247662 � � �
ORIGINAL TO CITY CL6RK '' � �Ll���J
CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCi� � i �`�
� OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE NO.
.
C NC RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE � �� DATF
RES4L�T'ED, That Robert and Janet I{uhlman be and hereby
are permitted to �onatruet a 3-ur�it addition to an ex3.sting
10-unit motel on p�oper�ty located on the south �ide of I-9�#
between t�hite B�ar Avenue and Kenr�ard �tre�,t, and deseribed
ass
��� xes� �33.08 feet of the east 937•3�
fe�t of that part of the sou�heast quart�r
of Seetion 3�+, �ownship �9 North, Rar�ge 22
W�s�, lying south of Trunk Higk�w�.y 12 as
now loeated and eetabli�h�d, exeept the
south 658 feet thereof; also exeept the
west 34 feet of the ea�t 229 feet thereof;
being R�giste�ed Land, Certifiaate of
�itle �o. 1�7827; which lies northeasterly
of a 1iMe rur� parallel wi�� and dis��nt
30 fe�t �outhwesterly of the following
des�ribed lines Beginnin� at a point on �he
ess-t line of' �aid 3ection 3'�, distant 510
feet north of �h�: �outheast corner �hereof;
th�nc� r�n westerly at an angle of 90 degrees
�. �rith �aid east s�ction li�e for 115.7� feet;
�hence deflect to the right at an angle of
� ��.00 degrees for 3�9.93 feet; t�ience deflect
� to �Y�e left on a �0.44 c3�gree curve (delta
an le 3�+ degr�e� - 5�# miMUtes 22 seconds) for
.� • �; 17�.53 feet; �hence on tangent to said cur�e
� - fo� ��1.29 feet and there ter�ninating;
� con�a3.ning 0.61 acre, more or less;
� �
a,
� '� a1:1 in accordanee with pl�.ns attaahed hereto; be it
�
��
Q
� �
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Nays
Carlson
Dalglish Approver� 19`_
Meredith _ T� Favor
Peterson
Sprafka ����9 Mayor
A gainst
Tedesco
Mr. President, Byrne
O
- . . , ���76�2
ORt61NAL TO CITY CLHRK '
. CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO.
� OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONER DATF
��I� RES4LVED, that upon and pursuant �o �he pertinen�
appeal, tznder the Zoning �ode, bq Robert and Janet Kuhlman,
owners of the aub�ec� real �state, situate in the �it� of Saint
Paul, and descr�ibed above, that the provisions of �a.id Zoning
�ode hereb� are determined and va�ied aa and to the ea�en�
necessary therefor and the setbaek requirement for said premises
is hereby r�laxed to 35 feet so as to aceommodat� an extension
of an exis�ing motel in "An Residenc� �istrict, sub�ect to �he
conditia�n that said appel.lants,and �heir suec�ssor� and assig��,
o�herwise, sha11 make dc�e eompliance with all applieable provi�ions
of m�ni�ipal ordinances, state sta�utes and rules �nd re�ula�ions
of public authorities ha.ving cagniza.nee.
F E B 2 7 19�0
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Nays F�� 2 7 1970
Carlson
Dalglish Approved 19�_
e
Meredith Tn Favor � ��./ �%',
I,'ete�se��.
Sprafka C �6tin9 Mayor
Tedesco A Sainst
���E PUBLISHED MAR � 1�7A
Mr. Vie� Pre�ideat (Peteraon)
�
, ' .
. ` ���f���
. BO�ARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
�1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
February 11, 1970
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
City Clerk
Room 386 City Hall
Dear Mr. Marshall:
This is written in response to the appeal of Robert and Janet
Kuhlman to allow the expansion of an existing motel in "A" Residence
district and to relax the setback requirement to 35 feet. The
property is located on the south side of I-94 between White Bear
Avenue and Kennard Street. See attached sheet for full legal
description.
This matter was considered at the January 22, 1970, Board of
Zoning meeting. The staff reported that the Zoning Code permits the
City Council to allow a motel use in "A" Residence where it is
adjacent to a trunk highway. The established setback is 50 feet
for the property and the appeal requests a 15-foot or 30 percent
variance. It was noted that the original motel was approved by
Council in 1955 and a previous expansion was allowed in 1968.
