Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
243241
, OR161NAL TO CITY CL6RK 243241 CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO. : OFFICE OF THE CITY �LERK COUNCIL RESO RAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONE - � 1��`r DAT� � WI3EREAS� The Housing and Redevelopment Authority of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, did, on March 28, 196g, adopt a Development Program �or Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21 providing for the acquisition of 120 single family dwellings on scattered sites within. the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, at a total cost for acquisition, rehabilitation and program administra- tion of Two Million Four Hundred Eleven Thousand Forty-Four Dollars (�2,411,044.00) ; and WHEREAS, Said Authority has demonstrated to the Council that there is need for such low rent housing which is not being met by private enterprise and that a gap of at least 20 per cent will be maintained between the upper rental limits for admission to the proposed low rent housing and the lowest rentals at which private enterprise is providing, through new construction and existing structures , a substantial supply of decent, safe and sanitary housing; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, does hereby affirm the determination that there is need for the low rent housing proposed in Low Rent Housing Project No. Min.n. 1-21 which is not bein.g met by private enterprise, and that a gap of at least 20 per cent will be maintained between the upper rental limits for admission to the proposed low rent housing and the lowest rents at which private enterprise is providing, through new con- struction and existing structures, a substantial supply of decent, safe and sanitary housing, and does approve the Development Program for Low Rent Housing Project Minn. 1-21 for 120 dwelling units to be purchased by direct acquisition on sites scattered throughout the Gity of Saint Paul, Minnesota, at a total estimated development cost for acquisition, rehabilitation and costs of administration in. the amount of Two Million Four Hundred Eleven Thousand Forty-Four Dollars (�2, 411,044.00) . FO APPROVE o d b the Council A R 1 8 196�9_ COUNCILMEN Y Yeas Nays Carlson APR 1 8 1969 Dalglish � pprover� 19—_ Meredith In Favor P.eter�n � Sprafka �� Mayor A gainst Tedesco Mr. President, Byrne PUBLISHEr ApR 2 � 196� O , 421 Wabasha Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 551 02. Edward N.Helfeld,executive director.phone 223 5218 f �43�� , 1 HOUSING AND REDEUELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA ��� Mr. Joseph P. Summers April 7, 1969 Corporation Counsel Rooau 316 City Hall and Court House Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Resolution approving Development Program, Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21 Dear Mr. Summers: Transmitted herewith is a proposed form of resolution of the Council approving a Develop- ment Program for Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21. The Development Program has been transmitted to the City Clerk for presentation to the Council at such time as the resolution is prepared. Yours very truly, .� ;2/�-�1 J es T. Hart Chief Counsel Enclosure VO �!`� �6� ��� G G�� �Go���� �►v Q,Q ,��p� ��P G��e Lawrence J. Hayes, Harry P. Strong, Jr., Orville E. Anderson, Henry R. Thomas, Kenneth J. Lynch, James J. Dalglish, Victor J. Tedesco ci;<,��m�� 421 Wabasha Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 551 02. Edward N.Helfeld,executive director.phone 223 5218 . ����41 HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA Honorable Mayor and City Council April 7, 1969 c/o City Clerk Room 386 City Hall a�d Court House Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21 Develop�nent Program Gentlemen: Transmitted herewith is the Develogment Program for Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21, which Program provides for direct acqufsition on a negotiated basis of 120 single faaaily houses containing three, four and five bedrooms. This program is similar to the direct acquisition program undertaken by the Authority in the fall of 1968; however, the rate of acquisition will be slower than that of the earlier program. This will permit the Authority to select houses requiring less rehab- ilitation than some of those included in the earlier program, and should provide for a broader distribution in the caa�nunity, and avoidance of any concentration in a particu- lar neighborhood. It is hoped that these properties can eventua.11y be disposed to the low incame families as their family income increases, in accordance with the Department of Houaing and Urban Development's home ownership programs. The total development cost for acquisition and rehabilitation, and program administration, is $2,411,044.00 The Authority respectfully requests Council consideration and approval of the Develop- ment Program for Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21. Yours very truly, ���'�'�P N Edward N. Aelfeld Executive Director Attachment Lawrence J. Hayes, Harry P. Strong, Jr., Orville E. Anderson, Henry R. Thomas, Kenneth J. Lynch, James J. Dalglish, Victor J. Tedesco c,�,,o;��� 421 Wabasha Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 551 02. Edward N.Helfeld,executive director.phone 223 5218 , --,, _ �,, HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA Honorable Harry E. Marshall April 7, 1969 City Clerk Roam 386 City Hall and Court House Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21 Development Program Dear Mr. Marshall: Transmitted herewith is a request of the Mayor and City Council to consider and approve the Development Program for Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21. Transmitted in addition to the Development Program for said Project, is a proposal to revise income limits for initial and continued occupancy for public housing developments and demonstration of the 2d� gap determination dated August 9, 1967, as revised August 29, 1968. These materials are presented for Council consideration as a part of the con�ideration of the Development Program, and should be retained for your files. The writer has requested Corporation Counsel to draft the necessary resolution, and when this has been accomplished, the Authority would appreciate your placing this matter on the Council agenda for consideratfon. Yours very truly, ���2 J,��es T. Hart �hief Counsel Attachments Lawrence J. Hayes, Harry P. Strong, Jr., Orville E. Anderson, Henry R. Thomas, Kenneth J. Lynch, James J. Dalglish, Victor J. Tedesco cna���n�� � . P R 0 P 0 S E D D R A F T 0 F R E S 0 L U T I 0 N WHEREAS, the Housing and Redevelopment Authority of the City of Saint - Paul, Minnesot�, did, on March 28, 1969, adopt a Development Prograia for Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-21 praviding for the acquisition of 120 single family dwelling� on scattered sites within the City of Saint Pau1, Minnesota, at a total cost for acquisition, reh abilitation, and program sdiainistraCion of �o Million Four Hundred Eleven Thousand Fflrty-Four pollars ($2,411,044.b0); and WHEREAS said Authority has demonstrated to the Council that there is need for such low rent housing which is not being met by private enterprise and that a gap of at least 20 percent will be maintained between the uppar ren tal Iimits for admfssfon to the proposed Iow rent housing and the lawest renta2s at which private eaterprise is praviding, through new constructfon and existing structures, a substantial supply of de�e�nt, safe and sanitary housing. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, does her�by affirm the determinatior� that there is ne�d for t�e low rent housing proposed in Low Rent Housing Project No. Minn. 1-2I which is not being �aet by private enterprise, and that a ga.p of at least 20 percer�t will be maintained between the upper ranta2 limits for admission to the proposed Io�r rent housing arcd the Iawest rents at which private enterprise is groviding, through new construction and existing structures, a substantial supot�► of decer.t safe and saaitary housi:.g, and does apYrove the Devalo�:�nt Program for La� Seat Housing Project No. Minn. I-21 for 120 dwelling urci�s to be purchased by direct acquisition on sites scattered throughout the City of Saint Paul, MinnesoCa, at a. totaZ estimated deveZopment cost for acqaisition, rehabilitation and costs of administration in the amount of T�o t�Sillion Four Hundred ElevQn Thcnsa�d Fozty-Four pollar� ($2,411y044.00). � . 120 Units I�To�elderizi Project �o. Minn. 1-21 . (Prog. Res. No. Minn. 1-F� Room Ratio 5.97 PART IV ESTIMATED DEVELOPMENT COST ESTIMATE OF TOTAL bEVELpPMENT COST • Est. Est. Est. I,IiA Est. Total Est. Total Account Classification Pttrchase Rehab Admin. Development Cost Per Price Costs Cost� Casts D, �, ADi✓INISTR.ATYON 1410.1 Nontechnical Salaries xxx xxac 10,2G0 30,2aQ 85 1410.2 Technical Salaries xaoc xxx 15,600 15,6G0 I30 14�0.4 Legal Expense xxx x�c 600 6pp S 1410.9 Employee Benefit Contr, xxx xxx 2,400 2,4p� 2p 1410.10 Travel �c�c xxx 1,200 Z,200 10 1410.12 Publications xxx xxx 240 240 2 1410,14 Membership Dues � Fees xxx x� 360 360 3 1410.16 Telephone & Telegraph xxx xxx 600 600 � 1410.19 Sundry � xxx xxx 7,800 7,800 65 TOTAL ADMINISTRATION 39,0�0 39,000 325 1420 Interest exp, net �°J eoc 3g,��� 3�� xxx xxx 1425 Init. Oper. Deficit � � 3,000 3�0�� 26 �.: . � PLANNING I 1430.1 Arch. & Eng. Fees x�c 28,800 0 28,800 240 !, 1430.2 Consultant Fees xxx xxx 0 0 0 i 1430.6 Permit Fees xxx 6,000 0 � 6,000 SO � 1430.7 Inspection Costs xxx 12,000 0 12,000 100 1430.8 Fee for PHA Services xxx 4,769 � 0 4,769 4� 1430.9 Housing Surveys � �� ;�� 0 Q � 1430.19 Sundry Planning Costs xxx 0 3,60U . 3,600 30 TOTAL PLANNING xx�c 51,569 3,60t� 55,169 460 t SITE ACQUISITION 1440.1 Property Purchases 300,000 xxx 0 300,000 2,500 $ 144Q.3 Excess Property xxx xxx 0 0 0 � 1440.4 Surveys and Maps xxx xxx 3,600 3,600 30 1440.5 Appraisals xxx xxx 9,000 9,000 75 1444.6 Title Information xxx x�oc 10,800 10,800 90 1440.8 Legal Cost - Site xxx x�cx 2,400 2,400 20 � 1440.10 Option Negotiations xxx xxx 120 120 1 � 1440.19 Sundry Site Costs xxx xxx 1,200 1,200 � 10 � 1440.20 Site Net Income xxx xxx 0 0 0 � TOTAL SITE ACQUISITION 300,000 xxx 27,12a 327,120 2,726 `' CONSTRUCTION AND DQUIPMENT . ? r 1450 Site Improvement 180,000 36,000 0 216,000 1,800 ' 1460 Dwelling Structures 1,400,000 264,000 0 1,664,000 13,866 � 1465 Dwelling Equipment 0 31,200 0 31,200 260 ' 1470 Nondwelling Structures 0 0 0 0 0 � 2475 Nondwelling Ey;�ipment 0 L' � C � ' TOTAL CONSTRUC. & DQUIP. 