The URL can be used to link to this page

245498 Orisinal to City Clerk ORDINANCE 245498 � COUNCIL FILE NO / �� PRESENTED BY '`b�(J ORDINANCE NO ! � An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to Use Districts, Height Dis— tricts and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, as amended. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section l. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to Use Districts, Height Districts and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from "A" Residence District to "C-1" Residence District, to—wit: Lot l, except the North 40 feet thereof, and all of Lots 2, 3, Block 3, Hudson Road Gardens; situate on property located on the west side of Haze1 Street between Con.way Street and Wilson Avenue in the City of Saint Paul. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect aztd be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Counci� SEP 2 3 1969 Carlson � Dalglish � Tn Favor Meredith � c� �� D..��_ Sprafka � Against Tedesco ��p 2 3 19651 -�� {� ��:n: -.�� ._ _.. Approve A�St: . Vice Yre t'.:i' City lerk o �� orm approved Corporation Counsel By PUBLISHEO S�P 2 7 1969 � � BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 August 27, 1969 Mr. Harry E. Marshall �� fl Cit Clerk �'`J'�} Y Room 386 City Hall Dear Mr. Marshall: This is written in response to the petition of Richard J. Coverdale to rezone from "A" to "C-1" Residence property located on the west side of Hazel Street between Conway Street and Wilson Avenue. This property is further described as: Lot l, except the North 40 feet thereof, and all of Lots 2, 3, Block 3, Hudson Road Gardens. This matter was considered at the August 7, 1969, Board of Zoning meeting. The staff reported that areas to the southeast have recently been rezoned to "C-1" Residence and that a staff study of the area indicates that a medium-density residential use at "C-1" density would be proper for this site. The staff study indicated, however, that the northerly portion of this block should be reserved for single-family or duplex development. It was noted that the maximum units allowed if the rezoning is granted would be 56, while the staff's study plan would allow 51 units including se�veral duplexes. The staff explained that by using the south side of Conway Street for duplexes a good land-use progression would be provided and the single-family uses on East Third Street would be protected. Mr. Gerald Frisch, representing the applicant, stated that they are in accord with the staff's recommendations, except on Conway it is extremely poor soil and would take considerable money to fill the land. He stated the applicant plans to leave 100 feet to the east of the site across Hazel Street to be able to condense the area to be filled. Two buildings of 28 units each are to be constructed. There will be two-to-one parking ratio on the proposed site. He also noted that the 40-foot strip along the south side of Conway Street would be filled and landscaped with trees in accordance with the staff's standards, but not used except for green area--to be used as a buffer. Several neighborh�� -�idents appeared in opposition to the rezoning and p��ol� 7�$�0�, bout the effect to their homes along East Third Stre ---"'—' �roblems. p.pe titian hevin6 ba:n aled rR4uest- �g �hat Chapt_e��Zo� i gt. Pau1 Le6� reqw eteX¢ept t�heenuTth 40�.�T eeax�ta� finding of the Board of Zoning that the rezoning expei Gara��d��B�w� ��e�°i 'roperty would have to have fill and may be petit��n�r��@'C u cil °P the ra' therefore, recommends approval of this �y o �tp��, �e o�e�� C-1 Residence by a 5-0 vote. We fcret+oe�4 � � �C id C�itYC�� in the ctty xe� �1e ��u w�u Very tr.u�l.y yours, sata ttme ana �s�• ' ,.� hea'r ail peraon�and all objectfona and ) recpmsnenda4lons relative to said pro- � .,�_ .��j�� ppsed Yai�dillent. � 7-. � „+--� t�. �- -� i 7�," `�, f 3 i� � � ..� Dated A�t Y �'�,sxnr�. �PETER�I�A/ . `1� �j d ;�� ity Clerk. /; p,TM;g2 (Angust 16, i�) Secretary, $oard of Zoning ✓��:w; CLS eo i Z. F. ��6734 . � NILVA, SHAW AND FRISCH , � ATTORNEYB AT LAW 2900 WEST SEV6NTH 6TREET SAINT PAIIL. MINNESOTA 55116 ALLEN 1. NILVA IRVING SHAW 690-1°397 GERALD E, FRISCN 646-790f June 3, 1969 Mr. Harry E. Marshall, City Clerk City of Saint Paul 386 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr. Marshall: Enclosed herewith please find Affidavit of Richard J. Coverdale in connection with rezoning Petition for property on the west side of Hazel Street between Conway Street and Wilson Avenue. You will note that the Affidavit sets forth that the property may be rezoned as "C-1" Residence District. I have been in touch with Mr. Paul Kelly of Corporation Counsel's Office. It is my understanding that this Affidavit will be adequate to clarify the record and submit the matter to the City Council as a rezoning to a "C-1" Residence District. Very truly yours, NILVA, ,�9AW AND FRISCH %``/� � �: � . \� . , � �-^ , �.