours very truly, �' ��,�����: _._:.:a� __ � J. William Donovan ! i s Eug e V. Avery cc: G. Beckett � y ; � � c,n -� �� �i� �J i (f� � � I' . �� • -, � I �� � � � � �� � �, ., , �=- - =-- � " , �i J ; �_> t..1� \.� I , 1 --� -i I �- �'� ; -� �... t�: I y �, . - . j � � - � I ,- , "" _------- -- -�._..____ . . _ _ I __�, .___ _____ '}.�_N _ __ _ _ � -+- � _ _ 1_----___._. _. _ _ i �- ' __ ; . _yj �--,�l r , �.; . � i •,�' �- ,� _��,�, � � ' � -� p � `f_. :;: �D I � _ ,, i n_ m � '_" �� ' �<< l+� !'- '° I y{ � � .-�. � � � �,'' I -i� t�.' -i i :-� �.� �,, }. �� I � 7 �1 (��Z i �(rl _1� � _ �� . �-C1"I � �� � � �J � � � � � - - �UI I (�;. (Tl -� {r . ( .. � , I� t,i ,� � ,. , �., r -�- �- (n � .� �� � hl ;'� C 1 1 lti) �; � ('1 '� �' � ' �-/ ,) � '� �� � N' ��� (() � �>. ' • ` ..{., v �� � _ � � �..`� -- " �r ��r � ' (�7, '� .— � �v �51 ,�� �, N �� _Q , ._:� q, � - �� l�) �> l �.�� � `'� v'• v ''; ', ________--_ �--------- -- ;-- -------------- _._.�__._._._.....__ _ ._ _ -- � --- ____...__i rTl � , `1 ; ; I � ' .:> , � i � . U� -�, �� . ; � I ; � � <� i ' ; ; c�.� � ; �, r� i _ i `� cn i `6` (n � � rn .- �-� i �,, , -� C n ' �_ ,� �R I � i � r a � � �� �`.,1 �, ..t \l 1) I �F \� �� �� �' -�7 � 1\ 7 � �J �, Ll � !n � :� �' i _� - � � � � \ . i �n r_,i �,1 1 ft l7 � �A � ._ '-- �.� I , - S� � �� � t�vv �'� �__ � n ��j t� ; 6� 6� CJ � !il \_ __- � , — l_> ��� ' _. _ _ .,.. ! ____.__....___.___�—_ - - � ---._.—__ --- ------ -.. ..__ __._. _�..____�. . i —-- --_ � !� � �) � I � � rf_ � - i i � ,� Cn I � i �? ; �:� (n j n U' � .: � ' �;; n �.� �� (n i ct� J C� i C•,` 3 C�J� I (1� � ��� ��� �., ((1 � n _z= �i I : �� cn . � - ` L`-- � " � , ��� �� I v ;� (n � �� N n i �" �: �,� �� �9 � � � O i O � e p ; � _ ,.___. ._. --;...�._�_ —-- _ _ . _ I _--_ ....-- _. --- _-----�__.�-- � � I � � i i ' � i � i � %i I i i i J I . I � I � i I � I i /� I (�f) I '� � "� \ , - • 1 � lT1 (Jl ,� 6'ti �- �,1 ��.� � ,61 �. ��� �� . �, : ... -, !�-� --� 6� rr, �' �-'- t f� � ,i �� � ,� �d � ')i '� � -i' �� �:� �, U �,» {r� I �i-- i --' � � ._ -� ('i� 5� �.'� �� _ � . . . I . ; .� 'r t ��'tl :•,: � �- 4'• �� ��i � �� p ; . ! � ' - -- l7 i ^' J � �- �J ,,� � _ ___+____'--___ ._ _ __ ,_...__-_ _______ ._ _..__.. l _..�__'__`_'""__—.__�_._ ...�-���_�___ __"_'. ' i � i i � S.� i i ,� �� i i S� •F f � �'� , � o\ � , � ` � ,�� ` . � . .� :�� � . � , • _ , . A� � 1 i ` • j� �v ;;_ , ;t.. I�,, � r � ' �I � ' ``` �` � . . 'i-� � . �,v ('f. _ I�. �l. 1 �� ,�. � , � ` l� � 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..:..y ✓ wT" r � , . ?0: Jam�s .1. Dalglish, Comn�isslona�r of l�inanca FRuM� .�. tdi13 iam Ilonovan, As�t. V�ivstio�n �tigine�r T�AT'L o Maqr 3, 1965 SU�C7� Crr�ling cf Rosg Avenus betve�n Har�slYOpd a�d �sr�in Stre��E� �rad canaLreact ing s sewer �equixed Lo ser�v�a ebutt�ng �'�ant�g�s. Hoth of th�ae arda�a come befare thra C�on�tcil on �2� pet�t�orn►�s ot three �butting Prop�r�,Y o�mer�. '�he c�rig#r�l e��►i�tts�t c�t t�s costs on thes� pro,�ect� Were bas�c3 rnt owr usual torm��I�s lot� assessing cot�n�r �.ota �nd ��ducing th� as��aueble l:�aAteg�a fo�r lots xhich ar� svbstatttia2ly belc� tha propt�sed t�tr�s� grade. Thase formv2�►� reaul�ed in tt� foli�r�ng e�timsted aca��s per asssss- ab2� Soot� t�rafling .. �1�.U0 SsWer ,. � 9•3� The fo�r coxrters in �hl� b2ock have bess� devel�d ao t�s to 1'aoe Ha�eixood and Gerfnaic� Stre�sts, �Q t,he qutstareding notfctic� resulted �.n prot�s�s froau �h��e avners tt�t Lhey �rere bvd t�g as�s�+�d �x�e�.. siv�ly �'or thg devs�op�ent in the cran�t�l t��► t�t t�he �2o�k w��ich r�quir�s con�iderable cut �d fiil to prwide g u��abl� strtst graide. Tha graui�d conto�rs in ttafs ar�a ars t�u�u�12y ssrattc �ci, tn gen- �raZ, cot�sld �� described as a grad�.ai rise �Q�ncing at Ne►���vood StraeL and enc�izag i�c � knc,x�. �hieh f.s spgro�imate�.y 12 feet abovo th� grade of Ha��ala�ood, �n�4 tnen dropp ing abrugtiy to s �a�ade about � i0 feeL belc�r ths grade of Haze�wo�ad and 25 fe� bsl�r► t2�e grade of . t3erma�ia Street. Interiar lots, r�prc��n��ng �bout �40 tset ot' f,;ontag�, will be sp�roximatel� 1!� feat belov th� gradt b� fu�ut�e Ro�s Street. The propo�ed grading vauid consiat oY rs�aaving th� pr�eea�t riss !n grade �nd �he }mo�l ancl using the etate�ial to fill tht �ra�Iley #�sc.. �ion. 't`�.is, �f co�se, xc�vld result ic� a cut �pproximattns 12 teat in tt� knol! s�c�i�n ot the pre�ant terra��. Af'ter turth�r atudy of the probl�s� �d vieain� ttNa arsa �n qu�atian� I w�d s�eComaend a depasiture fror� tt,s usual fox�maias for �a��a�ing imprave�nts of this type end tt�� ths falZawing Sor�ula� apply� 1. t�t the cornatr lots xhose Yonp �idsa e�t3ut ttu pro_ po��d impacov�aent bt asseaa�d J�t'D� ot the actuai tront_ age inst�ad of thQ usua�. foriaula a►t' SQ� of ths actu�l frontag�, restrict�d to a d�pth a�f 2?5 feetj 1 � . . . y � y . ' � 2 — �y 3, 1965 2. that where th� seu�er abuts tt�a dorner 1ot, a�d d cQrner 1,ots be as����ec� a m�:xim�sm o�' �7s.Q0, wi�hout r�astric.. ticas� s� to tt�ra depth of the 2ot; 3. th�tt al2 uther Iots and peresis ct �turd abc�t��ng cfn�,y on Ross S��ee� b� a�sessed on �hs b�►sis pf t2�i� S'essil frontage vi�h raa a,tla�r:�ca g$vea 1a�caz���a of �Gt�e p�rc�.. pez�y�� ¢X�rat#cr� 3a��.rz; be�.��r �h� �z►�!� 4f t��.futur� Ftc��a 5#�.�'�e�. Th�se fornn�lns �rou1c� r��t fn whe fa�2c�orit�,q ��tir�tgd rt�t�s per assessrablr� foc�t G��utin� - �11�.�5 S�ar » � ?.28 'The r�r3s�d fas�al�s �se� sug���t�d only 3�ectt�use b�th o� thasa vrdars arc ur,iq�ue mr,d pr�sent cl�v�.vpz���t �rc+b�,�ms. Ttte petitiosi�rs ars the o�rners o� pra�ticaily a�i �f ths 1a�..lying �ot� and sh�+u�d recc�g.. nizs that Lh� pa���sy t+en�f�t t� tv the l�r»�ying Pr'c�Per�L�+�s. In ord�r that the ps�cpsrty o�mera r�y be advieed ss t�o th+a baeis on �rhfch th�e k�earin� �s txid, I ��s2d furthe�c ��cc�tet�d Ch�t th�ss mat- t�r� a�d th� he�ing mn th� ar�oge� eaa�m�ts A+e laid r�r�r �c thg ls� d�y of June, 19��s wd�h n� natiae� �Q be �ent t.a the pz�apsrty a�m�rs. . ,�t . z3�� � y , . , �._ i �� � :�' � � � . � . .. .. , �:'�:-����� t U , ; � i� J �.,, 4'� ' v , `) ., r � � � ,, f � . t l '� !'�t�- G c. ,' ° {`. j% � f`, ( ,..c ;/`_.vx � _, r `, /'"��`. Z;�t^;7 c. .� tr.. �� -, .t.: , , i ?;• c _ i� '� i, • ✓/ . . �' � . - - ! ; ,� . ._ _ i + .. 1�4 ,� � �i i��...1 �� . j:�(•�-'7i.i L. . �. , �. L, C � Z,;' C c, ' • V i � . � ` : , ., ;, _ - C:; r_ � ; ,. �, ,�� . . , ,' " t:. i ,.� � , .. � i ,...�.. �. . " . .t:�,; <, _- _ � t' . ; , .__ � .. � ' •. , f � ., • �° �. / .a ..`,. /:.�_ r ; Z�� '/ t�"t�. 1 ,, ( i'i ` I 1 -� t.�_.� � � ? i..-�� -�.., . , Z �.-r.. � , �.. � j �� > � _ l-. �� �` � �1� i �; • " -� I !' ' C =' �'.-7 � t .-y� � . .. ._:- �, � ; ,,, , �^.L' .. � .`. � � J C� .� C,, C� I : , , . , , ,_ , , : < - , - � ._.� �<�_ �s ?_,t , ,..... /-:-t ;,, ��� - -- , r; ., , ;.�� ,,._ , � �•r ( , ,, ' jti •. � �( .'f [ i, � • 7 i' /(- �`^��. ' � a. �" %�i, 4l��� . . .C. c. L ,,�� � r-� � � ��. _�� l'�,'Y � � 1:'� (f " : s J" ' : : � : .; -` ; ; '_ — i � . • _._.