1,580,000 33i,200 0 1,911,200 15,926 TOTAL Includin Donations . i � g ) 1,880,000 382,769 111,720 2,374,•+89 19,787 � Less: DONATIONS xxx 0 0 0 � 0 � TOTAL (Before Contingency) 1,880,000 382,769 111,720 2,374,489 19,787 ADD: Contingency 3% . xx�c 11,483 3,352 14,835 124 TOTAL (Without Relocation) 1,880,000 394,252 115,072 2,389,324 19,911 ' � f RELOCATION COSTS � 1495.1 Moving-Tnd. � Families �nac x�c 15,000 18,000 150 1495.2 Moving-Business x�-x ��x 0 p p 1495.3 F.el. Adj. Pymts-Ind. � Fam, xxx x�c 0 0 p 1495.4 Small Bus. Displ. Pymts xxx xxx 0 0 p j 1495.5 Relocation Services xxx x_-�x 3,72� 3,720 31 TOTAL Rr�..00. COSTS xxx xxx 2i,?�u 21,72C 181 TOT�;, (Inclu�in� Reloca�io;�) 1s880,OC� 39�:,'L52 l:ic,7:2 �:,4Ii,U44 ZO,G92 13� =o:i��.x-,� �n-��n��x.I i�`-':i i i7�1 ',r '):LL',"'�)'ut -> -� �.__ �" ` a�'.,Q � _ ��__-----_—_..___._..r__ _._....__ -!9 b I`6 ��S(?`:[?�' � •rsej �p��pa;� puL ' - ,»r_,� 7� ?u-c,z,,;,ui �t;� t�tu�r,.� c.��;o�u-r r•�oC 3o s�; ttai��� o:� l;a,:T�::n��o ��Yl�:;a.:� l�tt,�� l.:l�zoaZn�; at.1.1 �iq nax;c� s-�-r�uzj ��uo�+,z „tI� TL�,� ���czotl�nV szc�Z �o u�zt�Zdo at�� sY ZI �IT.OS3i�Tfdl?�1 `�i11V T `T.S 30 I�.LI� :!II,T, ;Ip �Z]:2�O1t:L11V �:LN,�IY:dO i.[A3Q:I3 Q•"�iV ��'��SfiOH :�1�J X4I . ��IL`J.�I�ti'��31�;?Q cIVJ %OZ . . Q�V S7.:�':?l:�?Oi;7A�rC[ J.�TS:10II �I'I�::id cO:I �L7<'�Vdf1��0 Q�11I�?IT,�OJ �`�=�' `IVC::I;�iI 2;U;i �,I.?',�L�I :li•.:17i\7 '��S?!1't.RI O;L �iVSOdO?Id , � � R _ , _ L �l!O�.)J(', .): �C�f�(,; ,�il IiJJ`. jC�::l�J :j� :1 (.�'!",�r � � �,, -'�- �??3'7 OC�'7 �:c;.: ._. :�.,,�,�,.,,r �, � �1�,�-,- �„_. . ,v:y (i7., � �J�J`;� �..Gtilc,-'( � �'�'%r Oou�7 C��t7 `>�'�"',•_' ') ('QGS OU<3�I QO�JFI SL:C?S.:i?Cl S 0���7 0�3�1 OOZ�7 st�os.z�<< t; �JC�1'7 Gr7;7 U�J�� suo��za�, £ 0'�i i�I {1`JO''I (1QZ£ SL'.O£',�a�T 7, bJ�£� O�I�ti C031S ?;os*�� 7 .__---- -�__o���";�-i�_i,:L�<i_,v ___--�-�--- �c!o�:.��y .;��;i:�;�:ja�; uo;=�YSe:;� i� 1 Cil�:(�`^')c. �i`'1�(C`) •� t1 : .?:i i ;!U`y! �L'TJi7GS` UO�`7S"C�L'��� {t?Cl::� �t_o�:','----; ;f �tc��;�����'r�sr�I.��.:o�l1,T L?!=111!'C;{t•11 '096? `OZ z:C:_�a�dag i�o i�o7��z-ts7cr�u�;�� itr�srloi* �Zjqn;� au� dq panoxc'd� s� �ui�j��w�a�u� ;o����npai;�g=;uas�x� • � . •.�Ta��.,.,� pa�,.��Cd �xs sa�ti�u,� o!� 'ZS6Y `9T -(-r,d� uo GoY��'11SYP�YI'.!��'`I 2�7sno�; �x�qn�r au� �tn p�no�c?�i� s»co w�<�x�a uX r±ou �Inpa�.��s �uaJ ��ssq az,T, �Ti��,,���5 ,,,��v� '7, '�?.O.yT�L' L'.L'� t��t(� 3�L13� �� 1t�7U:AilIL!O� E3U� L!Y c`�ill?SC60t; p:^p��c�s uz��qo o� �����1� ���!�x��l o� tl°noua p�si�ax�uY svu ��ao�uY xia�a azo;�c; os op oa p��zc�3 �i� 'u�xpT7q� j�xenas t�:�7.y asoi,� �C-�x�:�����z�d `s�7u�Yj �t�u�di�a�o p�.utauo� yu�saxd �noq�.� asta s;>�o�ut zz�t,1 �sneaaq Uuzsr.o�i a�a!'oxd �:ox� anoGi ys���u oyr� s�2-��me3 ;e.{� s�x.tr.} osTe �C�E�ou�n� �ur •�Csd o� ��'�Y�q� xx��la u;��IZYM tiuisnoy �Cz��xu�s pu� a;�.>s ��u���� put� �ouu�� s.zc�;j�oti �;�ns Z�.�tl� paatwzj os st !nq zo �uaz �snw sY�a',ior� �,ac�� �{���.�r� �eisnoi� ptepue}s ,u l��dn, ay� '�a�qx�-cjau� �z�.� sqoC pY�d �s��.o� !-�7�u�xz�pt;:�� av,� u� t�a�Co��d�:a s�!a���o�y aZ�cn �Cuce� `o96-� L,-• pasTt�.t :lssT a�a,:�� Y;����n� `s:�xiag�� a?�.:o�i:-e Zu�s�zd at�a x�pu[► •s.z��;:xoc•� a�t�ui p��Co7<I�,�� ,C�ze�t���a pt�d ysar•:oj au� 3tr�cptiT�uY °(�:}7Lt'tlili'.1?03 .7tl:j U� JV7T�IULy3 �L^,UJL'.��-D10�[ �O DU�C���J3 SE`iO.;f.7 �AY:�LZLI"JS�.Z��:L i1.IOlA ti .r. ?o ��:rsnot; ��.{a �Yta2�d o� �CauT.;�dn��o p�nuT,uo� pu� uut,s�ut��r ,zo� sZZ�-c�i ���,o�u7 u�nuitxr;� 3�. �TnP�u�g a�{� as�no� o� sx j�sodo,zd sYt;� lo asod�nd :�t{.L � jeso o�o��so�T.:n� •j � � s ' 4. Pi�o�osed Schcdulc o� Inco,�,e T..i�nits Fi}_ed t>y llizthori.ty � � Tfa�.i.ir,rtri 7nco:r,e l,i_riits Aftc��r I;xe.m;�Li,�iis i�lmily tldmi_ssion Spec7_al. Admi.ssic�n. Co�z::i.nued Occupa�icy , Co�iposition NeL I'an�i).y 7nco�ne Pdet I�,�ni.lv Incomn \et' Fami.l.v Itico���e � -- - --- 1 Pe;-son%� $2,gpp $3,200 $3,200 2 1'crson:>'-� 3,200 4,000 4,000 3 Persons 4,400 4,II00 [�,gp� 4 Persons 4,800 5,400 5,400 S Persons 5,?_00 5,600 6,000 6 Persons 5,400 5,800 6,7_00 7 Persons 5,G00 5,800 6,400 8 Persons or more 5,300 6,000 6,6G0 �tiThe Authority does no�. feel t}iat a revi.sion o£ income li_miL,S for on�. anci two person £ariili.�s is necessary ��_ this time. �p�la.c�.ta.ons received fron eli�ible o�1c and two person �amil.i.es are :na�nl.y �rom tiic elderly. It is fcI.t thaL a suf19_cie.izt nu<<.ber ol the cldc:�l_y pc»ul.atio�� aT� includecl t��a�thin tlie exisLin�; iimits and ti1�L- th�r.c� i> no� i�;di_cat-ed need f:o izicr.ease limits fo� other tc,�o-person L-.�ilxl.ics. {Sce Item �i-r�) 5. Def.ii�:ition oL Net I'an�ily Income Our uciinitio� ox n�t f<<mily income tiaa; ap��roveci b;� P,4'� iii l�u�ust, 195�. ��ie pl;in no ctlanges in Lhis cletiniti.�n cur�cnt].y. � , - 6. Exempti.on Poticy �. �'17.i�ClOu,l TIICOT�IC �CC11)].('.A� I;C�Ii1:L:_lOi7 �,'O[l`1t1i3��._Ci nCC�l^��iiCV F1c..d *v'one Noize Spcusc: $600 of incor�ic $v00 oi a.nco;,;:� Ot,:er $600 oE inco:ne $u00 0; ir,cu,.��� �1it;or $bOG of i.zlco:,�e, nll. o}: inco�:�c. Ivoi�-mino-: � $600 oi income $6til� of. i.nccrn� F3. �,•.i.cr Thrzn Prir,cin.��_ 7:�cor�c . P.eci.•;icn� ta:i.Lh l.rtc�;�,ic: oi �?o;-c ��--= �_ �.�_---- Th�r $100.00 , ficacl �;o�.::� � �Ionc� �j�OUSE: �v'�J O� ).il;:;i;�;L" r�i)uv Oi i.iiC0��1C t l-�r — : �i � �t112C � Ul)l� O: iiICG'i1�C. G�;� i)'1. li;CGi'.C` :tir�or $uG0 r��� inr.�o;,��o E�,1 i ��: �_ncu;,ic �OIl-i:l.il01' S�(�� OL 7_i?COI?;� `r nn � .� �U�:v Oi. 1;lCOJI`:: .. , . C. j�;:11=!1, ]ftCt�il1E` O]: y )_n0 .O;" 1C�� �iC:1C� .JOi1C r�0;... �iiDii:=C' �11.�_ O;� 7_i:CQ.•�,i`. i�l.l. l.i,, l.il'C��,.t.. ��il(,'.L �..l.l Oi_ l.iiC0�:1+� �1� ,� Al.i. �. ; . . ,n ?•i�.r�oc L�1_1 ot �_nc�,:,_ .',t�1 a,_ �,cu:: �. � t - L�vii"i;11:(�l NZ 1 C:, j.11C.C�ilii,l . (��_j. c?i. 7.ii_. . ... — ! _ r � 6. I:;;cr„�tj.o� Pol.:�r-,� Coi«in��ect � 3J. All am�ttnts paid by t:hc U. S. Govcrn�i�ent for disability cr cicatli occurrin� in conne�ti_on w�ith m�litary [crvice. �ii_lila-r.y service in this connection rnr_iy incl.uue penr.e-tzme ,ervice. � I;. I�'c, Lan�:�.ly �JJ.1.7 Uu c�;riui.drrC��] �;lf.&i1�1.: Uy reasun rL exc�rnpt.toris it net income bef.ore exe.m1�L�_ons ey,ceeds $6,OOC� at: a�imis,i.on ,,nd S7,000 aL conti.nued occupancy, ui.ii_ess tlie members of: tlie �,izti�ori�y find and document that the family a.s truly ot low income. No family, regardless of incomc, �ozll be made e1i�i'ole by Aut=l�ority • action if the incoroe aLte.r exemptions exceeds the ap�licabl.c income li.mit for acimission or continued occupancy, except by AuLhority actioa concurred in by tilc I�ousS.n�, Assi�taace Admi.riis- tration. \OTE: Tile foregairlg section will be revised to provide a n�a�imuri �f $7,000 at aur��iss7.on �nc] ,�'&,000 at cont9.nticd occupancy to lcee� L-his policy comme�lsurate ��fir_h th� �r.opo>ed increase in i_n�orne limS.�s. 7. Stater��ent Concerninf; J'u;,ti_ficat_�.on oE Exen�i.on Poli.cy tti'e bel.a.eve thaL our e::c���pr_ion policy to;eti�er wiih the a11o�T«ole dcuucti.ons for net fuuiily xncome deterrain�tLion a��d eur ren� schec3ule take ii.to accouni . iamily size, co;npositicn, a�e, p}iysicaJ_ handic.:.p, and o�.��er �actoi:s �;�ii.c}�� mi�h� af£ect t1�e rei�t-�pay�iz� ability o�- thc iamiiy. Tl�ese exer,iptions recognize the f<1ct L-tiat as a r��le a su'ostantiai part o� ��lE Ln1I17.i1t�S Ui SCCOi1C�ui"y W02"iCCI"S� ].11C�llGli1� Li1nSC Of �JJ.V�S� .3YG i10� �zVc11i4�J1�`y nor can be de�ended upon to meet eve��yday f.�mii� ��x:��cilditure� i_ncltidi.n` rent. 8. t?co�io;�iic lnci Ott�e;' ;�i-��ort i.n^ D,^.La. ____�----- _.k� _���._�...,. A. Ci.�_?vorkcr's ].�,,mily I;t�dret. ...._ _�— �— In auLumn of 1959, the li. S. Depar�ment of Labor, ihircau o� �,<boi- Statistics, preparcd a bicu;eC oI Fc,ods «nd services :ai�ici� ;,�,,:.'_d 3�1G1r7 �� 7110C�C:St: t)ilt <aCIC'CiUutC St:•^;i1C1;71C� Oi �.J.V?.ilv 3.i� i:[1;iIlS Oi �:ililii�C!;"Ci:� O��' i:�1C 1����� `i. jllC bll���C�; �da5 �1C��L�Yi.C't �"vT" ,'l i_V�):.C�;1 1:��:;;�1V (il �_<)'�.;�'; ✓ . Cdl11.C11 J_�iCIUGi?(1 �iCl Ci;;���_O�('CZ [llt;ii)D.ilCl� �•7�_7:C I�iGC C':�ij�2i?j':•:i� <.�iCi �.:!i) CIl'1�.<�i"l'.i1 l:il��i_'f C1�:2i.CCi1 j'G^T; C)i 1?i�i`. ��; SUC�"t� t=il:.: i;'.(C��;'_'i L'� l;l.� . T'Cj)10EiCii�i: .�il ill)�)C'T' �.];li:i_�:�1:].011 L'J �i fOLli'-('�C�,:t1il i.::!il)_i�/�5 i;iC, ��;C , ':� C0.ltitinC�c: OC.^,1:�)1tlCy. .. � _ , � ` ts. T�:conomic a_nd 0�1�cr Supporti.n�; Data Co��Lin�_ied A. City h'orl:er's I�arai.�P,ud;et Conti;�����d Bud�..t-s were preparcd :or tt�cnly lar&e ritics. Since St, iaul � was not one of the t�•�enty ci_r.ies chosen for Ll�e sCudy, tae are usi.ng Lt�e budget figuLes prek�ared ror Piinncapolis, t�tinnesota, wl�icii is coi�riguous to St. Paul . Due ro Lhe pro;;zmii.y of tt�e t:ao cities, services, shelter, transportaLion, food, taxes and other living costs are co�nparable. This r.elationship is borr, ouL by a compari_son of budgct data for other cities in adjacent areas in L-hc study: (C1evcland $6,199 (Dceroa.L 6,072 (Philadelphia $S,�i98 (Scranton 5,693 (Washin�;t-on $6,1.47 (Bal.tirnore 5,718 Thus, the 13LS ciata for Mznn��apolis is as follotas : 1959 Cit�t•]orice.rs ` .t��r��-i_1_y Pu�1�eL- ILem l. Foou and bever:;iges , $1,64i 2. Ilous in;: a. Rent, herzt anci uti_lit:es $1 ,150 � b. House Luir�zsiiin� 193 c. �touscl�old ope-ration 50 1,393 3. Clotlii.n� � 5�30 �F. TicdicZl. care 332 .�J. rlCiilSnOYL"�1C1011. C}���� 6. Otiic�r �;ooc;s a:ld scrvi.ces: a. Ttead�.n� and recrea�ion ?_07 b. Personal carc i.30 r . Tol��icco E% d. Pul�lic school exi�cnsc ?.0 c. Commiinication:; 7S f. Gifts and mi_scel;.a�lecus ; 20 g. I�ii.�ccllr,neau: !fp �79 �. OL�'t:. � COSLS: a. Insi�Lance & occup,;tional ey:pc_��:;es 258 ?5� 8. Pcrson.^�1 Lz�xes ��� , 7�0 1:�.J�L li�.'�1�1i'�i� �l���r1�11�, �,��1��. �/i' ril'i�i,l.�� . ��\l� �i)�. Increa�i: � tLc .>'uove �i>uri�;ct b,r c.;^i�t �c-: �c�nt:- �•�uitld r�ei'�.s - `<� __'�.----�-.__�_._.__ J � i 4 s�o r �1;�� 1'.:.:.1C�SCCi COS� O� i.'�V].i1V :7_�7C�.� � JJ�. i�1C ��_<i j'��. �. , ,� t - ' �. _ � �' - iiC'C� LU�.i�-i_ AdL�ll1.U. i)(' ;?�U/.. _ £or a ty��ic��l ic,ur-perso;l �Car,�ily. %�.�T.,S csti�nate - 4 - � ` 8. f'con<,.:,ic rn.3 O�.i:•,r Su�n��rtin,- n,��C:i Cc�ni_f_r,ue�d �_____�_.