The URL can be used to link to this page

242664 OR161NAL TO CITY CLBRK i • " •• • 242s�4 i CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCi� ' OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE NO. � COUNCIL SOLUTION—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONE DATF RESOLVED, That James Ayotte be and hereby is permitted to install and operate an 11—car trailer rental lot on property located at the southeast corner of Smith Avenue and Curtice Street, more particularly described as Lots 15 and 16, Block 51, Lawton Brothers Addition to the City of St. Paul, in accordance with plans dated Received November 6, 1968; subject to the conditiors that the trailer parking space noted as #1 on the submitted plans be eliminated to maintain sight lines at the street in.tersection; that advertising be eliminated from the street boulevard; that a bumper guard rail be installed to protect the '7-1/2 foot buffer adjacent to the trailer parking area; and that shrubbery be installed at least every six feet on center in the now blacktopped buffer area; an.d further subject to ; compliance with all applicable city ordinances, state statutes and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance. Fq� pp� « �"t' �O1'�°'�°" MAR 18 1969 COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Counci� 19— Yeas Nays Carlson � 18 1969 Dalgliah Approved 19— Meredith � Tn Favor Peterson ' SprafkF, � Mayor Tedesco A gainst Mr. President, Byrne pUBLISHEI� MAR 2 2 1969 0 . . y , . ' .. � Z • t ' . . _. ti '�•`;:-�' � _ � �_ Q�l��ia�! M;�,1.� i . �,` .,..r.,y.. ... ... . . . � ■MI��'i�rhi Fa�'�e . BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 � PHONE: 223-4151 ` March 12� 1969 ��Ir. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 38 6 City Hall� and Courthouse Dear Sir: On February 27, 1969 the City Council laid-over -Co t�iarch 3, 1969 the application of James Ayotte for a permit to install. and ooerate an eleven-car trailer rental lot on the southeast corner of Smith Avenue and Curtice Street. In laying this matter over the City Council directed the Zoning Board statf to re-investi�ate the r�remises and report on "housekeeping" on the site. A new field investigation of this �roperty by our staff took place on i�4ar�h 10, 1969. It was noted that the site is occupied by a Nidwest filling station which, with an exception� conforms to vlans approved in 1957 for Skell.y Oil. Company. The exception is the 7 1/2 foot buffer area at the rear of the site alons� the south property line. As noted in the previous transmittal to Council, this buffer area should be re-estab].ished 3nd protected by instal7.ation of a bumper guard rail. The open area at the rear of the site, about 50 by 65 feet, is used for pa.rkina, trash burning, and advertising sian and old tire storage. The ille�;al advertisin�; si�n previously no�Ced as beinp on the Curtice Street boulevard h3s been removed. Snow has been removed from the paved areas of the site and from abutting sidewalks reasonably we].1. a�C the time of this 1.atest field investi�ation. It was apparent, ' however�, that mosty if not all, of �Che accumulated snow has been piled on the buf�er area along the south oroperty line, the City boulevards abutting the site, and the CitV boul.evard across Curtice Street. Snow niled along the south property line seems to be encroaching on the adjoining residentia]. p�operty. Curtice Street is stopped for Smith Avenue at the adjoinin� inter- section. Smith Avenue is heavily traveled and sight ].ines are somewhat restricted due to building placement and area tonopranhy. i�lhile the piled snow did not ag��vate this problem at the time of this fi�ld investi�ation� it may have ear�.ier in the winter af�er fresh snowfalls. The Planning Board staff is not a re�ulatory or investi�ating body and� as such, is not equipped to carry on policing functions which � �,� '�,�'��, � � � �� eo � i Mr. Harry E. Marshall -2- March 12� 1969 are more properly the preview of the Buildin¢ Department. As a consequence� we hesitate to interject our eva3uation. However, recognizing that this has been a difficult winter, it is our conclusion tha.t while there have been some attemnts to maintain the appearance of this pro�erty, these have been somewhat below avera�e and what may be exnected for a commercial establ.ishment wishing to retain the public's good will. Very truly yours,� � ' � .�-a � � ��---- � C �� , �;,��-. t�`". Nol�and R. He iden Director NRH:cv CLS Z.F. #6665 i • . 