244283 ORI6INAL TO CITY CLBRK • •
CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
COUNC RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY �'
COMMISSIONE DATF
RESOLVED, Upon the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning
Code, by Milton. L. Van.Buskirk, owner of the subject premises,
zoned in Light Industry District, under said Zoning Gode,
described as Lot 13, Block 5, College Park Addition,
according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the
office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota,
that the provisions of said Zoning Code, in respect to density
and lot frontage requirements, hereby are determined and varied,
in their application to said real estate, as and to the extent
necessaxy therefor, and that a permit hereby is granted unto
said appellant, and his successors in interest, in respect of
said real estate, for the conversion of a single—family residence
�
to a duplex; and that otherwise, said appellant—permittee, and
his successors in interest, shall make due compliance with all
applicable ordinances, state statutes and rules and regulations
of public authorities having cognizance.
_ __�. F0�1 AP�'ROVEp �
zox�a�rswi. � - ,
. ��
Notice ia hereby vcn tliet a public �g ^:.e���[fn--�atWf� �i0411fd
�e�g vvill bE.he� betore the City �h�'
Council at l0:A.M. on MaY 28, 1989, in l G=°�
the Glt,V Couacil Cha?nber in the City �
Hall and Court House in the matter oi
tlfe aR +a o# Milton L. VanBusklrk„
COUNCILMEN "�d`�' �8 t� ee so � ��,�ive, at. JUN 4 196�i_
�X�a�ty�e�naaTd�sno� Lote'la Adopted by the Council
g�ock!f,College Fark A$dition,located
Yeas Nays on tha �outh side o! C�rrqll Avenue
b�Et�veea P'rY �eet and �sieilisg Ave-
Carlaon �n"e. J U N 4 196�
•�a��� �8.�a�.
Dalglish •��'' Approved 19—_
Meredith �� 1?' s��
-- - ---=r
_� �
Sprafka � Mayor
A gainst
Tedesco
Mr. President, Byrne
t�t��t �t 7 1969
0
_
, � .
Ha�ry E. Marshall �ITY �.�� Albert e.Olson
City Clerk and �``��`�% Councid Recorder
Commissioner of Reqistration a '`�" `
;aW.00_,�a� .�
:�� ^c'
�
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
BUREAU OF RECORDS
�8B City Hall
St.Paul,Minnesota 5510�
�tay 29, 1969
�, � � � � � � �
M AY � � 1969 .
CC1N�t)RATION COUN�EL
Mr. Joseph p. Summers
Corporation Counsel
Buildin�
Dear Sir:
The City Council today requested that you prepare a resolution
granting the appeal of Milton L. VanBuskirk to relax the density
and lot frontage requirements oP the Zoning Code as they apply
to property located on the south side of Carroll Ave. between
Fry St. and Snelling Ave., described as Lot 13, Block 5� College
Park Addition.
Very truly yours,
/
City C1 ^
n8 �1�
O
r . . ,
. e . .
� ' -
BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
May 27, 1969
Mr. Harry E. Marshall, City Clerk
Room 386, City Hall & Courthouse
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to the appeal of Milton L. VanBuskirk to relax
the density and lot frontage requirements of the Zoning Code as they apply
to property located on the south side of Carroll Avenue between Fry Street
and Snelling Avenue. This property is further described as Lot 13� �lock�;.5,
Emllege Park Addition.
This matter was considered at the April 3, 1969 Board of Zoning meeting.
The staff reported that they appellant proposes to convert a single-family
residence to a duplex. A two-family use in a Light InduBtry zoning district
requires a lot area of 6,000 square feet and a frontage of 50 feet. This
site, however, has only 4,900 square feet and a frontage of 40 feet. The
variances amount to 1,100 square feet or 18.3 percent in area and ten feet or
20 percent in lot frontage. The surrounding area has industrial and mixed
residential uses.
Mr. �IanBuskirk, speaking in behalf of nis appeal, noted that the structure
was large and had sufficient bathrooms. Off-street parking could be provided
for two cars. He noted that there are other duplexes in the area as well as
a four family use on a lot the same size as his. He said that he needed the
income from the proposed second unit to`'provide for himself.
