The URL can be used to link to this page

244535 ,Ori�inal to Ctty Clerk . ' . , , �� ' ORDINANCE �� COUNCIL FILE NO PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO �� An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, per- taining to Use Districts, Height Districts and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, as amended. � THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section l. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, ` inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, per�aining to Vse Districts, Height Districts and Rezoning of certain pro- perties in the City of Saint Paul, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property on the terms and conditions expressed herein from "A" Residence District to Commercial property, to-wit: Lot 4, Block 2, J. A. Humphrey' s Subdivision "A" ; situate on the south side of Montana Avenue 120 feet west of White Bear Avenue in the City •f Saint Paul. Section 2. The property described above is subject to the following terms and conditions : l. That, subject to any further reclassification of the - hereinabove described real estate by virtue of proceedings there-- for hereinafter instituted, conducted and completed according to the applicable provisions� of said Zoning Code, effective as of the date of said petition for reclassification and the applicable provisions of the statutes of the State of Minnesota, hereby, the employment of said real estate henceforth is restricted and limited to the following specified use, to-wit: Commercial District for the con- struction of a parking lot only by the petitioner and property owner, subject to all applicable statutes, ordinances , rules and regulations prescribed and pro- mulgated by governmental agencies having cognizance. Yeas Councilmen Nays Pasaed by the Counci� Carlson Dalgliah In Favor Meredith Peterson Against Sprafka Tedesco Mr. President (Byrne) Approved• Attest: � City Clerk --��-�G �O � Form approved Corporation Counsel By��1 �� OriQinll to City Clerk • , . .r • • � �-Y� ,,T ORDINANCE �� COUNCIL FILE NO PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO 2. That the owner of said real estate, within the period of sixty (60) days next succeeding the publication of this ordinance, shall file with the City Clerk, in two (2) fully executed counterparts , said owner' s written acceptance of this ordinance, incorporating, among other things, said owner� s grant unto said City of Saint Paul of a negative easement affecting said real estate, for the imposition, maintenance and enforcement of the aforesaid conditions, restrictions and limitations �pon the employment and use of the property described herein, approved as to form and execution by the Corporation Counsel and recordable in the office of the Register of Deeds and said negative easement and restrictive conveyance shall be drawn to exclude all uses permitted in Commercial Dis— trict. 3. That, in addition to other requirements therefor, said own.erts written acceptance and grant of negative easement shall incorporate a certified copy of this ordinance, and immediately upon the aforesaid filing of the same the City Clerk shall cause one of such counterparts thereof to be filed of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publica— tion. JUL � 1969 Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council Carlson j Dalglish � �O 7n Favor Meredith S�� Againat Tedesco Mr. President ,grne) au� � ��&� App d: A est: - - � Ci Cler Mayor �O Form approved Corporation Counael By - ru�t�t J�'L 12 196g DaplIeate b Printer ORDINANCE ��4�� COUNCIL FILE NO PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO � An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislati.ve Cod�, per- t�in�.ng to Use Districts, Height Distriete and Rezoning o� certain propertiea in the City oY Saint Paul, as amended. T� COUNCIL OF THE CITY GF SAINT PAUL DUES OR.DAINs Seetion 1. That the �oning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclueive, o� the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to Use Distriets, Height �istricts an.d Rezoning of certain pro- perties in the City oY �aint Paul, as amended, be and the same is hereby �urther amended sa as to rezone the following deseribed property on the termg and conditions expressed herein from "A" Residence District to Commercial property, to-wit: Lot 4, Block 2, J. A. Humphrey' s Subdivision "A" ; situate on the �outh side of rSontana Avenue 120 feet west af White Hear Ave�nue in the City of Saint Paul. Section 2. The property deacribed above is sub�ect to the �ollowing terms and conditions: 1. That, �ubject to any further reclasaification o� the hereinabove des�aribed real estate by virtuE of proceedings there- for herein��ter instituted, conducted and completed aecording to the applicable praviaions of said Zoning Code, effeetive as of tY�e date of said petition for reclae�ifieat3on and the applic�,ble provisions o� the statutee of the State of Minnesota, hereby, the employment of said real eetate henesYorth is restricted and limited to the following speeiYied use, to-wit: Commercial Distrfet Yor the con- struetfon of a parkin� lot os�Iy by the petitioner an�3 property own.er, subject to all applicabie etatutes, ordinaneea, rules and regulations prescribed and pro- mulgated by �overnmental agenciea ' having; co�nizance. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council Carlson Dalgliah Tn Favor Meredith Peterson Against Sprafka Tedesco Mr. President (Byrne) Approved• Attest: City Clerk Mayor O Form approved Corporation Counsel By DaD��iate to Printer ORDINANCE 244�� COUNCIL FILE NO PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO " ' �`� 2. That the owwner of said real estate, within the period of sixty (60) days next sueceeding the publication o�' this ordinance, shall �ile with the City Clerk, in two (2) fully executed counterparts, said owner' e written acceptance of this ordinance, incorporating, among other things, said owner' s grant unto said City o� Saint Pau1 of a ne�ative easement a��ecting said �ea1 estate, for the impoaitian, maintenance and enforcement o:P the a�orQ�aid eonditions, restrictions and limitatinns upon the amploym�nt a,nd use of the property d�;seribed herein, approved as to �orm and execution by the Corporation Counsel and recordable in the of�ice of the Register of Deeds and said n.egative easement and restrietive conveyance shall be drawn to exelude �11 uses permitted in Commercial Dis- trict. 