1 . � BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 February 25, 1969 t�ir. Harry E. Marshall City Cl.erk Roor� 38 6 City H�al,l. and Courtnouse Dear Sir: This is written in resnonse to the apnlication ot James Ayotte for a permit to install and operate an eleven-car trailer rental lot on property located on the southeast corner of Smith Avenue and Curtice Street. This property is further described as Lots 15 and 16, Block 51, Lawton Bros. Addition. This matter was consider�d at the becember 19,196�3 Board of Zonin� meeting. The staff reported that the site is presently occupied by a fi]..ling station approved in 1957. Plans for this fillin�? station indicate provision of a 7 1/2 �oot buffer area along the south property line. Field investigation, however, discloses that this buffer area has now become part of a blacktopped parkin� area at the rear o.f the property and that an illeaal. advertisin� si�n exists on the Curtice Street boulevard. Three lettars in op�osition (attached) were noted . The staff recommended several cha.n�;es if the a�plication w�,s to be approved. These changes are: a) Trailer parkin,.a., spa.ce noteci as ;�l on the submitted plans be eli.minated to maintain sight lines at the street inter- section; b) Advertisin� be e�.iminated from the strEet boulevard; c) A bumper �;uard r�il be installe3 to protect the 7 1/2 foot l�uffer adjacent to the trailer parkin�; area; and d) Shrubbzry b� insta].led at least every six feet on cent2r in the nota blacktopped buffer area. .,. �""°- PZr. Geral.d Rummel, rep�esenting the applicant, irxiicatzd that the staff recommendations �aere acc�ptable to the anplicant. � Consequently, tne Board of Zonin� recommends approval of this agplication sub�ect to the above staff recommendations. These cnang�s are r.ow indicated on the �1.ans. t �o, urs, I�v O)J . Chai n RLA:cv CLS Z.F. t�6665 Attacn,-nents (3) � 80 - �r�� ,� � �� . L��!'-2�y��`'U� � /� % �,�• z , �= �b 6 �,�— /� /)�� i//��] /� � /1 6 �r/V�I' �� - ` l./ C�l.��±Y�() a�� J % �-�L� � ��-= ..e-z� �g-�i%.�--� �_C-,� ,u�-':'-`�u�,.� :��_ �x.2 z� � . �� /� U (} �.,�=t��-c�e_� -E�r L-�-L'.�-L �`"`�T � ' .. _-..�" , " �,�� ✓�--C,,z.�.�. :_�. �. � . C^� �l // �_j�. .�---�� „""�-IZ/ � �r�' /�c�� /��C� ./Y> �/ � _,� � � ,� '- � � ��.– `�-C �" � � ., �� .�v�x'� � �� /�� , � ��t� i��/�---t rr_'' �� . f��i-Z,h�+2__ ��2-�t-t�' �,�� / � � � �� Q'�'""`� i � -� �.��:�-�. �� - ,`��r�-�' •�•_�- ti ��.•_'i✓ -�'i'!� /✓ . � . . � /S fi/i'��C-i'� � '`� f .� ��.�'�'L�� , � � �� i / � . �,��- /'��"v �� , � �- �- .--"� 3i ��.. ti ///JJJ �~. '`� ��i'� ��'�� /, ��, .�.,e%�f�� G � �� ,4 J/z .? ��,� 4=�- • �� ,�--��.--��, �� C� �-,�,.� �, � �,� -/`�,� i ` � , ..�,� /y Gt-��-�e.. ` ' / l� �� -f� �,�' y� ,� ��,��,�. �.��'` r%'�"`�. � �,; �•'� � = �': f� �, ;:. I!;. !_ ' �,;, :� ; � ;•;j� : ,, �: � _ _ . � ;� �q ,� � ,, � W .� . . . - r.� . .v..x_1,�.N.i ��F:.t ;J. 1 1:1C�Li$ IIOARD OF 70NING RE��ORT AND ACTION December 19, 196� Pl.at M�p 47 Actin� under Le�islative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 File Pdo� � passed August 22� 1922 as amended to April 6f 19G8 6665 Also 3633 . 1, APPLICANT'S NAME ; James Ayotte � 2. CLASSIFICATION s �Amendment Q Appeal �Permit ❑ Other . 3. PURPOSE s Insta�� and o��ratz a trailer rental lot 4� LOCATION s Southeast cornGr of Smith Avenu� �nd Curtice Street 5� LEGAL DESCRIPTION s Lots 15 � 16, 3�oc'r. 51� Lasaton 3ros. Addition 6� PRESENT ZONING ; Com,� erci�l 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapters 60 Section: .05 Psragraph: f 8 � STAFF INVESTIGATION � REPORT; Date3 By: CLS A. }iISTORY: A germit to instaii and op�rate a fillin� station on th?s site was granted on Au6ust 1, 1957. B. ARE9 ZO�JING: The frontaQe a?on� Smith Avenue is zoned Conmercial� Area to the east is zon_3 "A" ?�sidanc�, C� DESIGN STAidDa:tDS: Th� plar. f.or the exist�n? fillina station cal.led for a 7'o" buffer are.� alon; the south p.~�opesty lin� �aith a retainin? wall alor.� th� eastsrly oortion of t�e buf.fen area, Rep-�irs to the bituminous narking area east of t��e �uil.din� app�ar to have encroached upon the buff�r araa . The buffer area is noca b�.acktopnad. D. FROtdTAGE � AREA; The oroparty has ?5 foot frontage a):ong Smit'� Avenue ar.d 117.7 feet alonu Curtice Str�et rrith �.n area of 8s817 �5 s�uare f�et, E. SITE CO21,�ITIOA!: Tne existin� .f-illina station is aoproxim�tely thre� to four feet lower than property to the soutn. An ille�al advertisina si�n is on the Curtice Street �oulevard. F. AREA C�?JDSTIO:vS; Comm�rcial d�velo�ment exists on t5� southusst corner of Smit'� Avenue and Curtic� Street. The pr�do-,iinatn area devalopmnnt is sin;la-fa�ily. 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend X Approval � Denial Council Lt. Dated Moved by: Gad1�r Yeas Nays Ames Seconded by; :IcDartlin Cohen Date of Hearing X Janes,Chmn. X McPartlin Council Action Secretary's remarks; Haarstick - Alt, X Gadler Date SU3JECT TO THE C�P�I�ITI�iIS S�T �71'; X Maietta - 3Y STAFF BEI`1� S:i�';^I 0*1 PT 4'iS. LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SFIEET � �-, `-� „ �; - � � • + �' '' i J �' ; �I _� t i - � ^,; I i � �-_ (i' el r� � .