Loading...
251708 / OR161NAL TO CITY CL[RK � ����o� CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCa � ° OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK F�E NO. �COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONE p,TE RE��S�VED, �h�t Arlington Prop�rties be and hereby is granted a permi� to install a 69-car parking lot �o be used in aon�unation with a �+6-unit apsrtmer�t build3.ng on property loceated on �he northweat aorner of North Iiazel Str�et and Meehanic Av�nu�, more partiatalarly des�ribed as followes Ea�terly 11 fee� of�ot 22, ex�ept the North ].6 f'�et; I►ot �3, eaeept the North 16 feet of �he West � feet; all of Lot� 2�, 25, 26, �7, 28, �9 ar�d 34; the £�aste�ly �88.28 f��t of th� a11�y �to be vacaat�d�; a11 in Bloek 5, �Iazel Park Pls� B; _ al]. in accordan�e wi�h revised pl�ns; aub�eat to the aondi�ion that said appli�ar�t-per�i�tee, and it� aueeesso�a �.nd assigns, _ sha11 mal�e du� complian¢e with aTl applieable provi�3.ons af y munieipal ordin�.r�ees, s�a�e �tatutes and rule� and regula�ior�s c � o � of public au�horities having �ognizanee . w • c > o � o Qa.. o K V _ �: � y Q � � DEG 2 9 19?0 COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Counci� 19— Yeas Naye But�er n�G 2 9 1�7� Carlson � 19— Levine n Favor Meredith � Sprafka aqor A gainst Tedesco Mr. President, McCarty ,JAN � 1g7� PUBLISHED �� ,� A 2����g � . BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 December l, 1970 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Dear Sir: This is written in response to the application of Arlington Properties for a permit to install a 69-car parking lot to be used in conjunction with a 46-unit apartment building on property located on the northwest corner of North Hazel Street and Mechanic Avenue, and noted in detail by the legal description on file. This matter was heard at the November 5, 1970, Board of Zoning meeting. The staff report was given which noted that the revised plan meets minimal design standards. The Traffic Engineer had reviewed the plan and recommended approval on the condition that the adjoining alley not be used for access. The staff pointed out on the plan where the a11ey adjoins the proposed parking lot, and recommended that the Traffic Engineer's condition also be a condition of favorable action by the Zoning Board. Mr. Richard Sagstetter, the applicant, agreed to the condition. In answer to a question regarding the possibility of auto headlights flashing in neighborhood windows, Mr. Sagstetter said that garages would block this. Several residents of the neighborhood appeared in opposition to the proposal, stating that it would cause traffic problems and be a hazard to children in the neighborhood. Three letters in opposition to apartment development in this neighborhood were read which noted: 1) potential traffic problems such as congestion, hazard to children, and on-street parking despite parking lots; and 2) that apartments are a threat to the character of the neighborhood. -1- ! + °.��.+:'`I � ��f - �� , .