Loading...
250096 y� - �i:. F. r� � dY -:� ,. �_ . . ,:.n ., J '+"°'yc<< r: ^�y� Ys. '}y . "�c.n' � �� �� . . ,, ; ,,., 6� ' . ` ' COUNCIL FILE NO. � _ , ; By : : File No. ;�� � r\ , .: In the Mat�er of ��Il��i +�� �� �+11� ��.�. a �! i�. ' �. ��l �3� �� as ;aT�x f�s �r �"�� +�wMr�wrs +i�► �i �r; ` ' e��rtt +�t�et +�M�t s��r �!'�; +�wr�t�t �o� Mw�ar � ��r; �e a�t, �a�'+NN �r s�►!M �r�t#Mar# �rt�ewet a a�'!�s +Nr�*� �t�r +�e ��ii�w; +� +i� �� �are rr�n��iei�i #�► �rwMr��t �t L�ti�irta�t� w �/�r as� ��rc. . : � _ , ,� . - � r � under Preliminary Order �4�!!t approved �� �� !'!7! , � Intermediary Order , aPProvecl , . ' A public h.earing having been had upon the above improvement upon due notice, and•the Cour�cil having heard all persons, ab�ections and recon�rnendationa:relative thereto, axad:having fu�ty eo��dered F the �1tne; therefore, be it . , . ` ----�?RE�OLVED, By tne Couneil of the City of St. Paul that , - f -, . . . ` ; ,. = : , ; � 3�ra� �rs �.. a.�a� a.�r.-a► __ . �t. ,.�t,�r r��s r-�w� . �� a. �� .�►:�t ._ ��'�'` �� a.+ .. ' � s+�..a� ....t�r:.st�a. �ar �dil� . � � art �r s�s�at �wrtt�s= s�st�t � t�'�� �1ad�1 � �t �S•;, � �, � a� ir ai���r s���rM�rla�i is s�!��t ��st���r +p��,+� ra�i� ' �►. - �_ �; , : , F , _ , _ r . . _ . . ..,�,. M�,�. . . . . . '+ % ' Or�e�s in the above matter be and are here5y cancetfed;°armtr'i� - �, � ;� , ,�' 'e e,�nd all �roceedings in said matter be discontinued. i �_.._. _ , \ ,1 ` an ti�e Council hereby orders said improvemeat to be mad - ESOLVED FURTHER, That'the Commisaioner of Pub Works be and ia hereb ` inst�ructed and directetl�-to�u3ep�e�p s 'ans for said improvemen , d submit same to'� Council for appro�ral; that upon said �.pproval, the p er city of�'icials are hereby a �'7ce�d a�nd �irecte ' pra ceed with the making of said i�nproveme an acoordance therewith. : �� �( �\ _ : CILMEN `�`L v/� Adopted by the CounciL A�'a 1 8 1��0 Yeas Nays Carlson , Approv AUG 18 197�� Meredi <� ; � � - ,-�e�e�t�q."' . ,, �Tn Favor `�;-�ra fk�' yor ` TedesCO - � """!T�'"'1��� ��� A�a.iri8,� ' c -° .�$ i� �-��-� .� �� � EUBLISHED A � � ' . / � : � ��C�` �6 OFFICE OF THE COMMISSI�IER OF PUBLIC WORKS - ' ' �`'�� . � _ �PF�,p� T r d.��F,��o �',�� ,� REPORT TO COP+II�LISSIUNER OF FIlVANCE Q FO �, . - , ��� ,�A ' .��;�•r _ ;; .,, . �h � 19 70 _ To the Corrmiissioner of �Ynance of the City of Saint Paul: The Co�nissioner of Public Works, having had under consideration the pre- liminary order of the Counci.l� known as Council� File No. 21+75q(, approved Februarv 2�+. 19 70 relatine to JEFF'ERSON AVENUE . � ' frcam Snellina Ave. to Edacumbe RQad (Citv Pro.iect No. P-�240) • and having investigated the matters and things referred to therein, hereby reports: 1. The estimated cost thereof ie � ����)o• ' 2. A plan, profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached and made a part hereof. �� 3. Initiated by the Comm3.ssioner of Public Works Robert F. Peterson 1�. Improvement ie aeked Por upon petition � � . � . � Commi.ssioner of Public Works � . � . M=,�,', WATER DEPARTM� NT • CUFfORD W. Nn!.�BUN ' ROY W. HOLZ[R c.��,�i ',,^���,� SA1�1T ?t,L'L, MINNESOTA sUP+.of Di:tribution r � . BOARD OF �"✓AT�R COMMfSS10NERS :�-�"' ' COMMISSIONER RO�ERT F. SPRAFKA, Pres�d��nt w. �. r�1�U'Nls�e�J' , J�.: .,,:"ra� �.tnna,ar :,�:p4.of H/utor Supply . 6 , ,'�� ;� I li�� � ROB�RT�F. P[7ERSOt�! � '` JAtA�S 1. DALGLiSi-i , . , .,.'�.� __ SUAPLY - .. ' ' ,.:,..� , _:_ti�1S51SSir^FI RIV[R � . . LAtC[5 -� T;��+;.SL-N7 PUMPlN4��"�a� J�%�j�p{S7i ISU710N .: _ _ .. ,. .�.,,;..._...._ ._ � _ ._ . . . __.,.�� �;:. March !t, 1970 �`.. � �Q�'�q,Q � l��' ,�� ��i �y�o � . ;,�x ��� rlr. Claude Thompson '��'_�� G� 4:,"� Public Works Design Ehgineer ' `' �r�� � �* Public jaorks Department . � ,,�% 231� Court House , �. ' ��ti Re: Jefferson Avenue, Snelling Ave. , to Ed�ecumbe Road Dear Sirs In reply to your letter dated February 23, 1970, we have xeviewed the pre- limenary plans and are returning oux plats showing all water mains in the pro3ect area. Also enclosed is a list of service connections giving size, type and location. Costs for new or replacement services are as follows: Jefferson Ave., Snelling to Pascal (60' Street, No Concrete Base) Size of Service Schedule Charge , 3/!t" �205.00 1" 225.00 � 1�" 320.00 2" or laxger Actual Cost Jefferson Ave., Pascal to Edgecumbe (80' Street, No Concrete Base) 3�1��� �2t�s000 , 1" 270.00 1�" 37�.00 2" or larger Actual Cost �� The scheduled charge is guaranteed to January 1, 1972. The above coste are based on the Water Department bein� allawed time and access to the �ob ta inatall ar�y a•erv3.oe connection after the old surfacing is�removed �� ��,�> � � �� � �.~ , (►�,,}��� � � � T""� `�VR SEQ`, ; � , nr � - 2 - Ns. Claude Thompson Re: Jefferson Avenut Snelling Ave. to Edgecumbe Road March !�, 1970 , and before the new surfaci.ng is placed. ; In order to give an accurate estimate for ar�y other changes which mi.ght be necessazy, it would be advantageous to have a final des3.gn of the pro�ect. If you have ar�y f1u°ther qusstions please call our office at 223-l�7.22. ; ;-�., , Vexy truly yours, : � /� ° �____, ;„ � ;��,. �.� /l `.�/.i t-�� �:/ Thomas D. Mogren ,'� Chief of �hgineering Division ' RNS/eh � ,1 ';v"�► �,�';s. �� �,,� , .• o b�. ; } 'Q �9� 7'��,'�� � �- Y d �� !9, --� ���,''� �� ^^ � � ,� iG o ��._, \ S. ,. �� � � ��A �� � . �,�� �` 4.< �.,�_ - �:..:.�:�-`�` :��,, � 1'.'� _ �� - , RICHARD A. SCHNARR C I T 1 O F S A I N T P A U L ANTHONY J. CREA , CNI(F [NGIMEfN DCPUTY COMM14410NER Capital of Minnesota DEPARTMENT OF PU�LIC N/OR6tS 234 City Hall & Court House 55102 ROBERT F. PETERSON Commissioner . �::::��� March �+, 1970 � I i Honorable Jamsa J. Dalglish { Corarnissioner of Finance � 113 City Hall , f RE: P-02�+0 JEFFERSON AVENUE I • Snelling Ave to Edgcumbe 3 Road. (includes 5-0990A) � � Deax Sir: � Transmitted herewith is a preliud.nary estimate of the costs and financin� to improve �TEFFERSON AVEN(JE Prom Snelling Ave to Edgcumbe Road, under Preliminary Order C.F. I1o. 247596, approved Feb. 2�, 1970. Estimated Costs Estimated Construction Costs , $1g6,150. Engineering C12�,$ 23,540. Inspection C 2°� 3,920. Valuati�on and Assessment Services 8�+0. � � Misc. Publication, Court a.nd other costa 750. I Other Misc. Costs 00. � Tota1 232,700. Estimated Financi.ng Estimated Property Assesarasnts � �+2,150. Municipal Stata Aid 19(0 7.�U ��U. Total 232,joo. �I �� � ,.�:ti Lt�E' /�' ,, ; ��� 9f�� �� i ��' ��.'hq�p � j , f �d�,��C`���p �._>� � o Fo �i ��,� �`,�,� ��. V,:, . ., . _ _ 1"'.