The URL can be used to link to this page

245154 • , , • CiTV o , Har�}1 E. Marshall `w F�� Albert B.Olsoa C'+�y Clerk and ` �f % Cou�tc�il Recorder Co;nmisa2oner of Repistrmtion � � . �-_��=' � 2y�- hr OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL � BUREAU OF RECORDS �88 City Hall -`�� St.Paul,Minnesota 55102 `� / ,Tu13r 31, 1969 � P � � �. �' � �; � �;�'�� '�,., �€;n " ��g�� ..� �Y �l r i 5..o } ��. �'' `111� l.�%,�� -.•• Mr. Joseph P. Summers , ��r�� Corporation Counsel ''�, Building Deax 3ir: The City Council todqy x�squested that qau prepare a resolution granting the attached appeal of Donnary Realty Co�pa,ny tc relaac the area requiz�aents of the Zoning Code as applied to praperty located on the ea�t side of Winchell 3t., aonth oP Arlington AQe.� described aa the north 1/2 oY Lot 9 and the sazth 1/2 of ;,ot 9 eucept the east 150 �'�et thereof a.nd except part ther�of taken for Winchell St., both in Black 6, Rogers and Hendrick's Acre Lots l�o. 2, 81TB�1ECT to the conditions as set out in the attached letter of the Zoning Bosrd. Very traly yours, ` , � City erk C� � � �80�►RD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 July 31, 1969 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk City Hal.l and Court House Dear Sir: This is written in response to the appeal of Donnay Realty Company to relax the area requirements of the Zoning Code as it applies to property located on the east side of Winchell Street, south of Arlington Aventa�. This property is further described as the north 1/2 of Lot 9 and the south 1�2 of Lot 9 except the east 150 feet thereof and except part thereof taken for Winchell Street; both in Block 6, Rogers and Hendrick's Acre Lots No. 2. The applicant desires to construct two duplexes on lots that have an area of 7,325 square feet, the Code however, requires 7,500 square feet for a duplex in an "A" residence district. The Board of Zoning considered this matter at its June 5, June 19 and July 3, 1969 meetings. The staff reported that the small variance of 175 square feet, or 2.33 percent is caused by the improvement of Winchell Street with a turn-around which required acquisition of a small portion of e.ach lot. Several_neighbors appeared in opposition, noting that the proposed construction would cause a drainage prcblem on their property. Consequently, the matter was laid over twice to allow the appellant and the neighbors to reach an agreement. At the July 3, 1969 meeting, Mr. Donnay stated that he had made certain con- cessions to some of the neighbors, i.e. to Mrs. Mildred Lindahl, 1329 Barclay, he agreed to fill in a low spot and provide her with additional fill; to Mrs. Ma.rie Brobakken, 1455 East Ivy, who has property to the south, he promised to take down the bank adjoining her property, reducrng its height and will also provide stone for developing the bank as a retaining wall. Subsequently it was the finding of the Board of Zoning that the variance was small and the request reasonable. Therefore, the Board recommends approval by a 5 - 0 vote of this appeal to relax the area requirements of the Zoning Code, subject however to the agreement as stated at the July 3, 1969 Board of Zoning meeting. ry rul o s Robert Ames Chairman -�... �... RA:FGI % �'.