Loading...
244404 ORIGINAL';'O CITY CL6RK r � 244�0� . CITY OF ST. PAUL FoE Nc�� NO. . ' QFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK C C�IL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONE DATF RESOLVED, Upon the pertinent appeal, as amended, under the Zoning Code, by John F. Bureau, owner of the subject premises, zoned in "B" Residence Dis�rict, under said Zon.ing Code, described as t�he west 4 feet of Lot 3 and all of Lot 4, Conver & Theopolds Rearrangement of Block 8 Excelsior Park, according to the pl t thereof on file and of record in the office of the Regis er of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota, that the provisions of said Zoning Code, in respect to density and lot frontage requirements, hereby are determined and varied in their application to said real estate, as and to the extent necessary there�or so as to accommodate two duplexes to be moved onto these lots; subject to the con.dition that the building moved on the property affected by the appeal would be placed 8 feet from Lot 5, Conver & Theopolds Rearrangement of Block 8 Excelsior Park; and further subject to the condition that said appellant, and his successors and assigns, otherwise, shall make due compliance with all applicable provisions of municipal ordinances, state statutes and rules an.d regulations of public authorities having cognizance. � FQ�AP RQVE .....lS�..4�. Aist. Corpo���wn Countel JU 11 1969 COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays Carlson -��-��� � � 1��j� ---��a� g-�-��_ A rove 19._ Meredith .- T� Favor Peterson � Maqor Sprafk2 ; --� A gainst Mr. President, Byrne PUBLISHf� ,�.(�.N 14 1959 �� a .�. �'` � . � � y ��, . . 2����� . � BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 May 13, 1969 � Mr. Harry E. Marshall, City Clerk � Room 386, City Hall & Cdurthouse Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 Dear Sir: This i� written in response to the appeal of John F. Bureau to relax the density and lot frontage requirements of the Zoning Code as they apply to property located on the south side of Iglehart Avenue between Pierce and Fry Streets. This property is further described as Lots 3 & 4, Conver & Theopold's Rearrangement of Block 8, Excelsior Park. The appellant proposes to move two duplexes onto these lots which are zoned "B" Residence. Ti�ese lots, however, do not meet the area and lot frontage requirements for duplexes in this district. This matter was considered at the April 17, 1969 Board of Zoning meeting. The staff reported that the Code requires an area of 6,000 square feet and a frontage of 50 feet for a duplex use in "B" Residence, Each lot has an area of 5,379 square feet which is 621 square feet or 12 percent short and a frontage of 44 feet which is six feet or 10.35 percent short. It was noted that moving permits to alternate sites of sufficient size had been de�ied by the City Forester because of the extent of tree branch removal and that injection of two duplexes in this area would not be detrimental to surround- ing proper•ties. However, the Zoning Code requirements are reasonable for this use, the requested variances at 10 and 12 percent are excessive and no hard- ship peculiar to this aite is in evidence. It was also noted that, although it is likely that this property will be in line with the proposed extension of the Short Line Route, the Public Works Department reports that, at this time, they are not in a position to purchase right-of-way nor to consider the alignment final. Mr. Bureau, speaking in behalf of his appeals, noted that the lots were plat- ted in 1889; that they exceed the density standards for single family use by 1,379 square feet; that the lots are not ideal for new construction; and that he proposes to move in a duplex in good con@ition. He also noted that he has changed his proposal and now intends to move only one duplex onto one lot having obtained another site for the second duplex. Mr. Hathaway, owner of the second lot, indicated his desire to move a single family structure �1� ,i� �. � 3 F��--• x� -a � eo � a . ..� . � � ' 1 Mr. Harry E. Marshall, City Clerk -2- May 13, 1969 onto that lot. Mr. Robert Wright and Mr. Gregg Bailiff appeared in opposition and noted that their area is a good residential area; that the new proposal places the less desirable of the twq duplexes in their area with side yards of only five feet; and that existing dnplex�s and the non-conforming industrial use have been in the area for some time. Subsequently, it was the� finding of the Board of Zoning that this appeal should not be granted. �erefore, the Board recommends denial, b� a vote of 5-0, of this appeal to relax the density and lot frontage requirements of the Zoning Code. Very trulq yours, i � ��� Peter . Maietta Secretary PJM/j ld CLS ZF�� 6732 ,. ,� �,, '' > - -; , , ��4' �,��1RA fOF 7A�NING R�P�!' ��l1iD ACT ON Ap7�,fii1 l�i 1 �_, _ Plat M�P 11 � �=,, _ ; � Actin�; u�der Le�i�lative �od Cfiapter 6� thru�x��►� "' ` Pile rro, 6732 pass�sd R:�,ust 22� 1922 as= �,, , ta kpril 6; �3���8 , , � � ' ; Also L 1. APPLICANT'S NAME .. Jc�u. �. $ur�au' , �. ,; .