-7v��~—~". f? 1 � /��- n�� G�rald E. Frisch GEF:nr Enc. cc: Mr. Paul Ke�ly Corporation Counsel's Office 316 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 - ' �. . � ) . , A F F I D A V I T STATE OF MINNESOTA ) �j SS COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) RICHARD J. COVERDALE, being first duly sworn upon oath, deposes and states as follows: That on or about December 21, 1968, he circulated the attached Petition to rezone the following described property, to-wit: Lot One (1) , except the North Twenty (20) feet thereof, and all of Lots T�vo (2) and Three (3) , Block Three (3) , Hudson Road Gaxdens. That at the time he circulated said Petition he had informed the owners of adjoining property that he inte�ded to cause the property to be rezoned for an apartment development. That at no time did he discuss the specific classification of the rezoning district, na�ely, either "C" District or "C-1" District. That thereafter on or about April 15, 1969, he circulated an addi- tional Petition covering the Southwest corner of Hazel and Conway, described as Lots One (1) , Two (2) and Three (3) , Block Three (3) , Hudson Road Gardens Addition, and obtained thereon signatures of Alfred J. Tetzlaff and Eleanor M. Tetzlaff. That the last mentioned Petition designated the rezoning thereon to a "C" Residence District. That at the time of filing Petition o� December 21, 1968, your affiant changed the Petition to a "C" Residence District in lieu of a "C-1" Residence District designation. That your affiant is agreeable to submitting the said Petition of Dece�ber 21, 1968, an its original condition, aamely, a Petition for a "C-1" Residence District. FURTI�R YOUR AFFIANT SAYETH NOT, Save and except that this Affidavit is made to clarify the record and to request that the rezoning Petitions be amended to a "G1" Residence District. •';� /� �; /: ; , � cribed and sworn to before me RI R J. C DA 3rd day of J�e�969. �... '��.,�.��.�- NILVA, SHAW 8 FRISCH Gerald E. FriSCh, Notary Pu 1iC ATTORNEYS AT LAW 2850 WEST SEVENTH 8TRfiET Dakota C�unty� Minnesota SAINT PAUL, MINN. 56116 Commission Expires February 16, 1976• . . - i • _ • � _ . , , . . . '� � � � .i"�'.,` �,�.� r �� ` . ' , CITY OI�' SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA r�' �� ,��, �'!I ' i l;i. �, `, � \ ��: ,_ r PETITION TO AMEND C}fE�PT'ERS 60 thY'U 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE -� �r�\� , \ � Noto; Tho signer should appraise himsolf of the uses pormitted un de r t h e new c lass i- "' � i � � fication before signing this petition. For further information about the .'r"�-�' , ; rezon ing o f property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. � (Please type or print) � y Date; v�C'�.vt ��=� q � � ljll � ,. TO TKE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL j - c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall ? City of Saint Paul, Minnesota • � ; S Purs.uant to SectiOn 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of a two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of � the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of SOq, or more of j the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- . � ing described property; (legal descr'ption and street address) � .� o r /, E �C ,�,� ,- fs� �. a o f�E T 7�� ,r�o F� �.�� c � mF .�, oTs a, �f- 3 �.loc/C 3 � �vDS�o;�v �o�f0 !rA-<r' D�NS' , � � from �/� � �F,!'ip,e„�C � District to ��C-'.- /.�,/�ES`/pC-�+/C� District, for the k purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following; � (describe briefly the proposed facility) . � A pA�7'M F n/ 7— ,�s��i c D /.�/ct S � 4 i RECORD OWNER SIGNATUR.E � TAT BLOCK ADDITION 3 SubjQct Property• ' � zo GNES` l.✓NtAA/ :�.. ;z- � �_ ---1��i �� `i-� 3 NvDS��✓ ,�,� �y�p ENJ` , t ✓ �.o � �� N� s /�� IN�c��/ �_::,� - , J ' � - l0 3 ��ar�� r� ��s�o��r �,. c -._-y?: �r ��.(,,,�,� V, ��✓j'1�'�FS c �+o�� A �``"�Ll�r�-.'� '''�- ��.•-ur� i ,� • ;,�• _.; � ,c%_ti>.�%.� ,� (.l��o ,/j��rF /�vA. '��PG��v J � ��C EA�+1�?M /F7`Z�eCFF l - �p /j'm�T �, w��e� . E,�,ly, , �/�rr��n l�y-.r. �! �c� / !?�tl l �. �v i.� K� S �� . � �ic-N//3 � � ,C—�.ST r'rn/ ,� Ts-. L�'�„',��r��c � �i�7`TLC � ^ � ?. r�ti�2i�. ,„ � �;,��:, .� 3 /�v Oro�( �t'.� �°.z��c,✓s ;� � a �Orf'/T/Yi�✓� .�. / �77% '(:.2 ic�. c � v lzt`a � � z.;� . ,�- ~,-E--�/ � � /� � r�� '��n �✓s G-NE,S �. /' �r o °_ � rN�tc�`N !�- '' � '(�. .� j.,- � , . O�/ ` � ��v Aso� r'C� �/��OE�JS' �^' ^ ' '7.t.:L� . i� � T��.�i��AV � �iP��ce� C. Gc��4a /;�.� � --�d�- �f o� �� . .. „ i l,a�„sr. ',r/ L. ,t �.,(��G... � � r �� C��Es ,¢. j'�v.�,�,�� '"' /�,, t 3 J / /1 ',L�"^r� ' / �( • '-,�Y1�k.r(j� �9Q��' 3 /7UDSD� �d l9-Ati�l�C'�✓S ,(� ' � ✓ �,�1'ff �.0 �� J��;,�,�.��v � � 3 ��as�,�' �'�'. C"�,��.✓s C- ' "r�'�S' /�1 • Sffn;'J,n/ � i� .. ,, ,. ., �� / , �>cr� ! /�'f. Jtl�i�G � 3 ��'.�J`cn/ ;i'�� GiA�,'u�N� 1'��;'-��: r�� (i i^ (l � � �. . . :, , State of Minnesota ( County of Ramsey � ss - being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he - is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �--- pages• that the parties described above are'the owners respectively of the lots placed� immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said - owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above� are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to before me this �1 ��r day of %i��,.-� l �,%�7�L,e�C�-�Te� , Address; � '� f' G�E � .i`E�g � � ` C��Z'�-- � Telephone No. �d�� ya o 6 Nota y Public, Ramsey County, Minn. My commission expires Approved as to form 1/4/65 R: A: MORKRE, Office of the �orporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 No!ary Pu!dic. Ram�ey Coun.ry, ;,1:��. � °7 My Comn�ission Expfras iYlarch lo, 1373 \,/ �' / � i .��'1�i.''�� ``'`�-�--l.S-��:�__�`� . . _ , � ) r + .• . - � , ' CITY OF SAINr PAUL, MINNESOTA ' , ` � PETI'PION TO AMEND C�IAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE {ZONING) CODE Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the ' rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. � (Please type or print) ' Date; ,� l��!L`r( r� �� l//� (: TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall - City of Saint Paul, Minnesota • : Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate aff�cted, hes�eby acquiesce; and we, the owners of' S0%, or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- � ing described property; (legal description and street address) � �r � �. �Cc.