249601 ORIGINAL TO CITY CLBRK C��� ! I�
�CITY OF ST. PAUL couHCa '� '��
' OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE NO.
COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE DATF
RFSO�VED, That R. William Reilly be and hereby i�
granted a permit to ins�all a 169-ear parking lo� in
con�un�tion w�t� 96 apartment units on property loea�ed
on the north �ide of Wilson Avenue between Hazel and
Luella Str�ets, more particularly described aa followsr
�o�s 2, 3, � and 5, Block 2,
Hudson Road 4ardens;
sub��ct to the condition �ha'� �aid applicant-permittee, and
his �uccessors and assigns, shall make due compliance wi�h
all applieable proniaions of municipal ordinances, s�ate
�tatutes and rules and r�gulations of public authorities
having cognizance.
F Af? � ;��
Asst. orporati0� Counsel
7 1970
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Co,tc�i 19._
Yeas Nays
Butler :��� 7 ����
Caxlson Approve� 19�
Levine n Favor
Meredith
Sprafka �i ��
Tedesco A Bainst
Mr. President, McCarty PUBLISHED
JU� 1 Z 1970
�
,
.
� B�OARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
June 22, 1970 2���r}�
,.1
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
City C1erk
Room 386 City Hall
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to the application of R. William Rei11y for a
permit to install a 157-car parking lot to be used in conjunction with 96
apartment units on property located on the north side of Wilson Avenue between
Hazel and Lue11a Streets, and noted in detail by the legal description on file.
This matter was considered at the May 21, 1970, Board of Zoning meeting.
The staff reported that the revised plans indicate 88 parking spaces within
the structures and 81 surface parking spaces. The resulting rate is 1.76 spaces
per dwelling unit. Staff conclusions noted that the proposed parking layout
meets required design standards and has the approval of the Traffic Engineer.
Mr. Reilly noted that his application provides above-minimum parking and
that he feels the City will benefit from the proposed development.
Subsequently, the Board of Zoning recommended approval of this application
by a 4-1 vote.
Very truly yours,
i r
•'
� ..
• 1
PETER J. IETTA
Secretary, Board of Zoning
PJM:gaf
CLS
Z.F. �k6983
/�� � f�
t f. ny.. ,. .,:��
j,..�' �:
� '�
� ��
G �
, � _• r
� ` � �,
, City oP Saint Paul, �innesota
•` �' APPLICATION FOft SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT
� � (Please print or type)
TO THE �ONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUN�CIL
� the City Clerk
City of Saint Paul, Minnesota
Application is hereb made to ����x����������
y install and operate a new (cross one out)
� FILLING STATION
No. of islands and pumps :
No. of tanks and capacity:
(prospective tenants and their guests)
Q PARKING LOT for (�7eu) (�itf�Oly]�i� (iKtl�4atY��T�e) (1Kt�4���� (d��)
(indicate type)
Capacity of parking Lot 157 automobiles
To be used in connection with: 2 apartment buildings, housing 96 units
� MISCELLANEOUS:
(indicate type such as Drive-in Ref reshment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 8tation, Ice Vendor, etc.)
Capacity of parking area:
*Location The north side of v��ilson Street between Luella and Hazel
� Streets -
Legal Description : Lot s `L, 3, 4 and 5 Block 2 Addition
Hudson i-�oad Gardens
Applicant•s Name : F;. ti'�illiam lieilly
Home or Office Address: 1220 Minnesota Buildin�, St. Paul, P��innesota
Phone Number ; 222-1761
THE PLICANT, ��{ � 11_ I� 'i ,�f ��i ��+
A VV « � U ��� ��� ��
� `�� ' aPR z� �970
Signature (date
Address : 1220 Minnesota Building CITY PLANNtN6 BOARD
Phone No.: 222-1?61 ��� PsW, Minnesot:�
Whea completed: file three copies of this application form and three prints of
the preliminary lay-out plans of tbe proposed facility a►ith the City Clerk,
Room 386, Cftq Hail and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of �aia St. and First St.
2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St.
:...�_.__---.
N NG FI LE ��
ZO 1
ROARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION May 21, 1970 T13� 'q:-, �k42
. ��lotinK under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 ------- l
: � pastiecl Au�;��sc 27_, 1972, as amended to April 6, 1970. 6983 !
6982 I
_ . � " t ��,:1 � � � �;'�.'ll: . R. William Reilly 6961
',',:�� : ': �'i;� , I.v.� i,menciment C� AP�eal � Yermit � `)t'�er X-898 j
Install a 157-car parking lot to be used in ' ----
�" � �'�" '`"' ° conjunction with 96 apartment units
� . :'- �;�'�'�'': > North side of Wilson Avenue between Hazel
and Luella Streets
_. . '_,�;���ti.;. :)E:��' ;���•�il��:l � Lots 2-5, Block 2, Hudson Road Gardens
, . ;i;�!; !'1' ,,,:';i'! ;. "C-1" Residence
i � !:�.�.� ,,.'1'l' �,�i ;',ur�in��. ��:��cie C}iapter: GO �ection: .23 E',3ra�r3ph: 4, ?
s - �i�?`f� II1Vt�"i"i�:�A�I'I��J f, REPORT� Date; 5/15/70 3y; ATB
A. HISTORY: Lots 3-5 were rezoned "C-1" Residence on 5/24/69. The City Council
approved the rezoning of Lot 2 to "C-1" Residence on 5/7/70.
B. AREA ZONING: North and east are zoned "A" Residence, south is zoned "C"
Residence, and west is zoned "C-1" and "A" Residence.