__.. .. ` . � y ✓l 1 �' �� .. - , �.` � '' ' ' � � / '� ;�� t,� r , , �^ f � ,. ,' �. �, �� i �. i_s�. '�` , -� .I.�)2..t�,�'` C., C; 7 �j-.-�,.�] �:�.i�L. ��.. r. � � ! .. . ��7 Z L�r � ', -�� �`,�'>'� � .- � ' ,' � '� �� � f�' L� � � f � � ' % - ` � r 1 :� \ � f 4. ���_.��_ �" . E .- '.__:4 � ,:�j, � �.,-7� �� :, �� .',� � ....,. . , ..� � f 1� ?/'' � ''�/' . C: � '. -4� j �" � • i - i , r' �' .-'� , t t �� � t � ' J � C l �. Cc �i ' `,. ,'� if t . , - � � L �i'�/ - � � .� � ,.-�__ ��;'l f 3 � _,`:T/ l.,/ S � �..� 'i- -{� i � �/ :�t,, �. �'`' . J . i"' ;' �� �..�J., lt� , � -i.: ;� , ,. � !, ;4, ,� � �l- ��� .� � ,, i . ` -�, ? % ( .Gri� �• � �. t ' f � v , � �.. >� �. ` V � , 1�. i ;; r, � �_�� '�'"� � _f�!J �� ��_ � D,°!'�,:._ ,�,�Li � 4'y�•��' � .. ` j. '�. t j,I. l.. .._ .. : ' r ''` ; {,' � , L.. �� r ♦-..i ,-� �� T " J �� ��/�.i r,j't .�-t i'... �,�_C;'i., . v:_ J�� �� . . ,��� . ._ �. .i .. � _ . . - � {�Z JL.. �.. .. _._� �,�, ...,� , {� 3'4'C... �` L` .. �+, �Z: - ..�-..._ ' �-'.,_, . � . , ....., ' . ' .- " . �: % ' .,_ ;i � / 't_i'.L,,.{ Jl.� '/ �, l+ / � l— " :GC�`t�— � A i , , : �. - t, t t j_`'" �- �; � � , �.�.� 1 • i_-. � : .. <, -� . ��C-„ 1 L., � . ✓_-, r� _. j . r �: .. j.. �; � A `�..� �j�- � ti. ✓ ..... � . . , ! . ,. . . �� � , /� � . :. i �../:\� � _ �,` c: ',,>' {_ i ty�(' ' ''- •. Y�:-,('t. �;.-�7'�, � � ` - �'�. . �:Cr �,i.�'.�j,. l•�.L �,,. • /!N,\ 4/ . �� . ....... �.�� .. i. = ....- •' , �-� < �� - - , � � � � r'" � `(`-- ,, �_�.�' �� L . �,.? � U 'i�,�� � "✓� ,. t .._.�,�� �-'Y7;"L� !L.-�.-+�'—L. l.�, _...,. _ " . ,/� :' . _.._ � ,- , , , : : .._ � �_.,_ � L .f� .� / f l � . _.. ! i /', � V - ' � .. � ... ' ,`. �-"�"� �:�� l_ L._.. ( � ",� �/'l..:c. ! �..`!�� t,/� ���1..�� :( . . , ,- _--� , . , , . f /� . , . - ; / . . , .,(,.� . :, � .. . . . �, �- {��. / _ � i �� %. � . . • ;.•..=,' i t,. L..`.-tl'�. �'`.-•�i C. ;i ��_�\ (.Y�'�Ll.:. °�-�f'j..'?,.� t,4�'../-i-��...� `. - -� �-� ,. �. 1 �, �: _ �L•�. . - �- _ /; %-= i ,-"� _ _,•; , _f�, ., �. �; ; ,, .cJ / � �: % -�.,�:_. � - :, � " s � -� t c.. ... _ ,_. � , � . _ �. ,_. �� �..--� - c_: � �-� , . (.':' ` `—' -"� j, � I'(.i c �'c:-T �,'�.�, �- _t �i b� L%� ' .f .;� (% 1 � � 1 �/'•.^ 1 . .. / � .'�..� ./� , - ..� ..�`--� .,� �J l.�� `..:�l.� (,-t'`" :.�(�. �. � • / ,. ;'� . ,.' 1 � ;� ..� j ; _C...i.. _. 4�;,?-��� �. �1 Z.i _�.'-C �, t_G.J l� �__,C .. � � �l n r' , � .�. y� , �^. "— ( \. �/ - / �j�" C� __�-- l� � , , /"j� �' � � � �, f--e� , V� �lr� �.c=�'�� C. ..—� �. �T�t� C-,t� , �L �"� /, ? _..1..._ r..-' � ��, [ � C �'._`,�.. C:_�,-,-��:.�%-� s t��.'� �t t'-r—'�2- �— ._ l L f � f. -7 �,- �; 1 � � `.� ,� �� 1 ..._ � J, / ._,L,� )'.�:�� . C.+� � r' . __. i . , - ''�� /' I �. �.i.-�� ��" , l. , , .c. C��`..) t,.i 'ti.q �'_ � -zi ._�.,`--L � s;l� �,.:` •i �, � ,` /` , _ _. -, . � � � : , ; . ' - , ; , , , ; .� .r._ , � , �y �� ` � C.� �' � �.(�' �',t/._%' ( 1. t j�:. t -,: � .�_...-i �-;% C..�-t " ) ,,4'�.....� N. ;... ;.�i C. -- , ..� �- ,. / ,� � , . . , � l � _ % - , . - ,-- . '� ' - • � � L , - _. .._� , ..j:2 � � , t �, l., 4��. �C �� l�2.=!�- ' G f-� � � ^r!•(7r �'12 i'� �, .';'t. C, fi_ f i �_ �--. � �. � \._ " �" � � ' � � F, ' '_... r '_ ' " C �-, _... . ._ " '°', r -, ` / ' ... - : , C:� -� , �, ,.,. , ; U.�C=, J... , .�� _ C .J �. -� �--' Zl ti. L, , c � L(°t C. t_('" �-�,��� , � `' � . ; L 1_ . ) --__ - -j ) . ._.. 4J'-L./"j,-Z.... �,i T...,,._,� ,` //,��, � /. "7� � '�i, � ,''�.//� � �1.� L.c: ,�--- !Z. �C / C._ . ., , '� L- r � . / � �r , " ' ` !l '�' °� ,- �'�r i! i,.f�. < . '" .. I' .''. . -r/-'._,. : / � / .,l .. "l i.�'�...!� .:'��.�.�. � J �`...._. C`..'�."���� � C-"��1'-C.�� '�`'(- {-.��` � � i ,� ,t _ � � �,� � i . � ��i � ` t � l E ' ^ , L-� „ � _ �., > ry ..t ., ( �-- .�'L, ,. 7 -1 � � .L r t, �i 1... � 11. . . - � . �' •'�.J� !;` j��" .C /� �,!. ` ,.'. .Z `' -1, t �= �.��; r�t_�`�'� . 1 fi.: r �c: �., . �� +, �-' � � � J � ,:...�< .__ , ; 7) c ;' .. ,.,J .'' 1 i. j `9 r.' �� ��.� .,. ': ` _�\. � ' • ♦ l. �. � � ..�r ' _t,_:,3...��:1, .. . : ' , ! i. .� ��� c. / . :. .L . . , , ,• ... �-_� . ; , . , ; _ ' . � r� C / ✓ � t t � , 4 � ..�.f ��:_ .� -`'� F , c..�.�-_. 1 ,�:G� �_.�;�� .-�.. �' � �/i.. � C G }-�,• c `�- . . ' � _f_.)--- ! �l.��. � . �, � Lr � , �`r �: � ` r, '' �' ; f {. ��'- , s f ;,.� ,�. (.,�-t!t.�,,,`_ ,,.�� /�i(,:�'� !--^.'��, � r .- �j'l-e'. . 4 , t, I l.,t, (,;, e��.. ( �,�? ,,, � i f 2 < F 4 J ' T � f �f � � - �.L` �' �-:r�. '1 L � �f �-,_7. r_ `�. .�`-�'-- �i:__�-.�.t'.I �t-��.: ��-v�,�'? _ �. ,7 ; ,� z�� . �;• - �. � G " , � >> , _ . �� �� f - ;, - . :� , , i� /i� � : 1 Y : II .'. . , f.:' l._:• , J 1+ � .f ):.� '..,... �_; , ��; . , s .,} , �y • ; �'L. ,i / . � .1:.-'j � t v ,�_• / �.°tl �- c ( -�'�Z '_ !�/ ,: �/ I ✓ ���.'� /:�t,� "�`. . L' /{. � `� .... �.. ` ' l.. . . �' , '� .�_ ,� . , : . � � . - .'.., �r_. , � �.t , -C. , �.�l..-� �� .. ��t��..�"� �'��l.t -���•` `.`_:.{. 4 ` , �' y C ' ��. 1 ! -�' : � . �:.� � • j � . ,�. / t ��l ' �..;'`l-- r y L , ' i' .� .�; ��,�...�i L. ������/v' �/ ��{.� ` .(�/ '�1�.� . . n) 1 ,..1 �. ,. I. ' -.'.. .. .. . .--.'�."�•"f l..'l.. � � " . ..._. � . �; — `,'. � ; —� '��� �, , " ,, , �� J".. _ : �; Cr.. S� . � . (.J Z.._ � �;'._�,' t ;� (��',l�C ci. 71✓ � �. ,. i ' �' L.C. ` `t . " �� � t;'� . . r:] — ': �. �.. . , . ,� ,, ... �. , , - , • - � . _5 -- S - f , , ^� �:" _ �. � _.. .. 4"t ✓�1. �L.'-�'�l�l--` � L� C.."(,��` �..-� �..Li. �", t / !v � �.�' `'.-:.� f�.i �r c �� L, �.c'.��. � % ._ ( „ .. I . r � � ^. � � 'i ';I�'L ,(_.�- L_ ;"i: ,J,t.�,l i'.,f �: � �•../\)� / � � � (__(; ? Z.;.✓ . �.,.. �;-�,_�'_ , .'�� c�� �- ��:.. l � � - f � ,� � '_ . , , l � � � � � r � . i �; _.__ I �} q . . „� , � .� . � • �/�� .;�1 � �'.''�� ' r // 2. (, J, r �� -':Z,. t L Y . �I ��;,' � � ��� _�.i .� . _ � � � ,1?.� :_z.,l. „ ;., � . ' , _.. , , C �t��. t C i�i� �!�J� � l�j�`" '`��7� , , . , 1 c�: � r . ; _-. _ � . �..-�--�>, .-'�') t.. l � .,. ,, , ;. . . . . � � 1 ,' 'r"� . � � .�, � �� - c� . __ ;- . ; , �_ j , ; .�.. �-= r-;,fc _ � ti Y-'_ .� �` . > / � /� � . .. t �� 4.L•�� ..�. ' �(�� ! G�� (. (., -: �` � ` c.' ., .' : - , , � r , L� � :� , . � ;; ; , .` � �,� L� � c .�_ 1 /,(.�t , ;; _ (: / �r i ,, •' ..+�. /�/ � . , � , , � ` j7 � 7 . ; f 'r l l,�C c- !� ,. ' � t '� � �l.�C..-�/��., .{,.V_.i,i.� �' �, f /; �� .� /�'"�/ " _.•- %-— . /} r �(��� . /,� .' %.__ / �/ ,.<� ! 1�l�-( � .Ci�7 ����'--���!t=�-,� / . , (,L;� � �'� �" (.-�� � _,__ : ,��� �.� 7 -, ,"l �--t � . -��' , � Lr' ;'7'?"L � c t/ � ' '� �' ,, ;�� �,., � ;r; ^ `� ` ` �v L�',L.'�,c..t:� C (.t. � -'c [( / L � ,. � �,�../4 � l.���(:.�. ' .-L. , v�J.C-' .�.G`-- i� /� . '��,- V/ � �� ' i• tf .� �. ,:'' l j ` � '�:-.-C' �,_` �,_�-L�.�;.z.�-r..�.t �.•�--�t. ,. ; � ��(� " J:- ��.�;f iir�, .- , �_� �.r ._� c: �t �, , ;; ; ,� , � ; . ___ : , ,. : . , � ,-- t� -�� :,. � _, .l_ / 9�._ ..,-i,"Z � ,=�����.0 _�,1; � ,,;_;�r�t� l ��-;; _, � �- -!i:_ � �i� �--1 G�: ���z...:� , . / C jl v _� : . ..._ ; �,/ / ) -�__. . „ � � : < ,; -// �7 ! i 7 Z.