Loading...
245585 -. . . ; L��-� . ., � . R, . � . . 1 � - � � y ..n...' . � :• �. . n . k . " ' .. � `. ` • a. - .. �� �'� �,. + � i ' � FINAL ORDER COUNCIL FILE N0, � . By File No Z�"i+lt�� �: k � 3 � In the Matter of � aM �rtss3�tttdt �#o�d�liM ss�pef�t� dw s1�aq► f�lt � u� a � � !1, �a�ri�t � �"re ��ei� firw Qir�lt ��MMlwe s�► .�lrl��#Md�M� '�r• I�L��� � �, . � . . . � � � :.:� R- . . � . � . � . t� � . . . . . � . � . � .. . . . . . . � .. . � . 'y:� . . . . . . . . .. �.. � d � � � €�� � . . �� �-:i �(:. . . . .. . . � . .. . f. � � � .. . . . � �.��:� i: under Preliminary Order �� approved �� �s 1� , Intermediary Order approved �� A public hearing having been had upon the above improvement upon due notice, and the Council havmg heard all persons, ob�ections and recommendations relative thereto, and havix�g fully conaidered � the same; therefore, be it �� RESOLVED, By the Council of the City of St. Paul that the precise nature, extent and kind of im- provement to be made by the said City is t�► �ia �i's�welW� �r!#� i��s �Itt�r411 d�we �cli�g► fr, �i+� 7t1, � +�! i�t�s �iiitL�r �r� t�■we a JMwi�r �. w3� � � � . . . ..��• F� . . . . � � . . �:. . . . . . . . . � �k. � and the Council hereby orders sa,id improvement to be made. RESOLVED FURTHER, That the Gommissioner of Public Works be and is hereby inatructed`and directed to prepaxe plans and specifications for said improvement, and submit same to the Council for approval; that upon said approval, the proper city of�'icials axe h�reby authorized and directed to pro- ceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therewith. - COUNCILMEN SEP 1 6 1��}9 Adopted by the Council Yeas Nays Carisorf Approv .�S'EP 16 �96g Dalglisti Meredith - Peterson �In Favor Sprafka J Mayor '��;�sco : 8yrne �gain�t PUQLISI�f� ��� Z 0 1� 6-88-2M "� 8.1 . �� � ��-o�-� w ��� 24558� ��� ' � OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PUBLIC WORKS �� � `�G � '' � ���F����9 � � � G REPORT TO COMMISSIONER QF FINANCE ��' a � ,�'. <`' � �� Q � \, �� �`�+ �. � ,,�r,..,�C�,C;� :� June 11 , �9 69 To the Commissioner of Finance of the City of St. Paul ; The Corr�nissioner of Public Works� having had under consideration the prelimina�y order of the Council known as Council File No. 244263 approved June 4, �g 69 relative to 9rading and surfacing with bituminous material thealley in Blk. 21 , AUERBACH � HANDS ADD, from Cook Ave, to �` Jessamine Ave. (G-1878) ✓ and having investigated the matters and things referred to therein, he�eby reports: i . The estimated cost thereof is $ 2,54� 2.83 ____ � �� 2. A plan, profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached and �`'� ;� ma de a pa r t he reof. 3. Initiated by the Commissioner of Public Works 4. improve�nt is asked for upo� petition X 4 `I ' Co issioner of Publ tc Worlcs �� �'y.{ ,•'T"M19qr��aX�+�.,,Y°'�Y r . tr .:,�„ Y . � . . y .,is. �+.