—._.--'._« � _ __L�_�._. _ A. Ci.t�Tdc�l-lccr' s Fa,ni_Iy B�.d�et Cnnt.j.nnecl ' '1'he 1959 L'ure�zu of Tt�bor Sti�.�istzcs B�rd};et sludy also cont�ins est:imates 4 of costs for oti�c: size famil.ies ir� te;:ms c�f ttic� b��sic bud���t- �;hoti•rti o:l pa�;e 4. I�or u twc�, three and tive j�erson f<�mi.l.y� the budnet c�>ts �ire esti.�n�ted ar 60, 87 r�nd 1'ZO percent, respectively, of the four- person ��udget shoum. • If we were to base our incon�, limit solely on thi.s bt�d�;et, t�le scliedute for each family size wo�il.�3 be As folloo�s: Our continued occu,�ncy Iimit w�ul.d be set at the level oi the cost o; the modest but ;cJequ,^te budoet and ou� admission limzt woul.d be 20% l.ess in ciefi.;�itzoa of 1 oiv inc oir+e. � Fami.l.y Size Admtsszon Conti_nue�' Occun;ncy -----_ —. -._._ — ___..._,.�_____._ 2 Persons $3,520 $4,400 ' 3 Pcrsons 4,640 5,£00 4 Persor.s 5, '4d 6,675 5 Persons 6,400 8,0;.0 Tn comparison, our p;-oposcd aurni�sion 1?_�i.t o�: $4,°OC� ior the tynica?. ► iarnily of iour persons, as wel.l �s L'hc l.in;ifi of $5,�+00 fo� cont:a.rued occup<.ncy, �.re suust��tially le�s th�;i the buc',;ct pr�jectiar:s ior �.. funiily oL this sire. I�or the 1t�sF;er faraily si�es, the uiiic�rcntin]. :i;> progressi.vnly n�ucn g�ea�e-r. �L. }�lli_C�i U O: 7,�:>�J1 �t:it�lSi:.1CS F�lii�f.;Ci. i=0i" .^. [�Pl:1.i'(1!t (;(ll.liJ�_(' 1lUll.11�� i�l�1�J�1�i�Fj� c t1Lf.i���.i: f01" i Tl't:l�f'.Cj CL(:Cl"��7 CGU�i�.l` 1v.lS (�CV:'�Lt7>cC'. Uj/ i�ii' CpC:.�.� �C'CUflt�' [�(:iIl1Il;LSLru�.].nII i.0 p:iZ'i��_(�� t:'I•^ �'.a.���l �,','Oi:�i.r��� ', 1'i ..,l�.�� iil:�.�'�ii . 1llC t3U:Cc:i: Of r�:7JOi" ;i.".L.1Si.]..^.`i i.cVJ.��?G ��i"�i.`.i UI:Ci�' .,. U t • c":llu �JLIt:� ).£.1-'ii li:S CGSIS i0': t't1(•ili��? I.�Y��`- C3.1:7.i':�. iii�_ E��_`ii ]"Cl`1.. i.�. buci��C ;rov:d�.., e��ti �.t:cs o[ th�� co� t o.- a i��,_,�.i .;,..,;1., ___ 1..� -: c '. , �.. ..-.i11C� Oi 17.V11-��� 1Rl' f. 'I(17�1)' t., �.. � C'�<<�Q wQ b<' .. l�ll :iJ:._ii.a .� , i._ +.�� ;:i:(1 GJ Ol" 6:rC; � �.1V7.11�; ,il .`�il U�."��:'. . �..i'..,.. �.''(ll_ �.ri-:7 l� :i.;_ i�_it` _C�`.� . � . . . . L �� , : � . . . . �� ;C ;�]:l�lit�,)OL1S �t.'_��C�4� ..�liCl'1 ,. ;�.�.:>p U��i_i:�C iiti(".! r . ��: . . . 1�. , _ . ..:� -�L::i.:i1('lil: i ill. l.ill:i'l:<..:n(, I..i`.i: _ L J J��: � . � C _ � _. 1 c�. I:conci,�ic aiid Ocher Sa�_�7Urii.n,^, Dr,ta Co�ltinucu . B. 33ure.u of Labo� S�aristicr �3udf;et �o;.' a RetS.red Coziple Continued I t_em � 1, Food a.ld bevera,•=;es $ E4� 2. I�iousi���;: �. Ren�, hc�t a.�c2 u�ili�ies $ 9�2 n, fiouse �uri�is:1�_n�:; 9"/ c, tIousehold operation a.�d co���;�u��zcations 157 1,21.b 3� Clo;.hi.n� 231 4. Medi_cal c.nre 319 5. T�a:�spo-r��4ion 162 6. Othe: gooc:s and ser�*ices: a. ReAdin� and recre�tion 100 b. Personal care 7S c. Tobacco 37 d, Gifts, con:z;.Uutions, etc. 149 �61 T0:'A?� COSi Oi GGC:�€� AidD Si?.�V]:C�S $3,135 As i.s illustrnte.d by the above BLS Bu;3;;et, ou� pxese.it co.zf:Anued occupanc� l�rii� of $4,000 �cr yea;- fo� L-�ao-perso;: ��.milie� i.s mo,:e rh�n adequa�e ���.ien applic�i spcci.�i.c��:.ly to el.d^x;.y fr:r�,il�es o: 4hzs size. (T'r�is Ii;:iiC i� 1150 COiIS'LCiG��Ci aclequate �o ac�o:;;;,;odal:e i,o�z� " . elder.ly �G,�o-person �ainilies w.zo m�:y 'u� E11.�IJ�C.) C. F�:�zl� �.{ccrie in 7.959 � . i;e a��Z p�ese.^.Led bclo:� si�o:•.s �a:,iJ.y ir.co„c �.n 19S9 ;a.- all f�.,,,�l�re:, and ;o� thvse J.C+/11L�.I.CJ witih a neau 65 ye�xs o� a�c o� oJ.dcr i..1 S�a P��ul. l.. All. :a,:�xli�s 1-:O.;�C�1��;.Ci z;ICC;' _ L+o. �:t;;;1L'.�<<:1.�%" ;�C,'.C�?.ri� U:�:.:cr $J.,C^vG 1,797 2.3 $i,COG to $1,9;9 3, J��7 6.�� �Z�vv�J °.:o i2�n'iJ ��y2�� �.�.�; $3,0�0 to $3,999 5,�s�>; 1�.3 $��,Gt�O �o ;[�,>99 7,ui2 23.6 $5,00� �r,c; ov�x 55,a99 ?OU.�"i; :i 0'±':�I. :?Aiii.I�'T;S 77.S 70 . Z'.�'.Cil.�sii .�1�:;O:�i£9, 1'�.:�1'i�l£`S � Cr rr �� �,�l�_)•-'�✓ l]�iL'^1.._..Ci: ili:.t,',.'�7:Lf.ilii;l.:; 1. yi��;_ , m t� -- . r , $. :�:ccnL.-..ic �d Ot::cx S:.a;�,�o:-t��:,-^���:�,t<� (Co;,L-i�weJ} C. F<^����� Incc:;;^ ,in 19.59 (Con�i::l,ed) 2. ElclerJ.� 'r':':;�xxi_c; ._.____.__.�....s._`_ _ �'o;ze�Ain:.a T;:c�-�� P:ousc:zo�d tte�,d GS yev�-s �.nd . Ove: t _._.r._� 2 or r:orc Yer;o:�s 1� Pcr.�a:t ---�--.- � �.. _._.____._..; i�o. �Cu,+: I / No. Ctr.:i Y i, T��s �}:�� $5,QO� 982 770 2952 4i`7e 1,000 - �.,4;9 E�0 1/: 1250 58 i,5d0 -- I,99> 1�93. 22 820 6> 2,OG0 - L,499 101�; ;0 5�3 77 2,5�0 - 2,>�9 1CC9 38 �v5 g3 3;000 � 3,999 lbi2 50 �539 fi9 4,000 a 4,999 1358 60 32£3 93 5,000 - ur.d avei 5770 lU0 603 1G0 1?�730 7,308 Souree: U. S. Ctr,su� o� Pc���cal:�ti.e:�, Soci:� a:�d Lco.io::;?c: C.il:txc'3Grt'il.�'.t:'i.C.:iy �.�J� �it�, 25^.C�J�� l�. F.r:;�__._.?.�,lo�,,,:�n�. ,-a Z.,;,.y�.. t�. ''r'...i�io-rr:;e:t'r. • _._.�.._� ln� fo;.7.ccv�.r.� i.� a co.�c �il�i:i�:� o� r:;�gi�J'�.ic�.n� �.c; ���.;e �i.aL.�1 aF.�XG:ii �ilti �'i+�i�i.f:.:1�3t'��.i.`�.�°S.".1.11i: i�:;liA i..''i':l. 1'.if' 1 3.�Ui�;� i0i: tiity �:7�.'i:1"QiiJ.l1C�;17 +'aii< ��1't�, CCi;�7i7�:.ti�Ci 7.Ti �i1C .:t.��<7i ;: i. _ �/YQ�11.Ci C: �7 j C: � ,. . r_ •_ z_,.n. :. � 7., l'i�il_�4':JO�� �C";c';:i:���i�1: O.i. i'.�:;�9OJ..... 1F; aCi C C ii i.].1:�• 1 al E: ��%�)�^.:, c:��Ca C��'ly 4�;.,_�i.i:1`: G tr." 3.17 Li'si:.i:'a"f� a�i C)G Y:a i CI::.LC:3 �i.c. CG:�;t):3i:-iil�E'„ �;lf?Y � `' �)�'4: � ,� �: r ", , � .3 A10 �u. , .:i 1•^' C.a.`:�:...— €':ICC �0:.' Ci.'�ii�I: C.3�.i.�,'� 7.i7:;O:��:i .^.:: CJ:;��,' 1.:1�G�':,i:i.e.C)`.i ?_:i CO:iCc'�'X�<i,t5} :�.eit� ���'^':"�i0e"�i.'� f:i:�� G:3i::3 2.:'. C:iii:l:i.l�' :J'j��.`.Lp C<^t:)�.%� �O s<.L1;� 1�',U�., %^ 1 � Pi. J',CpTl{)^t:_C �1;;'1 �L"}lt„- C.t -� • ,� �_ . �?,.O;:1:;.11�- 1i3�.i �GUii�1��LiE(�� D. E�n;�lo ;y�ient aeicl ��1:��,es (Continued) a. I:mplo}�ne�zt (Coiltinued) . 1. j�lorlc For.ce Su��mary--1�1 i.nne�ol is a:�d Saint Paul. � l��etr'c�pol.�.,*_an ,'1re:t � OcL. 1954 Nov. 1.�64 Oct. 1965 N�v. 196'i LAron roxc�, 7?_0,900 7].9,8oC 739,400 740,000 Total T;m��l.oyment 701,200 69£3,800 ' ?24,200 723,£300 CLS Non-A�ri.cultural 629,300 626,700 655,500 655, 100 Other �Ton-A�ri_cultural 65,800 65,700 64,400 64., 7Q0 Unemployment 19,600 22,900 14,200 15,900 Labor Disputes 100 100 0 300 Unemployraent Ratc 2.7% 3.2% l,)% 2,1% Employrlent in thousands Per Cent Chan�c F:orn; Manufacturi_� Oct. 196� Nov. 1965 Oct. 7964 ivov. 1i64 Durablc Goods Tot�zl 10I.2 10I.3 -'r7,2 -I-i,/� Nondur.ablc Goo�s `1'o�al 73,3 73.3 •I-1.5 -t-1,9 Orclnrn�ce � Scic���ific Ins�ru�r�ents ].6.9 16.9 - .3 (;�eviseci) I'a}.�ricated I�ietals Prod�cts 13.2 13.2 + .7 -}- ,g iv'oti-Eicctrical i•iachinery 34.9 3[�,7 -}.la.,� _;�.5 F,lect:r.ical 2lachinc.ry 17.E 1�. 1 -I-1.4 +1.9 Food & ;Cin<ired Products ?4.0 24,3 _ ,4 _ Papc�- �: �1liicd 1'rodi:ct> 17.3 17.2 -1- .6 -�- ,� Frinti_ug � Puula_silin� 17.4 1%.4 -I- ,7' -F- ,� N�n-?ia;.0•`::c tii�-in�; . Co�7s�:-uction 38.7 36.4 -�-2,9 -�-2,5 i'rac4spo;-ta�io�: 36.9 36.7 -t-l.l -I-i.O Coi;l�;�unica�ions & Pu�, t1Li1.. 14.9 15.0 + ,7_ ;- ,!a Rctai.l T;-ade 1.11.0 1i2. 7 -F?_,8 -;ti�./F j�7tiolcsale iracle [;7,g 47,g �_ ,2 _L � Finance, Tns. & Real. Est<:i:e 3�.3 3u.2 - . 1 - ,l. Serv�.cc & i�iiscellaneoiis 1u5.8 105,6 �-5,7 -1-5,5 Govcrn�„cnt 8%.4 3�.0 -i-�.3 +4.i? Non-A�ricultur.al (all Otliers) G55.5 655. 1. ;-26,2 -;-2g,�� A�ri.cul�ural 5.2 4.0 - ,9 _ ,[� ' Source: Pii_nnc+.�polis and Szi:i� i'aul i•ict;�c,,no:li.r.�n i1�c: � l;lll�liOj�l'C a'iUl.it��.].Il� �Pil_i-ti1C:::OLF�1 1:C1)�li"LtL`Ctli= O� � I:ri�j,l_oy���;;t�� Si�ct�i-i��y �_�.:��1 Piir��'�x O� 'i,..,�.��_� - ; stR�ist�.cs, i��,rcit, 1`iG'v _ � _ � ! D. }':'�_�ji1G�:'tC;i:i. iiiCa i�:�',��tl,UtSi:llll!u.�1 — L � b. Occu���.tio�;«I W:� Sut•ti•� Th� l.�Les�. aTU;;�. ;;U,°v�y 'v-� t�ie ii�li.�ed SLates 13vreuu of L�bor Str,ti.stics �;a<, ca:,�pi�.ed in J�;nua:.y 1955 fot ti�e .-iitl�:ca;�oli.:�- ti .SE17.T:t F'�U�. i3�'C'�, kU�.3.GwIli1� �S C�ui:.af C'ii�x vCtCC� Lri`0:;1 �il:�C: i.CpJOYL" fox s�Iectcci uccz�z�:tzans. Tae <<�a�e zei�o���cl is fo�- L-rEc 2St�h pex ce�ri.le: Occup�4iona?. �;�::�e Surve� � '.i��.t���ca�olis-S«3��� Pr,ui Adc:� January I965 7./ 2/ rYedzan �.a,�;�in�s [S°! o� i•io-rs:e�a Ea�s� T,^s; '�h<.n Acco�n�in; Clexks $ 5,980 $ 5,25?_ T'a5�ro�1 C:.e:-lcs 4,3��5 4,264 Ordex Clexks 5 304, {� (, s �p�'7J 1�:J ll.:il.ill.�� V�J�LC:�Gi:� Il�li �i �1VC5 (t , �s,3=�3 F e-a�.-..„ b:-a��.,,a,..;�, C�•:ss ���,� �� 3t,� !� �,72 Carper�e:.s, �•iair.te:;�nce 6,:�05 5,7�s:. :3elne:.s, r::z:;�.c..a:�c� �:d �:rad�ti 5,9�8 � 5,[;9� 0<le��, i�.;:��2:�uci:;:xes S �7<< 5,429 � ;,levr,;,o•e G�exr:4ar.s 3,32� 3yd1� Guazd:/;�;a�ct��,���� �a °v7 2,�9-, ,i�=niio;:s, Po'<i:e'�:,, Czeti:�r_e:� l�,C•,.,3 �: ��; l� �'� S,2a7 �,�ao.-:..�ti, �.��e-.;i:i .i�;�:z���.ii�U 5,5�t: � - �7�r%t�_�,�J� V�2s���4.11V „/� /�\/ �,l L.�A ' 1 S:�in?in�; Clec<cs S,S�b 5 5i2 , h �..� ri�i:�.'. �a7 ��:Ft��.C' cizt? �.,1,`ilU:� L'�:I'ali.Ti�S' iJ.:�:C:�l O:l .5>'•:�7�it: j�':ii', . \2� �<ai.�:1 })2'�[':,GY1�Cii i0: �:i:�il Gi���� i3G�':lia`i .t f;il<^�£liF_� z:s�i:i:l �.Cfi.^.•. C• C.:_l`7 Ci ,�5.'.':til� i..a��,J�11�� �`'"?>�:Z�j:;Cil�' �"7rn'? 1.'3�•`_'^ �-- �_��_ �...�._ �..,» T ' ' ` ' � . .� L:e ,oi.A.;.air� �.;.� <„a :;�d;,y o� <,at�. c:;���ct c �� c�:,; . C:.viz SI.A YT�sC�.�. ✓l.i�l'GG4 \f.4 �..�� �, • � �C,,��� �• i l.i.�� Oi .�.za.�l� x��l:.`ti� i.�l:�� l.'�t�J�':i 'L�G:' Cl�y C:;.'��i.0f��., :i:; OLr .1�it:'.I�7i"� .li+J�. Lii•' �j�iilt: :C'.;`Ci:�'G %.`«C7i `CT1L�.iC L:u�71 i.�° u...'>G,.^_Sil.d:.'C3 ..��i� C:C3'.:::;£ii:�i::lCii:; C?L .i.v::".4�i�.:C;.'�C': .1 C��) 11��.,c? :`.1; �� _ 't'�' i ,__..s.�..� _.___- CG.��.OitJ.e il ,I,,',. • ZiZ � l��i�,-��': �114�w..i�41 .�.`r . \' +. .--.�..�.��.-.-.��.�..�..�...�....�..._.�.........�.ti.�.��.�.. ..�.+...__...._......�.�..�s�...��_.. .._._,., _ _ ....- . .... . �ji _ _.,.....�.�.........�....�...�. ..�...�_.�>.�...�__..,�........-,........�.._.-_....-..��w_....-......_"'"""_",.��.__.�.�,. , .� ) , t,,:. ....�..-� � . 4. _ ...� i l. . .-... ..�. .....- - . . . .�.. .�.:......r..�..ti...,.n...�ti_.�... . t ._..-.. ...�...�...�......_�._.._.. _ -�..�.._._...... ... �. .- . 1• /.i. �. � .. ..\i� � •�� .... . .... .�:.., ._.._._...�_..:�_...,...��..�..w..y..,.�...��._....�:... ..............�......�....��.......v. ..�._�..._ ._. � . i r� � ,, . _._ --.. .,_ _. ... ._._ _ - ,. , ____.�_____.._. . . .__._. _._ .. , ,. � � i � � c,=. t,._ 1..,_�.:, ,��._,_,. �_.__a.._ .. , _ . � _ �.. � . "r C r'_ � �.�)� t) �-�� 't .