236991 s , C■^'
ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK ��A�y��
CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL �� �l`���
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE N4'.
C UN IL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY /��
COMMISSIONE v- ATF
RESOLVED, Upon the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning Code,
by Graham F. Boyd, owner of the subject premises, zoned in Light
Industry District, under said Zoning Code, described as Lots 3,
4, 5, 6, Block l, Kiefer�Park, according t�o the plat thereof on
file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and
for Ramsey County, Minnesota, that the provisions of said Zonin.g
Code, in respect to density and land area requirements, hereby
are determined and varied, in their application to said real
estate, as and to the extent necessary therefor, and that a permit
hereby is granted unto said appellant, and his successors in
interest, in respect of said real estate, for the construction of
a 17-unit apartment building to be constructed thereon, all in
accordance with plans therefor; and that otherwise, said appellant-
permittee, and his successors in interest, shall make due compliance
with all applicable ordinances, state statutes and rules and
regulations of public authorities having cognizanee.
---...—
zoxnie ae�s�►r.
l�NOt 1i wn �a! 4 Dub1t1�er
at DO�d�nuirY � 198�.
i in 'th!'CttS'- Coun�l Chamber in the
(�ty �iell: and 4'.o�Z`t Iiou6e, in the
matter of the aDP�al Oi f1i raY►am ,F.
Sq'd,�nder Q�ntera 80 to.'Q!Anclusive,
6t.P4�1 �tive..Code. ��g Code,
#ar s'elox�a o!ii�ity e�talidercis to
�;'s,,��",,,e g�a���T�&, f AP P ROV D
o�p t�he�ut�� dt A'�rr�ana ane.
vq.aat o!Clarance St.and a� rox�mat�e�'
��c os rr,a�.���a��aa Asst. Corporat+on Counsel
nated Jimtter9 11.,1988.
HARAY L.�4'AR$HAI.L,
CitY CRetk. ,
(Jaauary 18, 19l9)
��� � 1968
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Councii 19—
Yeas Nays
Carlson �"�� � 1968
Dalglish ' Approved 19�_
�' �In Favor
Meredith
�� (� ��il��' Mayor
A gainst
Tedesco
F�'x�i�'����:�:::::'•.'� Pd�LISNE� FEB 10 1968
Mr. Vice President (Holland)
��
� 1
BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 � PHONE: 223-4151
January 22, 1968 �������
�r. Harry Marshall
City Clerk
386 Courthouse
Dear Sir:
This is in reference to the appeal of Graham F. ;3oyd to r�lax
the zoning code's density standards on property located on the
south side o� Maryland Avenue befiween Clarance Street and the
Northern Pacific Railroad Tracks. This site is further described
as Lots 3, 4, 5, 6, Block #1 Kietfer Park. The applicant proposes
to construct a 17 unit apartment building on this site. A 17
unit apartment buildinff requires a lot with at least 19,560 squar�
f�et of area. The site in question is 60 square f�et short of
tne required area or 0.310 short.
This matter was considered by the Board of ZoninU on
December 31, 1967. The staff reported that the existing zoning
consists of light industry along th� Maryland Av�nue tronta�e,
heavy industry to the south, commercial to the east, and "G"
residence to tne north. Existing development in the ar�a
includes mixed types of residential structures to the west, an
apartment development to the north, and commercial developments
generally to the east, and new commercial developm�nt ta the
south. The city's Compreh�nsive Plan recommends this area for
the R-7 (high density residential) classification. It was th�
findings of the board that the relaxation would be a minimal
one and that this area in the future might allow ev�n highpr
densities.
Therefore, the Board of Zoning recommanded approval of the
request to relax the density standards to permit a 17 unit
apartment building.
Very truly yours,
�f ` '/ -_;�,�.�r-�--�_
���,� ��� ; . .
Vo and R. Hei en
Secretary
ao
� _ �
_ � �.J-�
v v
. D ✓,.
• 1
' T
Cfraham F . Boyd p�
1150 Transit Street
3t . Paul, i�innesota 55113
484 •- 4849 �i��xl�2� �v �
� „ 7t'1
� 3 � �. �
Thr iionorable Mayor and
City Concil
C/0 City Clerk
Room 38fi , City Hall dd �ourt House
Dear 31rs;
I haae a vaa�ant piec� of property zoned light
industry on whia�h I would like to huild a seventeen
unit apartment l�uilding.
This location is eighty fest West of the S. �T.
cornor of East M�ar�land and Clarencse concisting of
160 feet on Mary lsnc1 b� 1�1 1�2 f e�t d e pth ulus an
alley .
Tbe purnose oY this appeal is thQt 19,500 aquare
feet of land ie nee�essary for the type of building I
wi�ah �o construc�� , and that I fall short of that amount
r�y 60 squ�re feet as my total footage equa�la 19,440.