� � � Mr. Harry E. Marshall (continued) December 1, 1970 In discussing this matter it was pointed out that the site is zoned for apartment development and that the applicant's plan has provided for 12-1 parking, and meets basic design standards. It was noted that some type of parking lot musttbe provided for the proposed apartments. The Board further discussed possible problems of traffic flow and congestion caused by the apartment development. Subsequently, the Board heard a motion to recommend approval, subject to staff recommendations and also subject to the condition that the City Traffic Superintendent of the Bureau of Police be consulted in regard to the traffic problems. The motion was seconded and carried by a 3-1 vote. Subsequent to this meeting the parking 1ot plan has been revised to provide a bumper-height fence between the parking lot and the alley. The City Traffic Superintendent has investigated the site and can see no objection to the development from a traffic safety standpoint. Very truly yours, ;,��:.��-�. � �����'�-�t , � PETER J. MAIETTA Secretary, Board of Zoning PJM:ga f PLR Z. F. �k7054 -2- Horry E. Manhall ��TY � Albert B. Olsoo � City Clerk and ,�e�' '�; Council Recorder (�ommissioner of Registrattion o � y � . _ d -•�� ,y ws -- m ^c OFPICE OP THE CITY CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS 186 City Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 5510� • AuguSt 27, 1970 Zoning Board Commerce Buildin� St. Paul Gentlemen: The City Council referred to the Zoning Board far recommendation the attached application of Arlin�ton Properties, st W. Arlington, for permit to install and operate a 69-car parkin l�ot in conjunction with �+6-unit apartment development at the sca�st corner of Hazel and Mechanic, on the property more fully described in the application. Very truly yours, ,n f �,,:.� - �... . � City,C erk (,;� ng � ,��,`'� �`�� �� ._ . � ��` . �, o � � a � � - ��� e � ���� �� ���� -�.�-- � . �, �` ;,,�" �' - � sk - � �� � � �� � �� � � • ' City of Saint Paui, Minnesota ' ` APPLICATION FOA SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERadIT (Please print or type) TO Tf� FBDNORABLE 11�AYOR AND CITY COUNCIL 96 the City Clerk City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Application is hereby made to remodel or reconstruct an existing instali and operate a new (cross one out) � FILLING STATION No. of islands and pumps : No. of tanks aad capacity: � PARKING LOT for (customers) (�e�p��e) (p�3,�•�) (�.�••us@) (�,�,�M,} (indicate type) Capacity of parking Lot :_� �___��Z S To be used in connection with: � [j �f/�'�"�� �77'; � MISCEI.I�ANEOUS: (indicate type such as Drive-in Refreahment Stand, Used Car Lot, Dry Cleaning�ck-up 3tatioa, Ice Vendor, etc.) Capacity o parking area: /V _� *Location : „. �. C �, ,,c, N rr rc. �1 s�f � �. 6.. dt /'c•i �c N� iti� c . gal Description : Lot j"r LY rl � o � �,�,,, Block s— Addition /4�c.a. R.2 r k��1 ,�a N p ft'�c. /�,�J�c �.0 Applicant's Name . f72. t �,c�c_Z-c..-� /✓.z� A �,L 4 T � Home or Office Address: � y � , �q,� �„r %�- C- T c. rv Phone Number , y � � � � S� � � FOK/BY TI� APPLI , p� �� , (Si t �(d--t�� Address : �vG,3 !/�9�/ /.� G''Z � t'4' Phoae No.: � p � � � 5...� v Wl�en compteted: file three copies of this application form and three prints of the preliminary lay-out plans of the proposed facility with the City Clerk, ftoom 386, City Hall and Court House, Safnt Paul, Minnesota Z-3 6/11/56 *EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St. 2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St. ������ ���.E �� BOA'RD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION November 5, 1970 �'13t i7a� ��41 • -Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 p_assed August 22, 1922, as amended to April 6, 1970. 