The URL can be used to link to this page

243459 OR161NAL TO CITY CLERK � , 243459 CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCi� N�,. OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE O RESO T ON—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONE • �n DATF Anril 28� 1969 In the matter of the constructing and/or reconstructing the sidewalk in the following areas: On both sides of Davern St. from Highland Parkway to Randolph Ave. under Preliminary Order No. 242524 approved March llthr 1969. RESOLVED, That all orders in the above matters be and the same are hereby cancelled, annulled, and rescinded and all proceedings in such matter dis- continued. APR 2 '� 1969 COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays Carlson n,,t?� 1 °, �r r . �.�.�� Dalglish Approved 19�_ Meredith In Favor �� .��_ Sprafka Mayor � A gainst Tedesco Mr. President, Byrne PU�LISHE� MAY 31969 O w„ . .��..� � �, �..r c.. �.... �„t.�. .�.., T..'� .. .� . L ` , .. . . . . .. �' /�� :�, �,�� *�'. K" . � . . „ . � R� ` � ' � � . � � . .� . . �' COUNCIL FILE Nf�: ::, M1,, � . , � Y t F�NAI - O RDER f By_ � t : File No � . .. . . . _ . � � . . . .. . _ � � � �.I4 i In the Matter of �„��,"I�1� a�/ao�r ��eNrt�+�ll�°dMl� s�+��►"� �a i�e �#�i�i �t � i. . . . . ' . . . � � �� ' . . � � � . . .. . , � � :,�,j 'b'� � � �#'�. ��.�� •� � �� '� � 4 C . . . . . . . .. . . ' .. - . . . � . ... � . ✓? S �.'�i �� M .� .. . . . . �.. .e .. . � . � . . . ._ . . � . . . .. . � f . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . . - 'i f�. . � . . . . . -. � � � � � � � � . � C. � . ' � . � . - � �.. . . . . . . .. � � ; ; . . .. . . . � . .. .. . �r i± . . . � . � . . . � � � � _ . ..y�.` � . . .. � � . . . . � � � - . � . � ....�"+�� :�' . .. . � . � , � � ... � . �� - .. . . ,;:5 t� � . �. � �. .. . . � . . . �7 �� under Preliminary Order�3�L approv� �i 1�` x!�! l , ;:� �� Intermediary O�der aPProvecl � � A publie hearing having been had upon the above improvement upon dne notice, and the �o�ncil �' , having heard all persons, objections and recommendations relatiye t�ereto, and having fully consid+exed - � � ; : the same; therefore; be it ' � 12ESOLVED, By the Conncil of the City af St. Paul that the precise nature, extent and kind of im- �, provement to be made by the said City is � � #o�► �t�st a�i/re;�r�ft +�Ms ��iw�s�k r�t "!� sf�s �M' lr�re� *�� :�aw ��ri �� + . � �. � � �� f ��.� � �� .�..� �� '... � .:.. N, � �� ,�•.'� ��.�� i ..� .!� ��. . �, . . . .. . . � a,�h'.' . � ; � lt�R+ ;� � �w . � and the Council hereby order� said improvement to be made. RES�LVED FURTHER, That the Commissioner of Public Warks be and is hereby instructed and directed to pxepare plans and apecifications for said improvement; and submit same to the Council for approval;`that upon said approval, the proper city officials are hereby :authorized and directed to pro- ceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therevvith. CO.UNCILMEN Adopted i�y the Councit Yeas CarIsOA Nays Dalglistl . Meredith A�Prov� Peterson Sprafka Tn Favor � Tedesc:m _ 1Vlayor Byme Aga�n�t s-sa.anc a�� i �„ ' , , � Herbert F. Chase Ernst A . Jat'fray � 16�6 Hartford A venue 1697 Bayard Avenue St. Paul, Minnesota 55116 St. Paul, Minnesota 55116 April 21, 196g The Honorable James J. Dalglish Commissioner of Finance 113 Cc�urt House Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re : File 58729, Page 3 (Sidewalk Construction) Dear Mr. Dalglish: (1) The undersigned Petitioners, Herbert F. Chase and Ernst A . Jaffray, respectfully request to exclude from the Preliminary Order 2LI-2 52� approved March 11, 19 9, which proposes to : "construct and/or reconstruct the sidewalk on both sides of Davern Street from Highland Parkway to Randolph Avenue" �hat portion which provides for the new construction of a sidewalk on the East Side of Davern Street extending between Bayard and Hartford Avenues . (2) Petitioner Herbert F. Chase is the owner of a sinole family residence located at 16g6 Har�ford Avenue; Petitioner Chase 's property direetly abuts the proposed side- walk area at Davern Street extending north from the alley to Hartford Avenue; Petitioner