C. DESIGN STANDARDS : The 157-car parking is provided in conjunction with two 48-
unit apartment buildings. 88 of the parking spaces will be located within the ,
buildings and 81 spaces will be surface parking spaces. The parking provided
is 1.76 spaces for each unit. The plan will meet standards with some minor
revisions and additional infor.mation.
D. FRONTACI: AND AREA: 'Che property has a fronta�e of 475.34 feet aloiYC; Luella
Street wit_li a dept}i of ?_97.3 feet and an area of 141,305 square fe��t. '1'1►c�
total building area is 34,586 square feet or 24.51% ground coverage.
E. TRAFFIC ENGINEF.R: The Traffic Engineer reviewed the plan and recommends approval.
F. SITE CONDITIONS: This property is located along the west side of Luella Street
between Conway Street and Wilson Avenue. The elevation of Conway Street at
Luella Street is approximately 50 feet above Wilson Avenue. The site is lower
than the grade of Wilson Avenue and slopes down to the north.
G. AREA CONDITIONS: The area south of Wilson Avenue is developed with multi-family
and single-family uses . A multi-family building is nearing completion on the
northeast corner oE Ha�el Street and Wilson Avenue.
9 ROARI) ACTION: To Reconunend D Approval � Denial Counci 1 Lett�r
Dat:ed :
Moved by . McPartlin Yeas Nays 6/2?/7U
Gadler x �
Date of Hearink
Seconded by: Gauger x Gauger
x Maietta 6/25/70
Secretary's remarks: Mansur Council Action
x Ames - Ch.
x McPartlin (Alt.)
Adkins (Alt.) Date
Rutzick (Alt.)
; ` .
MI�tUTFS OF �A� Pt7C�,1L'ZC� i�.IZ+T� BE�'f?It� TIalE Bt",1�i� �F Zt�!I�IG
on TYsc�rsday� B�tay 2�, 1910� �t 'L:UO P,M�
PR�SENTo Messrsa 1�s, I�cPartlin, Piajetta, Gauger aud Gadle�r of th� BoaYd
a�d �Sre Sorensors, Mra. �x�n�:ze� aac� Miss Sp�x� of the staff,.
84_ WIi�LIAM RS��.L��?: �A�, appl:t�a�io�a fca� a ps��'mie to iustall a 157-�ar �agka.mg
lot to b� used ist �oajuxx��ion wa.th 96 aparY�eat v�uits r,� prop�rt�* located
on the noxth side of t�1:�lson A��e�.u� b��c���� Hazel and �u�lla St��ts.
Mr, Soremso� sucnmari�wd C�e ��a�f repc�;rt notimg �hat the i57-car pa�kin� is
pzovided ia con�raaac�icea �a�.th ��c� �a�aasrii� Anax��:� buildings. 8� of ihe
parking spa�°�s will be �.�a�+�d wi��ai�e t�� huild�lr�s and t3� spac;�� wi11 w�e
surface pa�c�Ciag s�aces. �iar� parki.ag ��ovided is Ie76 sp�s�s for �ach uni�p
The plan wi�,l �e�t atar�da�ds £nr. �:his ��p� o£ �a�ili�y� "�kie px�c�p�:gty has a
fronrcage of �S75e�4 f��� al�ng ��sel�.n �Lre�t �aith a d�pXiz of 297A3 S'ee� and aa�
area of 141�305 squa�� �ee�o 7:he �atr�k �uil.ding mr�a is ��586 sc�uare fea�t
or 24e51� ��ound eove�ag�o �:"h� T��x�a.� Eragian+��r �eviewed ekie p�.ara aau�. re�-
c�nends spprov.���,
In �on�clusion, I°�. So��a�scaa s�aGec� �ha� l.andscaping ar�,d ��pog�a�skn�► pl�a�s aa��
needed f4r �ceview. ��s� shcsu�.c� E� suhmf.�t�cl p�io� ��i �h� �isue �he a4a�te�
goes to �he C3.�y Co��3_1.
Mr� Gadlen ��:�or�ed t�a�� �h�s .:a�x��aaE; �£ p�r1��.n� �o��Ic� b�: �sovir��d a��y iae�aus�
of the app�o��al af ich� �va�ig��w;, x� ��spor►�e, �e R.�iily, eh�: �ppli�ant�
saiei that mras� �oa��a��c�:,.� �a��u�:�.p� p�.r��as �h�� ha�r� �uc� �e�e�s�°��iat,g ��x��s �os
S�o paul. 4i� f��.ti hi� w���ea�.s �,7��� �°av:�s�a�at�Ie a�.d f��I�: �h� �C:��.y GJ�.1� �3&�F.'���.�
f�am this ��velopm��t, i?I�.: p�a�4:��€� 15"!a �esc�x� p��k.f;�a� y:utd 7�'�o me�T�-e� se��gc�k
from Wilso�a Avenue rha� *a�a�.t� �..., :���a 4�°�d ?�� �h� �sr�s��:�, �:oe�in� t°��3e.
Mra A�Pax��.in mev�a fa� 4zp}�xc��.r��� s�� t��;�e app�.ic��ioaa, wM�.�� �uas s��aaded by
Mro Gat�,g�x, ��ac� ���ried �� a �A�-� v��e tai� ��. Gat�l�,� �.a� op�sose_ti��xr,a
Sa��snitted by: �olost�l Y�. ��x����sza Ro���� Y., �l.uc��.P� �h�aix�azc
���
, City Clerk
` CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
June 15, 1970
File R898, Page
CORRECTED NOTICE
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the
Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House at 10:00 a.m.
on June 25, 1970, on the application of R. William Reilly for:
. 1) A permit to install a 157-car parking lot to be used in con-
junction with 96-apartment units;
2) An appeal to relax density requirements to allow the constructicdn
of 96-apartmentw�units, and
3) An appeal to relax setback requirements from 59 feet to 25 feet,
all on Lots 2, 3, 4 and 5, Block 2, Hudsoa Road Gardens. The property
is located on the North side of Wilson Street between Hazel and Luella
Streets .