� . �� 2, CLASSIF'ICA,TION �s � 4�Cn�endnl�nt �,Ap��� ��'ermit 0 Othsr , � .. ' ' . .^ .'.I ,. � . . �� I,. '";��' .. ..:'k' 3. PURPOSE % R 1 �_�ity snd: f�o�age :�r�rql�irements ' ,�• ' �;� ��. 4. .�ATION . � � ��,� ���e�� ���� � �y�rc�e ��'�� .���ri�s , .� ��. �'� � 3 . � - � '�� � '� • . :� f� x _� d� ( ' ' �&,�. .. �. .. �i` �' ' S� IiFGAU ,DE"r�f�1�3`��'�� � ,"�����l�tg�* �F ? �,� ;R,l��;' O£- $�C'l�`3#:'�''�,���,,�'e�,s�r'�,�5��'� � ti ` ��3/ � . �y _ �M � fi1 h T '�3�`G' d �y S � 3,� ^}t^ � �� �+ ,k.- +, ����Y'�i,�,.��,� ¢ •�, ���.�"'� ���t� �����t�. �F c�" � 'i:"�°. . �.'+r�"�a��Y'� s��,.;'� `r 1^� � . ,r� w � �4' : < e > � : x � ,» � ;�e,� � r�"r�� .;u.. ; '� `'�� � .. � � xd�c � z�- # 5 �.. �pf �'}x�,�,.a4 �•ip£�,z 't i o+ 4 �' v +��� '�� .a.k4�ibtir��lay , �� � ra �� ,y v .� � �k,� pz c ' d � ��� � 5? �3 � �t� s P ���d�'l*��', � F 6� .:.��� � �;����` � � ��^��'- ' ��`,���g � � ��� � t, � � d':� `N� � r'� � �,,� ���. � > .� : � � � - c , � z �r -� '� ,�' 2t � ��. -y '� `� .� � � � �����}>� .�. ✓ C�� ��:�r� � � ts..�` .a`d � 9 � '� �G �"� ���-d } ,,�'x �y�Y���J: � ' ��`r e �. � � �`(� � � � �u� t .���� �5' '� .F,�� � y j�;�` �'. r � ;a¢g�� 4x�'���"'�'�r �'�'�I" '�� �: � . v� -y.t .' yc ��"� � ' �ya, Y ' �t�'�� 4a � y� ' .`,n t � ` 7��� 11'� R �?s������I a' .�� ���` Z� � �� .��� s 3 ����� r�� ��� s�' �,'*g � � r �,��7��` + �' � ( xy x r K,r� �, R .� � ,:�, � ,�, ���0 �ps���+��`"'�`k �' �' �.��` ��. 1 � ',.� A , s� `4` �, � � : , ": '' . �' � ,�i �r, �'t, "' � S � '' '�� -� � ��&F t-°i� �`�i+ .hpR� t�� y t�.;:t1 � ,'x. � �r �, �_ �F�:- y� $ �;. "V� z °� x ,, . , .o w4 x hs'. F', � � � � . .�;._ ,:_. `� �.# � ,�,������1 �' ,� ��� �o�"',� yr�� --.: ,. '�a,,. , � ..�- '�,. ..z;?° �.�, §)'i 'rk ...; ��f� � i�'� �� .. . ....- �'�, ... .:. u��� e � �� e.�� � ' 3 �,', sx .� . ,,.. �. . � ��j�! ��-�dl ..: • :� ,. ..,:. .. ..' �5 S.r �` > � . .. * .. ; ; .� � � I� _ V � � f j; t t, .�.... .� ... � , y� .� .:..; : � .1" yy �,.'. S�, ��.�.: -r«` - ti�'^: i�' �., . , . �: c r. , :� � �� ��. ... � . �., `� f `� � q �� n` �� � , .�.� � k�'+� -'t� l�.. ..� � � � � ,i'.- .F: �� " . � ���__ ;.{ �� ! � �{' ° �, Si -+ • x , ; � � ' � ^��� y ��. . .:t '�€�„ :±� '+ : . « a , : :' . ,. . . .. . . a . , ,.. . a � 3�� '� ` ;' j � . A, 'ss � " °.' i�r.•S � ' �� .r ,.r, � 7��r� &'°� �• �,� r �"' g. ' .:. �� "� � �� �'` .y .. . ;�� .y, ' '� '`ti� y't�', � x � f' . ' � 4 q r' "''9 � .r �y. � .:`:;.��.c181 . . � . y, f .y� 1'.t J� _ '� .:`£� '� �'�.. t ��{# � ` ��"-�s, P .�° �� Ti` - N a _ �{� �.F�1 �Pj �$�:�'�''{,�. � � � � +f�� #. �Pk � ����� :����� � �'� ( �� �M�,� ����"OM � ��. n' �? � f � _ +�YES _ ,v� + f.'-' � -;$� + �, � }`�'�� ^ � �` .M1��. � s�p� t' ���' � �`��+ �� -�` � �� t� �:° .��,-�:,.: _ ����m��pf������ �y, ,'t� f '�R 7f�""' w ' }�A �e�.����� 1' P� ,k ;C"'� y" ,�_ � S'� ��R' 4' � Y � t .:1��.. �i`� 4l� , �,. +i:' E � ._. i�:�.y . � � . .tw � �, .�. �' � �" ' �, �,t ,� .^� � ,�S P '+ � + ' s� ,�i�2`�"*- t �a i�,� 'e` " x�' �f '��.�} `� � .� u�9! � "'� � k�.. : d t' ' � �*� �"' :�ir� r�;,i t f � �t3+ �r�l4� �ff.� � � . 4.14,°t f. , �' � d � ���i�y� ,��� ,kr �� � �� �� � ������ *��"'��������� . � :��� � � . _ .. . . .. . . ��c3. :�a. a_ a ���� ,� *r.' .:,� �'�i..�'... .�, . � i; i ' • • ir '" i,..r_ 1 �rJ � ,', ! � /"1 ♦ � . ^ . r,�,,.�..�� . . ' a � ---1 /^ �',^y M r' ��,.�, O�O'^�^ �l ^ - . m 1 ^� � � � � � �'i .\J' '�.J V l�J LJ i 'V` ' !'sJ� � � �" �.'l� " ' _f 1 � � � , � � " • ' ��,�C�� �o � , 1 : ;� - , � . � , . . � . � �� _ ., . � . ,�� T� , � - ` 1 i\ � �,. � , ` •ti ` ' _ . � \`` ' •\ �� 1. ' . ��� ,\. , ,�,._� �;�,-�� �`;� � ,� � , - , r- • „� � � ;C � \ , �� � �,�! � ; Q ,Q'� �. ,'� . 0 : � ; _. . L�' �' '. " ' .• :.� `�` � � � _ � � ti.��� s: _ � �ARRo� 1 ' .�� ` � �' �U � � .-�-��� � � , .:.. -� � � r::-�t � �. s . . . /:� 6 J r� ; � , , '��L.��l`yl�` ?� `` 1`''� � � 1.,�- � j."1 �a V• ��: ����;� �;��, % ^ ,—. - ('s.:. ; � � '�'% ;� � ' � � u� ---`1-�-x_ �`'� {;f»1` { ' �' ;, ' Il t .. ;., � . 1 .. � � .. � + '''. .; . < :.�.� - y _ � �'L� r�r��� � � �,, . ,. �, t� < .. =1-. x�v;Qu;,ST!( �_.,�= � �r �,� � �.;,� 1 , '�;v^" r.. ^ :_ : i . � �•j j �� �. � � :,�`,�•. "-•ct,k � , s �. . ..i y,i oti l�'.ti. . �� O• � � � � f: �' �` � , �._^.. �� F?