The URL can be used to link to this page

247407 ♦. ' 24�4�� OR161NAL 70�'jITY CLHRK " CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCi� OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE N�'. CO�INCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONE DATF RE30L�ED, Upon the pertinen� appeal, �nder �he Zonir�g Code, by Everette Daigle, �.s owne� of th�* sub�ect real c�tate, situate in the 6i�y of Saint Patz1, zor�ed in "!1" Residenee Distriet, under the Zor�ing �ode, and dese�ibed as the �ast 74 feet of the north 1.10 f�et of Lo� 1, Blo�k 8, Furness � Q�arden Lots, �.nd loQated on �he so�zthwest aorner of East �io� Avenue and Winthrop �treet, that the provisions of said Zoning Code hereby are d�ter�ined and varied as ar�d to �he ex��nt nec,ess�.ry therefor, and the building setbaek line of said r�al � x estate, in resp�ct of the south lin�: of East Hoyt Avenue t�pon � � which the same abuts, her�by i� e��ablished as a line dr�,wn � � � �.� � aeross said real es�ate para11�1 there�o and 7 fee� d3.�t�.�t � from said south line of Fa�t Hoyt Avent�.�; sub�e�t to the � a �a eondi�ion that �aid appl.icant-pe�aittee, and hi� ��cc�ssor� � O �� and assigns, al�$11 ma.ke due eomplianee wi�h all appliaable �z u, provisions of mu.�;ieipal ordinance�, stat� statutes �ld rales � ancl ��gulations oF public au�horitie� havin� �ognizanae. COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Counci�F E B 10 1970 19_ Yeas Nays Carlson F E B 10 1970 Dalglish pprove�i 19—_ Meredith �n Favor . Peterson Sprafka � Mayor Tedesco A Sainst - � Mr. President, Byrne PUBLISHED FEB 141970 O � �� i ' � I . �p 1�--...��:r. ' � �I NO� �. ��f"y C0�8��•�� Zt�TC�p��pt�„blic ��c}�j � � �' CaN..'on J� v7� ', U . ,��"'��°��„�� ING, CITY OF ST. PAUI �� . � � �� c2�''°�� Ve G°de' �' ��' ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 c2t ��►b P�`t to ta,cd �de, ��Yr �G a do bid.. d�. �,1 1�Q,�F t�ieof� � P Eo Iof.�' t!d Ga'rdl1�� 1. ,$1�t � A��wv��r�weat�ern� January 7, 1970 � R' i�• ( �tY C1��ia9LL' '�er Y7. 18�) Ro om�$b�'�.'r�y--___ Dear Mr. Marshall: This is written in response to the appeal of Everette Daigle to establish a building setback line of 7 feet from East Hoyt Avenue to allow construction of a garage on property located on the southwest corner of East Hoyt Avenue and Winthrop Street. This property is further described as: �East 70 feet of the north 110 feet of Lot 1, Block 8, Furness'Garden Lots. l The Board of Zoning considered this matter at its meeting on December 4, 1969. The staff reported that the appellant's request was for a change of plat to establish his frontage along Winthrop Street instead of East Hoyt Avenue because his house was oriented to Winthrop Street. Lot frontage is established by the platting of the lot and the building setback line for this property has been established at 40 feet from East Hoyt Avenue. In effect, the appeal is to establish a building setback line of 7 feet from East Hoyt Avenue for this property. The staff reported that an appeal to establish a 35-foot setback on this property in 1961 was withdrawn on the ruling of the City Architect that the setback for the property was 40 feet. The 40-foot setback was confirmed by the City Architect in 1964. An appeal to establish a 20- foot setback from East Hoyt Avenue was denied by the Council in 1966 as there were no practical difficulties in constructing the building at a setback of 40 feet and allowing room for the construction of a garage. A