For further information, contact the Planniag Board, Room 1010 Co�merce
Building, or telephone 223-4151.
ROSALIE. L. BIITLER
Commissioner of Finance
O
City Clerk
�' � , CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
June 12, 1970
File X898, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing wil! be held
in the Council Chambers of the City Aall and Court Houee at
10:00 a.m. on June 25, 1970, on the application of R. William
Reilly for:
1) A permit to install a 157-car parking lot to be used in
conjunction with 96 apartment units, and
2) An appeal to relax density requirements to allaw the
construction of 96 apartment units, all on Lots 2, 3, 4 and
5, Block 2, Eiudson Road Gardens.
The property is located on the North side of Wileon Street
between Hazel and Luella Streeta.
For further information, contact the P1aaRing 'Soard, Rooai
1010 Camaerce Building or telapbone 223-4151.
ROSALIE L. BUTLER
Commi,ssivne,r of Pi.ssaaae
55
. . _ . . - .:
! ' ,
City of Saint Paul, l�innesota
'� , APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT
(Please print or type) �1
TO THE �DNORABLE MAYOR AND CI ��
TY COUNCIL l� �,
� the City Clerk '
City of Saint Paul, Minnesota '/�
�(�/o
I
Application is hereb made to ������������
y install and operate a new �c ss one out)
a FILLING 5TATION
No. of islands and pumps :
No. of tanks and capacity:
(prospective tenants and their guests)
� PARKING LOT for (��ers) (��) (�[i��x�e) (�y��X� (�)
(indicate type)
Capacity of parking lot 157 automobiles
ti
To be used in connection with; 2 apartment buildings, housing 96 units
� MISCELI,ANEOUS: '
(indicate type such as Drive-in Refreshment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 8tation, Ice Vendor, etc.)
Capacity of parking area:
*Location �e north side of Wilson Street between Luella and Hazel
• Streets
Legal Description : Lot S 2, 3, 4 and 5 Block 2 Addition
Hudson Roa.d Gardens
Applicant's Name : R. William Reilly
Home or Office Address: 1220 Minnesota Building, St. Paul, Minnesota.
Phone Number : 222-1761
FO THE PLICANT,
� � -��-��
Signature) (date
Addreas : 1220 Minnesota Building
Phone No.: 222-1761
When completed: file three copies of this application form and three prints of
tbe preliminarq lay-out plaas of the proposed facility with tbe City Clerk,
ftoom 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St.
2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St.
� �
.�_ �,, ;'��,�� �
�"""-�.""L ,.. � e I'.... t �� � � �.
�� V
R. WILLIAM R�ILL'S • cJ- a �J
ATTOENEY AT LAW
904 COMMERCE B'UILDIN(�
HAINT PAIIL, MINNESOTA 55101
812_227.9984
-September 25, 1970
The Honorable Mayor and City Council
c/o City Clerk �
Room 386 •
City Hall and Courthouse �
5t. Paul, Minnesota 55102
Re: Amendment to Prior Parking Lot Permit
Gentlemen: i'
On July 7, 1970, your Honorable Body granted me a permit to install
a 169 car parking lot in conjunction with the construction of 9� apartment
units on property located on the north side of Wilson Avenue, between
Hazel and Luella 5treets, which is legally described as follows:
Lots 2, 3, 4 and 5, Block 2, Hudson Road Gardens.
Subsequent to your granting of the aforementioned permit, I proceeded
to submit plans and specifications to several financial institutians in the
City of Saint Paul for the purpose of acquiring of financing for construction,
All institutions with which I spoke took the position L-hat the proposed
construction was too elaborate for the area, inasmuch as it did provide
underground parking, the latter costing considerably more to construct
as an integral part of the entire apartment project. It has, therefore,
become necessary to cut the number of parking spaces back to the
parking requirement of the City of 1 1/2 parking spaces per apartment
unit, which results in 1.44 parking spaces as opposed to the earlier permit
figure of 169.
Therefore, I am at this time requesting that the earlier permit to install
a 169 car parking lot on th.e aforem.entioned property be amended to the
extent that the 169 be changed to 144 vehicles, Fortunafely, the architect
involved in thi� matter was able to place 144 parking spaces on the subject
�
t�
' ..��
,
.. .. . . .r�'"�� �' ,{P- t �, �
. I rt,' ,',�
. . .... _ ,r- � ..
. � f ��
. � ,
• - ;,._..�
� .
property even though it was necessary for him to eliminate all of the
underground parking, As you can see from the plan which is attached
to this request, all proposed parking is on the outside of the buildings and
it is anticipated that we will have some interior parking in the form of outside `
garages, In addition, it is believed that if the amendment to 144 parking
spaces is granted, that same will definitely facilitate the acquisition of
financing for construction of the entire project.
Thank you very much for your cooperation in this matter,
Very t y yours,
- .
.
R. Wi liam Reilly
'ti ,
RWR:sld -
r .. .
. r� Arsa Code 6�2 � THOMAS J.STEARNS
�lTY 0 �
� 223-Sf21 - ���e� "� . ARTHUR M. NELSON
o �--�;� � �� ,I JEROME J.SE6AL
'� �` ! Q THOM115 M. MOONEY
'' ��''"��1 �� KENNETN J. fITZPATRICK
�d� ^c PAUL F. McCLOSKEY, JR.