�:: CLS '-�� rJ Z. F. 6764 '`'" "�- �; ��-�-� � /! , � � ' . ' . _. , .April 21, 1969 �� . �`'�� ; The Honorable l�ayor and City Council � c% City Clerk j,, Room 386, City Hall and Court House " St. Paul, I�innesota 55101 � Gentlemenr This is an appeal fr arn Andrew J. Donnay doing business as Dorm.ay Realty Company , 1471 I�ydia Avenue, St. Paul, I�i.ru�esota, 55113. Phone number is 633-1252. Lega1 descriptions of property involved are parcels C and D of attached plats. Tha property is located on the East side of Winchell Street, 3outh oP ,Arlingtori.. The property is naw vacant. I wish to construct two double bungalows. This appeal is necessary because of the cul-de-sac makir�g the sites approximately 300 s:quaxe �eet short of t he required aroa. Appeal is made und.er Legislative Code Chapter 64 Section 03 Paragraph i. Enclosed ara t�o sita plans. I ha.ve built two double bun.galows on parcels A arid B and balieve that the best land use for parcels C and D would be to put double bungalo�s there also. Respectfully yours, DONNAY REALTY COMPANY AJD:mfd BYs ,:.��i��/ Z�l.l�2 encls. 3 Andrev� J. Do ey �;��.� �- C J�� ,��G �a��°� _._,...---�,� . � .. . .. ... ._.. `�;.'Y ��.��'?h�� '� .i:: ��[ a n-,.�c.+�S, �.�v%: }'-".:<„°'',_a „t+...3` a`�'�`"�1y'Y " e."'%'N.,rA'�"4'� � >;;u-:; : . .�, .„ ,.... . . . . ,fi_�``s... �'t<�''�nL, . �" ..... .. . � . . . 3 �HOARD'�OF 7�QNING REPOR'� AN� /1CT�`JN July 3Z 19b9 _ " �'I3t :�{�� 13 :� Y � *` Aatirii� und�r L�gislatiw Cod� Chspt�r 60 thru 64 .� n� p�sed Auqust 22� 1922 as am�ndad to April 6� 1968 6764 �� y � , I f` d : . ::?. :,i�..'a:�'�'S hA'1L' : Donnay Realty Cospan . y � Am�nd�nt 0 App�al ❑ �ern�it u�Jther " � �. ��!.�SSIF'ICATI�JN s . 3. ^,1R?JSE ; Relax area requirements� for a duplex in "A" Residence � y . I�'Ki,TI�N ; Eaet side of Wischell 3treet south of Arlington pvenue � � ; S� ..C<;A:. �ESCRIPTI�N s The N. 1/2 ot Lot 9, �tad the S. 1/2 of Lot 9, except the E. � �; 150 feet thereof and exc�pt part thereof taken for Win�hell � Street; both in Dlock 6, Rogera and Hendricic's Acre Lots � No. 2. i v. P:iESI:NT Z�NINc,: ��A" Rasidence � � a 7. P:SQSJANT 1'� Zoninp, Cod� Chaptsrs � S�ction: .03 F��rapraph: i � ' s. �TAF'F INVESTI�,ATION � REPORT: Dtt�s 5/26/69 3ys CLS � ! + A. ZONINC ADt�lINISTRATOR: No Action. � _ � ;� B. HISTORY: None. ; � C. PROPOSED USE: Develop each parcel with a duplex. �` . D. NEED FOR APPEAL: Each parcel haa insufficient area for a duplex in an "A" " Residence district. E. pRESENT STANDARD: A duplex in an "A" Residence district requires a 60-foot frontage and 7,500 squere feet in aree. F. VARIANCE: Each parcel has a widCh of 62.96 feet with a depth of 120.75 feet. � If each parcel was a rectangle, the area of each would be 7,600 squere feet. � Winchell Street was improved s�ith a turn around provided north of Ivv Avenue. The area taken from each parcel was 275 square feet . Each parcel noN has an � area of 7,325 square feet, 1T5 aquare feet or 2.33% short. G. AREA 20NINC: The area west of Haselwood Street is "A" Residence. H. SITE CONDITIONS: Site is vacant and approximately 3 to 4 feet above atreet grade of Winchell Street and about 10 feet above [he grade of Ivy Street. I. AREA CONDITIONS: Most of the erea weat of Hazelwood Street is developed wiCh aingle-family residences. There are some duplexes in this area of recent construction. One older duplex is being moved onto a site across Winchell � S[reet and to the nor[h. ' Council Letter 9. BOARD ACTION; To R�co�nte�nd t ^t Approval . �Denial �ted 1f3Y69 Moved by; Cohen Yaas Nays Date of }{earing � X Ames 7/31/69 . Seconded by: Maietta X Cohon . X Danna (Alt) Council Action � X Gadlar , Gauger S�cr�tary' s remarkss x Maietta Date McPartlin (Alt) . Mansur (Alt) � LEGAL NOTICES ON THE BACK OF THIS SHEET ,��i �, i � � � _ ,. ,�. ..,,.,...,.,.m..;._ . „.. _ .. ,..,,,�.-.:.�,,..:;<,�r._.,T.. ,-.., � - i. i � ��M �� '/}j � ��" '��NMaIl;eR:,i�°n��". '� a . ,�:+sN.�*'hY.,, -��,...�" ` 'A�^.^."''- , i'r'yy^�e a 7 .! ��,��7_ ,��-P• �' � .h � . ��a.. .�� i+'. } �` �. !Y* " � i�.; � � � t 4 �, �:�c� � � +�i .�� , e x � _ o ,�::: �� N• � . � ..� � � '�� M i a Q � � �, � � �, . . � , � � t: , � � . o � � . . �� .�� .� ��o�,�,c��, � � o �; ,. ,� - _ . y .� _ � �{ . . .