236669 ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK • • 23fi6s9
CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO. _
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
COUNCIL RESOLUTION-GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY �,�/�/
COMMISSIONER ��"'� -�� �� DATF -_
RESOLVED, upon the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning
Code, by Mrs. Helen Stirzl, owner of the subject premises, zoned
in Light Industry District, under said Zoning Code, described as
Lots 13 and 14, Block 1, Beck and Breckenridge Addition to St.
Paul, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the
office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota,
that the provisions of said Zoning Code, in respect to density and
land area requirements, hereby are determined and varied, in their
application to said real estate, as and to the extent necessary
therefor, and that a permit hereby is granted un.to said appellant,
- and her succesaors in interest, in respect of said real estate,
' for the division of her existing property and the construction of
a single-family residence on the vacan.t portion of the aite, all
in accordance with plans therefor; and that otherwiae, said
appellant-permittee, and her successors in interest, shall make
due compliance with all applicable ordinances, State st�utes and
rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance.
F M APPi� E
,�,
Asst. Corporation Counsel � � � 19sa
���
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Nays , � , � ��6�
t
,�P�'gb�'i—�, ��'a'� � `,
Dalglish Approved 19�
Holland �U Tn Favor
Meredith '
Peterson � Mayor
Tedesco A Sainst
Mr. President, Byrne
PUBLIS�IED JAN 2 0 196$
�.2z
236�69
BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUI
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
�ZONII�SA I�PY�I.,
December 22, 1967���� � t°'t ie��'c�°'
�: � ��,
�i�e�. fa the 1CitY Gouuc� cruen'eer
the City Hall and CQUYt Ei4t�e, !a�
Mr. Harry E. Marshall, �,natt.r ot tt►e �r+� ��$•�. �_�
C i ty C 1 e rk �ci��ve,st"t.�rau����ve coae,,zon�
1 ia8 Code. tor Pe�ion to x�li►x
386 Courthouse aenstty at�,aara��a s- �ex on a iot
Saint Pau1, Minnesota 55102 'sfock`�x,18e��a�a''��°�A'�
tion. at the northe�st co�r ot Jmto
d Osceola Av�.
Dear Sir: �at� �c�ffi� ���r
tnecemtrer 19, 1967)��
This is in reference to the a.pplica.tion of Mrs. He_�..
Stirzl for appeal to relax the Zoning Code building density
standards on property located at the northeast corner of
Juno Avenue and Osceola Street and further described as Lots
13 and 14, B1ock 1, Beck and Breckenridge Addition.
The applicant proposes to divide her existing property
and construct a single-family residence on the vacant portion
of the site. A three-plex presently exists on the northerly
portion of the property. However, this action would reduce
th e existing land area of the existing three-plex below the
required 1ot area minimums. A three-plex requires 6,900 sq.
feet of land area. Resulting area after the new structure
was built would be 5,953 sq. feet or 10.37% short of the re-
quirements.
This matter was considered at the November 16, 1967 Board
of Zoning meeting. The staff reported that the existing zon-
ing for the property in question and the area to the east and
south is zoned Light Industry. 'I'he area to the north and
west is zoned commercial. Existing development in the area
includes mixed commercial and residentia.l uses. The Mi1-
waukee Road tracks are east and south of the property. The
Comprehensive P1an recommends future development to include
commercial use for the subject property and the area. to the
r�orth and industria.l use for the area to the east and south.
It was the findings of the Board that the relaxation to
the proposed density would not be excessive and would have no
detrimenta.l effect on the neighborhood. Therefore, the Board
of Zoning reco�nends approval of the appeal to relax density
standards to a.11ow a three-plex on the subject property.
Very truly yours,
,.� , , •�
�/ � --� � ,, �
.' `
,, �:���.�-,.}r�_....
N�/R.� �ei�en, ,� � ..��
� �',��
NRH:rc Secretary �� ���-� ���
GMK d ��
ZF 6400 �
�
_ + , . . � � �
LAW OFFICES OF � v�
D . D. WOZNIAK �,
MINNESOTA BUILDINO
SAINT PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101
P H O N E: 227-9494
October 31, 196?
The Honorable Mayor and City Council
c/o City Clerk
Room 386, City Hall & Court House
5t. Paul, Minnesota 55102
Gentlemen:
We represent Mrs. Helen Stirzl (227-3213), who owns Lots
Thirteen (13) and Fourteen (14}, Block One (1), Beck and
Breckenridge Addition, in St. Paul.
This property is located on the northeast corner of Osceola
and Juno, and its boundaries are 120 x 81 feet.
There is presently existing a three-plex facing Osceola, and
Mrs. Stirzl, a widow, desires to build a small home on the
vacant portion of the lots on the northeast corner,
We desire to appeal under Chapter 64, �ection 03, Paragraph
i. The purpose of the appeal is to rela� the density standards,
since the family home which she will build will require 4, 000
square feet. This will be built on the area of 49. 5 feet facing
Osceola and 81 feet along Juno. This will meet the reguirement
of the code of 4, 000 square feet, but the remaining three-plex
will be situated on only 5, 953. 5 square feet and, therefore, will
be 946. 5 square feet short.