�� z-- . �1,fi ,V��. � �% �� i r-h e�� , �^�� LL cs��` -� 07-5 .� � 7 � /3�m c fC 3� ��v o .r�-N ,�c�� - /1?o t�.ti�r ' � �i from �� „��f i %'��/� E- District to �l`�� i�F�/UC'�'�T=�istrict, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) . � /'��-r; r .�, c �• `T— l� �� i �. o i N� � RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BIACK ADDITION � Subject Property; . i . � ' • �'-, �i/t�� 1 �?GG?.��,Q� ..�-� �� uL�G`S^�,+.�- �O�I'�Pr7ti ��' "� � � C�� . i�� 6�"7 3 f�w�1�.� ��, State of Minnesota ( ' County of Ramsey � ss being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �-- pages• � that the parties described above are' the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. - Subscribed and sworn to before me � � �+ this S'�'`'-_ c�ay oflJf�-�l ;'//.l��j ( �.crz-�`' �=��.� � � , / J Address; ' �S�G f �'��-��, ) l,T,_� ,;'r�j��2JP Telephone No. `��':5� 9�O �, NoLrary Public, Ramsey County, Niinn. My commission expires Appraved as to form 1/4/65 R. A. MORKRE, Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65;Votary Pabiic, Ramsey County, h1inn. My Commission Expires March 16, 1913 � • Daplteate to printer ORDINANCE 24549� COUNCIL FILE NO- PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO` / CL��"� An ordina.nee amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, a� the Saint Paul Legie�lative Code, pertaining to Uee Distriotg, Height Di�— triats and Rezoning of Qertain propertiee in the City o� Saint Paul, a� amended. THE COUNCIL OF TIIE CITY OF SAINT PAIIL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chaptere 60 to b4, inclusive, o� the Saint Paul Legislative Cocle, pertaining to Us� Districts, H�ight Diatriats and Rezoning o� eertain properties in the City of Saint Paul, ae amended, be and the same is hereby further amended �o as to rezone the following deseribed property from "A" Regidence District to "C-1" ftesidenee Distriet, to•.wits Lot 1, egcept the rTorth 40 feet thereoY, and all oY Lots 2, 3, Blook 3, Hudson Road Garden�; situate on property located on the west side o� IIazel Street between Conway Street and �dilson Avenue in the City o� Saint Paul. Section 2. This ordinanee shall take e��ect and be in �orae thirty {30j days �rom and after its passage� approval and pu�licatipn. SEP 2 3 1969 Yeas �ouncilmen Nays Passed by the Council Carlson � Dalglish Meredith Tn Favor po+e_�� Spr�afka C Against Tedesco �� .��es��den�•F$�� d _ .�:;.� �:�...:�::� }.:"? Approved• Attest: Mr. Vice Presiclent �(1'eterson) ' City Clerk +� Mayor �OO _. `.: N�; � � Form approved Corporation C�unsel�y � �' ?�. � � � -��, �;� _ ' ' •� � ' ' -. . .. , I �� A � Lots 1, 2 and 3, Block 3, Hudson Road Gardens � Apparent record owner : Agnes A. Inman. * � � The ST. PAUL ABSTRACT AND TITLE GUARANTEE COMPANY does hereby certify that from an examination of the records in the Real Estate Division in the office of the Register of Deeds and/ or Registrar of Titles, in and for the County of Ramsey and State of Minnesota, it appears that the apparent owner or owners of the property within a radius of 100 feet of the above property which is to be rezoned are as follows: `� 1. Lot 10, Block 3, Hudson Road Gardens. Apparent record owner : Agnes A. Inman. � � � ,:� 2 • Lot S, Block 4, Wild Rose Addition. Apparent record owners: William V. Golla and Frances C. Golla, husband and wife, (as joint tenants) . � * � 3� Lots 1, 2, 3 and 4, except the N. 134 feet thereof, Block 10, Robert L. Ware' s Eastern Heights. Apparent record owners: Alfred J. Tetzlaff and Eleanor M. Tetzlaff, (as joint tenants) . * � � • 4.✓ Lot 4, Block 3, Hudson Road Gardens. Apparent record owner: Lorraine B. Ritter. � � �c - 5. ✓ Lot 7, except the N. 60 feet of the W. 150 feet thereof, Block 3, Hudson 'Road Gardens. Apparent record owners: Nicholas Knoll and Anne E. Knoll, husband and wife, (as joint tenants) . � � � 6. � Lot 8, Block 3, Hudson Road Gardens. Apparent record owners: Donald H. Sandin and Agnes M. Sandin, husta:and and wife, (as joint tenants) . � � � 7, � Lot 9, Block 3, Hudson Road Gardens. Apparent record owners: Albert M. Haag and Marie Haag, husband and wife. � � � - g, � Lots 8, 9 and l0, Block 2, Hudson Road Gardens. Apparent record owner : Agnes A. Inman: (Contract purchasers: William V. Golla and Frances C. Golla, husband and wife, as joint tenants. ) � �c � g, °� Lot 7, Block 2, Hudson Road Gardens. . Apparent record owners: Josep��itter and Lorraine B. Ritter � husband and wife, (as joint tenants) . � * � w� r , ��1 r,�. �_, �. � ,: �' �� . y . � , �. �+,�,�+I � �r � �,� . .. _ � _ . � �f i Taxes and Judgments, not examined. Witness the signature of an authorized officer of the said Company this 19th day of December A.D. 1968 at 8 o' clock A. M. ST. PAUL ABSTRACT AND TITLE GUARANTEE COMPANY, � �� By � ��c �;` An Au horized S' nature . FOR: Richard Coverdale. "��,�r;"' � ",�'�,� r �� ' � $.: � ��2 . , . . . �_,� 2 � • ' NIL4A, SHAW AND FRISCH , ATTORNEY9 AT LAW 2950 WEST SEVENTH STREET SAINT PAIIL, MINNESOTA 55116 ALLEN 1. NILVA IRVING SHAW 690-1591 GERALD E. FRISCH 646-7901 May 1, 1969 City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 Re: Rezoning Petition Richard J. Coverdale Zoning Board File No. 6734 Finance Dept. No. X687 Dear Sir: Enclosed herewith for filing in connection with the following described real estate please find additional Petition in the above entitled rezoning matter: Lots One (1) , Two (2) and Three (3) , Block Three (3) , Hudson Road Gardens Addition. The enclosed Petition of Alfred J. Tetzlaff, et ux, is to be included in the previous Petition of Richard J. Coverdale for the rezoning of this property from "A" residence to "C" resi- dence district. I am sending a copy of this letter to the Zoning Board for their advice and trust that you will forward this Petition to the Planning Board to be combined with the previously filed Petition. Very truly yours, � c + � ; NIL ^ SHAW AND FRISCH ' � j ; � '� � � � � Gerald E: Frisch � �� '.. GEF:nr E .