� �( � �.LiZ �� L C,��M i/ t��� j l i.%',/�l i.��� C �-` l�1"f .'" �,.�:/�"�/ ���'�`�1 l-L. a- / � . �,• , ,; r� _,� - 9 � . . t, . . � � .. . � .-� , ', � ,,��' l-L.t 's �J c_-�4 , 1�-" � � ' �,i,}'2-�:.- (� .. , ` �� ` .�.__;` � . , _ � t..1..1 -�., ��-!> l:ti c.� ` � �. �J:. � �• / ' �' /'f�' f'_'�r.`!•__. ` i l�i � _...f � L;..`�..�._ L,' .�', .%"�;"` �l�'7 1 J- . � l.-f 1 l� �,l �� i�: �. . � -t..- <:�-�-7•. .� ;j �''� ;I �f :-�r .. � '._ � :�,- /,. , f . �J� ;-� , � � %- .. � . . , � ��;� .✓:.L. ;,�/` -��...0 _:_ � �,.�-•>;' - � �� -' j�''{`! �,tc /'? �/'Z�' L �, _. :-y �. . � , �./_ � �� ;. l. �� ;.F '�/.:' . 4'�� r� . y . � ! f ' �i i � �� �"�..� :�-�� � _• � "-_ � ' l �`�.. C. .`^I...0_ � �.��../,_.� - ; : ; < .. , . . : � , ,. , : � - - , , , , 1 . 't ' L � � . � /��. :...1 .; 1...�-I .. 1 .l. �L�t:�..— ' � ��.� .(. . „ 4 .!1 `� 1/1.,.:f \�' . ,, i �i "'c i.. �. ,.. � "�� � ..-_ �I(.-� .._ tr . L`- ' r 11 ,. ., . � , .._.. �' , ( ` l_. j` ! 'L J .,�; f> y� � ... �: ( _ i "Z,4��' t_Y�� ..L�� , C.�.` ;,�'L. ` ' -,`,•L��r �! � .. �;?_ L: ? �G. ��\.,... r 7 L1 ` !i V 'r _ �f . �,'�'" •'� -� ' . '� • � / ' _ _ � _ C � r , ,4 _: : ..`,..., - �:; , ;� � .: , �i.�_� � ; , ;�_._.. C � .� , t L`�. � �, r . � G, �Z ., f� �:�'� � ,,�, ,_...�._,`, : �� i, .._._ ; :� ,. �.._ ; , . ,, � ,, , : ', +;� ,� ,�- . � ,. (.Ij�.L .�% .�.1 )'�..L. (,.��i.=t - �..._- C r.;;,.l..t/�� j -�L�_'(`�• C� / �..0 J";``..'`�../,+t.'`�'l.� �y� _.�.. ;' . . c ' r � / � `__:, i' �~ l. ; '�` s` l.! Z. C.:�t. ` '-�..y- . L-. � Z'i 4 �-4-j�_ ` C_,l -�" 1.,�_.t� � � �;�..L.i-'�=��' `,, r �. i.,'I i :' � �-i� �-�,�;�-�� �� L:: i� �� �-�': / .; l_ L f 1 � ,..i;� i. t-,.7 L , , L;„� r` �, �f_ .._ �: . � . , � � . ; , -- � - . � ' � � �, � �^..� `� 4%� ���,.j _ ,, �. � �;, c r���c:' t -� ` ._�.� � � . '�� .1 l. . -s 1�. 1 - u �.. � G _ �t- �,� �/. .. r r ^ n n , • .R . . � i` � , � , � .. _ . � -. . �~ �. %�� i � � � � f `���� r" 11��� �_ �� ��� t.=� l_ -�'�'��7L t, ��i' L.. ,''�,,f.,�:�-� �. � ���.;,I �,:t'- l-ti.r.. C' �'�t: _ C�C��� �_ �. '-�.. �.i l.: . �` „ , l� J .� � .., __. � �.� y � �- ( ..( i � • � -� � .�.-i�� -�,!:�7 ..� ���.,-'t...:{.�_�\.. .'�' �� t- � , vC ��.. . � _..!' � �.. . � ( � ` .. �. �; � � �� ��; .ti.-� . � � � �., � C �� ��c -� �_� ��- ���...�_��'. �, ' ,: �-- - - , , ' .. . __ , . : . ; . . , µ_ , / .. .. - , �z:` L ��-� �� l�� 'l. c � ..� rv, ` �= ��:'�L � �,�, t� � � � : -`-Z-�:��.,,4.. r G ,.._., � C,tJ - -�� L' L - . . , _ . � .'f. � . ,. i 'j _/ J i� �(��'' ��_ � " _...,.- / /'. .` - .. �. ���..;.t�1 . C'',:� � �Y l'. 7. ���1.i �. !....t, �. ` � � ,� l .. �...[ .�-�.'> � r�`i1 /` � .._.' . > � ^ ``_,r r, l � . t.�,�,-���' t_.���rj,.'i��-�L. � , ' - � - =— - .� , . l , `,J// �.._1.,��1 C/,�. , , 1:\ r �_.i ,., j-�: '\ C''�.L /'� �, ��7` �..lr� .� `'(7��� Lnt. � • r u , i ,: b.: , , -- :1 � �� _ ;,.:_ _ , ��.:__ , ',f�.-2•'� i �.t�f�. f. 4��� .. :' )Z C.� �: �--� - � c: ��L'�'4 �1�+.� �- ti:•�-�->C�I�)Zt c, > -c. ��, t, L � , � . .:-- ' � � . , , , , , . , . . �l , l,�t u, �.� ?;C- L--� � �..c % '"'� z f9. .:t--t C� �i~_ , 1 �;� ✓� � � �..:�. 1 �. � . ' 7 `L„ 4 �. L.,, . I • �� ;. , z'% } � . ; � - �, !� _ . �' ;"' � �._`,.�G ,-3 t..G. � 4::�� �' �t, �r-�� �'�_J� , , ��.t r` i!C %;'�-'7`;r' j�_. ,. '�;1 �.. � � � . , ��- , � "� :, _ . _. � i ;:� , r . � , _. -/ � ;7 "� � .._� j 'l. � ' r r- „?,7 �� '��� �.' .Z ;. �' �:.�/._ ,.�'_�� ''..` - Lt.,- l._..'t:' �� . ., _ll../ _ .. C...'��.� c,G-' fr ` � �; / L� '- I �� �.. ! �� �� � � (/ ��� _�:. �(�/�� ���/...��1�..� �"i'_).r' ,��_ �- �! � �'� �_ ',. ,�...,�..`�� �l_i_.��' �-L. .,!�...� �,-�..���..� ll..'` ..�. _ t ......- • �(_ `i y� C. �'% . j� (i;-1. . �.' /=�� �` , , , . ✓ ' ! -- - � � / . ,, ..: _ .� /' � ;.,=.:._ �.- i 1 �- :.. 1`../�.� ,�'; �.�. "�.t:� -�T' l.. i--�.•i' i `�� . L �L t. t...r-°'l.-t. �t� • j - � � �?�t.. . _ �-��.,l_ . - , „ - '� � / �'. -t j ,'�__ ��..,` ` , ' ;'�,� - , � ' ��, �....1�f � t_�_. �-c..� 7 �.� ., �, i, -� � .�- C ;�,...<. � t_�• �- • ' c ��-�: �-- - t. , r . � ' t ,. _1 :`,.%'- _"-C,... - , � (� '`�-, ,'i � �. i. ;2%i�� („ �...'1_-`.'._ L� �,,: �.�. � ;/ r_. j.-� -�.G` �. �`" l �- -a G ` � � L,-�� ` �; {�,� � _ . • _ • � .'� y, •�1 �_ /` . � v . �� i ` �''.� � 1/•..e., c..-,_, c , � � "_.=t,`�.,_ �-� �" -�� _�t_ � �<.-: l,�"_.l___ I, �.?< < :�. . . / �. . */ / . J A ��..., �/ I �/ r ,. /� ,.� � ,`/' ; .., /\ , , r,:_ j,�^ f' . �; t'`(,�' G 1�.-�.i•, t'"� "�!"�:/ b+j''4��1. ;`..t,.-'t.�� l. �{._ .. � (:,' �-%�"i, � �.� ��/ t`..,4� ` G ,•,_�...t..i�L `.. _ i. � � `l •-.�..._. ;' � ,�� ,� � � ' r _ ��-�"� , �,�:.T t -1.. (_' (j,4_`,,�.�;.1 .+� , 1�:� � l `` �-''L �� , !` C..:�.t��- �% c ,.. L �.- f r.� t� - ���; � j;^_� / /. , '' r .' ' � .,-C.�..��.� ����f1{��r�'T. .�_�'.r�'% �.-'7 �..�{.,-�f i i-���, ��L.C. �.-,` .) �!�` �.' :�l�1.,2�.(`�`_�� �,.-�2-' :J' '--'.- y,: ; ,.. ; �. . _,:__. . � i �;.ti.'�l. ) ii�,.� ...�.'l�%� 'L � C•._�t � �-,/.�rL (;- �.L-'". � t Y �� . ;' _� ,.�+�.._. ..,.1/_ � r•_,. . ' 'i :,�j c � / � i �; _. �,/ _ .�:�._ �� ) —. , �� �.' `. y l�: "� V� i� . ` ,` . � �. , l. cj-__ �, � , Jy � ..:� CEI-l..i.. i�!'.-,1"�l.c�7 � 1 l ;{ _ � .t ,,�..Z.!�. �--�,. ., �, ` -� .i_ . <: ,1. -�.�. -� �J �. , , , - __ _,-_. __ �- � � � c t : /., -. f � i , L . ) . �f'�... .. �,, ._ _.. ,,, 1 ti `. /� �_. .� �1 . f , L� �:� ��'/"L.. , -`�r��:.l 1 t L- ( ' � v • ✓ , .. - , � _ , ' ` � Z -".._`I.., . V . I` ."..� � �'. � ,�'S L,L�. � r r!t.,��_ . -a.. :_f�;:�^— ; '. �..� �� t. , i.� %. i 'V_... � 1:' , 7 i �'� .! � "'�.�` :��� .• � ���..`..��_� � �� . i . , .:? �. �,�.:�,�.�. �-- - ` (�' , • _ . " ., /^ " �`"}' J �:7 .j; _, ., , : , t ' " � � . •• • : ,r ' i�.�-. l . ��- L. . J ..`�i:.�t..��.`....��- .i."� J'7�1-•j,�.•�.� . ^7 .` 't"��, � �(� �.� � �� li �. .-/I:.. , l._-.:. � � _ . �_���`.. V � . � �� r� . �' _ �. � � z, `,� I I � ` ( C �{,;�ti � . -t..�°. �^ �'.� �J,.e_ � ��^l % � .-; l. � S t r �' i; t ' `ll. CtC '._ _ '- - /, ` , , , t- ' ,` , . � ; , . r� , v ��� ,� � , . , � �,� f ( � , , �_t....�—.�, j , �-- .�, �;i' f..,,. �� .�:._.�.._ � `; C~/ ',�.,c... c, �� ! L. i � 7�::L� l.-�'! .�. _ „ c � h. C.� , � I C , l�. f . `� L�� •�' �` L _,. % ,;' ;r •- . �! _ . � • : , �,'� �'`` r� �.'_i c�-c;i �- �.'l� � y��',� �!t,/i � �f �->_.—,i t; -_f. fr t S' C '�, C, c, ` '-� t't_ � ,< � � j f J � (�" � � r� ' J ' , ,- f, ` r , � ," . ;`� c'� _ � --(,. __,I t, - " r� ,3 `%' . . f � �::C i - ( � . t. �, � . �" 1- �� � J � S (, ._� J,_ _ . .-f j ' . , �, / 4,, / ��' �. : '� / y + % r _ ' ,i �; .,..';.., � G;-.- ,_ , , /,_.1.J 1. �?`��7'',.i_�C . . i ?—_-1_ t�: ��z.� �-t_'-��?.�.. � ' Cr..- /t. : L.�ti.�:-�,-� ��".. � ;� . / ._ r /' !. l f �' l 1, � �,/ e.� ' '`/" t (' .�� ( �rl.,(,' .G :/��,�.l- �.,�,�, � �.�/� i �- ' � �_:_. ��. t_%. 7 0'' S� C . .�-�, ..Z..�. L� , � t . � � %� � . (,' ...— .