� `�' ., -- --2-- Estimated property assessments are based on the following rates: Pavement: (including replacement curb and gutter) A&B Residential 1+,340 assess. Pt. @6.25 $27,125 c xes., co�n. & Ina. 25g '� '� eg.5o 2,193 Pavement: (including new curb and gutter - Syndicate to Edgcumbe) A&B Residential 1,770 assess. ft. @7.25 12�832 Estimated Net Assessment 2,15� Direct benefit improvements will be assessed as follows: �+" thick mono concrete sidewalks $.75 per sq. ft. There are no existing driveways on this pro�ect. Charges for new or replacement water service connections that may be requested will be at the rates shown on the attached letter from the Water Dept. The preliminary estimate for sewer pro3ect 5-0990A has been submitted separately by the Sewer Division. I recommend that the bearings for these pro�ects be held at the same time. Yours very truly, Robert F. Peterson Coannissioner of Public Works RFP�CLT�gb Attachment � cc: J.J. Mitchell C.L. Thompson � J. Wm. Donovan J. Schwaxtz ��` '" ,+ F '�`'�.► ,4 ,���/�r� � :� �d �' '4 ' �� ` .���'.�?'Fi � ,... G` � .�.p;��� � o�o � w � -�� _. . ��� ��;,�,, �.- � �, �`� �..: � � , _,. 4\ ....�uuu`� .� v � `' i;; Ciiy ;�. � / .✓�r;�, i �� �� �i � I 1 r��Trnn+it `� `�"�: ,nnwe � I �����L � I -. �� 1� >�`- ' �=Jr 1t�L_' .,'� J' �� l� � 0 � V,.. ,i it � �-�o�' Av—,����;r.M—yCHR[J����.r J _ _ _ - __ _ ___ ,L��+.r _ - _,. _ _ �t s_ � ��,._ , �,� �.�_ v. � . � t 1 � �.,... � - -- - �� _ r 1 - 'j� �� l ( . - � � - � , � �.., �. _ t- _ _ � � = - -- _= — - - — <<__ - 1 r• ti J�L1�___J�; e� - -�(( _.�.-----_1�. � 7 - . _�� �.:J I l � ���� •��'[:7:JJ!!��_�� - - , �r_ � . , -.�r��`_�']�� ^ •w i I �' � ■o ir �vE. onrnrvNn��i} ' t r r�nue � �,- J � I�r U�eOIM �r J�� ��� Ilcu� � :�. �����nn �U L���.���.��,.���-ru� 'L1'�►r 10 ❑��� � �� �.'' [`�O O O O C �� T 1�.1^���N " . � 1-OUNNING i1ElD ..' INh ( � �--.vE. , O C�1 O O ❑�J��t��t�,.A�o 0 o u��a� 2�z . �-:�; �,,M,� o� 1` MAFl;HA�L �aa�ac�o�oao ��t,��n,..� 0 2�2 � c.�ooc�c �ao�r�oa000���,�o � �Qoo� o000 � AVE (1j'���� ( *--� ,, j'�� �❑��LJ�W�H ��1 �C��0 Oz� .�,I.n,. �1._�3_!t. �*' ��a U 5.^._J V'���aU�Ou� AI�J � ��cl�'��CI�"=""r�0e'����j-.�� _.1���rq��,_ �,� _ . .��i. �� z o O Y�` J��������'7�J� a�� A��¢ \'S. i �URE W �?�'��(�"11VEt ��� �LL r—� �{-'� _ J��t���� �y ����I..�JS�U� �`�_A�� 44 .�, ' ��J� Q��~ �"L� � ¢ !'_ ��I�r�.,J�l�l��4—J�� �o� �, "�"� �� � � &c�e � `�F � or.s U_M�IYp•T:-. cros .-----� ��--- `a c:� �-^ � �.ai �lR+V£� i� � 8 Y M M ,�c---a �sa� � (�� �J�� "7i�'s;.,a�Q �51 , sc��n �j;rsat' �� �'�oii ������ Et asal t 1"�� � '��� � ���_• ������ � ' � � NAN IL��� ]� ���> ��p o�'�.��] �e. ���0 a `t.�O�y,�l��� � C6. ��O� AV . COODRiCN �O 0 0 Cl " � � � � [� ' .<;:'5���"��L_10 C �Q�� AIRMOU ��p ���� AVE . F RMWN7 �A �C� 0 0 ,.�„ � �l 0 C �O��� p,NG TO �/ � d�� .!"� Pt.Sch. _-� a �O Q �E O O f"'AVE�'1 Q SCEO � � '� rseA v�Y.:'0�'` AVE� Y� � , s �v � �1..�10 0�� L�M��I� I O `"�w C lii O Qw O U� � ri. �` I!d �^��� Y��.��rA ������� d .' r: BAR VE. �Gr <�� �,,j' ��+O��1�i��� �C 111" G ���Ja.,���0 VE.W ���� �°� � �/,I ., ' ` ��' wR:C 8r�. � �- 11. �/1�� o�o- .) K::: �o���—�A `���� E a:� •a � ;�3�i d� �-::`.' 3 . r5 .�'�,� �O ,7 `��O E`•� SQ"Q W " $ ; ,. . ' A p--��p{�/ ` �__.)L�fi�a 1 � � u �� �o�o��o� � � � `JtlLiE �� �o�o� � °CT. �..�. �� � ��+ O� altx s � � ����� � A� �f� ��o��o�o� ao����� Y�� �� � ���o � � :.:•�• :�`:-':�� 0 4 CIC7 ■�'r�ao H�qti � C �v =--- ve o o c�+. s�n. ��c��ve�� � �. � ��c*-1�:,%"��BbOnth,ln�e�� Academy ���� p.�osePe I�� N��- ; �� � RN Q�� J�7,y Oolle�e m � l rPthana e l ���� �.e 1�- VE i� WAfi50N AVE M� `-' WATSON V w.:�� �� U�7 � °� f p q10 O� �,X (:;.�.�.�.�..��....�...�,7".-���C� YE�. R�oo� o��o�o �^ �.... o�� IV� L� BA�r ��p�7���AVE B/�YARD �-. e � � �� aoa� �000 J� o� o�o �'' 1 HEFFE V. . W EfFE AVE �'7_� � �,� �;i�e. g �N �:U ����'°'�� �'`� �< ������� d ���'V�J✓/j � IV ELEANOR --AV ELEIINO MOMiC�tM� VE v o 0��`'�� U ����1 ��.�►�. �l�J L�C7�i�"�`�= a Q�� C-1 DaF � KWY �•"' 4'GCi�:AN ° J(-VM;Y HIGHL PKW Y• �,,�) ono y ■ ^:?i'({'li�:::!y:`i.tz�'.' �• / o` O�� �� /S� � / OOW O � ��� � wrl'r' :rf.�, n��xuoar��[. a / 4� �� "' .// ��"'V � g Jr a 'O �Vi f PINEHUR VE. y� kf S� J y� ���/�j f �/ i�. '�':`�.''M.�'::;:::�.� ..:Edicumha 1�. \. Y � � 0 Z �: �} b �.,.... 1 / � �. � \ 't, 3� � \ N 7 �� � t / � b f u � a ��o � �_ � � � o�� < �+ < �::�::::::::- W �. _ y � ..� , _ � F A K AY ��J — NWAY P R W � � :'���:•:�� FOR f— KWYf DaWeoiL• y ^ � � (I�' oi�.:.'`' '..�.a:;:�:.:;�:`'`�; � � p o°� / �o���PP. � ��O 1..� :.�:.:.' IIILLC�F51 O p 8�� � I�, / i. O u,ik..�i � ILLCN i:N�':•.'i`��• - o / `�y`� � rl'. . .��,: ...... y Q� r j,,� � � o��o� :�'��;:::::�::�:.� �... (� �� D �,,� � y�o � � eoxu.o •i. j� �� � � - � � BONkAND- VE �} �.��.���•�'.::•i��'.+:.•::�'' . c��Otl � � Z:�_�!{}��faiul�'{�;�.7:::ti':�i.1�i'�"i:•ii:,';'C.•"�L_J °'2- O � � ��1,1 _�a�����'LL,�1��1�L���.�.Pmbr i;:'�`�:-�<0::;>:;i�:. ,at[cx«oo?J e`�-�'� _`..1 '�V�t � �� � rBEECHWOO�--� �-AVc�. J.'.•.,.r:�,y:'�{;j5:.:.`.;t:t';� . ..:::..�.::::...p i,�;��,�.":�.t�.;:;..� WaL� : o.::. p� ( '`�pP 0 � o`����J�I�Ji"">.:"' �` ;'"��Pi Park� dq�l� / � � � rS�HNOEry "f.VE N�� . .�� ! / ZEF:.;:��"� � �� � QO' 'I�,, �w� �..'•",���J t►�en s a�.1 � ���, HiI,,G H:L A N�. �a z°�LY P� K^h ,; '�� O o ,/�,r�' ,,. �\ ������U� � ~��'�y `\ =°2� a/�.�� � o � g.�� \ ROME YAYE. o h � -y � Iub.Hooe� O ':� rlpm►CRUNE"�� ��.�Jy ��f�-=� �r•+��• � Iy. � 1 — W �;�$`_-' a�toNr�nL-� . .. .... .. ;,•�.,;s;-�. o ' . ,sT•-r- � � cA� ��L7• . ''r.i:.E�.} c :!<r;;..,i�t:. ;,yt.,.;.'i:y,�•�.•.•����'�. ���. ;. � � ;ti`.::,-';;. � . � y HIRhInndPk L � �ry�l 'S �0� ���4 JC� � ��'•` � ,�O Jr.N 3 �'M.� � \ � � J4 i �v. ���� o : �h��\�� o � � E p,+ ��t �i'��i �3_'\ �o' �� �r :�.�.i•:�:i?i`:.: :ri . '���. � , ; / . �Gi o NI ( '. f 0 ' `�::. C"� ggcc �VR p L W HIRAi d Pk �.... ��1���` � F;"'y� .r�.f'�% R�"• ,� �< 3r.H.S �:���::::: F ILIAR Q���, ,��• W A�4. �'• ::d:':'.' t ..�.�� � �� O AV. fh'., ' . i+ �•( 1 � J I � �•< �(�au. tl � G .. .:: �..a. �. •F��':;y..t.::. . - s � . `�' � .�' F.1 PS�%7���U � ' o.�.,� rc° �a�e�`;�� ° _ .:'.�:r b _ qE ��o w�+��R9, ` - � 0 j „ .\�.. I � _ ,cl�', . ` AV. �P .4`� 1r�' . I - i RD. !� ��'� � aG_ P� • i' � 35 + W m h' !''� 9 e> � ', �,a �(. � ,-, , � a a `.so �, =�llly. �vi , re`J,"l��•,,�'' �� O� ,���' l � E a r% �M,�. 's, b .� ,r � ' '� 0 Dnt = o � � ���'li��,- �WE Y ��, i� ��� F:t�� '2,r � J'�` � ; / � �n ��Hrs� c�{ r�J <�; �nt' '�5 r � , , $��a�0 ��?Q1iLA!' �O}�auu.�A� i�. .r�11\1�� 'i u� i�.,,..N.�A�� `�y^. �fo9 JF' 1 � � _ ��" ...►�'' i � ♦ . � G�'h�'� ( - G��l� \O�v B�_-� M°b uo A .~/ /i�4n . .e��!�:•+. • w.Qi-T��.'___"_ __ / � `„ \ �� ., tr DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I13 Court Houss,bb102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commiuioner ,, LOUIS H.McKENNA, Depufy Commissioner Phonr 223-4646 ,,^ May 18, 1970 Mr. Harrq Marshall City Clerk Building File Po. 17473 - Iaproving Jefferson Ave. Aearing Date - Maq 19, 1970 Dear Sir: Forwarded here�ith is a letter,with reference to the abave project, for consideration by the City Conncil. Sincerely, i aaes algli , Ca�ai .oaer of Fina ce cc: C.C. Sorensen �� `�i,' �j�(��;fY��"'�#�Y"��� i4�raS 4�'�.�'�r �`t� '� Xr�?�^� �i -i,�i. , � , v.:+ r+� �w ug� , dl� � �S '� fb�' ,t �k� � �°y `' �1��� rY.�' rf �� ��yu t i�e J s e ��1�� �i'r�r7��L?�'J ,+v �u t H� ° � {ti r�,� + i:{ i� Y3 '��J��' � � I i`� �� �1�- � ��1:t s �� �f;,,± ' ,�.�' �t.t 1 , r k" 7 G ��� z �►` � >t�. ^ '4 ��„ �° "' �r,-.b' � 4� , nf 8��f rti e ��9� �r t� . r� "`�,��{���i f � �'�, �P y, , s � 1�€� � � ��� a�p '�1�J� n .1, 4 �"4� � ;! r � vi���11 J .