�..y,. Encs. � �•.�� cc: Zoning Board ;�t �` � . r i. I � � � � � �u) I 7 �� `� � � 1 ��: f ' M N'r' 'l i969 � ` CI1'Y �L�4��ii�vG B6�RD , N/` Saint Paul, Minnesc � ._ - - � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA • . PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE Note; The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fieation before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date: c'��/� / �� p TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50�, or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description an street address) �/ S� �-r4 r.0 cs i �� ?N�r� e �' ��Z E L, ��✓a C'o��v�;�/ � m TS /- � fi 3 ��Y. 3 /�� 1>.1'0.✓ ii'm�f o G'/��aF�c�s �oD i �� ir „ from � ��5�. District to C �f �S', District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE IAT BIACK ADDITION Subject Property; ��f�r0 � rz��F �� .�4 f'. �� -�-3 /O '�,�T�. GU/��' 's � ��e�� iY/� ��TZ��fr ��A ,'. . ,.,, _ �1 f V � �;i3�C, ,�/�sTe;nn� /7�E i��, TS � � � � 1 � .,�. , � � � � .�. � � � � � State of Minnesota � ss County of Ramsey ( Richard J. Coverdale being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of � pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to before me � this ��5th day1 of April , 1969. � > ��*-f �� „l �� "l;,' �G Address; 1 Chelsea, St. P�inn. �ia Verne Sandin Telephorie No. 488-9206 tary Public, Ramsey County, Minn. My commission expires May�Ch 8, 1974 Approved as to form 1/4/65 „ � �O�f;ice of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 ... . . . ,. . RyMr1� � . . ' '� . . � '�` � � , r , • + � , ► a . • . .1' ' . _ � r, -. ' . � � ' • i�pril 15,1g�9 5t. Yaul rlanr.in�; Loard and i;ity C,ouncil: Sirs: ��e ��zsh to ma'�e it kno�rn, that ire are in favor of Hichard Coverdale' s petition to rezone lwots 1, 2, and 3, nlock 3, rludson i�oad �:7ardens, from ^A" residence to ��C" or "C-1" residence. r�nd <<rish to add �ur siF;natures to his petition to .rezone. _�espectfully yours � r,��-l t� �red J: '1'et z f ��-t '�� ._ �-s-Ltz �leanor ��. '1'etzl f c\\ V � �� J �� 0 . ;� o'�- ' ;\,/. ., � � �� :��- ��1 ��C�c�.z „� � � � � ��Qa��, � ��s'` ��I � �� 0 ti _ MINUTE3 OF THE PUBLIC �ARING BEFORE THS BQARD OF ZONING on Thursday, August 7, 1969, at 2:00 P.Mo PRESBNTs Messrs. Ames, Denna, Ganger, McPartlin� and Maietta of the Board and Messrs, Brown and Sorenson and Miss Poechmsnn of the etsff. RICHNRD Jo COVBRDALE: A petition to rezone from "A" to "C•1" Residence to permiC construction of apartments on property located on Che aoutheast corner of Aszel Street and Conway Street. Mr. Sorenson su�narized the staff report stating Chat the aite has 320 fcet along undeveloped Hazel Street with a depth of 297.34 feet and aquare footage of 95,148.8. The ad3acent properties are soned "A" Residence; north of Wilson �venue between �iezel Street and Luella Street two large tracts were recently rezoned to "C-1" Reaidence. The Comprehensive Plan recou�mende low-deneity development for the site and the adjacent properties inclnding the one recently rezoned. The subject site is vacant, has denae brush and undergrawth, and ia relatively level. Zt is much lower than Van Dyke Street, Bast Third Street. and Wilson Avenue. Wilson Avenue is paved and Hazel Street is paved from Wilson south to Old Hudson Road. All other ad3acent platted atreets are non-exiatant. Aa apartment ie under consCruction on the northeast corner of Wilson Avenue and Hazel Street. Mr, Sorenson stated that the atsff has studied this sres, sad then explained a proposed development akeCch, a part of the file. He noted that apart�nenta at "C-1" density would be proper for the majority of this aiteo but that the first 120 feet fronting on Che south side of Conway ahould remain for low-density develop�ent and not be resoned. He noted that uader the proposed aket�h plan the three lots could be developed with a total of 51 units insteed of a maxim�nn of 56 allowed if the rezoning is granted. He gave the following conclusions: 1� recent rezonings indicate a change in the character of the area and the Comprehensive Plan which origiaelly called for park apace; 2) public improvements for single-family development in this area are high; 3) topographical, not geological, featurea in the srea acted as a deterrent to low dens�ty development of the ares; 4) Lot 1 should retain its present classification as ahould all those lots abutting Conway Street in this area; and 5) Lot 1 can be divided for low-density use under "A" Resideace. Mr, Idaietta wanted to know if these ia a definite reason for cul-de-saca, Storm aewers are in oa Iiazel Street. Improvements are needed on Van Dyke, Aazel, Luella, etc. A new street could be platted between �ihite Bear Avenue and Van Dyke, south of Conway snd north of Wilson. Mr. GeraZd Bo Friach represented the applicant and atated that ehey are ia accord with the sta.ff's recomnaendatious, except on Conway it is extremely poor eoil and would take considerable money to fill the land. He stated the applicaat plans to leave 100 feet to the eest of the aite across Hazel Street to