� :�A` i f � 'M� r'Y;� .4�a r',v d . .. . - . ..f � ,. �:',�. M11Ll.lAM DONQVAN ` Y, . ` r' •�,Valuation Engineer � � ' � : ' 223-5317 ; '' � ; � . � ����� �� � � OF SAINT �P�AUI�� ���� ±' •, ROY E. BRFDY►HC Jr. , C I T Y A�s'� Valuarion Engineer ' BUREAU OF VALUATIONS � �' - � 286 City HeU ", . Sein4 Paul, Minnesote 55102 , .�(J � , August 15, 1969 Mr. Gre�e Beckett Loca1 Improvements Engineer Department of Public Works City of Saint Paul � Deax Mx. Beckett: Set forth herein is information pertinent to the property assessment for the proposed•public iiaprovement described as: G-1878 Grade and Surface the alley in Slk 21, Auerbach and Hands Add., under P.O. 2�+4263, approved June �+, 1969. The total esti.mated amount recoverable by assessment is $3,500.79 based on the followi.ng; Estima.ted grad.ing cost (per P.W. report 7/25�69) $2,5�+2.83 Valuation and Assessments Service 50.86 Est. publication, Court, postage & misc. costs 107.10 Est. Slope & Opening costs 800.00 Estimated Total Amount to be Assessed �g,5pp�79 Estimated Rate per Assessable Foot $�+.80 Ba.sed on the above, the heaxing on the advisabili�y will be scheduled for September 16, 196g, Very truly yours, �r� ��� a�� �, . Ro E; Bredahl r Y , J . Ass't. Valuation Ehgineer REB�lo File No. 17410 cc: R. Wheeler F. Crowley�' 4 � - ,`';!"�.� _P/'/ — - - .�'-t Y6. - � - ; � ;— � ; , , � ; � � ' � � � � , � i � .-; f i� � , �� �i��i�✓i� sr. I � : � ,� �`�,� ��, � ��� �� � ; � f i` ; � � � � :�� ` I \ i � �E,�� � I � � L ~ � �rf?/Z�/NGTON $7, O �1 D � ! , f � �.�� � � � I i G � � o ' ' i I � o � i � , I f � .� I ! � � ; ' �,;�'�:iLV,r,. ST. � � � � � i �� ; � � { ' � �` � � /v � ' , ( W 1 4.=',GT<�� , ST " ; �--� � � � i . ? � � ; ( —� ; � I � � � , 4 � � � �!!'/OF�/. s T j i -� � , � � � ' � � � , � � I i � �.'�' ;. � I � i � i I �� � � � � e�`✓�o�:-��c� � � I � � _ �_ S T. � � � ___.___� f � I t i f�' � I � �� `�` i . �ti� I�� ;�; ;� � `�.' , ( I,�� j1: �n � i � � . � `� ' � � � ' � � ! � I �_ � I �II/r/��Q�'�e_ ` ST. --i � I i ' I � f � � � � ; ; � � �' , � p ( �_�________--.�. .. ? , � � ! � ' � 1 i i�-----------� - -�,- � � i �, � ' - ------ ---- - � 1 � � � � � �� i � , _� �_.---- ------- -� i . , i —._-_ ' L �( . %,�'�./� � � � � \� , ' '__"__ ._-_... _.I �._ ..___.____.____'_..j �...__-_.__. ._'_..__.' . ___.__ . _ ._'__. _..._.___'_� . /�' . � � , �-- ---- � l I ' . J• : , � , . .._ ._._ . . _......_ . . ....__ ..--,...,.-...J . � �. ��� , ._ _ _ . . ,� � . �� �� ���'�- is � � � 9 � � ' • , � .�t/yi ,,, -�,�Q � . .� ���v� Q►.�`� �``0 �t . �. ����in � , s" ��� . ��`� � ` , !� � �. - � � � �� � . ,� 3 / 17 a�� /� . � . ��z�' �6/ ��� � f . . . •. � .� � � � �� �� �� , �- , .�.��� � .�1d 2���� .�-�" ���Q�� � �r,�G� s � � � � � �� �� � f , ✓�� � � f � f � � l� �- ,i �1`� ...��- � ' � ,�� o� f - . � ! �.�� �'Y�� c�� � � � - ����pG C� ,� ;�rJ �7�.�����c.� � l �-� +� .:.. `,�t�-e�-�J ��� ' ` � � � � o�� •���� i � ����'� � � ��o� ' j����� e _ G�X � � � !�� � ^ � ..��t� � �--°-� • G�.� � � � • � � ..:. �,��.