--�- . ---- --- f--=-- -- � t, i � -1---+-- � —�----= � �� _, -i:-- --- � • ! _`��"' �t�i--t--�— , �---�_. , i � �� l')- � ' =�-- � . � ., � `�-- , l� � � � �`_ - . -� ' • � � ;�-+' _ J` 5 — ' ' , — � � I 9 � j i i � �� ; � � _ �v�,1 � ..� � i �, �� , i ( � i i i ' � -,�- �� i � � � � —�--� (:: j '� ��'� i�'�� "a ; i`l i`l . � �., _�; ��0 ;G _� _-- ---- ��-T � -,�,- �: ;�� i ' ..r �' � � , r) �� ' � ' � , ' _ _ �.' � ' I,a{—_ — ! :� ;��• �� ., �� . — — — pNE� � � ��4 � � .�.,, � .---- , � � � `� -t-� � � n ` � Q,7 �;�! `� �O � C��O .-O- - - . - � __ - __T� � _�__ � i i C�. _ _. ' . : +�! -( --_----� q -�-------- � ---_-"_: � _3 i. � � --�-.. _- __ �---- -� -�_ � � , "' `� I t.t' )- . �-- !.) �-- _ _ `� l i �� : •a � � � � I i _ __ _ -__........ _.. o � � � ---�� . 3 _�r� i ,, �� 1 _ ._ a �?. . _1 . _I_ _ � � .__}_ , - ,- � --- -- --- --__---- _- Q -�-- --- -- ----�- - � _. _ _ , . (�' O '� r . ..(� _. _ n - a C � I � i =� ��`� ' � �, _�_ �-._ �_-.--J-- �' -- ---- -- -.------ __ � _- .-�-- --1 , , �_ -=�=�---_-�.._--� , . � -- � �c ~�� }' " F - - � � � � � ; �__.�_ - --� � - o --f--�-.\- � --- --�� ,� . ;�.. .. I --- �:�-__ �.. ' ; i ;? -�.-� �. ____ � � ,. . ,}_ .. ,�,. --�} , -�- - '. .� _ - � � � v �� - _ . _.. __ _., _ � . ; ' .�, . .� •.,, .,,..,. �j • • cuR't�c� � �� • �.(�) . ; � � � I • �I�,�'''''�� ' ' .( v � U �.� I (� �,"!�� , 'I. ^� ,,•1 ; r ` �� `� ��1 � I (_� � ) ( , � � �I . �•� \ , l/ . I1 I { ��j � , � t�) ; � �, , � , . � ' . _.. .. : � �, � , , , � � I � c� � O , , �I D�� t_� � � ,� ._-=--_�___ _.._. , . _ ._ _ _. _._ - ----a �` L � , , ; , ; , � a � - -- _- _ - -� �l - I � � I _y_-�----'- �.� �� -- - —�- - ; \ � _j__ � `�_ ..--- -I� --- -Q ��. t �'t--�- T-r �� -'^ ' _�I�__ � �O- -'�---- ;�-f-� ,0 ! � i� j � ! I I --- - _ •d � t� _ '1� � ---� -- -- �` _ _, � , f . , ,- �) ^ � ; I C,-,i E �� rti _�.__ r=�--�r - ��_.,�1I' _ _�. -0-- --; �-- O ��__�o�,; ��,�� ._� :O��J�,_,!Q � � �J'� � � . . ...�-� � • � � � ` ` i �fi I i _• , S � . _ .� . -: al,,�o N+� ' _....:_.._. __...�. ;� � i � p�� -o- � �O�11 _--�- � i��:O O�i � i Q� O�O C �� +- ------�) ------- q �'�Ir-- d i _ ' _� ( �� '� i � � ► ' t. . O � � ' � � � _n v� � �! C� � � � � � � ; i ( ' .r O ` � � � �� . O w � -1� p CO^ �_1�-�-- � �O ' � �- � � �I O � � 1 � '_ � �---�- ��—:--` O __�� C' � I�C� C � � � , -�i--- � � —�--� c? _ ' __-�_ �-n• W � �� —o_ •--�—�---,Oj n!�I n� c� �� O ��J �. , r ; fJ -�j- �i � � q -,� i�,_„�'� �.�.o;.-',_-�..�...,� ; � � _......�� ' � .{ � �", � � `��`r:r.��r�•._.. � �1 � � . . . . ' 1�I y�-M�t►t C, 1 � ' .�... • ;---�-�---- � , �';� '� r'_'� ,r,.:j"""'�'"'"i.�"""I I � �- � ,-. � ) � /'� I 'I O (�_ �J �Q��- �`� ''i -`-1--� � �-' �'-' I `-� ` I�.: �'.,i I\ � �,._._� !� ± -�- � C-) v }' (� 1��-----� (-r i � � i � I � _ � } r � i , -� �� O I ,� r�_--I i f�`__---- i;,.�-.--±--� , , � I � . �' " G- �_l.— ,. :_.�._ _. ° � `. �� - __.-;��- _-�_ r; _-*--�-;--_� i_ ----�- i-r , � �r', � n -- . .�-,--_ --_- .I�--_ � . . f\IJ��`=�iV �I Jam�s ,Ayotte �-A��4:J�1V � . . f�' i Prate a trailer rental lot \ �t'oiV� �� 4�llf�"��. Install ancl op_ � � � � � O OP�:ta°r,!1�,�11 Y �'i��:,��i�I' �Di'�;�i�,C7 Commercial � � "�' �_l'y�•'�,f�ll�I��Y ' � , 1� �'N°��..�E:•° {�;�1��,11 LY ��r�i i a�i ��c��;r;,zs . . . -�- � �our;--s:�;�,��Y � . . � �Q ��u±_r'�--r�'n►��1� ' � � o n n Cp:`�iP.'1�:�;CIE�I.. � E'��.� �;0 #6665 . NoR'�f� • f�l � ��i��JS � ��. . . . _ . . v V,�1 C�1 N'I' . � � S�t. Paul �'IClilTlltlC�j [3o�r�d, Da�?e� November 20 , 1968 ��'.��!� f'rop�rfi�,� Ui�c1�f CCi131G3'rqil0i i CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 February 14, 1969 City Clerk File X632, Page You are hereby not�fied that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court �:ouse in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on February 27, 1969, on the application of James Ayotte for permit to install and operate a trailer rental lot on the £ollowing property: Lots 15 and 16, Block 51, Lawton Brothers Addition to the City of St. Paul. The property is located on the southeast corner of S�ith Avenue and Curtice Street. For further information contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Commerce Building or phone 223-4151. J�.N�S J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance O _. - �G City of Saint Paul, I�innesota APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT (Please print or type) �Q TO THE HbNORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL . � the City Clerk City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Application is hereb made to remodel or reconstruct an existing y install and operate a new (cross one out) � FILLING STATION No. of islands and pumps : No. of tanks and capacity: , � PARKING LOT for (customers) (employees) (private use) (public use) (other) (indicate type) Capacity of parking lot To be used in connection with: � MISCELI�ANEOUS: I r��.��.e� ��.ti� � c�� -- i � r -fi.�.��r —f v�c-.