Sin�c�erely �ours,
.,,�';��0 ����i�''l
Property legal : Lots 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 Hlock �1
Kieffer Park.
�� BOAt�� OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION 12/21/67 Plat Map 33
Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 File No.
passed August 22, 1922 as amended to August 24, 1964 6�25
� Also 6�26 .
1. APPLICANT'S NAN� � Graham F. Boyd
2. CLASSIFICATION � Amendment � Appeal ❑Permit ❑ Other
(
_ �.
3. PURPOSE : Relax density standards to permit 17 unit apt. bldg.
4. LOCATION ' So. side Maxyland bet� Clarence & N.P. Tracks.
5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION � �ts 3, �+, 5, (, Block �/1 Kieffer Park.
6. PRESENT ZONING � Light Industry
7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: b�t.03 Section: Parag'raph: i
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 12/18/67 By: Gerald Kimball
A. ZONING ADMINISTRATOR: Indicated the area did not meet the requirements for the number
of units requested. Suggested appeal to City Council for approval.
B. HISTORY: None.
C. PROPOSED USE: Construct a 17-unit apartment building.
D. NEED FOR APPEAL: Relax area requirements for a 17-unit apartment building.
E. PRESENT STAND. : Present standard requires a 50' frontage and 19,500 sq. ft. of area.
� F. VARIAI�JCE: Site area is 19,400 sq. ft. , 60 sq.ft. short of required 19,500 sq.ft. ,or
. 0.31�' short (less than 1/2 of l�).
G. AREA ZONING: Ad�acent frontage along Maryland is zoned Light Industry. South is
" zoned Heavy Industry. East is zoned Commercial. North is zone
"C" Residence.
H. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is approximately 6' below the grade of the ad,joining pro-
perties and Maryland Avenue. Vacant, no sidewalk on Maryland.
I. AREA CONDITIONS: To the west is a single-family residence, a duplex, and an 18-unit
� apartment. North is a large apartment complex, east a single-family
residence, vacant lot and commercial development. South is a new
commercial development in a Heavy Industry District.
J. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: Recommends this area for the R-7 classification and Maryland
Avenue operate as arterial.
. _
9. BOARD ACTION; To Recommend � Approval Q Denial Council Lt .
Dated
Moved by: �e$ Yeas Nays
X Ames
Seconded by: McPartlin �Ri�&l3 Date of Hearing
. X Janes,Chmn.
g McPartlin Council Action
. �
Secretary's remarks: ' x Haarstick - Alt. .
�t��t3c�x D a t e
A��cR3��C� �
�
LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET
" � ��.� � �_. ._.. -_ • -- - � �,-'' � . '�� � ... (�...
�"' 4f� � ,�t �:� > �<-- - - �_ • �._.__ - T"_ . _v • .
�., � .;� -- ---_._---_ . c�^ ° � o --.----�Tr;
..;,�.;j i ,,#; .1 > — < . C3 . . � . � ,� __ — - � `�,
��.r,�'� �� '�• 1__"__.."___'__ �. � �O � � �� �
� -� �;.t:: :I'}�::�:�: � • .
.-,� ...,.:.. . .. ----_ . __ - ...______ __—� o
�� . �,� `�i,::::��- � - o ,� - a < o
. (� �:: �
) ( � .
��� �•,`;`::.:::;';?:;• .
j {•}:::• -- —- -- "' ---- -� • -- ---—-
�::i�:�[r�:. � - � ,-q l-�- — . ..»..
' - n :ii�::i .'i;�� • .
4y� � # �. _.._..._�..____�---- ��'_I �`L_> W � � S'� �' �(� __ _._..
' :� � �� � , � ; � � o � o ' o . ; �,�,
," . , -�::��.-- _-_�- — ,. . �Z . �.---...
� '�� z3 � . �, , ,. ,�1 � ;� > � o C,�
� ,
t ���E � '� � �. ---�- '-- -- --' Q � �_�>.-:- o o - �
' .: �::;:����::��:� �'� �� 0:- �. �� �, .� a ..�
� .k�;���.`�f:. `���-_ _ :_. .__ �- -- � i -. ----J � � -. �---- , � a � ��
: � :::}:::::f�: ,� i� z� ., ��Z > � � 4
_., ���.(�:����:�:�:' =� - ---� �� --�--- � "' � __ ._ � -� ,/
r :t:�::::#� W �--�--- ' -- �� < � _O � � �.
.: ..:
�. , � � �
;f,; � �•,:;.::.� 2 3 � - �. .. �j. �_ � • •.
._ .
( t�,::::� (� -- , � c� a �
� � , � i. '�• •�� --F 1W -�-�------ .�r... y k--' .-- � � ,.
w' � �:f`.:'`,1� , G �- �'� 'r� _�-�__ � -
`� .:� `�----_ --�3 __ � ?' Q --=a - Q�' '�,
?� �e ;:�:7:...t F_ '- ', �1� � . � � � � ^�__ � � �'I� 1. � '---__ I l � 1' •
.