} � -�- � �. ; : C � � �fl t /� � � � . . , ., ,�, � , t �_, _� o � ,. .�=�A� ., r - �.�.:_. � O � J f' � �� . . �if�'4.:,•' . '. t �"-� �. . � ..j . ;. � . . . , ' � �` �� -..�. r C�_ � • + « � �� . � � � �. . .. O .� ''� `C �"°'�►� �. � � 4. .., Q� i� � - ,.. o , ; ,;. . Q ,� � fh ,, �, � �;, .,. ,.. t . . , h� � . . o �.. . .� .��.� � .�. � . � �M � ��, . �' � . p � / �.-.�� ." � . . .� ..�_ -- - Q� o o - ' 'i � :�� . ... t� Q. o � .� ¢ o o _ � � v .�. . (7 •p , � . , �I •u,. . . p� � . �' � � o .�„ , O i w � . : �' . �. ...- 4 -� �/ � O � ;. Q � � � � ':� ��; .O -� "� � O .� � . � �' �► o a � o t o � �. . _ :; :� I � ° � . . � �� o 00 0 �0 0 o ,a o ; d o o .�j � t � , b o aoo� v � � f . � � ✓y ��1�' � . � -- � _ , � . . , ' ; . > r• �•y . ♦-�. � . . � . . �'►t�J`��t.�r� , a� r�' �_ h , � �_ ... _ ._ � � ,E�Grl7'S �----► ��..., ' ; �: : ' .� ti..' : . . ; O �.� } �--_� i / 1 �;} ' �` , .;;.�' a. jf' ! :�. , ;_,_ � , � . ., . . -• - . . F � r i L � i. � .,� r. �f F. � ��,;... ` � �� ' REALTY CO.. i.�� D . : ��Q� Relax area requirements for a Lf+�N� V � ` �. � vuplex Q 01�—FAMtLY ��I�T Z� ��A�� Residence "Q" TWD�FA�..Y ' . I�ETfTl�1 S�HE.RS TMR�E-FAMILY � � , #-`QUR-FAMILY�� , . , t �JI.Tt•Fi�l.1f � f1LE N0. 6764 +�K 't""1 n��RCiAL . . .�� fNOUST'�L . �'� � . v VAf.�NT � . . '' �� f� $�"�� - . 1�rY 2�, 19b9 . � P�y � . . . : . i _�..�•.+�.�,,,..�.-_.�.,.,.,.,_ „� . . MIN[1TSS OF TH� PUBLIC AEABING BEP'ORE TI3E BitAitll OF ZONING ON TIiU$SDAY, .T[JI� S, 19b9 AT 2:00 P,Pi., PRESEI3T: Measrso Ames, G�d3.er, Gs�ger, ria�e��a� AicPartlin of �h� �osrd; �nd Messrs, Sor�naon ar►d Wilkerson �end l;rse Irish a�f th� staff, �Mre rir.P�rtlin l�f� tt�� mee�C�ng t�ft�r conaiderat3.an �f tk�e Beligonge Company mettcer.� D41�'+,IiA; An appeal. to re�a� er� requir�m�n�� a pr�rmi� �:he const�.�sc�iom of two doubl.e-buagalaws on property 1o�at�d oa �he �sst ai de o€ L�'irn�h��.l �eree�, aouth of srl�ngton Aveaue, P7ro Sorensmn �um�eriz�e� �h� ��ff r�poxt ��x�h �_1rffi� du� �o �:he coae�ruc- �ion ef � �ul�de-s�c on �dfae:lie�? S�r�etn �n �� of �'7S scge�ar� �'eettwao �ak,�n fgom e�ch �srcel lesning each p�r�c�l IT5 sqw,nre ��t asr 2�?s3�� d�f�c�iex�� ia area; The aiee is vacaut and ��pro�cia��+�2y 3�a �e�� ahc�� r��t �r�rle a£ Wa�sneh�l� street and �nou� 10 feet abov� �h� gxac�e of Iv��► S�r�t� ?+I�<, Sar�r��o�a �s�t�d �he follawimg concl�asiog to th� stt�� r�por�: in fmvor c�f Gt�r� a��ae��.; 1� Th� �cscatior� of the cuI- d�-sec has r�duced the 7a� a��a �ela�a the are� r�quig��r.C� fmr a duplex; �) the actu�l shorta�e is s�ll � I7S aquar� fe�e o� �e33 ��reen�a ag�ix�st the granting of the ��pe�l; 1� The $pp�il�sn� h�s aot c2�3,m�d a �uerdsl�fp �1�� ul.d preven� de- velop�tn� thes� prop�rr��s undcr g�xa� �i�t�ng coc�ey 2� �he tcao pa�r�e�s aesci�,d be com- bf.ned sn:d di�fded to �l�.o� �� dcapl� and cr�e s��gl��fsmfly rea�denc�; 3� �he origicasl Zrre�ing Code (A�.ege�� 1922y r�qufged 7,40i� f�t for a siupl�x� �.'he ar�a reqair��at has e�cgs��ci �gr many gr�rs and f.a a r�aea�a'61e m�uin�am� S�v�ral z��ighbors livfng on ivy Street $�s�e.�xed 3ra oppasYti�a aYtd asid they �elt ehar� �aater would dsein o�f eh� s�b�ec� prop�rty c�nto �h�irso Mro Dannsy ssid i� woul.d b� possih�� o �ccze�rm�ct o�ne d�ble b�ssa�ala� a�d aaaa� �f�g�e-f�aily dwa112�a without �skfYag �e�r szsy waiv�r whate�ers and ��ast he did neat w�nt �he hard feeling3 of ��e� n��gi�bors a _ Aft�r �ome discuz��2� b�2-ra�en �ixe �c4ard me�4s��c8� ti�� ueighbor�s and Mr, Dodnuy. A4r. G�dler moved �h�tt �he a��t�r be laid aver fo� two weeks to pet�enit rlso Donaay and �the n�ighboLa Co r�ach �n s�re�at; motioa se�oaded by r7ro Mai��ts and ca�ried un�aimously. � Suba�itted by; Colonel Lo Soreaeon Robert L, A s, Ch�i�n �6_ � MiNUTES UF THE F'U�LTC k�IE�RYNG BIEFQktE TH8 