The URL can be used to link to this page

247190 Oriainal to City Clerk . ' � ORD � NANCE ��'�� v _�� COUNCIL FILE NO PRESENTED BY i�v`�''�� ORDINANCE NO / � An o�dina�ce a�endiM� the Zonir�g �ode, C�a.pters 6� �0 6�, inclasive, of �he Sai.�t �aul I,eg�slative Coc3�, pertainir�g to �se �istri�t�, H�igk�t �i�tri��s and Rezoning of eertain proper- �ies in the �ity of Sa3.nt Paul�, as a�tended. � �DUNCIL OF � �I�.'Y OF SA73i� PAUL D(�E: ORDAI�T s . S�ctio� 1. �hat �he �onirr�g �ode, �k�apters 64 ta 6�, inalnsiv�, of the 3ai�t Pa�1 Legisla�ive �ode, pert�.ini�g to �Tae Distriets, ��ight Distri�t� and ��zoning of a��sin propertiea in the �ity of Saint Paul, a� a�ae�ded, be �.r�d tl�� same i� hereby f�trth�r a�ended so as to rezone the followir� d�seribed p�opert�r fro� "B" Residenae Distri�t to "C" �tesidenae Distriet, to-wi� t Lot� 16-18, �1oa1� 7, Winter's Additio� �o St. Pa�zl, and that part of t�e ��F� of the SE� of Sea. 26, T. 29, R. �3, co�eneing at -th� 1�E eorner along No. vicstoria St . 131.5� oP point of beginni�g of prope�ty to be de�cribed; ther�ee �onti�aui�g north alo�g �o. Yi�to�3.a St. 118.5' ; t�e��e eaat 150' ; the�¢� sDUth 11.8.5' ; t�ien�� _� west 15�' to poir;�t of beginning; si��ate on prope�t;� lo�a.ted on the soutY�east corner of �ngl�wood Avenue and North Viatoris �treet in t�ie City mf 3a�t Paul. Sectio�a �. Thi� ordinar�ce shall take effeet and be in foree thirtY (30� days from and after it� pas��ge, approvsl and publication. _ s�eKr w:rswc Notie��bsbheId �cs t?a�C1��r� C�a��J1q.�Y[w.c,!�1 JC,h�amb�er 1�i�'7i CitY I�II anQ CAUrt House.in the ma ter of`the appeal.af Northwestern Sta sank. w�aor �pcere so to s4 �nciu sive, �t. Paul r��8tive Code, Zon Code, ior the waLver of a 48-ioot se back in ¢onaectlon with erection business.e�n (heiShC district) on 23, 24. 25 and 2d8, Block 3, Hil�s - tion.�l�o�cate$ on 'the xwrth pas oi �dora �1sAve. fixtwwa As�de d Cny Cl�rlcYA�WJII.L.. (Ianuas'Y S. WAO) f E B 13 1970 Yeas Councilmen Nays ' Passed by the Councii Carlson �-- � �- � In Favor er�t'edYthr Peterson � Againat Sprafka 19�� Tedesco F E g 13 Mr. President (Byrne) Att �"' Ap oved: City erk - � �ay r� � �� orm approved Corporation Counsel By f � PUBLISHED ��Q� 2� �9ZO a , • � ♦ ' � 1 , CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA � 4 `. , , � . � . PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE � Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- C 0� �fication before signing this petition. For further information about the �' �j\ rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. '� \ (Please type or print) ��\� Date: May 6, 1969 � TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property: (legal description and street address) . i 5.�. Corner Englewood and Victoria St. ` Lots 16 , 17 and 18, Block 7, Winter' s Addition to St . Paul , and that part of the SW4 of SE4 of Sec. 26, T. 29, �0 23 commencing at the N.E. corner of Victoria & Minnehaha, thence N. along Victoria �treet 131 .5 feet �'o ef point of beginning of property to be described; thence continuing N, along Victoria Street 118.5 feet thence E. 150 feet , thence S. 118.5 feet ; thence W. 150 feet to point of beginning. 3. Molin Concrete Prod. Co. Cl� '�'� � �•� e�e��h John J. Rongitsch & 5. Laura B. Ron itsch 2� �. Barry J. Merriman & 6 Nanc L. Me�riman ,�; �� Laurel A. Norman Donald L. Bauer & . :�-c.c 8. Arlene M. Bauer 9. Alice R. Lindeke , ► -__ _ __ - --- _ _ 10. Holin Concrete Prod. Co.��v ��, ' � tuyene r. �rosxa a� �J� 11. SAirl• C. Kroska James J. Pral.utsky & 12� Erika J. Pralutsk Robert G. Goeritz & ; � � �- ; �� 13 1�abe1 S. Goeritz / �G . - State of Minnesota ( Co ty of�R msey � ss - _ ✓ , � being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of pages• , that the parties described above are�the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so descr' ed. � Subscribed and sworn to before me �` this �/.�! day of� ��6� � ' /� --�L�c� Add re s s; y�C� �i�ft-� �!( ��2�-L/ Telephone No. '4p / " ylo'g� Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn. My commission expires Approved as to form 1/4/65 FREDA E. OLSEM1, Nota�y Public, Ramsey C�.,M'ni� Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 My Cammission Ex�ires Navember 5th, j973 / . • . ' . • BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL �`��l��o� 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 January 14, 1970 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Dear Mr. Marshall: This is written in response to the petition of William C. Molin to rezone from "B" to "C" Residence property located on the southeast corner of Englewood Avenue and North Victoria Street. This property is further described as: Lots 16-18, Block 7, Winter's Addition to St. Paul, and that part of the SW'� of the SE� of Sec. 26, T. 29, R. 23, conanencing at the