243840 ♦OIlI61NAL TO CITY C BRK e , Li3tJ��
• CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCi� N0. �-�
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE
C U��L SOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE DATF
��r- RESOLVED, Upon the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning
Gode, by Gordon. R. Struck, owner of the subject premises,
zoned in "C" Residence District, under said Zoning Gode,
described as Lots 1 and 2 except the west 40 feet of Lot
2, Block 2, Merriam Park Second Addition, at the southwest
corner of Marshall Avenue and Dewey Street, according to
the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of
the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota,
that the provisions of said Zoning Code, in respect to
density requirements, hereby are determined an.d varied, in
their application to said real estate, as and to the exten�
necessary therefor, and that a permit hereby is granted unto
� said appellant , and his successors in interest, in respect
� of said real estate, for the construction of a seven-unit
- apartment building to be constructed thereon, all in
accordance with plans therefor dated Received February 5,
, 1969; and that otherwise, said appellant-permittee, and his
successors in interest, shall make due compliance with all
applicable ordinances , state statutes and rules and regula--
tions of public authorities having cognizance.
F�(� PROYED
Mst ' Gou
MA�,- � ; 1969
COUNC MEN Adopted by the Councii 19_
Yeas Nays
Carls n �,�:? ` � '��,�
Approve 19�_.
Mere ith � ^
Tn,Favor ,� -
Pete on
Spra a � �CtlA� Mayor
Tede co A gainst
.,r_ ��,,,���El�
��id��a�,�Yrn =
Mr. Vice Pr ident�� 'PUeLISHEr MAY 17 1969
0
r •�
• � Harr:y E. a�shall w�'T'' �F� Albert e. Oisoa
' City CZ k and y`''��% CounciZ Recorder
Commissioner o Registrati.on a �
_�,°. aro
`rJ, ^C
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
BUREAU OP RECORDS ������
�88 City Hall
St.Paul,Minnesota 5510�
April 10, 1969
Mr. Joseph P. Summers
Corporation Counsel
Building
Dear Sir:
The City Council requested that you prepare a resolution grantin�
the attached appeal of Gordon R. Struck to relax the density re-
quireznents of the Zoning Code on Lats l ffid 2 except the west 40
feet of Lot 2, Block 2, Merriam Park Second Addition, at the south-
west corner of Marshall Ave. and Dewey St.
V ry truly yours,
`' , ���
City lerk �
ng
�+ � � � � � � �
��R � 1 ���9
�ORpI)R/�T�iQ`'! ��'-1�:ti='-'-
\
O
� �
BOAR OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
1010 COMM RCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
April 8, 1969
Mr. ry E. Marshall
Cit Clerk
Room 386
City Hall ard Courthouse
De3r Sir:
This is written in response to the appeal of Gar�don R. Struck to
rela the density requirements o� the Zoning Code on Lots 1 ar�d 2
exc t the west 40 fe�t of Lot 2, Block 2, Me�riam Paxk Secord Addition,
lxa ed on the southwest corner of the int�rsection of Marshall Av�nue
ar�d ewey Street.
This matter was considered at the March 20, 1969 Board of Zoning
meeting. The staff reported the site is occupied by a large frame
six nit dwelling in neecl of rehabil.itation. The area requi.red for a
sev -unit apartment building is 10,500 square fe�t. This property has
an ea of 10,260 square feet, 240 sqvare feet or 2.29$ short. It was
not that the Comprehensive Pl.an re.commended a density of 15 dwelling
uni per acre ar�d this proposal represented approximately 30 units
per cre. It was noted that the existing d�teriorating building
con ining six units raeul.d be replaced by a new building containing
onl one more unit ar�d would provide off-street garking. There were
no bjections raised at the me�ting by the area residents.
It was the fittiin� of the Board of Zoning that the r�quest to
rel x the density requirem�nts was r�asonable arxi that the new structure
w�a im�ove the area. Cons�quentl.y, the Board voted unanimously to
rec erd app�oval of the appeal.
Very truly yours,
��k!�r�CJ rl� �
�£'eter J. ietta
Secretar
PJM: v
ATB
Z.F. #6719
�..-�� � ��
� �
� �
80 �
.