3. That, in addition to other requirements therefor, said owner' s written aeceptance and �ra,nt o� negative easement shall incorporate a certiffed aopy of this ordinance, and immediately upon the aforesaid Piling o�' the same t�e City C1erk shall cause one of �uch counterparts thereof to be filed of record in the o��ice of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey Caunty, Minnesota. Section 3. This ordinance shali take effect and be in foree thirty (30) days from and a�ter its passage, approval and publica- tion. . ,Ut: a ]9�� Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council Carlson 6 Dalglish In Favor Meredith � n � A ainst Sprafka � �� Tedesco �� Mr. President (Byrne) Approved: Attest: City Clerk Mayor O Form approved Corporation Counsel By ` . , � � . ,. K ..3 ` � Q � . � CITY OF SAINi' PAUL, NiINNESOTA pETITION TO AI�tEM1 CHAPTEItS 60 thru 64 Or THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CDDE , Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses pormitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the ' rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. . , (Please type or print) � ' Date: J� 20, 1968 TO THE HUi�'ORABLE MAYOR AZVD CITY COUIvCIL � . c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall . � City of Sair.t Paul, blinnesota , . pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of • the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50�, or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) ► Lot �+, Block 2,�JA Humphrey's Subdivision "A" to the City of St. Paul. S� _ . �� . from "p" Residence District to Commercial Dis�rict, for the "'( � °' purpose of installing, constrvcting and/or operating the following; � (describe briefly the proposed facility) � � Off-street parking lot in con,junction �rith existing filling station. � RECORD OiYNER SIGNATURE IAT BIACK ADDITION Subject property: • �,�� JA Humphrey's . � " -�,�� -�L't-�-=, Subdivision "A" . � � -- ;�i�/J � 1�2�3 � Fred Herri L�.v�-;�y �6 2 „ �g 2�+,25 Ben Gleeman • �"��-s/' _�.P,>�� 26 2 " 28,29 � Ben Gleeman „f,��,,,,�.,,.,/ � „ Gus 1�'elson 2b'25 I . „ � _ /' 28,29 Fred Herri /L��L-�- ` p 1 " c; 4' • �Late of �tillnnesota ( ' � � '� " County of i�K��'y( ( ss _ ,_ � '' . i� . �.., Hennepin . � " iCeith G. Holvenstot being first duly s�sorn, deposes and states that he is Lhe person who circUlated the within petition consistirig of ` �ne pages; that the parti�es described above are'the owners respectively of the lots placed ir:;.,ediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said awners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above� are the true 3nd correct signatures. of each and All of the parties so described. Subscrft,ed and sworn to before me ' this -� � � � �/ _� `�=,;,�day of ��t , �G ��' �� ,.�J � �, �' ,,..� _ "► . �/ � ddress; "-' -' c v�✓� ��.- , � � „�; ,.�, A �So7 W.78th St. Bloomin�ton,Minn. h.,ta.•P�blic ' . t--- •-�--r� Telephonc .lo. 920-7020 , f:y cor.:,ission �X�_rr i�ountY, Minn. Approved a� to form 1/4/65 I :'GI ti 5/�� HQRRY H. KNAPP Office of the Cor�oration Counse� ,..�.� No�ary p„blic, NonnepSn County, MFnn. / �^�.- / A',� Comiali�iaa Expiros Apidl 24, 1949. �/ J %//� ( ��f C. l.;S O /1/ �L I^� �� . / �- ' /..---- i -�� ` f , W , ��= �}� � � � r . � . �� ' . . , � •;;� ,:.,�� - • ' � . w � ._ _ ,, ,. _ _ _ � �..� :� ,, �_ _ , _ � ' ' � �`3 � O . . � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA PET7TION TO AMEND �HAP'PERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- . fication before signing this petition. Fpr further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. , (Please type or print) � �ate: June 20, 1968 TO THE HUNORABLE MAyOR AND CITY COUNCIL . � c/o the City Clerk, F{oom 386 City Hall . City O$ Sail^it Pa41� bSi;�nesota Pursuant to Section 64�,06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet'°of �° . the real estate affected, hereby acc}uiesce; and we, the owners of 50� or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property: (Legal de�scription and street address) � Lot 4 Block 2 �JA H ' �� „ sl(,J � , , umphrey s Subdivision A to the City of St. Paul. � �� from "A" Residence District to CommerCial District, for the "'! �' purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following; �k`�„ (describe briefly the proposed facility) "`�+� Off'-�tr�et parking lot in ec�uncticn �rith existing fil.lf.ng station. � °; RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Subject Property; • � JA Humphrey s � . Subdivision "A" ,. - Fred Aerri � 1'6'3 2 rr 24,25 Ben Gleeman . �r�� 6 „ Bea Gleeman 28,29 r� ! Gus Nelson � 2 '�5 26 2 " : 28�� Fred Herri /Le , , � 1 �� _. , � � s I : ' . � - . . � c r�� . . _ � . � . � � .�i..�" , . . . ...;�..'�' .. . . `, . . � - ' � , .�..� � ��• . . . . . � �:J -3:a a�af.e �i �vtinnesota ( �' �._` • �1 : � County of�C ( ss �;' �; � .,�, � Hennepin . , • :'., � Keith G. Holvenstot being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he ' �'�� +, is the person who cixcuiated the within petition consisting of � one Page=; � that the parties described above are'the owners respective?y of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said � , ou�ner: in the presence of this affiant, and that the sig�tures above� are the true -" and carrect signatures. of each and �ili of the parties sa:,�scribed. Subscribed and sworn to before me �� this �'l-� day of i 6 d .c� � �r�',.,� �.,� . / ��"�` , Address: �567 W.78th St. Bloomir�gton�l�`inn. �� =�'��'�� =' Telephone No, 92a7o2o N..�ary �u�l c, , ixiounty, Minn. ls:v con:mission Cxp_r Approved as to form 1/4/65 HARitY H. KNAPP offi�^e of the Corporation Counsel ?GT 1�S�o5 Notary M'bik. H�an�pin Cow�tY. Mim► � c.w.w�.. ��+u. �+w� /`/a T//=`r' ��l c.K S o ni ��T. c.-,° . - °�` ��'b w . �� . . _ '� 1��NR�Al a `- . , � � .� C- , — � D:.�';� G:' I'�C:r'T'I;� �.AS�t�i 1 !?ND �iCG�PI.'AIv'Cr. OF ORt�IT�tANCE s4� 2'3�S I�E"�.'�:,�, ma3c; anc�. exec.�ted thi� �� day of� , 19�, b�r an� b��wr�e� Fr.ed S. Herring �c� F?orence M. Iierring, husband and wife, of the Coun�;y of Ra.�sey, State of P•iinnesot�., hereinaftc�r designmted "the first parties", a.nd CITY OF SAINT P�UL, herein�fter designated "the second p�,x~t;3*"� 41IT1`E:SETH: WHE�,EAS, the first parties, on and �'or a considerable period of t�!e nex� precsc�ir�s i:he 12th day o� July, 196g, were s.�..nd ever since, said date h�.ve be�n the o��mers in fae sim:,�le, of aL7. of the following described real estate situate in the City of' S:�int Paul, County of Ramsey, State of Minnesota, to-s-rit: I.ot Four (4), Block Two (2), J. A. Humphrey's Suodivision A to the City of St. Paul, Ramsey County, State of Minnesota, situate an the Sou�h Side o:f Montana Avenue, 120 fPet W�si; of White 73ear Avenue in the City of S�.int Pau]L. WHER�AS, said real. estate on said date and for a co�siderable period o� tine next preceding tne sames was zoned and classified in "A" Residence l�i:�tra.c-t under and by virtue of Ch�.pters 60 to 64, inclusive, Zoning Code, Saint ��a�,al Le�isl�tive Code, as �.mended, and pursuant to the petition of' the first ��.�ies the Council of the seeand pa:°ty, aecording to th� provisions of said 2oning Cod.e, as �,mended, and the Statu°L•es of the State of Minnesots, in such cases m�de and provided�, with the �•ri�ten acquiescenc� of the owners of two-thirds of the severa? descripta.ons of rea1 estate situa.ted within 100 feet of said real estate, duly enac�ed City of Saint Pa.u1 Ordinance No. 14221, approved July 8�h, 1969, �,i�. published in the Officiel Newspaper of the second party on the 12th of J�al.y, 19b9, amending said Zoning Code, as a.mende�, so th�,t said hereinabove described real estate w�as thereby �nd thex�evnder rezoned and reclassified from "A" Resid�nce Da.stxict ta Conmercia.]., sub ject to �sneci.P.1 exceptio�s and consiitions in the nat:;x�: of especial restri�tlans upon the use of th� �a�.� whercby the u�� nc1 e�^.�:.�;��r_er': ��f ��.id ii�rtiri�Uo�e descr�.bed rea3. cs�tr�.