►,�C.. , ���� ��-, a ��� o�U Q2 �: � � � _ �o Y� " � � ��� � � � ���-- ��� ��� �-�-�� � . • . � . . � � � . � . . . � _ _- _ � � r a �ss�s ' SUMMARY OF EMGINEERING RECOMMENDATION Tuesday, September 16, 1969 ADVISABILITY AND DESIRABILITY OPEN, WIDEN, EXTEND 6RADE SURFACE AND SLOPES Atley 1n Bik. 21 � Auerbach and Hand�s Add, from Cook Ave. to Jessamine Ave. (G-1878) This order comes before the Council based on a petition signed by six property ow�ers. This petition was received by this office on July 26, 1968, and on December 16, 1968, a petition was received against the project signed by six property owners. However, the property a�vners signing for the improvement compose approximately 33°� of the assessable f rontage. At the present time the people are using a strpp of lend approximately 16 feet in width to gain access to their garages and their backyards. However, there is no existing public alley or opened alley at this tirae. For this reason our order includes opening the alley and if the Councii passes the grading order, the opening order will have to be passed at the same time. In the last several years, the property awners who own property on Farrington and Jessamine did quite a lot of extensive work tn the proposed aliey which included asphalt driveways and the fencing off of this strip of land. They, of course, gain access from Jess�mine alley and have no interest in the aliey. However� if the ailey is to be graded to the grade that we believe is the rr�st practical grade, it will have to be graded through from Cook to Jessami�e, which wiil require the re�noval of the fence , ce�tain steps and other instaliations that are now in the proposed altey. If we we�e to deadend this alley at this fence so that all parties could gain access frore the Cook end of the alley. we would have to cond�nn a 20 x 20 foot strip bf land for turn-around purposes and also construct a storm water seM►er in an easement to be obtained going from the proposed alley to Matilda Street. If the Council desires to pass the alley straight througfi from Coak to Jessamine� the estimated property assessment per assessabie foot would be $4.80 per front foot. However, if the Councfl would decide that the best solution to the probtem Is to deadend the ailey approximately 42 - feet south of Jessamine, construct the tur�-around, the estimated rate per front foot is $9.00. These are factors which must be considered in the Council 's decisio�. After viewing this alley severai times, we beiieve that the only practical sotution is to grade the alley through from Cook to Jessamine and remove any such barriers� paying any damages to the ad,joining property ow�ers as the Finance Department deems necessary. ` . . . . -2- If the Council would decide to deadend this alley and install a storm sewer, it would be necessary to lay this order aver until such a time as new rates could be estabifshed, new notices sent out, condemnation praceedings instigated and other details ironed out. For this reason. namely, the cost involved, we believe it would be in the best interest of the neighborhood if we grade the alley strai�ht through at an estimated cost of $4.80 per front foot, and the Engineering recommendation is for passage of the order as written. Respectfully submitted, Richard A. Schnarr Chief Engineer � . V.