��`�� (indicate type such as Drive-in ltef reshment Stand, se Car Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up Station, Ice Vendor, etc.) Capacity of parking area: *Location : � �l � �O J w�� + Legal Description : Lot ; � ij +"" l� Block j� �,;,,w�oy►�-dS.Addition Applicant's Name : j�� A � �� r�� .�tomc-e•r Of f ice Address: � y,��• � ��.� Phone Number . FOR/� THE APPLICANT, � � � (Signature ( ate) Address : W g�� 0 `�� c+X�cw..Jl�•s�.k-�J�� ' Phone No.: � .�� _C��r, f When completed: file three copies of this application form and three prints of the preliminary lay-out plans of the proposed facility with the City Clerk, ftoom 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota Z-3 6/11/56 *EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St. 2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St. � . February 25, 1969 City of St. Paul � Department of Finance 113 Court House St. Paul, Minn. 55102 : Gentlemen: RE: Permit to install trailer rental agency Case File X632 Page 7 In regard to Mr. James Ayotte's request for a permit to install a trailer rental ageney on the southeast corner of Smith Avenue and Curtice Street, I wish to protest his application because I feel it will be a deteriment to the neighborhood. There have been so many break-ins and accidents on that corner that one more business place will invite more trouble or ag�reviate the situation, especially ovexcrouding parking space, whish is now such that I can`t park in front of my home or have access from my sidewalk to the street due to businesses alread,y on the corner utilizing parking spaces. I own m,y home and have lived there over fifty years and do not feel I should have to move elsewhere because of business enterprize� taking over the residential district. There is no parking on Smith Avenue from 2:00 A.M. to 7:00 A.M. and when weather is such one can't get in an alley the only place to park is on Curtice Street. Then too the new snow ordinance requests no parking on even numbered streets startir�g March lst. 1.g69 which will further complicate parking. I work at the Veterans Hospital and need �y car for transportation and winter parking is already a problem. Smith Avenue is "Highway 49" and heavily travelled and approaching Smith f'rom Curtice is a problem now, espically with cars already parked nea� the corner and is a hazzard as it is. I trust after re'viewing the situation you will revoke the application of Mr. Ayotte. Thank you, i�� /` .�e��XiC�� G�""o� Mrs. Mabel Carlson 766 So. Smith. Ave. , St. Paul, Minn. 55107 . . _ . � February 25, 1969 � �ayor and City Council R E C E I V E D ;City of St. Paul � FEB 2" 1969 Dear Sir: MUO►YOR`S OFM�lCE Concernin� File X632--Pa�e 4: In regards to petition fox trailer rental to be allowed at the corner of. Smith and Curti s (I,ots 15 & 16 block 51 , Zawton Bros. Addi- tion to cit�T of �t. Paul.� This letter is to inforn� you of the position taken by home ow'na�'o in close proximity of existin� service station at 778 So. Smith Ave. In the past year trucks delivering gas to Jims ' Ididwest have broken dov�n curbs, scraped garages and literally chewed up the a,lley. On Ja.nuary 30, 1969; a resident in the block on complaining of such tactics wa.s punched in the nose� ca.using considerable discomfort, profused bleeding and two black eyes. Police were called. This winter snoi�v has not been removed from side Vvalks surrounding this corner. This operator has plo�ed sno�� across both Smith Ave. and Curtiss Street during heavy snot�s, creat�ng high piles of snow that are hard to see around and impossible to see ovex causing a safty hazard. No snow h�s been remov ed f r�m this site (winter '68-- '69) which seems odd due to the fact that this man has the equipment and contracts out to plov� for others. Snow has rendered the lot smaller and smaller and would be smaller still had not snow been pushed through and over neighbors fence and against l�i s garage. Considering ��r. and �rs. Ayotte's lack of consideration for their fellotivs, we the undersigned home owners feel this petition not be allowed. The affore mentioned incidents and others too numerous to mention should suffice to show we don't want a trailer lot here. This letter should also suffice to curtail G.ny further such pet�tions; should such petitions persist. There may soon be a petition to curtail existing business run nov� by �.�r. and Mrs. JU.mes Ayotte. SIGN�D--Aieighbors on S�mith ve. �� 0 S� � �n � \ =_ �� ., ; �� G��e�'� �=� �.:' � c�,� � � �� Z � �� -' ' ` ��' �;�-� /i"�- �+V�° ' '� �. - _ -7� G � , �oy y'� .;� \ , , �,� �a � �a � r 1- , �/ ��0 u,LU.� T�'/ ?s/a�u�Lz �� . � G�- �G�%��'`�l . � J 7 7 5�.1,�,� ��ti � �� i�;�� .� � I.