I hope that you will give this matter your favorable consideration.
Thank you for your anticipated courtesy in this matter.
You ve y tru y,
r r
D. D, Wozn"
DDW:fg
P.S. Enclosed find check for �30. 00 covering the costs of this
application.
BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION 11/16-67 Plat Map 8
Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 File No, b�p�
passed August 22, 1922 as amended to August 24, 1964
Also
1. APPLICANT'S NAME • i�rs. �ieZen Stirzl .
2. CLASSIFICATION � � Amendment Q Appeal � ❑Permit ❑ Other
- 1
3. PURPOSE • Rela�: Dens}ty Standards to permit 3-nlex on insuff, area.
4. LOCATION • N.E. corner Juno & Osceola `
5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION � Lots 13, 14� Block 1, Bectc & Breckenridge Add.
6. PRESENT ZONING . Light industry
7, PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter; 64.03 Section: Paragraph:
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 11/9J67 By; ATB
11/6/67 GK
A. ZO:�ING ADMINISTP.ATOR: h�o action.
B. HISTQP.Y: None ,
C. PfiOPOS�D USE: D�tvide the property and construct a single-farnily residence on the site.
D. NBED FOR APPEAL: The proposed division of the property will allow for sufficient area
and frantage for the single-family resiclence but will reduce the area of the
existing 3-plex below the reQuire� Zat. area minimuas. ,a
E. PRESrNT STA:�ILi�RD: Si.ngle family residence requires a min. of !+0' lot ��i.dtlt and 4000'
lot area. A 3-plex requires a mi.nimum of 50' lot width at the set-back line and
6,900 ' lot area.
F. VARIANCE: Required for a 3-glex 6,9Q0 ' area available is 5,953.5', (946.5' or ].0.37%
short). .
G. AREA 70NIA?G: This proPerty is 2oned light industry as is the progerty to the east and
south, north and west-is zoned commercial.
H. SITE CONDITTON: SiCe is� ap�pnrox. level and at the ;rade of Osceola and 2 feeC above the
� g-rade of 3uno S�. �e�Z� exists along Osceola St. but not along Juno St. Old 2-car
oarage to the rear of the existing three-plex adjacent to the publ.ic alley. Space
� for a 3rd car available ad,jacent to the garage and to the rear of the existing
structure. Tall sh�vbbery surrounds the site to be dev�loped with single-fam�.ly res.
I. AREA CONDZTIONS: The adjacent area is developed with niixed residen�i.al and commercial
uses. The I'ord spur of the t�Iilwaulcee Road is east„��d �outh'�o� this property the
area t-Q--C-��w��:: is mostly vacant eas.r ��.�e.sai.lxoad--t�aele: (Cont.' over)
9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend x0 Approval � Denial - Council Lt.
Dated
Moved by: t�icPartlin Yeas Nays
Ames
Seconded by: Cohen x Cohen Date of Hearing
Janes,Chmn. x
x McPartlin Council Action
Secretary's remarks: Haarstick - �Lt.
;� Gadler Date
Maietta '
LEGAL NOTICES ON TI� BACK OF THIS SI-�ET
, �
„ _.
,. O _ _ • .. -
.r� 0 , � � �t -Li `��y�� , ��
.
_ '' .__- ___r_ ._. �� - - �: � � .. _.�, - : ,, •
� � l'f ^ V -�- a "� ' , � a.`�, Z' � \ I .'
,
J +._. .__ r.. ,,,� � � RE TORY�� � � , ..c•.<` �
{ti- �� � /_ ..__ ' _ � �� A� - '.�N � � ,..r.-- .\ �... _ (').^.
__ ��
- ' � O ,� 1 .�3 r� _ ���• "•�.. ��M� �:�
, ,
. . ____�.r---- - ,
- -- -
-1 ' r� O ��'� �”. �` � ' G � '4, \ , . 1. �. �
: � . C • •
_._.---;.--- _ ^ �.
. ��- � - �, �o Ps }, �a P ��,. ,�� .:� . � � c �
—,`----�yc--1♦ � � � f�1 .
- � •,'� � � I ''r � � � '' �'.p �_—`;��p �
��----� -- _.. . . . .__ � � . Q ;.'.,. '��: __._... `�_'-! Li.�
� I n a � I � � �o � ,'�'�� ,r S` ` "t 1.
r1 --+-----�-- —. _ _._ � Q - o �� � -
. '• �
, �l � ( � ,� ' ---
r. +—' � , �Q`� '-� C� • YD r-»
� ;�� -- p � p � ��' �'��,�,'�'� c� l��-��'' - _
tio���- .: �
, ��,_
���,�.�,�.:J ..�: l ...
� . . � �• I Q�.^•f[ �`.:.•vf.(J:f�.( `:6✓,�� y
' C G `°1:� ta O � �r.-.: ....
I I I I I � O �\o � '� .M-• � � .{ � ;3�, �,`�
C�i O;,O O I �7 O � U U; Q -Q. � --�- ' � Q A, � •. Q ,._ . �'_ 1,, 5 �� ..
