The URL can be used to link to this page

236716 ORIGINAL TO CITY CL6RK � "-v� • 16 � • CITY OF ST. PAUL FIOENCIL NO. OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK COUNCIL RESOLUTION-GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY '�i� ��t'.� ��J COMMISSIONE � DATF RESOLVED, Upon the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning Code, by Memorial Lutheran Church, owner of the subjeet premises, zoned in "A" Residence District, under said Zoning Code, des- cribed as Lot 19 and that part of the north-south alley lying between the extended northerly line of Lot 19 and the north line of Maryland Avenue, all in Block 8, Phalen Heights Park, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Registrar of Titles in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota, that the provisions of said Zoning Code, in respect to buffer requirements, hereby are determined and varied, in their application to said real estate, as and to the extent necessary therefor, and that the required eight foot buffer from residential property be relaxed to four feet on the property to be used as a parking facility for chureh activity, all in accordance with plana there- for dated Received September 27, 1967; and that otherwise, said appellant-permittee, and its successors in interest, shall make due compliance with all applicable ordinances, state statutes and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance; be it FURTAER RESOLVED, Upon the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning Code, by Memorial Lutheran Church, as owner of the subjeet real estate, situate in the City of Saint Paul, zoned in "A" Residence District, under the Zoning Code, and described as Lot 19 and that part of the north-south alley lying between the extended northerly line of Lot 19 and the north line of Maryland Avenue, all in Block 8, Phalen Heights Park, and located on the north side of Maryland Avenue between Earl and Frank Streets, that the provisions of said Zoning Code hereby are determined and varied as and to the extent necessary therefor, and the building setback line of said real estate, in respect of the north line of Maryland Avenue upon which the same abuts, hereby is established as a line drawn across said real estate parallel thereto and 2. 5 feet distant from said n.orth line of Maryland Avenue. RM APP 'D � Asst. Corporation Counsef ,�� . �i �.��1� COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays �� „��,� �, �°> �� :;; , Dalglish Approvecl � 19— Holland Meredith Favor , Peterson J MaYor Tedesco A 8'��st Mr. President, Byrne �U�LIS�E� JAN 2 0 1968 . . �22 ' 23�'7�� . , . BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 November 28, 1967 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Building Dear Sir: This is written in response to the appeal of the Memorial Lutheran Church to relax the required eight foot buffer from residential property, and to relax the required setback from the front property line on property located on the north side of Maryland Avenue between Earl and Frank Streets. This property is further described as Lot 19 and that part of the north-south alley lying between the extended northerly line of Lot Z9 and the north line of Maryland Avenue, all in Block 8, Phalen Heights Park. The applicant proposes to use the property as a parking facility for church activity. However, the Zoning Code requires