7054 :. . •,'';�L1c:111'i"; r�q�-9f�' , Arlington Properties .., C,��^,�SIFICA'I'ION . t._.t Amendment 0 Appeal Q ?ermit � �ther X-960 _,_��,,�J� Install a 69-car parking lot to be used in '' ' conjunction with a 46-unit apartment building 4. i,'iCAT1011 ; Northwest corner of North Hazel Street and Mechanic Avenue 5. ',E�AL D�SCRIPTION : See file �, P`<�S1:fJT Z01dINGt Light Industry 7 ,. �';1't;�UANT '1'� 7onin�? Code Chapters 60 Section: ,23 F�ara�;raph: 4, 2 '3 . ;'ft�E'I' INVESiIGATION f> REPORT: D3te: 10/29/70 3y: ATB A. HISTORY: A part of the alley in this block was recently vacated and is part of this property. B. AREA ZONING: The south one-half of this block is zoned Light Industry. The area to the north is zoned Heavy Industry and the area to the south is zoned "A" Residence. The area to the east is zoned Heavy Industry. C. DESIGN STANDARDS: The revised plan meets the basic design standards. Bumper-height fences ara now indicated to prohibit alley access. U. FRONTAGE AND AREA: The site fronts along Meclianic Avenue a distance oi 328.2 feet and alon�; Hazel Street a distance of 144 feet, resulting in an area of approximately 46,257 square feet. The building has an area of 14,030 square feet with coverage oi 30.33%. The area per unit is 1,006 square feet. E. TRAFFIC ENGINEER: The Traffic Engineer has reviewed the plan and recommended approval with the provision that the alley is not used for access. F. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is slightly below the grade of adjoining streets and properties. There are indications that the site has been filled in the past. C. AREA CONDITIONS: Ta the north are two new apartments and two single-family residences. To the east is a large warehausing complex. Soutli and ea9t are �i�if;le-la�nily residences. The surroundin� streets are surfaced. 9 , BOARD ACTION: To Recommend � Approval � Denial Council Letter Dated: Moved by . McPartlin Yeas Nays 12/1/70 Gadler X Date of Hearin Seconded by: Maietta Gauger � x Maietta 12/3/70 Secretary's remarks: Mansur x Ames - Ch. ���inci l Action X McPr�rtltn (A I I . ) /��iki r�s (/1 I 1 . ) U:,I r• It<<Lrick (A1C.) ---- -- ---- - , , . , .... . . . _. .._.____, � _ . � , f • • (� , - ----_. _ _ _ _ � v -- --�-_ � � _ � � � , � ��. �y�� , ; � , , ; - ; - : -_-_w�_._� . ; a ; ' • ' � � — �'� � - �'=,/�:i� ' � �, ; �,� �� ; :; ;�-'� � � � � � .�'. �,� '�� •,- � � �-._ . � :• .. � � � t � �,. :�/ .,... ..5 . . ' _ ! i. ;`_ � _!. : �i __' ' — 1 T ` � � i � � �, '`'�� � ,,' K� � ,, , ' �� , � T � 1 ✓, t ( � �, , ;'�- , ,� � � � � ' � � ; � � 1 j ' � : �, ., - "^ . ��',� / �N�D U ST � �, �_, ,;�� , F�;, , � F ' rI ;�. i , 1 " : � , Y � ,. � , ' .,. �' � � . � � _:.t.. `,_.L F�.1.....+.,.., .�_._ _.' ..�__�., _.,...�'..._I_..n�.._i_..._!.!.±_�; � I � � / � ' �' �. � � � � �� ������� ���. � , i � - � ` ' —� ..._. � , �� r.-_...._.._ �17` ,�_.... _,... � � .�,_._.,_....�.. ... � � � ' � r � i a � � , � ; � � � i ! � 7i ��� �,..� ; _ 4 .i, I � ' , i � + ; � ., � ,� � '. �\ , , :� , �OI � � �, � ��, � � , � � �17 � � i � � 1 � � I ' ;, ' ;� � � . • ' - - � � �I ._ :_ . . � I,r, I + � i � . " ' I � I� ` ,�. � .. . �. .. � � �r �.. .