� . .. .;%� _ ���'��'3 . .�. � . .. .� -- .- . ' . .. -" . '- .. �. .. .� _ ; ... . . . . . . . . . . � s .. n n� ,, � . . .. . ArE. -�� , ..'��_'- ` .. ., .h. .afAR��Ar:J - ,,d�� �- - . .. .... �� . .� . � , .r o _ r�' .JO �. . . t t . + �. • - , - .. _ 1 A✓E. . . � . , • _ .�. _ • .. .� .. ' . ... . a ' ' e ,w • _ •• �"J � .a ..• � .� .f�{ , . . . . . . . . . ' , . � - . . . . � .l . �. . '1 ! ... . . . � . . . - . . . ,1 J , �� . . � 5 � _ . i _ . _ , . � F � . _ �. • • ' , , , , � � _ � . . , ' . • �3 ? � y1 . : r. aCSa �� ' _ ,�, ... `�?.�avE. . •: , .. .. . . __�, ' ' ' - ' ' r " � z e+�`t :•f —.�--�- � . . . t . _ _. .. ' ` ' . . _ _ 3 . . . �. . . � _ . . _. 2 ._ - . . . . _. ..�� . . . . . . 6 . . . • 7 . . . � . .. _ ' . : 3 r . . . : . ``� , , `��w ., +` . `��. � - !� � , � -� -Z . 2. _- `�n� . _ ' . . . - . _ , `�� . . . �� � � ' .;�� . ; �. e : > ,r ' y. . • ° , - .. ' .. , �. • � ' .-- • � ... ' . �„ �0 3,� ,�� . .i.. .:. � ., ;�' � ,. , . , . . ., :. "•�a ' �v. GFAAN/!/M . ._ _ yiP " _ _ 10�AvE. - - __. _ ,, - .,r . . ,_ . „ . _ -- ..- - - .e- � ' { �e �� o + �ie � ' iy- -• �•I- �,�:- _ - --- - - - ... .` � � .. : . � : : . � - - . _ .._ �1J .�. �G �� • . ' . .. ' .. , ..•. ._ '_' ` , . . ' . j .. __ .. . ` . �) � j j .. _ 3 . _ . . . �. : .. . .... � . ._.. . . '0 � . � K .. . -r--- . . . N . .. ` � . . . y .e � { y . 3 z � .' y :' ;� ��1 . V' . y :5 � .. . � . ' �� . - ,. Q � �a � , „ � ,. ' : 'J � , 14 , 6- �,� R h�,.,a R v•s E �� t . . . . , :s e v d . C l 1 � Q q . � ; . , ..._._. . _.. . _ .._ _ . .. _... . . � . _ .. .e . ' �t' _ . . .. ' . 1 . . ,l . 2 ' . . .-j_ � �.. . ` '4i __... ...._ . . . . .. _ . � . . .i „ , .... . . " ' ;S� � ' e �. .. . . . . ... . . . - . ... _ ' .s � � ' . 5 . - � � - ' _� .. {� � . . . . • � � .__� 9 � . . . .._ � . � . . .. � „ l , __. � .__ . .. t ,u • Y .•. . ti .:: ': " . ? ..._. . _ . _. ....._.__. . . _. _ �-.. -. � � ., ' ., � .. • .�„ � � - O. � 3 ` � I . . .._ -^ .� � w _ ,Is . ;. , ... . :.__:._ .t,• _z .�tt�v4_11� � r.. �.�nn . .. _..'f9._tT 13M'_ � � W� JfSSAM/NE - ' ---77. . .--- --- - � . - - �-- . _'lCp.OYE . -... ._-'-'-._..__. � ; e .�� . 71. _ _.._-.0--� - � '� �---•,- �f �- _ . ;_ �}�--.r.� �n�..+� i�7� . � -.tna^ ��e ..._za-�- �r•x \ .____ ._'__ ____' ' _.___ ..__. � - _. .__ . ._.. f :� . . � � ., _ � . � _ . - - v : ,.. � a . . ,, . . -. . .._• . 3 z ;� , ` .a __� ♦ .`__. . . • :9 ._ _ - sI ,y� . t � � . s--.a�' • - - � � .._. . ` . '. `� .e _ `�P--,� 3-..__'. `�}f�_..�, I`� _. ,. j��tS' — a--� - -�_ - �' .�"!.�._ ._ . j re J . i6 . 3 . _ r7 � : • __-_'_ "_'__-__'_."'