Subsequently, it was the finding of the Board of Zoning that
the requests are reasonable and the Board, therefore, recommends
approval of the appeal by a 5-0 vote.
Very yours,
�
;�� ' �� � �;-�- �
_ ' � __
PETER J. �� TTA
Secretary, Board of Zoning
PJM:gaf
CLS
Z,F. �k6936
�..--, ��: f`��$��,
�
� �� �.
�
. ' 1595 S�LBY AVENUE � ST. PAUL, MINN. 55104
'
. ,
REMENDERS, INCORPORATED
Telepho�e: 645-5565
MR. AND NlRS. ROBERT I{UHIMAN
CITY VEIW MOTEL
1660 Hndson Rd.
St. Paul, Minn.
___IEGA�L �SC�0�1
All t2ut part of th� folla�ring dsscrib�d traot�
T� xest 433.os r.et or tt,e sast 937.3z rset oi t�at
part oi the eoat.heaat quarter (SE�) of the section � 34�
toan,�hip 29 north� range 22 vsat, �yirig sauth of Trunlc High�ray
No. 12 as nar looated ar�d satablishsd, �xc�pt the south 658 feet
th�r�of i al,so rxaept the Weat 30 Pest ot ttls �sat 229 feet thereof=
bsing R�giatsred Lard� Certi.t'icate o�f Title No. 147827i
Which liea northsaeterly ot a lin� ran paral],el xit.h and distant 30 fest
soutt�eater�q of the lolla�ing dsscrSbsd linet
Beginning at a paint on the eaet lins ofa�►id seci�on 34� diat�nt
510 north of th� south•aat aorner ther�of� thsnae run weaterly
at an angls of 90 dsgr�e �rith aaid eaat ssotion 1.ins for 11�.75
fs�t; theno� d�flsct to ttu right at an ar�gl� of 44.00 degrse tor �
379•93 feet�thsnos d�tlect to t.h�a left on a 20.00degrse curve
(dslta angle 34 dsgree-,54�23")Por 1?4.,53 fset= t,h�n� on tangsnt
to said curva for 441.29� leet and there terminat�.ng�
containing 0.61 aors� mors or 1•ss�
Saut,h oi Higtaray # 12 B�tiresn Whito B�ar Ave. arxi Kanard St.
zoNiN� Fs�E �����
DESIGNERS • REMODELERS • BUILDERS • KITCHEN SPECIALISTS
�..-. w. �- _ _ _ _
� ��:
, �3�A2D �OF' 7.,ONIN� REPORT AND ACTION January 22, 1970 °lat htap #�42
�Actinn, under Le�;islative Code Chapter 6� 'thru 64
n-ss:,A�1 ��a�ust 22� 1922 as amended to April 6� 1�G3 6936
- _ — 6378
. . ��.'':"�1�:��1'i'S NA'1L' , Robert and Janet Kuhlman 3125
. ;',1�,SI;'1CA'fION . � Am�ndnwnt � Appeal ❑ Permit ��ther X-844
Atlow [he expansion of an existing motel in "A"
" , ��'�'�'�'IJ ' Residence District With a setback of 35 feet.
. .��X:F,Ti��t� : South side of I-94 between White Bear Avenue
and Kennard Street
. ;,CGA:, �rSCRIPTIO.J � See file
. 1'::L;I:�JT .;!�NINGs "A" Residence
1 - P:J3SUAN'� '1'� ?oninp Coda Chapter� 64 S�ctions .03 Fararraph:
+ . :,1'AI'F INVESTIGATION � REPORTs Dat�s 1/14/70 IIys ATB
A. ZONING ADMINISTRATOR: Informed appellant th�t the Council would have to approve a
setback of 35 feet from T. H. �12 and approve the expanaion of the existing motel
in an "A" Residence District.
B. fiISTORY: An appeal for a pestisit to con�truct a 6-unit �otel was gr�nted for thia
site on June 7, 1955. An appeal to enl�rge the exiating motel wos epproved on
Jan�iary 20, 1968.
C. P1tOPUSAL: The proposal is to c�nstruct �n addition to the existing motel to
conrain 3 unite. The propoaed etructure would have � setback of 35 feet.