NE corner along No. Victoria St. 131.5' of point of beginning of property to be described; thence continuing north along No. Victoria St. 118.5' ; thence east 150' ; thence south 118.5' ; thence west 150' to point of beginning. This property consists of 17,775 square feet with a frontage of 118.5 feet along North Victoria Street. The site is vacant and at the grade of adjoining streets but lower than the abutting property to the south which is occupied by a gas station building. West across North Victoria Street is a concrete products company and to the east are single-family residences. The Comprehensive Plan recommends multiple-family use at a "C-1" Residence density for this site and the area to the east. The now vacant Home of the Good Shepherd facility is to the southwest and the area is included in the Thomas-Dale Neighborhood Development Project of the Housing and Redevelopment Authority. This matter was considered at the July 17, August 7, November 20, and December 18, 1969, Board of Zoning meetings. At the first consideration the staff reviewed its report and concluded that the proposal would provide a better land use progression than presently exists, would help revitalize the area, and would be in conformance with the recommendation of the Comprehensive Plan. The plan, however, recommends a lower density and the proposal should be evaluated in conjunction with development of the Good Shepherd property and future Neighborhood Development Program plans. Mr. Molin explained his rezoning request noting that he hoped to construct a 23-unit apartment building on the property and a portion of the gas station property to the south which he also owns. He noted the absence of neighborhood opposition and said that the Housing and Redevelopment Authority felt that the proposed use would be a welcome development. A motion to recommend approval of the petition failed for lack of a second and subsequently, the Board laid over the matter to August 7, 1969. -1- t`i G„;�y...t�..� � �;. d � � V William C. Molin (continued) January 14, 1970 At the request of the petitioner the matter was again laid over to November 20, 1969, at which time the staff report was summarized. The Board discussed this proposal, the possible acquisition of the property as part of the Neighborhood Development Program project, and the position of the Housing and Redevelopment Authority and PAC group on the rezoning. Subsequently, the Board decided to again consider the petition after receiving further information. At the December 18, 1969, meeting the staff reviewed their conclusions noting that the proposal would be more desirable at a lower density and if any apartment development also utilized the gas station property. A letter from the Frogtown Community Council was noted in favor of the rezoning. Mr. Gerald Mangle of the Housing and Redevelopment Authority noted that they are trying to return the land use to residential rather than industrial and that the redevelopment plan for the area is for multiple-family. Mr. Molin again appeared in behalf of his petition and noted that if his concrete plant is removed, they would like to build apartments on that site also. Subsequently, a motion was made to recommend approval of the petition which failed for lack of a second. A motion was then made for denial which carried by a 4-1 vote. The Board of Zoning members, in recommending denial of this petition, noted spot-zoning, poor zoning district boundary, too high of density, and exclusion of the adjacent commercial property from the rezoning petition. Very truly yours, � � ' - �� /� � �� i �� PETER J. MAIETTA � Secretary, Board of Zoning PJM:ga f CLS Z.F. �k6792 -2- b ' . r/ / . . i y � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE � , C1TY OF SAINT PAUL , MINNESOTA � , I 13 Court House,66102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner LOUIS H.MeKENNA, Dspufy Commiuionar Phons:223•4646 June 5, 1969 To the Cagt�c i 1 City of Saint Panl Gentlemen: I have checked the attached petition of Williaa C. Molin, filed in the �atter of rezoainffi, Lots 16, 17 and 18, Elock 7, Winter's Addition Ce St. Panl, aad that part of the Sot�thwest � of the South- ea:t � of Section 26, Towuship 29, 8aage 23, coe�encing at tke northeast e�raer af Victoria Street and Kianehaha Aveane, thence North al�ng Victoria Street, 131.5 feet 7o ef- point �f beginaing vf property to be described; theuce coatinuing l�orth alang Victoria Street, 118.5 feet; thenee East 150 feet, thence Sonth 118.5 feet; thence West 150 feet to poiat of beginnin�. The pr�erty is located on the sontheast corner of Englewood Avenue and Vict�ria Street, frv� a Class "E'` Residence District te a Class "C" 8esidence Dis- trict, and fiad that said petition is s�fficient. Yours very trrt�.q, „ � � '/�� L�-'�==�"� '�r� ��ames J. Dalglis�j`%�� Comissioner of'Fiaance �e: %-727 c.c. Isr. Aae s K. R. Heiden Fr�ntage: 88'x Parcels Eligible - 17 Parcels Sigaed - 15 or 88� peeded - 12 or 66-2/3X �� '"'J a/ � 17117 . � - August 7, 1969 D�AR� 8f �?NIN,� REPORT AND A,CTI�N , . November �6, 1969 , £ �; Dece�nb�r li, 1969 t�,�t 11�� /�b Actin� und�r L�gislatiw C� Chipt�r 60 thru 64 nsss'd Auc;ust 22� 192� as aint�drd to April 6� 196A 6792 -• �'':"��l�;A:i'(''S NA'iG t Yillia C.