B0�liRA OF ZONZNG ' on Thursday, June 19, 19b9, at 2:00 P,ri, PRESENT: Messrs. Ames, Uann+a, Gedler, Ga�xger and Maietta of the Board and l,essrs. Sarenson and Wilkerson and Nrs. Irish sad Miss Poechmaun. of the staff. Mr. McParClin wss also present but did not votE, except for the firat m��ter when Measrs. G�uger �nd �leietta had not arrived. DONNAY RF.lsiL1'Y (:0,: An appeal� to relax erea req�irements on property loca��d on the esst side of Winchell Street, south of Arlington Avenue. Z;r. Sorenson said the mattex had been laid ov�r from Che last meeting in order for Mr. I?�nnay to rneet with the neighbors who had indicated o�pasition. Mr. Dounay said he had nvt t�lked to thc neighbo�s, aud wanCed to witl�draw his appeal; he s�id he could construct one duplex and one single-family residence without an �ppQal, �nd that the drainage problem the aei�hbars ��lked about was brought about by the contractor who built the reaide�aces on ivy and did not put up retaining walls. A£ter �ome discussioa, he agreed �o discuas it with the neighbora, and Mr. Maiett� maved to lay the matter over for �wo weeks and ta have new aotices s�ent out. Motion seconded by Mr. GadXer and carried unanimous�y. Submit�ed by: Deaiel L. Wflkerson Rabert . Ames, C irmaa tt -3- � , MINUTES OF THE PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE BQAKD OF ZONING on Thursday, July 3, 1969, �t 2:00 P.Me PRESSNT: Measrs. Ames, Cohen, Danna, Gadler, and MaietCa of the Board and r�essrs. Sorenson and Wilkerson an.d Mrs. Yrish end Misa Foechmann of the etaff. Mr. McPartlin was also present but did not vote. Mr. Gadler moved for approval a£ the minutes from the Iast mesting, and 3��r. Danna aeconded the motitin, which carried unanimously. DONIl�TAY REALTY C4IPANY: An appesl to relax area require�ents for a dupl�x in "A" Reaidence on property located on the east side of Winchell Street south of Arlington Avenue. This was a lay-over from the two previous lBoard of Zoning meetings. Mr. Donn�y �aae to have discussed the problem wiCh neighbors in the vicinity; after much delay, Mr. Donnay and ad3oining neighbors had a short conference in the Council chambers. Mr. Donnay ataCed that he had made cer.taiu concessions to same of the neighbora, i.e., to Mrs. Mildred Lindahl, 1329 Barclay, he agreed to fill in a low spot and provide her with addigional fill; to Mra. Marie Brobakken, 1455 Eaat Ivy, wha has property to the south, he promised to take down the bank adjoining her property, reducing its height -- will also provide stone for developing the bank as a retsining wa11. Mr. Cohea moved for approval subject to the conditions stated, as there was accord between the parties, and the appeal was reasonable. Mr. Maietta aeconded the motion, and it carried unanimausly. Subanitted by: Colonel Le Sorenson r . a, C sinaan -1- Ikt ,..r� .I/�� •" ='� �►_ . . � - ' ` � CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 July-18, 1969 City Clerk File X721, Page You are hereby notified that a pnblic heariag wiZl be held in the Council Chambers of the Court House and City Hall in the City of 3t. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on July 31, 1969, on the appeal of Donasy Reaity Company to relax area requirements on the following propertq: North � of Lat 9 except East 150 feet thereof and except part thereof taken for Winchell Street and south � of Lor 9, except East 150 #eet thereof and except part thereof talcen for Winchell 3treet, Block 6, Rogers and Hendricks Acre LoC No. 2. Th e property fs located on tt►e eaet side of Wiachell Street and approximately 123 feet north of Sast kvy,Ave. Fo r further information contace the Planning �►ard, Room 1010 Commerce Building or telephone 223-4151. JAM$S J. DALGLISH Caannissioner of Finance O