� c�'-�a�� _ � � � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA 113 Court Hou:s,6b102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner LOUIS H.MeKENNA,Depufy Commissioner Phons:223-46�46 February 24, 1969 Mr. Harry Marshall City Clerk BUILDING File No. X632 Trailer rental lot on SE cor of Smith Ave. & Curtice St. Hearing Date: February 2p, 1969 Dear Sir: Forwarded herewith is a letter, with reference to the above project, for consideration by the City Council. Si erely, � �`-"_ ames J. D glish � Co�ission r of F nance cc: Robert & Dora Hessger File �� -,r--- - �` � �:« "� _J- � , � ..:�-�--� � � I � � i '{ � _Qr—' � � � �/.� _ _;__ f j � ; , , � � � _ _�-- -j � ' G .,-�.. � -^ ` .7 -' - � �� .�� , � -, � ; � ,�,; R �' � �` � ` � � _ y +�;O , G �.� - - r------�- r�� , ��' � : , ; ; - . ._ -.r � — — — �ioNr, — ' � G. �'� s-� ' � � ' � ( . , . . _ ,-, � _�. _ _ _ � . _ _�3 -��---- �_:_ {- i ' `� --��--�(1 � 1�, .7 �� :� �� W � � r' t`� . , i � � I _. ____. j � rJ_ _ . i �. _._._� _.. q - �--- --._.-!�''r__�_. .�:� . _r�__i.�� .:,_ � _ f �v _I �; � � , � , � � _ ' I , _...._ _-�__ ._ _._ }.� � o �' � r ' � (� - - � -- .- �, ? C.� � � a _��' � � ! � i i � - Y. ; , , � � + , �. . _ �__. -- -- � � _. _. _ . - , ' �'' �- -. � _.- _ - ---a - �-�I t � a d Cj I �� C� ' '' r' L� -- - �= _ a C� � i ; ,�, __ .__�__ __.._._ -- __ _ _ .. � __.__ ._ �, -i � ---�---�-- ; ,� , j � �; F __ _ f-, � � ► � ,: � V C)._ .._. � - _i .' Q f. _.� ., � �� -- - �� 11� �-_ � __._._.�' - l,� - 1--� ' c j I j � (n (l; ,. 1 ��. ,} n t " � .I ,. . . .. � .. � � <�; � �, � • c u Rt�e.E :�. �i) , . � �!_,,_.,._ .�� p�� . (� �J � U x �� `-� , � ' i � � I .�� i C.� ��) � i � I �',�~ � ' ' � I rI, � , ,,,� �'jj �J ' _II� D' � �I I I� ; � i , � �I ( 1 ; i , "` � ) � ' � ' I , p" -_____. , � . ' _ __. _..� `-1 - -� ` -- ._ L.. '\ -- � � � " _� .._ � t+ � � ( � - --_ I�----- � - � '� ` ' ' � �, _i_._ � ;�> � _. . � - i- t —+-- t_ ,__ �--r._ + - - ---• � �— �� . �� _� Q � ` � ------+ � � I '�• ' � � I � � 1 -'� -''1 -- �----- - -' - , { ' , � 1� �--`- � - �--- ��F - ---Q L7 I��___ -^ ---� �i ; � � ! I � - �-----; �- � . ��- � �I __ _O. _.; � __�o� ;•. '�I ,'a; `O;U`':�C -----;-_ _� -- , ;J� , , ,." -� I - � � ' , . , , � i I _ , , s--�- . - � w,NO�vA - � � . . , ; � , #; �� ; a o � _ -a- Q � ---o- � �� ;o�c'� �� o� d, o � � i i ; '' 'I � � � � � �� ' � �r ; �� , � � � O � w � I' � ; , ; ,� � ;� G ; ! i r. , i �? U I . O w 0 �p C ,. � , � _.� .� � } i ;�; � � p � 0 , . I � �- C , � i � 3;._ O__+- � !_;_._. 0 � . �� F r; � ( � ; � � I ; � _ � , � Q � _J� d �.� i � � ,�I�17! r�� (� � '�)i'� I:.� --1- � , _._.._� -- �,. - — - .� .�, � , { I O � � (� n `� (� -1, °� � ` �' � �H� �� a�,o�y�<r- ! ' ' ' ' � �4i,_ `i , 1 . S 1. � � w�� - i .� . . .� i� � � �� i� O 0 _ v �l i � _��.�;��;� ;�� , � �:: P�� , • � ' O� n O v � ��r---� t r--�--� '' � (` � I � � � � `-: � � � �� y `:� , 4 ; 1 � � , ) (;; � ; (,� ,.� - ___ ii--- . —} , _._._ ----t � _.�..__; _�.�._ ,_� . ; _� �---�-- , ,��'� -r_ -__ __. _� �_ _ - . : M , A1-�L�C!�N� JaMa Ayotte �G�3LIV� . � . , n, • PVt'��J� Inatall and operate a trailer rental lot L�IV� U�� ,. . . o o��-Fl��iILY ; : : P„�S�N(' ZO�I�JG Comm�rcial �"' ��"�0°F�I'l�ILY � ' , �j TF��iLE-FA�,�ILY � P�TI i 0�1 S1G�l��S . -�- FOUF�--F�r�11LY ; . . � � tiq U L�'I-�/�r,�f LY ' � � o On C01�iP.1�:�Cl�l. -�; F�L� �i0 #6665 NOR7H f-1 /� l�1DJS�RI�L �` �;. �, . . v V�1CnNT � �' � St. Paul F�ianntn Boflrd, Data� November Zo, i9sa �� Prop�rPy Under Co�sid�raii� �� : ��' .� . ' . . . .: � ♦:'.: .:..:...:.: .....er•.- x � . »a ,r.4e>, ni.ti�.�ay�v4s� . s ..::::. . ..v,:,: rv..a :�.,. ,.�r.°��:i: � �q ti,. � .. .: . . ..:,.... ' "�_} :... :; ... . -�. � . .. ..'fi�.�s:;..�_�a.... .. .�. . � CITY OF SAINT PAUL � Capital of Minnesota �e a�t�e�t o cs�`ic �a et � � � POLICE Tenth and Minnesota Streets HEALTH FIRE PROTECTION WILLIAM E. CARLSON, Commissioner POLICE AND FIAE ALARM ROGER M. CONWAY. Deputy Commissioner ' DANIEL P. Mc LAUGHLIN. Licenee Inspeetor �arch 11, 1969 l,°r. :Iarrf E. ?�;�rshall, Ci�t,y Clerk 386 Court i-Iouse St• Paul, T�::�.nr_es o�a 55102 .�ttentions 2.ir. kl Olson, Council ltecordsr ;�ear Sir: An application by Jamos A;�otte, for an eleven (11) car trailer rental, in connection tivith a ;-,asoline fillin�; station on the southeast corner of Smith Avenue and Curtice Street, sras referred to Commissioner ►iilli.am E. Cai�lson, f�r presentation to the License Co�nittee. At the hearing on P',arch 4, 1969, �he mat�er was referred to me by the Comr�4ittee for a physical inspection o7' the �reniises, as -�he area resident ob- jections, ��rere mainly "poor housekeepin�". On T�arch 6, 1969, myself and Deputy License Inspector Geor;;e ��arel e�mined Lhe prer.:ises, and found -�ne station, both inside and the area ou�;side, very neat, clean and orderly, r�.�h walks ahovelled, clear of snow and ice. In vie�r of our inspaction, �.