. JOSEPH E. CARTWRI6HT
CITY OF SAINT PAUL R.SCOTT DAVIES
}QA4DCX]CBCO[ DANREL L. FIeCKER R
FintAssistant LEGAL DEPARTMENT KENNETHA.SKRIEN
316 Cify Hall, S+. Paul, Minnesota 55102
DANIEL A. KLAS .
Corporation Counsei
October 14, 1970
The Honorable Mayor and
Members of City Council: .
Mr. R. William Rei11y submitted a request that the City
Council amend its Resolution, C. F. 249601, approved July
� 7, 1970, granting a parking lot permit to Mr. Reilly for the
purpose of installing a 169-car parking lot, so as to permit
a parking lot for 144 cars instead. �
It is our opinion that Mr. Reilly' s request, under the terms
of Section 60.23 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, must be
treated as a new application for a parking lot permit, and
that the ordinance does not permit the City Council to amend
the original parking lot permit without receiving the report
of its Zoning Board and holding a public hearing ten days
after notice to interested owners .
I herewith return Mr. Reilly' s letter to the Council and
suggest that it be referred to the Council' s Zoning Board for
study and recommendation. The plans of the petitioner are
changed from that which the Council originally approved, and
the Board' s recommendation should prove very helpful to the
Council.
Respect lly s bmitted,
.
0 J. GA
Spec . 1 As istant
Corp ration Counsel
. �y . ��, _
JJS:er � :�� �i"
att. . .� • ,
. � ��,a
��,, ,,-- L y.
J ,}.;
...t/
�O
Sept. 29, 1970
�
Mr. Daniel A. Kl.as '�
Corporativn Counsel /��
Building ,/ '
Dear Sir: i
The City Cauncil t�day adopted a approving the request ot'
R. William Rei11y f�r an ment o is 16g-car parking lot
application on the nor, d��c�P�Wil� Ave. between Hazel and
Luella Sts. due to t deletion und round parking.
Please prepare any o ument neces ry t4 concur in the Counc3.^I's
action.
Yezy truly youra,
City Cl.erk
AO/ng
oet. , 1970
s �
�.W�_`�_---� �
�.�
.
� '�--�_,. �
.�
_,.\ ,, �..
� ;
r��1r_ . '�,�;��ert T,. �'lrnes �
Ci_t,.� -�;•chitect ,�
T3ui 1�;�.n,�r �'�.�.,,,�
�
1i�a�� Sir. �� �.�\ `�\\
/ �� ��
Th� t;ity Cola.ncil. re. rrec,i �r� yau or investry.,p-��ti�n on ?�rl�,:�t f��rthex
�ctian is necessa.ry y the Counc the a.�t�ch�c� letter of R. �?itliam
Reilly, requestin� t t his par � lat ax�plication on �t�e na.r.th side
o�' T�'ils�n b Haz .t�nd_� a �;t�. b� ttmendeci,
._"' �
Very trulyv youxs,
AO�ng �`�-�,.�, City C1erk
��.-/ �,+ . _ . �
'•, ,r..�:��
L . _. . , ._. ..� . . _ _.. :�_... _ ._._...
.....,.._...�, � r �,,,� t
1 �.�, .«..w►:.:�.
"'�'�"�'�"'f""'�y�� ..�•.�...�.T.�,.i.�;�,wn.�..`r,•.+�„.a�.srw�'�:.r-1 r-.,.r r��..y.«t �a1r�2'mskcx�'C�7►�` . i . �si -- 7.."f'r. .
{ � + i � � t
i ± � � f � � ' � � � ' ' � ! � i ` ` � '
i � i 1 � � � � l � �� � � 1
- I � � � I� 1- :. {.. � � � f ! . _I � I� �, i � f. � i � I ,<-'-+--- ,
.
�
��`���- L�(,U �lsw;.j � t I
. ' : , 4 .,,� J;
� � � �
, � �, ; , � . t ; � , � , C , , , , ; , .. , _ � � _ � �,.
_ � ; ; , , , i ; ; � , �
i ( , ; , , , � � � , � � � ..�
, _1 ' � ' ; � ' � 1 ' : ' .ti„ ti'�}-:
, � �, 1 % �, . ' � � � � . + �I � . . � ' { �. �' i.,.tilt•- � . . . .
I � i _�� � ! I . ����'�-t. �
,
, . , :
� � '.w+!�'.. . �.++�.�.��.-.....-r.�r�e tos YF'..Y"<'m`r�"4'TT'C" . re�..�6.�Ik+Id��=ar+W � . },3 r�� .
a��,. ' ' ' _ . .�_.. . ,. '_ "_' .
'., I � -�--- . _ � ...}._ .. _ ..f -}-- ,^ j- . .. , __.�^ � ,
. ..� . i ,, � �
i--- - � � •�? �, �
�h . � �
'� ��e �,,. • :� - �
�,�� ��ry, .; �a�,il�� ° �_ ° __--_—---- �
�a, ��` :� �
r�;� _.. � � w
y �, �+..� 'i'���.r^��' � :��'�`3�,Y '.: � ` _.�. �
� �'
��'� _ �',4�� ���,`��,: i
�` ��• `�� `(?�-•� '
_ � �. . ��
�,.� �.;..;w,� � v+�4....�,�.,:�,c�.;.,... .c ,
'!� c�. t � ;
� \ . � /' �:A�f�v 7,l.rl.i-,�,,,�y�P...', - . . . . � :
d M1l', 1. ' . . ?
_ _. _ i . �E��.f?� ' 4y
-��,. `j * � , i
.�
:v.n•+- � ' 'I �F+.�� I � . . � � � _
� _' " :j ' ` ' ' '� ' - ----- ;
''_1'' � S i:«�ri`� �1��;» �� ' !
.-�. �.__......._,_ � .� � L,__�� � . . r� -r---1_...`-..-""- �.av�w.�r� � . � � , � _ .