- �� , .. � ,- �_ G S �"� 5 .., � • � - , �-:; �, /. � �) ��" � �_.. `;. — _- .. _ - �:. �; `� ���;f �. . S'.- �:� � t_ 3 ,_ ;�.�1_:z=� �, - � i [. - �; _,(:--' u � � t� � � -,. ..,�� j !f' ) . � .. . .! �'' / f`J� C�/�' l��V/� .��"1,!'�!� �-�.�:...`�j ..t�-�J. �L...-:�: �! n.� '7. �--1`-�f�"i�.�•'\. �.." /,.,,,_, . , f_./. `_,.� �:�i i.! 1J �_I � � , f T____. � .. v � ` !)7 _:..,.,. 1� / ./--- . .i, ` � ,�l{.,.,��-- �,�,..n C'. �..����,-r1.,�`'.% !. ���1�/ L,` t....�.�s t\`�, / � >`-' � �'�...1. : 'Y �: � a.�=_.... �' � if .. �f _... � . --�. � ` -� r L . .i' , � ,j i j,y r . '� /�� E .r� r-: t! � :�--i�.:_ �,�,Z' � _.�. ��:- �. '� � _ L.: '`::�r . �;���� �, 4 � :-�. ._ . . , _ . ; � � ,. , - s • ' . � .. „` , , v l ./ �^ .�.� l _. C ' ,,,' y '�, . L �/ �)�`. r�,./" t 4L.._..� !:� � '2.!j � /, L:.���J� ���4� [�� l. � �.[. .C. .L l-��l i�t...:'�' �. l . ✓' .7 � .�t,./l./ �' . • / .t A,., �j,"" . ' -; � I , �-� �• / .{,�).�1,�� �C.. - `� , �- i ,a l �. i � t:: �. 4�' i. � l., � l.. (,. i .,-, �-�,._1..,-''� 1 ��cC:`�•'% 1; �' - � - �� , � , _�_.. / � � .�� 4/✓.✓ � �" �� � ;l,j� �� ' � `'•C. .-7.� .t�� C'�l f�. _%.C,' l ��: . , „� /..� ��'�_'� ` t� V �1.,.'(��� C ��-�'- 'i.,�.... � l..�, t � � , _..,�.�.... :t� %' _,,,, �.� _,,. � . '�� 't r. �`.:.� -t.. � -J ._.� i ..�.',, L,�,.i � (r � L/L("'"i ;'� ` .' . � if � i� U �. , f , '� ! ,. . � . ` � I � .� ..�� t ✓ ` '�� � `..� L .� �? / _ C l �;� ... - ZC � ' � c ��•.._ ... , .: , � ` �� ` , ✓ �..j .. �. . i � �, G J �t;'% `{ �r.�' , r - , _:, - ; �, � r _ ;.� , . ' �—� ,:;C _� � -- ' ., � t c �_� � � T�� ` "� S '_�.: ,� , ' _ r 7� ,�>� ;_ ;, � r � L �` i > �,. �, , . �..., � �' ' ^- i ' .: , �, , . . r� � ' r'. :� c �'- .�, t.. l �S, c � � • 4:�_ �. r.r- t"� - �'t � � �. � � �:"'i: '�t.c t� � ,_ i ,,'j � ) �; � ``1� ��%' t c' --� l_ ,..-�{ C i� ^�:_ � �-j_ ''`/L � ! . , S � ,. r'"• L '` .� ��; ���,`:a-7 ��� l �� .�� i.f �� �, �-%,.' / ' _ ��-- . �, .. _ i �. , _..:._. =; / - -- i % � , �,/ � � , / i �./%'> ,C �_ l i•�/y '%,l� ! . 1 .� , C. .�f--�. 1., �-�_ r'� I J Z..c,`.r: 1� %L C�E',1 ` �"L-:�I/ - - r �J4 "� /i• L./� ti'-( /� �. � , ` c., � , r`-. . �� / � ., %, ., /i �-.. .. . � % ,� � ,, � / � r ,. . - � _ , , ,� c,;�� 't. `� `f, � �� �Z-J't,t.� /� �� i' G', 5��.� � 7`-t;-�.,�.--���.� ��l C� � ',-c?r��';-._�`�'. ' l�` G i, �' � , - c<_,i ` � ; .� C: _ -> __ -- _ , . . , %� -. �� �_ ,.... ° ' - /c� �`; <' '� . � 7 �.� i� C c-7"� G-rv t '✓`L'!"✓�-� C � � � �� ' ,- � � . � . , � , _�'1 c �. c `- � `�L C S , , � G �i 1 , , �__t71�� �j. lt � � - .. � - - � J! �l _ �.. .7 4• /�. � L G ... , ' / / � i� ,. � . � � % ( r' 7 ` '� _ � � ' ' .. ;, �'• y�f� �. I � C ;/ i.., t�,.� �, L C .... t•'7:�!,'� \� �� ���' L [ .�(�`4) � (. ( J /- �~i �-- ^7 S, � , , ./ �. `' � ' � ,� ' , � ..L� �L.� 'i..` '7 �'l L-,�./-� �^"��L,-�LL��." �- �'. C_ .}2` l�:�j/�'•� (.�• `�.1�... �,G''.Z.- / � �� J � �� i . �� t 1/ ,s!_. , ' � ;. .� L c ,, . . �, : � :7 _ l-i l C -t -� ,-;;!� � - �- . . �`i � ; � � f, _ L . ) t� ;,t J. , > �;_ L ... .. ` . � .. �`r �� �� ` L.. `�J I r .! j ..,_ ,_ � '%r'S�,j . . � �'-i �_a r� � �.�1.-i_. y �'"i. i.,�`.-./� ..` N,.''� i'i f: t�`. � _ C_:�` �...(.' �,' �^ 1..� ���'�. ��(, , '� � �~ f i ` ' .�:. I ,; _f._ ' }� �,r " � �, L . �l L` . , V ry r ' �i l .. � r' !.� � rl �? i--i�t...,f J �� �. �-c , '� :� i.. l - `� , � C:� , ;,...�, c 1.,� . ,: � �� � . • � ;' j`; r �-� L t`- C.' ('" �,,�-' `� ti (. .�Z t>���/...;j i � ".? `..1� C' , Ll...�.i - � _ C' � '�!/l l_'1.:• � �, J 1�/ .) f • �.. �. 7 c.. `- -� /�:: L' L± a i �. _ ,, / � ;! , i /�'' / y_, �.,c� ^ �/, ( ;r t „`� t t �I'f � -c. f llr L!>" � '- ,' , ' : , Z ..-.i-:,.... �� l` -�Yf'/ /::. t. ��� �.',jl` - l.� �l_ y^ 'TY . �...( ��� � ..'~�.- • 1 I; �... , � :, ,�, . i i J ; ,.. . � ! � .. ., r ,� �. `t:. 1 � �3 �, �, -' /,'�,�f � �._.,,, j , . ' f 1� .i?' �: : I ) ' . `. �./� �.� < �4,.�-, 4,.C- l.�- L, -� (G-. �, � � C�-4,�,.�1./"' �,.i. � (,.� � t, � � v -...t.� l_ ' � • � f {�% t'i .. `, � ..,_., ✓ . • `'� f `, �i� �, j . � �,; 1 �V. ,� �4_ �=,� ,._, ;-z.-� ( ` t-� , .-�__ � ;�. C � / 5 . 5 5�;;��`Z;x�_'1 3 U ,�. �, � . , , ,,� ,� ' Lfl.. �C.. �.. ,+�., � C"'','i.-�-(�_.. (' �' �/ ��: , i { �:--�'l.t t'. .i� (.� r�t, ��,,,�^-� �_� f`, { _ _L , � .� ��, ' ! j� , ��� . �, : �� �'-�� �l G,�.;% -v' � L,C t .�.,( `�- f: �� ���ZC � �'f' � � � �/� �i.0 G �� �/ .� j�� ��,.;}z, / �' �"�L, {'C.;'� �.._. ' �'l. l< <'"!.'�Z �� -/ l-.f', l��C ` '-, i ''� ' ii.Z`-J'li`. �C.-'�� t' .. �. J , : ` '� f/ ` . . --y�_.� i ^ ' , :' ' . _ / ; ;-l�.`'--; ,_.%:�'Ji lrf�t: ,- � `-," tt.~..-(. � G�,�;", .'--�'� L!Ll.C' � J'C,'-�-C_...•'�,�._� `/_ (,li-7ti`\�' _ r `` ! ` ' �.. �... ✓?{�, .,.�,. G. l C .`f(�.,.(,/r�^.—. /!"�,n'` r:.. - ...i/� �,. ,_ / l r. .f: �•'' \�, > � � lt �' L� �- �r .7 'ls.• Sr iC� . � •-'7' G�.4`j. ; � ' < � �._�.. ,, , , - . . , , , ., �,.f ; l ,... ., � . , ��/ .: .: ` j � . ` �-'� " `' �� -�' `_. [ L i l � Jk... -�.t �� t. �f, c: � i,�s.ti '), (.-j�.._ f 1..�._ � + f`�i� �� '�J�`- � ��'' �� ��1�C�/: ....1 (.-.J\ �.���� .. -�.....-�j �("� ;� � t.��....•,� . y, � �_; ,�..�� (� c %! �-� j � � � , � . , ' i`, J � � � , r � ../ .J ' 'I ,� / .�+ , , � � �- � .j`_. :�: . ���7 L.�� �t'%-Z.�.+...7-%(;)-Yj C' .f�'l'�.�` 4 ���{. ,� '���:�.�,l• �,.�1„•v�.�, �'L..�� '��..-V �./.� l'-1,./`. . � ' ,'y C. V � .�t,��Z,! L/�-z.�' �—�- __�'�1 �'���-�-Z. �<,, l..L:'�J, ,�� � U f , , �/�`;.'�,,�_ I "�-C.,� ��� ![,L,�/° �I 1 � �`- 'f ,•� _ . , :� �Lv.. ^^ '`'' ' l L- ` t, �,�.�`; C_ , '"? C�: ( �`1�(( -�, �i7 '�,�..:'�/' f V' ` ' ( - �^,l +l ') ; _., 1 �; �_ .:t�._�,... '�2, � �- �-"� z!c%I J ,_ L. t, _..� /'-�"� ';�1., t-•t., c� � , . � ;.:- � �r� .. � y � � "`Y' T -- y .� 1 /� r �-'I' l _... �n � � ;/., �" �j'-- r.` � � ,`� �,1.._"� 1 �, �--� ;J 7"/:'�'� � •� �� �: � � �� `,.I'�:��..\... j7 .l� l., � % ``_J..� ,� � / �' ..i I,�t/'✓_-C., . . � � ;, , , . � � .: t.-it��_.��/ L L 'l.C—` �.:���-•'.,�___. (,-i.... ��7 l..- ''i / �• ' �'--a'�� � C✓": °� 7 ! ,,:... 'Z.+:'c' �1'?' •i: , �f/ � . _... _ r �., i. y' .a t J.;:� 1�'L!��='�.. C'- �.-�,i%>��-� :...�_ �.�`-�-C�.�c t� c t.,,L.��_ f��1�.L,.�j=�, t-t'1,.�_, � � ; ,� .�" . i� , �f_ �' , ;�. ,� � , • � i .�, _� �_r�.: � ' )- t ; ��,. ��7 �' (.I— a/ i �, �,. �, � �.. � ..-t � _ � �'` � c,� .. C, f"G' i-�_�� l'. , .,:.�',;_ . L--�ti- � - - ! v', ,�; 1 - ,"! � 1- � ,� � . '' -1,•�' �%_L. .f 1.i/Y�"+? ) .�,`--- �.;-�.`!.j�-f'_�"i,-:- �_, �.-�../.�. `,'�.�,-L ii i1.�'� i./L•�C--i� L;!" a t.. , � .-;,r'- � �C� �,;� � ., ,,..�"� �"�� G'%`i._ t���;��`L`�,{,.�t,�.. {% , -�'2��,2 �. �C.�(_ �: '/�` C'��(� (::: C% � �I � .�,.. �� `/�. �. • , f!� ... ..�,._. :`3.�^ '} w "� .� / �' . �! f {� /. �,./'� ��,f .4. ,n-�:��`;�f-./ ".��.L� c..-�-..� ,.�,zC� (. ._' � �r-��) i� t. • C c -`�' -'� ._ �ry"~�`�. � . � � . G _. � r�1 , ,.._ ; / : • , � r ., . - � �..) L '-Ilf.� -• � Z,. �.. ) Zt'rZ• C.J 1' . tt �..-l.. .- . ,_...�. � 2��.__ �, C....� 7 7 :�r F� ,• (I '' . f .i ' �/ .. . -- . _. .:..._ /-...� Yt ' � - . i ,t.Y L �.- �,. i ...;_ ti �!: � � ,.