be able to condense the area to be filled. Two buildings of 28 units each are to be constructed, There will be two-to-one parking ration on the proposed site. They passed around two pictures of the afte taken in the wiater. The 40-foot strip would be filled and landscaped with trees in accordance with the ataff's standarda, but not ueed eucept for green area--to be used ss a buffer. _7_ � • �Mr. Leroy Shea, 1$86 East Third Street, wanted to lcaaw what the planning of the ' strip of land north of Conway SCreet iso Mro Ames anawered that it is vacant; Mr, McParClin said it would continue to be "A" Residence and that ehe Boaxd is not concerned with that property at this time. Mrs. Marie Chatterton, I882 East Third Street. queationed whether an alley would be behind the apartments. Mra Sorenson said no alley is platted. Mr, Clarence Fincel, 1.890 East Third Street, expressed concern about a trsffic problem. Mr, Maietta ca�ented that rhe apartment tenants would came off Old Hudson Road oato Haze1 Street. Mr. Shea said there is no access Co Conway Streeto Mra, Chatterton noted there ia a big hill in the vicinity and is worried about more accidenta occurring. Mr, MaietCa moved fox agproval since the request is reasonablee The property wauld heve to have fill. and may be �xpensive to d�evelopo Mr. Deana aecanded the motion, which carried onaaimously. Sul�itted by; CoYonel Lo Sorenson Rabert L, Ames, Chsirman -8- City Clerk CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 �'� August 15, 1969 File X-687, Page You are hereby notifie8 that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. , on August 28, 1969, on the petition of Agnes I. Inman to rezone from a Class "A" 8esidence District to a Class "C-1" Residence District the following property: Lot 1, except the north 40 feet thereof, and all of Lots 2 and 3, Block 3, Hudson Road Gardens. The property is located on the southwest corner of Conway and hazel Streets. For further information contact the Planning Board, Room 1010 Comsaerce . Building or telephone 223-4151. JAMES J. DALGLISIi Cou�n►issioner of Finance 55 4 , � ' r s - - ., . `_� ;� � . . �_ ,. �� .- • , �OARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 May 16, 1969 Mr. Harry E. Marshall, City Clerk Room 386, City Hall & Courthouse Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 Dear Sir: The attached petition of Richard J. Coverdale to rezone from "A" to "C" Residence property located on the west side of Ha�el Street between Conwaq Street and Wilson Avenue is being returned to your office without consider- ation or recommendation from the Board of Zoning. This action is taken in response to a legal opinion dated May 8, 1969 from the Corporation Counsel's office which responds to the concern of amendments to the petition without apparent recirculation. The legal opinion states in part: "It would be my opinion that this petition should be accompanied by a sworn affidavit of Richard Coverdale that the petition was amended prior to receiving any signatures thereon. If the amendment was made after any signature was placed on the petition, the petition would be invalid and there- fore necessitate recirculation." Also attached are a supplementary petition received May 7, 1969 and related communications. Please contact us if you should have any questions. Very truly yours, � , `/%� � ,' i 7 ! .LI_ ��,��_�/� _�=:��-� Noland;R. Heiden, Director NRH:jld CLS ZF�� 6734 Enclosures: 1) Pending letter of City Council dated 3/5/69 2) Insufficiency letter of Finance Department dated 3/14/69 3) Sufficiencq letter of Finance Department dated 3/26/69 4) Referral letter of City Council dated 3/27/69 5) Petition dated 12/21/68 6) Referral letter of City Council dated 5/6/69 7) Letter of Gerald E. Frisch dated 5/1/69 8) Petition dated 4/15/69 ,.� 9) Letter of Alfred & Eleanor Tetzleff dated 4/15/69 ' .� �. ' � �t 8� t. . � ' 3 � ` 4 W ..�t 4/fV1�Q/(T7l/ ,�`, �!�" ,`�'� . �.��I= �«r �� PAUL J. KELLY � �3i121 �� a: THOhAAS J.STEARNS +" : + . .�. JON R. DUCKSTAD `\, '• �� : ARTHUR M. NEISON �t. " �� JEROMf J.SE6AL 7HOMAS M.MOONEY RO�ERi E.O'CONNELL JAMES W. KENNEY p��•� CI� OF Si7iNT PAUL KENNETH J. FI1ZF/�TRICK PAUL F. McCLOSKEY,JR. DANIFL A. KLAS LOU15 E.TORINUS sact•t n�rda.f L��AL 0l�ARTYENT JOSEPH E.CARTWRI6HT ' �1� Cifr N�il� St. �a�l. Mi��s�t� �51�2 • �OS��H �. iYNYtRs � ca.�..x..c.....� May 8, 1969 � s Mr. Na1.�d R. Heiden �� "�� Director �'�� . �`�'"` 3aint Pau1 Planning Board ;, . �` 101O Cornmerce Building 3aint Paul, Minnesota Re : Petition of Richard Coverdale Dear Mr. Heidens This office is in receipt of the petition of Richard Coverdale whiah was forwarded -by your oPfice on April 18, , l c.369, , . . � Yoa a9k the fo]:lowing two queations : � ' "'t (1) the effect of the proposed rezoning being amended � Prom "C-1" to "C" reaidence without an a pparent reeirculation. � �: It would be n�,y opinion that thi$ petition should be •� � � accom nied b a e�orn affidavit of Rf�hard Coverda�e that �� y� � Pa y � . petition Mas amended prior to receivit�g anq signatures thereon. � If the amendment waa �ade after any signature was placed on the pet.ition, the petition would be i:nvalid and therefore ; `naeessitate recirculati.on. . � '" �. �.. � s � - � (2) the Cowxi4�.l poliey relati�re to amending a pe�ition ��,. � in sueh a maruier wl�isih; appeara to be gerrymandering �:c� ese . . �; , � � .� :. � S : �� ti� need� for addi�ia�;�7 elgnatures . ; : s �, . . . :�4 . :�:� f �;, �T ..:. , . . . � � . . � �"� � ." `��.:� . £:Ka ". . I �rou�ld r�Com�`i'id .that you me� �ri�l� l�a,yor Byrrt��9relati.ve x4'�; '� : to- this atad:�sterm3�ne �►i$ poiiey rel�tive ' to this type of z�zoning. ,_ . ��:� 3 Ae gou know, there is '�thing apparLntly il'�egal with t,�s type =.