�Moli� � ::. �:!,',SSIPICATt�bI :! C� MMi��! �Ap� ❑he�it �4tlwr X-72T _ :�. ' ��tP�)3C � �ss� tro� "r' te '�'" M�i�ee 4 • :,ixAT10N ; d�tl��t ca[w�i of l�l�wo�i �v�raui �d porth Victoria Stre�t y• "�r'�� nE��t�'ipr � 1.�t� li•18� �lock �� Mitt�t�� i�, to St. Paul� & that part of the SM} of th• SL� oi S�c. 26� 'lowai�;� Zg� �� 23� c��neing �t the NE corner . aZo� Victori� 6t. l�l.s• ot ML�t ot �. �! p��rty to bi describ�d; thence coa- � tinuie� � �lowa Vittwri• �t. i1�.S�; ttNwc• � 1S0'; thesc� S 118.5'; thence W 150' f:. P";�5CNT ZONINCI �� • �' �s�� to poi�t of beginnin�. 7. ?i:RS`�AyT 'M 74nift� Cod� Cltyt�l M► �ot�o�11 .0� hr�t�aph t 9. STAt'f INYES?If.AT10N t R�pOitT� Mtl�� /1�/69 �n� 11/i2/6! iyt ATg �nd CI,S A. SUlTICIEIICY: 11�e Cow�i�*tawr ot tis�u�� iN � 1�tt�c ��ted 6/5/69, declared the petitioa �utfici�wt Mitl� tA� v��r� o� 1S oE • paa�i►I� 17 (�8X) tracts hAVing •isnsd the ptitioa. a. HISTORY: Motss tat th! Ptoptcty ��r ew�l�K�ttN. �. P�liD USL: 23-unit �rlwt wild ira�ti a portioa of ti�e r � � � �1�� wv�►u� utiliziwa p op�rty �se�ytN br � ��lliw� rt�tioa to the •outh md ssAe1 Co�rrci�l. A' r' �� ' � ��r�f � � tr�� oi lli.! ie�t •la►a Morth Victoria Street vith a ilpti� ot 130 l��t rtwlt�lar i� N �rw of 17,775 squK• feet. � �' ��'� ��.I�� The �ry t• �1� �� «+� �Nt !• sowed "1'' �sidence; �d�oining to the �outh is Cawerci�t; �ad to t1» w�t i• soww Li`Rt I�dustsy, , t. CA�iPREHEN3IV� p�N: !#� Ca��A�yiw tl�w reca�nded R-i (ZS d.u. per acre) for the blocka tast ot Yieteei• �trMt aw� a�eth •t MiRa�h�h� Av�nue� •nd R-7 eaet �d west of che�lia�e •f tM �o�or ShN1�ee�; the rsat of the •re� resain• is it• exi�cing clas�ificatiow. C• � _�IT[ CONDITI�: Tl+� stt� ta weMt wd p'spi��ir �t •treet grade. --y__--- — �------ .,._ H. AREA CONDITIONS: Weat acroa• Victoria St. ie the Molin Concrete Prod, Co. 1b the north ia vacent land �nd •inale-fawily uses and to the ea�� end south are mixc�d one �nd two-family uses. Th� �rea ia in the Thomas-Dale NDP and the areA PAC has reco�ended approval. _,_� Council Letter 9. �OARD ACTION; To R�co�dd �Approval L�D•nial Dated 1/14/70 '�ov�d by: McPartlin Y�aa fJays Date of }iearinj�� x ,4mes S�cond�d bys Gauger Coh�n 1/15/70 x Danna (Alt) Council Action Gadl�r x ��r Secretary's :wnark�� ?yai�tta x T�ate � K P1c:'artlin (Alt) Man�ur (Altl � MINUTL�S OF THE PUHI.IC HEARING BSFORE TEiE BOARD OF 7AN7NG oa Thursday, July 17, 1969, at 2:00 Pot1, FRESBN`I': Messre. Danna, Gadler, Gauger, Maietta, and Mansur of Che Board and Mr. Sorenson and Miss Poechmaan of the staff. Mr. McPartlin arrived �t 3:d0 P,Ma but did r:ot vnte. WII.LIAM C, MOLIN: An application� tv xe�,�ne �'rom "B" to "C" Residence property laceted on the sou�heast cozr��r of L�ngl�wood Avenue and Victoria Street. Mr> Sorenso�z summarized the s�aff report noting �hat 8 23-unit apartment building fronting on Engle�rood w�s propc:��d. The property has a fror�tage of 118.5 feat along Victori� �treet �+itl� �a depth of 150 feet r�sulting in an are� of 17,775 square feet. The ar.e� to the north and e�st is zoned "B" Res�.dence; ad joinfng to the souti� is Co�mnercia�.; and to the west is �o�.ed Light Industry. 2'he Compreh�nsive �'Ian. recom�ads �-6 �25 d.u. per acre) for the blocks e�s� of Wictoria St�eet and north of Minnehah$ Avenue, and t�-7 east and west o� th� Home of the Good Shepherd; the rest of the srea re�ins in its ex�s�ing classification. The subject site is vacant amd sppY•oximately at street �rade. :ir. Sorei;son gave th� fol�.dwing po�tn�s i�e f�vor of the rezoniag: 1) the Coumxe�ensive Plan recoae�en�ds multi-fam�.ly use; ?_y most �esid�ntial niseA in. zhe �nre� 8re e�lder s�nd vi��lizatiora x.� ncvded; ead 3) the proposal wauld improve land use progression. �ie g�ve t�,e fr�3l.owin� poiaats against the �iroposal: 1) the Comprehensive Pl�n r�nd ttae xecent atuay x�.rmiy reco�snend e:he multi�fnmily use and development �e �es�ricted to R�6 or 1°C-1"; and 2) this area should be evaluated in canj,.�nctian with the property of the Home of the Gcaod Shegherd c,�3aich is avaa.l.�b�� for develoFment. Mr. W�.Zligm C° Molin, the applicant, pre��en�ing a drawing of the building that they intend to build, sAid they woc4�d tiak� enou�h of the service station now on the site fn urdes ta build a 23-�xnit apartmenC building. Mr. Gadler wented to knaw ff Mr, Molin had an archi'�:ect for L-hE plans yet; was toid he c:id not. Mr. Molin said the site is lev�l wLth Engl.ewood Avenue but lower than Minuehaha Avenue, and noted tha� tk�.