�"i',:�.;1`' i: �i.� � .,>��` � . � `. i Z.. '7,:i.t.. '`�,• L.} � "` _ 1 ] i �' �. . ` - t"' �.. �,-2. , � �.. �/ Z. .�..__.1 . J� � ' ! ' + ' ' r � - '�� /J'i ; . �' �� � . . � . ' {*q/_'-') � i ,�, • , • ' � �t. -`;t C �. �.-w �'C- _L._- .. ' l i' f,2 'f 1 t` /"`tit ;�t-�'. (,�-?� .�� ' �, �;?i.c_`c y =i- �(� . . ; ;- � , , ��, .-. � . � .i � �ti �:'.. .. .,..i t _..y _�;r �. "-� � r i . " t �.�-y�J�t r`.� • �. ., 7 i-�� .�l.. f , ,... ..__ � f.l_ t'�,.,'_` / � l y.�: �� � � � i �'�/,• � , C i .. " .. � � �` j f i. .. .J ..L .. l. l-.'� ��..- l_ -� �1., �..1',�, _ <` �-C-•y!i. 'ti.. +., ''� . - i t-4� ��., . , � � ' j ( ? , , ,_ :.... / - � ... .._ > ..-. .._: t._ , �; i�f � , � �� � �,�� , �. 4 �.a �: �, .� �=1 �L. � ,_ ,� : � , ,-L it...c . 4� ;. . `� . , � � t.-.1.-: . �. ,. r� � �- _, ^ _�`f ,, �' . , . __' < 'C 'l.-yJ.� (~ir �l l `��• Z v� - �' `.�''� ' �r�L_-'v�_\ . t...._.'.C., !! :7�..�:.�.��° C. E�;��'L... -�.-..`' ;j ;_ _ , ��/ k r .� : , ,. �' ...y i. �,~ -, , �. i:� ,-, r .. �L...�...�..._ l ,..�,.,` ,� � , .�---,.,.. ;: .1.;-�. z .-�t.+,;. 4.i, • , �.__�' ..-]�' c- ., �.��.._, . � ,�, �, t:=�,._ . �: t �i.d�._� Y.. ��' ' � � ' ' `7.`I ' _ ./ � V . . ..... . ., �. �� .� / .• i T. • • • �i ? C:`'i�.'f���1, �(:. 11-'l' �"•; (.l_c .r';; Z j• i:�, �'�� � � 7'i.':I 1�- �- � c.. c. "l��%`t.. t ,.. �, �r1: : `.. �' jr •%� ♦ �! �' � � �— I/ 7 / . fi k ( .�'� �'i-� .__� (". (� t . , ' ' ji/j � - (.` ,.� µ�). - ! 4=� � - / L' �^. `7� J� C,�L�` � / � �.c ��...'�/S� � .f.....- L!��L_\ r.. ' ., .i � �, r" �. ' L � � �_'�. G � ; ,; . t' ._, �, r / l..' � ! _f �� /' /� ... _ f '. ,',f . . / �; ��, l \'__ �:7' � � ,. �, r� • �-�.";��'. •J [�'�_ 1- �.. � F� �-E) % l -�'` �_ �.., � �, � � c_ � �° - • % ` , Il ��r c' ; :� L � ,�..1<__ C. J . � � c�' 'l c'�_c.��; `7��.-�t=�.�_ (� "�-..� % C �c� ,� ; ; , U � , � � � ..— . � - � r ,� , . �� ,f- � t � � �y.Z.�,._ -U z.`, -�z J . �,< < �' �.��.�%. �:�:�1,�'-�-f�.,,1{.��' ` , � • •`• .�_ ,: � �. - . �. �%t 'l��ti��.�J� /J'�<.� l. '��` L ���`'�1.1...i���:.\.,, f l��-.l'- ` ,..`..i`,.:'��✓ [.l��?�1..��. �Ii.7�:i{r,- .7,i..L�t:'( ... �. � r � � : f `.' r . � v (_.. .� / �� � �- : / �?'� j ,: .— i f ,_. /__ i L �, � . `_% 1`1.;!t�-.. ' � � , � � � � , .. �.:'J�=�.c'-,;�-� �:�.,.�:. < <-. �`_ ,; � t �, c.� � ... � � � �- . - /� , �, c y � �. '`�—.1:.... ,,� � � 7 �f�� r-r� .. .'�\.��� ,,f..l•�/��`��'`�'�_ l./'l. �,. 'l�� / /�''1/C�.i '�..���,...J... .�.. ��`� � �( .:�.(� '�� ,I_"/. /� (i'/ L, �/� . � Li i ' i: (/l C i / / �� ..'1',--"�•. __._.., /n ' .:y ,/���.� /• .�_�I/�'�� �'��;--- �� ��,1/ ' � ,I� 4 �� r,�l.._.. �`! �!�-'�'f L--- 1..w/ � , �- � '`� "`�" � ,r. ; b� . :._.. / ,. , , �� ' l.. �. . _ . �! : ;, 1 , . J� �� . � i 1 'J/ -i.i�...`�'\,; '` �� ,.tiE.�-' �L:. ,�--�-t� f -��. �.�ti..� �1 L- �.i ti-1 LL � � !:..� ,U�. �' � �. , , ,� ,�. �' , � � ....--_� � =:. �.i�%% /' ., � :'� i ti'L� / .;-�t.;�. C ,''�,�y``�C'�<..�, ,l�-!} ��,7.�3"2�l, t C�_=', r- �`� t : -j..` �-�` 'i .... , �,- � � � /. . .. �.- � , _ .._ , ,f., ,.�/� ,{ J.�(../"'",/' _ '''_'?`Y'L �+�:.��✓I�?l.�i.-'���C L L•�1,�_1�..., l�r..._' ��? l /��Z'� '����j /J ./f/ .t. �� � � -� /� r` .. ... � _ Y '"- '-. - 'r ' � 1 ' � �� � / � ,. '� 'J __ - _ . _..... � •J,_., � .i, i7_�i�"J_ ��a � �f �f 7.�1'?/�v �.`_ t `�. j�� t Jy� � �,�(,� t .r..(��/' � � � j, � '`''� ' ._, (�, . �� �� ��. ;�/� � .� r ,. / � ,����'j�./ - ( !; ,,''1.G, -�.r�L i. �rl��:�j;�. � /_ •r�-�/'��%i .�l�'G'�'�\.l.L ,f`. �,`, � �r ,j` / l �'�'' � � � � �-t;�" , `��-�'i__�_ . ,_. (� y , j -/� �l` / `, �%'' •:�) � °�: C; r� ' �_t," �- -��-��-��::'J `,� f ��.'(.,Y'�D'r��C.. l../�.. l, -\..,. ci ,� , u !a �� .. � J.., �, --- ' ' � � ��� f �� � � ` �". )�....f I .. .:,.-l. ,� 4.`� 'L_,,.:`���) 1 / �." l. � C,� .�r,�.�,.. L_�e..�,�./f ���^'��,, � �-f•�ti•:.. /: � _ .. � , �- . ��- ` j ', �. '�C...� � `„ -�� `/� �` , ��-'�J ,G��._ f�%L_5� '�� ' %� -L�''C/ ` J �. ; � ��•�k. tt-.C-�- - ;f � . , � �/ ' � / {���. L� �;�'' F` �, '�(•- ; i�. . .���,�.j:���/ L,��./ L_���./6:' �- �,(,.',��T.,G:1. r_..-.t .�_.� C ..(. 'i")✓L. � (�Jlr:� - • 4-������ � • ., � . , f. .� _ - C. � ,. ; , _ l . ._y. , : , ._ �`� ' � 1 f `,_ ,. , � _y , s �.,, � - �� t � �: , �,.�`��, t_, <. .r �. � �- .�-. .�I. � •...��1 . « .��-�>� �. :� - . .. �� L • , . ��,.�, o.�'" ` � � - �+ � G`' / j '1 � ./ 1`�`*`,t 7 j �l, -C.�, L �'a� .'. i.�v 2 A•!J LGfL�-,'-� ,:. i � J,l- , ,, �; `,. �. .�_.�.-�i •° ��<<`� Z L/'�. :�� �. ;� � � . r :� . f' y �. ..,� � l._`_� ).t 1./�l-..C..'�1 j./T-�)-� �. <C 4J�\.. ��L.._i i:..,/ �� ..�. l. �' . t;`-���(.� { � . �- � � �` %.�. ..,�.._ ,i .f '� ' � . � � � �,, ?� � �.-; ,, . ; �, � , , �.�>�:�.� � . t.l��-; ' /� ��. �,� ��.�� ; - ��. , ., � { �_ , , � ` ; , ., � " ' - ��---�.t,`--,t.�_-_,,..� � t � , " �' _��- . `` - - ` �'' -� t� � �L r l ; S i ., c 't '"t t�:'i� i :-7'L.;:z."�'c.!-� ; , ; ; ," i ,_.- �` ,� J `/ !• ( . � ' i, / �� �:.._� - . .._ �; ,- ,. , __ ��,.. � " e. ' ��L, � . , �.�... 2.c t� ,�y�t. � ' l. �, �_ ��,,L}..}.,� t.. C C 7 � '�/ �`�: ,�' • a C - %" t._ "- - ` � • (: - ' • .. 'C� _ � �', ....!_ ' _ ,, � ,. L.�;:Z � �:�,;;--t r'-tt---t-L;�.` y/.�-�' �c"::�r-�, � t���� G:"C� _ �r-. (_� c.:, 2� :::�';� � !, : �_ _ � ��� , �-_.. ;, ��7� �. -< ,.-j�_.��: � . . _ �. �.. ? ��-�. �v..�_� �,.L�. C -t �L.�.r '->'� L '' L=� �� ! ' � .� � 4 -/ �.���,., _ti, %; . ; ; , r , _ , _ - , , t �� , , , .._ � � - �� - � - � � �._'7 "` .�L�.,'� L. ;�:'����.r � t, L ,,yt �r.._�,j L;� �:�' ,�.'-�'�L� , � �� !� � _ ,`` / ` r� `,�,_� t�: �`_!L,��,�L � . ; ;� �. . , ,," �, r � — � ,� � � _ �. �j t � ,,)i; v:'. > � .t.-1��.� :t � �i J �_� , ' ,.���•_t� c'.�1.( 1, --- ,` - ', L �:` � � > . . . : , � `.� , � ; `, � '` �`� Z'"Z� -}1.-:� ;�' � ,%` r T._-`:._) ': c^,f`_ `� /'(�.'�j � � � L� � ' . .,, .. " _1�1�-�"�'" C; (`- f �.1 l..k;..i � � �'� - r �� • � � , �..�t';1` i_ ;�� _�t-7.,�z� .��� L.'.�1.� �.. � � y ,< < ; � � ��.�,��._�.,; �C..1;1 �. 7 � t'�:-v�;�.1.�.; :,. .. - , ., � , : l , / h £, _ _ ..._ , : 'L � L , - : , _.. .. . ... .' _>:.._- ,�l '' 2 _� C ` �,i.� .. _ ...�.. .,.;. . : � �_ �! ._ ,, ;� .-��. .� . , . . � , ._.,. �.�,.� , �. ,; �,,. - . , . � . - _ �{,..� ;^.�� C.�, � �1/. '�_ �_�-' � �. . G. _ � , -.._.. / ' �, r •, ! / ;'� _ . � :' �, /'` ; � y�...�,. �, � ''�-'Li )'�c.%-�"� y � j .- .�`�;� ✓ �--J - �. ,. 1 !` L" ��I � ,�-�.:` ,"! L: 1.:-�.j�� C. L _ . j' i i;' _ ^ � :�' / 1� �..�, . . ... _ .�, / - . . t ,, , !� •'1.��"'C..,..1`7 � � 1.,� �'�i� t / 1 � C.: � �`/` <<_. �: '� v � � ,! � � � , . �.� `/r / � I ` , 4^i ..� . . , i, ✓L� _ L � _ �� f � ♦ �,. , � , ; ..- .; ' .: �: 1 .•.� .' _ .`t. .�; � L ��, c_ � < � <<:";' �! � t� l. � ?Y (..t. . � � . �l :e_. l � 1 �,; ti.. �t/,�� c � _ ,)" ;.' �... `, ' �, �. 1.L'� �--_� � _. . l . �"�/ � \�.� '�� / 4 . . � � �� l.. • _ . �.<.... f/ � / ... _ , - � . ' /. _t.._ , / �, ) ��._ t.���- �. .. �,, C.�'.,l � , eT •t L � ' i �' 4..� � Z. , - �� ,ti,::..r_. .�.�,.� l t L .r,..