� �.C�1�� � v r Ji� � '�d ��i� a + � ,�� F'"_,tt i�r�,1 °1 `t'� � r � i."� � j � � r ,a" '¢ i d, tl y;, s � I�A,d U9 �Nd`t'�'F� '� �"i'� �� � 4 .p � � . r r� t�r . . �„a �;i, rf +��; r vs � . � � �.,�;� a f/iv �x�: � cr`:?°� �y��y�� ;�� �i �k` �y V ��� �� � Lf��,�^ r�,g 'y5d�',.�` E�j,,jh�� ��� � YJ, .-.a J��+,�ll+�����,��.f�,W��Y�Q,µiO��� a: ��" ��"�'�.�;��1} � +�� � � ��� F� + k _ pa��.,� ., � 1,���.,h �, ,,�� � , ��� _� �.�r ��, S�•� � M�.rinesota :5� �`� � �''"� `�< ,� ��4� ,:�, � � � _ May ��1 � ,. ��70 <� ', �� , .� +X kF�, i�{vf t „ , ' 's,�:. � - ' �,: y. � 9�l 1'� X.;��+ . � �,. �n � � ,.; ° E J;ai��s .�J. �Daglish Co � ,, �;. 'E�; '.a �� � r " C3.tV � mmis�ioner � { wl �! � �. I l I f ��'. l� � V ��H����.'.. ' ��, r= � � � � 'r >; .,.`(�y� W• ` Kellogg Blvd. �,� 11 j I ' JV�• � 1.,':, . . 1 �, ' � `��r ;»;�t , �, �� Patzl, Minneso ta 55101 � � ,/ 7 7 3';" ` ���, -,� , , � �:, � , �� : � '� Dear Commissioner Da�lish: � � I am writing in referer_ce to P proposes to widen Jeffer�on �±,jPeliminary Order 247596 which , -, � Edgcumbe Road b four feet ue from Snelling Avenue to ` ' y excert in the half block east of Snelling Avenue where it i� t� be u, ti�ill be considered �t t��e ;'o�.zncil meeting on�Ma f1 et and which : project is to be coordinate�? �f�ith �reliminary Order�246681 whics vuill construct a public stor;-n �e�,��er in the same areas h It seems this dual ro����l �,sr . in city plannin _ , �,l em���1 f?.�� a basic contradic'tion sound and is in�kee- irr;��z��r'`� �=P�`��er proposal is ecologicall,y environrnerita.l ualit� �� „1 �` °`'r nev�l,y- at:�akened concern with avement Tf q 1' ��`t t�'� COY'�li�ry of additional feet of P rill Uerve onl�T to intru�?e u�on the current quality o� our neaceful neighborhood. If this proposal is enac+ed, thir. t must be removed. The resultin� �'`nix�e beautiful elm trees uvill jeoparc�ize the safety ci '�'_ne1school�c�hildrenrwhoeattenafic Randolph I�Pi�htU �lemPnta_ry �chool ,=�_� ,Iefferson and Hamline avenues as ��x�ell as t�iose ,,�, � � r anc� rr_�.�T� ,, v �Q tz��P 1','��;cur.�be Pl_��T�round at Jefferson � � '' 1 �edleti U to c�l, incr. eased noise an the avenue tvill ' also im,n,ai_r tl�� �ualit�;� of o?�r i_i�res. ,� A There a.r�e :r,�zn,y alterna�ives to the enactment of this � First, ;_;�;Y�era� ;..i�a� �ast-,,,Jest Uf,reets exist already inrap�2a1. r^il� c3ir�ctior1 �;� the :aorth anc� (�Fiitn ���„�r, ,., south of Jefferson: Randol h y �,_, tr� ,.>,1��her. d �'oac3) �1• P ar.d I�Tar��l;�� � . :��„on� � �- �,. Clai_r, Grand, Summit, ,Selb;� �ne-�,=.,�,v �, ,T�-r.,.i� �r�a r,�;_,',.T�7effer��o.i could �ossibly be made into a :� the a�.�er,zF,� � ��� ` � =`'' ���.rPac3y b�rined on the north side of �>�� ''-��,��c� Aven�te, orie 1a1_ocli to the sotzth �prs�p ';<, C 'r��t��—; + ., f � COU�� ` Lcl�cu�nbP ?�;�.a,�` ��r �-�c in �hf� opnoUite direction as far as � ;yl Please •recon�icler ,+,his preli?ninary order before the council '� I � � meeti��. [; l�r _r.e r����orit.Y �f the 1 10 �I �L� �»1':r �z� �7.ci t�j! 1'�1�,T� i�etitioned to askG�thatethe�urider ir_�cted Jeffersc�,ri ,' v�n��e h� ta��led. ' ,, o f Sincerely yours, � C�� r.��'�,z�-�.�—�,-t� ��� Clifford C. Sorensen ; • � � �'i 'I f w� . � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I 13 Court Hou:e,b6102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commiuioner LOUIS H.McKENNA,Deputy Commluioeer Phons:223-4646 May i8, 1970 Kr. Harry I�iarshall City Clerk BMILDIIiG File �io. 19473 - I�proving Jefferson Ave. Heariug Date - Maq 19, 1970 Dear Sir: Forwarded herewith is a letter, with reference to the above project, for consideration by the City Council. Sincerely, d� ames J. lglia . Coaaissioner of Financ cc: C. B. Joriaaa �4 e DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE � . CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA ROSALIE L. BUTLER ��3 Court Hous•,bb102 Commissioner 1A�IS##�AFIC�t+l0�l4�i�ilb���if�i7Wf Phone:223-4M6 June 4, 1970 To the Council City of Saint Paul Gentlemen: I have examined the attached petition of remonstrance, filed in the matter of improving JEFFERSON AVENUE from Snelling Avenue to Edgcumbe Road (City Project P-0240), and wish to report as follows: Amount of frontage involved in said improvement - 7,399.82 ft. Amount signed for on said petition - 4,243.33 ft, or 57.34% (Amount required by Charter - 50%) Number of residence owners involved - 214 Number who signed on said petition - 154 or 71.96% (Amount required by Charter - 607e) From the above facts you will note that the petition of remonstrance is sufficient. Yours very truly, � ��� � `�. ,� Rosalie L. Butler Commissioner of Finance File; 17473 HEARING: June 5, 1970 c.c. Joe Haider Bill Donovan Walter Hurtley Mrs. Butler File �OO . • r � , ro . � r r� . � H Z � G � � ►C 'Ti '� h9 t�i O� t=i H - t7 (�!! �3 C!� ~ � � O � b o z ro � � H Z O O � . � c z z� z a ro � � � �o � a H O J 1 N � G O ,fa 'l7 (A � o Zi H th O � � tn � � n � Z � �C H N � 0 N � � � J z O = � D m � -� - V i � m A f�l N '� Z A r � m m � N ll� A rn � � y 0 = D � vZ Z � D AI . 3 D O Z D Z 'J}.���'i �1i��-'-. I C z 0 0 � � O � ��4�_��v ,y. ,� :, "",' s ?} ZZ � o C oN '1 rl�:_` �' ��I V /�,��f J m D z r p ro N r N � m v 1 ...,,, o m � � .Zl m nVi (;� I. � �O ;`° �r D � � � �v� �a� , N x 0 m D '_" m m � Z C? II� . o � Dx r 1 D � r Z D Z , � f � i � I 0 I N � i m . A � r "V-�� 1 � � .� � ' /,,� ' . � � � y . H � N rt O• , � � � � � .��.t � � , -f n �� � � � F (p �• �o p tD � v � a� r-S, �, C� (�D (r. , � --- � n tyD tt- F-�• t�, '�C � � � ��� (�p �C f�A C� f.• � v � fi O � '� � r-. , � 1-� O � � �2� ,, O :3 @ C� �• N• � , r' n C � ~ � �\ � � � M � , ro � � � � � . N L7' (D (D O on- u�i C� N — �, �. " � �'� ~• � � �' T` � (D � �C � � � S' �. (,� a in �' rh � � N C` \ N N O ct cn ►-�ro • . �\.i �' � '� tbT] - '� � � �A rr iv a �'C G H sv N H � O •� H � � z�:� R� E O ' � Z . trS (p t� t-c O '`' Cn '.� � � h �j . � � a � � r,_�-� �' � � N rt � G CO � � t tn � � � H � n � N• C c� —� � -�..� � � � N � � � ._ � � N � �7 � � � N C �� � z N � � � tD G n � � rh i� N t7' s c°� � O O ►-t � a � � � ri- fi @ � �� �ro � � � O � f�+ ` •a + �15 L N ',C Uz .'` �1 c "�.��'1 }.�-� � `� fD � E �1.'�' U �� ,� tA N n u. '� N � . j � �' `n � v, � \ �' � N �t' w �;.° � a l� ',� � � ' E,l �• F'. � .'t J ; ` �ti�''� � � .� p �t �k F''' C'1' • c: � :�1�� � ',j' �• � . � � A� N m n a � K E � � w � � � � O i�.� & � '. C � \13 fi �S fD Fi � �� tD � ` \ � � w- �. � � � � p � h � �� fD - � ; � � ! O � � �.' •�' � ', F'° N � � -s-- � `�- �Y �; • - � � � `' � � � N �i° O • � � � n (D � ' � � � � p . (D tD �-'• � rn Ffi (� � . .L � `^ . .. @ � � � C� (D ft N• r-h �C � �� � � @ n ~ b N G � . :: ►i O � � O � (D () rt - ^ u. N- � � C �" t-� - � , ro � ro °, cn - a ° � � � � tr �n ro C �` a r�t� u�i C� N 1. `� v F'• W• � � ;� N • m � rt � J N � � �W � � v� � U� aFh U� N � �' � r� �, � � NO � . N N (D 'd . � � Fi '� t�i � �A �C G � H J � O ~ t-yi � � � �i r� Q., n o � � � , { �n b m ��` � w � � � '_ � �- �, � �. �.