__'_' . ._ _.._ " _.. . . . ___ _ - -._. ... _____"._.' _._.. . - ___ __'.' ___......_ � _ , , A „ _ -_ -�— - 5 . ,� . _ ,. . — '' ' . . ; . � „ , _. . - - - - --_ . _. _ _ .N 'o , -.__. � 19 ° . .. ' c0 s . 5 � , - ' . ... .�6 23�-'s e s . � s :. ,,,. . ; : ' • ' � ' ... . � . . . '`.. - e. . 2'� � � �S ;S � �� i �: s .� 6 : : .._. _ .. .. � . " 6 �` " s w:�� ""___ _. _. .__.—. _ . ._.__. ' —_".'_ _ ra _ ... . . _...._ . ._ ___ _ .«w..._. , . i: � . ' . .. :.. ._. .'_ __ ' y . .• v • � 6 ) . � � . .. .. . . . ... . _. . . . _iIIJ 7__ -_" _. .. ; . . . ... _ . _._ . _ ' . . '_ _ . � _ . - _ -- _. - --� . . �... .� ' �_ - e_ - ,. _. _ . .? . r y� . . . __ . : . � v ,r • : � • r,. _. : �; i : i �= i - - � - � - ; � .__' ' '_ __ .—"—:.. __ _ .. " . ' " - - . . _._ ...._ _.... .—. . .__ ' _— .. .NI ie_._...11__t• ..:Lfll. _..t;. . _ ''- t _�:'v.� • •.-t .1vE. �_ W. COOit .�p C - _ _. _ � . - .. - It_._V7J_':K^.' ._:7T____�__: .. ,e� .. ' _)1_.._ . .r =. e..__.._ 31.; _ _ .. � . _ . .. ,� - - ��o o :.. ,a � . ^ . � . . .. � __ � _ ' „ .._. . • : �f.l ,. . , s ;• ,r i� . .; __ .-___. - _t .., . .. ;. .. . . :' __..._ .___ . _ ,_ .._. . _ - , . . . . .. _ . _ : . . Q� , . . _ ,s e -.._ . ___-----_.. _. . __..V� .�_ . ._. __ ___ .___ _ . ' . --- � . . . . .j'.,_ ' .r J M l ,6 � 3 .6 ! ', V A : i+InG�Oti� i _' . -� . ' . _ .�:�� .-' ._� _ "__ ___ '' "_ "__" __ =. � ._..._ _ _.. _..... .. . i i! ) � . .. _... . _ .. .... ... . _" _' __' ..� �.. '�' �� ' : I l�.. ' _ ' ,� . . s • � _' -' �nO�L_ �3�� ,iy t � _ . , . . __ _ _ _ •- • r- .. 4..._ • 3a s � - ��� .. 3g s . . ,< 3z s . . " . � - ' '" , _ _ �� t - -- - r----� " __. _ __ I _ _— - ___ ;.-_ _ _ _ _ . , r1 = � � .__.-_.____....__.. ._ 'J V6 - i) i . ;l 5 .a ; ; !. ....i_� . I . y T . . . _ . _ _ �f • . �. . . _ . _. . ` . :.�,_ -.� -� A __ _ , , _ _ s = � , ,r , • - _ _ _ _ __ _ -- _ _ — � , r ._.:,r.� .� � : � � .. .. . , .. �-. � _.� ._ � . - . - - ._.- � ..��..� . _ . . .. . .. n-_.. .. ..; .. .. . . .....y .. .` ...+.. .._ --- .1 . _. .. . . . . �,_�__ � _ . _ . ,.... �o �.r . .. , . ,. � � z , r ,� . . - - -. __ . - --- - ' : .. . , ; . .__ . _ . �> $ , �` ... . ._. __.—� - ' - ---- � �--- . _. _.- ..• . ._ _. , , � _ .. __. _ .. . . ._ _. AVE -� � - : W. LAWSON � 9� � �- ��e` � cQ AYE.` .--._ . .. . ..__ .. , .__._. .� -•_'f . n __.�1_.._____7f_ __ ' _._ _._. __'.. _ _ _ ... '__- ___ __ _ _ �. "_ i _ � � :r ti - _ .:l Il- ��'-� • : ♦. . i� r ' is a � j �lo< ']�.. .��l y �f_ • .. Z '_ _ . _.. •. �.. _ _. _ . . . . . � _ ' - .. .. �n. ;W. . << �. 2 ` ic v e ' ! f . J � ^- � : �J l . , i3 z : Q '� .J z ; ` . . ' :j` �rrr z• � . " l � , , ^ � __._ ....__ •_ ..__.. ' __.. � h , . . . - � o � . .a � � Q ; .r : � �- U' [� iz � ` � _ . . . . .z."----_ . O s it� Q ' . . � .. - .____. '_'.__. " '___ ._ ' J W : . . b. . _ _ � 35 • i ? '. .�� 3. .�.• .. ' ? '. �� . 37 s -. 1� , J , . . � � „ �y-_. `. .:_ y h m dl � � --� -�- - V. . � _ ... ' -� . .__. . _.. . _ . ... Q < � � � ..._-'_... . _.5 � :� S � . r, s . �, . Z i, s -� � " . C , . . ..