• J _,, � � , � 8. F:conon;i_c anc3 OCh^r. S>>nporti_n�^i�atr�� (ConLitlued) D. Em loyrnent and ��;ages (Contiuucd) d. Avcr.a�e ��7eelcly Earnzn��s (Lmploy. & Larn. �LS Series 9-63 and S-G5) , 1960 $ 98.00 Tianuf-acturi.ng payroll � � l_9G1 $ 103.00 1962 $ 107.00 1963 $ ].09.00 1964 $ 114.00 19b5 $ 120.00 as of Oce. tiov. sli�htl.y hi�;her in St. Paul . 19b5 Bres?cdo;7n COI15�;"lSCt1.0:1 $ 1rjZ.QQ Transportation $ 130.OG Util.ities $ 129.00 idhol.esaie $ 108.00 Retail $ 67.00 Serv�ces $ 83.OQ � E. Ove.r-i.ncumc, Tenant-s anci L+; *�P� licanLs 1. Apnlacant-'s ovcr acL,�ission inc�,��c J.i_mi_ts 1/ (tciiti.at�d Ir.o,n occupancy apl?lications axld P,el�cati.ori L:rnily record car�s.) 1963 - 19(,6 , �xcess Amount I�'urni�c�r i_il Fami"ty �. , of Annual Income 1_ 2 _ 3 4 5 _ G 7 � _ 9 _ 10 .v Ovcr _ $0 - $200 2 1 2 5 ? $201 - $400 3 3 2 1 2 3 $401. - $600 3 5 2 3 2 � 5 2 $601 - $II0� 1 2 2 3 2 3 ,5 5 $801 - Over 7.9 8 �E 5 4 5 5 1 .....__. ._..___.. .�_, .____ __�. .._.� _�-- -- TOT�1,S: 3b 15 13 11 9 15 I3 13 7 G1:�.t�D TUi'«L: 132 1/ I:Iigibility Inco�ne Co�npared to Aiet F�:,��ii.ly Tncorle , 2. Ten.tn:-'s Ove�-a.nco;;;;, (At re-e:�aminatio�z, fro;ii IT�\t. lo�-�� 1245) I�iay 1 9�3� Sc1.L. 196u 1�;xce"� n,not;«� r:�,,,�,�: �.�1 :�� -,a.;�;- . o� l�nnual Tnconic 1. 2 � 3 4 5� C� 7 �.� �9 1 C) ;�: ��vc•t--�- $U - y200 3 7 4 G 7_ , i r:'_�1 - ?400 2 7 2 2. 3 ]. 4 3 S[F01 � $6�0 2 1. ? 3 2. 7. 1 2 ? fi�ol - ���0 2 � z � z � $8�1. - Ov�r ____. _1_ � 10 _ _�'._ 1-� _9 .�' _ . �' _ _,__;---�____ T O'i�1 i�S: 4 4 15 2 9 15 2 5 7 5 l i l i� ?_u Gi::�.id;� TG'a'�1T.. 1�E3 ' - ].U - , � 8. i.conomi_c anci Othcr 5t;pnor.t:in� llata C;otlti:itt�d E. Over-incorn�, Tenants and t'}�nlzcants Conti.nucd Our propo,ed income IimiLs for aclriission would have enaUlecl ttie �uthority � to hotise 48 of the 132 families �•rho appl.i.ed during the past two and onc-half year.s, but who ���ere rejectcd for being over income. Altliou�h thcse fi�ur�s are appa:eil�ly lcw Lor the exL-ent of �ime invol.vecl, the actual volun,e of applicanZs i_n tnis cate�ory is considerably �reater than that ��hich is reflected by the num`uer of ineli�i.ble �pplications reL-ained in our files. Tt is estimate:l by the staf£ o� t}2e tluthority's Tenant Selecti_on Offa.ce thai. approximately 100 inquiri.es are recezvecl ' monthly f�:om families for whrnn applicatiens are not processed bccause oi rcadi.ly deteL-n�inecl in�.li�ibiliC.y, bu� wiio are apparently in need of adequat-e housin� and are expe-riencin� diffzculty i.n obtaining such housin� wiLh�.n their. me�ns. This has become particular_ly true of � larher iami.l.a.�s with 1riCOmCS dc�i.vcci £xom re;ul.ar cmplc��cnr, As a result, the AuthcriLy i�as experienced a ;teadily declininU Laeio of lar�er �aa�e-earni_ng f�,m:i.lies in its teaa7t load anu a concurrent increase i.n those suppor�ed by public aid. The pro�osed continueu occupa�.cy limits �.�oui_d 't:avic eiiaUled the Aui:ilority \ to re�air� 65 oi the 148 fami].ic�s evicl-ed ior being ovr.r iruo:r,e du-rzn� the past threc ycars. At t11e pl-esciit time, there r�re a nu<<Zbcr of f-a:t;il�_es ���ho face. possS.ble eviction cor bei..l� over i.ncoi��e 1i;�lits. RCIOC�tlOTl ZCCOYC35 1i1G1_Cc1tl'. Lil�t I',i�Lily Of i:llC,St' .�o^i11J�.1�^.i WJ.1_1 pr_ob.^ii�l� il10VE' 1T1t0 1ri8(�(:CiU�i.C. uCCOi11��1OC1�itlOtlS �A��1Ci �:1�.ri �S:ltil'; ttlG �:CO.1C:i;11iC hurdsilip of available aciequat4 housi.n�. ' .. i ' - , � . 8. Econc.�,ic a.nc! O��I;cr Sup�t�l.��ita Cor.tir.�,ed :'. In�o;:ie oi' 'ienants ai. �r,'r�i;sion 1�6�;--1955 ---- - _ tdi���ibcr i.n FUr:i1y .L0�.31 TI'iCO:i12 7.'Oi.ft�. . O� �1 E'_il:�l l't..`'i %a l i1�Ml)^�(?9 5 6 _ l. ? Y3 4 ,.__.._ 7 & G�;e x U►�der $1.,375 82 2 2E 36 �I.4 2 0 0 1,375 - 1,650 72 0 2U 32 13 7 0 0 1,65I - 1,925 87 0 13 29 21 19 5 0 1,92G - 2,2Q0 54 0 11 15 1S G 4 3 2,20I - 2,475 51 0 � S 9 3 16 12 6 2,47b - 2,750 57 0 6 14 7 11 8 ll. 2,75�. • 3,025 51 0 G 1� 8 11 7 9 3,026 - 3,�00 44 0 8 9 8 2 8 9 3,30I - 3,51� [►2 0 4 G 1� S 5 9 3r57u - 3,$50 3£3 0 2C 8 8 4 �t 12 3,851 - 4,:.25 28 0 3 . 4 7 6 1 7 4,�.25 - 4��.00 24 0 � 1 5 � 2 l2 4,401 - 4,575 23 O 0 2 S 7 5 4 4,u75 d �;,9;0 14 0 0 0 ]. 1 Q 12 �}yi�.%� " OvCd 3-2 C 0 �0 __1 2 �3 G i�TAI.S 679 2 105 I75 1?_S 1CG G!� 1^v� .°ioit�ce; II,'�A ;.�o�cn 1L?% "i c:��' " „ 5 � 1 ,' ,� ,�, o� C .;`L Oi: A�,Rl:l� C 1ACt ii.�, �.7�•.'� i ilil�].0 i�J1:;J.:1� � 10: Pro�jcct:� :•;i.r;n 1--i �:d��ot��a 1--i��. � .. t;� .. . �. Ecor�c;,�ic �t:;d 02:�c: Su�o;-t;i.r� Dat: Con�it;u�c3 G. Inco�n� of 7'cna:��:s «�. �-:c-ex�rii_na�i.�n 1S'63�1�,'6G � ...._.__...._.___�_�_-- --------- _�-.__...�...._.._......_.. � � r;tr.r.�e r. iii i�r.ni ly To�a.;� T,cc;.,,e TuLal ._ "'�' c` 'i'ena;��.s r<a-ii.l.i_es 1 2� 3 � 4 S 6 7 & Gvcr. Unci,� $1,375 5G 26 9 16 �S 1 0 0 1,3%5 - 1,65� 80 1 32 2F, 15 � 3 1 0 1,b51 - I,92S 12J 1 20 57 24 12 b 0 1,926 - 2,200 11% 2 9 3S �s5 1G S 5 2,20I � 2,l+75 110 1 11 12 31 27 12 lf; 2,�a7o - 2,750 130 1 7 14 33 3G 19 20 2,751 - 3,025 112 0 13 9 23 27 23 17 3,02G � 3,300 114 3 5 S 19 23 23 33 3,30Z - 3,575 74 . 0 8 6 9 7 21 23 3,S7G - G,12S 205 1 14 19 46 23 35 67 4,12b - �S,[,p0 69 0 S S 9 l.l 12 27 4,401 � 4,�75 87 0 2 5 19 14 10 37 4,67b - 4,950 55 0 0 5 12 7 S ZG 4,951. A ovcr _ 28v 0 �F 12 35 57. 50 i34. TOiA'L.S 1s615 3b 139 231 32.�; 25$ 2`22 C,OS 1 SOi1tCC; :�r�.� :'OTlli �,2�,j ��:C?�Oi'i. O: �G�ll�4is. �P_^E:;R�1�.Ii�.�;7.nI1 Gi 1�,�lZl@S ATl �,G:7^�Ci�� Housir.;", �fJ"a" t�i"O�LCGS r%li?I7. id], �.1110U�i1 1w1,0. _. 7 ^. _ � ��. �Ci('_t'I,I7_il,'li�lOri O� 1 O'.:'CS� 1�T7_V<stC �:�ri�S ���� �i�^.�) �L'U�1�J� �n ox'der L'o establi.sit a basis for tl�e conclusi.o��s of this determi�}ation, three studi.es were prepared and rxre presented as follo:•�s: • � � 1. Survey of advertised rei�tal �nits: St. Paul Su.lday Pioneer Press - April 16, 1907 2. New �zparirrent .ent sui-vc:y. 3. Single fami.ly dwel].ing tii�it.s - net,� canstruction. Federal. ftous in� Auri�.nis trat a.on In addition to the above a���lysis, data is nlso presented to d�mo��strute the followin�: 1. Compliance of pLoposed income limits taith 2•1i.nnesot� lr.w, � 2. Availability of Housin� in St. Paul, « _ 1 tF _ suRVE�' 0:' AD�Ji:iZ'I•ISL"u P.F,N•.i'AL t1�ITs St. 2'aui Sun<«y Pi.��n��r. Fress �pril 16, 1.9oi ' t "� The classi�ieu ad secti.an of. the Sunclay Sk.. Paul Pi.on�>.ei- Pzess, cl�tccl ,����ral. ].G, 1,967, cont�:ined dwelizn�; uni�s listed under ti�e coiu�ns related to rental of dwelling units in single fumily homes, ap�rtments, duplexes und other rel.ated units for renc:. Phone calls wer.e made L-o 2&1 of the rent��l lzsti.n�s, all o� cahich were tzot�-s�a3on�l dwelling units. The manzger of ti�c Classifiecl Ad Department i7di.catcd that the Sunday chosen for the s�mple rent survey �a�uld probably produce a cross-section of the type of dwcllin� un;.ts avai.l2.ble in the St. P�:uJ. are�x, as acivertised in ttie classified ads . Tt was deLermined that appror,imaeely 47 dwelli;i� units {17%) could noi: be considereu as standard �vaa.labl.e dwel.;.ing uz�i.ts. Unxts �z-re cotts:iuered to l;c substa��dard or unavUiluble if. thcy �•re locatec� 9_n a slun� area, if the;�e i.s an �absence of aciec,ua�e plunlbiu� or electrical facili.ties, o;- if there «re rac:i.ri� or fe.mily restrictioris. The aver«ge utilit-y custs (as est.imated) �;ere r.udea ro re;its in order to deterr.�;.ne Lhe bro�s �helter rent ior each dwellzn� uzi.i_�_. F l�iE' tubUl�;�lOi1 belo;,7 Sil04;S �1.� Tltiitii>�Y Oi u�.�;ilG:�::c; Cj;•J�ill,i'4� UT1it5 CGi1i�.CL(;G bf L:��J:'_� the hi.ghest ��i,d lo;aes�. �ross shelter rent for. er:c�� �.�ni� Lype r•..nd the medi.�7 :e:1t;l.s char�ed for euch d�aelli.n� ur.it type s��mpled. ADV�:}:'i'iS?D V<1C.��,\'i' �T;itii�;'+.;:li iJ: 'TS AV,�.II,,';;.I: I�O;: (�.�„,1 ri'�+lt?Z11i2^� Ulli� �U�nt�.ty Lo�:C'St i:i.^li�.:L 1�i;`ill�.(: • �' - � � ' Zv'��^ �SJC��2.:1<' UI11iS �CI1� i�t�llt _,r ._._._.�..__�_._._�.__._.. _�____. :..�___...�_ _____._-- ----____..�� _c�: ^l� _ c �;j: 9 $ s�.ao $ior.t;o ;� <<,.oU 1 BR l.?_4 45.G0 1�4 .SO 9�3. �0 2 k:R £sb 6�i.50 i�2.00 13`).�!ii 3 c'.;Z � 13 97.00 3?�;.��,) �"��.;;��;�. 4 B': 1 � 109.00 1C9.;0 1C:�f.�:�;�� S i;R i 310.Ci0 31C.G0 �;1G.��J - i" - r;l.:j3 AP1R7't��cTv�, lii;t�;�: S'J:VE1' � '1:he naL'eriaJ: prese:tt.e3 in tlli.s seci:ion oaar, Cotr.r�i l,ccl fro;n z sur.vey of xenLr to be ch�r�ad or beir�� char�ed in new apartmen� �;�;;uctures%'r ir. the C�_ty of Saint Paul. Information fvr L-ne report was �at-hered from de�l es��,te agencies snd developers, and represents the buldc of the residen�ial �welling units l.ac�red :�n �,r,ri;mc�zi. developmenrs in t��e Saint �'auZ vic�nzty. '�he Relocation Office indicated that �l:e report is rep;:esenta�ive of the rentals be;.n� char�ed in 27 npartmen.t developmen�s co�itain�_n� SSu -ren�al uni�s. ��New stzuctures are th�se buil� sir.ce 19b0. Ci:ZQSS SzAL''I,1.'!:1: �2T:iim� I.trr�T t,���� $�'QV:5.'j �� ;. DttiTELLAi�G UIv11 . AVi.�t�G',: :�O.I'1rii,Y l�VLR����; li`[T_I.�`�Y GR0�5 S::;;LTui.: .,__.._ TXFz: . RE�ITA�, C�i<'��',^,�?�� C0�'�' � �;r�:�_�____�_. (�lec. onl}) �' � 1 ;3R (?1 LldSs•) $1i9.00 $5.50 � $1?_!„_,� 2 i32 (22 Blc��s.) 144.0� 7.00 151.Cs� � i3;1 (� �31ci�s.) 290.00 B.CG 29��.CG , 231 •- l. �R L:Zirs 317 - 2 �R ����i:s 8 - 3 BR L.1�.ts 55h s^.o�al tii�:i:.s LOC��i�]:C>;�'��:i) -:G:_;i�i�±,., L,�;,.,��'iy�\'_s {:'� AJ�A;:�'t�i_':iJ' 17.'.V;1,�i�:'i'.;�-.,,;:� 16 22.0? :io. Ja?� St.r.ecL - ll u��its 1�9Ca.L'C'� ��•?p b°_iipClil U:llli�il:.<`�'12CC! U.73:�=5 ��.1?01�� T)("' i:iCi;;Li? t'l.V@ Q:ii. :)c�C;;�OOii', Lli1i l.Il:l� c„ -1 ' �- (� o „ • _ . ) .t.�i�E��. �.ti�.L�:� ylJ.l.l�eC1 �/('1' �.i�, :,l.ii ?. 22:iG_�'�ia_t)=�a e -5_=-r.c^�� -• 17 u�t:; ,.., J.'L)P.�Vt�� ._��;0 uC�Y00;i1 i;:::�i]iila.L:i1C?Ci 1121a.�:r; C�.)(�.O�! E���7' �:�<�:;�}; 7'1VE� OIii3 ��Cl'�O011l 1,1:1�i1i'i1J.Sl"lE'_<a L11i:�ZS $i�_l�.(iU �)C`"� i�1F;i2�:i; .i e !�J�� .'l: :i ',v:';1R •• �1 li(1�. ., � � n�� , �1Wi`) .. �l .:)7:,�� l.iiZii:;.ili.:.1L'ij ll:ili_.� ..j�� .t'.. ..i. !;�. ,.�. ii � ^ 1 0 ^ � jco 17.40 f.?� Four.th Strec�t - 17 ur,.its 1'saclve, t�•JO bedroom un£u7-r►i:>hcd unit, $125r00 per month Five, on� bedroom unitir�ii>hed U111�s $110.00 per month 5. 1532 ;Zandolp� l�venue - 11 units � TCJO Bedroom, unf-t�rni_shcd units $135,00 per iilOT1�I1 6. � 360 Co�tas,e - 30 tutits A11 o,1e bedroo�n unfurnisheu units 5110-$120.00 pe� month 7. 390 Cott�� - 36 units Ali two bedroom uufurna.shed un�L-s $130-$I40.00 per mont.t� S. 13�6 j�]es�ern Aver.ue - 3U units All one bedroor�i unfurnished units $110-$I20.00 per month 9. 