��X� were no oppanents at the meetfng. Mr. Mol�.n said all peaple contacted were in favor of the rezoning; 15 of the 17 poas�ble (88�) signed �he getitio�. Mr. Gauger talked about the Home of �he :;ood Shepherd; safd there is slot of are.� that will hgve to be dewelop�d sametime in the futare. pir. Moli•c� said Mr. J�rry Mangle, a representative from the Thomas Avenue NPighborhood Development I'rogram comm�en��d that �he 23-unit apartmeat building would be a welcome development. -3- The site wou2d allow 14 or 15 nnits to be constructed if the present $as eCatfon Would stey there. Mr. Molin does not yaat to cut daam hia plan fr� 23 units to 14 aaits. Mr. Sorenson s�id a uumber of things could be dane in this area -- that whatever is proposed for this ares would probablq include same mixed densitiea -- apart�ents, duplexes, etc. Mr. Maietta seid as lang as 8a7'. of the land owners had signed the petition, he naved for approval. The moCioa fail�d for lack of a eecond. Mr. Danaa moved far a layover to be ab�� to study the area more thoroughly. Mr. GadZer seccmded the motion, wizic'n carried unanimously. Auguat 7, 1969, was the date set for the next hearing on this petitioa. Submitted by: Colonel L. Soreusoa Robert L. Ames, C'haf.rmen -4- MINUTES OF T� PUBLIC HEARING B�FOBE THB BQAxD OF ZONING on Thureday, August 7, 1969� at 2:00 Pa�to PRESEHT: Messrs. Ames, Danna, Gauger, McPartlin, and Maietts of the Board and Measrs. Brawn and Sorenson and Miss Poechmann of the staff. WILLIAM C, MOLIN: A petition to rezone from "B" to "C" Resid�nce property Iocated on tha southeast corner of Englewood Aveaue and Victaria Street. This was a laq-over matter from the July 17, 1969. Board of 2oning meetiag. Mr, Sorenson said that at the applicant's request, this matter will be further laid over until the November 20, 1969, meeting. Mr. McPartlin moved to have the matter laid over, and Mr, Maietta seconded the motion, which carried unanimously. Submitted bys Colonel Lo Sorenson Robert Lo Ames, Chairman -2- MINUTLS OF THE PUBLIC HEARING BEF�ORE TfiE B(aARD OF ?ANZNG on Thursday, November 20, 1969, at 2:00 P,M, PRESENT: Nessr�. Arnes, Cohen, Gadler, MaietCa, and Mcl'artlin of the Board and Messr�. Brown and Sorenson and Mrs. Fr�n�zen of the at�ff. WILLIAM G� I�iO�IN: A petitibn to rezone from "B" to "C" Residence to allow for construction of a 23-unit apartmeret building on property located on the south- east corner of Englewood Avenue and North Victoria Stre�et. This matier was laid over from ,7uly 17� 1969. Mre Sorenson sumsnarized the steff report atating that the property is in an N,l3,Po area. The site h.es � frontage of 118.5 feet aZong North Victoria Street with a depth of 150 feet resulting in an area of 17,775 sqceare feet. The si.te is vacant and approxfmately aC street grade. West across Vfctoria Stree� is the Molin Concrete Products Compsny; north is vacant .laud and singl.e-family us�s; east and south is m:[xed one and two-family ases. AZthough multiple-family could be a pro��r use for this sitey Mr. Sorenson concluded rhat the st�ff is concerned sbout the density �could be re2oned to "C-1" Residenc� instead) and that the site on thia corner should be developed as one package. Mr> Sorenson said that the P�� group in the erea was reqtxested tco make a recamanendation on this rezoning. A fo�sner question about the Good Sheparct �Iume hae been taken care of since the W3.lder Foundetxon now owns the property and uses it for private eduea�ional fscilities and possibly future eld�rly hausing. Mr. Maietta �s�ted how �any uni�s cmuld be bua.lt tihere and was told the proposal is foz 23 unf�s, using p�rt of the prsse�t gas staeion. Mr. McPartlin stated �hat thP Ho�asing and Red�velopment Au�h�rity rev�rewed the area and h�ve thia p�operty listed for acqcaisi.tion. Industrial properties wi1Z be reused for housing purposes; 40�-50(3 new housing ut�its are proposed for the area. It is first on the lis� for acquisi�ion in 19700 Mr. Gsd�er m�n�ioned laying it over ag�in to obtain a repart from a Planning Bosrd subcoumn£ttee that Mr, McPartlin said wauld be reviewfng the Hoeasing and Redevelopment Authority's Report. Mr. Wi1F.iam C. Molin, the petitioaer, said he waa told the Housing and Redevelopment Authority agr�ed ehat the propexty should b� rezoned. Mr. McPartiin stated just the opposite. No other persons appeared on ttais mgttero Mr. Gadler moved for a l�yover to receive further in�ormetioae on th� matter. Mr. r;aietta seco�deci th.e moeion, w�ticts carried unanimo�sly. 