� ,I I''.S'���7� r � �.•� .' � � �: `r j .f�.' ' � .�.-_...__..• ' ,• ) ,i�, � �:; � " ,, �y,, .�, �.•� . ' � . ��t Et��r AV �� E �n - -.�. - ac ,..�..�,, '� �,� � : , � � r . C_, C O O n�� ^ r� 7 '�' � ,s � �, ,) ..,.'....A�-.,� 4'� r� .� , �s Q .,, � , Q� .��.� i � � `�'����� ' i�' �!'*►� f .. . h ; . , i �, 11 ._.� �a.. : `+ ��-, .s+ �r .� �• � '� ��' �ry.�� � � "!��'. ��.. �i ' �� #��S .�� . -y ''� , r . . , '� {. � ,, � } t ,, f ' 1�; �- � 1'` li� �.� �:;�.✓� � ;�- ; " �,� ''` ,'; �. , �.' i. :�:' ;� � /"'� � . �t� �, �`, � ����(� �. • �� +� . . . ��� ?�` `� i� .. � ��f'`� 'I � \�. `w�M � �?V L�� � ��, �r('`.��. e .�'"' c ;,� ,�, . °..�- ��r '•.'!� `�A. �'! � '� �"� .� � !�'� � �,�L,'` �' r 1: �, .�s �.... '/�'c. ' � � s �. d. ) ' � 4 �, - � �� ' ��� � { � " � ... �� �� '# �:r'��� . �"'�^ `'�� ��" :Ly _u�;,�,,,�i„�.,..�+ e+--� '� T"-- r i�a.r KfC+�`� �:v w a�T..� _ , �{' 1 � �- a .,.�r " �� ... .�'�� �. , ;� '�' ';� ddr s t- . . , d�rt k!F t d ,.� -� �.s � ,`6. �'�� ''� '� � � �a.. , � e �. ., � k �'T A°" t? _ �tia � N �- i ,�,' . �� �� j,� . �,v �a �`. '{� �(��\� � �,w�,wtr � �''R�'.. w4' y 1 y 5� T .'` �.��K; �� 1���f. ,..i � �f� � , � �! ] � '�l' i �.. +y'Z' 'u V'�"YN� ¢'... �� _� 5 �. r1 •. , M r .��k ,� ..A. 1 e t� t .� `� sv : �k; �� �k �'.. ' � ,f. 4`.g 4V ` � 3� ir.;�C� } � J T;,, ,}4 : y .x�.,'r �z�.:` ., fi�aF�+ �- � �r 4��"'d4� � �� � 1�r:�b � 4��3 .�� I � t' �� .�' '.:� 5 K a �?���f. �6 `� � d t� Nr f ' '�,y� jFi M Ri �..!- r� i?e >SA ��;� �M * �y�, �p. ��� � ,a ��.� �_, y s X � � �, � +" #�p�TM�'. �� �'�^� `t-:: �� �t. Tq��` .}ti sV`� 1 � . 6 , . ,- 4 ��, ; -:�, . ' � ., S�. ' J Ti Y : �� Y - �,�. � $i[? r"" . �+ '��y.� ,+ �L, Y: y a� r l �` 1' { t . . � ' � t .{f.'" ^�l � '�.�'�+ � Yj � 4 r . ..�, } ..,., o��i .:; � . re. {ti' 'y�,:i 0. f C • � } N ' .,., {� . .�. e�i .- rt � .�d�+, r �� ,'}�, �,�� � d {' � :.' .:,1`< H �� :/"� _�. .rw� N 1 /'� � {'a . � .s '- � �"�{` A�', �r�v'S���f `a.. . , i. t 't � N t �:� N (, � � � ��r�'� � ��� r�'"� *�' .� i e � f c �r� � ,,�,� , � �;'t , �r� �i`"` �� �, -y t;.. ' � i� ;�� .� yw, �fi � h',%N �q�' 4. � N . � �' �'s" � �y°'� ��[ '�, '�' � �� �l�}�1� �s�- ;k a% �� � ��i� ��� �3� * � .w .�i+�r.° �a� F �� i+� ,�y �'� ''� � "# � . . � � �,: : '. "�����, '�� �� 5 yRF_� : , _ y�yA}�. w�P s , , ° ' A4' h°^ y, � a� �. . � �G . a' 3 , f� , i� r .., �; }� f q z � � €� `� ��y. t ��t 4 • 4� YaFx� � S , E k '� k( � 'i+L. h c�j � �� s�, �„ r,. '�,^ � y� �sY.� `� ''� z s,' r � ��: �" • ,�} y.�$� . '�H ' t �� . r d �.� t�'9 m ,ti'� ". �` , _ � �,: a ..; � .. � ., 'yy . �fi� i",y,,t � : e fi �,. . .. ,� • r���f�7� r^� �� c�y' ,r �At��'� � � #*> ���""��r�'�� ,� t� ��k'. ` � ,� �w����`Y a � :� � `iw �x�3i�Y i*�:��k 3: ��.` ��� ��,� �r .�fa '�` �. u .. �� �I� - ., � ; � t w'�y, � ti f,t y � ',� � � �: a � '' �4 ,�a� s? �� f �j � � e,�z � '� F >.�l»�� � �.; fi ''Ma° �' �;: y�, . �.. �$ r r,��#' 1 � ���.� l . �ti � � rr 1 r-„ �! 'a���.' ����� t'� a� �`�5'�'� p��� � gtF �� r` � � ^r �� 1!�h � . +{Y � � �t. � ' j r �+4. , � T � ��+ £ F .� � q . R ,�j ��� � +, ,,�i,�. � ` c1�,�''�'�" # f � .;I}'Su� !�s � ��� �,�,� ,��r � �'�`i k�t �}+ k�; k'+�� �� �"� � ��s-�'� ��. t "�" �, f`��' �., �+t.,�- �� ..� ����� � � " � e} a�.���.:� EQks}.; �Y'a T� i "�� �� � J tb � .� � �,y� q,� �3j.!,� .� � e'�s Y '"r,w Q fi - ? , f - ,� t? 'H �� �. >e .���'�� _�axF �w�c �o '�£ " . „ , � �', v � �11.��°��► ���� ���#_ � ,� �� .. ��; + � -w�; ��� �. , 'a� . � . � . . . � i:���7 wF.�; ,�;,¢ $ ������ i k �{:. � .� � � i'. � �. { � �° , � �� • } � �- # ► , ��.� , �. ; °� ��-� ; � ���� a � z ,, � � ���.� x '�, ' ,,��; tr � '� � t �, . . . . '�-. ° ; '� �� . -. � �"�+ ' �,•. <r,� f, �, ��� r'r ,�� . _ �. . A:; �,,. �„ .x' �,� ,y 9 c , : �* �,� r,: � p ' `� i y.�� �r, . � � �����l� ; � � y �� `���� t �� ��r�� d ' r� � �` ` by,� �, '�;' ' �' R e€ $ v � ,3"' �. � � w a� x 1 .ra+ , , a `� �_+s�Rr*�c ' .±l�i�� . � ��*,�"�,�i � �'�a''�?L� . � �t i �`,xm. �v � ajca��� ° s � . , a x...F��� t r a< ^` '; '���'e'� '� ,,.. '$.,,�y"�.R» i�.r: .. �. .r,•�.,�+ w.'�:;;,d��.; _.`�-. ., .. , . . ...- ... .Yi.. �.. 1Le+� ��i�n�l, :iV4G.iR .��.§.�51��, v!