�e �ras restr�ct�d #,� �.:�e fo�..I 7w�.n�r uses and CTII�3�Uy�l�:ills�:i 1 SU�/.��C� lIO iu��cl�ei r•e�onin� r�sxci reclaesi�'icaiio� of the sa�ne by rirtue of proczed�:�s th�r+�for thereafter instituted, conciucted �d co�leted, according to applicable provisions of said Zoning Code, as P.mended, and of statutes oi' the State of Minnesota, to-�rit: Com�ercial Distriet for the construction oP a parking lot only by the petitioner and property owner, sub�ect to all applicable statutes, ordinances, rules and regulations prescribed and pro- mulgated by governmental agencies hsving cognizance. W"HEREAS, the first parties, for themselves, their he3rs, administr�tors, exzcutors and e,ssigns, intend hereby to accept said Ordinance No. 1�+221, a.nd to provide for the imposition, maintenance, and enforcement of such espe¢3.a7. restri.ctions upon the use oa said hereinabov�e described real estate to run with the ].anci �ncl to grant unto the second party, in further compliance with the cond�.tions of said Ordinance No. 1�+221, a negative easement therefor; � N�T, THEREFORE, the first paxties, as such aWn,ers of said hereinabov� described reE1 estat�, for themselves, their heirs, adminictraturs, executors, and �,ssigns, do hereby covena.nt a.nd bind themselves� their heirs, administra.tors, execu�ars, and assigns, unto the second party that, in accordance with said Zoning Cod.e, as amended, particularly �s the same has been amended by said Ordinance No. 1�+221, said real estate Y�.as been effectively restricted and li�i.t�:d in respect of its use and erapl.oyment and sha11 henceforth be restricted and limi.ted in such particulars as follo�rs, to-wit: Thr�t� subject to ar�y further reclassifica,tion of the hereinabove described real estate by virtue of proceedings therefor hereinafter ins�Lituted, conducted and completed according to the applica.ble provisions of said Zoning Code, effective as of the date of said pei:ition for reclassi�ication and the applicable provisions oY the statutes of the State of Minnesota, hereby, the employment of said real estate henceforth is restra.cted and limited to the follo•rring specified use, to-wit: Cornrnercial Distr�.ct for the con.struction of a parking lot only by �he petitioner and property owner, �ub�ect to all applicable �f��ute�, ordinances, r�il.e:� and regulAtians preacribed a.nd a;o�ulgated by goverur.-��ta1 agencies �ving cognizance. _ 2 - and the said pa±rties, for the�e�.ves, their �eirs, e,dmtnistrators, executors, and assi�ns hereby grant, convey �aa warra.nt un�:,o the second party, said City o� Sai.nt Paul, as such munic;pal corporation, �n trust for the bene�'it of the public, a perpetual negative easeneut i� and to said hereinabove !iescribed real7. estate and al]. thezeoP, for �he imposition, ma.intenance �,n�d enforcement byr the secand � - part;�, as such municip�l. corporation, of' the aforesaid restrictions and limi.ta- tion� upori the use a.nd employment of said hereinabove describea real estate, to run frith the land, and for �ood and value considera.tion, the receipt and sufficiency whereof by the first parties hereby axe acknawledged, FURTHER, the first p�rties make reference to said Zoning Co3e, as amend.ed, and by rcf erence incorparate the same herein; as part hereof, �rith the $ame intent� purpose and effect as if said Zoning Code, as anended, Were fully set forth herein; and make further reference to said anendatory Ordina.nce I�o. 1�+221 to the duly certified copy of the same hezeto attached and hereby incorporated Y.�rei�a by reference as part hereof; a.nd said first parties, for themselves, their heirs, administrators, executors an.d assigns, hereby accept said amendatory Ord3nance No. 1�221, and every provision, term, and condition of the same without reservation or excep-tion. _ IN TESTIMOIVY WI�REOF, said firsi: parties, Fred. S. Herrin� an.d Florenee M. Herri�g, Y�usban.d. r�,nd, wa.fe, have set their hands to this instrument as of thc day a.nd year f3�rst above written. • In sence Of: �� ; � •� L�G�� - . �'}'' Fre S. Herring ��=� � �.�� , � � Florer_ce �. Herri STATE OF NL[NNES4TA) �� COUIrPrY OF HEI��PIN) � . On this ��ay of , 19�, before me, a notary public with�.nand for said County, personally appeaxed Fred S. Hexring �nd Florence M. Herring, to me known to be the persons described in, and who execu�ed the foregoing instrument, end ack�owlec�ged that they executed �he same as their free �,ct and deed. � � � .EORM APPROVED Notr�ry Pu�Iic, Hen:P;��ri Cn�S AS:,.�n. t015 E. HORSCH, � commission expire� �Otiry�°bi'�,Honne�ihiCqunty,Minn. Asst. Corporation Counsel �--M°fcsmnn:s9an-e��rx�E z3, 1976. (SEAL) Narry E. Marshall Mbert B. Olson City Clerk and �`T'' �F Council Recorder Commisioner of Registration a��' y� � �-� � .. a � V'y� ' �1 � .. , ... . M^` t�l�,�_ � OFFICE OF THE CITY, CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS �86 City Ha.11 St.Paul,Minnesota 5510,°L o _, ' .� . y , , �� . � Sept. 13, 1968 , , ;, ;� , : , � � . . � �r" �, , � e j . � . � :� , ,_.. y � � , , t _ � � . _ __ Mr. F�ederick S. Herring, , , � , 1716 E. Hyacinth St., �� ,� St. Pat11, Minn. '�• k °�. Deax Sir: The Commissioner of Finance today reported to the City Council that your petition to rezone Lot �+, Block 2, J. A. Humphrey's Subdvn. "A", located approximately 120 ft. west of the southwest corner of White Bear Ave. and Montana Ave., to Commercial District, is insufficient. For this reason, the Council cannot act further in this matter. Very truly yours, ,�Cllcr�r��' City Clerk �,� hp O CITY OF�• SAINT PAUL � MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 December 20, 1968 City Clerk FiZe X585, Page You are hereby noCified that a public hearing will be he2d in the Council Chambers of the City Aall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on January 3, 1964, on the petition of Frederick S. Herring to rezone from a "A" Residence District to a "Commercial" District Lot 4, Block 2, J. A. Humphrey's Subdivision "A" St. Paul, Minn. The property is located approxianately 120 feet west of the southwest corner of White Bear and Montana Avenues. . For further information contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Coaenerce Building or phone 223-4151. JAMES J. DALGLISH CoBmnissioner of Finanee 55 � ERICKSON PETROLEUM CORPORATION 456� WEST 78TH STREET MINNEAPOLIS,MINNESOTA 55431 Januax'Y 3, 1969 Mr. President, and Co�unissioners ' • City Council City of St. Paul St. Paul, Mina. File %625 Gentlemen: � Our Compar�y, having a vested inte:�est in the land aWned by Mr. Fred Eerring and being the same paxcel under considera.tion, speak to the issue O� R@�ZOII1IIg. ' We f eel the action of the Zoning Board in reco�mmending denial of this petition wa.s ill-considered because: . (1) The use of the additional land axea as off-street parking is a compatible use for the existing filling station and store which fronts on � White Beax Avenue and has the approval of the traffic engineer. (2) The rear line of the Commercial Zoning (xest of White Bear Avenue) is not Btrai�ht. The rezoning of the parcel under consideration would not extend the Commercial Zoning generally but would tend to make the rear line � of the zoning district more uniform. As a matter of �'act, even with the rezoning