'The mmex� me�ting was set for December I8, 1969. FoZlowing the vote, Terrance Mid�s of i:he Housing and Redevelopment Authority appesred and submit�ec3 a la�tter from the Thomt�s-Dale PAC groupo This letter expressed approval of the Molin rezonir+g. Submitted by: Colonel Lo Sorenson Robert �o Ames, Ch�irman -2- . MzNU'TES OF '�HF. P'I7BLIC HE�RIIYG BEgOR� THE BOARD OF ZONING � an Thursd�y, Dr�cember I8, 1969, at 2:00 P,1�1a PRESENT: riessrs. hmes; Danna, Gau.ger, PfcPartlin, and Maietta of the Bosrd aad Messrs. �3row�i and 5orenson and Mrs. F*_'antzen of L•h� staff. WILLIA?�; G!. r10LIld: A pQt-L�ion to rezan.e from "B" to "C" Residence to allow for construc�l.on of�a 23-ur�it a;�artment bua.l�i�g on properiy locnted an the southea�t corner of Englewood �Ivenue t�nd North �'ictot•i.a Street.. �h�s m,�tter w�as 1�z�1 ovp�� f��r: �t2c Ja?.y L7 and November 2.0, 1969, meetings �.n order ta determir�e what plz�ns the Housing and Redevelopment �,uthoriF�y has for the area. 1�'r. Sorenson agsin summ�rized the star:f reporty a part nf the file, and cancluded Chat tlae �om�rehensive P�.an recnmmends rr•.ult?.�Ze-family use and that the proposal would improve the presei�L l�and-v.se �rogreasion� He a7.so csoted, however, thaC a "C-1" Zoning at ?_5 ritaelling un:�ts per acre may �e more desirable and in agreement with the densi.ty of th� �c�mpretiensi.ve Plan. He also n�ted rhat an apartment development proposal tizat would incl�ide the land occupied by the former gas station on the norLheast carner af North Victo.:ia Street and West N:innehaha Avenue would be more desLrable. A letter from the rrogrown Community Counci.l was noted. Mr� Geral.c� Mangle of the Housin.g anc; Redeve:.opment Authority read this letter which, in shart, stated that due to soil �and:i��_+�ns, high-denbiLy housirig wanld be the best use for �his area. The Caunci�. feels Y.he property should be rezone� �.o allow apartment development. Nr. McParti:Ln tol.d �;�-. Man�1e that� he feels this rezoning would con5titute "spot zon�izg"�, rar. M�ngZe said the Housing �ana Rc�develop�ne�t Au�hoxity f�s trying to ret+�rn the land u.se to resfdentia7. rather thaat indu�E:ri�l; thc redevelapment plan f�r Che area i3 £or multip7�••family. '�hey �:re t�ying ta upgrade the wl-.ole �;eneral area. People wan� the vacant, vandalizec3 bECildings out of the �rea, Mr. Gau�er noted th�t he is op�posea to "C" Residence zon�ng but might consider "C-1", Mr. Wflliam �e Ma�i.i�, the petitionez, said if his plant •ls remove�, they would like to build apartmenis on th�t site Also. Nr, r°eiett-a moved for approval of the petition since he felt the rezaning to "C" Residence has merit. Th�s mo�ion failed for lack of a second. Subsequently, Mr. McPartlin moved far deaial of the pet�.tion stating that he felr it is "spot zoning" and a praper�y line shouldn't be a boeandary line between mul.tiple-dwellings and single-family residence�, Mr. Gauger seconded the motion for denial, atating 2hat he 3s more inclined tn "C-1'° rather tEean "C" Residence zoning for that particular area. The �o�ion far denial paESed by a �-1 vote. I;r. Maietta voted against the denial becaus� of. the Commercisl property on the corner. Mra Ames s�ated that h� voted aga3.nst the petition. because he feels the Cammercial area shoul� alEO be rezon�d to "C" Residence. G�st,�,ir.ee� by� ('o?_�nel L,, Sr�r�.��n R�hert T _ �1mes f`h�irma� �:;;. Citq Clerk . � CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Courf Nouse 55102 January 2, 1970 File X727, Page You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in � the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on January 15, 1970, on the petition of William C. Molin to rezone from a "B" Resideace District to a "C" Residence District the following described property: Lots 16, 17 and 18, Block 7, Winter`s Addition to St. Paul, end that part of the southwest � of aoutheast � of Section 26, Township 29, Range 23, commenaing at the aortheast corner of Victoria and Minaehaha, thence north along Victoria Street 131.5 feet of point of beginaing of property to be described; thence contiauing north along Victorie Street 118.5 feet; thence east 150 feet, thence south 118.5 feet; theace west 150 feet to point of beginning, located on the southeast corner of Englewood and Victoria Street. For further information contact the Planniag Board, Room 1010 Co�nerce Building or telephone 223-4151. JAMES J. DALGLISH Coannissioner of Fin�t�lre O ( ` � . � � . , Mayor Byrr�e ` . Re; Molin P..ezani�g � � � HOUSING AND REDEVE�.OPMENT AUTHORITY �r ' :;;_. s�•� ; �! :" i:. �lk+��,� i'�.??:.. �,-;�s�9��,; ;�;sf, January 12, 1969 Honorable Mayor and Members o£ the City Council 1715 City Hall and Court House St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 Honorr�ble Mayor and Members of the .City Council; The Thomas-Dale Develapment Council has reviewed the proposed rezoning af the Molin property, which will be up for your consideration on January 15, 1970. The Development Counci2 feels that a rezoning ta "C" residential district is appropriate and desirable as this proposal fits well into the overall Land Use Plan that the Development Council has spent the last six months develop- ing for the Neighborhood Development Yrogram. The Thomas-Dale Development Council would like to see it epproved; however, if tlie City Council wishes action on the rezonin�, perhaps the Council could postpone the zoning matter until you have had the opportunity to review the Neigliborhood Development Plan for our area on January 16, 1970. Thank you for the opportunity to review a zoning application which may affect land use in the area in which we live. ,,,. , - �:.: �....