- � ��' ,-bf rezoni�, but as y�u have statedr� it 1� ,a.��'onsiderati�'� for: �:v< � .t:h+e CouncS��l. �,�� ` � . �� 'r�� -r`'; ,� . P `�g= ' �,� ��` � � .� �. x � (U �: ,� �� M�r � � u�, a�� ,� :,� � � � � � ��. . � �9b'� ; Adsis�nt Corparation Counael � �,,: � �� + s , ,. + . {�+ d �. '.''. Y �.�. � �. R+S+ "�.i�+�..{`. - ��•• n� V Y�. `!4.... ; �.:. ..�: . �. !;.'— �' . '_:'»� ,. ... - iay ��..,t A'�. �. '�a! `( � �, w e �.,C:i .yy.A.b.,. . � . , . !M . � e , j r • , . .y , . _ , � April 18, 1969 � , � � Mr. Psul Kelly - 0!lice of th� Corpontian C owseel Cit� Ha11 aad Cowrthow� � St. Paul, Minn. 35102 � D�ar Mr. Kelly: . Re s Petition o! Rtclurd Cbwrdtl� Piws fiad attaci»d th� pttition to a�nd t�aptss 60 throu�gh � 64 ot tbs Ls�islatitrs (Zoaing) Cod� No. 8b8�' consistie� of ewo pagsa. ,Thi� lttition is sigwd by Hr. Riahard Co�►�rdsls, dated D�c�nbar 21� 1968. � . . Also enclos�d is ths 3t. Paul Abseract aand Titl� G�earsett�s : Cc�spaoy'• csrtifisd lta� o! the appasr►nt awner� oi pro*srtp withi� a radLw o� 100 lsst o! the prop�rYtp r�fsrrad_to in p�tttio�,X687.. � , � T�ta �►tittaa i�aiaa� t�►o qw�ttLona oi conc�trn bp oar d�part-�' �iot s , . . . � (�� tla propos�d r�soning bas bs�n a�s�d�d irom "C-1" to "�" rsaidaacs without an� appas�nt rs- ' �circalatiaa; � . ' � (Z) tha pstition also apparsntly lus b�sn cbaagsd �xcepting tbs north 40 f�at of Lot 1. , . Thi� in,af�s�t �li4iaats� ths aecuaity ot aacurin� asp �ig- t . ► . natuxss far tba propart� on tlu nortb aid� of Coan�a�. Ws haw bssti► og�rsting uodsr a Cov�ncil polic� Mbich �a�rs -thst , , Couacil aiil not considsr proposals far rssoaing in whic6 th� bouadari�s baw bs�n garsymsadaxsd, app�reatl� to. eacap� � , • tha na�d for ai.soatarr�. It Would b� appractats i! �au wonld loQk this �owr sad , advia� �rs aa to ths b�st Maa to proc�d. ' . : . Vity ttul� your�, � ,. . 1��tRsPB � l�olaad R. H�a�d�a , Banc - 2 � Dir�ctor '� '` � i , . ' . ' . � , . . . ' • DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE . , � CITY QF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I 13 Court Houss,65102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner LOUIS H. MeKENNA, Depufy Commiuioner Phom:223-4646 March 14, 1969 To the Council City of Saint Paul �entlenea: I have checked the �ttached pctition of Agnes A. IUman, filed in the matter of rezoning, � ��g?,,,�Q ,¢,�� . o / Lot 1, except the north�feet thereof, and all of Lots 2 and 3, Block 3, Audson Road Gardens. The property is located on the southweat corner of Convaq Street and Haael Street, fram a Class "A" 8esidence District ta a Class "C�" Residence District, and find that s��.d petition is insufficiemt. Y�a.�s very t rnly, . � � C �� . � y� aes J. Da glish .�° /'��-� � c�no�ission r of Fi nce Re: 7C-687 c.c. Kr. Ames N. R. Heiden Frcntage: 100'� Parcel: Eligi�le - 14 , Parcels Signed - 8 or 57',G , Needed - 10 or 66 2/37G : � y �� 1� i� I �� ,,��"'�" C"lr' �� , . . - . . � • � ' � � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE � ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I13 Court House,5b102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner � LOUIS H.McKENNA, Depufy Commiasioner Phone:223-4646 March 26, 1969 To the Council City of Saint Paul Gentlemen: I have rechecked the attached petition of Agaes A. In�an, filed in the matter of rezoning, Lot 1, except the l�orth 40 feet (per asended re- submitted petition) thereof, and all of Lot: 2 and 3, Elock 3, Hudson Road Gardens. The praperty is located on the southwest corner of Conway and Hazel Streets, fr� a Class "A" Residence District to a Clas� "C" Residence Dietrict, and find that said petition ia suffici�nt. Yours very tr � � _ ames J. D lish �%� Commissioner of 1� ance Re: 7C-687 c.c. Mr. Ames N. R. Heidet� Frontage: 100� Parcels Eligible - 10 Parcels Sfgned - 8 or 80'x Needed - 7 or 66-2/3X �O . . ' . , • . � ' � •,�u��•�,Q,�,•�'`�' . � � ' �. 'r" . . � CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA ->^'`�� /}{ � ��/��` ��:�'�� .` . . � r1f L� V , ' � . PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE -'' � � ., .i�� Note: The' signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- � fication before signing this petition. For further information about the � rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date: �EC�M 13�� J f 9(� TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR A�TD CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Purs.uant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- . ing described property; (legal descr'ption and street address) IF T��1'd'� 1 07` / � �C ,�p-T �� II�. � fE�7- >'��rr.�oF, �•�rd .9 �� ,�N�.�� m F .Z o Ts oL, � 3 l3<o c/C � /ti��1�S oaV j'/- OAD l�A-rr' D E NS' To �o�PTfi` Sl� '��(cePt� from �A � �FJ`/D,�NC � District to � C.--��FS/a�.�/C�E District for the purpose of installin � ��y��/�/�/�6J g, constructing and/or operating the following: � / �� /�� (describe briefly the proposed facility) � �/l��,lr- ��'"�►`a� A I'�•d�7"M F n/ T .�v i c D /.ni�S RECORD OWNER. SIGNATURE IAT BLOCK ADDiTION Subject Property; +: ��o ✓ GN�S` . l�//yt��/ .� -�'�,%� '� -%�v��L.�,��' �o/ 3 /�I�Ds o/✓ /�.� (r��'� �r!S` � ��N,� s /�• .jN �s�t�r�/ , �� ,'�" � /� 3 /��'mg/ �ll' �r��'o�-�s ^ �1�,. :(.V/�C�C i,s,v� �� ✓�,�h��ES l.- Go.0�A v� � e ,�' �i(�i�,D �oSE �D A, /t��P�.0 I/. 