. , • � �� �6 `= � S69
. � �S�s
.
.. _
4�1 R. Lynnhurst Ave.
St. Pea�I, l�ia�a. 65104
�'f/�►ruary b, 1969
'Pk� norable Ya�ror aad City Couaail
c/o C ty Cl�rk
Boom 6� City Ha11 and Courtho�e
$t. ui, ltian. 5b102
G1ent 1 ;
lppli tios is hexawith re�pectf�ally submitted for psrmie�aian to aomntruct
a► ne 7-ronit spartmeat building at the following describ�d location;
ts One(1) and 'lh►o(2)� except the Xe�t 40 feet of Lo� Two(2), a11 in
loch T�ro(3). �econd bddi�ioa lterria�a Per]c to the City of St. Pau1,
Thia oce.tioa is _an t�la,e 8outhwe�t cerner of the interaection o� Nwr�ahall Ave.
and wsy St.
�t pr .aent there is a sia-�mit apartmeut building oa the �it��r, approxime�tely
70 y old, in a d�teriorafiil�g condi�ion and a ilefisits detrimeat to tlae
sei onc�ofl. Our in�tention ia`to raze the old building and to erect a aew
7wni a�tmen� bu�:2d3ng anc� a 7-�ta�l garage on tbe sits. $xtra plaaning
and ense will be underts�3an to iaet�rporate aonvenience s�nd d�sign iata
the ldia,� tc ao�aplemea�t �aother fine apartment building recently con�tr�cted
ia t seame block.
'4�a se of this appeal ia to ask for e► relaxation of th� dsnsit� raquir�--
me �� i�r� 65�4 �1qv,are Seet in exaeas of that required Yor 6 nnita, making
a d�e ciency of :s�16_aquare feet in the tctal laad ar�a to presently �a}.ify for
7 u� �. Per.miesion to construct the 7 unita is needed to keep lt�nd costs per
unit ore comparabls r►ith currant lsnd co�ts for m�ltiple dwellin�e, thu�
maki con�truation coata more feaeible. ll�o, 8 ?wnit plan will enable uo
to c atruct a more workable floor p�au to include convenience facilitiea for
the enants� au�h aa a,dditfo�al ctorage. utility ancl recreational area.
Ordi ce Legialative Code, Chapter 64. Seation 03, Paragraph i �e►ke� provi�-
ion r thi+� �ppeal.
I a�m �ta�hiag 3 aite plane of the proposed Qonstx�ctiion. Your atten�ion and
con� eratton in tb3� matter will be greatly appreciated.
xesp c��'ully yovrs,
� '
--a-*-✓ �'f.�ti c�
� !-' u �
E}ord & 3truck ��i �� �;tt �^ ,d �
� }1 �� L�
Tele one NoB. - s44--�r1s2 F E B 5 i96s
s�5-�s38o
CiTY F'i.�i����V�ii€� �3����D
�' '1/linn��
ZC���t�� �ILE ��'"���
�
_�
; � �.
�, y
• BOXRD'0�` 7A I.NGJ REPORT AND ACTION March 20� 1969 Pl,at Map 19 �
Acting u or Legislativa Cods Chapter 60 thru 6� Fil� No,
p�ssed Au ust 22� 1922 as mmonded to April 6� 1968 6719 '
Also �
1. APPLIC NT'S NAME : Ga�dor R� Siruck �
;-
2. CLASSI ICATION s I.�Am�ndm�nt Q Appasl QP�rmit ❑Other
3. PURPOS s Relax density requir�menta
4� LOCATI N s Sii Corne� of intea�seotion of Marsl�sll Av�ue snd Der►sy Street
5. LEGAL ESCRIPTION s Lots 1 ani 2� e�spt the Msst 40' of Lot 2, !l�rriati Park
Second Addition
6� PRESEN �ONING � "C" Residanae
7. PURSUA T TO Zoning Cods Chapt�rs 64 Ssctions .03 . Para�,t►aph� i
8� STAFF NVESTIGllTION � REPORTt Dat�� 3/11/69 By= CLS
A. ZONING ADMINISTRATORs No action
8. s o� cor t is aite
C. s To develop the tite witli a 7-unit apartm�nt building
D. APPEALs This site is d�ficient in l�t ar�a for s 7-unit apartmsnt
n�
E. P'RESEN STANDARDS� A 7-unit spartn�nt buildir►g r�quiras 10,500 squsrs feet of ares �
F. s �i' s�site is 10,260 squara f��t in ar�a,short 240 square !°eat or 2.29$. �
G. Gs The !`rontsge slong Marah�ll Awnue is zoned "C" Res3danc�. To the
sou s zon�d "A" Resid�r�ce a� to the north is zoned "B" Rea3dence.