1365 k'estern Avenue - 36 w1iL-s All tcao bedroon� urrturnished units $130-$14G.00 per montEi 10. 1022 r,�nville - I1 units All two bedr�orn ux1£ur;�a.shed units $115-$130000 per montn ll.. l.$71 a?, Sevcnth Stre�t - ].1 uni.ts AlI one bedrocm unfurn�.s'neci units $s}�-$°;,�0 pec iaon�h 12. 1.874 E, S,^v^�th S�z-�>et - 11 u�its All. ot:� bed�oom unfu<<lished units $94-$98.00 pei i710:2it1 13. 1£:f35 E. Seven�l� S�-r�e� - 11 un�ts • . A1]. ane bedrooai unfu_nished units $94-$93000 per nontii 7.4e 1H91 E. Seveni:tl Stre�.� - J.1 units AI2 two bedroam un�urnzs�ed unzts $1I5--$130oC0 pe-r month I5. 556 ,7e.�,1:,> - 17 units �Iev�r,, tt•:o bedrooal ui.Lrurnistled u:;i.t, $I20-$13SoC0 pc-r r�;o���h , Six, one bedroo;n tinfti.nishec: units $98-$112.00 per r,;o,�;.;1 16a 334 C�;e.ck��e - 4� u��its Seventee�, one bed-roo;<< tt;�furnishe.I U311tS $].35-$175.00 ���:- n�o::�s_;� , . ltaenty-three, Li•lo ocd�oo:n unfur:ii.sl;ed units $1vO'•��JJ<OC per r:;o:,�;� Ei.�i�C, th;°ee beuroo� iz,liurai.shed unzts y275-$3J.SoCO pe� ,,;ont;i 17. 3°0 �tr:�r,se�� - 2?_ unzts , �li'iE � OItC hC'(ICOC)iil Ul7l_tii'it1Si1E`C: 11i1iiS .�l�il�.Q�i i;C� ,�1�;il�i? 1F2irteen, t��,�o bcu:-oo:�i u��f��;'na.sheci i�r�its $ib5 .;�175�0� p;�� �,�o.�t;-: Ri_ve,= lil.vd, 1&. ?_00 ;�o, ,•iississ��-��i/- 7_C tin:.�s I�Olii_ � OiiC �)CCj�Q0:;1 lii:i.11i'i1J.Sl1L.i� 1:i1:iL5, ����$)` �i��`S„�'J ��.... ,.',� .�_. : :�: S1.XrE':�1:? l`.�SO DCCe."OOiii i:'il�U.?"I?i..,f2C�� ll111i::i yi7v�)°jJ�:�.�tti ��C� ..,..;. '. �1i 7.�. 7.72.0 i�r<�riol?t �',v^�iiie -- 77 �init:s :�7.`7t�� C�'_ JOr.TC��;;l ��,..�iJ;"._!c„i^�l t;;17.i�£, T (�r' ,!� ? ;_. .� ,.�.... �' � z � � � i - L�dC.�V(_'� �LJ7 i)�dl'OG:�l L':`i.l.-"1"7.S;1� i 'i..il_:, � _ ��. - . � . , � ,� . - !7 - r 20. 17�s0 No�-foJ.l; �lvcnttc - 7.7 uitirs Fi.ve, one bed�ocm unfurnislie�i units $1Q5<00 per month Twelve, two bedroom u��uzila.shed units $130.00 per month � . 21. 1750 iv'oY`olk Avenue - 17 uni_ts Five, o:�c i>cclroom uzi�ur.n:�sh�d i��iits $105.00 per cnont.ti T�•:elve, twc� bedrooal uniu�-nislled uni.ts $i30v0U per rionth 22. 2450 Ste�*:�rt {Rivcr C7.iff ApL-s,) 23 uni_ts ltaelve, Ywo bedroom un£urnis}ied uni_ts $145-$150<00 per. i„on�h Ele�Ten, one t�edroom un�urnished units $115-$12�.00 per mo7tti 23. 24�1 Youn�man - 23 units Trrelve, two bedroom unfurnished uni_ts $1�E5o$150000 per mcn:.h Eleven, one bedroom unfurni.shed units $115-$1?_5a00 per r�onth 2��0 1161 St. C1ai.r Avenun - 23 units Eleven, one bedroora unfu��ished uziits $98-$3.I3o00 per month 1��e1ve, two bedroon un�uLnzshed units $12C-$14Q,00 per montti 250 7.95 So. Dtinla� - 23 units Eleven, one beuroom tinfurnished units $98•-$113a00 pe� n�oritiz 1�relve, two beciroom un£urnisi�ed iinits fi12.�J-�1��0.00 per nonth 2.6e 215 Soo Dunlap - 23 u�tirs Eleven, oz�e bedroo��i unfurzlis;i�d t�nits $9F3-jx3.3.OG p�.r month 1�leve, tzvo l,edroo:� unfurziished uni�s $120-$140000 pe;: r�o�1�n 27. S50 Viei�� - 29 units " • SCVL'.1Zi'C':t� OliE' h�C�Z'OOi:I LiI"liltXi11SZ1iC'1 11i11�S y�`Z!7-$1.�(�'P�'i�� i�^i i�lOi?�:1 ltaeive, ttao bedroom t�i�fur�-�isi.ed units $120-$"l�GoGO �c;- mont��i •- � _ r �JtJi�i`��L�X C: �.�1,�. ���:l.C��'.7) iii;��l):.l'r17llJ. C�ii�J�.ZI��,17�11 The 1;elocaiion Cifice co:�tac�ed Grrin 1:1Utill�son Ho;nes, Inc. , Mzrvin �i. Anderson, � Inc. , and �a.cchus Cons�a:ucL-ion, Inc. , developer, of p:-i_vate housi.ng units a-tounc3 � �he Sai.nL- T'aui a:°eZ. T1ast oi these new LlI7A.Cs ar.e fa.nanced thiou�;h k'ciA and for that reason we hezvc used an P�3A facto;- �ax a projec�i.o.t for Gros� Shelter Rent, 1he follo��ring is our uizalysis of the ne�o residentia� conszructfon marlcet ior this area ���ith re�arri to the suppl�y of housir.� Ue�n� provided by private entecprase, unaidecl by public subs;.dy. 1. In ou:. opi.nion, the lo�•aes� sale prices (price to t�c purchaser) at which 3 SUGSran�ial nunber oi PIiA inspected sale houses •fre�c built du�in� L-he last 12 months a:-e; a. Orrin `ljnompson l�o;,ies - 3 beciro�n� uxli.�s $17,800 4 bedroon zznx�s 18,925 S bedroo;n iini.�s 20,875 (all i.nclude sin�le ga;:a�e �oorti� $1,1C0) b. 2larvin Ii, Ande-rson Develo�i:lCi1� 3 bedroo�n un�.Ls $15,3.95 4 bedroa� �ni�s 21,704 (i.nclucles t,a7_�-,�e) 5 bedroc;n u,z;��s n�ne ca J'anctri_c IIomes, Inc. - All 3 bed�oo:l unxrs ` $16,500 � � d. l3ucchus Con^�.ructi.o.�, Inc. � 3 bedroc,a unit.:; $�6,?.75 [� U�.d-roo;�� uni ts I.9,OOG 5 becroo�a units 19,G00 2. Tn ou;- opi.niea, the �iiA financec. lio„��s ioL w;i�ch �he lo:�es� sale p�.ices 1Tf_' i:Ci�OiZ�Ci l.ri 1i.C:�l 1, above, 1"Gj)`A2sG'.11i.S L(iC iG1�C�1'1..�,� i O<i.1Gil O;� �.�1 Sc'�1C l�OUS�:i �U'�i.12: '!Il e.^cf1 u:l'.:C �s011� 7.I7 �il�S �I;t`�l C�U'1"111G Lf,C ��,:i� i_� � nor�th s; 2 bcdroo:a u���_�::. T.c:::� t::i.:�� 1 f;; 3 bedroc:a uni.ts I.e;<� ti,,;t; ] f3 �� bedtoC:n un;_t_.� LC;.. i:h���� 1/� 3. �'YOii1 �:"ll� li��O��il�i,lO:1 �9C 1C:CC1VCu ii�0i:1 ill:'_ Pi�.1:::C•�_')O�.i. _ 0:'i3_.... Ci _.. . •� l.riC iil?.i'i.i_i.il!�i1 .,�i�_C� L Ta.CC..> U.`. ]"i.C'r7 Cl�'.!i'�.��.il��S IiOi: ,��1-. a;.'C�CC: l'�� ''�i,'�1� [;.li; �;tC_�-i:.._iin . .�,': IC:i.C;.l�'�.L'`„ �,..�lil:l<'1X'CA3 �'.'CiC :17.��i2E'_'� lii:`il'� LiIC �)�3_C:_.� . ��. .... 2.�i �.�C:il �.. �,i)C�V�. ., i �' _ 4. ' Closi.n� costs (ott�c-r t�ian prepa:.d e::penses) o:ould generally add nbout 3% to the sale price ot low-cosC. house:: in thzs A2C<1. t ?'ile followin�; ta�:uiation sho:�s the avera�n,e sslc pric�: of a sin�lc f�mily dcaclla.ng un�.Z r.s zndicaL-c�3 by ��-�c ucvc.lai��:r:� �s�c: I'iIl� aald u projcci:i.oii o£ the Gror.s Slielter Rent. A conversio�i Lact;or oi .G085 is a�nlied Lo the ::ale pzice, plus the 3% clo�in� costs to de�ernine tne ien� eq�:ivalent. Ti�e esti.mated aver��e utility costs are adde� to the rent equivaleni. i.n o-rcter to deteru�xne thc Gross S�el�.er Rcnt. GROSS S'.IET..`Cc.R nF„�,\?i�SI:�GT.l: FE1•:�tII.X Di+i':T.7.�I::G iiNll CO.�:C_- Fii�1) 3 Ill: �E I3ic S I��: Sale Price $16,OG0 $19,000 $19,GOQ Closing Cost �48C) (3%) 570 (3"/,) 58° (3`/) Ad�usted Sa.le }'rice $16,�i�0 $19,570 $2J,1E8 �quavalc�nt I:en� (.OQIIS) $ 1��U r�o. $ .165 mo. $ 17?_ mo. Avera�e UY:ilf.ty Cos��� 28 mo, � 3b- �ro. � 39 mo. G•ross Shel�e� Itent $ 168 mo. $ 199 m.o. $ 211 mo. �SeF Detezminat.ion oc Aver.�^�e Utili,ty Cos�.. " \ llis'l'i:Rii�_i�;[:'i::i:0'? Q�� t�VZ;R�.tri�, i�1.':f:L��'CY C�S'.�5 li1 OIC�CL tU CiCtE.'TT1I1C L�7G lli.].Zlt� COS�S fOi a:l �1VCY�:�C fii111�.y C'C�7CI.11:t�� Ui11:� i:.t1C i3ortizern Si.�ifiCS �G:J(.'� (`i07;1})�.I7y ��T�S C0.1i,c'iC�Cd concernin�� �:I1C <.Vi_Y'��`^,C �:1; I<:i.C'S :.Tl �11� Clf:�' aieCi 'i.[i(_' SV(.'.i"i:�C CiCC�i].0 C1]<i:VE..'S 7_ii t:�l� Cl.g;}�. ai1C COStS �Oi" C7a"LCi: C0:1S�:i:t)t:il?i: L9GrG' CO.���Ut.CCi fTOGI ��OUSliav c'iYiC� RCCi�'VClO��iiil'.iaL .iU'L'i101'7.i,� 1."CCC1iC:S CIIIG �'7Cx!? a:U�i:��'.'.i' VCYI�ICG Gi1i:i t:i1C'_ 17( �2Yt�Ci1Y: Oi ��UD71C �i:a.li.i.}� OL L:("iC �::l.i:f O�: ..`�i�l.:l'L" i�:ii�.. �II Z:tiC b��lS O:F t�1i �.i1�0"L'i:1t.,GiOit OU��.�12CCZ 1r"iGi�l L�1C I1�OVi' `.',OU':"Cl:iy 1,:[1';. i O'„},...,._ `� 2S r • t 1 �-.,_. ti r. c1SSU;��:.� f01 I�'�IG4?OSC.°i Oa. GSi.i.C,Qt1�7� �il� Vi'O;S S.1C':��.i. iC711 .�G'' i)i7.Vlii:c:l;` � _�_.� GWG�11.1:; ilil.l�.i:� i0i: TCIl'i. OT i0Y SLilL; � ���r;: :1,^ A`G:�'S' ,?, 7�'; ,T,C"`I C; .)tae:ll�- ., l)o:,::..;�:i_c ti;:.J_z, a.c:� 'i��. ... . ,�x • , ,„ < T • . / . �L 1._ .i�. .e .ir.. \l�.i. 1�� . �i C.� �.C) 1�:..t-'a�r 1_�l�(��.�. �n, i� �t�:- C' ..'. , � ��,.�L_J.�_._...... ...,..�._ �..___�-.. �_��.-._ ,�.s_.__ _.....,._.__. �-_...-__.._....�.....;.,. __.._�___.. ..-.... .-.. . � �� ii;� � `i.�%li S.i.�i�� y /i ,r:l..l Ci .�.' . _. .i!'`! �. L: I.�i� �F.Vt� �). ��'. � ��:� n ).:l rr 1 L%�. 2 �,I: iU.Oi) :i.Cu %.;"� i._i-) :?:�. ,.. 3 7;;: i:?.CC) ' �;,ii0 3.{;;i :'.`�:� ?: , ��. ;,i: l�`t.�'� l.0�� 9. ;U _�. �;; `'%..�� . 5 i;�: i l,:;0 S.C O ll.� 0 . .�;:; :�`> .:j ; _ ?Ci .. + DETEi�„Ii:ATI():d i-?' I.0?�iL',S'i Gi?OSS P.i;?�iTI�L F.OL'1VALe.\TS -• Si'��vi;,1RD SAT�:S A\ll R3?�T�1L �iased o�� the data cont�iiized herezn, it is the cob�clus?on of this Authori.ty, chat for St. Raul the fol.lo�oin� are tt�e lo;Jest gross rcnes (includin� utili.ties) a� �•�ha.ch pri.v�zte � enterprzse un�ided by publi.c subsi_uy is currently provid;�z,g (throtigh new const;.ucCi.on �,nd ..1V£11.LI;i>LC'_ C'I.1aL1.I1� ,°,t1L1Ci:UY'CS� � a subst�nLi.al. supply O.F. ClE'CC'.17�y uafe uT1U Saiiltary hous�.n�: Gross �nelter Rent Gross Shelter Rent lhaellin� Units Lowest Gross (1�'et�r Apt. Sil�vey Adv. P,eil�al Units Sales -- I��iA Rental I;�uivalent -�. _S.__�_____�_. ) 0 ER — $ 89.00 _ $ 39.00 1 13It 124.50 99.50 - 99.SO (21 Bld�s) 2 rR � 151.00 139.00 _ (?_2 B1d�s) 139.00 � I3R 293.00 180,00 $163.00 163.00 (2 B1d�s) �+ $R - No substantial supply 199.00 199.00 S BIt - No subst�ntial supply 211.00 Ir'o stiu�tantial stcpply . - 'r.i. - � � A 1 �'T �}` C>r', �"1� :`1��(,�� I�r•�._��....__�_._./__.�__',_.. t�.__i:�� 1._...lii: 7 li�: 3 eil2 �i lif\ 5 ni:Z �{. ...�i +ni,� - --f•;;.� i�:("i;1�r:i.� :a?IIt.S i • . , i)::a_i7�` ,?C:��l �.�* .�; �i�-.r '.•� -1VC.L.0 , _ _ � � , c.'_',:t�CL,,'Ci.;C' ;'.01 ti:'Cei:t, t;�i�'C <�rid �:��,�i.t_,�:��y h��u:�:i;i,�. r;,9.��0 $9,��.5f� $139.00 $.163.00 $1�)9.00 $2Il.CG �. .' .,.�.raur,t rcnts per:ni�Lod .in , �,.i;: �,_ .;(;�,._ .t_i:,, lti iiiuC.i� i`o . � f.ii�lii�.<"a].il 1 ��J� V�i�). �i�CII�S � �.;� "A" «bovc less 20%,j $71.20 $79.�0 $I11.20 $i34.40 $151.20 $1Gr;.;;0 C. i:i,;ilest: ;-tioss rents �o be ct-�.��,-�ed �o� aui�iission to piibli.r_ t101.1S111E,. ,�54.00 $G?_.GO $�;9.00 $97.00 $101 .00 $i.00.00 D. Percent��e oi �c�ual ga� be�ween ��1��� ��d '�C'� ubov�. 39.33% 37.69% 35. 9�% 42.?7% 49.25% 5?..6iR/ ii1C ZZiO�,�G CICtCLG1�Il�rlOi1 C1tR11}l1Si::.":i�GS tj1C' C�,].S�Ci7CC Oi 1 �3�) C� iilOT�. �i.2� 2�1% iJC��Jt'_C11 the io;acst �cnLs �t w177.Ci1 priva�e ente°cpxise unazded by pubZic suL-sacly is providin� �titiiCii,��';7 Ili'_';�: CO:�S��UC�:LOil �,17Ci L<:_ISLLi1� S1:LUCtlii"CP,� �t Sl1iJ;ii.��iZ�ic`il Slt7'�Lj/ O{ v('_CC'IIi:J \ Sc1i=' �' �IOUS.i.i1�' 8.I1C� 'G i c.�1Cl Sizl17.t2,i.�% � j1� U��>C'_L' OY' :ii3:i._fiUP,I YC11�i:1, l �i:ll'l:S �O1 <��Zi:l[�SlOil i:O LO�J°i�C.�Z ilOiiSlil�. �ri:C V�7 C�ECCGii�llil�.t)_Ott 1150 Yf��i'i'_SE.'?t�S Lii('. �J_ri«� C1';.i.Ci:l.;.1 i01 �V.aj_Li;�1i1�; CttL !�'iU�i(}S�U � 7�t?COIi.0 �1.P,11Z:>. �lU'L l.tiCOii1C.' I.Iilli�$ 3� COIlL].11Li�^_C� OCClli�:iilCy S�lOLilCi 1?C.' l?SL<�i)��Sl1C(� ;;C <� ��0111� 4J(1�"::t? 