-�-j t :: � ,. ;., .; , � ,t�. . _ _ ' . - � �� t ( - . -: � , '� f ' �. L._-:. - c C r � ,• -'�_� u.._ ,- � �.,y, > ��_ . �1 ,.� � �--r� f .� ; W . ,:`�- , : . .. : � : , . .,: ,, � _..t c : � ... 71.,- :--7�i. � , ,r j . � ..�:...,_ � �. . _; ;% i i , ._.__ . - n J. � .�..�` ` _._�...._ /� � ' 2_..`� j•v - ! I L '` \. - _ �' ..�-/ � � l i - '�f'Z �- �� .. �_._.�-" �:� ,i 1 �l,.,,. _ `,i . � ��/ t.-1..� 4 �. ��� . � L �/.._ �.�.1^��' '� .�.. `✓ j. . J �. �.,. � _fF_ _ � �. /�� � . ' ^,1 s ��, '.1. - .1 .i .- ..... ....-' , l,i>_�4 _ .., , ".' f�` .t. t � _ 't, _.ti%- , i - � �. C.� > �� �_.. ��j't ..�',- �, �,, •, � � . � �' C ����.�- � /� . , �.�l_._ .� �' '' . .�j" j) , , J,, , 'f �i l%� �!,. '�.f�-C�t�,,�,.i�C � ^< / c- , . `;,_-•_ • _ , - _ _, , . �� ; _;_ � :: " ;' - % . 1 � £ . 'l 7 . �, a ., � 1, � `� _ i r ......�y�-w./ . ' 4;` `, `., ,J_� 1 ` �,.�'/�c.....�` �. i.:� � L,�-�-�'l t `���,- ��.. / L� C'�-. Z. ;r , ....,. j.- �� � .! � _.. -.. � , ...`�_'. r ,- ... .; .. - � : , /� � ! !' ..) . ,'. � . ^ . �,�� f'L � 5 c �. i. �,__.`._._t.�..._ � 'l *:._ .. � � �i � ? G�c _�,' �% � / i_c i � ;,' . _ �, � - ._ -� '�_ , �__ t!."� - � - ,,,' , .i., r..:: 7 `1 -.; � � ��_-C c: : y 1 c. � r -� � _ � ,.. <. �, � �. .. '- t. � t "/9 L , :.� 4 t:'. ' �<<�y �., i.._ f,I l (A.. �- .f. � �- �} ��� � j' . f ,��'�i �.• �L_, t.__,f. ` [.-�.. .�-' l.c:'��% �..�4��_:"��{C,�J/ .L�i` �''i.i_i..�`f�.(-��. .��i .d_.� ... .1= . � ' .- (.. !. .i J� /' � 1' t b �� , _ � � � � , . . ��'t,, 1 i,� ;�. � �: ..'�-c ..` �Y�Ji. ,� : � ( . .(/� 'J (�'� l �./ L i�'� c� � �,��,r . , I/ ' � � �_�!.l. i..' �c•��� ��. , ...'"C.,. _f�....._• . :� L r c , .� . ".�• - . I ,, ,. 1 i, . t . - 7 : :t 'l l�-."J l, . '7�-'L' C � .. . .. .. ) ♦ � i I l C/- t^ �'), _.... / Z..`� �,��.-�+.. , t„-i..'C �_ .;�(. Li���l ('/�•2 t. 'C.�:f,l^ . t L( � .�' �,� �.. . ( i • i ( "' �•;7 ��� � �', ��/f i.�- � , r".. ,�L _' �- +.. li L.i 1 �.i l: .�: •(:"..��t-/� ^`� ' ... ti -- / .. � ' t.'.���J c�.r�',i�_�; ��.L--��- i ,.:,�,R,_1--��-- c:=��.�C.:i.��-k% C�-�� l��-��. . -_.. ° . . , . ; , , _, � ?'��'lit•J �l:'%L::_ � ,,,i"�l� �l . J l'`'i�` � .�. `� C l � � Z � �.? L, . % i � _ _�-�'')' I�`. °,�. . , ',L. , r ` , , . r 4 �� _/ ; 'j. ,., ': . .'% . � . �7.- �....� ...i , .. -- , - . . :. . � � � / .^ �'i 4 " �/ r _- .� 1'� �'_'�,.lL l, c" i r T._ - . 4�. , � 7 l y �; �'1i_- (" , C-- , �,� )�.-'' � L , l.c�' c: �.. C_ ;7 7 L'�,._� .`;4{. L' � � i t � '' 1�� � / �� ' �` C `�- ��C%i_.,� ���I, . .., Jj ,. � ;%-' , � ,��G -'� -v.. �. � l_ :, > � � r� ti--: �'i r't. :\ ( !._ ,� c'�l, L •� �/_(�C--�� l--� .J �. �.. , `.;; � ✓, �, ,;- , . � ,, �! �% /f � 1`_;� ,', ,�: .}--�(� �.:..('�1-l..!�.�.�.c, .r-"f` ;` ,., r � , �i. .�r. G,�.'��./�/ � 4��. c- / �_�� ��l a�-�C-L �l.`�-`� ' � '�i t'_� �.LL� � � i . .� � /, � `� � ( ,Z) �r� C �. / �' 1. ? �',',.�_.� � t� f�.. .. `.t-(.,� � `�/ �l/, l� ; �- , `;'7''i`�.( l / _ � � `.1 �. ; �� :; `t.:.:. i `i '}� +l l ` . ._T`_' /` � �r �. �_._ - .../j f,,,l_L� (!'�;,.� ,,�"'`-L-. �.i � .. � -f ,.�: � .L.'� l � ��-�.. , �_ ' ;/'��.,.c.r'� (� j. �, :� � � ..�i �.c � - ._.._ I � �"C � � �� .. /'v�-r.,�i.- `_� � � � , i ,f :- � r � . , 1... �. / , :L.. � ��/� �C�� �.'li...'o-'j')� L t.'%r t. /�' '� ^ �`Lt.-'% C ) t-� � �, f•.-J ,�,.`;� •� , � �t � ,°�`'?��l ' '� ' . (. �, � ,. �.' / :•, .�. / : r••� '� L_._.. 4�' f. � �� � � �. L;'� C,' f'l.%4, �{ /.1 J^ j �:, "4�^'L.r ,�+ �, .! l (:') , ._'"L.C.` �� ' j -- ._ , '- i ` ` . �q . ~ / i• .: r -- ���'� . i'�'i:/� �.�. �....-::1 � , '✓ :r-Lj, r' .1 , , 'i' J,. .�"�..(. . t �. . ..�� .. I , � t ` .. - , �. _. .�� ,.. � i. �- : i : : ( " J�'(.,..w.. _� � �.. , _ , . ..:�j � . , • � ` � - ,..... � C_�� :s i � �. �. � L L S.. ` �. �- ' 7 i.. . ... ., - � ... - ; ,• _. . � ['1 ,�- � ' (� ..%���L. l� .i�' �i ' i. �,��,,.-�. `, l . � -' ._. .,...� ,� , / `i ��!.. i • r �4 � . L,���\._.l_.. . �' '/ 4 � .. :.M„' �. .i, � � �� / 7 ti � � f � i ,/ .I_ �'• (..?.,` _.1., .%� �_.;` �.�•l" "i '�.. , ! � '_.C, ' l ,� / , ` . t � �... � E i V L t-. (- ,, {' � c�. I_ .l.. �`. C� \ C . �, _r' .� " /'j `A.��.�-'�t ` l� ' L.•l i�t�-"� ' ~ ` "��. ,`-�,. !"L/-� I 2 ,f��,= � y r" /t � �� � , : i � � i 4i,-'� 4 L..' .. � �. ._ �. � .. _ :J ( L , ', i l: `j'..._ ..ti: f �/ f��"1 � L�.��-� l.'(T � ����\. � ,�, ��� f. L •��j )�_. �,..-7 i�'.r (-� l ,C J '1�- � � r t'u . J , � �: . �v� ln � "� ,rv.C-"L.'�,( L..%'\�.. �.��.L. , �C�-�G�`.'1�/. /�'� �f�3'L"�C.�'`i�'(�,`Y`._� .i;,.��,.� _, C.l<-",,�� �`�''''\ ��--'`� f ` ` _ i �` . . . !' i • . .f:� ,,_ n ; , _.-. ; . f i� . . � ; --t- . ��--�.. . l.'':.`,._,�-. �,. � �-Ef „ � ,� / ? � :�'l. c-i,-� ' i..�' � C '`'` C..�C{- 7!t"� (.'�; > .�.�� . C� /��'L=-. . f: r� � . \/ , f�. � � __.r,....,...._. � ; ,! ! " i` � / � 9 ;' ..:..� %:, "..• .- . _ . ,C l� .�-t,� L f� 1 C. �-� �' �._�� ;l�'�i,_ �-;'% L.--�-. '� � (�, �:.�.:,f�,� . ;� �.; . _ ` - � ._r , : . .... ` �. , ;.�__ �_� r ,. � � �' {t'r� ! .1-- �t:';7 :� t�' � � �y,�� , j;�.' l ,�`� � r�.c.F�• �-�;� ;� �...�-��` ' L' . t- c �, t� :% ' �� �., D i �� __ /` , 1 , I LY�/: _ 'i , 7 > :tiw L,�._� ,�' ,�,� ( l. � � t�;i-Z �-' '�_���_ ��j t . ��`� t ' ��,..__� �.�' `�;-�,i_ . r��- � � , , ,.. . . , _, - ' ^ .� � � � " � ` � ., � i � ,: • . _ � . . , , � ti � ��-. �.t �.. - - � i...� � � ,�, l ..- . � " ,:� t �:, , • �.... , � L... _ iI '/ f t � '1 � � . % �� � f [� ..' . : � �� t� � �r.� �. J .� _i ' 7 f" .�/'� j t � l � � ..'/ Z.,�t L.. `'�'�.l . L ` ; t' � �' ` r � ! � C L. ._ , , L :^, , .,_ . . � , : , . � : ,,. ., � . � � i :_:... , , r . . ' �: L,� !i .__ ;:� . . :< , . - . , ° ' .," �"-t'` � > � " � ., � � , t.. ��_� �_ - ,� --c.;.� 1�� _ . , l.� ,�� Li' J:. ��'�� . � ' ' � . —'"�� �� C,� C t�/�.c:�-.1 �„�., ! i; 4 r' . �. _.i'....... . : ... . . I � ,� q .� 7� '. �1 ` ' .�_.._. � ��� �. 'I l"� , �,'�-C.'.../l!� � �/C, '.� -� L-s� '�"t'-��•� � " ��.:���� l:: G�v't.l;`, f,<_:l�'��. �� ��� F �. '` I_ � , ��C_. ��-c:�-.9 �.��-�,�:L,, `.:__.�,��� , �� � �`� ,.`'`c%.�'._ t 1,�� ` ;�'���-� ' � � . �: l.. �� I .�°' - Z�, - � .,t��`'�✓[ (''�M / . _.. r - _ - �= ^ �; , __ ,,. � .j`r i..J�"`.t'7'1--, {,i (.,' ` r �t..:'y^...� �� ... L �L. � . (�7�l. �,,,.r-�`�...� v. .� .� . t.. /° f. :' (. �f_ i_ r' �%'� � � _ ( •/� ,., � ,� f � ,. � j ��f t��_ �vS�'� _''{�1�.!`.._ �''-�t.:•_rr=, �. ( �: (r'`�.�_-�� "�,�.`,� :��-'J �\. ., ?. .`.�,��-� � - t; � ' • � ,T � ' ;'. � �`�.:Z.� ;�; ; ,� t_:�.r� .1�^ �, �/,_ C,...,-� ? c�-'�::-t.r�-..��.:' � �:l �;_ ��� , -�� �.� ,.:-ti.� � -� ( � , � � r�t.l�-,`�: •- f ` '`" ;i' j,• , `� � , /,�� ` � i � ' �f ✓i G 1!(�'� � �--• 1` n ,� ./ f ( r; �/• �-''` �""��' `- . � "lL--� l� ;� f'L z�-L +� 1 V �. � ,��-� "i. '� .�� " Y , , j .__ ,� , �-"'` � -`r :�,�.�' �y-1-c z'�'.j�f.:.��4���; , � . , 1 v . � . � (, C. - , �� ,. .. ,� . l _. � -� � � / .L , �i' ,' � �,��_.-�_�r.` �. � ��� •. : C i__ � � � _ , � � � , . - , ' ( _�/.�t . � � � ( � .-�"Z. �� �•%i7l f�l(^'"I� / . �._ L�i..--7-' •� '�G �`_ ,. ��` ? � � /%r .r� �;J,� (r`�.,, !