Jaffray is the owner of a single family residence located at 1697 Bayard Avenue, said property directly abutting the proposed sidewalk area at Davern Street extending south from the alley to Bayard Avenue. There is no proper� owned b� others directly abutting the area o� the proposed new sidewalk construction on the East Side of Davern Street betcaeen Hartford and Bayard Avenues . (3) During the past quarter of a century the neigh- borhood was able to live without a concrete sidewalk on the East Side of Davern Street. The proposed sidewa.lk area in question is now seeded with lawn, which is properly tended, attractive to the eye and does not constitute a safety hazard. The neighborhood is static; there is no significant pedestrian traffic on Davern Street nor has there been any in �he past. �t o • I The Honorab]_e James J. Dalgli�h April 21, 1969 Commissioner of Finance Page 2 In Petitioners � opinion, any such pedestrian traffic as now exists will decrease ra.ther than increase. (�) In summary, Petitioners verily believe that there never has been and is not now any need or requirement for a. concrete sidewalk on the eastern side of Davern Street (between Bayard and Hartford Avenues) and that no such future need is anticipated. The undersigned Petitioners ask for due consideration of their joint petition and respectfully request you to EXCLUDE from Order 242 52� any construction of a new sidewalk on the East Side of Davern Street between Bayard and Hartford Avenues . Thank you. Very truly yours, � HERBERT F. CHASE -- �— 1� ERNST A . JAF� Y '`� . . ,�?� �s��. ERNST A. JAFFRAY 1 ATTORNEY AND COIINSELLOR AT LAW T&LEPHONS. 783-1631 2601 HUDSON ROAD Aasw Cons 612 Ap ri 1 Z 2� 19 6 9 SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 6S 119 The Honorable � f � E i v E � Thomas R. Byrne �P�2�31969 Mayor , City of Saint Paul �Y�� ICE St . Paul, Minnesota 55102 Sub�ect: Public Hearing Scheduled for April 29, 1969 Re: File 58729 , Page 3 (Sidewalk Construction) The undersigned Petitioners , Herbert F. Chase and Ernst A. Jaffray, respectfully request to exclude from the Preliminary Order 242 524 approved March 11, 19 9, which proposes to: "construct and/or reconstruct the sidewalk on both sides of Davern Street from Highland Parkway to Randolph Avenue" that portion which provides for the new construction of a sidewalk on the East Side of Davern Street extending between Bayard and Hartgord Avenues . Petitioner Herbert F. Chase is the owner of the single family residence located at 1696 Hartford Avenue; Petitioner Chase's property directly abuts the proposed side- walk area at Davern Street extending north from the alley to Hartford Avenue; Petitioner Jaffray is the owner of �he single family residence located at 1697 Bayard Avenue, said property directly abut�ing the proposed sidewalk area at Davern Street extending south from the alley to Bayard Avenue . There is no �roperty owned by others directly abutting the area of the r proposed new sidewalk construction on the East Side of Davern Street between Hartford and Bayard Avenues . During the past quarter of a century the neighbor- hood was able to exis� without a concrete sidewalk on the East Side of Davern Street . The proposed sidewalk area in question is now seeded with lawn, which is properly tended, attractive to the eye and does not constitute a safety hazard. The neighborhood is static ? there is no si�nificant pedestrian traffic on Davern Street nor has there been any in the past , and in Petitioners ' opinion, any such pedestrian traffic as now exists will decrease rather than increase . M. �.. . .. . .. ..__ _ .. . . � �'~' . ! ' w DEPARTMENT OF FINAN�E . CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I 13 Court House, 55102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner LOUIS H. MeKENNA, Deputy Commissioner Phone:223-4646 April 24, 1969 Herbert F. Chase 1696 Hartford Avenue St. Paul, Minnesota �5116 Dear Sir: Your petition in opposition to sidewalk canstruction on Davern Street, has been forwarded to the City Clerk for the attention of the Council at the hearing to be held on April 29, 1969, and to the Department af Public Works. Yours very ttu�y f`-., f� :l'� /n j_� t.