�. � o ~ � �. o� �' �, � � �. � � � � ' � � o � � � � cn � ` N ro � � � N tD G n �' � n a �• r � s� � � a � � � � o � o � � � �� �n a �.o � ¢ N � � � fi S]. ' � ns �o � � -�`1 'f"� � FJ f'�' � ,� � 1 N o f � , o � •��,' ;y�i "i� '��.� ,!.11`� � � � � ' ,; C " A► N '7 �� h] ri 3 .° � ` � il('�} n �C : y � .� < � n O n' . t,�� � O ��I � � � O ^, n � � �� » � Q � � p m� N, � � " � Q � ` � n � � � `� o A �� � � � � �� �� � ��. �. _ • - ��7'-��h� �� � _. -- / � � � . ,� ...,� . � �-,� � �--�� � �� � � -� z� - f-- �, �`�'Q�-��_ � ��—e—z�����c�� ` � � , �('�(� - � - - -Q- �� � � C�--� � �- Z._ j . �`+I � � - � � � ►:�1 � �, � , ,r� ��.. , �� � _ . �. , .. . ,, ;�. C ,, , � � ��� ,� : ` �, ti � , , . � � ` \ � - , . t � ��► �� � �� ► �' � � `� �_ • ,�� . � • � a.� � � � � �\��� � � \ 1� �� ' � ' � .� \ �� ,t � • � � ��. ��v ��� . ►� �� �� � �� . � � �� � �, � . � � � �� : � -�� i � �� . ► : �� . � ��� � ,�� � � � � � • .�_ � �� � � � . . I'� � , ' . • • \\ � ���\ ��. . . \,1 + � { 1 , . � 1 , � . , , �` \ ; • `�� ` ' •I w , ., � � � • � � �� , � �: � \ \ � ` � \' �,�' � � i ��� � t� � �'��� �� �' ����� � � � �� `�. � � f �\.��� � ` ��� ��1 �� ' � . �, �. -� � �; �� ��` ��� _�� � � �� � . � �� ► � � ' l � �. � � �� �� . , r. , _ . ,. � _� , , �, ,, � .� ; , 1 k � � � . � ► • \ ', y ` � � . �. � C t, • • . ��� '� ..�� ���� � � � � �e � � . � � � � . �. � � r� _ �� �� �,,�� � � • r ► �� ��- �, .� �.A , � , � \ � � 1 � . . i .� \ '. �' ��� � �� � �� � � ' � ` � ; ' - , . � _,� . � . . , -� ��� � ` _` � � � ,e , , ; , � . , .. • � . ,_ , , � , �� � '� � _ ; i� ��� . A . . � � ' + t� �'�� ' 1 �. '� � ' ��. � . � � � , i ' ' � � .. � � �. . . � �� � a . ! . � , • , . • , . . � . � � • ' . . • - ', • - :� ' . � : '�� • i �' � • t • • � �\\ � 1�` � �! � 1, 1e ', � � ► � r � \ � ` � \ � , , ♦ � � i �: � � � . . � , . . , • . . �' F . :� ; ; � � '� � i- -� • . - t-{ _...._.._.____.__ __�_-----------:�':�:..____.�._---- ---�.._..__�_�_.. _..--�--- --{�-----�--_,..,�-- ---._.._.____� .,._ � F� � - t� �� � O .� T ,:� n (J �;� • n �I • f'C' - tj N G� U� .)' (> � � � �.. �.� p � (J �3' �` r ;!� G1 t-h �� . ?� ' � ,S C) � � � �� .: c, ��� . n �, C� n c•i- !�i . � F'• !:ti 'ti ��{ �t r',- rh � � � n '�ti (J C) F,. �, Ft O i-,� �( �:, tn r: 'C '�V �,, � +S O '�; :� ��. O :� t� (� • �fi �a. f,. �. O ' til �i± t'r t_� C� �: :r" �f; � r� t? (J 4 - .� ;s ti� �i r �'i� i� �; � �J ._S ('�' fJ \ � O £�� :.f� O •� �^. !-� F n , . . `' --.---_______..___- .___<__.____ _..___----------,.�_. �� �� �� C� CJ ,� � ---�._. 4�_.._p---___`-�-�-.__.�------- ..,• � }.,. �.,. w • (; _� �;. :s j' J � Q� � � � � �; �� .�` `W p� � � � f]J �-� O � `� '�_ �! � � i?, in rh U1 �- t-j :3 `� �` � � (') � fl � �� �lr� �7 }"1 Qt (t� �� C �.7 �'�rll �. r.� fJ' � �I i '� ti J !-: � � '� r:' :� . �3 4�, f, f-a � � r3 O �� �1 ��• � Q, ; O , `2 � ---__ ----- -�--------- •---_------- -_�__. __.�_......____. _� ._---- ---- ----_ __._ _._W__ _..._� µ�� t� O 2 �•j '� �� � � :� ^, � r. o a� � : s�� �: >s t�� �, ` � � �-�: }; t' �-; o � � � a :; y�. �� �> � � � ,� ::.. � �.y ,.� � �, '' � �' '� � fp i� � ��' � ._I. 't � � }, �`f � � x � , S :S L� � � > � S% O (7 T �.� !. , f� .j �•7 � � �, � i, ? (` � �� � .�, r,� S l ��{i'c,��y,'�d� �.�,. .7 _ ._____ .._.__.__��-`� ...__�_.__.�_.__.. _`......_. .�__.�_____.__---------....`�_- °--•�-�_.._.__. ._�- ------- � n� �.. 3�� s�,t W t< „ ., , • �; � _ �, � � rc ('����1,'�,�.� �j �C ° � L �- ` ,� 0� � {r n O p►�'� C �- � ' t11 �� � � , ----- ��' �.. =,: •�•r�S ;.i Q yl�� _ `_ �Q �.,.:� _ , ;y n. __...--.---.,-----.___.__..___.__.....__--- ._._.___._.___.._ ..,..___._.___..__.�..__..__.._.____..�._.___._____.___._____ __.__ ;s o v� � �C cn ` �� � � �U t� \,�� ` � � � ��• �}.. \� Qr � �, t }_� F j �'-Q �Q n r.� �f J L> :s ` i� f-'• � J . :� �, �'r +:. F'. rt • � � , �S ��� . �� '-__---___._,.._ _____...._.._._...._-�-_-.._._._____._�..__. ._.__._.---_.._°--_,..._____._.__._...._._..__._.___.__.__._-._------�,�,.';• '�^ C) f-h � � - � �-ai C� }'• o � �-t i ,. � � c � � � �, �:;, `i. � ; � . c� i, si �� i '.r, -� ,:� �s; (� F., (� � � 1 !� �� `-a �lj f 0 O • � IJ' "_�_�.�_�_......�..�.�_��.-�,.�..-__.�_..�_�_.�.��.�..������..-�.....�.�..._�_��_�.�._�..�._�.�_���__..��..��..�.�.�.��.._.�...��.....�.��...�_�.�.. cn ' ' + ' J r:ay� z9, 1970 9 I� Francee 8. Waite� a aingle person purchaeed the property on 1332 � Jeffereon on May 1� 1969 on a cont�ract for deed basie f'rom Roae A. Jacobs. I filed homeatead righta in 1969 and have resided on the premises since May 1� 1969. � /`� � (�tf ��'��� / '/ � 8ut�scribed ani' sw�r, t , �-:.iore mA t�::,,�� . >r1�.._ :ti� . .�,--- � ���� RANDALI: 7. BtRxE{� � PubII0. Ramsey Cpmt�. ,�1. �#a0lNmisslon Explres Aprq 1�, �_ �� r ` ' �. Y t_'" � G j,� � .. ;� r I- � � � �;�j�1�� ;�,������ 3� -� Z;�� � L� �� �� ,!��`d 0��13 ' e / i ro � r H .�3,' H z � 4 K � ro � � O trJ H � t�1� y t� ro o ►-+ � � o z °z � N t=i � O N � n � � � � H z O � � b � z � N rn i � �c o H O J ( N � � o � ro cn Ki o �1 H � t� � C � l� � z �' +C H N � r � � 0 n =°:,= :�� _:_� -»c c�-< ,,._ �n ��� � �� -*� c- _"_� �"� �::_ �=-• ��''' rn • :�� � o --'� -,� ::-�, _... c� ' m �=_ , � . . ' .5-- a� fD H � ~ N �i° O � . �y- � �A C� � \ �. ��� �l • (t n � � � n_.. � cn �' - � � �' � � � � � � n � °� n cyn r�r � N• r-n �c � �:a � ' ► �"'� f'°�' �"11 � � ' ��� � I� !D �C (D � t-�t' ` _ _ ' MJ N s, .'�� � � ` � } � ` O � lD C2 � D, f... � ; � � � � � rt � � � � . , a � � .� _ � � ro ' �. i � � � � � � � � � � ' o � � N i3" (D fJ O � C ortv�i C� � - � \ . � � N• N• � i�. '— �� �. ' � (D � �C w � �l � ` ' ��' �, (,� I� • ' Q � � t?� O � � ,_ `T r � ' � �� � �' � a �� �++ (- � � � cn , � m r� tn �n F-� O c�P� . , ., . � - � N F~�- fD �d � \� _:,_ ' .� ' ' �A c�-t � . H ,, � '- , � a � � � rt� � O � t-y-i . \ � � @ � (� � i=W fi �� � , .� �Q U� �=J ' ` �_ _\ �j � r � '��,+ n O :d rr a � � � � � '��� `,. �- � s� �• �, � '�� � �• ' r� � ~� �r !D t�6 Z , � � C ~ � � r � ^,J cn� � � M H � r � � � r �.'' O � ti � � � � K � N Z � r � O C) � . ��. � (D � �''1 � � .� � � � � � � C � � � t � m �r N � � � �� -- � � n �' ~� � � �� p O K W t3' � �' , \c � \� f`' �� � \� � � � o °, a � � � ��o � �' N � b � �C � � � � i1. � � � � � l_ 1 ,� ' � \ �, I-� ct � ,_� 1 �• O � � T _ � O � �• � . � C.' • .� W lV 5 c � � W � � '�C �. �, `•a � � � o Fi �� ,� � � � G ` \� o � �; O � p � � a � �� � . ' ' � �u m w �� � � � °A � � � \ � � . .�` � � n� � � �,� `� ` �, �, � �, � � � — � �� r H � � H N r9- O , '� � J n � ' � � ° � . � , � � o � �. I � � � �, �-,, � �.,, - � .� C.� N• n � � 1 �' � N tfi �C t{ �� h� f F M � - � � � f't U `� � fi O�-�( m`" � \ IJ O �/ 1V � rr �r . � � cr � � � q C :s � b � � �, cu , , � o tD a ..�� �- N t3' fJ fD � � � ' O ('1" N C] fD � � f''. f'. � \. \ \, � � \. • tb :f2 c#' �' � � � � �� � � J a � ao �n � � � c,� �`'`� a �.� ►� � (D (D K tJ) (�. ,, � (�, - tn N O t�t' •� . �� � .�� � � F�'-N "d � r j `d trJ � W � � H � 1U F-� H (/1 � � � �� ~ � ,� ��- a z o � z � � � � � K o � � � , ` � - , �n � c�i o x ' � ` � a � � t� � � � � _ � t.