-�-�l� � t , �. f � 1.-`-'• ! :�1, �� � �% ' ; ' � � ; ' ` 1 i�' 7 �..- � , ). �,....� �� .� t �;' �`�' ....� ` �.•�4 l�� l, " L./7�', i „ ` �' � ( :.:,..- -'� �.,.f,;.. . � -` L � '/�,:t.: � �" `. ,.i� :— )l� �,2. l ,r l_ � c - � � ,t ' .'- L.. ` Y .r..,� f i . . � i ..w_t ` `� . � .... /{ ..,.J.�t::'�.1 • � � l. ��)'�-_/ l : �'.i !..`�..-... (,�.�..�:% �. � � �. ' �' ,�% �.�L.%�% l •� � . �.it.��. \,� � i.�� / 4 � �•. ` f ��.C t_' / . I i , j' : ' , � `.� `^� � �'j t�.j �J;.•j � ,''�,� .r-? Z� ;1-11 :L��-,.�'`�--'(_-C.. L./�i �L��� '`..`� �, `(.., � . � i�,' a i-. � �, f� ` f ' _ _ !__ `i_....� , ; f _, � ,. , , ' .� .-2,,.' � ti��'\.CGl' •ti,l ) ; -'l ��'�.; � ( c, �..� �., � ; , .-.'-�L' � .,' ;7 l, i " � � ; C 1,.4�_i �, , : i . ` - � , . �f ,� ...., .. -> j, � �.,% r. , _ � , r� � �.t_,;�- .� �., t„ 2 � - C. . � • L. . , � , (r { �� -L �� �. � t�' ,l �.: 1,f , - .: � l� ., �. ,.� ,... ,.�C .t—_- _. _ t (. 7�... t ��7 c . • . . , ; ..s;_. ." � F C - , ,•, ' �; ' i a.... � i ' .f .r�! �( � C. C � � � ^ , _ �i i:_ � '� �� ,-Z..t. "t•' G` 'L-^ , 1 �. � -� 7.. ;./;�(_ C �.� _ f . , �� lt ` , , '; : � -- ' , .� , j /_. r,. c; „' j�' ,'.,..�""�, t �ti'� ��y�.�.�i'i.`�, , '��'��.,�<��Z'7�-�l��',`I�''r}� C c i's:, � _ \....�..� �.� ^.-'1, • L.'��� t� � L....."l. �. .� ��, /I l (/ � ( �/ �/ h�.�� :� �_`'�.-, .f t... ._ `. � ,�`Z� �_ �. , -7�� `; ,, i` ;_ � i,-� �t.j �' . � . ; z • .? s, � ;• i (" ��� -� -, ;�_ t-� ,Z �� . �' i , �,' . . , . : ��� - �. � � , =�t,, ,,�, , . . � : , , .-r � � � _ . . �. :c.�- ,, , _.. _. , , - �, / . . ,� � �i i f,. ; ; / _ � . ,�- L '�. i i i.< -; ` '�. . �._.y' i�. l '�..� �'-,��. . . , � c.. � �. -i' c, � i.. , �. -1 1..�- .Z.., . � . � -�_ _ v% t '`" �,r" � t . � ` � L i_ '' 7 ( ' ��_ �j • i . � � . � l. ' '�(.... ..�� . „... i; .._ • - �..��_� % r���: �' C-i' .'Z :i ::�i �� � /.' . <.� . : V[:t, J l G',. �� . • . 1 . . i _-'_ - ; _... , .. ! � � / � , • j � -�, _ ;, �`. ,L,� i , �.�.C _>�. ,r j L �.��-�-� � ` �. ,� ;� ; J z> , �,. � c����, .�, � �.. ;' r.- ' / n '`!l,fl.���`, Y,� �r j�l� .,�. /t..`�� l /`: ..4../�..�'��.�� �{`'�� L(,.�'i ��e.'�_.� ` ,L ` r � /� _... l �•�-�� � r L ti � ' ,�;' �;;. i ��L/���:�7� �,. L�. -t.'7—� -�.,�._��_,� - -`..� l �.���� ...�(..�.� l� ,� f:� � .-�'.� �,'� � c: � � 1..-✓ �- �: �:° l ,�Z_�� �; � r r�. . �._... t � . . t i' �.'� � : �� � ... �...� ; _ / �_�' ,��..- ✓.`'l�?'"3-L,-� `'_��',.�.�... �'� t` -�t `i ` �---L-i.��_ (� /�,'y"�_, ,f �✓7 C�-/�.. (��%"1. � �•' � ' �_.:- _. . - . � f._ - � ( �' , ./� -z � - , � i � L. � �i., i;�t �� ''` �_�,,.._• ��, ,:� �..{'.7 .�C c �-.J �-" a,!/�"�'`;/ .I i`�:,..�-�- l f l {.,, /;. ;Z.�•'l.�-C,_�C' f L-'f�>'tii c..° ---�� �-,;�f-7 C.- ?�- �'7 Z..�.�,•<.-J 1 C._-'`.��>� �,�.f_- �.�� , ,- , � . � :� ; - f , • � � , . ,-, ,� ,� �../ L�" tt, :, I L .,-. .�f.� ��,y , :t , `; .�-�_.�"' t�, ;- �:f t �.'�_.. t. � �- . , � , ,, , : / � ,� • �'� i / .f i ' ..:f ,.j � i .. L�.-T L;� � , +�:-� k..l �..�` �.�,� -!;� �'"�'�r�. �-l, li C..."L.: . '�. ._ (��.�..� _..:f ( ��� 'i i �'t, � � , , _ L.`� C t. .�L i`i� ` ' �� " t+', , i / " -� % - � - - ,�—� ' � ti� , ,� �. "1. i c: ;� 1 .�—°�� , , � �, T ' 7 , , ,: ,, �_'7-.. 7 ;:_ 'J ���. , Z-� � � �. ��..�� _ =� _ �.` <� ,. �.�, � � , . ! v` ` , . j"� C , ` � �. .= ' �.-t; r. C� '}, �;;' �I'l_'t �. ,%1 �"z- I v t ��. '.j' i �, . �- � � �_- . > ,. . , _- .. ., " - �/ f. �... � . , ; , , : ; � . �• , s ,-,% 0 1 r� , . �-�. ,. ._. . .' : � .�� _ : - ;- •: ; ' ; .��` '' ,� ,a .) i . i' . - � .. , .. . .. .' �I i ) s'"ti'.. <. . �'.� ♦.� l {� ., L < .�-^ ' ...�.. 4.,. -'. r..__ - 7 1.. l'. �.:� ` �, � .� �`i_. . � ,. J ,. � �,,.-�.. .�l t, :� � -�.-� ;'�,... � -� Z. � ,_'-.� `�.�. �i �I'� '�3"�..: f ,` l ; �.: . ',r. �. , \...Y.% \`'. \ ... �' ♦ n � ✓�7 j J ��. . �� ` '( - / �� . \. ( i.) [ h.. .�� .:'�.? ��� 1 - �� / .� � �� '\. � � / � \ �. � 7 ..-,.. `�.�...t ��- ` / � `,� ` 1 { -- �������.}� ' '4.� - . , . �.. ..,- 4`-... .,. ' i � ; . � . .. . � . � � J. .' , t., ; `.. r ,.�)j�, ..-i.�L:�.� � .�L-� ����? r4 /• � � lr � �,, _. � . . l� � _ .. � � �; . . ; : ., - C- .. ` 4� J,, `,`,� ..�_'j� i �.. ..' , : 4`" . % l� ..! _7�--;-'1.��_.,j+�t..i . � � . �� . L: � : _ } , .��... .r �:, . .i • Y�'7 ���. , ...-: ") ;�..�>.,-l�'j'`f� �:�� -.-,,:.�. 1�,_,.�..// ,.��.. � _l�%'_j_�.. � � -,..!��''�' .. �. , . . ° `_ F , .. �. Y: ./�2.. 1 i� ....f _�' t •l.. % d / � �/;!� : ;? ' a � M ' i... .. �- �.���.! �./�\�.`(r.%'`.� �'[ .`ti.l. /\.r`� r �.�ti,.i�� ^ .c.-� � � / lf \.b`i �- `f ='j� ���,��.� �1-- � (, ,a � � "-.'i' J +i�_ . `�, < �..�v' C l-� �4,"{. '�`"i..�-��,•'�f'.., ��+...._... --F .� /") ^ �L— , � f�. Y . ��1��{,,� c . 7���.�� , �_�c �,�...7 �{�'�.�. ,1`.�C , f�,; ��.-<_� ����,_�:�;� c. l. ' . � f, ` . � ' , l, � �� ' �f' !"-7 "/;J."�{ , � � �. /� %� ` ` _ '� :j�`( .�'�'f �l� . ` ':�' �'�'�� �,,jr �� January 23, 1968 � � � � i ; ,---- _P ' Hon. James J. Dalglish ��� ._\ , Comsr. of Finance �,-----� �� ��� Building �' ,�� Dear Sir: �/ � The City Council today laid over fr� arau 31st, ig68 to Wednesday, February 14th, 1968, Resolutions Rati ng� Assessments for grading a.nd surfacing of Ross �ve. er i � oss Ave. between Hazelwoac� e.nd Germain St., an<1 req that sen tices to abuttin�; owners to �,dvise them of the r sed hearin date. �i Very truly yours, .�-� '��. � AO ���' City Clerk � n� � � � �.�� ;,��` �.� �. .��.,y�� ' f � January 17, 196� � � � � � � I Mr. Joseph P. Sumr�ers -�--- --�`� Corporation Counsel �� Building ��'"���,, `��'� r' ,�''^'�� o ` Dear 3ir: � �` � ` r � i The City Council lsid t�ver to Janu lst w�b'�RESOLUT�NS RATIFYING ASSESSMENTS for gradi,ng and surfacin a scwEr in Ross Ave. and requests that you and the Finance Dep � pre e a report far the City Council, mainly in conx�ection w3.th ette f ob�ection by Mrs. Get�rge Wothe, and also concerni rernarks Mr. ey Olsan pertaining �o statem�nta he claima wer made at a vious Council meet3.ng on re- calculating ths assessme s. '� Vexy truly yours, f-�'"�� --', /, .� t � �� City Clerk AO/ng � ��t � �����__�..��,� January 17, 1968 r� p � � � � � , Hon. James J. Dalglish r'^ --- Comsr. of F�nance ��V����., Bui ld ing ---�, � � V, Dear Sir: Atten o�i: Mr. �; Wm. Ddnovan �f .� The City Council laid over to Jan. 3'Y��twn �''olutians xatif�rin� assessments for �rading and �urfacing and sewer in Ro��`A�v� ii requests that you and the Corporation Counsel pr a re�,o�for the City Council, mainly in cannection with a '�tter` o ob�ection by Mrs. Gec���e Wothe, and also canc�rning marks o . Ha�Y Olson pertaining tt� atatements he claims were de at a pr�ious Cotz�c�.l meeting on re- calculating the asseesmen . � � � _ � Very tru]�y yours� ��,,y �....�"'___.-�' � ✓' �� ,� � & p � City Clerk � AO�n� � �, t ; �..,`��..�_.� /'��,,; �`..,.`�r»,,- � 37/ � � Feb. 1�+, 1968 ,� � � w � Mr. Joseph P. Summers, s Corporation Counsel. ---------� � t�__..-_.___.