�/�C•_:.Z e'l GL�"�•'�, ames J. Da�iglish�� '�Commissio er of �inance File - 58729 HEARING: 4/29/69 c .c. E. A. Jaffray Sidewalk Dept. PGI S8729 �ty Clerk 55 y ,2_ April 22 , 1969 � In summary, Petitioners believe that there never has been and is not now any need or requirement for a conerete sidewalk on the eastern side of Davern Street (between Bayard and Hartford Avenues) and that no future need is expected. The undersigned Petitioners ask for your due considera- tion of their �oin� petition and respectfully request you to move at the public hearing to EXCLUDE from Order 242 52b any construction of a new concrete sidewalk on the East Side of Davern Street between Bayard and Hartford Avenues; and to support Petitioners ' request in this respect . Thank you. Very truly yours, ,�L��. �� ;`�_____. r✓ � � HERBERT F. CHASE � � ERNST A. JAFFRA � ,�✓��_ �/ Y, .°r f ° � c�' � c M u�, .� � a C.�� .a. a`�` � FINAL ORDER � COUNCIL FILE N0. BY File No. �� In the Matter of c,oustzuctin� �ctio� reu��et��g�'A�h� ��.� c� both side� of Davsrn St. frce� Highlaa�i �r�ay tt� �.��g� Avs. and bq dai�zg ��:1 c►�hez �roak �hfch �.s n�c�ssary anct inaid�rit�al �a c�1et�. ��#�d ia�►rc�v+e��t. under Preliminary Order- 242524 approved �tr�h �.1, �959 Intermediary Order approved A public hearing having been had upon the above improvement upon due notice, and the Council having heard all persons, objections and recommendations relative thereto, and having fully considered the same; therefore, be it RESOLVED, By the Council of the City of St. Paul that the precise nature, extent and kind of im- provement to be made by the said City is to cosxatrnc� �/err ��+c�t��ct �C'he +aide�a►ik oa 'ba� ��cte�a �a� �� 3c. fros� Hi�hiaud P+�rkway tv Rsadolph bv�« �+d �r doi�g aiI other waxic �hie:h ia t�e�s�sa�► a�cd :tn�ide��.sl ��a c+om�lstti a�fd imps�at, e�ce�►t ��r �d a�d srxffic3ent poe��red rtde�vaik� e�a�r exis L. and the �Council hereby orders sa,id improvement to be made. RESOLVED FURTHER, That the Commis.sioner of Public Works be and is hereby instructed and directed to prepare plans and specifications for said improvement, and submit same to the Council for approval; that upon said approval, the proper city officials are hereby authorized and directed to pro- ceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therewith. COUNCILMEN Yeas ��SOI� Adopted by the Council Nays p�lglish Meredlth Approved peterson ��'� _In Favor T�des�� By�,� Mayor A gainst 6-88-2M � R-1 FINAL ORDER �OUNCIL FILE N0. By File No. ��' In the Matter of ca�astr�ctfug ant3/nr r,��t�Cr�ct�n� �� sidc�tlk �n �th �ide,e� taf �lavera St. frca� Highl�ad I+a�nar�y ta �a��.�1� Av�e. ae�d by doing �11 c►�h�nar r�� e��i�cb is neces��a�y a�3 iz�cidexrtre�l �r� c��ete �afud f�rov�arent. under Preliminary Order ��+Z��q approved 1Wtarc2� 11, I969 Intermediary Order approved A public hearing having been had upon the above improvement upon due notice, and the Council having heard all persons, objections and recommendations relative thereto, and having fully considered the same; therefore, be it RESOLVED, By the Council of the City of St. Paul that the precise nature, extent and kind of im- provement to be made by the said City is to co�atr�ct aa�i/or recc>�atruct �hs �id�►��k a� 'both �ide� of Daveru �t. frs� H�.��.and Paz��ray tc R�ndolph dina. a�d �+y� +d�al.u$ a�1,� +��her �oork wbich ta� u�ce�a��r�r �ad �,naidea�a� ta coa�l�te s�id �rov�e�t�: except irhera� �aad and su�ffc��t �+t�ure�d �id�lka aoaT e�cist. and the Council hereby orders said improvement to be made. RESOLVED FUP�THER, That the Commissioner of Public Works be and is hereby instructed and directed to prepare plans and specifications for said improvement, and submit same to the Council for approval; that upon said approval, the proper city officials are hereby authorized and directed to pro- ceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therewith. COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council Yeas �c,ri�c:�� Nays D�'��;�,h� fiJ�er�c�;�:�"r Approved ��.'if-'•!'"il'.�'� ��3�� Tn Favor 7'ed��c� By,�.n� Mayor A gainst s-ss-zn� �OO R.i