that for parking lots with a capacity of ten or more cars, an eight foot buffer should be pro- vided on any side adjoining residentially zoned property. It also provides that parking spaces be designed to be no closer than one-half the estab- lished building line setback. In this case, the required setback for the parking lot would be 12 feet. The applicant proposes to relax the eight foot buffer to four feet, and the 12 foot setback to 2.5 feet. This matter was considered at the October 5, 1967 Board of Zoning meeting. The staff reported that the area is zoned "A" residence except for the northwest, southwest, and southeast corners of Earl Street and Maryland Avenue which are zoned commercial. The lot is presently vacant. Memorial Lutheran Church is to the west and a single-family dwelling is to the east. It was the findings of. the Board ' ^+- the requested relaxations of the Zoning Code requirements would n �iinental to surrounding properties inasmuch as the parking lot wou ��t��,�°�v`�n Sundays. Therefore, the Board of Zoning ��y a�o�b� v�, request to relax the buffer requirement t ��p�,.°'��C�a'�„'��,ar,�� k requirement to 2.5 feet. Z��ap�o�.t�� s st: � un ��r,��°�e �"��t�q��,p r$ur�''��'7,ap�r'!��'y�m 19 tou �k hy�'+��z$�tve�,to� uly yours, ��r°�a��e ,d,,''�, �1et�ent�re�e,t�t 6c,�°`t'e th�d�cl � alle,•1 wa�_��`d p°8.g� �t ,) / , e g��.�lj�,�j�etY,y"�e�b��' t�8��y�� 'r �o� g P��°,p� ��og"�i"�,� �e°� _ c'k ' �'`�''�? -...._._. lja d�arl�da p� '8'�'��hg�d'-;l�. �aqj �,. j�E1 NOqe+�,bei,�k�"m� �,' o� et�ry �:FGI (nt,��Y�'.j� . � Z F �1$ j�f'��er• � . . 63 7 6 �j, �. /�� _ ,�,,,�,.;..� Encl. �:;.i _ � �,? °-� � � � CHURCH OFRICE: 774-75l7 ` ` � ' • �... M�MORI1��. �,U��R1�.N C�I�RC�-i �� i�� EARL STREET dc MARYLAND AVENUE '� � � _ .� F C� �� , ,� Jt. �au�, �inn¢sote SS106 � e � }3r� i - L. O. BJORLIi, rABTOR 1 • �' '� September 22, 1967 ' -�.�- ___._ The Honorable Mayor and City Council City of St. Paul % City Clerk Room 386, City Hall and Court House St. Paul, Minnesota Gentlemen: Memorial Lutheran Church of Earl and Maryland Avenues, telephone No. 774-7557 respectfully make a zoning apgeal to relax the e�,ght (8) foot buffer requirement and to relax the set back from Maryland Avenue to two and one half (2 1/2) feet required in Legislative Code Chapter 64.03, paragraph J. � We desire to establish a new parking lot on a vacant lot and recently vacated portion of alley abutting it on the north side of Maryland Avenue between Earl and Frank Streets. The legal description of the property is Lot 19, Block 8, in Phalen Heights Park and the description of the vacated alley 3ns "that part of the north and south alley in Block 8, Phalen Heights Park, e''�lying between the extended northerly line of Lot 19 and the north line of Maryland Avenue". Vacation of alley was adopted by the City Council on August 3, 1967. The property is presently vacant, we desire to alleviate a very serious parking problem by establishment of a parking lot on these properties. Relaxation of the aforementioned requirements will provide more, safer and better parking facilities, and we beleive that it will be more satisfactory and beneficial to other abutting property and also other nearby properties, and also to the good of all concerned. Flow of traffic in this vicinity is extremely heavy. The establishment of as much off street parking as is possible for use �in connection with church services and activities of Memorial Lutheran Church should be beneficial to all concerned. The relaxing of normal requirements will add to number of parking facilities available. We tlserefore respectfully request approval of this appeal and approval of the plan proposed herewith. very truly yours, MEMORIAL LUTHERAN CHURCH By: �. E. M. Sturzen r ustee ., . .