the commercial distr3ct oP the ad.3acent land would still extend Yurther to the west. (3) The total depth of the proposed Commercial Zone would be 160' (1,20�presently zoned and �0' under petition) a.nd is in agreement with the recommendations of the Comprehensive Rezoning Plan of the City. (4) The neighbors and ad3acent land owners who appeared at the Zoning board public hearing had no specific ob�ections to the establishmerrt o�' off- street parking at this location, but did seem to have serious problems of drainage in the entire axea. Pictures exhibiting winter and spring conditions . were shown a.nd these people were even told by Board Members: "You have a v�ery serious problem but it is not �rith the petitioners, it is �tith the Public Works Dept." and. comments were made that indicated storm sewer entrances were higher in elevation than surrounding areas. The land oWners present were , advised to seek correction directly �rorn Public Works Department. In sumivasy, we feel the Council should grant this peti�ion for rezoning because such action would seem to Pol1oW the principles of good planning; because greater deve2opment and en�oyment would accrue to the land owner and tenants; . and because no adverse eff ects have been demonstrated. Sincerely, ERICKSOPT PETROLEUM CORPORATION � �� Keith G. Holvenstoty Agent � I�GH:ms � _ ERICKSON PETROLEUM CORPORATION 4367 WEST 78TH STREET MINNEAPOLIS,MINNESOT'A 55431 aanuarr 3, 19�'9 Mr. President, and Coamnissioners City Council City o� St. Paui St. Paul, Minn. FYle %625 Gentlemen: Our Company, ha.v3ng a vested interest in the lend oWned by Mr. Fred Herring and being the same parcel under considerati.on, speak to the issue of Re-zoning. . We feel the sction of the Zoning Board in recomm�ending denial of this ' petition was ill-considered because: (1) The use of the additional land area as off'-street parking is a compatible use �or the existing �illing station and store vhich fronts on � White Bear Avenue and has the approval of the traffic engineer. (2) The rear line of the Coannercial Zoning (Wes�t of White Beax Avenue) � is not stra.ight. The rezoning of the paxcel under consideration would not extend the Cammercial Zoning generally but `+rould tend to ma�e the reax line of the zoning district more uniform. As a aaatter of Yact, evea with the rezonin� the commercial district of the ad�acent land would still. extend further to the west. (3) The total depth of the proposed Commercial Zone woul.d be 16�' (120'Presently zoned arid �0' under petition) and. is j.n agreement with the recommendations of the Comprehensive Rezoning Plan of the City. (4) The neighbors a.nd. adjacent la,nd owners who appeared at the Zoning board public hearing had no specific ob�ections to the establishment of o�f'- street pa,rking at this loca.tion, but did seem to have serious problems of drainage in the entire area. Pictures exhibiting winter and spring cond.itions . were shown and these people were even told by Board Members: "You have a very : serious problem but it is not With the petitioners, it is with the Public Works Dept." and comments were made tha.t indicated storm sewer entrances were higher in elevation than surrnunding axeas. The land o�rners present were advised to seek correction directly from Public Works Department. In summary, we feel the Counc�.l should grant this petition for rezoning because such action would seem to follow the principles of good planning; beca.use greater developmient and en3oyment would accrue to the land owner and tenants; and, because no adverse effects have been dem,�nstrated. 8incerely� ERICKSON PETROLEUM CORPORATION • � �� - . Keith G. Holvenstot, Agent . � � �^.H:ms � ERICKSON PETROLEUM CORPORATI�N 4567 WEST 78TH STREET MINNEAPOLIS,MINNESOTA 55431 - danuary 3, 19�'9 Mr. President, and Commissioners City Council City of St. Paul St. Paul, Minn. File X-625 Gentlem�en: � Oar Compar�y, having a vested interest in the land oKned by Mr. F'red Herring and being the same paxcel under consideration, speak to the isswe oP Re-zoning. We feel the action of the Zoning Board in recommending denial of this petition was ill-considered because: ' (1) The use of the additional land area as off-street pe�rking is a compatible use; for the existing filling station and, store which fronts on : � White Beax Avenue and has the approval of the traff'ic engineer. (2) The rear line of the Co�ercial Zoning (xest of White Bear Avenue) is not straight. The rezoning of the parcel under consideration would not e�cteud the Cammercial Zoning generslly but would tend to make the rear line � the zoning district more uniPorm. As a matter of fact, even with the rezoning the c�aanercial district of' the ad�acent land `rould still extend further to the;west. (3) The total depth of the proposed Cammercial Zone would be 160' (��presently zoned and �+0' under petition) and is in agreeanent with the recommendationi of the Comprehensive Aezoning Plan of the City. (�) The neighbors and ad�acent land owners who appeared at the Zoning board public heaxing had no specific ob�ections to the establishment of o�f- street parking at this location, but did seem to have serious problems of drainage in the entire axea. Pict�ares exhibiting winter and spring conditions were shown and these people were even told by Board Members: "You have a very serious problem but it is not kith the petitioners, it is with the Public Works Dept." and comments were ma.de that indicated storm sewer entrances were higher in elevation than surrounding areas. The land oWners present were ad.vised to seek correction directly from P�zblic Works Depart�nt. In s�unm�ary, we �eel the Council should grant this petition for rezoning because such action would seem to fbllow the principles of good pla.nning; beca.use greater development and en3oyment would accrue to the land owner and tenants; and because no adverse effects have been demonstrated. _ Sincerely, ERIGKSON PETROLEUM CORPORATION , ,�.r1 � ,��-�� Keith G. Holvenstot, Agent �GH:ms - . ` ERICKSON PETROLEUM CORPORATION 4567 WEST 78TH STREET MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55431 January 3, 1969 Mr. President, and Ca�n3.ssioners ' City Cauncil City of St. Paul . , St. Pa,ul, Minn. Fi1e X-625 ' Gentlemen: • Our Compaay, having a vested inte:rest in the land o�ned by Mr. Fred Herring and being the same parcel under consideration, speak to the issue of Re-zoning. . We feel the action of the Zoning Board in recomm�ending denial of this petition was il].