1�' ��E�d�1Io,T� /�f21.e(�F E� l�l r �O �Ord 7� �.. �uitRB„n � rT�E jd lhc. �[ yP�ttn G. w��S �' � �Tia ' �° ��sr� n✓ � r.r .. L o�J lr',��NE (�. �/ 7`TE?. C c 3 �{v oro� �X G°� ,nv E�✓s c ° � L,orP/�/NiN� .Q. J /77� '� ,� /�uRron/ /�� /,�/�Dfi�✓S' �rrNES �. L'N�sc��s/ 1c- • _ ,��.y f(^ I' � � O�9 � ��v As°m r✓ jP� (rA�AE�I$ ��.� i,��n �l �t ��PR�c�� C. G 0��a �',� 'o�.,.-�1�- s�-,• i� ., �. .. , , �- 'n�, �w3 q�,��.� ,�. r�,��,�� ,. , ., �, . ,�:��.� .,��• 3 /��DSo,� �� ,�vF�s ,D�n�� v �� J��r��v � 3 /-�Uvs�,,� �'� C"��v�,�s /�C-`NEs �. Sff,✓.v,� ,, .. „ ,. ,, ��, �3E,;T /�. ��l�/�G- % 3 ��o.ro.✓ �'� G'��Ns /�/�lf'/� �(4�/� G � , ,, ; , „ , �� :''"'�`� State of Minnesota ( ,.; '�"� County of Ramsey � ss � � �� ^", f.r .,; �� being first duly sworn, c�eposes and states _that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �-- pages• , that the parties described above are� the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the tru� and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to before me this � ''�� day of �'��t � ��,G�j�� Address; � � 9' ��E � s''��4 G�'�'zi�.. Telephone No. ��d� qa p (o Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn. .. My commission expires ,� � � �pr,oved as to form 1/4/65 " , , � .. � y �ic� of- the orporation Counsel �\ FGI 1/5/65 � • • r•.. � ` ,� r.:.. i �� ' , :.� � � � ' • � � ' -� � • CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA t ,, - . - ' r . ' � �:' PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE Note: The' signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date; �� C�/r'lj�r.,� Z% /y/� f lr� TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property: (legal description nd street address) �. �T / � �Cc�� r- �d�� iV�', �C' �� ` Th �� _ , � �v�D ,� LL cv i=- -C p�s � V, 3 , �3 c�c.l� 3, l� v o s r�v ,C'o�v C3. ,a.�b��r from � ��:.f i�'��- District to n��d� ��p��i''Cr�District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) � �/4-�( �" M C �/ `T— � c� i t,. 1) /i�� a RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BIACK ADDITION Subject Property: !�/c,�m GO�► .�C v��7 3 �lwAC��- �. "� , �r�ix.x,�, �. .�ue.ee� 6�7 3 f�r,�.oily,��•�.. e,rr�'�ir,. � " �y , f, � ti, State of Minnesota ( �s County of Ramsey � ss being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �-- pages; that the parties described above are�the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to before me ,!'� "� i this �'�'`'-- day of l%f rt�, ; % .lC� � � .� / � �, �' �-- J Address; � �/� �� /��Z� Telephorie No. c�� 9.�0 C� No ary Public, Ramsey County, Minn. My commission expires Approved as to form 1/4/65 H. A. Mo«��-; Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 Notary w�a�;c �. ; _. ' :,; MY f:omm�sspr .� � . . , � 7 . , �•; pq t; T� � r t . ' . r �. �, w o ►',' -�--�- :� (3 � � i�...._....:: ( � ' �, � - 'tJJ { C� Ca r ;�, :y'. _ _ �� `i-�, �� ' .; ��:� �-. y re �.... ' , .� : , ,., ' � � �. _.. . ;r - . � � a - � �3:�, : _ o,. - y �� . � ` �n o ��`o � ;o - � � � o� � , � . - < 4 Q � -r� w�`� .� �p 0 ;� Q --��-- '4 cn `" 2 � I"" lK __ o� a o, � Q � _ .w. D -�rj � r � Q. p �?. �. Q .. r � p � 'f � ,< I r .� �- ., � 1 ' � D j �' ' f i � t ' a i O C . Z + . .� ' < "', � ' , ; I , � �_ { ' +.' ; �z � .p ' , , . , O�Q..; O 'O �j. f�1 p� �,p1p �� , -Q Oao �Q.;.o � ' � � .�� '�- - r„ ! .� ;- - - �-- '�n/�,JI-��,.. j3.��q-.l�-. ,,; � _ `; �_. _ f. +r.T-ry. --•�.J. / .� - } �. .. F� '.��:'• x-�. ..:�� -� ,� � G� - o � o 0 0 �,�� Q �� Qr Q °Q, " r�, T :.,,�,,,. '� � =J,.` � � �; � �{ . ; . .. � t .�:; �� .. , �.'� i� i{ { _ �. .,� ; •. =,F . . 4 � O a. { t '+ : � � �. '.� _ r 0 �� ;f F F ,j � 7��s( ., .�1 �.:��' ' '� }1� ��.! (_ . � } :4 p '� � �J� a" .�- �. �➢� ''� � vi y` �� r�': `rs ��"`n�7 � � .p i:. :� � � �� <r 1 � � ,� � � �r �"� 1- 'r �� . ;� :: � .,: ., C� . � _ ., . � � , � , ; _ :' s ' . N �,, �', , ' _�'i. . , - . , �.. , ..,�, : .�. . _ , ,_;.. . .� ti� � '� �y� �o � � � { �. , :.�'J �.O ,; � '1� — --�-- . � :,� ..; .�..: T �.,. � �. .r _ A. ,p� ^o,. . :p. .. �; �, r, -, -,.;-�,,�...�: . D . - �: � r .� 3 � �, ��> � ' � � ►� � '° t j�1` < k� �< �. ' � -- _ ,`� f �.� .� �_ 1��: •� . � Q ' � . �1 • ` � !' . , h . . . , : ,.�.� � � . . � r ,: � . , ' - ., , :: _ - , , � �: _.s..'� 1r�'F' � _' e'•.� T L::2, ��_ •� --.F.. __ - ..t, •� K .,��I Ft:,�'4 :.:R.. .t .. . : .� �. .,.. '..� .��. 4 ��^ ' -..� : # S _ r"' �.�r��.� _,,.,�+a+.s ��: s V��- �1' � ��.�� "_�'�Z°�� . , .. � . ,� , i :� .� .. , .:;. +�-s�w�..R � ✓ (' ! g, ..'�S �i.T.F/� ...: ' fi _ . .;�- .-^ �..:. . �` 1- .�.� t . � �y.�`:''��' . 't'+ �,1. J� .}'.•..' ��M �"E ' �:�;`f' {' s��'� _� . , '4,� . . ,:��;:.,. t ,n ,.'_�.ti . ." '- ' ' � n.�� •. �:•' _�� f�� t �.�M'o".r:i�:�. .�.;. � " , � �w.,�.. ..�. . -.-. .., .::.. " . _�I � !. .Y� 7.1 -;:+� `",+._... J 31 ,Y'�� N. ;, ` ` � ` 3,: f. .,. ,. , 'r�. ..:. � ,� +.. kr t. ' t �.�:.. .';. � .�+ �A �'i `r v��:t � � � '` � �,.r ,.; ::��" _ ....' - '-• a, - _ >-: "��., '^ ..w . 't t 4• /� � /1�M �". �. £�}„� ,y. 5��"�` }� �*M � j '�� l ) F� (�j �.�� y�^�' , �r d �'� � ��H :!tr .�! Ot �M ( � K �:Vt �� \I' .��'. -f�`.r I,�'w �, :`��. �t.ty, �� '` � _ '. � �� r.. • t �'- c�..�`� �•` . .,.J � �'`" b+ 1 �, Y_. r'�,�- � �_ 'y:y,+�� _ ,a. Y �i'��. s` ��i� } w,:.� il, i.a� T ,},+ ��- :r "� ��.�t ,.�t . ��' -'�''y - f "1<:� .:N � � <; � 1� �� i� �.° ,f -.k a �..'^° � Sr. ;;:!�^ �,_/, � . •. �� • �{.- '{'�<.�. .� ,^�"' )• 1 —� �J�, �.�� t /� ;d �.�� A �.,J � � � �4 yy ,�r�� /� ��i� 1 ��. . L � 7 :t f.�' Y�, � ��J �,•.,y� �1�� ';� J�,� % . Ai '��^ � -�'7 n y..•�, W� k.f � -� .d' �9'. �.�� • ` • r `�� -��'��y �,x .�Ey:,� "� ` :� i�. + :,'� r�. .�;�,, �" ' �' q. � y��^ j .. , � ..,5:.` '�2�•� is' � i'tr'i_�r-,� ��-r ��;r ♦�::5-!^: r{:%' . . , 1 .�.�• _ 1b O t '�.