�Ir. Karel and myself, feel that -the license should be ;ranted, i�' cleanliness tivas the main objection. I:`r. Ayoi;te stated that the trailers will be l:ept on a black-top sur- faaed lot, in a nea� and orderl�T manr_er. �'ery truly ,*ours, � �� . � Daniel P. I.icLaughlin License Insl�ector CC= Co�unissioner d'l. �arlson Corr�nissioner D. i:":eredith C or�i s s i one r R. �'e�l:e rs on Irir. Dan Iilas, Spscial Assist;ant Corporation Counsel Deputy Inspector CTeor;�;e liarel C.C� C_. . � `�� - � �...,� -� Go-m-.h - �e.�.�,�, , � .�b ",`.��1 ,,.,,�►�� . o � �'��C �.-�-�, `�°-`r ,�Q�.. � �`� �j `� �%ar ch 13, 1969 Hon. Wm. �,. Carls on �\ Comsr. of public Safety � Public Safety Bldg. Dear Sir: Atten I�lrr. niel MeLaughlin The City Council today grante a cation of James Ayotte for permit to install and opera 11-car trailer rental 1Qt at the southeast cor r th and Curtice St., sub�ect to the c�nditions et out the in� Board letter of Feb. 25th. The Council reque t d that the condit4ons be referred to the License Co�mnittee o consid ion at the time the licenses are gre,nt a rene , e have att�.ched a copy of this letter ; your informa on. `, \ February 27, 196g � Co�e�ce°�uilding � St. Paul � Gentlemen: The City C�uncil laid over to Mar th matter of' the applicati�n oP James Ayotte fbr permit to insta operate an 11-car trail�r rental lot at thc southeast corne th and Curtice St. and requeats - � that the 7,oning Bc�rd st nve te premises and report back to the Council on March 1 a� to"h keep g"on the premises. Very truly yours, / ,. � % City Clerk AO/ng / � �, l \�� . February 27, 1�69 I Ha�. Wm. E. Carlson ,------------1 Chairman� License Co�nittee ��, Public SaPety Bldg. \�� Dear Sir: Th� City Council tada.y conaid�re appl ion o� James A�rotte for a permit to install and operate an 1 - ar iler rental lot in connection with a gaeoline fi3ling station on t e utheast corner oP Smith ave. and Curtice St. Two letters and a peti an cf resi t� in the arer� were read, mainly pertainin� to "houseke ing' at thi location. The Council rePerred th lettex nd p�titifln to the License Cammittee �or investiga�3.o�,� ; �/ Very truly Yc>u�s� I ,\ �-�-- Cit C1erk Y Ao Ing Fe�. 28, 1969 � �---__�_____�� Mr. Joseph Perran, �.\ 792 S. Smith Avenue, � St. Paul, Minn. Dear Sir: Please be infor.med that f Council on Thursday, February 27th. considered t plic i n of James Ayotte for a trailer rental lot on t a t co of Smith and Curtis, and after discussion a ed to ha the ation inspected and to hold another publi earing Th ay, March 13th. at 10 A. M. in the City Council C bers. The Ci Coun direc me to notify you as a leading petitianer � tion� uests that you notify the other ob�ectors se n�tmes appeaxed on your petition. I, �\ Very truly yours, \ ��`�j City Clerk AO�hp Feb. 2$, 1g69 1 i � i � ��. Mrs. Mabel Carlson, �\� 766 s, smith ave., st. Paul, Minn. Deax �adatn: Please be informed tha.t ty Council on Thuraday, February 27th. held a p ing the application of James l�yotte for a trailer r al lo� the theast corner of Smith and Curtis, and after iscussion eed a investigate the location and hold attother he g on Thurs a , March �3th. at 10 A. M. in the City Council Chaffi re. �, Very truly yours, � �, � City Cierk AO�hp �� \ � Feb. 28, 1969 ------. �� Mr. and I�rs. Robert Tessmer, \\� 786 s. Smith Avenue, � �i. P8t12.� M�.�171 s Dear Mr. and P�s. Tessmer: Please be infarmed that t e Council on Thursday, February 27th. held a pub 3ng the application of James Ayotte for �i trailer re c� the o theast corner af Smith and Curtis, and after cus�ion eed t imzestigate the location and hald a.nother hear on Thur�d Ni�xch 13th, at 10 A. M. in the City Council Cham s. ;�� Very truly yours, � � City Clerk AO�hp `��` �_ Feb. 28, 1969 ,� . ---__________,�\ p�Ir. Gerald Rummel, �; Attorney at Law, `' W-2581 - lst. Aiatl. Bk. Bldg., St. Pa.ul� Minn. Deax Sir: This letter is our lephor�e conversatian to inform you that the Cit ouncil lai er and wiil hold another hearing on Thursd.ay, h 13th. in he ma ter of the applic�tion of James Ayotte for a per to ins n 11-car trailer renta.]. lot on property at the sou ast corner f Smith and Curtis Str�ets. Very truZy yours� �� City GZerk AO�hp � , ` � I30ARD OF ZONING RE.PORT AND ACTION December 1�, 1.�;�? P1at Map 47 Actin�; under Le�;islative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 File No, *.�assed Au�ust 22�='1922 as amended to April 6� 1968 �'�6� Also 3G33 1. A?PLICANT'S NAME , 1a�;e; :��,,o:t? 2� CLASSIFICATION s U. Amendment 0 Appeal L�IPermit ❑ Other 3� PURPOSE s ir.st�ll and o�=-rate :� trai��r r�r.tal lor 4, LOCATION s ��ut'�east c�rn�r of c�?it'.� 4v�nu�' a*�� ^u_rt_c: ^.tr��t 5� LEGAL DESCRIPTION S Lot:� i� .. 1Fi, _',loC�: 51, L.3'.rton -3?,0=, qr:;it'.on 6� PRESENT ZONING ; Co^��erc�•�1 7 , PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapters �>? Section: .05 Paragraph: !: 8 � STAFF INVESTIGATION � REPORT; Dates By: �1,= A. �iL;.T�?Y: A �ermi� to in�tall and on�rat� a fillir.^ �'�ation or, *'��.� s�t� •a�> �ranted on <4urust 1, 1�57� � �• �'��.A -7.+�NI,�1G: The fronta=*Q d10�1^ C^li�ti7 A.VP_Tlllt3 1.z3 ;Oi12� ��C:^.1^l°r'C131� =�5.