duplex was constructed at the 40-foot setback but not located on the site to permit the construction of a garage within the setback limits. The variance requested is 82.5 percent of the required setback. The report concluded that granting of the appeal may be detrimental to the adjoining property, the established setback was reasonable, and the existence of a hardship was not indicated. The Board of Zoning discussed the need for the appeal noting the need for a garage in this climate and the exposure to the wind in the area. As none of the notified property owners appeared in opposition and since a permit for the garage slab had already been issued, it was moved that the Board of Zoning recommend approval of the appeal. This motion to recommend approval of the appeal passed by a split vote of 3-2. Very truly yours, i 7 _ , __� . , ,� �,�- ..� ;' J / (_. L i'_...i�._. / ,.(_ „ � �= k � PETER J. MAIETTA Secretary, Board of Zoning PJM:ga f AT B Z.F. �k6906 °`�.'? �` �.:�.�--r',��:s�.. i�"' `-' � - , . . �P��RS O F IVj p��R� � 4 ; A, G� �IVING SPAG� l��G : l�O. HOME MODERNIZERS , �,�'�'� 1850 COMO AVE. • Midway between the Twin Cities �� ` PHONE 645-0331 • ZIP CODE 55108 ��O o ��I�I I I Honorable Mayor and City Council of St. Paul; �� Concerning property at 1553 Winthrop. Owner of Property: Everette Daigle 1553 Winthrop St. 776-0218 Legal Description of Property: East 70' of the north 110' of Lot 1 Block 8 Turners Garden Lots ` r uK�14 t1 Located on Southwest corner of Winthrop and Hoyt. On the lot there is an existing duplex. This lot is not�' platted as facing Hoyt. We are appealing to have this lot platted to face Winthrop to enable construction of a double detached garage along side of house. (See diagram) . This is covered under 64.03 J in the city code. ��'�� w.� �� ,,..�a,,. ..... �onoao �* � SATISFYING CUSTOMERS SINCE 1915 • GARAGES • BREEZEWAYS • PORCHES • ROOM ADDITIONS • FAMILY ROOMS • DENS t<OISTlRID*1 ��, � gASEMENT AND ATTIC FINISHING • DORMERS • BEDROOMS • KITCHEN AND BATH MODERNIZING • LAKE HOMES • CABINS waoaw ■ KtYY��+ �AovnsM�� _ • . ➢OARD (7�` ZONING REPORT AND llCTION December 4, 1969 pkt �P #34 , Actin�� under Legislative Code Chaptar 60 thru 64 F'ile 1Jo. 6906 passed August 22� 1922 as amended to April 6� 1969 � Also 6109 1, AiPLICANT'S NAME : Everette Daigle 4845 X-822 2, CLASSIFICATION : �Amenc��nant �App�al ❑Pormit ❑Other Establish a setback line of 7 feet from East Hoyt 3. PURPOSE = Avenue (change plat to face Winthrop Street to enable construction of a double-detached garage) 4, LOCATION s Southwest corner of East Hoyt Avenue and Winthrop Street 5► LEGAL DESCRIPTION t Eest 70 feet of the north 110 feet of Lot 1, Block 8, Furnesa Garden Lots 6. PRESENT ZONING : "A" Residence 7. PURSUAMT TO Zoning Cod• Ctupt�rs 64 Ssctions .03 Paragraph: 8 � STAFF INVESTIGATION � REPORTs Dat�s 11/24/69 Bys ATB A. ZONING ADMINISTRATOR: Application for a building permit for a garage was denied as proposed structure would exceed the established building line. B. HISTORY: An appeal was filed to establiah a 35-foot setback from E. Hoyt Avenue in Dec. , 1961. This appeal covered the east 70 feet of the north 110 feet of Lot 1, Block 8, Furness Gardena. The City Architect ruled that if the appellant would accept a 40-foot building line, an appeal would not be necessary. The appeal was withdrawn. A ruled in Sept. , 1964, by the City Architect confirmed the 40-foot setback from E. Hoyt Avenue and ruled a 7-foot setback from Winthrop Street would be reasonable. An appeal to eatablish a 20-foot building line from E. Hoyt Avenue was denied by the City Council 8/4/66. C. PROPOSED USE: Construct a garage with a setback of 7 feet from E. Hoyt Avenue. D. PRESENT STANDARD: The City Architect has ruled that the building for this property is 40 feet from E. Hoyt Avenue and 7 feet from Winthrop Street. E. VARIANCE: The requeated variance is 17.5% of the establiahed building line. F. AREA ZONING: The entire area is zoned "A" Residence. G. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is developed with a duplex constructed with a setback of 40 feet from E. Hoyt Avenue, established building line, and setback 22 feet from Winthrop Street. A 7-foot setback would be reasonable. A concrete slab has been poured adjacent to E. Hoyt Avenue. H. AREA CONDITIONS: North is an underground water reservoir of the Water Dept. ; east is the Hillcrest Golf Course; south is a duplex fronting on Winthrop St. ; and adjoining to the west is a single-family rea. setback at 120' . Council Letter 9. �OARD ACTION; To Recomfnand CxJ Approval L..j Denial Dated 1/7/70 "loved by; Maietta y�s Nays Date of Hearin�r, x Ames Seconded by; Cohen x Cohen 1/8/70 Danna (Alt) Council Action Gadler x Gaugor X Sacretary's remarkss x Maietta Date McPartLin (Alt) Mansur (Alt) LEGAL NOTZCES ON 'THE BACK OF THIS SHEET . .._ �a.f � � �� . .... . .; �i r � . / ' . '_' a �i _ ' f.., � ! ,� .., i . _.` � . . 'j +� � � ' .�+^ �. i ; a , . � . . _ . �, . ^ i ", . i � , . .. : .. � " '� . y, (...' �� : .. —� � . l_ � � � �� . � �� +� �� .� ��, � ` .� I `�I./ f�'—_..._. � Y� .�v' rJ �.,4 J � • . ��l v -.� ' I \f `. L^�� '' • 4 j . _ ,� CJ ; v ! �-•, `; �' .3 �� F` � � ; ' � ' r ) � _ � i �� f.j'�.�;�j�;� .�,� ;,.� 0 +� A AV E, `� ----r , _ �� -� :� ,� �;� JL f ��' .+ '�� .�, " ; , ` l, v �`—,' Q, �7 ' � r. �J `�� `;� � � • Q _`�(j I WATER ; OEPA NT � RESERVOIR �� `�?��3 �.`"y , ' � w`'� � .3 .� '� � . I � ' �; ' ;^� � V, � �"� � . , . ..._ / �� ! � • ��t � 4� f"�, t , . � � i —. �• � ! ,,S , ; �^� , :,;,� ,�� l`� � � � � 'r-- ._. � � 1/I � i �•� � ,,� ,J � �� , � ,, .^ , �., .. . I � • i ,� 'r...�t t,� �{�.,�' �.� .,\ ` ��y T qv�. �� `;� �'"', ..� -; , ". �- � , , � �', ' '' ,�� _, _ `'_� ' �.\ � �,`� �� ,� �` � . I � ' I � � �-'' C'' Y� � �`' � � . � .�, .L", .. J ; i C' i � , � � • -,' ,� I • •`-�� '�� ^� `' `+,� ..I � f + CJ � � i � ( 'Q" i •y .:� , � .�i ,,. ,-' ! ," • •;�' „� • ,� v�,.�j i. I.'1 .1 �.;� . � i . ;`' . I O i � , .T�'". /�if ,'^.1 ,4:._� : � ` • `� 4�� '� .� � � ,� A ..�1 �•� :� �` �� I __ -�' I '� �) ,, ,•+� �,� ,�j`0�'�� `'c.:�/.�P' ��'� ;.�. 4� � ' Q ; I t I �''- I' �� • ~3 ° �"�' .� . .�1^. �-J�� '. ':'.�� , .�i._._. ��- ' ,.`` . �� , � F. + � �'�..�. . ; , _ ` „� ., 1 •�;, ,..�. M;. t-:�� . � �.� � o � -� `_?'-..� ; =�.�.`�, .� �_ ,,..; �• , -G , . K. � � ; f ; •i � � I. , , `� � ,;, � - � � � � � �.� ; - - . _--r� ' ; � (�/� ; I _T_� h ; '.F�( '. � �� — - —, I � ; � i :� ,..Y.-. , _ - � 1 I � � � 1}� I � � , � � -� . �,: � .'�� • �. '� ' � � ' ! � a ' O ' O � O � ' 1 ` � � i i � ; I , O 1� O Q I � � ' ' ' ' ? , ^'. .' _ I , � '"- � � �' ' ^' � ,�, � � i � ! �� I � � I ' ,:_, /; (� � ;� �� , Q j (7 � Q ��b � (� � ; � � � ' � � ,. �, . • � .,: r � � � � j �� ' . � � _> N�C3�Z AS/�A ,� z M, � ,� , '� y , �','' ' o � � i I , , � ; 3 .' � � .. ,' �; . o p a , � ; � , 0 , � � � �� ; �.� ;�, , , i ` , I � i I � I � I , , v � . ,' ; -, `-, ., ; . , ; ; � ,, . , , , t �. � ,., ,. ,.. — -- � —�___-_.