After additional discussion by the Board concerning the �xtent of the variances
and the effect on the surrounding properties, =a fnotion was made for approval.
This motion failed for lack of a second and it was then moved for ap�roval�� ��_�
This motion passed by a vote of 3-2. The Board of Zoning, therefore, recommen� °'
denial of this appeal to relax the density and lot frontage requirements.
Subsequent to the Board of Zoning meeting, Mr. VanBuskirk submitted to the
zoning office the enclosed letter of Mr. D.L. Smith, Vice President of Liberty
State Bank. Mr. VanBuskirk asked that this letter be transmitted and noted
to the City Council when his appeal is conside ed �-�_
ry u 1 y C.',,�,,.,, rrt,�.,
`� �.
: � �
S�ea�reba�a�y, Board of Zoning
-1- � �....�-r-�/�� r
. .
.. � � -
` Mr., Harry E. Marshall -2- May 27, 1969
Enclosures:
1) Letter of Mr. D. L. Smith, Liberty State Bank dated 4/11/69
2) Letter of reference fram Mr. Nick Delmont, secretary, Board
of Barber Examiners dated 10/27/39
. 3) Letter of appeal dated 1/7/69
4) Board of Zoning minutes dated 4/3/69
5) Board of Zoning Report and Action dated 4/3/69
6) Property location map
�
- _ ' /��
� _ �B�:xTY �
� SATAtE¢�
+ � !L�1\
LIBERT� STATE B.�TK
FUL.L SERVICF_
SNELLING AT SELBY AVENUE * ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55104
646-868�
April 11, 1969.
St. Paul City �Council
St. Paul, Minnesota
Gentlemen:
Mr. Milton L. Van Buskirk has made application to the
�otmcil to duplex a building that he owns at 1622 �arroll
Avenue, St. Paul, Minn.
Mr. Van Buskirk has owned this property since 1945. For
many years there was a small house on the land and this
was moved. In 1960 Mr. Van Buskirk purchased the present
house and moved it on to the location with the intention
of making it into a duplex. We loaned him the funds ior
the original land purchase and also for this large house.
He did not have the money to duplex the unit immediately but
it has always been his intention to make the necessary im-
provements for a duplex.
I feel sure that there will be no objection to this application
and urge you to give Mr. Van Buskirk your approval .
Very truly yours,
IBERTY,STATE. BANK �
�� �' 7 i l 1 .._ �
1 �, �� +,
r" V, ` " � ` �'` ., � - cll�
Vice President ��;� �� ��� '���, '�� y,; ;� �
il ! �� Ilr �_ .
DLSmith:ha APR �:; , 19�9
, CI�CY P��i"�Ii��u tsUr�,�€€�
� «�nt Pa��s; ,�-��r��_
�, , ..,^ �.� � �. �3 o s �
, �. .�. �� �� G
� �.t�t� �..j_'.{w�� �R:.�^a � :1 �,� x' . , ,. . � . . ..
�r° : � .y �. , _� .
�r��t�. �, �; �.��, .�w .
" P c, t ",� � ,� '� ,� � .
°a1�^ _�t y�r, '� +�e e.:' �a E� � '
���k�����' � ' 3 . .�i . .,Y , � . .
� ' �
�w r�4l�� �: E ds' � . .. , - .
� �r�z `"3' ^n^�` w,� � . � . . .
A+r�",x� � `��,' :i � _R. . .� .
S i -.ro �'��;rg .' . .
�1p .�;-� �q�� � 'rsa. � . .. . .. � , . �
'�� � ,� i�;i'y, . . .
.�,.r.,.:�;+1� ..p.�'�nt
d � ,',-. �rr .� �, � . � .. . , .��
� i""_: �"'�+"',.. .,s. ....�T,"�r"y.�.,,,.. „�.1.....+il�lql�"... .. �` .
` ._�tyr!'__�iK�p,rry-7��8N�;r � CARL A. GUSTAFSON �
�°� CK �� RUDOLPH W•SVIHOWE,C�inr��N
SdcwcrwdM
. a s
�n ...
, n.,r...�... ,+ � ,:
, . �t�te of �tinnesnt� �
�� w.