D, PRESENT STANbARD: Chapter 64� 3ectia► .03, Par�graph 20 permits the Council to
allow a motel adj�cent to a trunk highway. The established setback for this
property is 50 feet.
E. VARIANCE: The requested oetback of 35 feet ie 15 feet lees than the establiahed
setback, a variance of 30�.
F. AREA ZONING: Adjoining to the east s large tract ia toned Commercial. The reat
of the area is zoned "A" Aesidence. The Comprahensive Plan recommends Commercial
use of this property.
G. SITE CONDITIONS: The aite is occupied by an exiating motel. The ground slopes
downward from the motel to the hiahWay.
li. AREA CONDITIONS: A large percentage of the area i• vacent and rolling land. A
sin�le-femily reaidence� a reetaurant and motel ie to the eaat. To the south are
scattered single-family re�idencea. Coaetruction work ia in pro�rees on I-94 to
the north.
Council Letter
9. 3�ARD ACTION; To Recommend �A IApproval �Denial Dated
2/11/70
"9oved by: Gauger Yeas fdays Date of }�earin�
X Ames
5econded by; Maietta Cohen 2/13/70
Danna (Alt) Council Action
X Gadlar
X GauRar
Secretary' s remark�s x Maietta I�te
X McPartlin (Alt)
Mar►sur (Alt)
� , � � '�,., ! ��•i C � I � „ ,�, �_�_ � � r-•.— -
. i I I � ! v+! � jy � T �.� I �`? t J .�.,; �`r
. I + i @ � C� ! � V
. ' I i :1 � ! ,
� � .I ,
� O j � � p �,_ i . .� � . . .
�' � I � � 0 0 O
� I � .....� � O
�',--____ _, _ ►- � � A `� � O
�" � '�'`��_ � ��--�_ V ( i i
.°—__` `- _ _ - '`1--_`_�` _ � i '
- -� �--�, _ �` � �-- � �
�� � - ~�� `''�—_, - - - - . � i
_\ \\ ;.'.`---_. __ _ �
_—.
V N V `�--'`-----�._ ,_
PA�IFiC . . . . c�wh �, , _ _ r
� � � - � -
v v vv � v v v � � � vv v ' — —'
ii�o � ,, �.�.....,..
' � '� ...�.. ? . .y= .... , �
, �.
� � , � .,,,� �
� ,, � ,. ° i
L�
o V V v v I „ V V V V V V V V V ''•�'�.�r�,�.w�� •M � � �
....�,:. ------- - - �
� �i.�� i u� •�.V L . . ,
`� 1 1
� ( i
V W VVIV �/ VVOVVVV ✓ .
� ,
! �4 __ � 1 � � � ,
, ;
� Q ; �vvvv � vvvvvvv .. j �
�M ' -�-� v
SueuRea�v Av� , � -..-� , �
� � ;
' �' �b � � v � � i4O � w ;.
� ' I � � i ;
_ -�-- ;
� � � � ' � � .
o d 'o �, o� ; � � , �
- -�- � o p a p n 0 0 _ _1
APPLICANT Robert and Janet Kuhlman LEGEND
PURPOSE Allow the expansion of an existing � /� qiD � 1Sc
motel in "A" Residence District ����� v G
with a setback of 35 feet. � ONE-FAMILY
PRESENT ZONIf�fG "A" Resiaence -�- TWO-FAMILY
PETITION SIGNERS �� THREE-FAMILY
FpUR- FA�1lLY
T MULTI-FAi�ILY
• • nCOMMER�IAL
FILE No. 6936 NoRTH � n INDUSTRIAL
v VACANT
St. Paul Planning Board, Date: 1�14/�0 � Property under consideration
MINUTES C7�' THE PUBLI� �i�R��iG 7�E�OP,E Tf� BUA'�lD 0�' ZUNYPtG
on it�ursday, ,��z�xu�ry 22, 1470, at 2:00 P�T�,
PKESENT: Measrsw Ames, Gadler, Grauge�, x.c�'��t1in, an� ria�.��:ta of th.4 �oarr� r�nd
Me�srso Brc�r�ra and Ry�n, Dr, ReAden$ Mrsa �rsntz�*az, and lhiss Spexr of
�he st�df�.