�£I�f 7� tit^. �exus>1o.X_ � ✓n`_O 3:. ;4 F"�a�• � w� � . • . . �,� �urea��t �r��ie�trr�er�t �on���.r�p (� 995 Van Slyke Ave., St. Paul, Minnesota 55103 (612)488-0595 Commercial • Industrial • Apartments /F ,a� C x� ' February 25, 1969 (;�� U�'�' �' �� � �, , / � The Honorable Mayor and ity Council �� c�o City Clerk � Room 386 City Ha11 and C urt House City of Saint Paul, Minn sota SUBJECTs Lots 3 an 4, Conver & Theopold's Re. of Block 8, Excelsior Park Gentlemen: My name is John F. Burea�. I am a resident of St. Paul and reside at 1384 Midway Parkway. (Busine$s phone: 488-0595; home phone: 6�4_6769) I respectfully request u�der the Legislative Code 64.03i: 1. relaxation of theldensity requirement from 6000 sq� ft. to 5379 sq. ft., 2.. reduction of the ront requirement from 50 ft, to 4� ft. for the subject "B" resid nce lots. The subject lots are vac nt and yield to the, city real estate taxes of $111.00. I wish to move onto this property two structures located presently at the southeast corner of Snel ing and Carroll Avenues. These two structures wer both built as two-family residence and have been used as such since their construction (picture attached). One structure has six bedrooms and the other has four bedrooms. These multi-family homes have had excellent maint�enance and have been judged suitable for moving. These excellent duplexeslwould help to upgrade the area on Iglehart Avenue, serve as homes for four �families and would be a source of approximately $1,100. in real estate tax revenlue to the City of Saint Pau1. Sin rely, �� John F. Bur,eau JFB:bi �,`�"�°�� a ����' ���� _�� ��';, ,; � i ' i` 1�41; *� � ,`� �y1�i ' `��Vl; � ,-� ,:�.\�� ?,�,� \ �� , � . .. .` �+► �` ,``+\ t,� ��� �� r �� �k� ��\ � � — 1 "�.. � � /' /s_�..�..— +tr '�, •+� � v �- � +M , ��+« — . � {-i � -_r. . , - ," � , r I � � �, � I I � � 4�1i�� --��' � _� - � � -� � �' � . � ,'i � . . _ � ..�.. _ - �X,x'F*�` . -a` ,.,�...,,""?'^�...,, ��- � � ��,���a , 1ir I/ , �i+�� f,S�,$ ��.i�� ` �, i �„ � �.�" �` • �° � �,;,� �� :�� - �.-��: � � . � ii , ,,,�`t�4, ��, ��,��.. ��;�► ..., �� �• �:i 1 •v — �S , , \` % �� .��. � ��� ��y�■ .:; .. ,� , - __��_ ` .•�_-� �rai--- � � � � "- �— �.� �.� ��` � �� 1� � � _ /� �.1.,...... . ... z`�Z�.�.-w '+'-T�'v-�:.',1n�.�.qi �. '_ .�..�._...s.<�. -._._."_. ,_.....atif�... ... .._�.__.. --- .�...�._-�___._.��.__.-. t / � . I S •. : .r E' h �.e a .o iv• s \ ,q �- , �or ,. . t rir �.Y - (.�• in_�I � � e 1 ����i � ; • ° s � r'� � I � : t - - -ti..J,_.__._._..IL...1_.�1{rsri w � � � � � � ' t���� � � � � , � • � i . � � � � I..;r. � B R / G H T W �0 � O D P A R /{ i t ' i • ',; I , .__i_.��`..V.r �+ l'--`---�-- � � � ' 3 it.m I n:is.�n t mIrr i t:I r��rs�ts�te i s� zi� i�!,r�ii�i� n I� s4 tt ei r.�a � i �' _ . . ��. � . _" �;.�'u7_e±._�r.'a�._,_.�.�. I 1 +i r�.r7�zi. � �� � _> _ � -�� . . . � - - • �'-_�..__. � ; .. �,.�....x . .1 . l. + r-L--�'--�-�a.u�-i-u-!-is-a w �rr fsl+ i �� e __-�._W.i. �.�_.-.._. .. . �� - . . . � 9 . , ... .. . . .. . . . . .•a�f�viis�_�r j . ___1 . .UN/V S/ oa'_9«.i�ce . •! 1 - - ✓, < < , ; a L TY�, .�.a,.—s___.. � , .. _.'_ � � .. � � e* `. - , ; ; . —y4VE� �._ i_.... v ,l,a„ . ' . ry ' . �� . ..� , , n �j i�-.:-.�.-..���"I `r•• �7v r' �'�rrsi. 3r:aib �.�.r-�..,,..��-a^�r-�+. N,' - ' ' . . T � .�ex��x.r��7.�r.i:�i�evarr� i I � i � t � • � I i � � ; yt . r , � i - � ;�_ Ir'----- �i �T�Tirx _� 0 .�. �y � 1 ; I I �. �62SiF1JYT�!!.1lHtl�lTA6ON �/9/1Ap9AiT'OIJt)��71r..: � �•{��/i J 11�I�IaI� 7�R . " � � � � � yo .� ti �osts� y J i , ; � i i i� r S� h '� , � I l � � j ! I �S� j �k � y0�, G I S'� i ( :� r--__ • /I. . � 1 � I � � . , � + • ��'�`'�� � �'�tir--',---IrrTr- � r �nrr- e-� ulrr��'�::,. a i� WZ w---�e='_:e.iD�+-- i7�I..... �S� j � � � i S� I .___..._ � ., . F_..� 'cv' � el It q � k '�� .._..I �""�'....�N."""'yr' . �r ._.._. , --.I I ___� 13__NI ��.It�_� Z; _.�.-� p___ Y b •.\�...� M1 ...�..-•IO �u.....y,�'.1 ' !1( Y�TU i � I� .. � `.0 _ ' . � 0] . � b ' �! ,� , .i i -� '^�I . 0� I t � � R ' I � i � ti t. . r t�u j � , .--.-. � L___�y � io�� ro �i� " �------=��' � „ ¢ . � » --� � -A �-R 'Q ��!' J r �a' .I . ' ro9—' �n� c , <�� i�`ia i n �I ?, n �i y' A s�i.:�A ,��� l.. � i , >+-_�.'`_B3js "'...� a� � i�P----�A� R --_ .---_: .�i�.1.. r!__i2.x rs�i--� PT.i D a . . �J ie�� i7 ��;,._�ro; Li irl �'� t___� � � �� �_ e � A1 1 �r s..-_T � � . ' `�u ��._'��'�'� � 't�-s� � I�..� ;. �r��;- _.t� � l+ �I� � a ; � � � �------i � �' � xi ito � "��t <�� �-' � / , �� ����� �— � � �e �� ,a�� ----�{f'_"_ �--•-----� � ;4 : ro l7 r"" > v :.�._�' ' ��J ` '�' I i ai ur .�'� ��-�-~� � v .I i-_,..-„J t_J i �i� Q�� e � '�f�:e_" � � � (---�-----,�M -I f. ,9°',_'I r°°, •I F: f 'ii� �� �ii I �, I i �r---1 6 '� i i"'i ���{ rr n ,I r io— � _\� �,�-`v y —a �� �.:�_ � ' Q. �-- ' H•r---� ; ' ;-----� �"_3 , �e -� C_'__�i� s9�g y ,g ue �L'_ �n� � � � i y i-- ie --,�._�p,.� y� � ir i �--� 1 �i _�e_� '-�� � a _�\. '_ ^1 9' , I i_'_� « .a .. I �. r4 �i �s ?, 'Ii : i� ---ti ir', c .. ' � i ��nL��..w..,tn�_� .. w �rrrf. wl �»�..� « 'L�.tt?n �'i , as� � ` ` o--�-.tA,;_!__.� a...__ .�I _ d - '_�? I ' �:"+ � I� ' u ' ; ' ., .