246395 ORI6INAL TO CITY CLERK � A V'��q��
CIT1( OF ST. PAUL couNCi� "
� OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK F��E NO.
OU CIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY � � �
COMMISSIONE DATF
RESOLVED, that the Council hereby ratifies and approves the
action of the Board of Appeals and Review for the Housing, Building
and Fire Prevention Codes pertaining to the following listed pro-
perties as shown by the official minutes of said Board of Appeals
at the meeting of October 22 , 1969, a copy of which, marked EXHIBIT
"A" is attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference .
Case No . Address
56 ' 1236 Hubbard (Mr. � Mrs . Guy L. Coffin)
59 1138 Duluth Street (Paul Harvey)
63 1026 Pleasant Ave. (Edward Morse)
APP OV D
�� ��a�'oR Counse�
No� z � �sss
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Councit 19—.
Yeas Nays ��u 2 =� 1969
carlson
Dalglish Approved 19—
Meredith _ � Tn Favor
Peterson \
Sprafka (� Mayor
A gainst
Tedesco
Mr. President, Byrne ���-�5��� NOV 2 9 1969
O
` • I il/. ,'/1�!1
I�Ic�c�l i ii�� N�, , � !i
!•
�24�c�
�
..�
h1INUTt:S OI� 'I'I(E Ml:il:'f I N(;
S'1'. 1'AUL BOARll Ol� nl'Pl:/11,ti
1Veclnesciay, Clctoher 2' , 1 �)G�1
l;ureau of liealth I,ibrary, 555 Cedar St . , - 1 :.iO I�,m .
Members present : Lawrence U, Colien, Cha i rn�,i�i
I:styr 1'cake
Gale Rclinber�;
lirtliur '1'ieso
James Voi �t
Members absent : Norma Sommcrclorf
Charl.es Vclin
Others present : Glenn l:r.ickso�i
Ccralcl I,aucr
![enry Strcich
1)r. 13urtis Atc:�i�s
Dr . Paul Cox
I�rank 5taffcnson
T}iomas i'ayne
Thomas Anderson
Thomond lt. 0'lir i en
Mrs . Guy L . Coffin
C�ustav llxelrod , �ttorncy
llenry Lon�*hchn
I�ltig}i 0' l�ane
Wes Ohman
I)on A1a�nuson
Ilenry hluchle��;cr
Charles �nclrcen
Paul llarvey
David /lnclrews
A�1r. t; 1�1rs . l:a �1orsc
Mr. Cohen suggestecl the matter of a 10-ctay peri ocl to C i.1.c an
aj�peal be carried over until the ncxt meet in�* hecause only tl�i•c�r�
members were pxesent .
11rt1iur '1'ieso arrived.
.lames Vo i�t arri v�cl.
EXHIBIT "A"
. . i ��/.�.�/�,�,
n����•� � ��,� ►v�� . i �,
�•
C;ase No . 55 420 Summit !lvenuc (Un_ivcr�i.ty Cl.ul�, 'I'I�am��n�l t�' Itiri �•�� 1
'1'}iomo�icl 0'13rien appealed a letter of the 13uilclin� lle��cirtniunt �i;it ���l
,Iuly 22 , 1 J(iJ enumerating �orrcct.ions nccdcct to br i u�� �1 ��1� �;umm i t
�vcJiuc into compl ianc:c with t}ic exit rcuuire�ncrits of tlic (: i tv ��I-
St . Paul . Tn the appl icat ion for apPcal hy t hc Iin i vc�rti i t y c:! ��I► ,
clatecl Septernber 30 , 19G9 ancl accomPany i nr, "Spec i I' i c,L t i o►iti I���r tit ri i r
way Lnclosures" by Robert F. Ackermann t; Asso� . , Inc . ctui�ecl tie��tc�u�
l�cr 26, 196J , an outline of repairs to l�c rllftcl� to hrin,.� tl��� t�i� il�l ; i„�
at 420 Swnm it /lvenue i nto compl iancc wi th tlic� c�x i t rectu i rc�mc�n t �;
was presentecl.
Mr. Cohen moved that the appeal be �ontinuecl inclefinitely in c�rclrr
that Mr. 0'Brien may request a rehearin�; ol' the matter iI' I� iti �,ru
posal cannot satisfactorily conform �ait}i l;iai.lcling Co�lc stai��l;ir�l5
aftcr the proposal is examinecl l:�y thc 13ui1�lin�; Ucpartmcnt .
/lycs : Cohen, Peake , Rehnberfi, 'I'ieso, Voi�;t . Naycs : nc�uc .
/11�stcntions : nonc . Motion carriecl £ive (S) to �cro (f) ) .
(_�itic No . 56 1236 llubbarcl Ave , (Mr. F, Mrs . (;uy 1, . c:o L f i n ►
Mr . C:ohen movecl tliat the f il ing i ce for tl�e appeal fai• I 3.;c► Ilu l�l�ri r�l
/lvcnue be waivecl.
nycs : Cohen, Peake, Relinberg, Tieso, Voigt . Nayes : nonc
l�bstentions : none . Motion carriccl fivc (S) to zero (() ) .