�,�. � , _� i' � �/ � /: neth e�l art"j 'y��y�'�' C A1Tman - % homas-Dale Deve�lop ent Council Lawrence J. Hayes, Iiarry P. Strong, Jr., Orviilz E. Anderson, !� :��: f; Thum,�;, krnneth J. !�,nch, James J. D�I��lish, Vic�c�r J. Tf;dF�scn ,-., �. � �� i9� 1� �� I �� Lots 16, 1? and 18, Block ? , Winter's Addition to St. Pa.ul , and tha.t part of the SW� of SE4 of Sec. 26, T. 29, R. 23 commencing at the NE corner ofV��Ctoria & A Minnehaha, thence N. along Victoria Street 13105 feet to point of beginning of property to be described; � thence continuing N. along Victoria Street 118.5 feet � thence E. 150 feet, thence S . 118.5 feet ; thence W. 150 � feet to point of beginning. �� Appa.rent record owners : 1�4oline Concre�e Products Company, �9 (Minnesota Corpora.tion) R � The ST. PAUi, A�STRACT AND TITLE GUARANTEE COMPANY does hereby certify � � that from an examination of the records in the Real Estate Divisio�i � in the office of the Register o� Deeds and/or Registrar of Title, in �� and for the County of Ramsey and Sta.te of Minnesota , it appears tha.t Y � � the appa.rent owner or owners o� the property within a ra.dius of 100 : feet of the above property are as follows: � 1. � That pa.rt of the SW� of the SEg of Sec . 26 , T. 29 , R. 23 , described a.s � follows: Cammencing at the NE corner of Victoria and hiinnehaha Streets ; thence N. along said Victoria Street 250 feet; thence �. 150 feet ; thence S. 250 feet to sa.id Minnehaha Street ; thence tiv. one hundred fifty (150) feet to the place of commencement according to the Government Survey thereof , except that part of the SW� of SE� of Sec. 26 , T. 29, R. 23 commencing at the NE corner of Victor3a & I�Zinneha.ha , thence N. along Victoria Street 131.5 feet to point of beginning of property to be described; thence continuing N. along Victoria Street 118.5 feet , thence E. 150 feet , thence S. 118.5 feet ; thence We 150 feet to point of beginning. �� Apparent record owners : Molin Concrete Froducts Compa.ny, �� (Minnesota Corporation) •i --------- 2. � The SE� of the SE� of the SW� of Sec. 26, T. 29, R. 23 , except a strip � of land 40 feet in width lying S. of and immediately adjacent to Seminary �� Avenue as opened and extending from Vic'toria Street to A4ilton Street and �� further excepting those parts acquired by the City of St. Pa.ul for streef ►# purposes . � ' Apparent record owners: hTolin Concrete Products Compa.ny, � (Minnesota Corporation) � ' 3 , � Lot 15, Block 6, Winter�s Addition+to the City of St. Paul , �Iinnesota �E ' Apparent record owners: Molin Concrete Products Compa.ny, (Minnesota Corpora.tion) 4. � Lot 10, Block 6, Winter's Addition to the City of St. Pa,ul , Pdinnesota � Apparent record owners: John P. SYiebusch and Violet M. Wiebusch, husband and wife as joint � � l��, � if !� 7a �, Lots 13 and 14, Block 6, `ilinter's Addition to St. �a.ul ;� �� Apparent record owner: Laurel A. Norman #� 8. � Lot 9, except the F. 25 feet thereof , and all of Lot 10, Block 7, � Winter's Addition to St. Paul �� Ap�a.rent record owners: Donald L, Bauer and Arlene 112. Ba.uer, �� husba.nd and wife as joint tenants g� 9. �� Lot I1 , Block ? , Winter's Addition to Saint Pa.ul �6 e� Apparent record owner_^Alice_R_ Lindeke ; 10. � Lot 12 , Block 7, Winter*s Addition to Saint Pa.ul } ; , ,. �� Apparent, record owners: Sold to State of I�Zinnesota. for Taxes . � -------------------- 11. � Lots 19 and 20, Block 7, Winter's Addition to St. Paul �. rR a� Ap{�a.rent record owners: Eugene P. Kroska and Shirley C. Kroska , i; � husba.nd and wife a.s joint tenants . 12. � Lot 21 , Block 7, winter's Addition'to St. Paul , acc. # ;; ;a Appa,rent record owners : James J. Pra.lutsky and Erika J. �� Pralutsky, as joing tenants �� - 13 . s� Lot 22, Block 7, Winger's Addition`to^St. Pa.ul �� Apparent record owners : Rober� G, Goeritz and lt�ia.bel S . Goeritz, ° husband and wife, as joint tenants . �� -------------------- �� Taxes and Judgments not examined. a `g �� Witness the signature of an a.uthorized officer of the sa.id Company �� this 6th day of ri�ay 19 69 A,D. , at 8 o'clock A. P�i. �' ;� i= .