'i..^,ii11Z7.c=S tJO��iC� 17t' IIlOVlil� QUt O� lOW-YCt11� iiOtlS�Flt, t�?i.CTi �:(��,!"U�:�C PY1.V,�i:2 ilOiiSJ.il^ lS uV�i�,b1.e �aitilin rili'_lY i11Cc'ZI7S. Unc;er ��1C <<1Lit(IOC'LL"��S Di'£'_`;CIl� YE.IIY_ SCiICCiI]IG� �x'OS:i Y'C'ili. 1S C�LCUI1L�Cj CIl t}l� b�.Sla p� �l.n� �)C.'i ITi0ilt:li 1C11C �:0� CV�i;�J $52,00 oz «n,-�ual inco:�e (iess a de3uctio;� oi $i00.00 for e.,ch rnino:r in t�ic ��;,i-i.ly). T'r.us, to aff,�rd i.he $139.G0 monthly �ent for < ��ti�o-UecIzOC211 �.�v��te c���ellzr� (li�:e ".'1" above) , a typical foLr-perso;� �am:ily should have. �n annuul �nc�me of $7,?2.3 ($52 x $139) . I:G�JC°Jer, our �roposed contznued occu4�aijcy 1:�:�zt for �ot�z-,�,�rson .'Cc^.T1i117.1,S 1S f?51:�3�JLiSilCC1 :�:t 0:1i.�7 $5,400. t��.t:iiu�i�'il L17C1C 1SI c? :�II�S�=�;��1:.l j��:� UC�WC'C'il i.�ICSC �tl1011lli.fi� :JC �CCL ti11� OUC 7.i1C0(riC 11ti11,(:S �tT'C 1('_:311S�1C III:C�ICi �QC:1� c.0I1CIlt1.ORS. 'Che ._^,,��;�r�iit c�i,1�ariCy is a necess,�ry re�ult of ci�e <ii;.tc-te:lcr�:, UCL`WCL:� ti1C Clii:e::�a �d111Ci1 Tii��:it bt' :���LlC� ..1 f:t1P_ �^�7 (i(��CT':Ti:.Il;i�i0:1 „liCi i:�:�. !':llt:;101..��>tS O�1liil.Otl �:S t0 I:�1C I.0 V'C�. 21`. WLiiC�1 ��1C.,' J.O?J-3,Y1COiilt'_ ;�C'�liiC'Rt O� l`.�1(? CO�:''i;;i3�1 i.L f (•711� SJn>� i)u^ uCCC)iT?I�IOC�i;tCC�( C•:).i:Il2.i: i�1C iiiC:l[l�il�' O:l S��lte 1ilCl 1'C'(jCx<ll ��t?�lu. _ 77 - j'�� :ii.VC p:-eSCii��CCi ��Cy Cicit:El ii0i11 �Olii" Cilif2i"C��i: L}����.� vi Ci.i��-C�lu 121 UL'aY' 1C1C0'.li I�lIT11{.S Prc-�posal. The ]cey dsta are rec•4pitulatea as i�ollo��;s : CYl.CCYIA ��OSS1_1>l.0 71lCOiilt? Lir,lit:s �.{: �\C�i�?I.SS ]�lil , � F.1� Non-elc,cr� Budgcts. . . . . . . . . .$3,1.35. . . . . . . . . . $5,340. . . . (foux' person f�rnily) Census Tti�come l�aLu . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .yG,543. . . . (mcdian) l•laUe Su-rvey. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$3,328 - $7,713 . (l.owest-i�zghest) Gap Study. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .$5,732. . . . (four person fami.Zy) Cor,clus ion Tlie aumission and coiitinueci occup;r.cy limiL-s as p-rcpo„ed in Sec.Cio�� �� wi11 allow only workets in the lcwez-�U�.d johs to occupy public I�ousiii�. It w;.11 be noted th<�t thcse lim�Li-s full below the f�mily bud�et reGu�rem�n�s as c1e��onsL-rated in Sectlo�l nA. iio�•�- ever,, this will insure that th� Au�t�ority taill r,o� r�ccep;. any persons as �e.�unts whose , A��E',,YC,�'�atC annual 7.11CO�lC� �eSS SUCi1 C3�.GUCt:l011S �t74' @Y,Ci�1�JLxOriS uS 3Z'C £iUIilOiizeci by 1�:J OY' YE'&ll�.�tt10�1S esta'uJ.ished by t:ilC' HOuSi_T:�T E�SiI_GL`�Ti(;G' ,A.�I:i�:1.i11Si.i":t:l.0ily CCU:i1S Ox CXCCt:CtS ti1L' c2ifc011tlt necessary t0 CIl<_�1.� SUCil j>E"LSQi1S L'O SCCU'L'C C�CCe:1i.� SAiC aI1G S:1I17 'L'�;Y';J C'iWC�_° 1].Il� i,CCO�1tiilOG��IOilS 011 t[lE.' j�21V:i�f.' iiiulliL't �aitili.n t:t1? :ilCil O� O�P_Y�1�7.011 OI Ci:C 11L1L'ti0;'l.t`J EiTiCi L'U �YOV1CiC .:17 c1C3CCiti�i.L' St�..:7C�u^.CC� OL z7_Vi.Tt; i0i' tt1G1;i5CIVCS. � Eq utiliza.i:g the proposed i.n.co;n� 1�m�Ls, t��c Au�izo:zty �ai.11 he aUle to p.:ov�uc no�.,Ua.n� , �Oi ��.:7j� f�iiil"1.12C'S �J[l0 al:l'. Ctli"i"Ci'lt�.y' OVEi Z[1C izm;.t'� �Ui. uY�' LFi1:aJlt'. t0 �111C1<i:�C i3 ;G;ii` L1TiC�C.'i. SOi1TlC� i1T1<iiC�_c.l. ��c^.I75. 1(IC'SL' i.ziil��.1CS �1L1Ci :l� l�lO:ii. Cjl��:"�.CU�.i. i0 i:Cilt SL:,Tili�^..iC3 tiOilSj.11� �41Ltllil t�I1C':lY iTCdi1� WiICTC Li1C Ia'1RCl�.OT(j l^T11� $CCCi�t: tnei-r CiiiiClYC'il. �i(1;:'£'_VCi , L'ne �ili��:G7"lt:y �J1�.1 i10� I1:�1_L 'l�i 11011::;:i.i1�� £c'iCl.l.__`L3C5 i.0 1.�.�ilx�_iC'> C�7i10 �iiC Cr1��.O��tC.i c:ilCi WiIOSC 1:1COs11.^_S B.xC :.C. i.i1C? ll�)'?E'I" ZCV21.5 i0i' C11<<;1.'t)A�.;:i:y� �il �:iiC COi7�7".^I"i`, �[1C t'1i�l::lOi:1tJ �J:L�.1 co:��:Cnue 1:0 COO�7.�i�i.['. �•?:�Lil 'Cil:� �.Oi217t:� G1C•I.1:Fi:_�^ j)::�)Cii"i:ii;_'.i11: .. lt': O�li^_: �3��CI+CAc_iS �::1(3 (iGTSOi:5 ii1 i:[7C COi<<i;2.;IlA.�j' �O �IOU�i' i:�i!l:ili..°S tJl;.tl LI'l�. �°:'."-`j 1-G';.'��i: iilCl�',i;�... l.t�f'. Uc.i=u 7iG'Si.i:�l-Ci ,r�7C;7S Lil".:: i.ili �;<.'�� :;S li i" J_1: C}:Ci.'-S i n:. 71��: �O ;1�7:'i'.:1 Lil:� 1_ �':v�...:�: . �'iii, �E.LII�� c7C111uVLG by �7_"a.V.:i�E' .�.1tLi.i"}?i�.S^ <:'iLC: t.i?C iC:ii. i_(1�=ti: �'1i.1L ii:? CilLii"`�T�CCi GTI C.)liL Y:';li� 3Ci1'�<:ii�.4. I�RC�t./U7:i'y 1:'i i1C1J_f',Zi:. 'l:i:AS i�iiA�il07:..::� Cii:i 'J:`3C Ct;.i:j� O�li: �.t:` -C• -,�)�;i'.'. �.,..._x.l.?:ti :�i C1;C' �Yl';'��O�CC�. .',.T:. Oi;}C � ?J5i1.", �.xC' C`:L�;.J�.7_:it_'C'i . " l.J " , . . . . . ___'_'- . .._ ._..--•--"_--_..._____�_ `-'" l�i V� 1 l c t Pl!l': r i:l L:. '_' . _ ._ `_` 1.,,_._'.� Ti�e :Iousi.n� and Redevel.opn,ent l;ct of 1•��iu,�esoLa specifies t:ha.t low rent public housing s'riail be av�iil<.�ble ai;Iy to £an�i.lies iii thc :Lot,7esL 20% )_T1COii1L' �roup i.n tlle lor�z].i.ty in wlti.ch thu housing is located, �11so i;lclucl�c; i�i t:h� l,,te is a provisiozi L-hat the � .riL".'1f:C �.Gfi'Ii11I.�:;lOi1Ci O[ }�OU;i],ilv R77y R1�1j�(? il (iCi:(?;'llllll�i�l.011 L}l1t �1 ]]1�'iiC'.3' PCYCCili:ilF�C ICJCL may be e:;t�bl�;:liccl unc;er ce;-L-ain ci:-c�.i�n�tanccs, • �:i�c luc�t :aucli cict:��rrn:,:;;L'i.oc; ir.t;ci� by CtTe Co;,:r�;i.ssicnir set tlie ii�cor,�� r;a;timut;� at 3G% �. Local at�l�horities ,na�,�, tht��eLore, Cu4�1i)�.15�1 lI1COi113 IlCilltu tiJ(11C11 ��O IlUi: !�';tiC.CCC� t�1C j��o limit-, 'Che Bureau oi tl�e Census, CURR��;� rOPIJZ,�1�'7pti I:'LPO:�'S Serics P-6p, Nos. 35 and 51, sl:otas that tne annual inco;��e oi L-he lowest 30'/ oi fa;uil.ies in L-lie North CentraY Rc�x.on rose 31°� f�-om 1959 to 1905. In response to thc l�ut_I�ority's request for a reasonable esti_mate of tile maVimum incorrc� ior tl:e lowest: 3G% oi f�,mil.ies in SL-. Patil_, the rureau sug�ested ehat �iie 31% increase bc applicc� to tile lo?aest- 30% o; 1`arri.li_c�s in Lhe �iin,le„polis_Ste paul Staad�iz-d �letropol.itan Statis�.i.cal �lre«, -, {;;cc aLt<Ac,:;��cn�j �:ilis r.�svlts i.n a �i,aximu;n incon;e of. y ? 30% in ttts� rfinric�,E��l.i. ,.. °7 100 �or i.;��� lo�o�sr: � „ � S t. �'r�u I. S.°S.SA, � �e1l.S �'1V�S t��%O pOuS1J1�.1_i�1CS iOT' CSi:lRlZ�a.11� �IIC'. 19l)� 1T1COi;C O{� i�l�' 1(14lC;� .�iti� O� familic> ix� St, i'rna7.. One m..thod j•�ou1d b^ to rclate St. Pstt1 to t1:c i;ort'ri Cen; ral. Pe�ion; tiie oL-he-r mc�ilod would be �;o rel«L-e St. P«uJ. ro ttic i�tinneapo)is-"t. Pai�l ` Si1S�'�, 7'il� 195J Census of 1O�illai.j�0i1 .>ho��;; t_hat the rn ' . � a1�t�;um irlcor�.,� io� thc �ot:-�st �Gti or f<,mil�.e� in St. Paul r�zs �� � 1959. , �,09� ii� Tlu.s ��a.:,;; ?�.6% ^,.eatc� t',•:<.n Li��� , �i;- <_ ., ._r;,u�:i inc.oiitc o:C � ' { ,- � �-3� JU5 i0� Lt1C 1.0��:C'.St JQ� Oi J:ai�lI1CS xll i.�1C i�0"L'i:�1 CCi11:T<2�. ii�'"lO�t, r_ �� �.t 1; 1SSUG;:'_il �Ii3� ?I1CO:ti:CS :OY �j1G ZOW��S� �O�� Oi i�:i;�7' ._7:ies i_�: St. ;'rt.l. ;nc�_e,�c. � ,- , :�« ;t ���.. Jt�liil: Lc�l...�: tl.� l(]e ���i,iL.>l. �)ll� lti l.f]�'. lin( 1.11 lriZ:L1.�i�. �\:'��rAl Z /� �C \ ... � �� �� ./:�� , ti-�c 19�=;5 �;:,.:.-.��.��:;�� i_;�co;,,,� fni" i:t1�3 �O:•._.Si. 31)� I.Il �i_. L�C:iI� t'J11:.C( L�C cJ O°lJ, '; , �. � nr n,�.,, Y � :�'� c� �,"ot�c .;i'u y����,i��.i �n<,::i i„ttrt �.t:.:�,-::;,,, t01 I1li;1:iSS1011 ZO �lii)i.:.0 iiOLi; ' ` - i;i�, rc,>L�sen�:� uu i.,�c.-cc..;�� o�. c�.,' � 13.&% - - ; ' /- ,-; o;. i... . _r,;::�� �, � � i77C 1.11C1C�iSC lIl ;�T1COi,:CS i0Y i:i1C'. YC�;lOi? D��:G7�'.C'I1 i��)) C.'ilCi ��i��>j, �'��i:��.Q t:iit?Yl? �i1f? 1l0 li1Ci� '` , ` - , . i.Cc��011:' i11:"t� Li1C0[�::� 1't1C1E ,..., c ' - i.Ll �. . _�.ill [�. _ i: � - i't. . L �)�..._. , �.'J.i'tl tc;._. ]'`Si. Of .;liC i"C'"'1.011� � ' , ' :�:lE' � . � : - i� �� 1.`_ G r .,..a �1LCLl . !Cl'.,7i? 'tli'_� (•�i, i: �... �. . i'� _ ,�C ....,., . . :7L O:�� ��7 O:_ LI1�? YC:�7r1::71 i<11:C t..:i� [il£i::1f.1UG� ) 1Ci) '^ - - '-) . .�.� 0:�. ��i`_ 1.'1` . . �_ ..tl�,�� i}_ .. _ . � -- -., ��.'iil'.LC� C:ASJ 7.J i.:;::�`."`ii Lil�": �);:Oi?�i:;CC� ,��`1 iil�V G',.- �.i� �, i-� ' - � ;.i_.. � (i�;Cl, ._ �_i �."_i. ;.ii,. �...� �_..,. .. . .,, I;1 rclatinL S�. YauJ. to thc :tirinc<.�polis�S�. P�al. S�IS11, !:hc 1�u0 ccnsus shows t:hat tne ma::in;urn i_ncon,c of tlle lc�wes� �U% of �ami.Li.es i.n S�, Pat�l in 1959 �aas 5.510 l.o,,Jei- tlian ti�e sam� cnte�;or.y in the S,iSA. If it �acr�� still S.S% lowe-t in 19G5, the maxi.�,�um in- � come oL L-iic lot•.�est 30% aL familics in St. 1'zul taoulu i�e $G,710. 7f i.t �aezc as much as J.�.3% lo�oer i_n 1965, t�he m,:,xinuan: iticornc Lor the loc�est- 30� o£ fam�li.es in Sr_. Pr�ul woulu still excee<l $5,500. �1�ai_n, t�zere is no indicati.on �t11t Sr_, Pr�ul.'s i.r�con�e increzses are not keepi.ng �ace �ai.th L-hat of the 'rtiilneapol.i.s-St. Paul Si��e1, Tt can, therefore, oe demonstr.ated that the proposed znco�r;e lirni.ts do �not e�;.c�ed the ma;�imum family incomc of the lo;aest 30% of £amilies i_n St. Paul. . � . •"Ll�., , , . �iVA7�7,e�:iiiLi.T`i GI� iiOJST�;G Iir' Sl�xi';1 iAUI, Izt order to demonstrate the local si.tu�tion relative lo the availabiliLy of housin� foc lo;o�inco,�e fa�ilies, certain iniorm�iion has b,en gathered aiid- i.s`�presen�.ed her«in. 1. t;��nsus In;or.rr.rior. on I?oas�_t�,.^, Stoc?c ^nd V,^_c�ncir_> The 19u0 �Iousir.� Census }Zeports ia.da.cu�c that there ���`re slightl� over 102,300 hous�,ig una.ts in Saint Faul. A�proxin;ure7.y 10,E70 �11%) af th�sc �aere consideced substanda�-d. Appro�;.xr,�ar.ely 3,6Q0 units we;-e vtzc�.n:.. Of the vacanr units, 2,41b or 2.4%, we�e u��ailable for rent o.� ior sale. Of the 2,416 avaXlable units, 749 were substanc:urd, leavin�; only i,567 units �ts standurd, vacant, avail.a'�11e for rent ot for s�;le. 'i'he toi:al I,6G7 units (1.63% ot all the uni�s �.n Saint P�.�il) �cere fiirttier di.vided �s 1,370 Eor rent (l..34%} and 297 ;or s•.:7.e (.29%). 2. C�1'l.?1�C5 .in .tousin; Stock a:�d V<�c�,-�cies Sznce 1.96G Censc.s .'�'nfo�-natl,0i.1 ��it.Cit�i.CC� IrT'0.11 L[1C' De�u;-tmeni: Oi ��11it5� �1<^.����UUI1tIS cZ11C� �UiiiiC Bui�din�;s of the City oL- S<<�_nt P�:ul, indzcates a trend bc,t�a�en 195G a:,u 1960 �T'Oiil �11C C�CJC'lO��iile:lt= fl� .�ii:l�lt? fa�n;ily S�I"1.iCtU7:('.S t0 Li1C? Ci(?t�C�_O��1t.Lli. Oi £ipartmen� uti'llC�.Ui"(_'S. 2ili tOLc:� IlU'�Il�JCi: OIC. C1G7�:1�.J_i1�� ilI11tS COili(:il1Ci_CCi. r An:�uall.y �•�ithin S�iinL- Paui shows an ann��al fluct��,�t:ion be����ec�i �9u0 and 19b�i wi.�:lio�it u subst.