--l l. ,-, � i � , : , � APPLiCANT Everette Daigle LEGEND � � PURPOSE Street toaenableaconstruction LAND USE of a double detached garage p ONE-FAMILY PRESENT ZONING "A" Residence �' TWO-FAMILY � THRE E- FAMILY PETITION SIGNERS . - FOUR-FAMILY � MULTI- FAMILY � FILE No. 6906 � •nCOMMERCIAL : �1QR�" n n INDUSTRIAL U VACANT St. Paul Planning Board, Date= 11/25/69 � Property under considerotion � � . , . MTNUT�S OF TH� PUBLIC HEARING B�FORE THS BQARb OF ZONING ora Thursday, December 4, 19699 at 2:00 PoM„ PRESENT: l�Sessrse Ames, Cohen, Gadl.er, Ga�ger, and Maietta of �the Board and Messrse Brocm and Sorenson and Mrsa Frantzen o� �he s[aff. EVERETTE DAIGLE: An appeal to change the plat Co £ace Wiathrop Street to enable eanstructio� of a dauble detached garage on property located on the southweat corner af Ea�t Hoyt Avenue and Winthrop Stree�. Mr, Sorenson su�arizQd �he staff report stating that an appc�al was filed to establish a 35-foot setb�ck from East Hoyt Avenue in T�ececnber, 1961. This appeal covered the same proper�y as for this current appealo The City Architect rul�d that if ehe appellant caould accept a 40-foot building line, an appe�l would not be necess�gry. The �ppeal wsa withdrawn. A ruling •in Septemher, 1964, by �he City �►rchitect confirmed the 40-iEoot setback from East Hoyt Avenue and ruled a 7-focst se�:back fra�njJinthrop Street would U� reaso�able. An appeal to �sr�ablish a 2(l--fa�rc buildia�g Iine from East Hoy� !�•✓enue �uas denied by the Ci[y �auncil on August �t, �96b. The purpose of �h� present appeal is to consL-ruc� a garage with a se�back pf. 7 ieet �from Esst Hoyt Avenue. The request represe:zts a v�r.i�nce af. 82.5°�, of �he .xequired se�back. Presently, the aite is developed �aith � �up�ex constructe� wLth a setbacY oi 40 feet fram East Hoyt Avenue rnd an �st�bli�h+�d building 3ine and �etback 2� feet from 4linthrop Street. A concrete s3.�b i�as been poure+d for the pro�osec'. garsge ad jacent to Sast Royt Avenue� Mra Snrenson cc�nc�.udad �i�.�at �he appesl m�y be detrimea�t�l to the neighbors in et�e vicis►ity, �nd �ha� �he se�back is r�s�onable. Ad� hardship �s indic�ted. Mr� �veretCe Dai��e, rhs� �pp�zliant, noted that the �1ab is laid in the 40-foot s�t��ck. sr+�a �nd q�ese��n�d why he was per.m�tted to install the slab if the gara�e is sub�ect Ko �:�is appealo Diecussioca �o�icsxaed ccncerning the raes�d for the �pp�al� It wss not�d rhat the appell�Mt neec3s a gerage to cu� aff. �he wind. Mr, N;a�.Qtt� moved for onproval o� the a�peal, since there is no appoaition and siacQ � pexmit faz t�4 sl�b hxs �alr��dy t�een fssu�de Zir. Cohen Sz�ona�a the motian, which pffis�ed i�y a �pli�: vcat� of 3-2 e Mesr�rs� Gadler and Gauger voted in opposition. Sutsrait�ed hy: �oloa�e:,. I., Sox��nsax� F�;�tier'r_ L.:, ��e�, Cha�rn�an �-11- , , . . � � , ' , . . City�•Clerk CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 Dacember 26, 1969 F�.le X822, Page ' You are hereby notffied that a publfc hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.ca. on January 8, 1970, on the application of Everette Daigle to relax setback re- quirements to enable construation of a double detached garage on the east 74 feet of the north 110 feet of Lot 1, Block 8, Furness Garden Lots. The property is located on the southwest corner of East Hoyt Avenue and Wfnthrop Street. For further information contact the Planning Board, Room 1010 Commerce Building or telephone 223-4151. 3AMES J. DALGLISH Co¢�nissioner of Finance O