` io k .� �� k �s �g � ) '• _ �, : .. ;n,_N fn,�� Z 4 ..�_ � .., i �, i g 7 r. • i .. oo b � x •�roa�.� « ,�a_ .�_!� irFir tn �� i � SN/EZOS �"j_"�J" �_'7n7f-�r--Irtnr-t , 7s i!itrP S'�. � 4�. -, I ',,x.--,SN/fGOJ �6� AYE. � � ' .tYf. � ' i.:. n !:p � L t� 1 I � . �'--I� � : i� �fe ^� ua • "�ie�ro�= .:'�'�'rir'�i:%�itr��:..'1.� „� . �� � rr � .� r— ----� �� � -- �� —�° -{i 7,��( g�, ` . ' zi i i. � 'I t--j?i;---��.� �iz_i�_ � O� � r� 'L. r. __j � r°- -� I r-� � � I 6 z �, I �� eo !i�_a�j r—ii.-1 � � �--�i--,-- _ � � � �a s .I i. z� � � � � l�� p,��� � i '�9 'I s� ��.."`; i-, � �i ' � ; I I � :r a i � !�s' !``4—! � � <<_ N--�'-:5-?!-f{---6--�pti N7'�--!�-�-1-�0 ,N-r-?�4-.4I-�J?f K � � '`� � ` I' "� ! j� s 1 � ��' I a � a� I e , M �c, -I � i .�-_.��i I �. Z 6 r � ri l e � �- r f- .- . �---- I � b' J�- � .---� �__ti l �i».r �� !?�� '_ /d � '�----%—� /7 ;. 71 •I �__I� �; Q � 7. i , N �ri - Q � _ . 11 I i j 1 I� _.__._y e j ' � ^' i , , � m�' ' :� � I. ,, `,!-- � � h-----=J �-- ,—.---1� "�rt""�r. f .. �u 1 � ,Y i; s �-� �I 1---_. � _. .�.- ri � j� ; ti � I i fi 7!: __jftlt�:� 19 • � S/! � SJ I^ __ h.•p�. � ' �` 'e 1 . . °".G_ *�,,.y 9,s � 3 ie x w a � �e � � � i �� ri I o � ta r s i _ r� 1--'ts�� I . �a.i t'� � � � �i ---t � --1 1— � —z � � ' � � � �mr ti ---"'�--.._.,..e7� x-.-��jt--y,r��zrt o , �3 Ara i r6 yi : m 9 �1Y/ � zz `�'�"�' � R ;ro ' � � � �j��ir �-_nz: r .,;,.x, ,t,v�.', W '� � �t� _ i� � '' '?�� '.O io w ' ia � -- � - d -�� � �s ,n m u i io 4 i I�''� '�""T+r7,r�s; : a,.. �..sic k � ' , r £ ,O r, i . � t �is ia;ar �a��i i, � "+ � � I O �TTS''' _� ._ B ; u ; j .v--�` n T ro j 'a 1 . . i d is�. ,st� : , � i ie;�is;i� ia i ir n�" I � i_�I. '�tr �r -��--,�-�' v i-- . � . �l•- •_. [ � E n -'-�-�-°-��_1u.� ��� ' I, � � i y Q Are�t�I i i I I � �mr,n v���_� 2 � . 9� _ ,i I I ' __ � �.c"'��_yf jj b L ,� I I I �' I!O .1/I JS j)J�i � I �� I �, � �T' �— . i '�7j ' � � i�3T.-ANFp . . �rr ie u I i�I q InA�' . "''"`-*-.-�.r-rTr1 t AF!`---_'--------� s-,.1 ,� w�.i��i ,- . � ' �ic I , � �, Im . ��i i i �. r�.�ti`Tr i y ' I :�rrl.-,--..�,�.,Tir�-�ry b ��o�"- !'� ._. __ :-'_`_�t i'tu!.��y.��e�vi�a.t i, j a0C f. ;n j ie i is i�;i� 4d0 �ro i , j . ^i i � ! s � I r '�ti. �e � � � F � T� YY'Yr.s�'. __'.'__ t'L'--�-�.i��_.fct...:f, a � � � . s �I' n�is o— � �"� i� , s i� i � i e " I I `� Jti.+}� `y_' ----- '� �'�i:t_L,,,_ � a . , V � ' t ;�'T � ��� . .. ----- __ � , � �- : � ! , , I ./�� �• I � i ��-r�rm . : .�.'t'��- . yr,�t!.�ic �- Z-,--� I I ' I : �� �� � �3 � r i�w I - i � � �nuf"�-j-� , . '_'__ VbC0 1� s , � ,c ^ � � ; .r ..i , � � `� j ��� i' . ^i =� :I � �. i , ,°rr-�'ar�-n-1 �` . �+vE _��-.c.. �.�. '�-"' "'-----•' '�'���'r�2 Y w 2 k--L_.`,� ..� � � �7• ` e,�a�3 i r.�N a' tl . t, I tl Ni � j '°a+r,�•.,.-�,--.T-..�tnr 1.'-- '\ii i : e ; �---_� i.�-� V ��rrr-� i_' �. I .. . . ' `I a2� �a t��. l � � � e� ; I � ^ ���� -- � r f"_7ne-- �� :a,^.7 �i�: .ei�' t, � a-_ . �s i `d`� y �.1 � i I �� ,,_ .I �3 �aa n '+ t.._, . , . I F_"'--� ,-�_ a J.o r�w ! , . I � � I i f e\a � e � F�r ----�.: ; _____, ,—�; r � „ (� - ' �—� 1 ,o 4L�.v 417 I tij. 1 . � )6�H 1�vM I I � ~ �^+-,...dy ~--�,�Op N'g..a� '% - ' W F -�-�`___a a "Snx--r r2•• Ja� � - �(" xJ �rr..eior ! I � I i s � . ;�- , Ir�`'`` ^;_�'x„`,' Z I�.��s , � -._ � °T'-I , rr��;ra� 4re- r�rm� �i i ar..e. � '„a. e ^ 4 r� i� � I � � � � � �d00 k'��s 3i �io� h e I e �m � ii it ir° �b �� ��y�k� ��! o � � � � � �„� I ' �uor �. -_� � �`+trs�. -:•. 084Y �s'` ' � i I I F� Fts� I�� M i ii h��s ia�l re ,. � �, e , � t ' i • I'�`s'"�,��.`„ N ' �`��-"� aii e 46o I �� � `, A� I o�� � V' � ' I I �°po I �� n�ie.�� 'ro\zr rz\ �z� � �o� S �.�:!��r` 1 e 1 � ' � ?�� � a^i 17��.,".",lJ.:n� e ' I i pJ �. ��i4y4.:_•11J1'.Jd I 5.4�.L11fAta�� ' ��vr�.o I � . j 'i,.���M i��,v^��i r. � � -�,��_����� N �` IA, s ��'}�,�'i'sfs'�� i_ � Q � �6a� � AYE. y �i V Q i I\ � I i t �'�") i` {�r� j � �.: ,"� •[>s� Is • �dlz �,w ! ,i j I I � xl � I I m� . ^ �i i�--r I i r'�,,I �;'a' ` ,-�`' e4 ' s ; � ! aia �:o'u�- y� o I `~i�� I ! �. I �'� � fl / i � ir �:� wR� i • e � z�' i �,a:r�i1 ';�an�i�iir�n�m, oiew� r—� p �� .. I � ._� i � ` . I � Q I �� ,� 7 I ti 6� � � �� ' � °`r. �';'�.� � .: _� � I V �_'�' � f � I � I I � � Z __._ � i`o � . � __`_� �; .1____J�e j I s � � i_,,,, ',�, j � i�! \ �� \� ,'� T � � � � ,'�`�"T"�. ��--� s-__1___._.�._L�_ _� 4----, .� �__ . ! ' ! : � ,.� \ � o � � � I ti! � ' %� , I, 1 � ��TT T T I �__� t� '' ° Z ' �--i�. •e �;� 9 �,a !u i�r:. C ^ I i r� C k i � � i :' I a � �f w l9 ��.-,�._�� .. �-ir-�-��Al7r`'p< -���_�a,,--.� "itl.. j � � f� j � � 4 � � �ro ,��j s �r �, � ��si�i I ir n m i ri,��r.rf� I.__" � �_ : �--.�.,_.