H. COtlPRE ENSIVE PLANs Tha Conaprshansiva. Plan racamn�ds R-5 clasaification for this
ar , �te ng units psr ac:ra.
I. SITE C NDITIONSt The aite is occupied with a large frame dr►elling in need of
re on. Tha site is slightly abovs the s�eet grade along !larshsll
Are ue atd De�rey Street•
J. AREA C NDITIONSs To the north are miaoed resid�btisl u�ma. To the east ia a 7-unit
a traent ing aad one-family reaidences. To the south are one and t�o-fasily {.
res dential uses. To the weat are �ix,ed residantial usea. �
#.
;
��:
�:
R
r,,
Council Lettar
9. BOARD TION; To Racom�eond D Approval U Denial �tad
Mo od bys Gauger Y�as Nays Date of Hearing �
X Atnea `�
S ondad bys Danna Coh�n �
X Danna (Alt) Council Action .
X Gadl�r
X Gaugor
Sacretary's remarkss Maiotta D�ste
McPartlin (Alt)
X Manaur (Alt)
LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET
t' �� .- : . . -,.. -. . . ,�_.. .R��
�k � •� ♦A1� I i.�� 4C �`• "' •'� �i•-..`i �-ifl.. i 1 � ''l � ���0•�iOi O � fl�� � . �'O O V. ' .���'���.::.
:� } •� � � � ' ;1� �' 1 � � 1 � �� ; � ����! �
� � � � � f � i ' i °-- � � � � � ' /I ••s � � � , ;
� L1�� �__.__ _- 1� � � _._�._��:.�r �—i.�.�.—_��j_ � �� �(_„_.-ti,r. ! � � �
�
; _. � --____. � � .__"".-i . �. � � i , . , _' --�-�-�---....,,.
� � i i � „ � ) j o ! ' 1' �,J � i , ' I ' ;
� � ' n' � ' ' - I � i '
_�.._ C� O , � Q;Q - �, 4 � �5 • !E���� ,' ,__ :�. �O C. C� � C'` � � �
� � , � , , � p .� �� � ,� . ;�
,
, - -___ , � . � ;__ � , :
��-__ _ .. g
R
t ___ _ � G ���-� � ��r
'�� ; ? --i 1i ' _ `"� ; �.,� � ~ " ! :; ;,_71 � �' r7 � •,'O Cl! J O�� ►�t •�� .: �� O'
� � � ; f � ��� � � , + � � • � I .
� i 'J; ; ' � ; �� , ' � �l., � i ;
,;.,_ �--� �- ( w i
� � ��� �� r � � T� �_._�r� �w ��(,� i-�etl--.-- ..� � \ _. ^ _.� .. -.._.,{._� � �j
i.
�� '- .,_._ , r� � � � � � �� ���-� �� � Y ��► �� �
'� I � � ' [�, ! . ! . .. I � � ( � I �� 1 ! � � 4` `� � . . :� �
� , , 1 � y -• . '; � i � , � , ,.
� O ! �i O • i � r.l. �,{ ; , ; Q � 1 i ���i �.� :�� � �-, -1 -. 1, .-�' .f),!�' j ("
� � � ! 1.�, i � i�� �Q� ,� , + `a � 7 � � l"� �L•4 ; r ' � • �i" , 5 �.:.