-considered because: (1) The use of the additional land area as off-street parking is a compatible use for the existing filling station and store which fronts on White Bear Avenue and has the approval of the traffic eagineer. (2) The rear line of the Coamiercial Zoning (west of White Beax Avenue) is not strai�ht. The rezoning of the paxcel under conside�tion would not �zt,end_ the Coaam�ercial Zoning generally but would tend to make the rear line of the zoning district more unit'orm. As a matter of �'act, even with the rezoning the commercial district of the ad�acent land w�uld still extend. feirther to the west. (3) The total depth of the proposed Commercial Zone would be 160' (].20�presently zoned and �+0' under petition) and is in agreem�ent with the recommendations of the Comprehensive Rezoning Plan of the City. (4) The neighbors and ad�acent land owners who appeared st the Zoning board public heaxing had no specific ob�ections to the establishment of off- street parking� at this location, but did seem to ha.ve serious problems of drainage in the ent3xe axea. Pi.ctures exhibiting winter and spring conditions . were shown and these people w�ere even told by Board Members: "You have a very serious problem but it is not With the petitioners, it is with the Public Works Dept." and co�une�ts were made that indicated storm sewer entrances were higher in elevation than surrounding areas. The land oWners prese�t were , advised to seek correction directly from Public Works Department. In summaxy, we feel the Counc3l should grant this petition for rezonin� because such action would seem to follow the principles of good pla.n.ning; because greater development and en3oyment would accrue to the land owner and tenants; .and because no adverse effects ha.ve been dem,�nstrated. Sincerely, ERICK.SOlY FETROLEUM/CORPORATION � ' � ' � •C./L'L�s'V � N C��r��(�C//�� . . . � Keith G. Holvenstot, Agent . �GH:ms CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 March 21, 1969 City Clerk File X585, Page POSTPONED HEARING You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on April 3, 1969 on the petition of Frederick S. Herring to rezone from a "A" Residence District to a "Commercial" District, Lot 4, $lock 2, J. A. Humphrey's Subdivision "A" St. Paul, Minn. The property is located approximately 120 feet west of the southwest corner of White Bear and Montana Avenues. For further information contact Planning Board, Room 1010 Commerce Building or phone 223-4151. JAMES J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance O � t1 � ' � V • BOA1tD OF 7ANING RBPORT AND ACTiON Novasbsr 21, 1968 Piat Map 34 Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 File No. passed August 22, 1922 as amended to August 24, 1964 6603 _ , Also 1. APPLICANr'S NA1� : Frederick S. Herring � 6640 5373 2. CLAS3IFICATION � � Amendment � Appeal �Permit ❑ Other � 3. PURP03E � Rezoae "A" Residence to Commarcial district to allow off-strsat parking lot 4. LOC,ATION � South siil� of Nantana Aveaue, 120 feat wsst of White Bear Avenw �. I.BGAL DE3CRIPTION � Lot 4, Block 2� J. A.Hu�phrey's Subdivision "A" 8. PRESENT ZONINE4� . ; �,nAn R�i�dOD�" 7. PURSiTAH'P .TO �aqi,p� Coc�e Cbap�e�, -64.O�i Section: Paragraph: �s ' � . 8. 3TAFF' I�1Y�8'FT�fi�l'�'��t�; ;��e:. Zlt/12/68 By: CLS $ � A, SU_ F_ F��E�•"Y,;� • : ��,'�:�`�;��I �ufficisnt by th� Commissiaaner of Financa ,�� it� t "t't�c' d�d S�g'�sr�lr �E+�, �68 wGith 13 of a possible 17 owaers having siga�d -tl��#�ti t78'°.��). B. HI_STORY^ An appsal under Chapt�r 64.03, Sectioa (1), Paragraph (2) for a 17-unit apartm�nt buildiag was graated for Lots 4, 5, 6, 7 on February 1, 1964. ` (Apartments in "A" Rssid�tnoa adjoining a Conmercial district) A permit for a 17-unit building r�as approvsd on the site. Th� buildfng, ho�+ever, was not � coastructed. The app�al has lapaed and this procedurs is no longer valid. � C. PROP06ED USE: It is propossd to dsvalop th� site with a parking lot for tbe : �:, a��ng filliag s�tation and retail store adjoining� to the east. ' " D. AREA AND FRONTAGE: The sitt has a frontmge of 4fl faet aloag Moaitana Avenue and ank arsa o , 60 sq�ar� f��t. E. AREA ZQNINGs Franta�p along the west sid� of White 8ear Avenue is zan�d Co�rcial. ;� The srsa to ths �st is sonsd "A" Rssideac�. F. COMPREHE�iSIYE PLAN: Recorads tbe cow�rcial dawlopaisnt alang Wl'iite Bsar Avenue ° t to a fraatage dspth of approximat�ly 125 to 150 feet and ths area to the �+�ast b� classifi�d R-+�, on�s and txo family. � G. SITE CONDITZONS: Sit• is at atrset grsds and l�vsl but bigher than adj�cent propsrC.�. to th� i+sst. Ths sita has no carb or sideralic. , H. AREA CONDITIONS: To tlk north is a��s�ac�ntly canatruet�d 23-uait apartmsat buildfng ;_ and to ths east and aouth is coaMSrcial dsv�lopn�nt. Qn ths ti+sat is aingl.m fa�i�.y �wlopmeat. ; ,'* _� j 9. BQARD AGTIONt To Re�oa�end ❑ APProval Q Deniai Council Lt. Yoved by: Dated !lCPsrtlin Yeas Nays x Anes. � Seconded by: ��r x Gohen Date of IieariAg Janes,�h�. x x �taPaxtlin Council Actioa � Secretary•s remaz�lcs: Haaxst3ek - Alt. x Gstdler Date � a '. , , Ysietta , ., � ' � ,��. KOTICL3�ON TI� BACK OF THiS B�ET i �. � � �. ' : ' � � . .. , ., ,� lo A � `i � � ` y � � �� ,. '� . , ♦: - � •� –�— ---- ------- ,. . I � .� � L ~ a � � ► � � C�o � `� . 1 � � . r � a. e�.--- �----- � x � � . � � r •` ` O i` . ` —_ � ` r� ' � _ _ 1` . � � �; . � n '�`� - ---- -- � - C.� . � GJ z ;�` � C� , � _.._. �� ' � ---��.—. ---- -_--� , � y � � Z..,� - � �U _ ,� I U► . G,� �i, , i�: � C t a Z � � � c � � � , . � � _ , ,, -- + � � - r � S �, � J <v � '` � �� i , C r (T� i i �, j I . � jJ ; '� Or _ �--- - ' a ` — � � ' . y:_ � � �� . � .'. ' . .. . . �� II � � � � i\! a ; � �� 'R- � ..... ...,,r= - ... .. _- � . � � - � �. . . .= . . . ,/"� . . . A � � � _ � .. - � � '� /� C . ?� � Q --. ..- � .... � . --� � Q . . � . . '•'. �p :y . . . 3u 2 /2 4• 20 _ --'`."i2� :: 0 60 = iz�% 24 w - o � �� - -. - - -�f-01-�'� -B E�4 R- -- - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - A�� SUB.TECT PROPERTY: Lot 4, Block 2, JA Humphr ' •.b.isS�t' •'A•r--�o�` �''`�+ -- �' the City of St. Pau1 �, :. � � - � '��C�� . . ��,►ri `C.i t�, 'v[ ��:. '. . 4' :_ 2_.', , . .. .. . . . .. _-<- SCALE = 1" = 60' BOARD Or ZONING R.EPORT AND ACTION November 21, 1968 Plat Ma 34 P Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 File No. passed August 22, 1922 as amended to August 24, 1964 6603 . Also 1. APPLICANT'S NAIV� • F'rederick S. Herring � 6600 � 5373 2. CLASSIFIC�ITION • � Amendment � Appeal �Permit ❑ Other I 3. PURPOSE • Rezone "A" Residence to Commercial district to allow off-street parking lot 4. LOCATION • South side of riontana Avenue, 120 feet west of White Bear Avenue 5. I.EGAL DESCRIPTION � �t 4, Block 2, J. A.Humphrey's Subdivision "A" 6. PRESENT ZONING , "A" Residence 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64.Oti Section: Paragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & R,EPORT: Date: 11/12/68 By: CLS A. SUFFICIE;�ICY: The petition was declarad sufficiznt by the Commissioner of Finance in a letter dated Septer.u�er 24, 1968 with 13 of a possible 17 owners having signed the petition (76.50). B. HISTORY: An appeal under Chapter 64.03, Section (1) , Paragraph (2) for a 17-unit apartment building was granted for Lots 4, 5, 6, 7 on February 1, 1964. (Apartm�nts in "A" t�zsidence adjoining a Commercial district) A permit for a 17-unit building was approved on the site. The building; however, was not constructed. The appeal has lapsed and this procedure is no longer valid. C. PROPOSED USE: It is proposed to dsvelop the site with,a parking lot for the existing fillir.g station and rAtail store adjoining to the east. , • D. AREA AND FROi1TAGE: The site has a frontage of 40 feet along h4ontana Avenue and an area of 5,360 square feet. . E. AREA ZONI:TG: Frontage along the west side of White Bear Avenue is zoned Commercial. Tne area to the west is zoned r'A" Residence. . F. COhSPtZEHENSIVE PLA�v: Recoinmends "the commercial development