�, F'• � � O � � r rr � c� � C ►-'• � � � � � � tA � Yr�h �-3 � � � N• C m �- � , `� � � � � N � � l -� (D `� 'TJ � �• �� � � � � J � `� � � � � � � � rt � � K �, a �• � -- �. . � �.. \ �. . � o o n ,� a c� � (.J� U � rr � � O , � �,b � � � O :� S�' " N � ''� N � N \ � � � � � � � � � v W � � x o �, � � � o � � o J �N . �• � �� - ' �' -�' c.a *� n ro � � ; c� � v n �c � ;�� sw , �� � � .� l: � � � , o �. o :� ;� ro � � c�, O �`- ` ` U � � fi �. ° � �, � � �, ` 1 �. �, s�. � t� 3 �J � �q (D N g" �, ro � . � p� h w � �D � '.� o � � � �- I � � � o � �:+ :t . �-- �� � � �, � , �, � � � � �,� � � � � ' ' � � �r� (D H � H t� rr O _ ' �- �• � ,� •t� A � � � �f • fi � tn �' � � ''�^� .� N w p (D b +o �'v r ,�2 rn rt' `� � ( � � r. c� N � � n ' � N r�h �C ..�.@,t ' ` !!R,�. � K ct �h rt 'l ' � N ''� hi Un ~ � 'd UI C ,C ' ' � �. fS O � � O � (D n � � \� �• �-'' rt � m � � a ' -� rt- m � o � � � � rt, � . ro � � � � . . �� ° tr m co ° o r�i- u�i C) .� � F.,. N. N . p�, � \ ..0 � � V'� (",,� � - � � (��D ",C c�n �lt w � ,), �\ �' , U; `�' -C � � �r� � N � � �n � o rt . . �� �, N N� ro � � � r� � � � H fv I-� y � N � a � .. z � � � � �, n o � � � � �' `D' � o x � a � � r� � � N � cyn z � -_� � � `, � m. � � � � . � ' p N K � (�, � �i � m � � � � � �� � N C � � � a� (D � N G N rr tD n � D ' � �ii fi � � (� .� A ' y � � t� rh W �C a \ Q � " � \` 5�. � � � � N rh A� � -.,�'1 � � �.- �� r :s O � a � �, a � ro � �c N -\ � � � ,� � �4 o � a Nr°s �`4 N �' � " ; ti - -� 1� � � � � �1N x � o !E o � � � , � � * � � � � � 3 '� w tr � � (� , '_� '�i ►i yi � � E 4 � � �• �' � � � (" �. p O Q. �°. -- t-i� �, � FS Q. � C' O 4��� O ft �+ � e 3 (D � � V ` � �. � � �„i, � K � � � , � ✓, � ° � fi � �� � , � ` r `:.f o W � p O , � � ° „�' �,� �� � � < < Z < < < � � �, `� �. � � ',^' ' ,� ! i �� � � �� ��� ' �� — � � ����i , �, � � � � �� � �. � �� � � � � � � � ��, A � � • �' ' � � � � . � • • � l ' � A� ' ' � � �� � � �� � � � � A i� f � � �� � \ 1 ��� � � ��\ V � , \ �\ �� '' , � �, ,� '� �, � ,. ' � ,� � ` - , � � �,`�� . • 1 : '� '` � �� � � ,� ' � � �� ,\ s � � `. � � � `` ! � � » � ' ' • i � ' r�� � � � � ' � � • � ` ' '�� � . . ; � . _ . � , : � \,, ,� . , �� _ . . I� , � . , , , ; , . , , , • � . . . , • , . . � `.` � ► , . � ►. a�� ► � ;�,,,� , , �� �• � �� �,� j ���� t�� �t �e' \y � � � � . ; , �,. �. , — � : _ _ i ' , � �l �� �; ; � (�V � . . ` � :. 1� �� ��� � A `� . . ; � � � 1� ` � � �� ,. �', 1 � � I� � � � � . 1 , � � � • � 1 �, \, \ � � k� �\ • • �` � ; �� � ; � �� ,S , ,t� • ` ` • • � ��; . � � ► ►\ ` � � � � � � . ��� • � � ' 1 � � �, . ri ` ` ' � . . � � � 1�, � � : �1 �. � `, P -J �� � . . • � ��` � � ' � . �, . � � � � �� a , , �� , ; , � � � � , � � � � 1 � '` ('� � ' a� ` . I, � ` ,.� . ; , � ` \ . � � ` ` � ' � • � � � � ' , � • � . . ' • ♦ F. ' � . � . .�� . � . � � . • � � � � • � . � 1 ♦ ♦ • • � � \ �` i � � ' � � � \ � • � � � �� � �� + � \ . • `\` � '; � � � c �� � �3 H - � � N ft o . ' r'-}'' . � . '� �P � `� � `�1 • ('i" Fi � � O � " ,.� \ \ \ , �,.� W � 1-h ,l :,� n � "� � �- C7 � c-� �i . � � � N• H� '�C � � � (�p �C (� f� N y � �� . ri U � � � � � tn � � j � � � o � co" � ^� .. �� > u, w. O (� _ j � . r fD ;b �-t F-' `��, , rt- � (D O� ro � ; `� �� �� � � � � � � � ro � � �r � � � � � � N U� (D 'C�il p � � � (D i-t C J C7 �-t N n � � `.. \ �,. � A ` \ � v (D �L!• �1' � ,\� 6- � .� � � - � �., �, � ��,,� `' C� `�" � � m � � vJ l�') �,,� t1� � � �, N;� e ��, f` `� , `p � i2. U ^ � � � \� U) h� U�i l� � � � � \ � - V � � `a � \ ) (D (D ►� tA 1`. N N O rf' �, ., � \� ' , ;' �' N� � ro " � � � ' W c�t A�i H - \ � � r. � �, x 1 � ¢1 � N H � G� t` c~ � � � •• � � � � t� � z � LL K O � Cl` � � tn ,ti � tn "-i F � � N \ � a � � � , � > a �• �, :� �, , , �• �r � o � � ��. �• O � r-�t, tZn �J � � , � � �� � c � y � � _ ° � � � . � � � � `� � o � r� � � � � � � � , �' • `� `' ` � � � � �' (�D � � � -. N � � � � � ` N G N n � � n � � �, �. �� � r �, s� `. ;,� , � a � \,. \ `i+� �`. �1 } � rt � (D p � �. *'�, -t� �' O t� W , � Q � a � w :� � C� � na �, ° �. �r � `� � � v � \ � � � �r � � x � o o ct �� N• c.t. g ° ° � a � � � � � � � . � — � � n �, T -^n N ,, � � o w = � }� a . � v �� Gy �: ,�' � � � m N o � � � � � � � �\ � � � � � � � � --�1 � � , o ;� . � � r v, �, u = � -, # � �' � � � � t. � � � � �, t < < < � �- ' q � . H �.= �i �3 N �i- O . ' �' ,�; � � '�' n � 'a ' r4' (�D � c � � O � • � . � � � ti� n . � ,-.. y ��. � . J � � � � � M � � � � �' � � N �C t�D f i ' " � ' ro u�i G `� �� � o � ron � - � - � � tJ. F+• � O �p � F"'' 11 � c�t (�D (D O t � tii {p „ ' �d � � � �L � � �' N C� (D fJ p �c• tU K � � � � �° p � � c't' � N � � . � � �! , � p � � � � � m � � o �. � c�n � . � 6' � � � w� �� a �n �' °, cn ,�\ � N w o c�t • � u� �ro • �, � _ ` � �• c� ro �^ � �, �' K � � � � J � O ~ t-�i � � .� � '� CL E O � � • trJ fD f2, n O ` � � � c + . � I � R+ Q O � � . � � �r a � � r� � �• � � � wrr � G o S 'I � �. p. � t-roh Uzi R. (° � � N• o C m � � � � � (D Fi n � ' � f.t ;3 N '� �Q � ro � � � w � � � N � �' , N � � � � � � n c,., �. r rn a . � a .,�, � � � �- � �. � r°r � c�u O �'' � � � � �� � � �.O � �+ N W "� @ .� � , i � N �. � � � na � n � � � � � �r � � � � x �� ° �� orr �� �• � O 3 �' � �l Ai N o � ' ro � �'°' t -�' ~ ►� '� E %' f-i•, `'' � o � � �� � N. �+ m p � � • � O A' °� � n i �' � 0 � �t n (� � .� m ., �, c o �, a � a , � t� w- .� � � . _ ►i � @ � � i � � � . � � �4 �`'� � � (u �''' v; `� � � � � �_ �o, T � �� ,. � � �' ��. � `, P, � ` `, " ° � � � _ , �",� �- .� � �' '� �" c � • . •. H � � . N t'o' O • �' `'�\ - a� Q .� � � ►�t � �o O �0 (D }.'• � � � ' � n (� J � � C� N c�' (p � . � N• t-h �'C K � � �C N f� f1' , � ' (D � � � � i-4 O " � Q Q � (J n r.�. '� u. N. p � \ ' � ro � r N QC �' � _ ` r � �" � �D °, fD - � , �i � � ��-' ' ~ N t3' (D � N� � ort' tKn f� �. �. �.' v F'• F1• - � ~ � • CU c.4 ct A� �` (,� �' _" M� !J � � � 'V► � � R+ O (�D �', �`' `� , a N l � � (�D N ~fi Cn (A F-' O �'t UI t°�'U • � ° � fi `d [roTJ > - �A � A' �-3 � � � tv F-� H � O •• t-+ a � y • r� c� c� n o w cn �i �, � `- N i� � c �' a � � � �., N• � � \� C M-�'. CJ fD � � - - �' � � � y � � � , �. � � � � � � ° � u�, z � � A\ c�D � � l� p� ,b u� `1• N � N � N , � � G � ,\ - � � ¢, N� � � � \ r+ �n a � a � •- � \'0 R ~ � ' �� \ �' U, � (� °- � � F'41 S� � �'� � O � a N � � � na h. ° .� � . �-.� {J� !� �' �' \ °� F° �+ , J � x �• o �� f � � �' — � a m � � � , � � �. p � o �s r W �' ° o a � g � o � o � � , o c �' � � �. fC � � � � `A . �+� �' � � �_ �� �� :� � � � � �. �, � < �. < < � . � C � `- � � � �, , . , H �N H - � b� J :\ �,', � A 0 ' � N - � � � v • � � . b' l � � �.