..L � . (,_ � �
� : ..C" R Es����t c E � (V�A F �'�--s' r4 L L
� `� ; a! Q _ ; ;6 ia o � ;Y ' 7 j ; ; ; ��,o'c-c �,, .� � ��,,�,�, �
� ; , , � ; ��; � ; o , i� � . ; ;
' �� ± • � ' /� i ''� ! ` . � � . � � �. � � � , _ t..� 1• � , � � 1 �y
;,� � \d . _ — --- - I I ,I� �. • i► � � � �_-� �. � w
' T,
� �, �--�------------ �
�''.�. �' �. .� r � � �"�.�'� � r � .r � �.. �.. � j
I1'"'"''__�i , , --�-- ,-�.--� _ �-- , � ; t�
; I i : � � I i_'--�'--�
,�" 1
� ; ' i i . j � i � ; � � -t-�.._ �,.� , I
� I ' � + ; ( �l_ J.'��\� �, ^: �.� ����r� �
` � ,^' ' i.,, � O , Q .� � •u ; C - �— ; ---K- , •
! � `' �O ;Q! iO�.QiQ � , `� � ' '. �^ ;
i.� ' � � � ; _ � � � VA�/ i0 ' � � �
� � y ��
•�.,! -u . � •` . � . � � ..' � ' i
• ` —=��-- C� O O�Q•� :i •'-; � C, �,��,
I ^ 'I ^ i , �� � �� ' , � , � 1
4� �� , G � ,� _ � ;� i � �i"�c�,� O ; � � { r-, .--� , ; ;
�� ' . ; � . i � ' ' ' ' I . �! , f � . - r-?ar-.-:..�. ....i �... ..�r �6 +w..�
ti, �. � 1 . � . � i # � � � �} " F `� _�� , I
� . '—..,- - �- —..._—_l--- ( + I i 1 ��� U�1 - '( ��1 ^ �S���;
�:.: ,� _ , ---r- - - -----.- - ��--'-- C 2'� � r" �--,j � ..=_..i
5� . . { '` � �� �. ' , �
, , , • ! i � , � � C` 1 \� �
t �� { � � _ I ! � � �_. � � 3, � � ..._ �CO/„IM�RG1At
C C ,l..J;C ^, O � O CJ � C!C?� �'' Y � IC� Q � i�� � 'r e � ^ 12 ' .
, �� , w> ,�. v p�p ,� c, 'o�.
-- __ _ ` ` ' ��� � � `�
.. __ :_. � � �.. `.-.. �._ .r. 'rr r arr �
�
� f 1�t�Ljl� g 1�i ! �ordon R. _Struck ��.�7�'ND .
,
� . �
PU -�'-Z��SG Relax density requirement ��j�� U��
��, ; o o�v�-�a►,�i�Y
.- PS�C5EN1' Z N1NG ����� Residence , ' `�"' T1�r/0-�Ar��lLY
"� , ; _ � YHRC E- FA��ILY
'PETITION IGNERS '
" - FOUg-rAllf,l L.Y � �
�:� _ � I�1�U LT I- Fl�l��l I LY
;;
�� o enCO'�i�i�RCiAL� �
FI�.0 No # ?19 . r�oR-�w n n► �I�DUSTRIAL �
� _ . e.
�� �.� ���� :� .��
�' -�� ,z�. � � � �/ � VACANT �;�
,.>a.a,�.� � ' _,�> � .
¢�'�'��'� ?z.�uc.��,.��ft�iSlcMn+1l�,�.��< 't.�ta^1i^,�„.�.:��..rr.,...�4.�_ . . ;:;��'`�
, ° � .. .. v .. . �,
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
March 28, 19b9
ity Clerk
File X680, Page
Y u are hereby notified thaC a public hearing will be held in the
uncil Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of
S . Paul at 10:00 a.m. on April 10, 1969 on the appeal of Gordon
R Struck to relax density requirements on the following property:
L ts 1 and 2, except the west 40 feet of Lot 2, Block 2, Merriam
P rk Second Addition. The property is located on the souChwest
c rner of Marshall Avenue and Dewey Street.
F r further information contact Planning $oard, Room 1010 Canmerce
B ilding or phone 223-4151.
JA1rD:S J. DALGLISH
Commissioner of Finance
O