_ � �D�r� nf i���b�r ���uttnrxs €
. . ,
� � e ���at ��ul
. October 27, 1939
. . o
�;
�
. . ;
. . i
i�... . ,. (.� . � �- � � , �
' ,. . .D � ' . . � � . .. � . � ..,�
� ' . TO WHO�, IT MAY CONCERfts . , ',a
� , � . . ; . �, _ �, ,.. � �
I �have known Milton L. Yan Buskirk as barber for
{
� many yen►rs� both as a Journeyman and shop owner. I can
certify tl�at he has for ntany years with the Barbers� Union
Journeymen donated his time and seiwice in different
hospitals� i.nstitutions and orphanages for the welfare
of the patienta thereof. �
ver i;rul o. � `�' ;-
' ' � � ,/ �
1/V;' "
�
Nick Delmont, Secretarg
BOARD OF BARBER. EXA:'�INERS
_
�
I �
; . �
Z�N9�� �=�L� �' '� � � �
__�
� . . �,�.�,. � � �.� .
Ti� !,E F�OB4Rd8LS Yi'I4A S`r�'i�L �I ��
�IIT� CIT� COUitQIL ` �A� 7 iti�
�
COT��i2 80� �Y ROOY 8�l3 G;?�JR�' HdUS�: ��J/
�r ��vr� 6p
�a���� -
(�I�iSL�[�f lHIB It l� 1PPLIt'xATItNt QF IIZLltlli L Wl� �1$Y2RH -•--i�4 08��
� QAR�bL �T!
�3? PAI� 5bib�i
�tT�ItE�QT�
��� a8
�EI� �.B 1L�'AY� 8�� gB�C�? LI��iT _,-�.�.o� ia s�oQa � ce�� p�c �
I�Dt3�9'1'�T 1�7J �i I�i I PIIR�H�A8�3J A ��'ti�E
L�Ii:A�D 1T i8�3 r9Hir'it A�? II�T� C�TT PZ�tI[I88I4�i[ T4 �4� ZT TO ?i� J!$�W�
dI3�F�S�,IIi DOTIi� �t0 I t��i �'0 8'�T'�D THS �'0�lfiI4F �QII� �I% $EY?.AND Tt?
���L 1 tGx��'�' L84� Tfl �T�D �'01�►►Y ��,t3�E'!' AIrD B�T� �THT� �IA�3 �Q��4&T � �8 1�
�IO'081E DID At}! CAiI�� '!� �'l.lt�lllT2� 8Z 11�A? i►AR.
Il� T�S B�iIYIID� I !�D �L11,AT�1 IUT3'f�DET� T4 �81� ?1�I8 AS !t. ?'�� FAIItLY Hatl8� AS
Y'! TI'!'� �1f1 I A�E ?!tE O�L� OUE�# L�tl� �i. ,
?!tt �iL�L SC�E ?8�4 O�I�Tf�►2.LT !3'lt�l? � I �A't� TQ 1 1.HT�� � YAI� !�
�dAKSD �4A fAT At3��S� �OV�� �P I �".S?!lI3�BI� T� �A�H �0� �ICI� � � 1�
4RIti�I��LL'i �?AOD.
ia �Ttl� 5828 A0�'! !LL OI�'? �c� � �L�A1� A�iD x18PEas�D 13UB ?t! l� !�Z
a ZACi�l1� 8T13'U� 18 A'�'1�.�3 S+�iCIIL �$�t2?? P�I4� 1tARE'� IS �C�B�AI' THAT
1 t38 St�it$'lSI� I�IA?B`LY !Q HYI� �t? �..1� llLt�.
� �t !lSBZAQ ?f�i' I �! ��1H� 3`Q U�? THt9 �'A'��L7 NAI� FaR ?IIO �'11�ZLILI� �
I�8lL� t3�' J�1'! O�t �LYIL?,
? t4ZtLD FR�R 40 �` I? fiA 4� ��+�P�.E.A�3 AE 1RY � A1�D ?4 ,�HI3 TFiIB �
8g SS !0 BIt� FOR !R8 PF�4PI.�.