^n,a f:0 ±i.,� �3st is zoned "4�� `'e,i•�l?nc•::. �� • ��' �1��:�1 STn:1)'�t2�5 T�l� D13P. {7I' �}1° 2X?�t�.P.t? '-'_11..7.'ln �1'a±�7i� ^?1 1 ;ri �:�T` � '��r� Uf'fAr sre� a�_on:r t"!f_' SOlit�l p:0??I't_�1 l.ifl': Wlt.^. .3 L`A�3�il..ii�"r -.v�11 �1 1^-^ ':ii_. @�;atFl^IV PC)I^t',.711 O� ?.'ti1E t.:•llf�'-Y. 32`H3 � rE`13].Z'S t0 i.'i° }�l.tll?^1^:OU= �3T`�!1,^.�' 32^?3 @3S� O�" �le ;:llli'�''i;l? a�'JpgdT' t0 �ldV° °_i'iC?'C?aC�'1°_:� ll7^Tl t�1° C>llfi=T` 3T':.-1 . itl�� Uuffer area ?S T10�! �13C}:t�^!�2G� � '�. F?�.��'�TA�i: � A��A; Tne �^operty na, 75 �oot fronta?e along S-�it'� aver.ue and 117.7 faet alon� Curt�.ca Jtrg?t :J1th 3L1 area of 8,�317 .5 s��zare f�et. :. �IT�� C�,�'JITI')?1: T�s existin�? fillir.? station is aor,roxi�natel;� three to four .`e�t lower than �rcoert;� to t;ie scuth. .4n ille�al advertis:�nq si�n is o� t5e Curtice Street '�oulevard. t'. .A�:::i C��NDSTIOi�1S: Co^�mercial develoo�ent exists or. r'�e seu*_'��rest corn�r of �mit'� 4venue dI1C; CUY't1C8 �treet• ltilf: b]^PC�O'1:Tk3t° 37'23 G�?V°10'.)T.'1°Pt' ?3 �lri�l°-�3'?111;!. 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend X Approval � Denial Council Lt . Dated Moved by: ;adler Yeas Nays __._ _ Ames I Seconded by: '�1c?'artlin Cohen Date of Hearing '{ Janes,Chmn. X bicPartlin Council Action Secretary's remarks: Haarstick - Alt. � Tr� �- * T + r t * !C Gadler � Date S)3�....,�T TJ TH.. C�:dDI;_'J,IS SLT D��7.; v Maietta ------- 3Y �TAFF �3EIN� SH�':;'d �'�I pt�,4•IS. LEGAL NOTICES ON TF� BACK -0F THIS SI-IEET TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL: Gentlemen: Re: File X632 - Page 7 In re: James Ayotte: Permit to install and operate a trailer rental lot on the southeast corner of Smith and Curtice Streets in St. Paul, Minnesota. We, the following named residents of the area in and adjacent to Smith and Curtice Streets, object to a permit being granted now, or at any time in the future, to James Ayotte,� for the operation of a trailer rental lot at the location above stated, on the grounds that it is a public nuisance and will interfere with the parking and premises of the owners of the property adjacent to and on Smith Avenue and Curtice Streets. NAME ADDRESS �..., � _��?��e;tz<.:e..�._�..�,�.��11��. �� o. ��-r,��., Q�.e�. � �� ,. � �6 � ��-- -- �� r�� ti� ��,�.� , r�-- - �l , . � ''�� 8 1 ,� , � � � �' ' ��-�-�i� �r1,,' ,� 1` ' .jt ';) i r : ,,.� / A . •�-tf'�j�� 1 � ��`�'��'!'� `� �. � ��, ��GL- � i�(tr�d �l�C ,�' � � . � �.� �� '�5��,�� S�%�e�-��, r � � � �Y�n�� ', ��/ ',��/�. ,� _ / ./�/� ��+-�ti� ,�'I ,/ L___;�'" 1 � � ,� " ^ / ' % r Y�� ` . l.�� 7 % / �'�'�v'G�- �� '�/'�'C ��'�� `'� l, � �.��.� . f �f . ,, ��./� d °�i'�ri ��. , `I v �;._. , � 767 So, Smith Avenue St. Paul, Minnesota 55107 March 11, 1969 City Council of the City of St. Paul Re: File X 632 pa�e 7 Gentlemen: I object to the granting of a permit to operate a trailer rental lot on the following property: Lots 15 & 16, Block 51, Lawton Bros, Addition to the city of St, Paul, Appli¢ation of James Ayotte, for this per�ft is detrimental to the reaident�l property in this area, James Ayotte has violated �any city ordina�cea; burning rubbish, �+ainly old tirea and oil rags in the back af the gaa atation �e operates. The p�11ce have been called, because of this violation. I board the bus every morning on the corner of Curtice and S�ith Av�.; the walk �nd cross walks were not shoveled all winter in fro�t af the gas station, Resi�ents in this area have been awaken by such noises as the big oil tank trucks de- livering gas supplies to the station. They proceed c� to Cnrtice Street then back up to the tanks, cressing Smtth Avenue, wiLh the horns blowing, Loud clanking h�s resulted in relemsing the tank eoverg. The polic� , also have been nofifi�d of this� South S�ith Avenue fs in_direct view of our State C�pitol and I do not think this street should be used for such coarneretal enterprise, �amely, a trailer rental lot.. I live �t 767 So. S��th Avenue �nd I have liv�d� in this block for over 50 years. I dislike any deterioration of property and any annoyance to the hocre dwellers in this area. Thank you kindly, Very truly yours, ��Q_�ce.��"�J�L-�:�C, (Mrs.) Lillian Meier 767 So. Smith Avenue St. Paul, riinnesota 55107 llece�.ber 17, i968 G�orge G. I�1cPartlin Secretary, 3oard of Zoning 1010 Commerce Bldg. St. Paul, PLinnesota 55101 Ref: 3F �6665 Dear Sir: One of My neighbors notified me of the hearing on December 19, 1968 on application of James Ayotte for a permit to install and operate a trailer rental lot on the property located on the southeast corner of Smith Avenue and Curtice Street. Lots 15 g 16 Block 51. I am in the process of buying, this month, the residence at 767 So. Smith Xvenue - which is within 200 feet of above=named property. I am very much OPPOSED to such a perLni.t. This district has al�aays been a residential area - I have lived in this block for 50 years. Smith Avenue is in direct view of the State Capitol. I highly recommend that these permits be NOT granted for the Smith �venue district. The Transfer Comp�ny� that is located at Smith Avenue and Baker Street, should be moved to our Industrial area. It is a hazard for the trucks to enter and exit on 5mith Avenue. Thank you for my interest. Very truly yours, � �t�� ( ' ` � .csLs�e..ce.