242919 . . . x._.:_...» �.,, .., ..... .� _..2. .: �. ....._.. .�;. _. ..;. ... . .a.... . ... . . _... ;,�.��e;;:;�a--,r.�-t . w.k
. ...,. .� . . .. .. . ,.. _ ,
� • � .. � , . . � � . � . ' � � .. °
� , " ; , COUNCIL FILE NO_ G�9
FINAL ORDER _
B�
� File No. �
«
�.
k . . � . . - � . . � .�J
` In the Matter of �"a�lt�l+�er1� tin �i+iiwlatile it '�ltlit sl�iY Iu�' w� i'�a.: l�wr ;
:�
� �
� �: _�. !o� t11�st ts. �t irjr i� � �r w�a�R �if� #� � a� ��t�s�
� fi
� � ��iM� � ��Y . � � . � " !�
� . . . � . � 'ri
t. . . . ' . � ' . ... .. .�,'�
� ' . . � ' . . . . . .. . � �°,t
�V � . . .. � � . � . . � ..�
✓ .�
�
F
�ii . . � . . . . ;:�
`' � . � � � . . . � � . . ' .�
' . . . . . - . . . � � �;�
under Preliminary Order �� aAprov�rd �7 �• �� '
g ;
� Intermediary Order approve� �
�; A public hearing having been had upon the above improvement upon c�ue notice, and the Council `_'
�. having heard all persona, objections and recommendationa relative thereto, an.d having fully considered �
�:.. the same; therefare, be it ' `�
RESOLVED, B� the Council of the City of St. Paul that t�e precise na.ture, extent and kind c�f im- ,�
- provement to be made by the said City is �
!rr s��M�tt ttie ��1'k a! �ti► ri�iM� � !� �s. !`s+�t �t �t. #e� lli�lt _�
a
ft. iii � i/� #�� � il/� � #t �►>i� l�E��M1�� 1?� M��! #�#+i "`�
r _ - - ,��
� �!�• ��It �!�'�t ,M� � M�� Mli�'M �� w� ���. �
�; ,�
�
�
�';t
and the Counail hereby orders sa,id improvement to be made.
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the Commissioner of Public Works be and is hereby instructed and �
directed to prepare plans and specifications for said improv�ement, and submit same to the Council for
:approval; that upon said approval, the proper city officials are hereby authorized and directec�to pro-
ceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therewith.
coUrrci�EN APR ]� 1969
Yeas Nays Adopted by the Counci�
� Carlson APR � 19fi9
Dal�g{� , ApProvec�
Petet'�pn �
TPrafka T„ Favor •
�� � ayor
By� Against PUBUStiE� A � 1�
s-ee.ai[ �� B.i
�—
. Dist. No. 2
B.S. Goodrich Ave. - Pascal St. to Albert St. ���/� �
„����
, �Q����� �gJC FFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PUBLIC WOR�4291,
�ti �, ��, 9
� `
� �Fc�, �on9 ;�.
} ',`t REPpRT TO COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
� d�,���F� °';t
�;�r,� p� , .
,;;i
�,a �'.� •...,i
ti,c�'� _. �t�?;,.:.,
,,�/;�f�'�., . �-
Feb. 17th. 19 69
To the Commissioner of Finance of the City of St, Paul;
The Commissioner of Public Works, having had under consideration the preliminary order
of the Council known as Council File No. 242134 approved Feb. llth. 1969
rel�tive tm reconstructing the sidewalk on both sides of Goodrich Ave. from Paacal St.
to Albert St. and by doing all other work which is necessary and incidental to com-
plete said improvement.
and haviag inve�tigated the matters and things referred to therein, herebq reportse
le The estimated cvst thereof is $3050 per lins ft, for standard sfdewalk �
wicie and $4e20 per lina ft, for standard sidewalk 6 ft� widee �;�
,���;'�:z/
2a A pls�y profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached and made
��
part thereofo
3o Initiated by the Commissioner of Public Works X
4o Improvement is asked for upon petition
�missioaer of Publ c Works
� •r.a,.,y,�'. , . .. . . ��„t+Mt �F,�1��> A"4 . . . . .. .. �.v.w�N-+��, .r��•r�Kr .rfy,.; s� ..iq .��it5<r��MIFA'+A►��
� .. . ' .. .. . � �R. � d:��' 01.
. . ♦ ' , . . � . K . .� o� f `N;.
4 j , . . . ,. . �'.{'*'� :f.