Gale Rehnberg left .
(;ustav Axelroci, Attorney, Henry Lonfibehn ancl llu�;h t)' Kane spokc
on behalf of Mr . anci Mrs . Coffi.n, appealing a "Noticc of c:ori�lcmn;, i ic�n"
a:�t�a September 23 , 1969, an "Ordcr to Vacate" cl:ate�l Scptcml�cr l:ti ,
I 9b9 ancl a 13ureau of IIealth letter a�tea Septemhcr 23 , I !1(�'.1 :i I 1
relating to 1236 1lubbard.
Mr. Cohen moved that the matter Ue cont inued ior onc ycrii• :in�l I���
rehearci at such time on the conclition that tlic followin�.; i temti
itemized in the "Notice of Condemriation" clatecl Septeml�er -':� , I !�e�!�,
be compliecl with in 30 days and th�it this be ver i f i ccl l�y an i n
spection by a member of the Board or hy the lixc:�utivc Sccrctary :
Item #2 - repair the light fixture in thc kitchcn
Item �3 - remove boxes and all unnecessary artic:les froin
all rooms .
Item N10 - remove the boxes from the fro�it porch
�ycs : Cohen, 1' icso , 1��oigt . N�iyes : }�eake. Ahstentions : nonc� .
�lotion carricd tliree (3) to one (1) .
�
t n/.�.�/���►
1-
Mcct i iii� N�, . I ��
Case No . 57 186J La(yrosse (llenry Pltichlet*�cr)
Mr , Cohen moveci t}iat t}le filirifi fec for the appcal I'or I �4��!1
I.a(;rossc l�c waivecl,
nyes : Co}icn, Peake, '1'ieso , Vo i gt . Nayes : nonc. /11�s Cen t. i c�n� : i�vii�• ,
i�totioli carriecl four (4) to zero ((l) .
I�tr . Muehlegger appealed a notice oF the Burcau o{ lle<<l t l� �l�it c�t.l
�ugust 28 , 1J69 whi.ch itemizecl certa:iri repa:irs to he m;�cie �it
186J 1.aCrosse . �
Mr . Cohen moved that the followi.ng items , 1 istecl as nc�:�lc�l r����;� i r�;
iii t}le Bureau of Flealth letter clatecl Jlugust 28 , 1 9ti<.J I�e w;� i v�•cl I�ui•
1�3GJ LaCrosse unt� l st�ch time as 1869 I,aCrossc bc sol�l or thc
ownership transferrecl, at w}i icli t ime al l. Ilous in�; an�l l;ti i 1�l i u��, ('c��l��
staiiclards be conformecl with:
l . Install at lcast one aclditional clectric out.lc�t
in the kit�}icri.
2 . Install at least one aclditi.onal elcctri.c �utlet in
thc clining room.
3 . Install at least one additional electri.cal c>utlet i >>
the northwest beclroom.
Aycs : Cohen, Peake , 'fieso , Voigt . Naycs : nonc . Abstctiti ��iis :
nonc . Motion carried four (4) to zero (0) .
(:asc No . ;� 3G8-370-372 Goodhue (Charlcs /lnclrecn)
1'}ic f.iling £ee was not waived for the appeal for 36t�- 37O-:;7?
Goocl}�uc .
Mr . /lndreen appealed notices of thc 13ureau or Ilcaltl� clatecl �;c�>t��m-
bcr J, 1969 , October 7 , 1969 ancl Octol�er 8 , i�1(i� l istin�; items wl� i �:l�
clo not mect I-lousing Co�lc stanclard5 at 3G8 (;oocllitic aiicl a i ti�� in�• I >>�I i ,�a�
an "Order to Vacate" . In aaa� t��,�, }ie also appealccl a iet.t��r• �I,�t ���l
Septeml�cr 16 , 1969 concerning :items not meet inr; Ilousin�; (:u�lc st au
clards at 370 Goodhue and a lettc�r clated Septemher I 5 , 1 S�ci!� ���>>>��cr•u i n��
items iiot meeting �Iotising Code sta�iclarcls at 372 (�oodhtie .
Mr . Cohen moved th�it tenants bc allowecl to movc i.rito 3c>t� (�c�o�lliu�•
November 1 , 1969 , as arrangecl, on the concl i t i on thcit tl�c I(e;� I t I�
1)epartment verify tlie improvements that Nir. /lnclrc�en str�ic�l hc I�;a�l
maae at 368 C�oodhuc . lle furthcr movccl that Mr . llnclrccn �:ul,m i t , ;i t.
thc next re�,ular mcetin�; , an estimatc of cost t�� inst�► ! l ;a �,huwe:r•
- 3 -
r � n/.','/i���
� ��1cc t i n�� N�, . � �,
aricl sink 111 thc batliroo�� at 368 Gooclhuc . 11c I�i na I 1 y inuvc�l 1 I�;i l t li��
matter of tlie appeal�� I�or 370-372 (:�oocl}iue he coiitir�ue�i i.ir�t i I I I�c�
next regular mectin�.