. ) � ` �., .. � . .. . . ' ' .
1 `:� �
, ,.
� y.
.
« _ ........� ' ,`1 f
+ r- �
a : ;
�. . _ _. .y �,. _ r � �' . '___. .._ . ;..�....._.__��i :�".��I��� '
. � 3 " � �D � "'" � ' � � �� '- ' �
� -
� �i. �r � �'' ``% � �f ..>
.�_._. . .r.. . _.._ , . .__.- --w_ .- � . . Ir �
.
i �.; ���=�� �.. L�rfn, � _.. __. . .
, �. �_ � _�_ .
: �,�
,.;
,; ,r
� � 'y.,. ,��` �= :�
�— �� -___._...__._ ----. , ,
.__... , _._�._.
� '� . � . _. ,., . .._ { l� i
. �_...�. _ -_..�_ � . ' -- ____.,_, � . -- t 1�'-�,u i�
_ . .,_ . __ . _ j � `��-t-�- '``C��''. ' f . j `` ;}�� `
� � �-� ,--� - ___- _ ---- . _. _ ��.
� . ,>>..�. - 'E i '�'' i -`
_--_ __ ..�_. _� ` �.. y � � ' '
1 �,t r v��F .
� `� .1�.1�k � t j�r'.' .....i �_ �., �� XtS ' ,
�.. l�'� � f\1:�.
� f .
��.� 4 , t '�r . .'' . �.�.� ._.. �.. �`\ � 1:
� � � ���. ,l . . _. ,, . . � , }, y� . .
� i yI ��'� . 1 ' .. . . ^���
~.'S ' . ' ' (, � .A ��.
�/��� L" "...�.r__�y. , , Q�, - - . _- - ��
�.n f i �a , � ',,`�'.
..� • +�;
�S � � � � , � �T ...-- - - -- • ____ -_ � �
>'*,'�ir`.� .':L v��
�_ ..- __�. � j �. k� �: . ' . � t '.
.,. � ��— :,� i
=��, - �. ,., �,•�;' _.._ . . . ----- ., 1
� --i'
.�...._ --�._.__�_ +-'�1t:�, ��, .�y ,. r � ,�/ `M1`L � ,� `! ` , ,
�
:.
, � , ���
�,$�` � i'� ^1 \ ,.'.' .'_"'_...___�,N .�..�....,. "' i �, f .
�+�
._�-..� ......�..... �� �. . .' _ (
� /�.
. _..�. . - '. .. ,. �._..- ��,;�..�1,,y .�. ,
tyl "^ � <w. � ', � �.�_�� . ' ; ;. . �'t- .+'� ' .�.
. /1 '. �. � . ,� '
i l�1 � '(t. . . �' Y . � , . �.�. • ' - . . '�� j ' ,�• i ���yy'�+
i� �.� � . . � f . �# ' :��.
- , � ._�----�-� f . � � . ,.� . . . . . . . t r ��' ���. �,�,.
. ,
� • • . t
r ''
. ,. 1
. ti :. • ''.
+ . � �
.�___,_� i. . }. '�7 't � �'a �r.. ._. .. .. _ : _ __. � ' _� . .. ' ��•_ ' -. t � -j , " �'`? , .
_..� _
. � � . � :I'�r°� _ . ..` � _.._.. . _ . �� ' + y_1
..
;
, y .�
. ! ,� . � � � , e/-•,
r..
� _.._- _-- . i . � . � _ . . _- _ - . �
. � �:���� �t r���` r . �� � "�aj/- `..� Y�� y�1� /�:.J� .
.' '
� � �! .,� � .. . . . ... =` ��a . � .
.
. r.'
� i .1'��rFrY'"�.+ � •�•� .�l � ,^' . . .. .. . - .�..,_,_._.._ � ��Yy. _ .
,� ��. .._""�" , ��i . . . " ��� � '..1 � .. . .. ^�� �7�..��� � .. .. ..
`-_ , I��..� . . .. ' `.. . �� . . . . �'+ �. . . �
.�._..�... ._� - " .f�'� / � � . , `�/.',. . . � . . . ` . ��..._. ... ._. . . (
� � � �t.* ��I',A• .. . � � . .. . � ' . .' . _ _r . ' ! � .. . .. .
_....:_-' ,. .. � . � _ . . .
i
. _. __.�..t .� . . .. � . �._ _.. . . �
� _ ..,�•-. .. ..
i
�
� ° `
------ �.... _._... ��-r- , ; ; �: _ ��`� �
� >� , c', � ---..__. _. -- � � r;;l
. ',��,: ���!. . . � ��i ' '.
! ��* � .. . . . . . . � � . � +:7 . . .
..__._ ._..___.. _. _. i °' '`�`� � . _ � � �k ;
t- �.�,• �1 ,
� ^ `.r� , \ a__.�� .� ... . .1 � . . . . ' P ,`'+y���� .
.�� '. .a. . .
��..�
��....
_
. y '
. 7 � �� -. � . A... �. �M`" ��., 1. " . .
_ ' __�_ _ 1� t;1: a � ; ,''z '' t,i
�.�� " '` . , , _ _ r � . -
.
'. � . ': �� , . . i � _. ..�,... . �- ~' � L,� .
, I .. ... _-�. . .. �:� ,3";, �..
.
N � -�---- - __. � :� �,�4,�'
i , _ __. ;
____._ ____ . � }- �_ . ___ r, _...__ . ; �� �`'`` '
_ .._., i - . Cf�€-� � ,.___
` �
--4 � �� '
� : ���
.----- �
.