I��i ��S�a� � I � � C _��.6, �, ,,y��J iR i '' , ^ Z I ,, i � ��� '�
� �--� �s... -1��. O � \. � .':�1 'M` �" T i . ('J O � , (� � , �
-i�+� _ ..r. , !..v��.. � o ,., +. . ,.� � ��`� . ..1.
I 1 I � .., � � _ . ._ —^
�ar�n��.��LCt�!V ��--t—�,- � R :�, �" ,%-; �> � � ' k .,r..
5 I ; t ,;:�t
� Q j,�� (� �O ti � O F--�---- � � ��� i f I `%r �,� l �-�'�! + �1 � ,
6 • � ' � ��� �I � � pG � ''�i � � �� '�I��� [�" �,-''� _ -+ ' ; ��+ .� ►l �,_
, , ._.
� 3 i / .►-: --—�-__--_:�J
�
a ..<__._
RAtil�t�LP�.! ` — . -- - _
__ _ --�� --
. ---�
s i� -� ' '�� ��
,:��r �� r_vcr: �.onh•�_�� _^r.. .__� '•,� -�— - , ......
. ��
�� �.( I }� n �. �� T� ,.. = .�� �. t:;t�ib�.
V � � U � � �! AC'�` , ',�� �� ' � O 0 t . . I �'�'' �F .��• r` ......
Q � i Q'� �� _ I �, vG:.•.•.:. ::� : ...,.,.�►, VtJ
� i , �M���`q�y; �� � � � r::;;:.:.:� � �'�N� D �
Q �.r.. i.. i _� ,, l o � ��t� , a � {t :.'� '
� ' Q��Y�.��1 ,'DH�"�1�. I � ' - -;M ��. � V �
�f � (. � ,�`�3. O A ,;���\ � r, � !T � Q �
.-.•
�- ���� � � � �� . . �., v J � \ ,
- O__ - J. ����' ^�` °�°P ` f' � � '`,.
�..' .^3�`�`� � �`. , p �, ,�' : � I O � � v •. ,,.
�� � .
� :�. ��.r�f ,. ., :�.: �
�- - , � � � .. � � � � .
4 4` '� �� V .
� � �
, `�� .,4,=`;��' �� ^Y�� �. ,�- I� � ; � p p
;� M , , . � I
c; e � `,°� , oo;�' ipip "J � a ; i i D �
,� � _ (,�,� (',� �
� -��\� .r`` �';tc , �� I � I I �� � `.t ` '1\� �J+�v �v� \� V� I
'•� �1��`� � � �oe?m!� I � ,�.:.�...... J__� I � .i. O� ..
�� � ,: . - - � ,.
� .,�� O ���` "� �► i, _ _ ;•
P a- `� � � �^� ( � �_.__r. j _T-_�- � \ ;
-� �,��-..j ;�� , • , 1 _� ,�, � ,
' � --►�� '�� .��. �� � i ��,��� �, ::�� � � � � ► i ,
�, ` (� .
C�_i0 '�r�\��►�; �T I���l�v( � (''' � j ' I�/, ,% i �/, i i �/� i � ' V � �, ��,.
� � .�._• �::..��� � , I ( p�,
;?'n P .i E'�.�5� S /�rc�:c��v t3,�.�.5.F � ! lS�,
J s� � ,,,A , �z,<� R.ON y �' L �V�, � � �
', . . : r S.ynr �
J9�. � +� . � ' ��.�� x . ` � � . .
I�.—. t�
R .l:i. ..��. .� ...•.l� _�.�� kiii:f. Y`�>�4 � � . � IN � �
�-+t- f�L���� 1 �P4rs. Helen st�r�l LEG�f��
. . .
�7U�-��-�u��; Re�ax Dens�t,y Standards to permit a L��[� U�j��
3 Plex. on a lot of insufficient area �
PRESEN7 �4�'IyG � O -O�dE F�t�11LY
Light Indus try �Q Y W 0 FA UI!L'(
�, TH f,E E Fl\P��I LY
PETI�eOf� S1�N�RS: '_ - -- FQUR FAMILY
_ � ' �lf:��L_�I� F�1��I1_Y �
s=l�_� R�o. 6��0 0 � n c�n�►��c�ac���
� � � t���t��ss��E�����.
. �o��� -- .
St. Pc�tsi f-'ICitl�llilq Qo�Yd, C��4o Nov. 6, 196� �i��1��'_�1.J ���:�J���Cd'�"�f IN �G3�.S'i t{3t�
CITY OF � SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
December 7.5, 7.967
City Clerk
File Xl�2Lt, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the
Council Chambers of the Gity Hall and Court House in the City of
St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on December 28, 1967, on the appeal of
Mrs. Helen Stirzl to relax density standards to permit a 3-plex
on a lot of insuffiaient area on the following property: Lots 13
and 11�, Block l, Beck and Breckenridge Addition. The property is
located on the northeast corner of Juno and Osceola Avenues.
For further information contact Planning Baard, Room 1010 Commerce
Building or phone 223-415i.
JAMES J. DALGLISH
Commissioner of Finance
O