� c , - r.. � � Or, � � ; , � It__ " 5� f �• `s �� ` � :� i . i I �7+� .r+-���1�9 � �s,te.� r.i�' � tzLau_;n�!1L �.iq�ro1.I��•i�i i,��„l�. °' � iz= . ; � � i ` �6 , ; � � ' � �_� � - T .�1� � e. , .._.� . � i I I 1 � • I 7 1 z �� � i , �0J fY4- Q iIV �--�.�,T'�; L + � I t � �e�.s �° t a i i � I�r�a?'i \ ���,r+ . 9 Tnr.�.«�t?7r*7u - ' .:,r-'-T� ` ;I��u ` T�___ ____� � � d � ° � � � `e � ' �5 k f i � � I � � � pia � e g I i' �---r-�°vN-� I E aj._3_-L�f'T. o j� / +Ji6 C �r!��,a r 'e �: �I J o • � � L 4�w • +. i i« n. � o' � I ..� i � ; ;io i q �'iz;.,� �' � � � � ��'� � r b B ? � �� � �w-�naa-� nr7r---I � � y.r�-�� i .�.: N T' o s _ a ` i � i . i irz? i I i ^�; tl � . ._ r u�s� _ � � . i � �i A v m c� i � � �r �1' 4 �' i -�� f------ : ��"L-� vi_-:_..� �� I � , ��� ��'" "� v' e I a ''ro n ��1 . �, � � ��4� e � �� : .f ? � �... .�_, �[� � � . . . I ��'a"! 'rn� 8 ��, �'is�r w , nti � z : a E /6LEHART f!ua..�o��i�.l__:� •• Ltzz_�_.�. z .:�`, �'t, i� � ' I— � I ' �'71 0 .Jii�.r. I n �i, 1 ( '�] ' � " +T `.�0 , d 1P' �.:u/.�f_rL_/N ' —(� � b t r N , I Y i � IJT•�- y . � oo - . ..-rrv � � \f �j z i 7 �e- . � I � , : ; . /rSrc...-rv `r-�- � urpa�� �. A%E. i ; V� I � I ' i �i �� � � � � , �� � ... I , � ' � � �" ' � - . , , " !' o'!�� ��rr--�r—z•e'."� �>�-- ��_:.__�___' _ ;" � � i i z i aii' r� i ;� r�i� ��f� �� iv_ �` -�- � ' � , ' ` , � , � r � f�i T� �- .. . . OQ ! -t.' I � �� ; .y �, + ¢-Z ` � a � k" �-r-� L__�I ' � 0� . � ' I ; ___' _. I �C 0 n, ��D: � �J j-__?l.tf_ �:��Nt'� w�� �s � � - z�9 �, � .�� i i . �-"1__' �'p9 -r�i i �. . aa 9� �sa+-�?-�Tarir : t �. . B , 'V'��� ,� 17 B 9 I/O�// �/2w� �f � � `,�� i '� �iv:.»��f3 1P l '� ! 8'� ;� .j �,��,� � c �� e j 9 I m j n i ir- :K/ e 9 j io � ii �u� �� 's �S �I u� itc�j J " �z � � �'s` ti :•� ��`�'f \. . , � . . _. ,-_--�s:'f"?... a I � � � `x � I ': � ' � � �s �� ;�,��r :���,� �n. l.,,`__ r , . `r3�Ii..�:.f -:ric�s���._^' a� �Ei_f}I �1 • . I i � . �: a �. —= .—fn'ARSHALL—• --��`�'_r.r.�'`•_ ' r. •�-- � -. . . � . , �:x�?`�`,,,�:�»...n.. , .,.. .s _":. _;.s�; � ��' '"� r'-' / .� ' e . `. '� _;'_`-.-------�.._._..--•-r--•--- ��_ _. [ � ' � s ��;s�r i Q ► �c--n.-T—.T.c��r-.n;a r r: '�'"r :r ' : i `dd°' �t�E.-— , , ; �a;s � et3i:, i . p � �� . r -ra'2':L'� • . I ��� A�3 3 ! D Y•� � � i � 5� i �s � c F . i �a i� s I s'a� � � � � r i�s s� • 7 ♦ i� � $ � � ��n� � �'�'•^.` , �S PA R•K A D D: j � � � 9 I` I� i � 12 � ,•=�;tz!z��zl�tr�r.'n zs' G--- �>,,,;,.j �� ��. O A I A � o f'_ ., .__. . �._ k A ,:.. ..�_ - — __ __� __ � � .�.._ �_ .. ,.._. - _ ' Y D C MO � � . ... _... .�.. +�-r...._ ' r�,J--� .. • �.� ... . . .'i� ��, . .:��"�n���.� v.� . . � ... . `.'.��,.' - � �` � �_. � _ . -.. _.....�. � . . . . � �� � . .,.._ ,.�.. f,', ..-... .. :e:... .w...v.., v.n.. .. ......._. _.�._, .� . . ' � . .. � ._. .. . . . . .+......r.qn..a+-m�ra,...�..+.w»wry�rv•�unmw.�w��.w.�� �.�,....�.. .._ � . _... ..,...rnr.�.r..�.»�..+, .. . . . . . .. . � � �f � .v.w.'v�aa��tw�vrv+��eM��n'Pw+�ae�+mw.�.nv�.� ,...._•..� ....._._..�.. t � , , ` � -' E . � .� _ I . A.n F`� �+ �j ' .. �/ .n ♦ ' . . [ � . t . � NLYUT�:S OF !'!."�LIC `.'EAK'::!t: dL'F ►R;: 'i���. i:�A�:► Ui' ��:t;.:iG � _ � ;,r•il �.?, 1_�t,9 r C , #� � � pWrW�S�s llsssrs. Am�ss, D�una, Gaugar, Maietta.and �IcPar*Lin of ti�e k3odrei, � Nr. Paul !C�llv of the Curporation Couns�l's of�ir.e acci Dt. ' ,� t1�i�.Ea, +�ir. Sor�nsan aad :irs, Iris:► of the s•�a,-.�f� ` • Hr� NcPax�lia �d that �th� aiautss �f the ��re•,iats a�ae�.�� � ap,irov�d, � ma�ic� a�candsd�by Mr. Gauger and carried uQaaidw�sly. ;: � :. BUREl1U: An sppesl to relax deasity and frontage requiresee�� far pro��rty located �; on the south s�de a.f isle rt Avenue between 'Pierce Str�eet a,nd F�t S�M►���- Mx. Sorsusan ou�.l,�aad e�hi patt�er u follovsc the apPsltant p�tct�oss#`�� ��'.tvo t�` 1 s�u�ri�x+ea onto E�'�=;1ot�' et►cb lot ha� insafficiieat f�roata�e��d ���:� Pern►it � a dupl�x !�, ,� "3" .�ea��� soAe. The 'lot fs�ta�s xequire�t �s SO fe,et: the . : ��;s r ai: ' '�#i�`'b,r#�Q� �u�t� �eet: �ac1t lot is b tta� �►��1�'X, �I��Pt �i� froncage: , if is.�, ' ' � e� �4� �o�r �� 35'�. defi¢i�nt i� area. �ite ��+e+� to t�ir north, east , ` 5 '.�,,,� `. +�d��`t f � �B'! ,�ssa idence: to the •wttb tl�s as�a i� s+�ai�+d „�".. t�s idence. The .. �3 � >� . �[ v�at �d at strsst grada. In r.�lwia�►, h* gar►e .che foilowing : �� . ;,�# �; � ° " : :4 Tr�;) c�e cro a�i.x.. ..y not be dstri�e4ntal t� !he ad jacent � ��►tsri�s to r�lect�d locatiana of sufficient frontage and are• ' �` ` zastsr b�caws of the extent of tra�•braach resoval. In � , ���►; 1�"d, �.!