L F .�:� ��' _ .':� �� � `- �♦.�. �T i. ' _."l _ .O�•...
�... . �
•" L,.•'.
w, � i _ ,. .�
�:.;•:�.. . , �� r - ,� 0- 1
,;,� � ; ::.� �. p, : ' 3u- � Zz - }L p� V W � �� vv�'.
�
� I
� �
� � � � :"� ';� I � � � 1""' � G ` j I p �� � . � �;
F :� "�. • � • '
—
fi �A��L A ��!iv�uiT+1Y _.._.:- --': - -- - -�--•- �-----aC��+��5�---------- ----A�
,:
� � , . :f:;. —
�`� '3�} ;` � ' .� ! ' � „ 'G ` r.�,o ° a °;: c�
,
s � i� � � .� � � .
�,-`�::t�:;::��� �, � " � �,F�CJ ,
.
�. -, :.:::. . . - , ..
. ... ,
f.:;.;�:::��. ., �_ �-- ! - -�=--- .,
� ,....:, --- -- � t. A _`
�..�;�C�.} , t..l .r � ' . r ~ .. �--._-__��� __-.- •,` .+ /� �- '�► S'
' j � 1�a(� �... - .
> >--�j,}���,���-f 1 , c� � .�
� :, ,, s.�:�. :'I:�' !v I v v v v v , ,� ' ,a _ � f,
'"�� J {.j .� i ��. �' , m .� ,�.2� � - - - - -- �
� � �� ,,� . ; � , '"
� . � ,
�M ���` �. :� R,O S E ��qvr � . � � �.. -- �- - - - - I •�� °�. r° -s .
� ',, i �`.::.�� ! , . . �I,
i,; �,,� 1 `� ; . � v tJ �. .. . . . . ..... .,.. v
1 Y . . �'
�`} �; N�v�v v;v�v v v v�v , , �, ------ _ :
... : � . .
,
. `�, � ' c�
;� � ,�� � � . �_ -t_--_ - 1 I-- -.- �--_�_ _I._ 1__1___ ° �� �
. r .� __ : ,� ;
r� � � :� � � —� • --•. .. ,._ { c.�aiz��5� 24 ; �
c;' ,., ; `�,� l .. . �
F . � � i. '-t✓'V�V � V !VIV�V V�V�Vi � . `i`2 \ "� . . � � . . ' t
, " ;{� �� � �;
:��� �� +t 1.�7 :� i . ' ' . �� �. . � � .� � j.
} I ' �:
-.'� .t T �t ,` ; F � . : �
'��'� � ��. :f.� �1. C� FF� � N I l 1 M. ---�! �1 ��`\ :2� . . , �\ . .. .�\ �a.`�...\� .., \..:��. . .....�\..,\ ... D...._.�
. V.1 . . _. .. . . .. . .
.. . . . . . , , � . :
��������� GRAIiA'f, F. BO}_'D _ .` ���.��D . .
�U����� Relax densit,y s�tandards to permit a 17- ��,�� ' ��'�.
Unit apartment bld'g on a lot of insuff.
. _ _ �. O ON�-�'r�i��lLY
area �
F'�ES�fV! �O��Il1�lG �i�►t Industry -O- TLP�JO-�Af��iLY .
. � � T�-��CC-�AMfLY
, .
{��`flTIORI �It�NERS ` - FOU�--F�f���1L.Y
. � �,�UL�"{- FI�MILY
rILE No. 61�25 . n1aR'CH � n CQMUI�RCI,4L���=` : 1
. n INDUSTf�IAL
� V V/�CA�T :
�, �,�..� n,..�r:...,, o„n,.a n„�,�.,,,,,, a ,0�,7 c�,l��� Pf(�r7:�Y�'U ltP1��E�1' �nt�c�rlr�rr�fiinn
�
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
j MINNESOTA
� DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
� 113 Courf House 55102
! January 12, 196�
,
City Clerk
File X440, Page
I
�
You are hereb notified that a ublic hearin wi be e in e
y p g 11 h ld th
� Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of
St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on January 25, 1968, on the appeal oE
� Graham F. Boyd to relax densiCy standards to permit a 17-unit
' apartment building on the following described property: Lots 3,
I 4, 5 and 6, Block 1, Kieffer Park. The property is located on
the south side of Maryland Avenue west of Clarence Street and
approximately 306 feet east of Northern Pacific Railroad tracks.
For further information contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Co�nerce
Building or phone 223-4151.
I
� JANI�S J. DALGLISH
,
Couunissioner of Finance
�
�
•- 55
Adopted by the Council 196—
Yeas Nays
CARLSON
DALGLISH
HOLLAND
MEREDITH
PETEftSON
TEDESCO
MR. PRESIDENT (BYRNE)
�
�
/
�°