�. �.. � .� I�. . � � J '. : `. � �•�, •'v rC / � f�✓ T ! � / %/�/'�O t,/ f `^ -' • r f'. , �I ' '�, ..�J.�� � i (" ,� • i�� , , `- � '� ✓� ;�� ; i . � � T ; ',,� ,�, :' , �_� �,.� i ' r" �.. � .� � , � � ....r►._...._.�.._........�,. � .�.�.�i u. .i....rw.....r��'_..._.�i. �i � � � , •'' ' � ��► i t � � �r�r�► I� ._ . . �- : I � . _�___._.__,_.....� N V'�. ; . ,-- --*�-�--� , ...-.r.-__..,.�..� _ . ._ ..�. � � � ; � i .- � ,� t ��� � � � � , . �.'_,�.., , i 1 ; � ; 1 � � :Q� , (_.�,i- � .\ ; ., .._.i.' i i� � � � � �O � O� . ��i ��� � l I ' I�/I ' ,�_� \.. . _ �� I � ��.� 'i . � rl�� � , � ' � p ' ' � ' � ' ; � � �. � I—_( ; ! � � ; ' ' , �'�i��' ��,,+ !' C �. � y t� �J � i - �_ _ --�----=i�. t_1 r' i i _i_ ;_ _. � ._. ! � 1_ , y �__ � �� � � � � . '�! � -�;��-r-���O �--� i j , �� ; � � . , ; ' �� � - � �t � ; ` � � � i • � � , i � � � % , ` � �_ ti�-. �. ..r�j � ir��I(�� � � ( � � � � ' , � � �� W r.. ..�.� .,� '``J ��.' ;J .� ���\.J � �ti.J�V'. (� i� � :I � ,�, �,;��; i; ' , -� � �- � � Z "� '� '� � � '� � ; � N _-_...., _ �-�.. ������--_.._.___ � �.._..L._.w...�....:_.�..._._ .. .. __ � , , ,_ __. ..------_ .._-----. a i � � ' �J� ___--_ �_ ._ ._ _ ��__.'.—�_-�.. ,..�_,. � _, -- __._ � ,` , ' ; i � �� � _.� �J O, i � ! ' � ; ' �. ., �,' 1. ! : 'i_,., �' �1� � ! � � ��i ; r�� . � �, �t � ,� � r C'. �� 7 � , f,s � ,_-, � � l_ 1 ��- �1 �► , ; �� � , _� . �S �DE�N�E � ; ; � t i � -_ d `-- , i , 1► ; ; �_ �a 1 �' � , �, � ' � � � '� ' � j i ! j ' � I ' � s'� � `� � i � � � ��/ � I � , ' ' , , ' �'� � • ���, #o�, �._._.� _ � �'��'�'�`�' G;c ,�' , �c=�;t. � � ; '' � i��` � Lq CROSS E w. . ._......___a..�:. � ♦, .._�--- ...�.� � 4 vE \ r` , f � - — r, , � : i � �' , '"_"�.......� I,�,r„�.� ' . —�— �.,�,� � ; , i , �; � rr. i� � � � ',, ,:��! lU'; ; i0�0��Qlt ��� ' � �.�, � �,'� + , �' � ' ' � ' � � ` i I � � �i�"�� '� �. � � � , __; �� ' I � ! � ; ' � ' ! i I ' i ; � � ��' I 1 i . � I� i � 1 � �k ����� � I� �'�1'J � i � i � � I . � '. � 1 , -- . i. 1 _. t ..__� [__.�_ t�' i— -I _` 1__ � , � �'', i � i � • . . . . . �. , i. _n � . . . . . •. • � � � . i . __i i. 1 r . 1 , ' � � r � I � 1 I ! 1I_f'�_.(l./`-�1 V��� Arlint;ton Properties LFGCRlp , ��l�h`�-►u��; Install a 69-car parking lot to be used in conjunctio�-AND USf�:� PRESENI' ZONING : With a 46-unit apartment bldg. � -ONL-" FAMILY Light Industry �O` -�-WO ����L�r PETITION SIGNERS� � p� THRCE FnMiLY . FOUR FAMILY FILE No, 7MULT1- FAMILY 7054 � • n COMMERCI�tI� . n n INDUSTRIAL , No2Y�� -- . St. Puul Plannin� Qo�rd , Dato �o�2s��o � PROPERTY IN AUESTION MIN�'TES OF THE PtTBILZC HEAR�NG BL'�C3RE THE BQARD QF ZONING on Thursday, Novemd�er 5, 1970, at 2:00 P,Mo PRESENT: Messrs, Ames, Gadler, McFazt�.in, and Maietta of the �oard, and Dro Aeid�n, Messrs. Rosetter� Ryan, and Sorenson, Mr.s4 �rantzen, and Mi�s 5perr of the staffd , AFtLINGTOH PROP�R`TZES: An app�.ication for a permit to install a 69-cer parking loC �o be usecl in conjunctican with a 4�6Aunit apartment building on property located on the northwest c�z-ner af North Hazel Street and M�cha�aic Avenue< i�i�, RoseCter summari2ed the st�ff repor�, a pnrt mf Che file, noting that the revised pl.an meets mi�aimai design standaxds. �'he Tra�fic Engineer has reviewed th� pYan