__...��i^' s.,,�._.,... � , ... � ._. . . _ . . t�49 �`� b ., 's '�� ,C� --�,� � �� 0 . BOAItD Or ZONING RE;PORT AND ACTION 10%�/67 Plat Map 33 Aci;ing under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 File No. 637G passed August 22, 1922 as amencled to August 24, 1964 Also 6371 � 1. APPLICANT'S NANE : Pieniarial Lutheran Church � i 2. CLASSIFICATION • � Amenciment Q Appeal ❑Permit ❑ Other � 3. PUR.POSE : Relax buffer requirement; relax setback requirement� 4. LOCATION � N. side T4aryland bettan. Earl & Frank Sts. 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION � Lot 19 & that part of the north & south alley lying betwn. the extended northerly line of Lot 19 & the north line of !•iaryland Ave., all in Block S, Phalen Heights Park 6. PRESENT ZONING . "A" P�esidence ?. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter; 64.U3 Section: Paragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: i%/�.J By; �C,� A. ZONING ADiSINISTRA.TOK: No action. B. HISTOP.Y: hone C. PROPOSiD US�: Use the one lot and the north-south vacated alley as a parking facility for church activities. D. PP.�SENT STAATDAP.D: The property in 60'x121' ; Standards require an 25` buffer for parking lots with a capacity oi lU or more cars adjoininb reszdential zoned property. The setback requirement is one half tne established building line set back in tne block 12' E. NLEi� FOR �iPPEAL: Capacity of t11e parking lot would be less if standard u' buffer and 12' set bacic were maintained. F. VARIANC�: Four ft. where 8` buifer is required and 2.5' c��here 12' set back i.s required. G. AP.E�`. ZONTNG: Tne area is zoned "A" P.es. except for �iie N.t��,, S.tid., & S.E. corners of �arl St. & ,laryland Ave. cahich are zoned Conuiercial. „ H. SITE CONDITIONS: The lot i.s vacanr and the vacated alley is still in use as an alley. The lot is slightly higher tiian the property to the ��est. I. AREA COI�3i ITIOI3S: The area uses are as follocas: north, one-family; east, one-famil.y; south, commerCial and one-family; ancl west, the church. 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend � Approval � Denial Coancil Lt. Dated 11/�8/67 Moved by: i�lcPartlin Yeas Nays �r��s Seconded by: Gadler ��sn Date of Hearin� 11/30/67 x Janes,Chmn. X McPartlin Council Action Secretary's remarks; X Haarstick - Alt, X Gadler Date � Maietta • x Gau�er LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET ,_ _.�_._._.�...— — ...:i'i _»._..T..� , ..�� i �°�r► � ' � . I .�� ,�j�l�•� ��' 'C7'�;(�:��Q�Q' ��'fli _�- � , I � i � � ; � i + � I °;° _o ___ q io,c� � o 0 0 �� I� � � a o U� � � I --o - __ � � � � � <I. � • � �.----a _�. _.�:. I__l_----J--- -_ -- . .--.._.... . ----__.. _ . .__---j -- ___. . � , T � __r .—r _ . l.._ , � -- ---- ..„. � ; I � f � I � *-- �'— (.� ,�, :., �f i �A -t- � I F— �3 ��;c�4�,��;�,, �>�tJ O��O�O�O� q , �_ CJ U O C� O C� 10 O�O C� � ;�� ; J ;� c� U O t.:� , „ � : �._...� . _ , t,.�..r�'�8._.. � _N A��i' �! � t� �f f� ; �r;��o�a c:�ca o c� �o 0 0 0�0 --� ---- o 0 o a o � o 0 0;o o ,�: c, �� o o v. _.