_. .___---- � . -
� ' � � `� � _ _ �__. � :
.* . : :
� i r . _..._---
� , ,
. , , _
---- ------t � � ,. ,_ ;
. ,,
-f- ....
, � ��
___ _ _ _ ... ..M __ _ �.__.�. -- - ---�. �
, ,
� y ��1� . � .. . ,�. . j ' � .
- � �-�,���yyI���- y � .��- �_ ti ����., .,�.�.��" � #
i. _ `� �`4� •`�(.9 i; t
._ .
� � � �
{.- 'i \ 4 . . . :��,,�. , . . � i . .
� � ;�J.`�•-'� � ,�. � ��i,,; ��'�"���� .� 1� �
'' , r�t �� `i�--'' � L;.r , ;, _ cr� ti� / '
, .,.". /�[�� .T� i ��x�y} . . �y�'. �.�y ,•.� +�� *`+y� ')' (S:� , ,�: .
,
V71 �, •.� ,� .. �lY. t1 �
i ,
_ . .� � ,_�.� ��t�:7 ° i
^"�——...._� �. _._._..•::+� T ' — _y a • � r ?q = t ...a.
� . .. . . � R -: . � �.'. 'f 1' ' .• l i,. �' j�.Y' ' � . . . .
� 4 h✓
.'!� ,iY ktrr� �11.t � �f fy.y, �',� J ; .
?�2 "��,;�
. . � _ y. � 4 ' "4 � ',�5 }� t.� , � -
{ � y
. �� ) i�! � ..�t t %'.1!� t..i'S f� � • ,'�eC� ^, f�ti f \ �� /, ���a� _.
/ � . �+}�1��" �.� � . � _�.��"� �,�r fii , � - ; , .�`� ��/� y �., •, ::;4' t +h �'r}�, _ ' . � � �;� ' .fr.. j�f �,' ..
�
.
1�,, � , j%j .�� � ,�, ;� F�� � , �lv� ! :f. . ' \r � '�/ �� ��\>r � ✓i . ;: '; � � YT ,�1�r%
�yt�� � `\� �t�. / i ..� .�- �� �L� �` � { rv r. '� . .t . �:' � ltt1.x' , `,t f� .,,' �fj • .
.� �r �`, ` /� ' � 1 `�' t j }
• � ` I i i . �.\ + i,,:.' �..:. . . � . . _ rS� ,. � . 1 ' � .
/ � ! ` . .. r, , . .
••�\\ ! �_ ���/ �^ `/� t w, 4' �,�„�.,�„� ..
. �
� �
i . .,�.
�} �� � � . _�a�...�..� .L,.ny�+ '. - ' 1� -.�� ; . '�...-�a - . ,►.M. �4.....�.-.►�- ... , ._ r,; ''r �; ?� .i
�� f , � . � ' f J,
.._ _ ..
. .._. .. ���A ',...._,..
, ,
e
���_ .. -• '\ 'r, r � .., �. , . ' ' . ' ' p +„�, .,.
/ — ` A '_i f.; +�rw
�I
.'.y!.. 0 • �• . � f� !. ......
`_., �.
.. . -. . ,�,F . � .
, :-S^
.. .. .. . „ .�..J f ♦. . ...
.
�,,,,�- �•,r..c` '. �� '-. i':. .� 1 �" ..., w..,,� y,. � Y ...,.... .�'� ... �� ,-' i � - � ... w ,Y� 'a� �l '�� � .
r �
., . .,.. � � . � � i .
\ •I �
' "?^,-r' � '"'� r.l�� / �` +." �" � '� , 1. ' � , ,; ' -,,`
� � /4 � � �_ � Xi � . 4 . ` . > � i ,
`� � � 1 '� ..._..�y.�,.. �.I-•'^- -�.��-r..m� t �% .�,/ .a,�,�rt �,�`�--, _.. �. ;r � ,--•.�. ...�... .,�....-L.I...�...�.1. ..v,�..� +�-�v-r-w�� . . ..
� . � ��`,`� ' ) .7�`,,1`� `� . f V -+�rl..� � ?•�_ _� « �Y—..,�..rt+++.rM�-�-�\ . •�� . '
�.� ��1��\. �i.� . i.t�.i . '�.�.t �� � . : . • 1 . . 'I '' �.��\. .� . '. � . . .
' f, ► �� � � C.,,�".��`.,.,�, ��`� ° ��4�t� +�zc����i �;'+Q.. ' � �
Q•;+S�tlnt�rstt�t n vvnw W�hc'i p+�4�'�x+e`�q►ot�t 9�,s f�tl ',
- - , ���•�� i« .....� _....�, :_ ,. ._. .. _:....._.,{_!G''� 1.'cu.i,o"a ,;
.�._�._....w...- r
— -----------— —_ _
— . _ �
��
��
h.:
k;;
;;:�
�
,,�
�
'a
(t
''�
-- ---_.__._.._._._._ _ ..._ ..._._ ___.__.- —___..__..._._._�.__........_._._..__. .,__........__._.__--.._.. .__..._..._._ .,K
^i
> -� '2___'�C�'_ � '�� 1 �l�-T�-;
;
� - ���I�t�I�C:.� � ��� �
i
- I ��, � � �1
� �:
- 2 ��. � / I �/4 ��T';-� `
� �I � %
� �.�
} �� �i��.-, `'ti:J ' ���i� `,�.�Q 1.��`�� j p -0 f s�
, �
� <r
u� �-rG1 ;
- .- --. _ ___. _ _ .. _____.
___ --- _. _____.._.__.__
__--- _ _.---__-----------
;
� __.