� 1 � . _. N � � (D � _, � fi. � ..c., w � � �� � ` � F�+� �-�h 'C �t �, . -�, �, ���' fD � M O N- � � ` � � � O � f�D � O �i � fD � �t N �, � �. r�t N f�D O tD� , ' ro � � M p� � o a � tT N O� (D N N ` � � � a � � F+• F+. � � � , �. � a", � k w �� �'; � �►. � � � a � � � cc � � � � \ � �� l �' ~ � � a �ro �' � �, n I� \ � � , -� J � (A N O rh ��; � cn rro • -�� � w cc ro i \` � � K � H a n � , u i� � � � H �' , � �+ � �� p � . n , � ' CrJ fD x ' an o , � � � w ►�! _ � , p�, A � � � � �,, . � � t v •fi 4 O ` �� ` , , r• � � � v t� `� ; � � M H y � �• C fD � � � f�A � . � `\ , Ft 4�� (�D 'J tA=1 � , � �' � � �� � � � � � � � � n cr �D M p�i �7' "C fD ~ � ♦ � °� � rt K N p, � U i `�\ J ,,, O � � �� � � O r�► N 'L� � w�v � a � o - a c� � � � � na o � o � o � 1' N � x � o � � oO � �•� � � am � � N � � �� � n � E � � � � � � . � ,� � N � � oa N o �, � � ` � H � a � w �4 � �, . . N . � � n � � � e � ` Fa. � C < < < �� �., � `" �, � � < < � � -� . f . f � �\ � � • F,,,{ � @ y � (� N rt O • • .t� C) (D . � ' �rt., • { � N � O (D � � m rn H� t�' "� � p� r. c.i F�a- N- M �C � rt , � (�p ',C (D (� ~' ' ro uKi G ,� ` fi O z, � � O � N C� � ��� ' � � nC �" t� , � � � � � � , FI (�D � rt' � N C3' (D (D � � � O �i- N C] � v � ~� �� � � � � a � � N � � ro � � \_ � C'� a cn R' °, � � '� � � �' � ,�• � m n cn � N �ro � � N• (D hU - � n ro � W t�' A� H � � H �' � � ~ O � � � z � � �� � � � n o � � � _ � �, � m � a � � � � � �, y �o. � � w. c� m � � ; N• � C � � � � � � � ti (�D � � � � � � N � � (� , � (D G N � � � � �� rrm � � .�, � r� o on �C (D � s� _ rr � cD O p' ,�'' ""� � �j � �',� rfi � �,o � i�' � p N �C U� , � " ~ f.�..� fi �L � y . � � �"� �j � � (n + � (� F"i �} �� l0 .`3 � � ,�' �• O �' ° . O rf' �� '�' �' o � • p A1 (D � � � � � � � E � � � O� � � u � �� O � �� � K � N ` � a � ��� � '• fj � N � 0 `,q (D F'- �� I � � � � � N � � N `Q C, � -• ., N' � � ` 'C. C -S� \ , , Area Code 612 �lTy � THOMAS J.STEARNS 223-5121 �w F� AR7HUR M. NELSON '� x JEROME J.SE6AL o ••"•: '' THOMAS M. MOONEY '� ' a�o..��� '' KENNETH J. FITZPATRICK �Y'' '`c PAUL F. McCLOSKEY,JR. JOSEPH E.CARTWRIGHT CITY OF SAINT PAUL R.SCO1T DAVIES PIERRE N. REGNIER PAUL J.KELLY DANIEL L. FICKER First Assistant LEGAL DEPARTMENT KENNETH A.SKRIEN 316 City Hall, St. Paul, Mionesota 55102 DANIEL A. KLAS Corporation Counael June 5 , 1970 Honorable Charles P. McCarty Mayor of the City of Saint Paul Dear Mayor MeCarty: Re : Petitions of Remonstrance At the June 3, 1970, Council meeting, you requested an opinion from this office concerning Saint Paul Charter Section 243. Yo� request presents the following issue : Whether an affirmative vote of more than a majority of all the members-elect including the mayor may be required to override peti- tions of remonstrance . OPINION The powers that may be exercised by the council must be within the authority delegated to the municipality by the city charter or other enabling legislation. State v. Clarke Plumbin� and Heatin�, Inc . , 238 Minn. 192,�— N.W. 2d 667. The City of Saint Paul operates under home rule , but since it remains a political subdivision created as a convenient agency for the exercise of delegated govern- mental powers, the legislature may withdraw or modify any powers so entrusted. Hunter v. City of Pittsbur�h, 20'7 U. S. 161, 28 S. Ct. 40, 52 L.Ed. 151 . In Minnesota, the paramount power of the legislature is specifically pre- served by Article 4, �36 of the State Constitution. As a result, when the exercise of municipal power conflicts with state law or enters into an area that has been pre- empted by the legislature , such action is null and void. Power v. Nordstrom, 150 Minn. 228, 184 N.W. 967 . In MeDonou�h v. Cit.y of Saint Paul, a recent opinion by the District Court for the County of Ramsey, the Honorable John W. Graff held that the provisions of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, Section 64.06, was null and void to the extent that it required the adoption of an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance by an affirmative vote of two-thirds of full membership of the city council . This opinion was based on the enabling statute which pro- vided that cities such as Saint Paul could amend a zoning �O , _ . Mayor MeCarty 2. June 5, 1970 ordinance by "a majority of the members of the governing body. " �ee Minn. Stat. 462. 357 (5) ; note also that the enabling act showed a specific legislative intent to provide municipalities with a single body of law in the area of zoning_7 Because the Saint Paul Legislative Code conflicted with the State law regarding the number of votes required, it was null and void to that extent . This is consistent with the well-defined principles of municipal power set forth above . The Saint Paul Charter, Section 243, provides as follows : "�ETITION OF REMONSTRANCE.7 Sec . 243. No public improvement , the cost, or any part of which , shall be paid by an assessment on the property deemed benefited, shall be made if a petition of remonstrance as hereinafter pro- vided is filed with the council at any time prior to the passage and adoption of the final order therefor. And no further action shall be taken therein and all proceedings had theretofore shall be of no force and effect and no other or new preliminary order for such improvement or improvements so peti- tioned against shall be introduced for a period of six (6) months from and after the filing of such petition. "Such petition shall describe the improve- ment or improvements and shall be signed by not less than sixty (60) percent of the resident owners , or their agents , of such property aforesaid representing not less than fifty (50) percent of the lineal frontage on the line of such improvement , or when such basis shall be impracticable then sixty (60) percent aforesaid representing not less than fifty (50) percent of the parcels of land so assessed. "Each signer shall write his name and place of residence, or where an agent shall sign the name of such owner by his agent and the place of residence of such owner, give a description of the property owned or repre- sented and the lineal feet frontage of the same when required as aforesaid. "Such petition may consist of several papers , but the names on each separate paper or portion thereof shall be certified to under oath by one of the signers thereof. � _ „ Mayor MeCarty 3. June 5, 1970 "Provided. however. that no such petition of remonstrance shall have anv force or effect whenever the council , bv a resolution adopted by a five-sevenths vote of all its members- elect includin the ma or and ado ted within twenty 20 days f rom and af ter the f i 1 in� of such petition, shall declare such improvement or im rovements to be a ublic necessit . " Emphasis added. A review of the existing state law concerning public improvements does not reveal any legislation that conflicts with the provision in Section 243 of the Charter requiring a five-sevenths vote of all the members-elect to override a petition for remonstrance. Furthermore , there is no gleanable intention of the legislature to preempt the field. Thus, the opinion of the Honorable John W. Graff cited above has no application to Charter Section 243 or the right of the people to a petition of remonstrance , and this Section, as presently worded, is a valid exercise of the council power in that respect . It is our opinion that in all other aspects , the five-sevenths requirement is a permissible exercise of council power. Acts regarded as of more than ordinary importance may require greater than a majority vote . Holzhauer v. Ritter, 198 N.W. 852; Savat�y v. Kin�ston, 274 N.Y. S. 2d 852. �ee also Sections 150, 1�8, 217 and 219 of the Saint Paul Charter which impose the same affirmative vote requirement_7 Overriding a petition of remonstrance should be considered as being of great public interest and the voting requirement is reasonable and proper as a local legislative action. In re 0 enin Alley in Whitney and Smith ' s Addition, St. Paul, 1 4 N.W. 983. Therefore , the issue noted above is answered in the affirmative . Respectfully submitted, DANIEL A. KLAS . Corporation Counsel � R. SCOTT DAVIES Assistant Corporation Counsel RSD:bl �lTY O� !