I �1�t 1lLSQ ASYI� T�1� � �.i�C 1P� BB �JCC��D 18 I DD I�AT THIl�i ?Ai1T �
IB l�Rf3S IX �#i�'il A� I Hl4I? T�L�ED 1tI'�`K PT�AR��3t� P��F'i�.i► l:4�?RACTt7►R8 A�8 I
•4tIb3� 8�'! �IltT� AJt9E TAB�t Q� ?SIB P�JlG�3T �� liQ fl�l�E �D /t�T �Ci�LFD(� OF I3
2 � �►BIt►?TA3'S'D �� '�A� AI� At��I? ?A�FB ?t3 fi� CI�'T All� �t�T AL6
BAT' 3'82 6 � �� 'f0 �41� ?�lit�fQ�ll�Q At� I HtD J� �g.tAT�A'T .t0}�?G�G� Ilt3li�T1
t?F 8 CiQ�t�A�IQ� �� �'$I QA I SHOIIL�U QF �I�.I B�A :�} �,"1tI1EA�t� liIII1 WA8
i�AA�La TC3 BJtBII3�Tr.
S �iit9 E !3'Q ?lI SQ�Z�38 I� 8T' PAQ� 1� Y ( I�� 2ID�3 82�C.� ��l3f OR i��+�►.
I 8i1E �TR28� �PP�JR 841i� Tff=!?Y ?St� i �96i �1�8�'i 08 �DA'i 1'�0 THi �--
1�W`t�4T !�lI�f?S Ii ?flS RI�T Cfl�'Y '�lt� �fqZER ffii�'►Z41L liilf� �YS? �
Z8 OB�L� ? B PRI�Y�Iiflti�Zi3li 4I�L�'t!8 CxIPPLTII �.ILD�liB I�'I�tL 1LL
01�81Xit��B dB� �3t �"IIS�L ���IL►�4Y IT �.
HOPI� T4t� IiAY ���'!' '�R�3 P��Z��i� A8 8T1?�? �HO�
1�I?8 A�A�tt�t
R�BP�! YAtT�& �
� � G% 2r�2�
YI� L 9�A BII'BICIRY
i�f�,9 ClRR01.L t�
8T P�QL a6i+�
li[��AB�Oi�1
ZC�
���G �1L� -�:
�,.. gm.�i"„ •^'�l��::..... . ..-�... ..�..... ._.�- ...�.�....J'ASx � . ... . .�..� .. ... .�� .._ ._ . .. ., r -�s+ . 'TaR"'v.�. y-� '�
0^'�A� �1'�ryA^^.� . ,� . .... ... .
. Ir � ,_ , . � . . . . .�;t
' . .. � . . . . . . . . .. - . .._. ..._.. "i'M_
° '. � Mi.'�UTrS '1F �'U9LIC i�f:AQT'!r 3F.���E T!�iE ?74�� �� ':'�`1I`t: '
� �N THURS;AY, .4?R:L 3� 196'a 4T ?:�JO �.'i. - !:ITY �'.ALL r ��U4T'i?')SE ,
?RESE"�T: 'aessrs� Ames, :auver, Cohen� �anna, !�!aietta, Mc:'artlin ;nd '�1ans�zr '
o t Ze oarl� Dr. ��eiden� '�r. Sor�nson and !+s�s. Irish of t`�e staff. �essrs. �
'�!c°artlin and Manaur �id no� rsa�ain for the entire �neeti�r., nor di�t th�y vote j
on an•� nbtter. yr. 'aul Kelly of ths Cornoration Counsel's oFfice �s also � ;
o�cesFnt.
� ..