� fi�x "
w,
�,'a
.�µ�
�a:�,
� ' �'
,,, ��
,���
�,�
� � ��
�
, �
����;
;
`�
���:
{�N
, :
����
� '
, „���
��S i 2S f 1;;
_ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____ .__-__._______---____-� ----�- ; ,,��
*
_. - _ �L� ' -_. -_ ��T•S 5 -� ;f
� _ _ . �.
- - - - -- - - - - �---,�- ��
_ � � ��
� _� �q�
� M r�
. - �V�
� �: ���
_. . __. ._ _ � —`�-_.—
—_-_--�__._� --�__ � � `� `��
�,�.
,.., j �,�
` f ��",�
' ��,til
1 ����;
,
<�� _)���,;;� -����'�; �fl�.i4 ��� . ` f N �
�-+ (p �=,:.k��;_-4'*':�-��.� P/�('��-'� i — ; r�
O ; � ! �,
�- � ���_
i �'..�
Gt
---- - .�,
- . ,
� , �
____ � _ � `� � ����
-- -�-- ; ,
�_._ -�-�
1 � �, ,
L�. _.._.. ..__t1 ! � �..— ----__— �'�---_,� t
i
� , ' , :
� � �
;_ _ _. _. a � 1 rt. _. _ . .. 4 _ .__._._. ,� _. _.... _.�__ ��
—, . � �,
� �_ ,
.+� -_...� �
� �
_ _.-- , _Y� �,�,,,� , � � �
,;
� -� ; 4
�` � ____..�--i_.�_J� �G�w_ _ ; . ; . � tt�
s
� � ��
..�.. "J_._.._�`._ � _. . ...,.. i .'�'. ��% � r�tE'
l`
� f__. ��� ��-.�c-�2EA��r-� �[. '�. � � ; ��1
, � .
f , � .. � ; �� ��
�_,�__ ^. . .\ ,� . � ��.. ���''T'° 4 . f�
� ^J
� �� ' . _ .. . '; .
_ `t ��; t. _ .. r , 3$sti
� � ; t l�St
y .
,.. --� -�—.,i! ..�� t ..�. ��_� _ . ...`. ,...,_, __..._....,.__ . . ' .:'�� �..
. '' ."'_.....,_._�..,._. .,............_ ....,i-.. ..._ ._..._.... ., ..-.__� ..,.. � ��
� ' y
1 i'�__.�.�� , 1 � y ,ni�*�
... ... .. . .i i �;I �.. ��-.. , r mt,j,r£
.
s,\ �
i ' `}�"Y���
{ �
._....._._.......__�y j y . � � i y+ f..
7
�1
� .� , � _.._ . � y5;_�
� � :
' �.. �. .� ! .
w.
.
..._..._� . .
� .. .. ;. ' .�� � ...� . ,:y�'�,..
....–l�- ...
. ... . , , . . .
� (.
♦� � � � � � �. -
i �.. ,:'� . . , �...� . . ' . �,.
�__._.... .— � ..... 4U .t _�. ' .... f � . y y
� �� �., C � ' �:�,�'.
, �
� � � � , . � , _ � �.
� � �� � .
,
, __ .�.� � :
_ _
� r- , ,_...
W,�
�_ � _ `, � ; �,�,.
- �� ':,� � �'`. � _ � � ����, � ,;�_�:
�-„ '
i �
_� . � .. , _ � ; �, F .
- � ��.
-- , ,
i _ ' ��!�
..
� 1. . . .
.. <
4--'"'–._ �\'\ ._. ' ; „�,�.
_...___...._.._"_� ' ,r_.�.__ '-- - ,., t � � _� � '� .
� _...
�
__ --} _ , � � f
�
____ _- -___�. �, .___ . __ +-_—�=� . ' ' -ry�'.
fi------- . �,._._. ._ .,_ � . ._
� ' �
L—'
;
�
� _.- ..� {� r� �l -�-,�/
�.._ _�� 1 . F-��--i'"���1 c�r..-S 1�.�._.-q,..� � _Q
I � i �:�
._ .-...., ; �'_. .,-' 1 ,T� ; . .
�-----'—�'- .. , i V
. � f,A� �
;
�' " r —_.._.�� ,�'� . itJ .,
_'------�. � i . .' ' . . . � �#
1 , � �'�'" �
� ' r . �..—.. T^— . . . . . ._. _ . __..._ �. . .
_. ._.: � _ �. �, � .
__
� .— ;
� �
, y'
".__. _._�....-« ......... ... . .�.. ... _t �.��
_ ._j � . ._. . 7j�` .
. i � �
.i . . . .....,..,�. L._.-...�..�.�...�., i . .
_'
._._.._. . t I
il
� . _... _ � . .
� .
�.,
' _ __..�. . F.. . ; . ' � ' ' „t
, �:.. ' � I. � . .s+
�� l,� : i
.__.. . --� i.,� . ';.. : .. � �, i . : •;..
1;� �,i �. t �� � .
. . � �.t. . j.... . ' I � . .
� i ., �• � ,. � ! .
� � ( �', I '�..-�, .
i
.. . -.1... � ,.,. ^!,. '., ' � � � ��
�
�,J W— ` � . . � . o',+ aN'�
t. .. <� ��. . i' �� ; . ,
' �{
t '_' .: '., , , .
_.... ....._i :. �,. �.,. . . �.._. � �
� � � TM :�
� t '�
._
� . >
; ,
_ _� t ..
�
, , .
' �------ � '
, ...._ ,__
... ,_� � ..�.._.._ ....._.. . ....._., '-. * '-• _ i � ' I . � +k��
} _ ._ -�__._.__ ,.--- /���+N i
���. --�-�---__.+..__. f�, /`-1f^�` �...14 4,.,,� . � m�y',�
� ` ` �
. ._.. _. .i } - - : t,�,�'.4r� �� . `� �•U f . �'�
,
,
+,
� � `. � a�r�a �7 �r ;,
_. i } -� `� N �"'L_ �� �IC't�-"�„t"J � �
.` • Su � � �.