__ 24,�� ���
919
March 20, 1969
To the Council of the city of St. Paul, Minnesota:
We, the undersigned, home owners on both sides of Goodric}i Avenue from Pascal �
Street to Albert Street zequest the Council of the city of St. Paul not to
ap�nrove Preliminary Ox'd�r 242134. We feel Preliminary Order 242134, which
proposes to reconstruct the sidewalk on both sides of Goodrich Avenue from `
Pascal Street to Albert Street and doing all of the work which is necessary �
and incidental to complete said improvement, except where it is determined �
that good and suf£icient poured sidewalks exist should'' ,be rejected for the
� �
following reasons;
\
1. Existing gidewalks are adequate for the nonnal and intended� �
use. - ; ' 6�
�, .
.,. . . . ` . ; , ,F.- � . � �' .
2. The expenses involved would be far �Cn excess oF benefits derived '�
£rom the proposed new sidewalks. . ; �
,
3. In view of�'�the condition of the existing sidewalks on Goodri.ch
Avenue between Pascal Street and Albert Str�et, these improvementa
can be% betCer made . in other areas of tt�e city of St. Paul. .:,
:,
In view of the above reasons, the undersign�ed property..:owners ,again urge the
Council of the city of St. Paul:to ,reject PreJ�iminary ,;Oxder 242134. ^�` � �
�,-� , „ �, �.
� � ME ~ DATE
�' .- ,/� ` /^ ���.
j )�..,-��'''C.- !�, ;�': /�. � �/ �
�"(/V t�' �/ v � �`�2��' C/: ` � -
. �
.r � ,:a,;�, �
�,: � , � +x: , �
, / ��f`� . .. , .. � � � J� � /� / . :� I:,.' ,N �
{ �-� �� ..�,'� �r �•
' I�I`Y! a` r
� � � ��� � _/� ���� �' ���� � C�,� �' �r.� � y � �� � :�
�%y�� ��'"r�---' ��' l .. ! q � �" � tn A , ;;
� D . :at: ��I�'�;C.., �� 4 .P4 ~{��J
��� �i /��' � ,.
� � ' � , � _ 'r,'? i � � _('�'
� �� � � �� � . , . / . �..�,�,
�
�� �.� � �� , 4 ..
� � ''�'�k , ,/ �, �,,f'� ,,�, �` «t
(/�• v ,r�� y ` � !r,�. � ., �, � ��'
/J� 1 _ ��� ���M 's ' '' �� i la ,�{ �y ,� � � �rk�� k ;.r
�' , 4�+.� i/ ' � 1 �'� `
'i".. �7 . '� , ..�v. j +� y,�V��s r F ,� ,�; R , � �''.
v a p'`y,�N��jpl�� A . ,
� '�' �c� � (,.( "f� �.�./ ,'a � �' r� ��r '`/�f�f�(��j r� � /���f' � ��.� �'���
���"�+� � /� L u.P S 1^Sl�'g J �+.,.,!T_ """"_ •���� �°�J�'�'"� t � l'�.� '3u �
//�� 6p a
,4 � ; � ,�f,- �i at�rp� �>!� st l ,� � �� ;
, ����������� .. lr'� 4 ��"��G,�' ' r h i�l' ii" iryx.�`a: E i a°. i� �., a , nk� �:� �� .�.
i A � ,� {ay y �.r' � I� f n� �1 f i �+ � A,� � q t,' +s 1 �
1 . 41`u )�.��arfT�y!r b ��4��rf� � ��y� ��'�. � �l �� I 'yr.
.. �� ' ^ � �, h�,p t} p � � '1 .` t . /� V:I{
� '�(I.// ���(Q�/�' }4 � H ���'�k k I �' I.�w A Y �. h, � 1�{jr � .l� f R � Y '� �
4'�"' ��' "' �t �t,:.,!� 1�l� ",� y y`r �.Ml� � 4�r- �iY'� t r4"''� l�� , r � 4'. '4
1 1 F.1 d�,.4r k���^"��l,.hl� '� Y '"� '� 4'+ y` ;� '4 �� � 1 ~� S�."�' � M '��.