�R, �i, •�._ � y[ � Y �y ,l ,�� ,..t:� ,� � . t. a�:�� *^ Y�• - x � � �b� � .� a' . �r l - �i, � � �+i. v. . 7..� �; � . �:�' f -. ��l' .� ��' �� ,��- �' ' - �� . ��♦' ''W .E�' �G �,� � �1b �� r i. �� .�' •��• _ '?� , T � " ' ? � �� - t y+,.��yy�' ��''� �• �f, '�� ' ...� �y� �r �a � t, N ��'� F .y. ;F`. y �Q�r..:-,. S y _ ��.,� v� n r � ,� s ��, „ ,,t�,� �'� �7� __j _� n - "� � � � � m a,� _' �, t•. � s , , •� A ��a �y�� +! A � 3. � i„. � , .� , '��,., �,,�W � , � , . . �. . . � •' � �' � '{ ��(� � � , �.�.� m�� : ,.�. i � ?.� �-. i��,'�' '�S � � {. ; � ..; . . . � t' �• �� /. . �.. .� '� �.. ' �i. +;1 1 �W .': j � /� y�� 1' t',� 'V� s. F � �f'�4 • '` `�� '� .,flft•� �," � �� n �,Y� !p��" � ��` +� � . ..l- . .� �� ' t�. �A . � y� r� ,�� ' 1 ."+� r .' ,. :�� 1 , - y� � a. ' 1 � ;;,�. �� „ * ;7 ~.�: 1' ,Y�+ . , Y . y �1� ,., � �� rti: � �� f � '' ��' ` '��+ , '+. �� :�I`1 �r` a�� . . , ` ;.r �.! 1�..' t - ' � � �� i �' .'� •�,.r y.' :��r �: `,� r iJ _ .s.'- : r ?' �. ��.�_ ,. ��: %�, �� r ''Y,�. .ri�' .r: i'c� 'r.Y :'i. t,=:t ;�ti: 1 � :. Y� .� . { • {' ,�:yr� �I 4. �,� ( •?,. �•,i, ;'�... ..t�: _ �,��d:_ t ;� '��'� �.• _ ' k "�, {�"�� =� �_�� < `< <'�'`� � ,, r�� ..,� � ;5 � ,� �,<' �v r '�;• �7e '!?� ,�• •- �' �. �, :: ti �: , ��z � ; ., .� �;` L;;, ;`� _i � =�'" ',� �,,:; ;�� f .;; � ,•,, _t� "i !',°: . , ,:., �.; .,- •� .�� `'� , ��`:It �,F - h �L i •r'�< �'� S�' .�. .a�� _ � Q i r w{ �� .,? � �( �Y} S` a �� ':I --'.-�.»�-w�'y� � • '.? ^ �� ;I� q • �,•., Mt. �'. �. . '' ,'_ '�•r �' ' 1 � / .' � 1� - '/' � y 5.� ^' .y� ar ...+� � u ,'. A1 :. ��✓ g .� � - t"a '�" �,. a ,�,��. . � . , ' t'�f w�� G �. ' � s .`. �� .� ". '"� S�✓t^ I' � �� . � � �T h r' '�• i ' ��-' ' �(�.i, tY . . . � � . �.�,�� M `'4.' u� f �. � �? �,�•y.R `�`..`p r,.: �.;�". ..' .�,..�. . � � , � �:- .. �� . t`� ,PY :''d4t' 7y!�` �♦ R,,� ..y ti" !M. •,�L C��•�, W 4 k .'�'� r T..-: ',, i.�' 1,. �-�� :��. �.'�� i.k.. ''i�.4 �R..� 1 � ��. �"ta f t ., .� A, h- � ' Yi. +S'�� sR�^`. 1 .t, .d�#� .�.: ��. � ` 4,.� �Jti.,, � .. .#, yo,�, n�� = ;:# - '� �. �/'�,7k �'+`'it"` '�: ,t t �}K s d�. . n�' �..e 1 ..� '�' y }/,��, t V� °?. "�� \a ,�,f.) ��: \ .� �,ry, ,� ,,�^ :.� L. ::`, �-:��arir..� r' �/► . ` L � _ l �� d� � � �� `� g '.' �,� � „�4' ��' z : - ,. ,, . ; F��°i�� ..�� _f . � i �_�. d,,:, 't�' �f� i-. � �= � � rT 'y �,F,.ti, ' �1` n;' ��v �p #�}� ;�! ,� �.1�. zy r r.';' .5h _ h�' ';y�.�-. ,��x.. , ,�, � �h; ' .,.;. r, i� "•'X'j -�- . .�` , '?� � Y �::.+» �. �L . `e. . . ; — . A ,... ..• ,.� .�,.,M{ . r _, ��ti y �� /I . [.,� `[ ,d �.^ � �� .. Y ��.:� . . 1" yri `1 4 � `�"�� r' y� F` .� ,; � � . ..�. . .� �/ . .i � i ..�� k: ,� .� .. ��' ..-.:V.�, { . N ,�-�..,� a� �! �n. 'i ..�+ �� .. ��: `'\ `�+-++�+'�� r .�.!'� ` y.� � . - . . ', ' '� �.� �r',., ' . �,r l. + :.'.; '�t:.c,`1f �"� : . �.., --. ..,. ... �.. N ' rr �,��,y ., Y` '�':.R ` ' ��c� 1 tt ��,�;i :i ,�,_: , �'� ;`'. =i�� f ',• �I�� ' , ,. J1 . � � ��. ;1 . ; �t,: � , r,, ,_ , � _ �� ,, , . , . � , , ., . . . : �� . . ,` , r � •* � . �3'•a : ..��.�. ...� , AG X� �'� �` � _ � . � . ,., , „ .. �, t,,, . , - � �.�_i2'+� • : . ,. ;.. .� N:-: � , �,.. � � y � , t F. � � ` � � .,.z� �;- .. .. ° � i� •i , y -,t } � '� r,r .� � �1 �. .�,.. t,� ..•�� •-'�.r �{ .:i2 � . •��. .� ! 't. /[�� '� '� w ,Nm ...3: � � '�?.' � 1f ii� 'S_- ,� �� 3 � � µ`A: ' y��.� +�.�C "� y �:� •�'r ' f .:��k� µ��$ �4 �� '��r..��'r '�• �� J . ' ��,'��'♦ �� .� �t t Y`�. a M :.M� 'el: •`�' - L ,� ��' � ,� �� ''y , '� )7 y Y. ..�� ' 1 ;•� y � �� y 'C,� _ �.�j. ( �"1'► � 'V y ��"r ��'• � , � .j � �Z� i.. r{�� ` �.Ji �� k A 4 .M�. N �� + �� '.f�� "5�: '' � - 5 � � �r;� Q � � � �,� : ;m ,.f�� a -�-,. �;:, *, t .� s ! i� . , ; � ,-'''� • �- � �: . � . ,.° '� .�. :..� r . •� -� { Y �yf '�(� ^ ; � 4� � . * 'Y1. 1 �.}� _' �'� ..'.�'1 �I P � i Yi. k�� +n,, 'f � �[+ �•/. �� . �4 ..�t�� '�r � fi� ` . � _ � 1� _ �, * � .' � 1�I-- � n ' � ■ � � �y �:�. 9�,'f. ��,`�� , � f� �- � �� 7 �� :.� y _ ^^��''1'' ,. � i, ,� :, :t' F, A 'wQ .�� 'k � —..�i.r+ �� F. +��.` � ,t'f� •l ` _ ..,..:e }�` �y T ; � ��Y �".eTt ! - � "� .. � � , � � .i. �� ' � r•_. � y � � .;�.� �.....� t' < �'. r {+l` '; . _ A .'� ��, t '� • • _�� rY�!. J��n� ' � � � �� ! i �'� �' �'� � •y/�� T O • �a' ��• t 1 f�" y}�.�1.- � :�t r�`�•.�.,�' .�. �1 � ' iai �� +�r.. . t r; ��;'ii a �; ,.��*'a� '>; ' '�"• �' �,� ;.Q � .. �� .�.:� � �i� �..�� :y� i �Ay; r`�• �ib:� t �� "%t.. •`�^ - s . � .r:�� 1�Htl�'. 'r,tc .. _fi �• �//�'\I ��- A � .'I �'�:' �A��/ �. Y ';4. �s.� *�'i 1�"� -r ti'7�1 1 � �� ..i��._. ` �� :- i '..l JY �'.�" +•�� '� C t. �,A �' ��. ,� ^, �;"t } � � ''��: .� {�� tr : }, r �� I�•-r- „' � � _ ' . �< � _ /� r. ::n} N .i , � . t M�- ` .: ♦ �� k'+� � ��f ..rr . �.. ~ G �� ^ �'� �- .! ^� /�. •�.y' ,%�+� -IAM � f� r.� '� � ,�' , �i �{ � '' �.i `� �.�' ,t .�1.�. 1�t ,...'v/ � -!,:� T. . . . � ., . _� .� • - ,. � � . � — , . , � � r , .: ».n �� _ , ,. _ . , , r. . , � . - * , . �:,. ,, . . . . . , _ ....�,� . ; _` � ,� , . .. - g �C? � � � �' : �,, , � , � � ,�E� � �, ' _.._.....:::..._r ' -% , .x �-�.�-�----�'-�- .-�----�-�'... :.�.. .,�:�_ � r • ,. . . . �.r!+ �r �..+� �.a�- . y Si` }' • r S ' . M � f ��'MM ,. •' ' �.. l. 4..^�'1- �ti ;G�C �' �t—'- r�. r �.t� } �� `5 Y _ ��` � t..,�: _ �,�- �i, _� ;;�; ,i. ,�,: f� ,� 'r ;:. .. , �a'', t .1. � ;� ��. ,,, �.} Y �,. vpi4: '� :�` �, x ��•; r e` O <� , a' �..-�--�� ° .�j , ,'; ,�' . ,`� A �'r i `'.�� .?�. �-J�:_ :S�s1.� .��'a=.��.f,* C'�'J,;1�.:�� w!.,a.�� rR„'.2!�� :.��°'� �:..�� . : � - �( �=_ _ :: . : � 3.�y� .� ,..,- . . . ; , �, . .. ;. _. -�.�i,... , .., t.: � , k'. �. cs.�... .,�....__�. J -- � � . . , �: j:, . . . .,�_ � . ., _ ,. : . .. . ��., s... � ._. �'� a iP'