<:nti�.l I.rend to�aard ii�cr.ease o� :decrezse i_n. ci;a:�,lli.;�� Ui1;.i:S COIISi:illCted� �,5 Si1C�v11 lii �[10 �,:U�.£ �C10i�: An�;:1:�c�;� lo t,oJSlr�;c, sic�:�x: �i!'17 CO�1,rii.:llCi.:i.C�.1 �t.Uti�.1C 111C� i);'1.V<'��C} Ai2C� COi1VCS';>1Gi1. i�''t�7 Di,'1;LLING U�;T'i; Ti�; �Aa.,�i' P.`,UL I?�:C��� 19,0 '+"',i�;C�P � 1�" _..._. .._._�__ _._..�_.___._�__.______�________. _..�_...'�'�_�'�r? �[1C'^iiilill� nU�1C:: n.'.�:'..�'i-ii1C'.il.l.:`iiit3.!.Cii.i'���� � i ._ _ �_. .__._ _ c��,1 1Cc2i" �.iSJG117.1_�,I�'S L':�'�:].�;ii^,S �L7"L;C`l:Ul"L?'; Ui77.L^ _Ulil'i:.`',�_ 1950 400 �r1 ���7 "GC�-'o- l,U<;;, 19�1 3�F�'� 21 5� 1,0�C; , , � j_ �r1� ]_Jo? 5��0 ��S iS 1,7_9� 1 ,�.�_, 1�63 �3�,� 15 Fs� l, i�;'�� ?, >G_; i�;,,�, 3t4 S9 J.i_; 2, ?u� �; =,-:�, ��.175 �SJ �I-� �=: i�i�� �. „ �,� , _ � , � � �i"v �U_i :,l 1� i�'i. 7�'; ,- � ., � � 11i. '.L, : _, ;(�: i,l �'r�!�� J S�`� ' ,_� �1:._ �-LiC:__.e �Ul. ii;�.,.`�:S 1� i�U1�i:�C. �c)ll::i7.i1„ l�i"O�i��'LS . C)Zii ;i:i. . , ._i.. i)i°!i, C;..<.i '��): . _. .. .. ~, �.. , , � .( " r io-� cicicx�7.y ana ?73 t;l��,t; f_o.- n�;i-��cicic��ly. r� SCIIt�CC: ���i",t�iU--.1. .. '�)O:�i.S OA �ilC i I;i- . ,.1I O.i. i'll�)i.�t' :�lf.".iCi �.;]', : 9 r)t�: . .�i.11;i�: . � �. ... � . ,.,� . -. ri • _ � , 7 iv�•.C�'l'iii,l[�_. .:ici L'1.b1.iC r.S11��i_1 ��� ��� �u., i��..�11� :ii. ��1,. _„..... . . - G.:> ^ , + 2. Chaz��;es in I�ousin� Stock ancl Vacancies Sa.ncc 19b0 Ce;�sus coi�tinued � fiousing units have been reraoved from the housLng supply a.n Saint Pau]. to a � L subst:antially lesser extent than the arnounts added annually. Infor��atict� in thi, rc:�;ar.d is re.Cl.ected t�y thr., Zpr�J,i,car��;i;� f��- 4ha cicmolS.t:a.or� o.�'.- structures reccived by the Par�:s, Pl;�y�;rounds and Public 23uzldin�s Depart- ment o� Lhe City, as shoc•m Leiow: SUBTt`�AC17C�S i ROi1 HOUSIi�G STO„K Demolitio;� or units talceii out- of housit�, u��e: � One-family Duplex P.oamin�Houses APari:meni- Bid Ls� Year Tlcaelli�igs DSJCZLl.il`?s �;�r�zctutes U��i_ts St-ruct��res Units Tot�l UnzLs 19u0 24�0 G6 7 75 54 549 996 1951 122 44 5 3G ??_ 1.b3 �;09 1962 � 2b1 103 0 0 Sb 274 7�;1 1963 199 61 0 0 41 231 55? 1964 ?_1S 112 1 8 76 S?_2 969 19G5 2b� 81 3 29 62 SOF 964 19GG 152 � ` 32 2 21_ 37 304 �541 TGiALS: 1�45�. 499 18 169 348 2,551 5, 172 SQURCE: AivP1U�'�i, RLPOi:1S OF T:iL 13U�:�.AU 0� PUT3LiC i,U�_zllSriGS, DF�iA�7.�Il:i;: OF i.��1PKS A�?ll RECREATIOid A�ID I'UBLIC I3UII.DIitiGS, SAli1'i PAUL, :i:LNNi:SGT�1 � Cur�.eT1t V�.cancr D::,.a A vacancy su-rvey in the i�Iir.nea2ol�s-S�,xnt Pau.l S�iSA h<�s been cond;�cted h� t�.e U.S. �GSt C/Lf:i.CE.' 1%Ct�21�:i11Cilt C1UY111� x'C'CC'�1� ��r?a;i"S� �U1SLic.i1� tG a:11 �ZLi'E'TC::lt: JC"l:�iCLIl i�i.r: �1I1C� pO:ital atltil02'li:lC;. I'CtC T�lO�C XCCCI?� SLIYVC� �4Ei5 COilliUi.tC'Ci 011 �OV�iii�JCY 1.� — ��� L9JUJ 111 t'f17.i c.lc^.c^�. 1f1E YC'_Sult:�.ill Vc:C�1i1C�7 Ci�.r"ii 1S i10i: Ci11GC�i.y CO'�li):�'L'i:i�'LC' i•ll�i1 i..lOSc OL t'.^.e 1900 C�nsu.u, becausc o:: d ' " ' ' ' , �_ ` ' 7.�.ieY(_'ilCC; i:i GC'i1R:L°�:1.011� i�Y�^_� CiCil:li',':�iC!:� :1C� iii�i'i70i:;� Oi e��n,:c�L�t�o;�. �iG;t'CVl'.i y t�1Cy �,Li' �1('�GiiZC'.� c.:; u 7.'�'i150:�:ti�1.�T :.CClli�`:i:'.'. 7.�1C�;_C'<1L2Oi1 C�. the })l'(Si�ili. V�4C:tI:CJ i].Lil�;i:lOil. "�� . �' ,1. ';,.!'.`i �, .r. i. �.f,��, ._ I l,� ' �7( � 7 7� l t.' . 1'`1 ' � r' ,._ � � , , , . . ., ,. 1�7i:«l. t'iti�C_'11l`_ .Oi..�. IC:'f.;.1Cit 1'C;i...i �.' :'i.�'i"i�. n^ .. ,_ , . 1 . , � . � . �', _ l` � ��:., �,.C. i,�. t�_l 1 � ' 11 ,;', �1� ' C ,�� i .; i��� .��].I7� I�u l i i l�b y��i i l . l . �> �)J y l.i'J -C). �.� �'����i li � �i . � 7. , ;��,;,�sey Co,,:�ty 'i�s,,7Ci) 7. . ', �4,25C 1 .0 �'�� ,�; ;v �'. . " 7�) ^ . � It has been indi.cuted by I'3:A tl�at in order to co;�form �he poseal vacancy survuy TCSUIC5 t0 CEIISUS COriCCj�L'S }Jy tC'lILIZE?� 1 IOWCY7.I��; Of L'i1C "residence" Ai1C� "apar�ment" vacancy 1_evels occurso 7'}tey have also c�llcul..tcd L-h1t approximately'onc-tl:ird of the vacant units avzi.l.a�le for rent may be c7_assi.fied as substandard. FHA indicated, ho�-Tevcr, lhat there has becn a tr.cnd tow3rd incxcasinb vacancics in the apartment m<^.r.ceC. � ;�� ... � t � �� I ' �, EIUn`F.0 OF�Tt t�_C�_ra�UC, • , � ` �:���.r.��/ / r .;_,. �--� , ���s o� WAS}1I NGT'ON.D.C. 202.39 r ��/ /(/ Y'� � July 7, 19u7 . ' N,r�. Edward N. Helfeld }�ousing and Redevelopinent Au-Lhority of the City oF St. Paul, 24�_ruieso-t�i L,?l. ��ir�bash�� Stree:t St;, Pau1� �iru�esota 55102 � Dear i�fr. He1.feld: Ttiis is in reply �;o your lei;ter of �une ?_?_ reques�,ing ��-ie la�est avail�ble data on farnily inccme for St. Pau1, Minnesota or t:�e Minneapolis-St. Pau1, Min.nesota S;;SA, We regret that the data sho4m in the Cur.r.eni; Po�ul�.ti.on R�narts "lncome in 196/f of Families and UT�elated Individuals by �etropolitun-iJo:unetropolitan Residence" were not tab�zlate�l for tl-ie MinneapoJ_i_s-St. Pau]_, Minneso�a 5:;�.�. � The size of 'che Current Popula.tion Sur�vey sa;aple is n�t lt�r�e enough to provide suf�icient accuracy for the I�iinneapolis•-St. Puu1, i:irinesota S:�k;A. . � In response to your request for a reasonable estink�.-ce for fari3ily ancome at th� third decil.o, we have doveloped �.n estin.a.tion proced�_z:ce f.or your consideration. Tho es�im�.to sho�,i:z in tne encloued wor�csnee-� .Zas beer_ prepared solely to asais� you in yo-ar work and should no�t be conside.rod � as an of£aci.�], e:�-t�mat� o� ��e Duro��u o�' vho Census. Sincere]_y yours, ' � � ' ;� . ,� �•� " , l �l;��f,x:;c��l (_l�_ � Hexm�a.n P. ,'•ii�1e-r Chiof 9 yopulrz-�ion �ivisio.. . � Bwceau o� th�; ,C en�u:� Encioauros 1°;�_f ,�� � • C- ��, / . ,� �'��,�;-•�.,ft,a y� ; 9 J�a�,.> � ; . ���;,� ;`t'i''�c'',,� <� _ � � . --I y�� ��`°`�`�'�:{�;1 ''.'�ti ' o � � 7 �::; , S- �si,,� " 961 .� � ; ,q�l� � ,��d ,�,� ` . ! s<�����o�/�J �'✓ ,�� j '4 �;,;, �n ' � ! tv . � . � � , r . �• X � �i..J�ll'1i�1����1'l ��Z�li1�I�t.pil.�i �'aZ �L�I��JZU l�Cl� l. `1'}urty (�0) �percent or tn� 3G1�,1.2�j �am:ilies in the i�iinneapo]_a.s-St. I'aul, l•;itliiesota St�iSlt equa.ls 109,?_3�3 ]'�ra�_li�s, • � � 2.� To detez�n�.ine the ii:cor;�e l.:imi.t oi' the third decile, cwt,tilate the rnal;�ber or r3�nilie� in e<�ch incotne �;roul�. Thc third decil,e is located �n the n:;�5,G0U to 4�5,999" :incon�c i���Lerva7.. ,. 3. S�;lit of inco���e il�terval.--- �';�,�?1�9 of the 109,23E3 f����ilies fal.]. be]_o�r� , :;;5,p0u. Therefore 109,2�F� i�i.nus �,9��1,9 ec;ual:� 19�3��9 iami.li.cs needed from the 1;9,394 familie� locat�Cl 1T1 the �i�5,��� �Q v�5�999 �z�oup, Inter- pc�l.atc th� income l:uu�.t as io17_o�-rs; � . Income . Split o� Percen� 1��Tidi;h of income Loti•rer ?ncon�e ir,i,erval lI1CO;IlC C�1SS interva.l_ l�ln_i.t limit interva.7. - r ! �5,000 to �5,999 �-9 �9 � _ (•39�54) ( y1,000� � ���OGO �7,393 . �+939� � . l�. Th� income 1.ima.ts at tha th�rcl decile for the A;orth Ceni;ra.1 ltie�;ion ox � the United StaLe� �rere y5,196 in 1.965 �u�d �3�G5 �n 1959, 131 prrcen� , increase. Assur,tin� th� same percent increase, mul�ij)_y the 1�=L perce�zt by �5,393 equals f�7,1C0 estirnate�family xncome in 19ti5 ior i�finneaPoli.;- St. Faul, 2�iinneso�;a Si�iSt1. „ . , . � ' . . ' • i < . �- � � ' , � Sub�o�t to Nrnitai+Gris in 1o;�cr ul -__._--.-------____�___ .��_^_�._.____ - __.__.._.__._...__--•------•---._�.__�___— — -,.__ ---- _ ----- -- � �5our.��: 3�ireau o7 (ho Gensu�. i Numbc: • Cumulative • zncome • °oaa�cr,,c�,c or ca�nmc� Total money income • o f T�umber was�,�,nL'�m"s�r; •zoz.3: Families of 7n�erval Snlit Limit � ' Farnilies , ' � All f��;n�_lies. . . . . . . ' 36��,1?7 • � Under :�1,Op�. . . . . . . . . . < . . • ) 7,473 . 7,�73 " ; �1,000 to y1,99�. . . . . . . . . ��°� . �2 00o to ;2 � ' � + 9l • , 2o,z7o • > >�,�. . . . . . . . . � �-<,59�3 • (I 36,�sE>�• y3�Onn t.Cl ����)��� � � � i � a • � � � 4�,q�.�� ' 1 jf;�7���� , , 'n��,�1t)U to ��,9��. . . . . . . . . � 31��p j � � �,�, �O '�r � ��� 9 • ��,or,o t� n5 t 9?9. .(tr`:,?:3;s)� lk9�'�� • 1 z+ . ���'3��..�_�39251�•` . � 39, � 3 -- �= �5►393 ' 3ofloo�'- .60,�;.��i �b,�0o to >b,9�9. . . . . . . . . • 5��9�31 � 190,221�' . �7,oG� to �'l,999. . . a . . . . . . 43�705 ' 233�`�29 ' :wf�,000 to bd,`�99. . . . . . . . . • � 33�7�1' 2E79 6�0' � :vI,C00 to •a���I99. .. . .. . . . . 21i,1�1' 2�2,111 � � I .�7.�,00o to b�_4,999. . . . . . . • t�9��96 ' 342 U07 • � � h��7��V t� 41�`i'7 7�9• •• • • • • � 1Jfr(Jl• ' �� i � l 357,7��3 ' � I �25s000 and over. .. . . . . . . • 6,3�9 ' 36��,127• ' j I� Nedian incorne. . . . . . . . o . . . . t $6,£3�0 .. . . ! � ` � � � ; ; . _ � ; Ratic� of ir,come. limit at third decile based an Currer�t Po�,ulation Suz•veys for i:ne North Central Region. ' ' • Year . Income Limit ' Perc�nt Increase • .. . 1�F,� ' r'��t 19< � = 137. • 1959 �3,965�.._. �; �- ��5�393� ��-3z. Pe�•cent) _ �7,100� es-�imaue,i family incc�r,c in 1>65• ior �arnilies at tnc: ' third decilc (30�) .for iiinneUpoi.is_St. Y��ul� Minneso:�a S;�SA. . � SQUN.Cr�: . ;' ° 1 �0 Vol I C ' � U �� C��nsus ol �u1ai.:z.or���• . , harac�c��.sti_cs of thc� Po;��_z1.�±��.o:�, • Purt 25, ��irineso�v, table 'Jb, and Series :.��9 r�os. 35�a;�d �l Y C�.�rr�,n�� �_ � Po�,t?ation Ker�or i�,s. �___,.._ . � • , � , ` a i;,��lJ � ::i,i i�5 l i i':. s.d_: .,,''i. � ° i �'.!ti ..4.` i 1�.�_? E !i Zi!�E e ! ��� s i i l r �.�� 1 i ���� �.l��i ��'; i I ��`��� �� ���i l !`i {� �.�7 L 1 � i� � t_ �q f.J fr�sd {' ._��� _t��1� i ,�� ��� 1�;i� c pl±�iz 9f'= f1 , � r� ll��i t iti � j... i ��f._ 41�.1..1��1.'.l. . .J�'�. ..:...? . L�����i� �au�1.::.+�L !�y �J�4i' t � �^�, / } � y / ���. � �`I1�{�1'l.'' I11i�6e.�F.��J: c.?b. t�'��:..:.�,r,+'i.�ii �".'c� �«k•a '\'� S�' sk..(�rr- r !-t`� ti:�P� �L��T�� �'! �'t;i..,;: I.l't-t..� �c��;: ,. �.; _ y1. i3 .t.. .., ��t1:1?d_.:s �`•��:���i�'�`:'� �!� ��E.=::w;:3',i5'1' �i�il�il.�:;v { E'.. �,. ° 4�7 ,,.,_. i Ft'-,� . .._:. �'. e .L n.o.,� . •. e 7.;.: �.Jt3LE7_�.v c�l�ti x�c: {^VC-'.�.t.�i;��^w£?e. t'.,?I.t.xit:°Z'�.a.y u �'+''e"C.':�'�t:a:: i.i.?CG.Si.:;S: �I.''.'....i:�; 1ic:i� i:iEi��i;"(:e`�'t;:i�i i}y( . ,. . , . ^.� C ��� ^3'tiu)_T't�� S,':.Z.:���'4:`.F+ �a�I��i"t`1i:Sf'1�.+.1`�1C�'i� Ci:,'. l�i;`rL'.�1; �.a Ztitle� F:':��3:1.� h � _�El .4 = o l.i, .L �z�.5.:•).6.':�.:�'.k...� 4 A. „ ? t l�. q ... ......�� . t . e i t iTitC'c�'.`. ..�.' 14. . . �J.pl:i3 ''�.�'i::�,t<.S ilii!: 1,.1i��.�tii:: 1'.i,..t.�.r`i i L��.d f;.f:t:-�li�l.tG-'' fl�.:F:tJ �a�..31!lwt� �i::�c�'�t p1I��.3_C,'. tiC'•'.1SJ1.IY:�3 ��AZ(�q �„jz� L'7_?'Ca.:!4 fJ� ""�'i�' r � ♦ ��qz�Jv` ♦ �a* r t 'y- t+� y 4 i.