Mr. auc,�� n�ov�d ao�rov�l of the winut�s of tha pr�v±ous rn�L inQ, motior� seconded �
by yr. qai�tt� aeu! carri�d unsni�noualy. i
�i
�
_ . . �
VAtI 9USKIRK: An aao�al to trlax tb• d�t�sity r�quir�snts to �rnit a c�uplax i
on a o a inuffici��nt uw on pt�op�rty locat+d on th� soutt� •fde of Carroll �
Awrw b�txs�n Fry Strs�t and SsNlli� Awnus. Mr. Sor�nson outlin�d ths i
matt�r as folla+ss 't+� City Archit�ct dir�ct�d ths a��allsnt to apo�al to tha
City Council tor a lot ar�a e�+�laxation to pernit th� conwr�ion of a sinv,l�- %
fa�ily dwllinq to a dupl�x as tl�� lot haa an in�ulficisnt lrontaae arui atra. � i
TM sit• has a width of �0 fat as oppos�d to tM rsQuirsd 50 faet ard an arsa . �
of 4,900 �qvar� liset 3� appo�+d to th� 6�0�0 squar� f��t r�quiermsnt. The site
and ar�a is zon�d LiRht Industry whil� to th• morth the �roaerty is soned "9" � ��
l�sid�nc�. 'f'h� hods� was �nowd to ths eit�; 3d�oininQ to th� wst is a lar�e '
six-fa�ily apsrtMnt and th�re ar� n�i�d r�si�ntial and indwtMal us�s in th� � �
sr�a, Thuv atr no tactors in favor of th� r�la�ation; o�oaed: the standards
ar� r�asonab],�i tha shortaa�a is txasasiw, ?09; i� width 3nd 18.33� in arra; �
th�r� ar� ro phys3cal hardshipr to or�w�t ua• of the sit• in sccordance vi.t� ;
ths cod�; s�c�ptia�s saeuat b� made to sonir►� ordinances. Mr. Van 9uskir� spoke�
in b�!►alf of his app�al; h� said this is a �lsrqe house which h� purc!�as�d and �oovtd
onto tM sit�. Th� foundatfon on tt►� sits xas too larRe for th� structure and he
. originally intsnd�d to out a Qorch on it and it Mas au�sted in th• 3uildinR
DepartrMnt thtt he add a room �nst�ad of th� porch and he did r�t kna+ that it . :�
would b� ie conflie� with th� Cods. Hs �sid ha t��ded th� incaae from th� s�cond �+
unit in ord�r to liv�s snd �ntioewd tAat thsr� ++are othar duplex�s in th� arsa .:
as v�ll u i �ourt�tmily us� aa lots th• sanN size as his. H� ssid thare a�r�
suffici�nt bathroo+�s in tb� how� to acconnnodat� tw+o fa�nilias snd ha could oravids -
off-strwt parkin! for two e�ra • pr�s�ntly he do�s not own a car '�inis�lf. .
Nr. C,au�r inqnir�d if it had b+��n the policy of t!�• aoard and staff not t� b�
in favor ot th�s� r�]ixations -to Mis �xtent. Mr. Sor�nson repli�d t!�at �he a;rea -
rsquir�nt�► ptwvid�d by th� Cod� ar� intend�d for ths.�ood of t�� ar�a �at�d .becauae.
of �his y+�ould bi ooaos�d. Mr. Cohsn said h� thouQht ttiis was a cas� of `�ardship. . :
Mr. Mai�tta said to vrant it �+ould b� to cnats a hard�hin for th• *��i�b�rs.
Nr. �autt�r aaid h• thouAht it a�s too gr�at a varianc�. Mr. Coh�n mavsd tor �
approval•� �otioa lail�d tor ++�ant of a s�cond. Mr. �auper then �novsd tor dss�isl,
nwlian s�condsd 'by Mr. !�lai�tta� with MNssrs. Gau�er� Maietta� snd .tf�m�s;vctinR
in farror and Ysssrs. An�s aed Cohan votinR a�airbt th• motion. � . � .
• ;
_.._.•e...--.� -- � .
' r� �,� ` � �:��Gi �'1L� .��:�.�-- , .
.�� � .
� �� .