�� 9� y� s 7. o .... � �` ���..�.�.. ab - �e � .. ^e �.. CITY OF SAINT PAUL Capital of Minnesota DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS 234 Cify Hall & Court House 55102 �� ,Ju1 y 14, 1970 The Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Cauncil Gentlemen and Madam: Re: P-0240, S-990A, 5-9908 JEFFERSON AVENUE - �nelling to Edgcur�e Rehearing On June 5, 1970, a pnblic hearing was held on the advisability of improving Jefferson ,�venue by street wi�ening and constructing certain stor� sewers. The Council laid the matter over in�efinitely to permit the Public Works Department to explain more fully the proposed pro,jects. On the evening of June 30, 1970, I, the Chtef Engineer and staff of the PubTic Works Aepartment, and representatives frcxn the Vatuation Enginee�ls office met with the interested property owners at the Edgcumbe playground and explained the nature of the proposed street work, sewer construction, and financing. 1 recommend that the Councit schedule a rehearing on these rnatters for August 1�, 1970, and instruct the Finance Department to send new notices to the affected property owners. Very truly yours, n . ert . Spra ka Commissioner of Public Works RFS:CLT;If 1, ,3 � r}i ` � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I 13 Court House,66102 ROSALIE L. BUTLER, Commissioner Phone: 223�F646 August 12, 1970 Mr. Harry Marshall City Clerk BUILDING File No. 17450 and 17473 Improving and storm sewer in Jefferson Ave. HEARING DATE: August 18, 1970 Dear Sir: Forwarded herewith is a letter, with reference to the above project, for consideration by the City Council. Sincerely, ' ��d � � �N¢-- Rosalie L. Butler Commissioner of Finance cc: Florence E. Huber Files O . ' � � ;� August 9, 1970 Ros�.l.ie L. Butler� Caa�nissioner of Finance. 113 Gourt House, St. Paul� r�4inn. 55102 Regarding File r# 17450 Pa.Qe 215 # 174^3� Pa�e 6 Dear Mrs. Butlers Thaxik you for mailsng the ncrti.ce of rehear- ing on Augu st 18th�1970. PJe w3.1], be c�t of the city on that date - but we want to infc�rnn yvet and the other C aaraai s si one r s and az r Jl�eyor M cC es-�y why �re axe vpposed to -the sewer as it is n� in draf�t f oxm ax�d al so ths wia�e x�.ng of Je ffe r- son Averaze. �Pe know that you w311 all give this very tho�grrtf�zl del1.berat3 c�n. I wduld appreoiate yaur rea�ling ths enclosed letter to the Cazncil when this ccalas up for consideraticrn an Au�ust 18th. Verv sincex�ely, r 1.�r. � Mrs. Reymond E. Huber, 1253 Jefferson Avernze, St. Paul� Minn. 55105 . ` i �� Atigu SC 9' 19?0 Regardin� Fi7.e �17450 Page 215 Every effort shvuld be made to find a way te re-r�te the stprm sewer as naw proposed in arder to saue the laxge Dutch e1a� trees that axch Jefferson Av�ezaxe to Edgec�umbe Road. Theee trees create a beautiflxl sight �nter ax�d su�ner and give u s ble s sed shade when t�e need. ar.i se s. We feel sure tha,t Mr. Dan Dunford., the sewer en�ineer will try to find e, suitable way to by-pass this s-Ereet 3f the aewers that have alre�zdy been installed in this are a are not ade que.te. Regardin� File � 17473 Page 6 T1�e proposal to widen Jefferson Avernaes Th3s ].s a frightening thought�:� Horrible for tI�ase vf us living mn the street if traffic is brvught claser to a�a.r �.anes. It is now knovm that 60� of polution is ceused by aratos. Even now the exhaust is s���rr�n� and perietrates cmar 1nc�tes when the window� are open. ti"le hava Raxid.olph School exld Edgecc�mbe Pla�'�rc�und, an deffer- son Ave�ze. A rleighborhood of chi].dren which is or� reason why we bu i1t aa.ir In c�e I�re. Scme-pea�rs later, it was changed to a 'thrt�gl� ' street �.nd later to a 'one side paxking' oril,y. There v+�.s no ca�plaint to these changes. This tam� it is differerrt and, we hope ou�r City Officiale wi11 pleasa �ive G1�A'T CONSIlERATION TO �JR WISI�S. Hanes axe well kept up rzrr.� not apt to beeane a slum a.rea under present conditions. Zoned as 'Residential' we belieae there is no need for more freeways leadin� to the heart of the city. There is Shepard Road� Randolph and St, Clair in this area - also #94. It has been braugh-� �zt recerrtly -that there is less tra.ffic on Jefferson Avernae than there was in 1959 or 196Z. V7e hope to keep it tha�t wray. It seems to me our tax dollaxs ccxxl�. be use� t� mare advantage than to remodel a stree�t that is perfectly suitable to the area and to the city axid to acca�rmtodate anotarists. � ��/���'�ve�''' '�/" `�/t� r � /��.� ' �� ,�� ����-�. .5�/a .5- � . CALVARY LUTHERAN CHURCH -_ -- ARTHUR H. BRAUN, D.D., Pastor "CHRIST CRUCIFIED . . . THE POWER OF GOD, AND THE WISDOM OF GOD" Phone 698-6138 341 5. HAMLINE AVENUE ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55105 May 18, 1970 The City Coutacil Court ldouse St. Paul, Minn. 55102 Gentleiesa This is a.n respo�e to th� notice of the propo�ed im- proveaen� of Jefferson Ave. Our Church Board is concerned tha.t the adethetie b�auty of our neighborhood be retained. �'e see aerit in the� widening of the atre�t only on cottdition that it is su�f- ficient to pexmi.t parking on both side�. It should be noted that currently no parking is permitted along our property on Jefferson �t Haaline� sor �,cros� the street from the Church on Ha�line, resulting in a shorta�e of paxking space for Church �ervices. Respectfully� "`°� . . Brau� s . . � _. `, � �$R. :�+ _� � � � � � �.� �� � �rabl� I�r lhMa� B�rs� MA� � g 1970 Uo�nsila�w� Dw� l+�r+�i� MQYOR'S OFFICE : A��erl� �j►ra�7ca �ie�� ?�� . Mill� t�ia�riaa ttol*rt P�r�ers� A�� �ar IM�r 1�►,� , r�art� hil�la�ar� Q�i�r 2�i6!!A a�d ��IQ6�1--�- 1►il��� ���, ,..Alr� lhr�l�s� Q�r1�r 24� -- 1�i2�i 1��73,� � �• . q�atil� t� a�t�ad s�nmaoil h�ari� o�t lle��l�� ��ti -••-+itw 1� 1Me��ia�sf o�ita�nts; 1� ris� f►� �►�►l,sa �► �pinl� r�asl� �l�t pr��M►t�. R�a 3� 9rwe Fr�f a� E'i�l�s 246lS� a�ri 2�d3.•� w �a t�hir p�l�st .• atit mw�►��swr,� raqraiit,uri in ss a�sk a� l�i� tr�j� ��rds i� �rL�a2� _ Atr�.� at�d w a�'o �mt �11� an�i t�oul� d!�'i�n a� b�d"31�r 11� ��l� t�w� •si,.�i� .w�ar �►. b.eas a�.qwat�. al t.k..i ;..ars urra v. wali ti. p.el.etiT i►app� t� #t i• l�t a• �e. Tt t� �s �rrr Ipr� +�1� xhioh � u� �►oi� thsri wul� b� s� traastil� �rl�i tiaol�••�. , �t�r: Ori�qr ?.