___.,,'\ �. Dtar Sir: �` �� \�� \ '�� Attached is a letter of R. tid.aon which was read by I�. Ohlson at today's Council m ng, in �dnnection with Resolutions Re�tif'y�.ng Aasesament the gra�,t,�8 and eurfacing of Rosa Avenue from Hazelwood. to i__n,��c�et, a�nd for the con- struction of a sewer in Ross Avenue. �`9qa��Council requeats that you fully investigate the ons statem�nts made by Mr. Ohlson ar�d report your f ���he G'i�t Council. `,,� �jV�ry truly yours, A�I� � �, e �,�-____-�q.� `�`.`__� City Clerk AO/hp �'�� � s � � i � � ; �� � � / �___...� ►����:�, ���10� �}-��� .�e; ; � K+�,: f 3� �1�� � S.i:t:� i • s.,. . Gi�'; ;:;���K�� (YF"�1Cr� ;i ,'r;'.;!_,�"f I��t. Jan�aaa�y 15, 1968 City �l�rk City of St. �'au� C�:u:rt Hcuse 5t. �'aul, hiinn��ot� 55102 Re: Public Hearin� January �.7, 196� at 10:00 a.m. F3.1� 16724�-G, Page 1. File 16772, Page 1 Doar Sir: This is with regard to the a����sanents arisi.ng f`rom grading and surfacing Ro�s Avenue f`rom Hazelwaoc� St�eet to G�u.ain Street and constsucting a publi� so�a�r in Ross Avenue f'rom Hazelwood Str��t �o Germain Street. Ou.r pr<>perty is located at S14 Hazelw�c�d Str�et. This property as on t,he cor��x of Ros� Aveizu� and Hazelwomd St;reet. In the Notice of RehQari.ng c�at�d fil�y 1.1,., 1965 received from the Depar�m�nt of Fi.rsance it was stated that w�.e�r� tl�� sewer abuts a corner Tot, said corner Tat will be assessed a maxi�u� o� �75.00 for the sewer. The letter r�c��.ved ��om the Department of Financ� dat�ci Decer�b�r 29, 1967 states the sew�r ass�assm�:�t is $$g1.3�. We .feel this figure �hould be corracted. In Apr�1 19b5 we w�;x� advised by the Bureau of Valuations �at w� would ba �award�d ��U.�Q tota�. dama�es to our prop�rty. After �eceivan� t�i� notice w� telephoned anai va.sitec� the Bureau of Valuations many �imes� stating tY,hat this airAount did nc�t ser�m fair to us. an� day Mr. Pottgi�5er inspect�d the property b�fQr�,,,�}y we�r�,,,hag�,been started and told us if the �50.00 was not er_ough ta re-5od th� bar�k� �o pravent the dirt f`rom washing away w� shou3.d "#.hrow oat�". Not�.ce of the final hearing was left wi�h a neighbor while we wer� on vaca°tion. T bel3.ev� this is highly 3sregular. W� °tal,ked to Mr. Battis and also told h3au w� ��lt the award wa� no°t faax and would. not p�rmit us to r�store the prop�x��� to its ox°iginal valu�. When we r�sk�r� raka�t would happen �..f we refus�d ta� ���ep� th� award he said, f°If you d�not °t�ke the �50.00 you probably won�t got anything�0. H� advised us to hi�re an at�orney. Why should it be n�cessax°y to �v to tk�� �acp�nse of hiring an at-�orney �to ta� fairly treated bythe ci�ty? Bec�u�� �r� f�1t t,�e Bureau of Valuations had. s gr�at d�a1. of experience in matters vf this kind and kr.6w what they were doing, �nc� �.n view of the statemer_t madc by M.r. Battis, we accept�d the �50.Q0. �1ow tha°t ��a �rading cf' the street has baer co�npl�ted, we find that it will take between �3UO.C?0 arad �/+00.00 to sad the banks tn prevent the dirt f"rom washing away. We are alss� enclo;ing �opi�s of lettor written to The Corpor�t�.on Counsel, C3.ty of St. Pau]., anc3 �xa� W. J. Eb�rtz Cons'truction Company r�ferr5.rig to dama�e _ � _ ta oun c�m� as a darect r�su�.� of tl�e gradang of Ross Av�nu�. Soaae time ago we w�r� contac°t�d b�y Mr. IDucl3ey of th� North Star Adjustment Company who represent�d tra� Gi°�y of St. Faul. He advised us he would a.nspect our home ar�d adviae us of #:h.he adju��tm�nt °the ci�y would make. To dat�e we have heard nothi.ng further from Mr. Dudle�. We Y�ave �1so b�en anformed that the Gity of St. Paul h�s agreed to pay in full th� amount du� °�o socl the banks at 1565 Ross Avenue which is aeljacent �to our prc�pertya In eiew of th� ak�ove, w� respectfully r�qu�s� that th� final h�arY.ng on tlaes� anatters be l�id over until an anspection of our property c�n b� made. W� would appreciat� any considerat3.on that could 1ae given to reviewi.ng the awards made nnw that grading has been c�mplet�d and it is pos5ibl.e to sccuratelv ��termine wliat the actual damage to our prop��y and home has been. Yours verY °�'�Y� �iv�.o_ .��c� /J, Vl/��--��- Mr�. G�orge D. Wo`�he P.S. I wi11 appear at t,h� hearing W�dnesday, January 17 and ask �to b� heard i.f n�cessary. _ DON� CHAP'Pf�.L C0. -- ���;�� E f � �. �. c. r.r.��� ,�� , , � ���, ' • � , F�td�tttt t�ri �'"�. �.d�. c or g . ., �� � + � ST�PAUI, MINNESOTA 55t0i�� . � . � oafe:, �:� �a� 19'� 'sus�ecT: �t�k' �.n��� ii. J. �� ° �;`e�.�►3:��t'r. I�� Yt�t�e ��t� ��1�.;��3:t�!oa�� ��i� � � . . }47�� ��Rl.���i, t+� � ' � � .. 1� ���� . {'i�8�1Qi �'t+.�... ,��`i �L'. � �� ��� '�'�,rs�tn�� �nd �. CQ. � M3.n.n+�,�olf.�, �l3.un. � �� ��� �� � ' ��; >�� � �� ��� _ . : ;� ^xa� 'rC! SL'i�}��Yt6Tl�'. TjEl137�' ��,�! Q3� "� &'�V�B C�.8�f1� 8'�.�� BT�i �9jJ�.�!# , , ��: Z , _ :�< �.�'�i'�'� #3�t'�i '�i0 �' � �sR'$2�l�'�'r,r`�r`t�. Ei�'l �.+�+�;�'l3�tf� �""���5�}.� �I���'$Yj�s�t �t ? , � { '�8lR#t 1�C`$ 2'l0"� :�.`�1'C�.#t� �'i0 �Ll. � � � �fi�at!e� i.n ths le�t.� +�f �.—�.�b, �� �$ srati,r�►�y per��i�.� t�a�. t�i�s b�� ' ;��' hr�s �o bseaa dsm�ged. �a�+wr,� ;be+�su�e �oat af ttze be,��uaa�t �sr`��n��+r�, "`� : �, ' t,�e t � �n ttw �aut� sfda 4�` #d�� k�u�� �zr� no� e�as�i,� �;; , _ ,; . , . . . � .. . . . � , . � . ��:�. . r� . � i -. � . . , � . � L�or, ch�ppel�. ' � ��� ` ?"H$ 1�, �'. C, Cq�nt,At`�( :¢ ��� � ��: �n�. �d1"t�L; (?LL `� . . . . . . � . .. � �,i � �� . � . . . ��..�' t _ ; ��N Ci�APPEt C . ' �. 0 � � �� � 204 Anchor Bidg. �:< � ` ST. PAUL, MtNNESOTA 55101 .r� , : � March 31, 1966 Date: SUBJECL• � I , i I .} • �. cT• �il�'t.�i �iWS$'tis �� 2325 C�,►1t V� Co�t St. �at�i., M#nn. 5�.7.0 . ____ ,� t� J�n�r �.2, �.�G6 +r�r t��rt� cu a� . � P�' �P� af lft��r �ttat�h�. ��a �,t,$ n�►ith� 3�bP. & �#rs. i�e�fi�h� car' �,h1,� �mp�ny �t�'�rs 't� �o�t�t� 2r�' �ou � ��' �'E>17�' �.21SLI�AriC�' C��'. ,'�, A�y we p3��e bavie t�+� c��r#�y �f a ��P�..Y. ,a . . . . . . . . l, . .. .. . , � � � � .� ,��-.. i T'. Don Ch�ipell , � ;�. 1 enc. `.,,.r- � . � ��� �ianh. ou k,; � � � � � � � � � � � � � �. �� � ������� � � �o . :�,�� . ;: � . W : , .:. : :�. _. ___ _ �v 1.1. �/G �� � 1./* �8Z61WOOd / St. Paul, Minn. 551U6 �.,_ --., _ . . . ,.. ._.�... . ,,, , � . ,, ., . ��_�,, ���:. , ��- —�.w - ..: �� �...�.,..-,�,., _:., . .. -._ � ._, , , . _ . ._. . . _ r �. �� i � � .... �, - . . , . -- .:. y.. � ..:..+.+.�.�...yu "�����S`z-.-`a--., � � � � i � .... 'i,.. 1` � _ f .. �V �., �. � � ..... . - _.._c / .� � � �r r A ' _` `'` � �' � . ' � _ � �` I � L1 , e � � � ; � ` . \` '` , � L_'___ . � � , ..` r ...._.." �.;'-`: .. y�:a�;�.Y:�--�u��.. Ti (� ���..:_ _ _� �_ _-_ . - .. � . �"�` � . '. .u.,�,� r.._ ` . P � __ . �`` ` ` ` 4 `/'�` � `�"I/ _"' .�\ ��w. . i . ' F�. � I � � \ ' i �... , .. � . \. "\ . �� j 1 �__-� _ , t __ . � --- _ � _ �, _ : �. _. \ a �,. :::.._-. _. � � '� --__. . .� � �� f2� � ^',� •� � � . � � 4 ��o • _.,.,�, �I��it� �+�.�,�t�� � L'�� ��'"'� ,,,,� � City Clerk � City of St. Paul � . No. 0 0 9 3 61 co�t x�se St. Paul, Minn. 55102