, � , iiYk� y �.F P � � ,1 .�' �t 4 '����R ��;�a� '� w uj� M�y' ,.r n�t�,J�9 �^� � � r��,
, � �� �� ���� ,� � t � }� �:���
. . h1�1��y� � � im T� r � �,.y�n�Y n ''� x�: � a ��`� x k�.�#�F�� � � � ii h' e'� nq�,g � �. P,
/ �''` � '�� �1 �? ♦ �;} ^� , �
.:.�.. . . . w ti�qSJ.t s. �y.\��� �` � �����,�.b� r�4��s'�'^� K�F ? .;'4������� �e . , �V
, `!�� ��,�!jy`�,� fi ��<r 1 " ". � X ��, 1�QG "•� �r Y:' � a S .,ri;; �c�" ,✓� tw,�*.�',, � �i}''' \\'t
//y7�`�y_, /� S t���^ � i � �`�t�s a �Y��` ��'�` �n+��,.�i. � ' .t�' �, :��4�/y��� � M,e�
A.��''�' ,��.`/'/r,/-•Yj/4/ ' ,. 5 i '4 � fj���l� bl h� �r� �� �' J ,FY F�I ^,�� y� _
y� / j (
.. . . � . �!/ ��� t f A�.� ,� r �'�.�!{�,�'� %',�,,� ���� � � � �i}���5 q -��,F . �~
// r,�y � � Y � {§� �ab ��
�. . .� � // � f�" G � �9�,L u 1 ,v' ��� j 'a'y�;1 t „ Y�..� 1! ' 'yk 1'Y y�1r�r i`�'rw
� � 1/ � b r�4 c�r f� i �r � y�; y�v � A� i �t i� � �� a k Ay '� n�!� � �!,
�1� �. / .. � ' r � , �..�1d � ar n � '�� �,, t}'E,� !1 �.� M` � �,�a'"'��1
� �,�.,,�`�.'. / . . n �j ^t r �., �'� �.� �e �.:� eF yt Y� ��. P � � �{ �ky PX '�i
+� �.�-=�•: n4� �'"'��t���r� t �.t"'1,�� � .;"��"„ ,''���,�rf�, ���{�r��y��x rAk��.a���
�R, , �,,�r� I,5� ��,
�r . ..��.. , � - r C i.�. w � ,�� ���•;r n �;`� �� ��r�.p ��.,�� ,� ���q������ N 7��,���4�� ��'�1ry�� +,���� ��
,� ��bJ,,,� , . S �^ � }� . t �a �{ ,T.' a ��
�u .y .� �,�� �i r�iM�. t4 k� ;i� � ��r ��� ��� '7�, ���{����`�� f:.
E, ��� � ,° iG� �'; r'' ` , �1���'+rb`�1�,`�j �+��p��x;r � {� 1�,.�i` P ���,�dr�7���p�r,1 .�„"M a
7p � , . ._ � . '� �..' .�. � t K ti- 2 "�C � � � wi. �,r �qi 3 � tt�� � l T,r � a Y
� e, ��j� '` i�r al t x s t,�w �� �� i�� t ti� ! '�� #,y i ky`
'�S , ���,����� �'�: In� e i��: «?k�'"��� ` 7 b , �t t'� y '�.,w � ,
��4�+:r��/f.. ����,, � � � .,a y'� �.�„ �r� 't �a.: , �t,y�(, ; �}' �'�� Nr�Y�t 1�',
�� � � ` 1�.� ��' , ��
�� ,':.1�=�c�tZ �. ,/� y J+ ���+�' �'��s k �d ,�,� �k w �.�r� { _y S e-� '�1�r � * fi���y�'�9^�'��� efh,t
. , . . . . 9• . . >�I . . � �.°3� i'fr. . � ���b.,J �+nt .��d��r�• A!� r ra!'... � .���i4.a rt��.*��t�,�. A� �1:
• , .ynv •;.1�
� e µ,.
� a
1� .
�.� •J
The following liome owners 11ave si;r�ed tiie re�uest to the Cowici_1 t1�At they
rejecr Dreliminary Order 242134:
AUDRFSS ON
N.4ME GO�DRICH AVE.
(In order tt�at their
si.gnature appears)
?�tln W. rahey 1423
Eliz M. Sweetman 1434
Wm. �3. F,ldredge ,Tr. , 1415
Frank R. Burns 1430
Dona ld C. S�aenson 1405
Thos . E, Albrecht 1431
R. C. T3ilski 1435
,1ean Kaye 1402
Carl M. Ahl 1439
Rose Warner 1432
Norman L. Allard 1453
Carl Enestved 1410
Edward Lanpher 1457
David Tenenbaum 1G58
.Tames A. Bosta 1454
R. K. Hanson 1440
Emily A. Reilly �'x ' ` , 1422
,
Robert D. Stober 1419,
� I~� 4 ry' ti 4 � � � .
Harold Kneeland . '�'" R�
;:�4 , 1446
.:`�l",d .,�, - . � . .. .
. , . t' � .. . , , . . . �
� h� ,;� �, , . . . .
, �,b t r�* '
ry � '.t,
i:i �
' 1�'; , �
. , . � ����.Y� � , il^�'�� , . �4 , }
' . ' . �t'� .. . � .. � 5 �; .
1
._ Jal+.�r�''�t�Y t . ,� � '
� ,w �s �k
. . r}�, r .i�'. . . .
. . . 1y ��!5�� ! . .
. .. ..-% , . �
. ' � � . � N . � � � . . .
- . . � •�1 �C . ' , � . .
� ' �' r� � . . ' � . .
. d,� �. � � � . �
. . � "���� ��� L .. . . . ^
M
� *4 1 '1 �^ �� � .�f- . �� 1�
.. . ,. J� ..� .. . . . � ., . ' � .