rand recosraner�ded a�provtal wi�h the provision that the alley is not used for access. Tt�e st€�ff would recc�nmend a bumper-high fence to deny such accesso Mro Richard Sagstetter, re�,res�n�ing the application, noted he is in full accord with the staf� reco�e�xd�t3.ons and will suhmit new plans to go along with these changes. � Tn opposition to the permit was Ma:. Arlen Johnsen, 1898 Mechanic Avenue, who noted that m traf:f�c problem would aris� from this pmrking lote He safd thls is a dead-end area which ha� only two entrances to it; and s�id that Hazel Street isn`t wide enough to £acilitate two cars passing at the same timea He noted th�t the number of cars sco the number af children would be very high. Mra Ames pointed out that th� are� in question is zoned £or multiple residenceso Parking is at a 1�-1 ratio a� present, and he noted the applicant f� me�ting the minimum requfrements, a�d �he Tr�€fic Engineer concurs with �he revised plans. Mre Sagstet�er noted that Hazel StrEet is a m�jor �rterial that is exCremely widea He s�id �hat perhaps they are �oing to carry this street across tih� railrosd tracksa Concerning th� wid�h of Hazel Street, Mr> Maietta said it is no differ�nt from �he rest of ehe stree�s i� S�< Paul, P�Ir� Ames questianed :atze�her. W�•i�e BeBr Avenca� as accessible frnm this pointe He was told that cars wonld ha��re to go to Van Dyke Street in order eo get to Whi�e Bear Avenueo �'hree letters were submitted i� oppa�itior� ta this �pplicationo fihey havQ been made part of the file, Mr< McPartlin �ointed out th�� there �t�s to be some type of part�:�.�.ng �ot, ..7 r . . . , � . ARI�TNGT�N PROPERTIES (LI,/5/�10, �Can.�inued': Mre Malcolm Faus�, L841 M�chs�ic Avenue, noCe� �h�t of th� 40�-some children in th$ neig�abo�:hood, 11 are his; �ae is eonce�ned wieh t��ffic prablems. He noted he is in favor of pe�nii�*�ing the �yarking iot applicationy but fesrs that cars owned by �he apar�n�nt tenants will stii11 be left on the street, Zt is s d�ad-end street, and pe�p2e can't be forced to use the parkfng Iot. Upon a question by Mro Gadler regard•Lng he�dlights fla�hing in neighborhood windows, Mr. Sagste�t��r noted barages wi11 block zh3.so He cor��nted ti�at he feeis garage� are preferabl� t�' opei�-space p�rking. Mrn McPartlin maved for �a�ptoval of the permit, sub3ect to staff secammendations on the revised pla�as and tha� Captain Anderson snggeai: some solution to the txafffc problerue The m�otiom ca�� �e�onded by i�fra �!aie���, �nd ca�ried wieh �ir, Gadler voting in opposition, a3.nce he had no�t finished a�king �Z1 hfs qaes tions on Che utat�er o Submitt�d by: Paul �, Rase�ter Rob�r� Lo Ames, Chairman _gw • City Glerk . � CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 November 20, 1970 File X960, Page You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the CiCy of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on December 3, 1970 on the application of Arlingtan Properties for a penuit to install a 69-car parkiag lot to be used in conjunctfon wfth a 46•uni� apartment building on the property described as follaws: Easterly 11 feet of Lot 22, except the North 16 feet; Lot 23, except the North 16 feet of the West 9 feet; all of Lots 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29 and 30; the Easterly 288.28 