�,, y�� ,; �� � , � � � � � . ` � � � �� 'Code r�quirNents are ressoaable for duplexea .in a � , �;= ��se. is nq lrardahip claised, or in evidence; and 3) s-iy ' . . ,��� `� - id bthalf of hts appeal. said that the lot was platte;�� `� ; ` ° e�d th�t aru for s singl�-family tesid�nce by A""" '��` � ,� .�� x�o!}l�ted out that there is a large induatri�ll buf ldi�g � �,;,�' ��iLa is 130 fe�t fran the �ain liae of ths Milwaukee �' ��:� ., , it� al lot ,�la wblcb to tiuild a new ho�e. He said the y , -_ . �D r, �,��+^. w is a i'�lst-eiisa �ood duplex. Nr. Gau�er ioquired ���� 4 "� "� f r l'�t3oet wre oa ths tMO •ls �or wbich ttre Board *`� y aPP� ;����.� : ��-� `' �dr �lu a�o: tbs aoawr wu 10''X to 15�. Mr. McAtrtlin . '� � j; •_� � �' ` ;i�ctis; ;hil�es ar� �ell kept; the loE� ars wll. ?his would � �f�; �, �,�, . � � ,�s �aek tih3cb ws crowded. A'� "`���,. h ��: "� �°i• ,;�kiss !os vns aupl�x o� o�e lot: or�ioa�1�. he vaated ;: u:{ - � � ' ���� 4 _. � �� �;� ` ir�t 1� 1rd obtaia�d another� aita for t1+� ssCoard duplex. At :�� ; >�d��� 3�"' ...�; . ' t � � ° a , �+ � f�►��;��'lsl�it �oa1y i to +�ovw► ths d�lsx at 300 'M. Sasi 1it� Avae►�e ta Lot 4. �. `'� �; ��, � y�� i.l�!;:�IM th� l�t tA thlt sai�t:�� �' a ���_ V+�a�s; to ;� 4� = t "° " � r.: c �z�igbc� �� � �� ���,�.: `�t 'Tt>'� �t =oio� to b�t'�i1ws.1�+����� `� , "��;`'�� ��.��� �� f � �'� ��M!►� �7► a�ssidanc� tiii� ��hba 4 � � ��'��ea.�:� w '��: `" .°�� �, :� ��`�`, •sar��ts� build. � . .� F ar � � �� �� .��' �� � ���� �� � � � ��'�,� � � ` .:��, ����� � � � � ,���� + ` � `��,r �s�hia� ' '�,� " '� . ��. 4 ` �'�, •�.� . � � }� +�� , ,��. .,� �.. ,� � �ti � � . +� �� � - � rt7 . �� � �+!� ;: �� � , � ; �: . ,,� ; � '� � ;t"�j ,� s ��� � °�� �'�- � ,. r F o � �:- � '� �`. ,�`' ` �i ��� Y � �r��: �'.:i�^.�, � , t�.;x�+a �� �� `'k ��� °�` +► R ��� � i 7 " � ��"' �' � P �' � .. 11 4. �A.� 4 � ` _w ��, h'\ 4 •i.• '�^ .� lA', '� ,��' , �,g�. 5p�.� 1$F` � ' }��+k�y; � �� t . � �, �. .`,7' . � �if� 1 �. t }� 3 � . � t !i y $S �+ Z ql,� ":, ���,..1`;� . ;s��� � .. . �:��:° , ,a ��������,.:�.�'`,, � , . `�, 2, �,- ' ' � �� , + + ' ., A - ,I' •'. Mr. Gauger said that on the Heille matter, there was an illegal use at that time. He said he thought it would be Well for the Board to notify the Police � Department and other intereated departsants of this situation. Mr. Ames said he vould call it to the atteation of the inapectian department;� if it is not in the juriadiction of his dapartment, he Nill send it to the Health Department. It waa the concensus of the Board that this appeal should not be granted: Mr. . McPartlin moved for denial, motion seconded by Mr. Gauger and carried unanimously. ; `. .. � . ....fy. . . . . . :1 ' . � . _ . . . , . . � _ . � � .� . � - � � . . ' . � . ' � . � . �, � . . d. . . � � ' � . . �. � ' , � .. � ', . . . � • � .4 . . . , . . , . � - � � . . - . ��,- � . .- , ._ �. .. . -. . . ..,'. . . � .� • �._�.. P* � � ,�4°.:,„ ... -�' � . ' . . � . � � � - � � f � .' �� � . _. . � �. .' . . . . . . . . . d�.i: e ._� ��` �.'"t' � � . ���, � *:, ��. �., .�`n��"� �'��=3���'-,. �' - � � � . . . � ' � ' ��`�.z f�i '�NrJ"��� J .. . - . .' . � . . . . � } �i���� :'"5x���y � . . . . f.. . . . � . � � �a' L •.' �� . � � � .. ' . � . . - . ' . . . . • . . �i ��' - . . . ' ; , . . � . � ' ' . . � . #+�� '' s„ . . r . � . . .. . . ... � . .' k r�+ ,.�.. . . . . . � � . . � . � � � x . S s � , �.r,, I � �� yi ., . � . : N � ; ,�., � r. �Y . ' . , �. r; , f; _ . s , , t , 1 ' � v�� ,, i ��,_�—• . , '.���te�t by: : o�oae�. ��., Sosenaon � � . obert ^.. e, . hais�an , r`�i� � � n , '.�: � ' � • :* , , � " , �, .:. � f9 f-. y �w �"t 4 4 " a.''� .. ,-v ';. �-.� �' . `�� .. .. ... .. ..�.��_. >�.. � ....,... �affi. .:..-,�- �e r��.c ��"si,�....+sr..;: _ ., ��.�..,_.:.�_. �_ .�.... �._ ���,K+ .,�".F.-d.�xu�.�:�f€ _ +.�< . _ .. _.. . . � � ►• ` r ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court Novse 55102 May 2, 1969 City Clerk File X690, Page You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St . P:ul at 10:00 a.m. on May 15, 1969 on the appeal of John F. Bureau to relax density and frontage requirements on the following property: Lots 3 and 4, Conver and Theopold's Rearrangement of Block 8, Excelsior Park. The property is located on the south side of Iglehart Avenue between Fry and Pierce Streets. For further information contact Planning Board, Room I010 Commerce Building or phone Z23-4151. JAMES J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance O , � � �. �- • ,� � � ` � , , �, ` � � � � � , �� � ' , ' � �� � �'.: �—�, `s ' �� L� _ , � °;�;�/�' ,.,.._ �...",��.. . _,..�.,�1 � 1 �, �, ' ', � , , _ . ,� �. ._,.,.. �-- _, ., , N /�r` `d '_. ,... . _ .._..._- ��"� ,.� __..