�►��d•••-1� d�!'i�i�l,�r s�+M �h� �tid�aotl� � �a �' J��siat t�ss �►11lr� i� �p�� lt�wt. 1t � a► t_.,r,�m�lx�t to ir3��1 �o� p • � � �a �s► P�Pa'ti7 1�Vi► P��a1�� !a� �h� �dd�l� � � str�. A� it t� � ar�i �� t�oaat� ha�r� t�r► .�iY� �r10�► s�irN �o�ns a sr� �a� �!' th� t�iMi it Moatl 41�sn b� r�a�ssasr !.e �T� �haie slr�i p�s�u►+�c63.� ��arus �i' �r acira �is� euad p�17at01stit. 8�r �o�li b� pt�it�at �qr t�a t�1 bnild� (!'ra� t�h� stx+rr0�. Thi� �.� �- ra�al,� bapt�nl,� nnm v�tb'�r w3.�� bsal�±aar� arit �• �' �l�► f�ar Pt1+ri up �n�n► �a ths s�t�••w� !,t i� i�esi�.til� ta r�sv� it�, aai #►h� ��t�rriasa�,io�n trra t�h� �alt i� �n� �L,r ?� 1��� � tla�► b�an�if'�! ��s iwrrull 6i►r �tosllK��h � b�r +rt 1�h�► a�rrs� ro �11 br sar az,� t,hoN► 1►r�� �►�r� �ro �a�asi�n � rMlasr►. T� appw��� �i" t.h� strs�! �1� b� bii�o�tM. Ii �nr�li oas� us ��ariY ar� �r1a� u� l�prs�r�.t�a��. . � Tl� �4r�d Moult i�o� a no� tna�t„ e�da��e� l�h� �dr�u �3.� t� aAd fr+f�a ll�l�lpk A�ights sohe�l a� �o�lw P'ly�eoaaL.. !sa!!is Lar �+r �i�N do� e� J�'!'�rsoat �i�� S� �11sit aa�l Raad�►lpir s1�rMMt• ar� vtsa�t� and mr prr!`�rr � ltNp �.� aL • awt�r s�ts �Iith �n1T 3 �esi��M ptuh oa �h� str� tt d�ld ba a1�i�� as a r�alat► r�aidaitie�2 �rrsi. _ _ , tQj tli Na� t�i�ic �' ea�r r�aWa � !'�� th� x�li ptv���et. Th� x�� 1MSgtb �t ��u pr����st Kouli eatia � graat 1��,� si' basfu�s� t�r th� sfos�� l�aa�� �n S��rilira� ar,d J+r!"trr� an� N� !Nl hs�i�6 b� t�htrt a gr�a� 1�•s whai SxMlii� xa. patid� w �nul� he�.e iN U� xsi�b�ers�i by th� ait�r i'�r a� 11�urOh�ar �ssss iw ti oi��ir� �ft s1�rNt• !os �rieh a �s� muus��� pri��. w. w.alt be sn r..�or or #►t►. pr.,�.s� b.� 1au +rr.r .e thal 3i •an U. �d9.�t N j�s�i���j � � tlur �rr�rrs +o�' thr �lamni� e�i�siwy �r arrtaiai� di� � �e►♦� �h* �tsr��t '�! t�1 tas�ay�s !u �ML whwt �h� ��rst� �naa �la�s : ?L� SttN►1 +eptriM�s �!' it�9 2t�s�, alr� r!` lh�a p�rpl� ar� �2tssl.y►:�ad r�isML a�l eumrt �!'!'�st thi� �dird laq��ap� thw qri is �uN� tee gr�1�. Thi l�s at� �r+l �iirs h�� lw�t t n�n► �lrr�s�t ow ah►err 4aariar� �b� ��raps�� ta1w. Tluu�t �e►u riqr �r l�t�wt lntesss�,� w rt�l�t�, := < ��'yL,(, ( t` , �.� !j^r� i Tr�j• t�ort�. (r �� '�� . ��1W�1 Y� �� � . . ',i6� 8�. 8�u11laq� Ar�.� �t. Paulr �it�►. 7S�''3 t�i �s�r .•-H�� ?v�I��---8yitlan piurl� Add�tiwt. t July � �� 19?0 - ` � � � �--___; � y 4 '�°'��.��..........�,...��..,.,.,... �: �.��,;� ��� ���� / � Hon. Robert F. SpraFka % Comsr. of Public l�orks � B�ai ld i n�; ���f!�� r--� � ; _-, Dear Sir: � -��`'1��. �� ` ��� The City Cauncil t�d concurred yaur rec�mmendation and set a date of hearing for gust 18 1 , in the matter �f impravin�; Jeffersan Ave. by st t widenin and canstructing certa.in storm sewers, all�af--�ch `prev sly laid over indefinitely. i - �.._.__./ Very truly y�urs, City Clerk AO/ng rray , i97o � Hon. James J. Dalglish Gomar. of Finance �uildi��� Dear Sir: The Council referred t u fo c eck to eufficiency the matter of the petition of r� s�ranee ed ag nst the improvemen� af JePferson Ave. from S lling Ave. Edgcumbe Rc�ad. The matter has been 1 o�ver to 1da June 5th. Very truly youre, AO City Clerk n� ��'uly 15, 1970 ! i �:�.�`��.j.`.`�.., � �~ �__\ �� ,/�;,_.�,\'`\ Hon. Rosalie Butler � � Comsr. of Finance �/ �/ Buildin�; � � , �� � �, � .,., Dear A�Iad am: --- --- � <:� �!'_�_�__..;;. � ..,�..�, The Council on July 14 concurre `��.n tY��xecommend�.tion of the Cotmt►issioner of Publ.i arks and s eduled a re-hea��in� �'or Au�ust 18th, 1970, in he matter o improving Jeffer�son ,Ave. by street widening and c tructin� s rm sewers. Pl�ase send �ices ���_ ed property owners of this re-hearin . I Very truly your ��, 1 � � City Clerk AO/ng Jur� �, 1�'J'0 Mr. Daniel A. Klas� Corpor�.tion Caunsel. Att . Pa. Ke].ly Dear Sir: At today'a Counc�l meet ing a hearing involving the 3.�►apravement and sewe e Je son Averiue axea f`rom Snell.ing to �dgcumbe, co d c rning the prop�rty benefited theor,�r oz� a ssments. o�ai, oner Sprai'ka asked that these remarks b e tn wri ng arrd be attached ta the f31e in our office. Very truly your�, City Clerk AO�hp ,� MaY . , �97Q Hon. Robert F. Peterson Comsr. of Public Works Building Dear Six: nti : Mr. Walter Hurtley At today's Council m in� the C cil 1�id:oVer the Final Order for th� imprQV ent of Jeff son Ave. from Sn�l].in�; t�ve. to Edgcumbe Roa to Frida ne 5th. Commissioner th hat nt that time, th� C�uneil also be g e� c st est for e. 32-f'oot street. V�ry truZy �ours, City C1erk AO�n� � . � . -���-, �� ►� �o �� � , � �'���s�.��. ,. � � ,��� a� � � � � ' �'�,,/� �// .��� " �Q � /� ����� �J.(Y-�.Y ��I�LVV�' b 'X J��l..� I/IG�' , w,,�� r�'" l� � � �� � �n � �. a,�r� �a�� � ,��� � �� � ,,�,� /�Zb�'�-��U� / . � ����� ( � ,, r' 'Z.x��l3� � �-�'.+��, 1 �- ,�• ��J�C��✓?/�'� � ��a / � �� S:�bacribed an�! swor� fo defore mi ��,. tl�:�',.7`�9ay of��. 19 � ' � � .c+f���I�..:,�yL"`�' '� . YY�,}�l� � RA�IDALl 7� � J �1t Pubiic, RemseY �OUnty. �MMt. r �,�' �OMl�ission E�Ptres A�If1 12. �YK � �� �� ,t, �'�,. �',.' `� (;1�`i - C . ��y fi.. h����C, �-6 �+: �+ s, �`'�`� �+_° � :�1,� `h�� �'� � �:;,1. . .. r� , � � ' - Y � , PHONE 698-4016 • - MR. & MRS. ROGER J. TAUER 1552 JEFFERSON AVENUE SAIN.T. PAUL� MINNESOTA 55105 � i� ��;%_ � � �%�l r �� �%� �� � '-'1 �" �-' �_ � �;r '%z��E � �t��� .�ij�-����-z�_ �� . �� � - ����, ���.����� ����'�— ��c��� ,-�`1.�-��{ �'-"���, ' � � c ✓�'-C� �'��%'�� � � r . � � . � -,i' � � � , � � , � �,� �- �� ��� ''�'�-� C��; y �� � '';`-L � ��-� !? � C-.;/ /,`� �' ��/ � .� /� �/ �, ; �� �. ��id ����'-//��' —_��G�"�j'�E e �. C/�7� C��� p '..,L ���G� ;/ , � �� }� � �; , � �' � � `��-�' , �-�`�.C��%�`--��.<�'� "��� ,Cc1�-` _ C"�t'�''�Cc'� � ' % �� ��, � � � �� � � ��j ��� / ��� '-C%;� `-������_ �Jc"����. �-1'��G�����!���� �/ - � /CCi(�. �% ' % —�' �'7 G�-C'���z�- l.�� .��'CC('%;'/ � � �_.. . �.� ;���'����\,.�.� _�m��� .�, �,,:; � �;'., /� ``�'�y c• RAIVflALL �. dIR1IEl: � � ����� r,~�,�., Obtsry Pubiic. Rams� CMwt�. iMMr � �� 1�1t COSnmission Expira ApIN t?. 1MA � •. �'�` �\ r� ' G'�' >, . . •. ., . . 4 ' MR. & MRS. C. B. JOR(MAN 1191 EDGECUMBE RD. ST. PAUt. M�N 55105 May 16, 1970 T�r. James J. Dalglish Commissioner of �inance City Hall S t. Paul� Niinn. 55101 Dear Mr. Dalglish: Re: File 17Lt73, Pa.ge 8 J�e would like to ask you to reconsider the proposal to widen Jefferson Avenue and to construct curb and gutter. . J1e feel that there are so many improvements at this ti.me, that the cost will be a hardship, especial_ly for tl�e families that are on fixecl incomes. �nTe have jus t had new s idewalks on Jefferson and we know that some of the neighbors have not yet finished paying for them. The storm sewer is another project. _�dded to this the cost of widening the street and curb and gutter at this time, we .-'. _, .. � 1 feel it will be a great hardship. Perhaps we are overly concerned with costs. However, we are rememhering .that new sidewalk is coming in front of our home and also that we will he receiving an assessment soon for the paving project done on Edgcu.mbe several years ago. . :��ny fie lp you c an-�give �us wi31 b e appreciated. Thank You� /d . �a-..