� y� ,� ;� ST. PAUL ABSTRACT AND TITLE GUAFANTEE COMPANY :; -, :�, . �� ' BY ,` -u.•��v;,; ' �. Q� 1� n u�t orize 'gnature E E i � 4� �!��`*," � �! ° �. �_ ��. �; f� iR _�,_ , - _ _.�_____ . _ r,,, �� „ t ._ �; . r �r�, •� , . .__ _ --__ _ -------- . - - -._. _ _--- -- ---- - _.._ . . ... ,. , _ __ _ , �. ,,, L �.:;, �.., _ . �"'� • l'� - ---- - - ---- � ( , `� �✓ f'� 1.- •, ,... ,. _!' N � � � � J .,� � .�...... I • _ , � r : . � . : , . ..- � w L- . � `` _j 4w �.; � � ' . _ � _ ''''�" {. • . , � �_ � � �` �� ' '" `.- � �,;? � �.;�„ � �% , �..1 O �� - � ., .:.:•' . �; � f;,;. F �.: c- f E _,� �; � n '-J �-'' F l � t', (` , � � � ~ ..� � � ` �' `"�`ti `- � �' 4 ', v � , ; �' �..r . . ��-' ' l �'"� 1.,� �,, �,; ; ` �l � . y'`� "' L y � �,�;_� !„ � ^ t. ,�-, �. i, -� t ' } �? . ,, _1- �- G � � �` �� . � � �� ;.� �� ;�� "" ,ti � , � , O � Q ; ._ •� ��.., ' .. � � 1 ; ;, �- �' O v ,_ � _ , + _ �� _ � Q �� ^ , `-' � . �.:, } � :�, t..� ` 4-:� `" . . �'J � , �� ' -� .. �,' ' F I1� �� Y- <, ,� �; � `�. ` ,- f •,j f • � �� O �, � ' , `J . , . ,. ` �� . . .. ; � ' .. f �. � ^ ^ �... !.i L `.. � � -- .� .. • � ` �+1' - �- . . � , � ._. � �`' ..2� • ,�� c..3�"� :• �, r � � . \� � �' � /'�'� . _ - ..... � . r � .^ \ " r • •... � � ,. , � .. -4 :., � ' . . . _ O ��'Jr . _ _. �,. i- � � � ; V � . , � t"' �.,' l� � Y, �� , , ; - C' 1 . .- ` � . . 1�. -C�- t - .,� � � w,. �.,��, ��. t..: �, 1,�. r�, � ��, , _ 4- - , �.. -� i.� ' '�. ; �; .�' �) . 1p,�' ^. � �. ` � ` . . W' �:.:� � . t.J .'. . , .. � ' 1 �" ..,._ , —f� ' � . . . � �� ' � f� �, � _, ,r'�E c:, �,.a ,• . �� -�w _ . - � J '� i �� -�r �� )� �', t�' ... �..r• �'�� r.�� y. � ` `.• . r, -1 '�L' �_J !r r—'^ 1� ,. ', . � ` � • �. . �.. . ,�.4: �,�� `^' i. ��'l•l�.uEW i� '� .�y` —_y / � . ._. . ' �) � �� ^ _ `' � i,� � j . i .. c •,,.. `�. ;..' f`W; , � ` �; O l L/ -_ �'. l.. .� _ _ .� . - �. : - o .- _ ... � ,_, , ,.,,. : . �� .^ �. _ -- . � �� . ., ` : ,. . ; „ � . ' �.{. ��- � , _ r � ` , ; . t� .. �, ,. � �.� � -.., :, - , Q r� �- �( . . . .�,. � , , �_ .:, . . � �. � , � _ , ,- _ 1- ,- . . ;, • � ,; . . „ � i i� . �.. . � , � _. '.. -+_J (.,'? - .r • �; , ,=� (J I � ��-� � ��) � r;� � '�� ,• (: � � i . � , �I ' .L� S ,, - . 0110� �`� _ a �. —`rl- , ��('�''1;(`' '- � ? ` J� � � .� , � _ __ - - -- - � r ' ) `- rJ t� ' . _ . . _`�' Q . ` T� � � � . �J -�.�- �`�'' ') , ,1 . _{ , ~C� _ , - - _ ._ , . tL ,. , . ..__. . . , � . --- � � } �,, n ; i_;' _ ' � -C�- O W -•� ' �; W , , �. � W `� . : � . ,. . , __. --- . � � , - . . •. ; � �r -{>- Q -�:�- � O � -p- . �, � { ,. � � �-- -- � . _ .� . Q � � ,, . . Q �_� . � , �._ ('; r , . -- . � ..� �_,� _ . � . , - _ , ! .\ , � , . �. �} r� � � _ . . � _ . _ ' } , ; _ __� ._ ___ _ . `, , ; ' ` - . _ _ _� , ` \ � �_� t , � -. , + <, �J . � � - � � � n. _ C.% Q , �; �j , � -�. ,. . _ _ � ._ - � , .� G . _ _ , __ _ ,, . .. ,-- , � ,_ ; . _ O �� •f , �� . � � � � ; � � � - - - _ f_ - c -�- ,: , �% , ,_. _ � -- - , . ;_ ._ ° �; . , �'' � � � � �. ,-, � .� � �� l \� -C1- ,-�, � � __. ,__. -- _ ... � -, � :. _ _ . � i:,,* > , � V� , U � �_ C; ,_,. . � , , - - � _-.__. C C. C� �, ,� _, � ; . -- - � � , �..} , . . . .� ` �� r _ � � _ _ _ , �, , ,. _ --- __� : , . _ ; . � � C� '� _ __ _ �' } .� Q �, �,}._ ;� i ,_ . � ._ _.__ _ _ - _ - ; �J ,. � , _ ( ; �, r,_ � , • _ - . ;� }? N - . ; �� . C C� . Q O: � , _ � O _ + .. - t , _. -:� � � -; r� , --, _ . - , � . , „ , ------ � O <� � � C` � 1 _i � � vz _. ; , ,.� `1 (, ---�. � ,.. � . - � v �_t -1"�--__ 4 ._..� . r_ �' t _ � � ` _. W �1 S n► ond � � � , � , . � W ;��L) ., , Q � � � Q L. , _ -.- U , -- _ - - __ � � , O - Q � , _ - J ; ' _ _ -' - ; -� � C O � ��_ � �_� �... � p -� � .-�- �� :� -� : ` .� _�._ j � :. n W � ` ", � O j � � . �^� O � . , ..r t ,... � �`:r _ �._. . .J --....�. O ' \J ' ' �� , -. ...__. ._. _ /'. a � _ �-._ � - _ , -- __ __ ; .. ,-` ; � '.� L; , i; `� p � ; _, f ' _ . , - , � , � � _ _. O � ._--�: � � � � �� _ � �,,� T �; N � .� � --- . . , . _ � _ -� - _ � � , � � ' � - - - � --- -- V � ` ... �' , � - _ ____ __. � . �. .. _(\ � F -, , � , ._ 4� - - ---_ � � - .� � .-_ � �' � � � t. � (, - � � � ? O , , � �, �.j - � �.� '� � �� V , � � o___ : - - o � �- �� _ .� � o _ . ._ ; `� --�, _ ! o _ ; � i _ - . __._._ ---. : ._ - ,--- _ � , - � e . , � _ ._ . c. , ; o ; V =p- �, C 0 ) �� , �' , _ J ,.r- �� ' c� - _ . _ _ . ; ,� _ , � _ , , I. _, _.__ _ _ . ; , . . ___ -, _ -O- t� p ` ___ � � � , � , . . .. _ �_. _O � - - - __..__ __. �_. ; - -- - �-- . c � � ; ; � C` � C:� _ i� �. W ` _ .� _ _ .__ O_ ___ � � _ O � O -t:�- --p- � - -- ; , �� - ---_ �__ _ � - _ � i v , � • � ... -.�- � . �. . � c� L :, � _ __ � .. , --_._ - , . ,�, � � � . ._ . i _ _ ; , ; ,� . . ,- ' .;--� _ _ � . _ . � , , --;-__ _ , . , _ _ ; a- �. - - , , . __ . -�- ` � . _. , U �� ' ! ; .