�.r.�.,, n.r�.y: � _.. . . _. . . ... Q . . . _ `� '.. , O /__. . . . � __. _ . . S � ` � � ` . . . " . . � . _ r S • . a . 1 . �G e , � ' .-. " ' - . . . � . . . , . • .v iv ' ` v v. � � � e ; � " . . . . '_-'"_-. , 'll_ ..� � . .. . .. . . . ._. . _ . .. -__ '_. ._.,.. ..•. _ ::,_..• __. an uw , .0 � _ ._ . ., . � � '.. ___._. t.._ . , ....... '�- . ✓C. . . HATCH .... . ._._ . .. ._. `, �- . ; ._. _. �tF : � �:�E . . :, .,--- : .; - - – __ _ -- � .. . . � �, � • ,r " .- -. - ;z � � -� �-. . :-�<- . , Z -nna- ,. - � - .. '� "' -rru�- �: � - - _ . i � �. . . . .� . , _. ., . . r � s . � r . _. _ . . . . • . � • . � - :.. ' . � . � . .. _ , _ . .. 1 . �� r , � n � . . � , i � . • ' ' . . . . . , � � ...r. J , '.• � •5 � �� ..� �.� �� 4� � �Ir, ,.. . 1�• . �.� • ir. 1S . . . . ,. i . � . . , . �il.�f��Il��� �l�I.�. _.� � e , i . :' )f • r • ) �> h r I• D� . . •� , n . �; J • • •4 • . . . . • . . ;� _ .s,' y. � . . . . . s '• L �� i �4 dd �CD 1 '. �� . . . -'ti .. ; ••. „ � . . � .� pj .�� � • + .. . � � .. - .. - . � i � � - . . � . . ' - .- - .. .. ., .. �..�• .. ..n..n, w � AVE. ni.: ' ] 1 � .. . � '_ _. ! _ . .r•'. . ••. :10 J.Ii,J.._..•e. /til) . •..: .[' . ,��� . • �, FRONT - . ,¢Q � �,..,s: • AY . vv..o.e e� � �, u /T •..��r.:nrri�,�h•. .n-rrll'- �i � � .. , s ,: > >�„�:,., y.� :--_. _,-. ,- , - . , - _„l; -,,,, �e — . . . � � , . � r , . , r , , r � � � ,c �� ��a a� c . �l -m---raE '--�-, a�..- .. � _ .... ' . . , . . _. . . . , ., . r.r i r .� s c s .. : - .,•� ,.o.,. ,. -...__ :, •a.-.... � _:_� e r � c a : � J i - `'- - ' +t _ _ ' �.-c.;n , � - _.. % � z :�_ . _. "" "" . " ' .. , / l. J 'Z`•` �A O ✓ D f RiCEiARD A. SGH�ARR ANTHOI`•IY J. CR�CA ^h"EF CPiCINEER C I T Y �O F S � I N T � P�A U L � CEPUTY GOMMIBSIONER Capital of Minnesota DEPARTMENT OP PU�LiC WORKS 234 City Hall & Courf House 55102 FtO�ERT F. PETERSON Commissioner �._�, q� ��a���: 3�, p�6� ���,��-��a� .���,��:� �. �����; �w� �u�3?1�1���9 f?{"d,?,4' ''S i' `t"e:'iF.ICIt°i3 is 7 4 r� �R: '�i:)i�'Y� �e'�a��,�i Y�,.�»-.�, . �S:: �~''!�'�r"�;a 3:��.�4" �a @"`: { �:�"�5t93fi11@: ttd:3°�ss� �;�� �?t"f,'� �€C��9"lr��"�' �*.'3�c(=(&p»�'; i!�° �1°Ja�: �L►�° 3,`��� "S��°e:�5'gxc"i,�' ���ieCi j�tij �r��!�, ���a� :��r i a:�� v��£�:�� �:� �f�,:;a s��s�J :t���ffi€�s ����+� a�� ���� �ra �3��:. �� , �e���R��'� r: t���i3� A�t3. �Y°f,�;r� �s;;.:d: a��+b '�� �.9��s�tmi��a ��,o�., :,n�:�� ���°�i i�,-�������� ������:r- c�o. '.:���f."�'�, ���c��°��r�d ,3�s�� =:, 1 ae��;'. � �� «,"?:,,:'s;?'r3rka�;i i.+:9t'#���"4.;{��;it)ii �wt�Btr� ,.�,'.t�q��C::`�•p"e� �Ci�6T3?'�':�'°B i'3� ��i�C'J�P f 1'Y��E3C'C�t�i`l �''«���•�d a�: "��.�t�a� w�'�'",�;�➢S;��a�t:e 3.�'���: �a�',y��:9}.�� Y�a��S t t°to'i y a � � � ��rf� S�+�er�� �'. P���t-s�� Cc�rni�s i az��at� ��` P��b i �� �94�t�� �� ��'r�'��/bp � � "'�,�;,, c�. �t c�rd �!���r��a°r R�ch,��d b��l�r :`�.,��. �8�� Sc3�v�rt� � °"� .lc���� �i trl��i i "'�s �� �;,'. '� �a��.:� � � �`3