along White B�ar Avenue De limited to a frontage depth of approximately 125 to 150 feet and the area to the west be classified R-4, one and two family. � G. SITE CONDITIO:VS: Site is at street grade and level but higher than adjacznt property to the wast. The site has no curb or sidewalk. H. AREA CONDITI02dS: To the north is a r�cently constructed 23-unit apartm�nt building and to the east and south is commercial development. Qn the west is single family development. � 9. .BOARD ACTION: To Recommend ❑ Approval QX Denial . CounciL Lt. • Dated Moved by: �IcPartlin Yeas Nays x Ames Seconded by: Gadler X Cohen Date of Hearing Janes,Chmn. X � x McPartlin Council Action Secretary•s remarks; Haarstick - Alt. • X Gadler Date . Maietta � LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET '� ' ' � 3 / , DEPARTMENT OF FlNANCE � y CITY OF SAINT PAUL � MINNESOTA I 13 Court House,b5102 ' � JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner LOUIS H.McKENNA,Deputy Commissioner Phone:223-4b46 , . September 13, �968 To the Council ' ' City of Saint Paul Gentlemen: I have checked the attached petitioa of Frederick S. Rerring, ' filed in the ffistter of rezoning, Lot 4, Block 2, J. A. Humphrey's Subdivision t`A'•. , The property fs located approximatel�y 120 feet west � of the southwest corner of White Bear Avenue and Montana A�enue, from a Class 'tA" Residence District to a "Commercial" District, and find that said petition is insufficient. . ou s very tru , . � _ �� .� James J. D�glish / �� Commissioner of Fi, ance , Re: R-585 . . • c.c. Hr. Ames N. R. Heiden . BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL ��'�� 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 January 2, 1969 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Dear Sir: This is written in response to the petition of Frederick S. Herring to rezone from "A" Residence to Commercial, property located on the south side of Montana Avenue one-hundred twenty (120' ) feet west of White Bear Avenue. This property is described as Lot 4, Block 2, J. A. Humphrey's Subdivision nA�� . The petitioner proposes to use this property to provide an off-street parking lot to be used in conjunction with an existing filling station on adjacent property to the east. This use requires commercial or less restrictive zoning. This matter was considered at the November 21, 1968 Board of Zoning meeting. The staff reported that while there is a need for additional off- street parking at this location, the proposal represents an encroachment on tne residential district to the west, and that neighborhood residents have indicated that previous commercial development has had a detrimental effect on the residential area by increasing a drainage and water ponding problem in this block. A petition against the rezoning, signed by twenty-four area residents, was noted. Mr. Keith Holvenstot, representing Erickson Oil Company, said that there was a need for additional off-street parking and that if there is a continuing problem of drainage, a properly constructed parking lot would probably prevent this. Mr. Kenneth Hansen, opposition, stated that there is a five foot difference in elevation west of White 13ear Avenue and that there was no water coming into nasements before the co�nercial development. Pictures were shown indicating a severe water ponding problem. It was the finding of the Board of Zoning that the present district line limiting commercial development is reasonable. Subsequently, the Board voted to recommend denial of this petition to rezone from "A" Residence to Commercial. Very truly yours, _ ', , , !' . � C !j / l �y.__-'" ��, � L, -� L-=r=(� ..r� �l/�� `/� :i`; L.L. � , �� George G. McPartlin Secretary " , �, e��ra�."�., GGMcP:cv � �-� ', d '�;�� ;� `� C LS �'�,y , �. ? �� ,„. Z.F. #6603 t�f" .�,,,.-�i`r,� .��,�. �..��°��`�4 .a iy } � � Att achment (1) ,�° , �^'�, � Y ,� '�"' �. � _ '`? �� 80 � � � � � Narry E. Marshall c�TY o,�, AIbeH� B. Olsoa City Clerk and �``� % Counci,l Recorder �ommisaioner of Reeistratlion. �'"� ` o ; � � :�s = ^� . y OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS S88 City Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 55i0� November 19, 1968 Zoning Board Commerce Bldg. St. Paul Gentlemen: The City Council referred to the Zoning Boaxd the attached petition of about 25 names in opposition to rezoning property known as Lot �t, Block 2, J. A. Humphrey's Subdivision A. V ry truly yours, , �e� Cit lerk � ng � i� i�r' �:_> _��" � �. ��'1'`;f �':.A.� 2 � .. ` . �.i:,y , � ,..-�; . . ' • „ � �. ' aia - • ' J. ,, • , . � ` November 13, 1968 Mr. George G. McPartlin, Secretary ` Saint Paul Board of Zoning 1010 Commerce Building Saint Paul� Minnesota Gentlemen; Notice has been received in this neighborhood tha.t public hearing has been scheduled at 2t00 P�M. on November 21, 1968 on the petition of Frederick S. Herring to rezone from ��A�� Residence District to Commerci�l. District for an off-street parking lot. The description of this property is Lot 4, Block 2, J. A. Humphrey�s Subdivision �A!�. We, the undersigned property owners in this area� object to rezoning for the following basic reasons: 1. �We object to Commercial Zoning moving closer into the residential area� 2. �;�9e seem to have a continual water drainage problem in. this block� Commercial ;interests who have built in this block apparently have very little interest �in the fact tha.t many of us have water in our basements after every rain. 'Also, tha,t there is a paoling area in the vacated alley after every rain. 3. ; This is a.pparently only the first of three petitions to affect this ; �articular area of the city. We feel that what happens now affects this � entire residential block and that all petitions should be considered as i part of the total im�rovement in this area since every one of them involves � abutting property. r+. ,� `vJe, as a concerned group of residents, not particularly wishing to move beca.use of this activity would like to be contacted by someone on your st�ff before November 21, 1968. Also, it would be advantageous if someone from your office and a city engineer would visit the site. If this can be done please contact Mr� Kenneth ?iansen, 1745 E. Nebraska, �ohone 771-6189 or Mr. Richard Rahlf, 1736 E. Montana, phone 771—6876. `�9�� NA1+�E ADDRr�S5 COMMENTS ''' Lre��l'. �K°'1'Q'' I�! •� L, "`��C�'�tl. � t� s� � /1,�.- � ' � 7�� 't-o►��'-�► � Y!}` •j~ 1 / �� r v`- ! �.�v�-V . � � J v � �1 �� - ��z..�-..r..1 � .(9.� �� ., .><< � � J � - �� /736 � 2c�.~�coc- ��' ? � ., , , % c�=-�--�e_- �, ��-�-c�a� �� >� � � ,�ir� �io G l��i�-�o;, C.t�r,.�1 � �-� �i ,��-zr.�c:��e�, � . . y ' �W�re�bsr �.3. �968 ' �,. ��!'� t1, ltcFsYlc�1� �ee�#�ax� ' �►ia� Fsu� &i�d ot '' r� �.O1Q t��t+�� .diztg l�E�tt Fa�tt3., Mi.:uafso�a E��l�u�pp►= �Ta�ia� �a htes re�sirs8 �� +� �+r�"b��rhar�a►d �bw� �abl�a l�ri� � b�► +�+s�urd�.+� a� 2�fl� P„�l,� �n �t�sbs�r �.�, �+� oa 4bw� p��0��3�on ot Fars��ri� 8,� ��a� �a rs�►as �� b� �+s�ri+�e�r �t�S+�4a��+� to t�s�role►1 �i�ltaei�t� �'ar-a�a �stf-r��sr+�� aarki� lo�, �'h1� d�sc�i�p��os► at t�s p�rer��► #s �t►� �, Blt►dt �• ,fi. �. H�l�'�� ti�aia�t +�Ap; Y�� '!�►p �3�d y��e�` a�a�trr� ia �lais a�� ob�e�t i�o aarw��ag fe�� tlu fol�avi� '�ss�.e ��ta�e� 3„ �ta ob,��+�� o t�mms�2 �►3�t �'+� �r1.