�,� -� (I��rs.) Lillian�H�ek Neier �� -- ;� �� _ �� i�n E- , {� i �� '. � i�� m $`��'`�.�3�9S�Na'2 �6Jt'tFlD �iS';� �r11.?�, �il�`,?(tFar,�:%: C;,' � � - ' � �°!, ',j ��-� i �ci. . � _ {f �� _ L r r- �� • _ �� , :�:��—� /�� -��I C� J-�-c " , ��;�- ��o � � � , ; _. �� "�-�v�� -�-��, ,_ , _ , � . , ; • ? , /<�� ' ,-E��--�->-� .�=��`� � �� `�. ; : , � � �.�� c-�, a _-�c--�7�...�, z;-��2� � ,� f��,�. �'�2�--�� 'i�[-t�'�',��j �-`2�� ' ��Z -'�° < � , ��/� �� . , �f1�L- -. �,�[,� �� ..�^GG��: � �L-� ., , � , - , � �-'C.�C� �L.•L�-Z,'L �� C��L� . �`°"" -z.1�� / �7.� , �_ . �- , , �' `'� -r�c° -'`''��t-� ��'� �` ��'� r/ "�s `�`'L�'�I, �L2 ..��C't�f�G�7 %�'� �� , �- r� J r� � L f_ ; � �: i �,_, (� '' ��' � '� �,� 'u ?ii-(' _i �qrr' . L ` �� 3� � �.�.Y1't�s�E!�is.i.',z z1�:.7..i.,��Y: :.'�zzli:t 1"�:1111� �`��lIIRE�p�A a � � . �t , `. - ��`� :��---/9�9 , � �� °`-� ��/ �� `�1�s L�'-�i , ,� / �'� �.�-�-�� ->-�, `��-� =�`�� - . �� , ��,,�,� - ' �/ � - . :� �� '�'/�� .�'"�``.�-°`��7YL�id:i �/f �f-' C�: � � � /CFZ�..-�^�-Z L�� ' G.�J-L�,� . ��r_ y �� —/ % �` i , ��a, ��, �� :�� ,�� r' Z.C./� (/�-'�� )� ��>j�.i�-, -t� , .'J,i�2��... � � �� , _. - _-. -,�t�4 � /�2�-e.��j �' _ ; ' �-� � � �_ , � �� -�- ��:��--� .�� ✓`�l L=� . �� , , � .-� ��'� . �'� .�� '�-�J . r � ? � .... _ C��v v/ •- '��1�'L'L-�i�G� '� - _. �� .�j �c-�L1 , � (�y"'�.p . �;�� .. ... _ ___ . , . _ f1 � !�P ^ � �Lr�I �...��4��t� ,��.► ✓� � -- ._. , ... �'�,�--�-� �;�� ; �,. r / !�,� G�.,� �. �l+� `��-'I ; Q-� --��` yL � Y � � � � . ! r..,� J _. � � �� r�,j��°_ .iL.( � �r�'� �LC� t ( � �// ' L�✓�"=T ��/��-��'f � � ��V� �� ,.�'ti2�G'%�G'L �i�/' �+ �i�1G G� (r^��21.t �� ' ' , .- � .� ,. < . , _ 5� a,� . � -- , : , . .., � . Q: .: . •�� ti � . �- , � � . � . ,. ' ' ,,_" ✓,t,...�.�� .�;{ 14' � � f - . . . . f.. . . . . : - . . . .. � . . . . . . � � .9 . �..� � ,.� .,, . � _ . . . . " . _ .. . � � . r�, � ��: .��.. � .. . . . ' � t� I� � . . .� . . , . ,. . . . . . .., �.. �` . . . .. . .��.. - . f . . . ��. � ..' '.. . ' . ,• . . . . . - �, . . . �., �i+ � � . _ . . .�. . � �� _� . . , . � , . -. . . . , . . . . - . ,� .� . . . . .. r,:, —ti._,..e. �iA�Y, ? ' . • -.. ' ' . - . . .. „ . f . , �.. t- v . `-:� �,;, .� , . �-t . �, , , ', . � .' .' e w; s ' � . . . . ; ; • . � . . � ,'� - . � • ,, ,. ., I .,, '�- ,;�. � ' .,�,� t�- 4- -, � . `` �-� . _, . . P� + , . - �. . � .. ' ! ,�.�.� . � � .4��', � - . ._ . - .' - ��r 1 p_.p dt I , � _,� � �` y �1 . +_ ,�l�`C� '='4� 9 ' L . � ( �- • ��..l�� 1 S'C�'1�� ,o � `p :c t "° � '� '� ` , \��`O �� a 7 � - �or- ` . \�� „C(V � sr • x '\�` . +\�,�,�� . �+t _ =a� , o � u- N �u�. �� ; f- �; ,,, : . 1. � l:.t� � . . ; _ :.... �: G� y/,` ( r� 1 _r �t � ,..��.... . �� ..`r , . ` ., .V, 4�r�p�IQtl.. R�A�5 G�S \�`��u�J. T'�11 . . , " "'i. ... _ � � . . . . t ° ' c� Lo� 15 and1G , L31oc�k F'1 Laut�on t� j � p 4 ; � ' 6 � C3�os. �d��-io►-� ;Rurrsec� Couh�� 2 , : .;'a" i �' t��h±n�so-�o,. I � a Ty P'�� !' � 'h�'.. �..r ,T- �,.g b JL ; F . . . ~A i��.Y i\'.��1',. ��.� . . � � ,'�! ; . �l1�YlQ.C': S�CQ�� 0•� � � i I � � d1$�p,� �� i --T ---- ---- -- Les s e a.: s i rr Ay o-H-� ; � � � i i '� � ; �, Addre y S �(�8 5. 5m�� , ; , � . I ,� S E,�Y lG� `�`t'Q�T 10� �L.�� ' �, I 'a� �J �C- � I � � � ', � � i . ' i , , � � NoQ�r� , `-`.-�" 7. ,� . ..r �'-''—_ ____..t / 1 � � , � �� `�-�- - - - - - - - -� _ _ � �o�e . I " = 10' i �a�-e � 9-28-6$ �� , �- I �- -�-- — -- - --� � SIoPe ;�_�t�-;» _ _ a�, � I � � � .� � (ancro�e �eri�eh� --�---_.�- ' � � �'��.�`s�.�� .�� - i _.. ........ _ I .. �...._. �- o i I � � Iin l'! � IkJ l� V tl� �� . v � '_� � �__.``` , I . __�__. � .� N ov � �ssa � �,o��_, �` � -� � , CITY PLNN iV i fVG �OARD � � �� a� � Saint Pauf, Minnesot: _� , —�� Q ; —�� i��;� � �:.. �� 1__ --- ------- — — � ----_ __– ----- ---------- - - - - _�s, p„R � _ - _ - � - -- - - ; ` , / : . � „.- , �=6�� S�d�u?al�. �� , - - `; < � . ��' l -- -- - ------ ----- ---- --� __ -_ ___----_. ___ � -- -------- --- ----- } i � � _ q' '�lu 1 ,� , _ `\, � } . ',,�, ` i � _ __------- —_ ___- - -- - - — — � � , , — -- ,_. _... _._.—� _ . ,� �s C-x�s�mc, ��r��Y�., - I • I , � I:. y I . 1, . Ca � . r ... - .. .. . . . � 4`1'io __.. 31�-0 .,� ; j'�,,' , .:. �.__ -----___ __- - ------ -------- __.___ • . . . . , �---- _ - . , . . . .,. . , _ , .- ;. � � c �11 i 1�-� t-=�`�� - � . �� ' ; . � . . - 4.L �. . ' �UQ,d `��r2�1� , � ' , ''. { �;i , . , ; - ,; � r ' � • � . i : . ' j _ . . � , ,; 1 , � , ' , . , . i '