1ZO�R°� A1vD JAId�T KC3IiL�t�1A1V: �:n agpeal tQ al.�.�c,r the exga�s:Coz of an existfag mot�I
in �n "A" Resid�nce Distr�c� with � setb�Gk of 35 feet an pr�pe�ty lacate�' an the '
soutl� side c�f �--94 batween Wi�ite Bear. �lvenu.a �c�d KLnn.a�rd �t�F•�et.
Mxo Ryan su:.a�arized the s�:aff repor� ��a��n� ��:�t the pI'O�flS�I �S to coz�st�uct 3
addi[icsaal units to €,n ex:;.stin� mot�l, C�,��4er 64.03, �aragraph 20 of th� Zoning
Ordin�nce peru�its �i�� Council to al�.�s�v a ff:���?. ad jacen* t� � tru.n�t highway. Tt�:�
estai�LiShed setb�c'� f.ur �l�is �sr=���r�� is SO �e:t.
I3i�cussson fcal2ow�ecl g� ta w�a�t�aer ,_hi. c�n �,� �se�rni.t��d �n a!� "A�� ResLdance Dis�rict.
Tl4'� Y�k�TCI� 0� t�e '�C��..'Y.�� �''.3 ���: t9LS�°� Lf3.r'W 1�(Sl��f��
Nz��ez�;� a�peared in opgt�si�ia� �;� etse ��g��:t�l.,
�?r. ,, �suger m�v�d �ar €��prov�l af th� �p��^:�l.., wkafch eoras se��.nded by Mr. Maietta �x�d
c�r�3,ed eFnanimous�e�.
Submitted by. Ro��r 8d,. hy�tK r��be�� ;�o A�ees, Gh�airman
_�y
Citq• Clerk �
�*
� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court Hou:e 55102
January 30, 1970
File X 844 Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the
Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of
St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on February 13, 1970, on the appeal of Roberr
and Janet Kuhlman to wafve the setback requirements in connectfon
with an addition to the motel on the property described as; All
that part of the following described tract: The west 433.08 feet
of the eesC 937.32 feet of that part of the souCheast quarter of
the section 34, Township 29 North, Range 22 West, lying south of
Trunk 8ighway No. 12 as now located and establis�hea; except the
south 658 feet thereof; ; also except the west 30 feet of the east
229 feet thereof; being Registered Land, Certificate of Title
No. 147827; which lies northeasterly of a line run parallel wiCh
and distant 30 feet southwesterly of the following described line;
Beginning at a point on the east line of said sectfon 34, diatant
S10 north of the southeast corner thereof; thence run westerlq
at an angle of 90 degree with said east section line for 115.75
feet; thence deflect to the right at an angle of 44.00 degree for
379.93 feet; thence deflect to the left on a 20.00 degree curve
(delta angle 34 degree - 54 minutea 23 seconds) for 174.53 feet;
thence on tangent to said curve for 441.29 feet and there termin-
ating; containing 0.61 acre, more or less. The property is locatad
on the south side of Highway I-94 between White Bear Avenue and
Kennard St.
For further information contact the Planning Board, Room 1010
Conanerce Building or telephone 223-4151.
JAMES J. DALGLISH
Commissioner of Finance
O
� . �, �
�� , � � - ��, �`>�_
, ' 1595 SELBY AVENUE '� ST. PAUL, MINN. 55104 �-�� d.1
. , ' ' �
_,4'c,y, y
REMENDERS, INCORPORATED � ���'(�'�
Telephone: 645-5565 �� �--,y` �
. r,�^ 't,- r/�,�
._..v. __. ., , , �,��.
_.. __� -� _._ � -�_ . _� ^ �_--�-- _=T�-�_T_ � .
,n .�. �_
�, ..- -� -�.--
, ,>�, _, . ,_ ,
- - _._ _ ._-,, -�_._ .. . _ __ ._�� ...
_. � n ' ., .. _. �
_. �• � y� . ..._„� �Jy..
_.. .. , ... �n � . -. . .. � i i.. ..� .
, _ . , ,-. , ;�„ -. � r,_. �..,..n
. .., ,. . ..,.,... . . . .. . _
:
..�.� � . ._ � ...1.. .�,�� ... , �. � . �,�:. �.,_ . . �� . . �.♦ j .:' � '... ��� 1
� r. . � . , •� . -, , . n i n, .t "/1. .. �..
..... .-... ;._. . .. . . , . . .. .