feet of the alley (to be vacated); a12 in Block 5, Iiazel Park plat "B". The property is located on the Northwest corner of North Ha�el Street and Mechanic Aveaue. For further information, contact the Planning Board, Room 1010 Ccamerce Buildfng, or telephone 223-4151. This notice of a public hearing has been sent out frosa the Department of Fiaaace in compliance with the City Charter. ROSALIE I,. BUTLEIt Co�nenissioner of Finance O f ` � ' � City of Saint Paul, �innesota ' /� APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT (Please print or type) /��� O !'oa TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL 96 the City Clerk City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Application is hereb made to remodel or reconstruct an existing y install and operate a new �cross one out) Q FILLING STATION No. of islands and pumps : No. of tanks and capacity: - � � PAFtKING LOT for (customers) f�s) ( ) (��se) (ebire�}� (indicate type)� Capacity of parking lot �, � p �2 S' To be used in connection with: u (p v��T � i4'T � MISCELLANEOUS: (indicate type such as Drive-in Refreshment Stand, Used Car Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 3tation, Ice Vendor, etc.) Capacity of parking area: (e 9 ' *Locat ion : S•��. � v z N��-�. �L F¢ Z ,c L dC /� �G!-/��V/ c. . Legal Description : Lot�LY !/ � p F ��, Block S" Addition l�c.c, 22 r�+•ti .3 b N'�f��L /��9�'c�•C Applicant's Name . 1�2 �/ivG-TesN� /'��oP /'JLc�7' C3 Home or Office Address: � y � , �Z L� wG- Tu /ti Phone Number . � $ �, 4 � �—� FOR/BY TI� APPLI , �'�G Sigri t e (date Address : �DG 3 !/�9� � r/2 � �' Phone No.: L� p G3 � cl S--�e 7o I When completed: file three copies of this application gorm and three prints of the preliminarq lay-out plans of the proposed facility with the City Clerk, ftoom 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota Z-3 6/11/56 *EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St. 2. South side of Main St, betw�en First and Second St. r , , � . �,� , :.�, ; . _ ,, � . ,,. ' � i - �. � ' �s' � � � � ...` , � b '� � � � . a - . ... . - •_.... �� . � .... . � ., .r , e• ... ;��� ' � � � ••' :,� � � � � � x' i V ��' ' ~ �,�t . :. � �: I . �I � � '�� ~. w ! \. • ♦ h. O��iw i • oi�.:.-_-:�`r- �1 ''•''t�.. • � � o �--- '... i � ' ',' • •'� ' , '• . � '�� 1� . � _. _ '�. x �j• � � ` • � • (�. �C� � � h� � Q � . � ? �� . � � � � P � � ; �• 1 ` � _ ' �_ � r � � � � A ;� � ti, n; • � � �n tr; _ Z �► ' . � , � � ` �� _ � o ` � A . ' . � ^ } .. o � J ,� °• ,� � _ _� , � <: � �� � � t ,• f.., ; p r•,� � �, � � � � � �, C ''' _ �, ` • t.� " _ � � � � �1 ` ; I1; " ,. ,� � � � � � i � .� � t� � -�� - , w � � ; � � _ � _ ; . �� � ��� �° � . � . . ' �O � � � ��: ; ; .: . � , ti •.., _ � , . 'A � ' � . , � ti Q • . •�t � � ° �� � (� ° � C • - �� �° - - ; . � � � 4 ' i ' ' � � � r; y` . � ; b �a "� h �., . � � �, . o . :v � � . w ; . �, . �' � � � � �� . �. ��. � = i ' . i � � ., � .,� ; _ __ . ,� � , � _ ' . 1 � �.,. �O' `� ���" , Z � � � a 4 rs 4 ' "' b ' . . • u/ -c-• � v� � ; • � : s r-, �r ' . A - � . "u -- �-� , � � � 1 C`=- .... � � ` {.: � � � . - Y` ^� a r• ' t�' � � G',, � � +' . � rp (-t� f . � �, "'� i� � � •/ I ��. � C �� . ,�� � � ��.. .CJ ._ � .� . ^ , �� +.� `�. � ��• .. � � . , . • \ O t � � � o �+ �.q�'�"L � �.S' .T - . ,. � . . . o - , _