� _� o � ; ; . " = ._ . , ; -,_- - �cI�� Cj {-r � �•? � — . . �-;. . � L�; -->__ i __- - , , _ __ �__ � � � _.y�_ _ ',- ' -0- � I � ., _ � ,_; O , ; �r �� : �- Q � ' _ _ _� - .- , . ,.. ,-. : --- � ; W �- i � . U , , ._: _____-.__.____..� . _ _ _ ; _ _ . .. +.__ ,__ � I r-+r--�- - _. _ . . • , �_ � � _ � �oL�� .� ,,� = Z 3 ` ;z o � , ! . � f _ . � �- -- .., - � o-� __-=� �!.� 'c� _ .. __� _ � Zp � ,� ; � . �-, ` _ _ _ � �.- -� _;' .--�, _ -4 �W Q _ , � � - - .: M � � A i � 2 � ` �, i . --� 1—- r.., � _ __.--�' �� , J ; _-� � .�-- � �^- ` J � � � �. 9 ��-__, � _ _ __�_ z � � � � � _ � � -�.�- e �-- �-� . ` . ° - ,, _ , . _ -- � � � , � y ; ___. } _-� , '� t �--�____ �_ � ,..i _ ._� _. _ o ed `_ -c�- G - -- � - _. - ; _, _ _ . --- - -- � i -- ' (� -� _ � ; N ,\ � � _�, , _ , --- � � - . , � -�- . r� , _ __ , _ _ _ , . � - - _ , �., I i � _ -1"�- , __^ __ _ ., ._ _ c.� 1 , � }� ; -� � -1.,'- 1 ,J = � � _ -� �_ __, _ , ,� i � _ _ -�` -- � � , ► , ; �. __ _ o_ , � �. . . , _ :..,. -� � _ ' �' __ ; ; ; ,.. .., ,. .. �, � .i' � ` - : � c `� � ___ , ., ,, • _'� i ,,,a. m p � ; ry` _ _�'.(,. --- � 7 �'�-I; Q � � J H a! �, � Jv 017/W � � ' ,.(.� S �' c�` � r-------, ____ -__-- � � � � _ � + _ _ J _ _ __ , � _; _.o _ , o � • p a , - a � ; __ � _ -- � -- . i � r-� . �_ � _ _ f_`_ ___ __---_ � p � ,_ ��. O � � o p �� -�-, - -� �- - ---- , _ .. ° - -- - - -.- ,- t�. Y. . �-,� .._.-� r�. -t.r �, �t-�-- - : '_ .__. _ 'a : � O . �. _ .1 - -{�-- � � V, ; O _----- _._, , ' Q�---- �--1�,�-� � O � N Z �- -- O _� . __-• - ,. -+_ __ _ _� � ..-- -f- �_ ' � ' C . : ` m .) � � �-- _ _-_ _ Z � , � � , _ a � ' ��-�-.��.._ ,� �_ +--- � � �,?� � T �•-�--�---�--�. � �_.Q-. h-aj: .` ~I ,_ _ _� _ _ _ - . � , . _: �_ ._-- - � W � � ,'.- - , �--- - � - _. _ _.. '� _ V ----t- .-- - -+-- -�' i-�- -- --t ; _ ---- � '/�� _� -: .. _ .__j r ___ � F�-. _ . _ (n. _ � � 0 _... ._ __ .. -t--- i 7 ' _� �1� d ,J � • Z � ' , .-� 1' �; -- . ____ _-- � f � ' O � ,1 , LL__ _ �1'� ' � f. '�� _b�_ � (,� �. -�----_. � i f .. � i . . _ , � :____ _ `- ^ -� • _� � , W I -+� � ,; V I � .�(� , � 1-____,_ . Q - �� - >.�-- a .�:_ ___ ; ; -- --- �� . ; LI � ; _. � r�~` � -' , �� -_� .,�� __ i'Q . � 1 � � I � ' i ` `' __ . ��..e . ... .'c'.� . _ ` ----`r._CD .. � � CJ� �.,E.. � � / � �- , ti..- � � i I l^ - - �� _ `� I � • � L ('� f . i h�t�O/Y� rl KH7 ' ; r ' . H 1 � d M S � , � 1S , Daplicats to Printer O1� DINANCE ;��rd�.�Q COUNCIL FILE NO PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO �" - An ordinance amendin the Zon3.ng Code, Chapters �0 to 6�, inclus3.ve, of �Che Saint Paul Le�i�lative Code, pertainin� to Use Districte, Hei�ht Distr�.cts and Rezoning of certa3.n proper- ties in the City of Saint Paul, ae amended . THE COUNCIL Or THE ClTY OF �ATNT PAUL DOES ORDAZl�: Section 1. That the Zon3.ng Code, Chaptera 60 to 6�+, Lriclus3.ve, o�' the Saint Paul L��is?,a�ive Code, per�a�ning to Use D�.stricts , Hei�h� D:Lstricts and Rezoning of certain properties in the CitST of Saint Paul, as amended, bE and the same �.� hereby fur�her amended so as to rezone the� follow3.ng described property frc�m r'B" Residence District ta "C" I�e�idence District, to-wita Lots 16-18, Block 7, winter 'a Addition to St . Paul, and that part of the S6�T,-�� of the SE� of Sec . 26, T. 29, R. 23, comm�ncing a� the NE corner along No. Vict�ria St . 1;31.5° of point of beginning of property to be described; thence continuing north along No. Victoria St . 118.5 ' ; thence east 150' ; thence �outh 118.5' ; thence wes� 150' to poin� of be�inning; situate on ps�operty loca�ed on the southeast corner of Englewood Avenue and Nor�h Victoria Street in the City of Saint Paul. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. r PETITION �� REZONE A petition having been filed request- ing that Chapters GO to 64 inclusive, St. Paul Legislative Code, re Zoning. etc., be amended so as to rezone prop- Block 7sc�bn eras�Addition to7StnPaul, and that part of the Southwest ?4 of the Southeast ?a of Section 26, Town- ship 29, Rznge 23, commencing at the northeast corner of Victoria St. and Minnehaha Ave.; thence north along Victoria St. 131.5 feet of point of be- ginning of�property to be described: S en118 5 feet lnthenceh east gl Olc eet thence south 118.5 feet; thence West 150 feet to point of beginning, located on the Southeast corner of Englewood Ave. and Victoria St., to Class "C" Residence District, the Council of the City of Saint Paul has fixed the 15th day of January, 1970, at ten o'clock in ' the forenoon in the Council Chamber in the City Hall of said City, and at .; ,,r:' `h�"�4'� said time and place, the Council will „ , � hear all persons and all objections and Yeas recommendations relative to saia n=o- Passed by the Counei� posed amendment. Dated January 2, 1970. HARRY E. MARSIiALL, �_` c�ty c�er��. In Favor I (January 3, 1970) � �.7�11'cl,1KiL � � Ag`dingt Tedesco : Mr. President (�3.yri�e) . ,