�►�rsr is� t�s �+1►aidsal��a� a�r�a►.. �� M* s�� a:ba�s�r +s +aan��;z�r1 t�e,�'4+i►s �1� prd�x�rm i�t t1�,s b�.o�1t, t��a�; �t1�+�s1�� x� I�nr �lfi 3�a tl�,� �a� a»aoa�t�r �►�'�► r��'9��s ta��i� !� � t+�6':'1�s� m�y► o:t ns ba�r� va��r � a�r 'b��as+�te a��o� �r+��'3► �,, �l+�o,� t�a� �b�rx++� 9�� a� �o-lia� e�ss i� �r �oa�sd ��2�g �►�r�► a�►�r' �►, �,. �� ,r �'eat�' �t1�r t� �tanr4 �i 1�hs+�� p+�►i:t��or�s �o ��i �s pe�yii#��►�� a# #�►a �fi�,� 1�s �'+� �s� tir�sl�'?�rApex�+r �r e►Elsi��s '�� a��1 a�M�a+un��+ri blodk am! �s� a1,2,pwlitire�ts .��d �� +aeas��a�rrd ai� '� oi` �� I��a�;-�,�''�, �� ia ewr�► ��aa� nr+��► a�� a� #� �'Y�dl�t�r� ab��.�8t ��'� 4,� 'w�I►,, � : aonas�►+l �ap �f r�de��s, n�fi pe��rl�3,+I�ta�iy �sb�� ;#o �►�► ''�i� #�C �• �+�t�,�� v�� bo b+�► �oa�set�� bv�► soae�t� �� s,�3' b�q�'�rr� "�+�'b,�r �.� 1�fl.; �ser� i� �d � a�d�rn�a� �:�t �Nr�m►a fi�r�ir �i� of��qa:�d w �i�►' �i��r v��! v+�t��t 1�a�t r��.t�� t itb�s d�le b� d�► p��a +�a�� ti�,� �e�aat��i �+�upt� �'�+S �� '�,� p��:�i89 +er �, ��e�r�. �+►hi�'. 1�Q�3,� �to��e►,� p��u '�"��'Tb. � � fj _ y y � / , . C� , � . . ..L-�CC _ � � . � , �, ' [C./Gt� � � , •.�-- � � / / � l'-, . t�G �� ,,'�,�/�,�_Q�- .�.'eF,Q��L. -_, ` � . . ► Harry B. Marshall �1T'' oF Albert 6. Olsoe t Ci�?l�Clerk and �`�w�'�.y Council Record�.r Commisazoner of Repistration �'ed I -� s9,,,,a.a�°� z� `�� c OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS 886 City Flall St.Paul,Minnesota 55102 . Sept. 24, 1968 Zoning Boa,rd, Commerce Bldg. Gentlemen: The City Council referred to you for recommendation the attached petition of Frederick S. Herring to rezone Lot �+, Block 2� J. A. Humphrey's Subdvn. "A", located approximately 120 feet west of the southwest corner of White Bear Avenue and Montana Avenue, to Commercial District. Very t yours � � City lerk hp �. U, ' _ (�� ('�` I,S' -_ r I �r� . � `�� i� ;�� ;:� �r� Clry SF� �� 196g �_��' ,t;�' ��,; _.__ ._ # 1� -°-- _°' _�, �� _..�.��. ��' �'�1' 'A'l,n��*`��1,,F ��i��a��,�# ;+ � �:,ro�. °�e � �_ � � � � ' . , . ' DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE . • CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA 113 Court House,5bt02 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner LOUIS H.MeKENNA, Depufy Commissioner Phone:223-4646 Septenber 24, 1968 To the Council City of Saiat Paul Gentleaen: I have re-ct�ecked the attached petition of Frederick S. Herri�g, filed in the natter of rezvniag, Lot 4, Block 2, J. A. flu�phrey's Subdivisioa "A". Tlae property is located approxi�ately 120 feet �est of the sonthwest caraer of White Bear Avenue and Montana Avenue, fro� a Class �'A" Residence District to a �'Co�ercial" District, and fiad that said petitioa is sufficient. Yours very truly, J es J. glish �� o�issio er of Finaace Re: X-585 c.c. Mr. Aaes N. R. Heiden ... _., �_. �.y r_. . ._. �,��I k ��'`'-ts�-# �E w , .i ��r .;.i s` ir 'r . ., -,. .. °�°Q �� J '�i�i��< I I�� '.�� k I ;v.. ;' �� .;k,hi ,,r � �. ,i �, ..�i�. � '` STATE OF MINNESOTA �,��, �If l� �� County of Ramsey se. CITY OF SAINT PAUL ' . ` ; � H8x='y E. 1KaT82�1�.1.1,-- � I--------------------------------------------------------------------------•---------................_..._City Clerk riy'i � ` of the City of Saint Paul, Minneaota do hereby certify that I have , , � '�� . compared the�attached co 2�+535 ,. PY of Council File No----------------------•------- -......_. `:.z:�'; ��`, ; being Ordinance 14221 � . as adopted by the City Council._.__.--•-�'-$'---------------------------19--69----.... �# � . ,. , Juiy 8, 69...------ and approved by the Mayor--------------------------------------------------------------19-..- - with the origi}�al thereof on Sle in my o$ice. � ,, , . s , ... . �, . . -----------------------------------•-------------------•--------....__...-------•--------------------------------...-----•-------•--.... ,;; , I � u Y. Y��:�� ........�....��.��.�.__..�.��....��.��.....�.....�....__.�...�.....��..��.�..��.��.��.�.��.��..__'.�� 4��, . �` �� :'. .� .�; �..-�a•..� ��'�"��.�.".�...'...'�..."'.".'..""'._"�""'�"'""""'"�".'"�""..�'�.��..""""""'.'"'".'""'"' I F. '�.""..".��'"""""""""..�. .�."....._...'"""'""'"�""'"'"""""'"��.._.........'."""."""'_'"""'"�'"'.................'.��".'.'""'""""'""'....__..."""' I' y i� �C,�I ' ��....��.�.......�.«"'�.'....�.....��"""""""".'�""."................"'.'...��'..'....._.._.__..........".."""""'"'"'.. � .II. �,:� ....�_.....�'��".��..._.....��"'"'."""".�"'"'...."�.."�""..�'�.....'""�'_"""""'".��""'""�..'�.....��"..�.............""..' , r : .. ... . .1. ; F I � � .<� j Y. .S + ....��.��...��... . ��.��.��.��.��..�..��.�.....��.�....��..��.��.�....�� .......��......�.��.�.._��.._��..�. �I � `:d � i i.Y r �;;. Y� p , ., . . . .:^ .."."�'�'.�"""""""""""""'""""'"""...."".'..."�'�.'"'..'""""..""'"".._...'.'""'.�.......�...�'�."._....�"�.�.._...."'""" 1 I further certify that said copy is a true and conect copy of , � * ` ` said original and the whole thereof. � �t � �"y�� .qI,� �,� ' �"�� w. � . � WITNESS m�►hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minn.. �` �,,'� r � -, �'� ,�, this-------30th--•---•--•--._day of----•----------------J?�,1!.�...---•---------------A. D. 19 . �•. . � �'�� f �`:�. � � O --- - - �-- -- ----------- City Clerk. ��..:'� 4T. ,s. � },� Y � � � d. � �M �a i '��t,�+`:. '�` '°.i �a"`'� �,. e��nly, t �f�z"� ,�x, ;g, ' � r . , `p y t' ' � w^�� ,�E�,�' .�v'C ;t A • • .. . .._ .... . (� � , j� � � � °= � s . � > � � �G '� ------- ----------�� 1 ? � � ' e ' � . r` • � O � Z � iV � ^ i • ' ` . � 0 � i`� ' �. . , — � r� �:` � ��*; C� , - ' �: , � � . . � � n � '�� - --- ----- x ,� �� . . ��. � , r :�.� � ..� c.� - - -,.-- . rJ � � � ' i. . _ ------��--- ----------° �. � � �� A � a ;�. � . v� � c� ' ' fi . � �� C� � . 2 �� ' - G� , ' `� � . � � � ' - - �� . v - � ;`, • f�' � V �J C � � ' t�'. f�7 _ , 1 d W � + � a � � � :�, — _ .—__ � � ./, � _ � . - 'r _ .._ _ ._� � i�,� , _ _ � � /`, a _ a `,� ' �`!�/ : � -- -- . . _ fj� � � �, � � . V - � _ . _-� _�- � ; W ___ -- - , � -- - � o . � a - �Y : . . .: A � /24• 20 =../2�r• . _ - � �0 Z /2�b 20 � c :� .:�w ',�� -.. _ `�• � � •`,, . o � �,y� - �� - - - - - - - ^- -`�= - _--- �. --� - - - - -[�'�( �• � � . �._s' �Ni . � s SU31'c�I' PROPERTY: Lot 4, Block 2, JA Humphrey's Subdivision "A" to ' the City of St. Paul ' SC�,i,� = 1�� = 60� . . April 3, 1969 Zoning Board �__ Cammerce Bldg. ��. St. Paul \� Gentl�men: The City Council today laid to Ma st the petitian o�' Frederick S. Herring to re�one t C cisl District property on the gouth side oP Montana Ave Pt. west of Wh3te Bear Ave., described as Lo k 2� A. Humphrey's Subdivision ��A�� . Very truly yaurs, ----� City Clerk � � r r � �;_�� January 3, ].969 I Hon. James J. T�a,lglish Comsr. of Finance Buildin� Deax Sir: The City Council today laid ove A r xd 1969 the matter of the petition to rezone to Comm istrict property on th,e south side of Montan 120 west o� White Bear �ve., described as Lot �+, Bl c , . H ey's Subdivision "A", and requested that yo send, new ices property owme�rs of this hearin�. � � Very tru]y yaurs, �,-----.. 1 � City Clerk ng ` \ ,, � ,TanuarY 3, 1969 1 ------,� Zoning Board Commerce Bldg. St. Paul �`.