.
- 1 � ��'�` - � _ - ,s�.at.� �
, , .----- �
�{ � ',` r.�r—__.- _fi__ (�.��'�= 1 r �
; i i �
_._ � , - { i ! . �
., I �, � .. . + _ ,> '
-.._: � k � I �
� � — ' N I ` �
, ,
, � >
__.� � . - fi `) v► i ���
i , 'ti , ; .=� � ,
,_..... :
, , ; N � ��
_.—� ---1 , `. :� � � �� � � �� �� ,�,'
, , i ; �
? 1 , i — _ , ,
, .. .
, , .
, �. _1 , � ^, ( � � � � �,�
�J I � �' ' l.�4 jfi
" ' �._ ; ?�c��
; ; �� , , �
'� ' � ` .� . �:: �
� � ,.. � ; ���
�� � �4
� `\; �`� i ; a
� ; � � .� ; �
J i ; •,. �`\ �, I i i ��
�-;� � \ � ',\ I i .LT;`.
� \( � i � .� �{ ,: .:
.� � - � i % � i . � ��� .
� J/
� 1 �
__-. � ..._—�J/ j: .
� 1 �
., �-- i . . ,,,
� -- �:
' ` �� �ll ' ' � , � � �� ,�" =:°�:e
; ,
� � �� ;�
____._ . �_
_ r�' _.;i' � _. ; '� : 4,..
..�. .r � 1 . '�Yp ..
� ! �
�
� l* � "
_ --� , _
Y � �� (� ��— ' j . . . . :..4y�
i r� . ..i : ' .. � f 5
i
� _. , _
y � � 1 � ' �; #,:
I
. ____._._
; , `�rJ_ �7;,� , �-__ 1 �'�
.t._. Ir I r
;
�
- - � : 1 �- i : �l,,
_- _ _._._._� , ;
_ ___� ' t� 1 i ��`
�� i s,.
_f 1 �__ __ __— � ; V �
I_ �:.. "— �r ' � � . A'. e,�.
� � ' {��y::
_� � �� �_� ; ' � ,+'�
, . �
, ,� , �
+ .= _ ,
, :
_ --�- .
Y / __... ... ... ..........._._, .......,..... :h#'.,
, �� ,. . . ; ; � �i
� �
/ � ' �
; /
� y� �
: � . � ' � . ?P�
.... .__. ', .,- / _ ' �.,. .
� . `� � � � .. . � i . ,{ ���..
� . ..-�� � ' � r
i
..r�� �� . .. . .
. ,.,. .w'� � , yw
_'____...._.� . . .
. �'� . .. `~� . . ,
_..-..
, ....— �__.-, .. �r
' ' - . '�..,.�—,Y--""' ` ' � . . . � 5`",-
v ._.._�__:_� ___....._---.»- t ,�y�'�
_.�__-– ,:�4
_ _. ': .r �
; ��
-- `�� ---'.""'._._.--.��''� �� �� `*� �
�`
, ! �
___ _._
� �
?.
�� __ -- __ .� � � h
. . . � . . . r .µ1a
�� �`,, - . . . „�
—_ � _ _�_ __' � ' � � � '
k
.:
'_ �. � '_.�."__ ' ' ' '_ � __�_�. . . ,�Y�"
._. _... __. /"{}''1 , ' . ' ' . _ —' . . ,�
Li ..,._ .- � � . --- — �. F�
� � . ,� . ,, . . ..
,
�
� � � ' j , . ^;.
*��
\ i �., ' t � - , . `.
�
. � _`---------____._-'._'-.-.._......___...._..__..__ _.`,-. .__...__.___......___ -�,,.� . . '
h ''
i � ` � � � � � ��
_ _...___�__.�,_�_
. ,�� i � � ; � � �
�
- , , � f 2�
. �.
-__.._._- , � ��
�, } .. _ _^.r .. .
M .� �/i I 4 '� ..._� � �...... .. ., �. ' ��
� . 1{- .__ . ._ . _....._. ..._ .. . . . ... . .. ..._._ . ._'___�___'___ ._,_.__.._..._ _�.. _' �.___.�._ . � . �
�Y '...... .,.....-��/7 ..
� I <-- (` �.� `—�"L r"�' -�" L �. .S '.�
� ��� ., ';L _� -_ � ) � ,--�. �f T .
1 i �.
r��, ti�}� ,..�-.1..� �j��• '. �.0 ������/'„� .. '✓��M.
,— r +
y�' � � U U 4'+ � �.'�' '�, 3 � S � c��:..�= ''Z ",�u�,.
� Ii� � �-���;�'`i:a r-� '�C-� �F,�'.���..�c� f�:.-''�t'?'!�a t�1 ���.,,
L» �+ :
� ',+t:,
-�.a ,�-, �;X :
MAY . • �`,. :;,:�
CI?Y PLAMNtNG BOARQ ,� '`
r��,�'��
Saint Paul,MinttesOC:a ��!�fl� 1�!� �� L E N��-! �� � �r�,.�
`��,',
;�°
�h .
;r�,.
�
SHE�T NO. �^ �
;Ri�Z�I�T r�_RCHITEC;T�, II�TC. �-�'�"� ��:�..r�,r�-� , �
��;�,
T.� ",a,� ��.
I �' E l� I T �' 1 V 1:: '�` l� E N�
� :� , :
L N.
, :�t I \ �' . T I_: L . 6 =� 6 — ; 3 6 1 � ;F a:�.��'
SCA LE._ � i:. �.4,�.
�^ �;�
�..d;..��" .