" '1 ..... �� '�. ...v,_.:."u ... .�"_ _'_" _ '_ ._. '"�.'._'..�:�1 : .� .. .,.. y .,..... ,. . � ... .. .. .__.�_..
t 1 �
.r/�il '.1 • i,n. � � �. .� /n� . . � .. . . � . •
, ..:- . .�. �. . .. . ,. _�. , . . -
..-.. �, ...'�� v'v �� "_ ..._ � .. � ...�..�,. .\i ♦ ...�..�,._ ... . ._�-.. '."_": ,.v .� ..__ ... _... r �__ ..:J
„ �' t .. ... -�,.. y . .. .
�. ��1�� . � . �. � .. , .� .� .. � ^� . / . l� � _ ,1
-._:.._ ��� � ...��. _..��-�� �..._ .. '�.�.__� • _�. ..�... .. " �.. ._�� ..�.. •1_.�.. . —. ... .. ,._ .
v ��.._. .J .
� �t � � .� � . �
� " � � • • � � � . � . .� �r.1 � � . •
. . . . , . . . ,. .. . .. . . ,-
. ..� � _. .. _, �. �..... � . . . .� .. • _J v_�' �.�_�.. �.... .�_
�
.. ^ . �. � .- .. �. � .. .
• .
v_ .� �' ,.., __ .• l+_,...� . .'_ —_.�._ �..+i �..._ �.:.'�.. ..,.�." .., .__�_��J.�.+..:� ._'�_,. ... _v _'" ", S _._.._°
, � . . } , . .�, i. , . .
, �
_,.. . , . . ..,,. . . _. . _ . . 1 . �.
_. ,� _' " y'�"_ '._ '_� ':..:. .___, ..� .:...y,J' ... �.: ���� . :_�.. -� .���_ ._� _.. y.-...�_.. ., .. �..,.,.i.._.
. .. . . , ,� , � . . . ,, . . . . � ", ,
� - c . .. ... .� . � .
..,... __ �. ".'" _'_". :.. ✓....,... �.:✓ .V a -..::.CJ V �..�. .. _:.. -.i .�� .:. . � � �_v...•
' 1 __" _ v '. _ .." _."�
.� .�� . �. r . i.... �
I �- • n
��. � v . ,.—�� "_. _� .,_r...... .... ... �. y " ..1 '�_ u « �� ,..,. „ ..,.i_. .._.. _. .. _.. _.�.�
. .. ^ ' _ _... � . 1.. . ♦ � .
. -� . � � r �� � �.
r •
� . � .. • � . .- . . ...� . ,
y.r 1.��� � _'�.. .. .. . �:_�'.� �.�.i . . �..� __... ...__� :. ..,. . :._'.':_��� .� v_�-�
-.• • !1 �r-�T • . n• . 1 .' . 9 .'� � ' . �
� '
' .., i\.ri���/�C�IiJ � . ' . . .._ • ..
� ! �
�� _ , ».Y _,__:._� _..:_ __,.� ! � ,__._ .. '_ .. � _. , � __
„ .. � . �„ � , , . ,
_ . ..
� .
_�._ �__',� _� :_ .__ �_�� �- _, � _: � _. ., - ---�i. _ � ., .;.,. __•... ,._ .'_. � - -" - - -
. , , ,. . . -,
, ,. . _ , , , ..
.. _ _ -.:._� _ -'--'-•� - °"- _ .���_.:� , _ _
__ _ , y ZC?NtNG FiLE ��►--
. , . . ., . , . ., . .
. ,.
_�_� . �� J�.. __ ���.� _. ��:�, '� ..�..:.� :,'..� '-"' �.-�..__._ '..�. � _.._'..-. ��...: .. y .._�...
, .. _
.. . _ .. .., . - . ,�
...,,' . --'_ --'� .. �.'. ��... . _... ..i,. . ' .._-- � . . _ _ . �__ _. � .._._._..� -._ .__...__..._ .
� -v - y
, �� - , ��' ,��M �f �-'
' � , � � , _ ., _� _ �_
, �..-- _- ,� �.__ � . . _� . ,
._, - - ��- -. � _ . � _ _ �
�
DESIGNERS • REMODELERS • BUILDERS • KITCHEN SPECIALISTS