�'�� Gentlemen: i��, The C3.ty Council today laid ov r to A ri rd 1969 the matter af the petition to rezone to Co cia strict property on the south side of Montana Ave. 124 fe af White Bear Ave., described as Lot 4, B1.a A. hrey!+�s Subdivision "A", ..�... and direc�ed t�e Cam of F e t nd new notices ta . _ property ownere of t hearing. Ver�► truly yours, City Clerk ng � , .�� ___- �ept. 13, 1968 L �� Mr. Frederick 3. Herr�.rtg, i7i6 �. �acinth St., St. Pstil., Minri. . De�r Sir: Th� Co�nissioner of F3 \ t eported to the City Couneil that your petition to re�one , BY.oek 2, J. A. Humphrey'e Subdvn. "A", 1c�ated appr 120 t �at oP the aauthwrest corner of White Be�ar Av�. Mon � Ave� to Comm�rcial Diatrict, is insufficient. 1 Far this rea� n the Counc� �+�nnot act Purther in thi,a matter. �f� V�ry trW.y yo�rs A Ci�y C1erk hp ��. � �--' �' ��s��-- Ju1.y 14, 1969 Erickson Petroleum Co. , 45u7 w. 78th. St., Bloomin�ton, Minn. Attn . Keith G. Holvenstot D�ar Sir: Enclosed is copy of a rdinance rezoning your property sub,�ect to c .•tain condi i ns set out in the ordinance. We c our cia�. entioM to Paragraph Z of Section 2 uir�s u file a deed of negative ease- ment in t parts in this. office within 60 days. he Corpora on Counsel's office can give you further informa.ti as to th orm of that instrument. Very truly yours, City C1erk hp � ' , :__.__.___—__ _ - -:----L;-q-R=p-£N�-E� R ___ --_—_ _--___----_____----._..-----,c��----,------------� �...-__.__----..___ ___--—_.__.. _____----__ -�- ----- + T`^'—T`�� -W� a a . _� ' _ c�,o.o .o ' o' c� Q o ; o � o a � � � o � ; � .�.� �, 4 r � o � � o ' .� ,, , . , __ _ , + : ,. ' � ; ' A �, _ _ _ , , __ , ,_t_ . _ �-�-_ _�. --�-__ __ -. . Q � � �. _----T.�.,1 _._ :._�_. _._t._ ; � i T .. � , 1►•+'� -. __ _ � i � _� �, o � � , -- i ; , � , ; �;.,- ,�R � , ; � � , � � � I � � ; ! � "- �---�- —�- - •� '� � , ; O :v C�' C� ' O d �O �� U O �� O _ __. Q` Cj� �i{.�; LJ ; a�; p I'. .�'?-` �� F � � _ _. _ , ; , _ : � � � �� @� _ .__ , r ; � �_ , A ` � AV .� � LL' ,� �` -_ °; � v " w� - , :_ � CAL(FORIVI _ , O � 4 � ' 4 ; ; � � - , _ i ' � Q . � ' , � � � r � �� d O �'Q l ,�� >-- C� _ : . � e a � � � , _ _- , � , , � , , � � : _. . z � � , __ __.�.... , � v : ; , . , ,� . �_ , . _ � �... � � i .A � � � , Z v � � �c _ � ; � �.. _ . . O G ''� �:� ��. � � p , O "` O i Q � � 'O � Q �� e � � � , �,. ' . � . . . . �_�_�. ....�_..___ � � �y. � .... �� ioAHo qvE - � . . �� - , - _ � C� U O C� O O O O� O O O ' ' ' ; ; j i ; I' , ; �i� ; ��-__--� ' , C.��C) �Cs '.�O �� `O ' O : ' jv,vLC�ylvlviv v v'v' � (`� ,. �. vA w v' V , � ; � , . i , , f.� ��__ � ''/ _ . _ :_ _ � � �R . . . ._ . _.. - ----! �V, • i---;--1-_�_._..1._.. _ __ . - �-- - . . _ , , --� -- --;- ' ,;�r �, �E;�1� F i � - __-_ �„ 4� . � , , , � I � �. IV i`�;�/�V'V��/ i�� /'�/ I�/I � �:,2 , ' � I � �:a , � i � �.1 <� iJ O C3 �.'�. L�, U (� Q i ; i i 1 ' �� ♦F � ;� � ; I � ; � � ; ; �..___-� _ c� �� e� O . � r`. t. I o W H AV� - � ` , t � —_ _.__-�_1 / ,,o � � co �.. o` o ' oo � � , � �� , i o o � � ;� �v��; "� �� : �� ;�.c� c� a 'o�a ; � � i � , i - � � ; � � � I ; .� � ��' � , ' �� , , . _. -. .. .i ._. . _i.. . _.... 1... . l. .,.1.. . . .. 1_� .. _""' ....�._. ._.. I 1 _ . _. . . , � � , T_ �� .--1 L _,I ii -_ ;� _ �_ *�� . -----_ _- -- , `�� a 1 , , _. �._.. .�.. . , , , ._ . , -,;- , 1 L-_r T � _ , �R_ , , ! 1 � � � � _ _,, !_— tr , , . , . . v; f , _ , � � � �T � �; � . . � � � �..� ,� • ! , ' �;O p O�i p � Oi0 O Cj�C� ;C�!�J;p,' (� �v�vlv��t Q � j �� - ; . Q „ � r �,� .. , , , �J ;`� � ��I �U � iJ ;O ! �� i il� WoYT qvE . � ` v ��; 0�� i� � � fQ i0 �'�0�0!��ialQ.�Q1�10;! Q � j � -a_' .� yi`� � :I,�jO Q?O O;Oi ; � � � � , ; r i ! ; � � �� I � � ------ � , ', ' I N. . , � ' __ ' ' � , �' j _ _. �._ �. :. y___ , .� � , , , � , , , � . � . ., . , _ , __ _ :_ � - _ .-- -� � � , ` � •• � ;� � i � , T . _ _ , . . _ . . � � � t ,. . ' ��,/ •� i i � � I f ( � ,F }� � - -, . '�'i ' ; � ! -�-t _._';.....�. � i � _ . , , . � � �� . ( � I � � � � ��xrWS°b;r*,... • :�' � �' � � �`U _ _ �"`' � �',O �O, O �O O � O� p O�;C�'O� ;d'p? ; � � ��° pi .p;O ' ,�',' i (� , � ! 23� ♦Q (: � � �0�� !�,�;�; T �� .. ` ` , �� M oN�`A�A AvE. �� - I .. I � ' , � , , . ; � O O�iQ� v ' ' ; ' � _ �o,o �o ;o�o �ofo 'o �o'o o a ' � o ,� . �� - �o�o-c� ' o; o :� o�o.o o�o�o�o,o�Q;o.c , i , , , , _ � - . . : � ; : , . , �� , �� i�� - � ,- , , i � i� � � ' i , ; � , , � _ ._. _,. .�__ 1____ . _.�.. , � ' '•.'I .1__ 1�. -- - , . E � � � , , _. . � ��r- r-.._..� ._,�_.._ -'- --- � . _ . .,... .... .. - -��_- .,__ ..._...,.. .�_1 / {, -� '' � . ._ . .� . .. r . . . .�.... ._ _ ... ... __ � _._. T __,_, 1 .. , r � r-�--� __� �__�_ �.� -- __r.. . +. , , � ; _ _ � Z_ , _ __.r - .----r � � ----1---� ---i 1_ _ �. ; ; . � ; ; r_ �� _.�. � --r � ? _ t � � - i ' � '. I� I . � I � � �� t ; i � � � 0;� �� 'Q Q ,Oi Q j � f� ;� I Q � �i � � 0 � 0 �� f � � r. ,_f � ~ ,: ; ' 1 ; � �� i C . � . + ; 4 i P-,� � ;O Oi0 Oi0 C� ; �J C,� t C3;C};C)j�0','Q�� , � N E R+�S K A v E � � I � co N►�. . ., , , . , �r� ��U! O O�i��O� O ,'O� ' � ' �' � � � � �r- ; , � , � �a '�p ,� , ; ; � �,�► � � a �'� �o, +�--�_ . c� � � �.� b � Q ; � �o��o � � c�;� , . . � , , . fi: s, � ; � ; � ; !' j . �� ' ; i J�� i i �� ' ' I � � ' � � � ' 1 i i; , , ' ,, i .1�_ i1 � � � � � � � , � -- �i � � � , 1.. , � , �! � �. ;_�. i � �e _ � I ! E � � � � � � - � --/ i � L .L. . . ,. - _. . _T.__ - i ---- -- . � i.L _J. ., �. . , � : � . i _ r . i (-� � ' -�--`1 �'.:1 __� -^�- . - .- -. ^__ -.�. ._ .. i___ � I_t"�� , 7 T` . --- - ,.T. : ; , r� � ` *'_ I _ . �. ` .: :- , � , i f ,, : , , : � • � � i � I � �_ , ; � � ' , � ` +� � ; ,�- i ' i t , ' � � ! i i � I � R t . � , �� 1 � � �� . ti i � � �� c--' � i � ' ' �ti ��V�� "'ye� � �� f � , I .� i � . i p '. . ; � � ' � /� � . < � V r 1 ' � �� {��:�,�;� �{Q�Q+�j �� f�j � ��!. �� - - � --+�-- �.�._.. ;1"1!�li:C��lli.f"4-:� tlt�!'1.4 ('� ��F� 1�'�" �, Q i � h � :f�-�- � _.._. � . .:.�: � _ , � . ; , ; ; . , �APPLtCANT .��r�� S. Ha��g ' LEGI _ , NEv� D A °. , . . : /a V E , .. , '��(;)` � C�{'��' Q � - 1� (�(� (� � (,�, � : ,,�"�„�PURP�S E Rezone from "A" Residence to Commercial to LANI ,r ` � ' f � ' � i j '{ , I 1��.;� � - . ailow an off-street parking lot in conj. � • � wit existin fillin s � ii__1T _.� �___�� -- :�— .L ._i_ _ _.__.L_L1 L.... _._I~_IJ .�. _i •. g g tation. -�7;- { '----��--f-- --I- -�- _ __i__. __; T.: � -- ___�.�__�_�_E -- ,..rPf�ESENT ZONlN� ';,A„: Residence � � _.. � , �_ - � � � � � i i � � � 1 � , � ' -� .. ' � � '.,�, � + � t � I. � ' �` � �,� ..., � �'`PETITION � 'SIGNERS � '�,1�i�` ; � � � �'��ti) � W � �..) .;�.i �� ? 13 of nossible 17 or 76.5$ , . � � f ' .7 ... .�._ _:._�w_. ._,-__ ----- --__--__.___ . __---�_...r__.__: _ � , -�� + ' . • �f . -ftLE No. #scos nioRtH . r, - c# ; �[ 'i p c� ';a � c� j � � 0000t� ;� �_ : �� . , . , , . � ' ► �; � � `' ' , :" _�..:..::r.� � y .�_j�-� �:.s�- �.---�- -t-I l�� '�1_.(_� .� , . :.��_; � -�� S�. Poul Pla n ning Boa rd, Date� November 15,: 1968 �� Pt1 -Y'.�.,...t1'..'•rr'ti�-'-i---r-'r-r�-�--, �„-.-� .'-�._-.�--. .--..�--. .......�__.� � . � � _ - ' .. . � . � � /�i K I st �' ' 2nd Laid over to 3rd and app�_�►dopted � Yeas Nays Yeas Nays Carlson Carlson Dalglish t� Dalglish Meredith � Meredith Peterson �4��35 � � Sprafka Sprafka Tedesco Tedesco Mr. Presidenf Byrne Mr. President Byrne O