�� . _.._ . . ,. __ ,. _ . . . �' �Z �_ _ _ _ ____ _ , ,, ___ _, _.._ __ _ L.:_.. . . ..._ ._ 1 ,. � . . , y„ \k � \ � _ ...._.,.__._ � �___._.._ - -� � V.. _� .� � _.. _--,- .. ----� ---_-7 ---- ii � �- , �; ;, � � � �.. , - �� "; �� � , , _. . , . ; . �, __.__ �, ,�=v��- _---�., �-- •—�.�.__.___..--__..�t_ , � V '_�` _.__i 1 , � tj ( t� j ' "i; � t! � �I � �- -t � a � + � � �s�� f� ;1 �� ti 1 \� x .,.t il� �9' `;a'�� ;� �� � �� ' �;�.�,��� 4'� �- 1 �i �,-' �' ! ' , r� 'i ' , '� ' � . � � �� �, a , ` � i ... ... . ,_.�.: � . . ..._.. .___ .., _ � �. : ,�. , .. y_._ _ ._.... '�i � '�. � .:�,.;:;:. _.�:�:,_ � f `. 4'; d _- --(`�;r�"J�`"f"` ; '' __.. — ,, , .,_,_. � ... ...._ _�._. _..�. _ .. ... _ r, -� - ,. .. _... _ ; � ' �� �' .� i ,,•;�,;, . .�� �`�'':�.�;''��,���, -..«' �,: y � °,y;°� ;,������� �,� �;z . `. ''� t,t � ' � + ,, � �. � „ � � _ _ .. T „ , � _ . _. __._._ ...- ,. ....__ ._ __ � ,, : �-- _-___ � . , , ; _ r i _ . . _,� . _.......__. 4_... - : . . .._.- . _ �,,..., r � ..____._..-_..»"' - ,�..,....� �__�-_ �.... . _. . � ..y..' . .�r� ��� I '� _"".._..—'"r.�. �.w 1: ._t".��"'���_�.�l� .._- � � . ' .. . .._�; �1.� � ` '� j_,. ' i. F"'F , t. "r'v;;.'i' T-- 1. , ,: , i : . _ __ r:.::-'° 1 .,. �r �.:+i'- � � �.,. .. . . . . .. �� r� ��` � � ,� �.��3 '-� ,� `� + :t �' . A ., ., . i� � i . i �+� ' c$T,r,Y i ?.'i�'�4+�� -J � , � � ! �, � 14 ` .. , { i ,t � � _, . _-. �; , � ..�;. . � . ���:: _ :__.._r � ._. , �.w..�._ --, , . ' , � . , . ._. . ; �; .... . � 't _____�__ ..�.--___ —4 -- . . -.. .� _.--- -. _ __. . .._-�---� � � -� � _. , � t _ ._. _._.__+,� � 4_ --__. _ _ _ . � . - �,,� C>� N �, .�� = 1(' ' ' ,!. .�L y _. _ � �..__ _. . G� �,n ��-� .�...-= � .�,_�.. .r��21,'"' � ��.=s:a%�:�;`' "_ _ � _ , � ..,, .., r..�� t� � w _.�. . � � �`s - --.�.- __. �•- ,__�-- � _. ___ _. ,._.___ , ___..._.- ______ . , , ...__�.____,.:-,_._... .. I ' � i r _ ti y' ...4,. . � � � . . . - . ' . ,t_ ,. . , .. _ . , . , . , ,'�.; �)�. ♦ . .. . . . � .1 { N� C ` !h . . .. � .. � . � . . . � -.. � � � � .'�„`�,.Ty,� � a...... .._. - ' . . . . �' . _ . . . _ . .- � � I ' .. .. ' . . . . . . �,..'.r .. . � - . � . � . : t. '� . ' .. . � � F.� . .� . . _ . �. .... � ' '� �.;_.;- . ..., ;, . i, . 4 l' . . � � . ' . ; q�.., . . _ ..-�_ ;•�. .'. , y . . l . _ � , ��, M1; . � . . � �4 . � �, , � y[� , i: ; j 7'4-z �I ' + i� a .., � f � 5 . � �� t" r.� - �. � �� • _ , �� E., � �.�. . Y 4 •;^� .. : i ; � � . .: i , _' .� i f (' `� ' � , . „ .� ... , , � y � I I E , �, s 1 1 . .�, [�1 � . `�''' ! ;� _ � . y�� ..c t 4` .` � '��� � � �` . . , . �. �-. _ � , � ._.. . .. .».._ ._,..__.�--r�-_-,y..,,l, ti��.. ._._.�.... .,.�..� _._,. '-� � , f .�.�.�_ ' � .,q�� . � ,. `, • �` .. � . -- ,., .. � . � *...� � '�-- .._._ ._....... y..�..""'-. ,- ... ...... ..._..., _.._.__. . .._... . -.. . -'}' � . . f�„� ...., ___... ._ _... ____.__ v._. ._.._-- '-_-- ..._ .., f� L.. �._ e � � �? � � �`� k� , , � : , '�, `y � . . , � ; � . � __� _ ..__._ � --- --__-- ; ; . ._-___-:� --_3 ..____- �, ; _. � � , , ; _,._.. � N ' ' � � ��..{ .. � � 1 .. � ,.�I '� �4 `[� . � . 4 ' � i l � ' � . . � � j i 1 � ' � _........., . }..--�....�..:..�..,,�...«�.�.�r�^�_..�...�}.r�...r.....�.. "—�-- . S �,_�___—. '-.,4 _.___ + t. —"'--•�- °--.. �� � ��' { I � : ' ? �' '� �-- ' � � 1 t; � '� � ' � , r ; ='4 �,c i ; ,„ f ¢:} ' �i1a c';���'''�'`�3� !i y� � � �t �t , ; � �i� � �i i ' r�1�.� -y� ,"'` � I {� ti}" j� . . �,� 4�' ! ; �✓t`F��S.J�:.y1 � , �f t � , � - i ri i � i; �� ��� � �t � ' _ � __ _.__s � i� t . R...�.. ,. r .�� .—___ �.::� ._. ._. . . ; i .,�. ,;� �, _ r,,�Fr.n�"� , - � r� r � . : .�,..__ . ,._. . ...._.... . .. ,i � ;_ �3 � ���, c -.g._ � :_. __. .. . _ , � !�1, ��; �; 1._ ���'�:�, � �'"" �r'�¢..-��" _ i�' '' !' �S . t : n3 : , '�' rP r' ::�':..�r �� '.� �' i ' � �.�, 1 ' . � .-_ 1 i` '� � � , - . `� �; ,; ��' �1,�i 1 �.��`.� :.> ; '��5 �� ' r E� �� '! :r* ': ; , � � ; r; � � I; /�'� ..�.._.� r _ _�_. __ : _ ._ �; .. � ;. � � , ; } _o.� ....___ ._._.._ ,_.._.._,_ ___ . , a, , � __ , ` � . � ' � � . _ � �_ . _. . � _ _ . +�._ --- - _ .y.. , �, �... ._ - ; , _�.__u r���t � �, ,� �� -r,, �,� �°�+ � ` �r � ' '\ r � �� + y ja �u� a .__._.____.�. -y — •� , � .._.} . f`l' �i''�,7. F�'��'��,;1������' ',� rw,�; •-,r,,�� ;_r :-, � i; ' ? � � ' , , � �,v � .-, i �� ? _, _ _. _ . , �._ . � , ,._ , . - . ._y ( u.__ _ . - -- � _.a 'r 91 ; R a� ` � � , , ���-a� � .: y�+��'(,,, '��.��. e . �. i; � Gf L� '"�' '�"J.�.�.r-.r�w �i ...�, : � ��,- �1 ,� ° �` � �, 6 c'�':1.,i i ;`f�V�-+ "'%' � . � i j.' ___.--*_ Y'.7� .f1 , ., . ., � ; .. ,j. . I � � iV �� �� � �. . _ __ ._.. tj \ I ? , , � ' � � .�:. _..._ __ __ , , � � ___._... _._-- --—•�___. .. r� � , .y, , �