� Y.e�-d�.Z� � �.S.C: �.5:� l,.% r�ix<.�Ti�.} �<.)L a�.L.11a1 l.�:y L�L:ti, ri�bn.Z�J� .�,a�ie��rd ��`�'�G.'�:.;�'�� !i'a.lili3,i;��.i 3.S�1 rP'L��. �5L°�`c�, �f'- 1:��!�L�C;�,.• �11 c^E"t.'1.)'l'>1�.: G►1� �c'�r.a.�n.�' 71.?'t,^C:A;" Y�°:;L?3,';.�..�q:;2�:::) �."4'"�f.:,a.; �i'1,•'.f,, t;:i�:': GL�r��Y."t:�'i:� j.liC'J�>x-:�'• ].T_Tst1�; r 7 `^ 3 f:H ,�� �. a �l'.e.� ta� t � f.:�i1 ��1 �o�!G�19'..!(9 .L��ii7...7. .,�s 1?.�'LP7i. 3�: ,.`S�.�i [nt.l- 3.s.a:,a�%��f�-'7i. LfJ �J`dlD4l�.��'.. P`.� �`,.�3l�fye 1,••�jty�... Fii�l:�`ili��.`n `w��..st�%9e:L`�t C"� �,3.�"���cf 1 t;i;�.ii:f.� Z._ a.,�:�.�",r�1'�'��{ �!.`PIf: 'c."1'c., a.�ui.. f ,�. . :, 4_ . ' �' � _ ,. a . } . ^i.� �it� �f �;�c'e�ie.>��. �1C�Li i�l±e* S'Ii.i:�`It.?'� ��dwf'. I..��t'?.'; Gi �`:.1�".:it`:.' � ?i�S1�.�.�!i i?i'..r t,�i�C.?laf.'t`xJ �I1'1.".3'��v=3.Tiu1 1 t " � , . . ll A� L�..i�::i�4.�..�::;iYs ��:t�.^ �i'i�C?��.!t'1 ].::i �r?:'t`iVLC:Y.?�.iyi"�, C Y"�.�1.l.°;=e�. i+�JY' �.c Z'�•'..'. l:'?:t i.�.7_£:. �•�.,,�i).�n ti:�[�.1�"' _�� � t :;Y c; i .a �.y:. �, a "�..�'f.1."U_)' �1:' .�.w:Y'�€?�: 12�i.�'L'�. � C�:Z.�J"'�Jj1C1.: 5's:�4'C;j" Oi �.7.f'�(`(� iC`@AI�w'�?1. Ifl131.�'s' �Zi�r �7f',x'1�:?!.�C� t.S'.E? S(?'�°C?�!a ��'tu"�i:£'.��� bl �tiic:r+y J'�Cii'::a �:?.tg i3.Si'� �E.'�l.7�C3:3i1 r?:�E.fi�ti:1. �N�Cc^:). tifi:l��::: i:.� 1°c.:'t�L'�iC3::'>:�r@ 2�?1w:;. . Z,;aY`2��' �.^.;�?7.�7.f::i i:£10 I::.I:a�: I�J+li� f�t'+;:9 �illtill.!_t� �<::4',::37.I1� �.`�L:.;1FdSE: f.1� �.';2,^'.Z'C..:�i':1 1,EEt.:a`;:ai�:".' COi:" �7..T"i:::y �(,l L�J.`4TG t'l���iCtl��'�' iCi�9'i.:."",11s:3_ta'.•. i1•1�.C(Ll'c'�..�:ra 1.�'�,":J_P,cn �2'�:T.t::.. .^,G2"_3::� �7.X1 i.._..'.� #a$ ..s s�.,• - .i .� �:;• ri;:.'it.�ii. ;:J'tf:J�l€:I� �:'t:L !`G4C>v�,ih.�.t�tl �t'L"C:��!C:�:1� �JJ:,::�: ��� �:i:t; liJilGC)lii LCt:l'�„�'� c;`....'? �LI.;::�li.i,� , . . Tsr�lvrr bi�y �ra�c�i�> illu�r.x���e the u �.- ^y , .'_;; c��_�t , 9 ;�W L 1.°,^c- .x72 �f __.�?� t�f f 1 1 �;a::'t ai��� �l41:'�� 3:Lt"e11.L1C'i, 7.t1 t;.ilc„3t: i>3°'c:e?:� �:2.�� �.1`1�Y.C.'1f::5 e`'.�]�: tiGI.,^*.y.La �i7?' L�7:>::= 3.�.t>::�.�:t?C'S 3:C:::;L��.3Y"Y'�`:,:, (Sca� �:s`z,t�i.� 11:I a�t;���e�ed) rS3G4Y��.0 �1.T.i1�3 i��9'X c�,`.iYTilli�fi:l�I� uilt� rE'�A3�S jYltl>� i�� �i0 iSad.�?�.7.413G'CI Z:�'i3t E: �;3� Q�; A� le�.� ?�l� goi.21 3ue le£#� t��tc-�r:.r �.Ff� ��p��:�cd �-e;7R_,.���. lir�irU f_c:.r .��r�irsic��� �-.n� �}i.� �ae���z,� xf:''s,�i e"..i: 13:23.�i1 j�TiVc'�.`ic: ta;de.3;'�f�t':;c.?' Li1!:<.�Cs�� �iJ �'i7.i�ii:�.0 r.�°':Y�,?�>1�,jT� j.S ��'L'!'U'3..C:�.11:i ����.i'tirL°s�i`3 7>^€r G"ia�X'L�r�ti01? �Y:C� C'.;.Y.�>+`_;.T.'V f?�:rt'�L:t!�"�^�8 r'], 5;'�?r,�'?.*.�'1-4�. �!Sj1n1;� Or Ci�?;C.s?i)f'y ,S�'?;F!:' ..�,. ..___.�..._-�... -��.. �r� s�,�it-�r;� �je�u�za�.�. IC�:� otclP.x i«�r tt:ere �o tae z:: t's��:�yt:�z�,�•:.�t et�Fp�,Z� ' �� v�;..,,.;��� 111:17.�'`.B L�'Jc21.j.r"'I3�..°'.. Fi�: � �'2.1+;t�! 1F`I?Y" l,n�'t'.�.y 5i.1C,�1 L'S �'.1:�>}�i� Tt?iSat bP 1.I1 E�1:�:E.':'S OL $;�ii"xe_ r�c�A.ziS'f•C� i�Y' I.flT.'7:��:I turil:l�*'u'�`. �Cs£' �t���i�� �.SlErL.iY'e�S t�1.3� ;.�r;^l•'[�i1�.` F7'1.di>7,1� �E'irJ't.tSi,Xt� ],S I'ifD� 1?'1 �,r.'ii;?.�r^..�l�lt►'�i T31.p.r,t �:'2Vuk.i; �z�.;:�`�,'F::'i�c.. T_t i.� b�ch a s�:,��e �n� �rrd�*'a]. xt.qa�i�-e,�:�.i�:. Th� �.z,Us�#.n� ��ixd Re;�;r�e:1.e�.::��=�t; �:c� o�' �Tint:;;;°�i:�. .�,>:�i£i.e� �3:�.t ie.�F-r�;4.�` j)L1��.1i:: �'liYi";i7�.1'3d� ::Ll..^•.1� �?<. 'r3��.11'�i::�7�L° C''��.V �:�.7 1c'$«���.d.(:::� i�2 Y:�Zf_' �.:i5?:'_Su"� G�i �.i::1:'°�'1� �.Tc!'(,�",'•s �t:i:?Lii3 ixt �:�°« �c►c-:�:1i�y iz� �;:�zch ti:a l�.c�v.��.�:� is laca�,�:ci. g�.�.7.ue:�:� i� tk:e 1��: i� �, �src��*i.;°ic�c� ►�:�'l�;,i. Q;�"ti: ..C.L3t� �.Gr::;^..5::7.C;�1C.i. G� �101'3.�-.°1.Tt? Y.�Ew'!� ?,`'.•'+�t.l: c"�. 4�.���;.G'W:312f't*i�1L�S3 �il�� c: }1�.�,�"E.'� �9:;1' . C'�t-''X:e:c'�i.?+c'. Zx'JE'.1 Tai.£?y �)t. E.'uic�3�7.£',iis'�a'�i ... .�C..'"� C��'�:<:33� �lY YX�:::.",'�..'i:d:L'n9. ��'�E', 1K3��,` 9tiC:C1 �uua����� �I��� ��i��i�v°r�i.Ul'i��}�:� i � �'�i.+T��U�fTY (� �= -I�� E CI�C�Y OF SAINT PAUL, Ml � id �SQI��A 0 . REPOR!' TO T':E CU�iISSZONERS - 2 - August 29, 1968 determination made by the Co.*nmissioner, set the avnilability limi.t at 30 percent. Attached is an illustration showing the estimation procedure used to determine the maximum ir.come allowed un�er the restriction. (Exhibit IV.) Z'he statute's failure to provide for consideration of fama.ly-size in applying the 30 percentile restriction, has deprived many needy families of decent housing withii� their means. Strict adherence to this provisi.on has created an obstacle to the esta.blishment of incoz►e limi.ts which realistically reflect the financial requirements of large far►ilies. I�. Pursuant to the provisions af the statute, the A�.ithority submitted a request to the State Director ot' Housing and Conununity Development, on April 5, 1968, asking that a he�ring be held to review the restriction on availability and proposing a xule which would modify the restriction iF found to be justified. . The proposecl rule modification provides a more realistic means of establishino income limits for the larger farnilies in the community who face the greatest difficulty in obtaining adequate housing. A hearing was held on July 30; 1968 (Exhibit V.) . The Authority has si.nce been advised that a favorable decision h�s been mr�de regarding the proposed rule modifi- cation and that �ae �•:ill subsequently receive formal notification of its approval. III. Procedures for Establishin P_ roposed Income I,imits The following is a sur,�;nary of the pracedures applied in determining the aMOUnts shown in the attached Inco:ne Limits Analysis (Exhibit Vz.) . 1 . The incomes shocan in column one of the Analysis were derived by determining � the amount of incone requir�d to pay the maximum rents allowed in public hnusing as established by the 20% gap requir2ment. The amounts are derived by applying the rent-income ratio used in the Authority's rent schedule to th� rent charged far the largest unit that might be occupied by each siz� famity. 2. The iricomes shown in column t:ao are based on the Bureau of Labor Statistics publi.cation: City Worker's Fa�ily Bud�et f.or a M oderate Srandard of Livi.eg. The figures have been adjusted for family size according to the BLS �ui3e for these computations. Data is for the Min;�eapolis-Sair.t Pau1 MeLropolitan Area. 3. The incomes shown in column thre� reflect a do�lTn�aard adjustr:ipnt of 20% rrom the '4noc�erate" budaet fi�ures, lowering the livzng standard to a "r�odest-but•- adecuate" Level ro provide Gppropriate criteria for establishing income limits. HOUSIN� A!�'� ��[:��`�.�.(3�"�v,�.:.=C����� ��i1����C�ITYOF THE GI�TY OF SAIi�T P(�UL, MIN1� cSOTA . REPORT TO THE CCI�iMISSIONERS - 3 - August 29, 1968 4. The proposed inccr.ie limits for admission, in column four, are set beLow the maximurn establ�.shed by the 20% gap requirement. Ho�Never, they are set at a level that more realistically reflects the inco:ne requirements indicated by the '4nodest-but-adequate" budget calculations. The limi.ts are set to cornply with the formula established under the rule change applied in determining the amounts of inco�*�e i.n excess of ihe 3Q% � limitation that will be allowed for famiLies of six ot- more persons. Incomc� Limits for adrziission cannat exceed an amount equal to the maximum ($7,200) as estnblished by the 30% deters, ination, plus $200 £or each additional minor family mernber noL- including spouse. For continu�d occupancy, an amount of $275 per additional ninor is appLied. 5. 1he limits £or continue3 occupancy represent level� at which families re- entering the private housing marke� should begin to find adequate housing at reasonable cost, although these figures are still somewhat belo�a the amounts suggested by the budget analysis. IV. Conclusion The 30% availability requirement will be met under those income lim�ts proposecl for admission and continued occupancy for one through five persc�n famiLies, �nd for admission of six person families. The proposed limita applicable to six perso�ls for continued occupancy and alI Iarge.r families comply with the limitations prescribed under the rule change. It has also been demonstrated that the proposed limits comply with the 20% gap requirement. Therefore, the staff recommends that the Authority's Zcicome Limits for Admission and Continued Occugancy be revised as shown on the attached schedule, subject te concurrence by th� Housin� Assistance Administration. At tachrient s . _� I. 20% GAP DF"�.iRAfINATZON Number of Persons iu F�a�ily 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 or �ar� Si.ze of Unit Required 0-BP. 1-BIi 2-BR 3-BI� �i-BR 5-BR 1. I.owest Private Gross $89.00 $99.5(D $139.00 $168.00 $199.00 $211.0� Rent ar I,owest Grosa Housing at which private enterprise, unaided by public sub�s,�.dy, is providing �.:�substanti�l supply of decent, sa£e anii sanitary hou�ing 2. Maximum rents per�iCted$71.20 $79.60 $111.2Q $134.40 $I59.20 $168.f�Q in public hausing in ord@r to maintaiti a 20"/0 gap. (R�nts in Zfne r�l'� abov� less 20yo) 3. Highc�st grass ren�a $6]..OQ $79.00 $111.00 $134.00 $159.00 $168.U0 ta be charged for admissiox� to public housing. � 4. Percent�ge of �ctual 20.23� 2U.617o 2Q.15% 20.24% 20.11�1a 20.3��1a � g�p bet��een ��1�� �nd n3��. above. S. Hishest Permissable $3,762 $�+,1.78 $6,042 $7,438 $9,008 $9,6U( Income Limits mee�itig Gap �tequirement3 (Per rent sch�dul�) 6. Prop�sed Maxir�um $3,200 $4,lOQ $6,000 $7,�a40 $8,E�0 $9,1�J� Admiasion Liuzits (Displaced Persons} II. NSL'�iXIi�1U:�t INC0�1E LIMITS FO�t ADiiZ�SIOi� At�Fi CO�I'TINUEA OCCUPAPiCY INITiA:L OCC1J�At1CY I,Ig�ITS CONTINiJE13 C�CCUI'ANCY LTI�I�"S EXCEYT DI3PL..ACED DIS�LA���1' FAMILX SIZE gy pUBLIC A�T[IOV BY pUBLIC AC1'I0:1 Pre��n� Pr°po�ed Pre��nt Pro�o�ed Present Pro�osvd One Person $2,80fl $2,$00 $�,200 $3,200 $3,2tJ0 $3,200 Ttao Perso�ts 3,260 3,600 4,00� 4,100 4,OQ� G,6�J0 Three Persons 4,�0� 5,4Ca 4,800 5,900 4,&00 6,O011 Foi�r Persan� 4,800 5,600 5,�e00 6,Ot30 5,400 6,600 Five P�:ramns 5,2(�0 6,200 S,bOfl 7,2Q0 6,000 7,200 Sz� Per�or�s SaG{�U 6�$Q(3 5�8CJ 7�400 6�200 7�8flt3 S�vcn Per�on� 5,60J 7,Ie00 5,��b0 8,G�a� 6,4�3� �,Q�J Ei�ri� PLreo:�� 5,�:3fl� :�,O��u 6,OU�i 8,6p4 6,60t? 8,6l�0 1�'it:t Fer�;o�ta 5,€�4 8,6n0 6,��i� �,li�a� 6,�(30 9,lfl�J Ten. or mar� 5,£CC� 8,F3�0 5,0�� y;3Ut� 6,64a 9,30{3 Yexsoi�� �