� � . � � , � ; :
. , ,
� .�
. -� . . , �1
�� . ��:,� .�
Submitted by: lonel L. Sorenson . obert L. Ai! ��r;�i�man
. ��} � �
�� A � '
J • �
, BOlIRD` 0£ 7,i�D1ING REPORT AND ACTION April 3, 1969 Plat Map # 11 �
Actin�• under Lsgislative Cods Chapter 60 thru 64 Ffle No� 6730
passed August 22� 1922 as amended to April 6� 1968
�� Also
l. AiPLICANT'S NAME ; Milton L. VanBuekirk
�� I_l Amendment �Appeal QPermit 0 Other
�i� 2. CLASSIFICRTION s
3, PURP45E s Relax density aad lot frontage requirements
�` • 4� LOCATION s South side of Carroll Avenue between Fry Street and S� lliag Avea�
5. LEGAL AESCRIPTION s Lot 13, Block 5, College Park Additioa
;,�
`� . 6.. PRE5ENT 7ANING s Light Induatrq
� . . 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Cod� Chspt�rs 64 Sections .03 Paragraph: i
;��� 8� STAFF INVESTIGllTION � REPORTt Dat�� 3/25/69 Bys ATB 6 CLS
,
::,
f� A. ZONING AD�lINISTRATOR: The Zoning Administrator directed the appellan� to this
:�,� office for the procedural methods to appeal to the council for a lot ares
relaxation for s duplex in a Light �ndustry zone.
B. fl T RY: None '
,� C. PURPOSE: Canvert the existing aingle-fa�ily dwelling to a duplex.
D. NEBp FOR APPFAL: The lot doee not have sufficie�tt area for a duplex in a Light
i"� � �nduatry zone. The lot is aleo short in frontsge for a duplex.
1:j: .
,,ia� E. P�BS�NT STANOARDS: A duplex in a Light Induatrial district requirea a 30 foot
',`� froatege aad 6,000 square feet of area.
�� F. V�: This site has an area of 4,900 equare feet, a shortage of 1100 square
�� feet or 18.33� aad a width of 40 feet or ahort by l0 feet or 20�.
�� G. A�A ZONING: 8ast and weat is zoned Light Indnatry. North is zoaed "B" Residence.
'� � H. SITE N�DITIQ�S: Site is level and at approximatelq atreet grade. The house was
.�� . recently moved to the aite. The rear y�rd hss an accumulatioa of �unk and
parto. Same appear to be for sale.
. _ I. ASEA CONDITIafS: Ad�oining to the asat is 8 large six family apartment. Mixed
�;: • rsaidential and induatrial uses are in the area.
� Counc3l Letter
�'Y`
� 9, BOARD ACTIONs To R�catarest►d DApprovsl l�X.lDenial �tad
��; . Mov�d bys Gauger Y�s Nays Dat� of N�aring
An1ea X
. S�cOnd�d bY'= Maietta Coh�n X �
, X D�►nna (Alt) Council Action
, Gadlsr
X Gaug�r
'�� S�ar�tary'� r�srlc�s X blsi�tta Date
i��
� � McPartlin (Alt)
f �� , Mansur tAl.t)
���;� �
i�'� LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET.
;i;:�
�a�
1f S
i.',�:� � � . . , . . .
_ . ..hR:r-.. .. . . . . �
, . , �.
_ LIBERTY
� STATE
- BANK
- • �:�. �, �.
LIBER'�Y STATE BANK
FULL�.'_4Vi�'I:. �
SNELLING AT SELBY AVENUE * ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55104
646-8681
April 11, 1969.
St. Paul City �ouncil
St. Paul, Minnesota
Gentlemen:
Mr. Milton L. Van Buskirk has made application to the
�o�cil to duplex a building that he owns at 1622 �arroll
Avenue, St. Paul, Minn. .
Mr. Van Buskirk has owned this property since 1945. For
many years there was a small house on the land and this
was moved. In 1960 Mr. Van Buskirk purchased the present
house and moved it on to the location with the intention
of making it into a duplex. We loaned him the funds ror
the original land purchase and also for this large house.
He did not have the money to duplex the unit immediately but
it has always been his intention to make the necessary im-
provements for a duplex.
I feel sure that there will be no objection to this application
and urge you to give Mr. Van Buskirk your approval .
Very truly yours,
IBERTY .STATE. BANK
��_.
�
'; �,, ? �
i � �� %� G:����� ��;
Vi`e President
DLSmith:ha
�.�. �
�,
; ;.
�:,
��
.�
t
;�, -
�ryt
� � �f .
t �—–
� .. �� .. . ' �.
�biPS$iY��y�:�� �� �
"y�.. . �i.++tir�..a.--�----