/�yes : Cohen , Pc��zke , '1'icso, Voi�t . Naycs : noric . Ah�>t ui�t ioiiti :
nonc . :�lotion carriecl four (4j to zcro(0) .
C.�se No . 59 ]. 1 38 Duluth St . (Pau1 llarvcy t; �nclrews l:�>>,s t , l;u , )
I'aul liarvey appcaled a letter of t}ie 13t,iilcling Uepartment �lrit���l.
Octobcr 10 , 19GJ, stating that a 13uilding 1'crmit coulcl not l�c
issueci for the proposecl addi tio�i to t}ie house at 1 1 3K I►u l �it li �t rc���t
because of the two foot inclicated sicleyarcl .
�tr . (:olien movea tFiat Section 33 . 04 suhsect i on 3 oC the tit . 1';i�� l
I.egis.lative Cocle stating in part :
"a. l�or a clwell ing hereafter erectecl Oile ( 1 ) ur t�vo ( � )
stories in hei�ht , witli or without attir , on ;1 lot
less tha.ri a forty (40) foot frotitagc , thc: s icic y;ir�l
spac� shal l not be less thau three ( .�) feet . " uii�l
"b. I�or a ciwclling liercafter erecteci one (l ) or two � ..' �
stories in heiglit wi t}i or wit}iout att i.�: , ori a l��t c�l'
£orty (40) foot or rnore lrontagc, thc s i cic y:ir�t �;1►;«�c
shall not be less than t-our (4) Cect , "
be waivecl to allow construction of the proposecl acl�l i t i c�n to t h�
housc at 1138 llu:luth street providecl that thc owner ol� thc :<<Ijn�•c�nt
property , 1132 I)ult�t}i Street , statc in writing that tl�crc� wuul�l I���
no oi�je��tion to such an addition.
l�yes : Cohen , 'Tieso , Voi�t . Nayc�s : nonc . :lhstent i.ons ; I'c<<kc�
Mot.ion carried three (3) to zero (0) wit)i one (] ) ,il�stclit ic�i� .
C:ase No . 63 1026 Pleasant Ave_ (Eclwarcl �tilorse)
Liclwarci Morsc; appealeci a letter of the Builclin�; J1ep�irtmellt �I.ite�l
October ].5 , 1. 969 stating t}iat a 13uilcling 1'crrnit c�ulcl i�ot. l��•
issuecl £or a proposecl enclosure or porch at 10"ZG Pleasant Av�� .
N1r . Voigt movecl that 5ection 34 . 01 subsections 2 , 3 , ancl 4 re���� i r• i ,�}�
tll�t tlie �;1ass area of� w.indows sliall i�c not le�ss than 1 / I (► uf tl���
floor arca �f tlie rc�orn; tl�at r_�t lc�titit 5O°; �f tlii5 ;irca hc o�,cr;,
t in�; sas}1 1�or vent i lat ion ��urposes ; an�l that wiriclows sh�s l l ►i��t
ope�i onto a filass ericlosc�t porcl� as th��t is �onsicicrccl a �;c�,;�rr�t�•
rooin, l�c wai.vccl for ) UZ(i 1'lcasant /1vc� . to all����� cor��truct i ��r� �, i
- 4 -
, . � � I (l�:'.'.�(�'l
� n1crct i n�� N�, . 1 !i
J ' �
the proposecl addition of ari enclosur. e or porch r�t lO2h I'l.�r,is;i>> r
llvcnuc .
llyes : Cohcn, Pcake , '1'ieso, Vo:i.�;t . Naycs : nonc , /11�titunt ions :
rloiic . �lotion carri.ed four (4) to zero (()j ,
'1'he minutes bf_ the meetin�; of October � , 1 �(i�) wcre approv�•�1 ;�s
,��.��i�a .
There being no further business , the mcetin� was acljourli�cl at
4 : 30 p .m.
�� �
'1'liomas bV. Ancicrson
lixecutive Secretary
- J '
IiUPLICATE TO PRINTER ���c�d..l�
CITY OF ST. PAUL FoE Nca NO.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONER DATF
RESOLVED, thafi the Council hereby ratifies and approves the
action of the Baard of Appeals and Review for the housing, Building
and Fire Prevention Codes pertaining to the following listed pro-
perties as shown by the official minutes of said Board of Appeals
at the meeting af October 22 , 1969, a copy of which, marked EXHIBIT
"A" is attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference.
Case No. Address
56 1236 Hubbard (Mr. � Mrs . Guy L. Coffin)
59 1138 Duluth Street (Paul Harvey)
63 1026 Pleasant Ave. (Bdward Morse)
�
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Counci] 19_
Yeas Nays
Carlson
Dalglish .-�� Approved 19—
Meredith Tn Favor
Peterson
Sprafka Z'` Mayor
A gainst
Tedesco
Mr. President, Byrne
O