��_�_1__._1 � � �-_-- ; , _ _ � _ __1 �1`�R � - ---�--�-_----�- -�-1- � ; b Q --- � _-1- .T- , � i �--- - ---�.: ..�� :-�I,-• � � � r a � � � ! � �. ' I ._ � � i , `.f .�� ) � � i � � � � , . , ,- �� '�� .. C� V;� C� � O � O �-� , a `� (��C)�Q �;O p;p�p � ,,� �.. , , C��Cj;C'�,p� .+ � �;�:�r•,•.,°��N n o -r.y�c��;�� .4' � I � ; ' K '.. .__......�------ -- ------ B�a�_�y:.,� • -��- -- --��( 3,- �--- - -----—— - --- - �- ____-----�---.._.....----- y ....,._._.._.._._.. " r•r.�r: ? J�i ��J� 'C)� � � O r--- � , � , , �_ �sa ' ;0� ! ' ' , , �� .�,v�v��,� O;J i � v � , i � i > o c:> �o o�oo �. �� R;�Y -��- � �;o; ;o,o o;o�o;o� �. ;� � ' . _.1_.�1._� _�._.� ' __�� - � � ' � ' , ' ' I � ' I I r_. 4r—a�p.,Q� L � � ! � R �ivn �; ., <�57.,� �— - ----- � r - - -- — -�----1--�- i ---�---I -- I _ a. .. �-�i 1 j _T _( _ .1 --._� . l__ _:_.,....T. . � �' ' ':,, I l , -°� �� ; ; ; � � � � , .� , ; I �; 1 - c::► �► c� �� o�o Uio 0 0�0 0;0 � o�o�o�o:o o'o o!c � !� ��o��;�,��i _._..�__� .:��_. , � ; � , � - , ROS� �.� M L��Q ^��..�I U' U U � �'� + Q__ �� C.�' )'' ' � ' � ,/' � ' I o � c ��o�o�Q:o�o�o a ��u, ,� o�o:� � , n,. '+: ; I � I� i � -- -- � ' i � i ! i f , I � i , ,; _ ; �� f , 1....: 1 --- --a --. _� � l_1._ -- ----- C> --� _1__.1_—l—�_L_L_L__l L___�--1---��–�---L_1__� . . ... . _ _ --' �- - �r �'--� � � I- 7-- I •• _ .. __�"'_�r—� -i---�-- �----i - r � . � I I � ' � I � (` � I U 'Q � � I I I , I 1--�.-- 11 ;r, r."_ ".��.-1 �-�! � J U O O , ' � � � � , I �, �.��.._�_..�L� �...'��. i�. _- o� ; .. -r U` �c o�,�,o,o,o;o,o:� ; .;�� r�;;�:Q,�:� �I, � �� ,� � � � c�r�;�� c� ;� o,o�� o � � r�o�'o o' o �� o ��c�� ; ;; � (. � O � t� UGC�, � � � �� i ; � ; : � ; � , . , i 0 I � ( � t I i ; i ; , � 1 I . � I � ♦ , � I I � a.7r i I� 1�' � �-�-.�1.� �_1__l_�. ' � I � _ ��—� . I i � . `—�,. I � --�.._._l.l_. � _...._.L. __ �. � i � , -.._. _. . _ ____ _ - r.__ � _� �. �. i U -,— ` I.._ � �.. I I —T--- � � I ��_._ �_.. � ;;_. i ,, I � � � � � I , ; ;-�_ � ° - , _ �� T � ; � ; ; �- ; ; -�-- ;___, ; �� 1 '� �(..1i,'l:( 1 �n� :�` (l� (!1 t I i � � ��.i ,,,�!r'�� r'�:n'r� r,,,�.� :� ._. .__ ., .I _ ! ... � . J J � %' , _ �R. }. ��f F� LIC��-��3�� c��.:.��,�� . Memorial Luther:� Church PU��,O��.; Relax Buffer � Setbacks ��N� US�:: PC-�ESLI�!�7' zU�1i�vG � "A" Residence O -ONL�_ Fl1f�.�11LY 'Q, 'i�V�i 0 Fn�I�I LY . �, �l-I-I f�l(_E i�-!\��1 I L`r" PC�TI!'!�(�J SIGi�!�:f�S� . ; -- F4UR F�t�filY ��t��U l_T 1�- F!�i��!i_Y �i�..� �o. 6376 � � �� co�f��;�e��ci�,�. - � �� n � l�C��1 S��F�11�� Na�t'i"�.1 G� Prht�E Plr��ittf� �=1rt[�s'ri . �f32'f� SeDtember 2II.1967 Y///�//� ��i�i�.�� j� ��r..�a�l ��..�;`� r� CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 November 17, 19�7 City Clerk File XLi01, Page Yon are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House at 1Os00 a.m. on November 30, 1967, on the appeal of Memorial Lutheran Church to: Z) relax 8 foot buffer requrement to 1� feet 2) relax 12 foot setback requirement to 2.5 feet on the following property: Lot 19 and that part of the vacated north and south alley lying between the extended northerly line of Lot 19, and the north line of Maryland Avenue, all in Block 8, �'halen Heights Park and located on the north side of Maryland Avenue between Earl and Frank Streets. For f�rther information contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Commerce Building or phone 223-l�151. JAM�'S J. DALGLISH Corrnnissioner of Finance O