The URL can be used to link to this page

249990 ,�.. "��„` f�.R;�!. ��h?x.' .. .. F' ,- ' � . '�y!:?H� `. .,.. .n ` . . � . .... � . '{..-� . . . . . ..��.f .• r. . °^ f. . . . . ... . � �� , '. � K �FINAL C�RD�R �OUNCIL FILE Na. ; F �� ,�, � By , �; File No. !'�# �- � ; ;; In the Matter of � aIM Mre�is3r� M►!,#� Ir�#RM�R�IM �'!i'� � �� : :�'; �� . a�� r � �°�*�tr�ti� +rll� � � 1N�rt� ��R1rtw�i ��r!• +r�t t� � �: °� 1Nrrlt�e� ��# a�i� !��d�r� f+��*�t +�it�t 1�► '��rrrwR �r ��#an �it !� �� ' �' � ; : �ili 1rr� iiii�� sa prq�et a � s�rs t� d� '�� irreqw�it �l3� � , .. � le+at Ri�� It�M�rrt at�► f�r lltis!i � � 1�t �i1wrri 1�t 3, (+��l�i) ' r � R � . , � , �. � under Preliminary Order_ �! approvP� � �* �� ` � �. :; � Intermediary Order aPProved � � A public he�aring having been had upon the above improvement upon due notice, and the Council "' ' ; having heard all pexsons, objections and recommendationa relative thereto, and having fully considered ,�;:,;; � the s�me; therefore, be it �; RESOLVED, By the Council of the City of St. Paul that the precise nature, extent and kind of im- x provement to be made by tPte said City is __ _ -- --__ _ _ ---- -- -- _-----— -- Grade and surface with bituminous material the East-West alley � in BLK. 3, WILD ROSE ADD�TION from the Easterly North-South alley to the West lot line of �ot 11 , slk. 3, Wild Rose Addition `f including a 20 ft. x 20 ft. turn-around to be lOGated s►, �ot > > , and l2 of said Blk. 3: also construct a storm sewer in the East� West alley westerly from the West line of said Lot 11 to the � � westerly North-South alley, thence southerly in the westerly North- � South a11ey to 7hird Street in the aforementioned Blk. 3. ; ;� �---- �q� _ -- - ----- � �, � � � p--�'�'r-- _....�.�. and the Council hereby orders xaid improvement to be madg as a public neceseity. RESOLVED FURTHER, That the Commissioner of Public Works be and is hereby instructed and directed to prepare plans and specifications for said improvement, and submit same to the Council for approval; that upon said approval, the proper city afficials are hereby authorized and directed to pro- ceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therewith. courrcir�rr ! � AUG 61974 ��-l-� '�'�t-�- Adapted by the Council Yeas BUTLER Nays �' ._ G,� � � 6 1970 CAR!SON� : APProvect LEViNE MERcDITH � Tn Favor SPRFFKA ayor TEDES�CO � Ag�nst PUBUSHED AUG � 1�70 Mc..�t�,TY s-se.sac �� s.l , d�� 9 � 9 Amend the order for the alley improvement in BLK. 3, WILD ROSE ADDITION to read as follaws: 6rade and surface with bituminous material the East-West aliey in BLK. 3, WILD ROSE ADD(TION from the Easterly North-South alley to the West lot line of Lot il , Blk. 3, Wild Rose Addition including a 20 ft. x 20 ft. turn-around to be located in Lot 11 and 12 of said Blk. 3; also construct a storm sewer in the East- West alley westerly from the West line of said �ot 11 to the westerly North-South alley, thence southerly in the westerly North- South alley to Third Street in the aforementioned Blk. 3. I � - ,� 1.�xi ; � � � � U . � � a � 249�� "' � � �;. � . . 4� " � �� -.:`�� '»- �'d,�'��G�� , OFF ICE OF THE COMM 1 SS IONER OF PUBL IC WORKS •�,:: "�,,'� �O � ��". (� „A :., `�i , '� '� QQ RE PORT TO COMM I SS I ONE R OF F I NANC E �'�.t,1�` � �� `�� ,�� `v�,�o ; May 26, 1g 70 To the Commissioner of Finance of the City of St. Paui : The Commissioner of Public Works, having had under consideration the preiiminary order of the Councii known as Council File No. 2'�+8929 approved May 20, �9 70 relative to gradinq and surfacing with bitua�inous a�teriai the East-West alley from the Easterly North-South alley to the Westerly North-South alley, and the Westerly North-South alley fran the East-West aliey__to Fre�ont Avenue 1n BLK. 3, WILD ROSE AODITION; alsa construct a storm sewer in the Westerly North-South alley frcxn the East-West ailey to Third Street in the aforert+entioned BLK. 3, (G-1951) ✓ . and having investigated the matters and things referred to therein� hereby reports: 1 . The estimated cost thereof is $ 6.183.00 � � 2. A plan, profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached and made a part hereof. � 3. Initiated by the Conunissioner of Public Works 4. tmprovement is aslced for upo� petition X T �� Co issioner of Pubi ic Worlcs � �� b �M �:'Ft�,�^•"N+�t � • . , � a � . . �c•a+'�� J. Wti,LiAM DONOVAN� 223-5317 Valuation Eng,ineer ' -�-, , CITY OF SAINT PAUL R@Y. E. BREDAHL, Jr. ASS't Voloot{o� E�yi�ee� : BUREAU OF VALUATIONS , , ;, 286 City HeU ` Saint Paul, Minnesote 55102 � ..-'�� June 22, 1970 . Mr. Walter Hurtley Local Improvement Engineer De�artment of Public Works ' BU�,DING Dear Mr. . Hurtley: Set fo.rth herein is information pex�T:inen:� to th� propert,y assessment for the proposed public i:mx�rovemen� descr.��_�ed as; G-�-951 Cxrade and Surface alle;y� in Blk. 3, Wild Rose Acldi��ion, inc�_ud..in�; Sto.rm Sewer The total es�imated a,mount recove�°a:ble ��y assessment is $6,407.00 . based on +,he _f.ollo�,rin�;; Esi�,imated cost �er P.W. re�ort �6,183.00 Va1.. & �lssess. Services 1��+.00 T�Sisc. costs ior �nu.blica�cion costs 100.00 Estimated Total EX�BIIC�I.LU1^P.; �;a07.00 � . Estimai,ed rate ;ae't assessable .r.''oot �6.16 Based on tcze al�a�re, i-,h.e nea.r. in� �n the antr:�sability has been tentatively j schedulecl :f'or i,he 1_�� er ;�ar. t �i July, 19`7��, Very trul,y y��:.rs, � ; �� ,� �= �j� � < ?'�� .::.. _� �. . 1 ROyt��. Br Pca ah'1, �TY'. " � A_ss'�1;. V�,.:L.�a.�,ti.on E.t��-ir�:�er '� � i ; RE�3'jg Fi.1.e No. �`�;�00 � � cc; R. Wneel.er _/ � � P. :f��Asc��i t�!" . ; i , ; i � � � � � • � . ��};�; 1 E B E R Y E� - _ n !� � m � ��= o � � • li � � � o � � . � � � � � 0 y Y � VAN OY.1'� ' r , VJ , ; ` . , 7 .L � . � i \ � VJ '� � � HAZE L v�. "' ' • �► t� . , � � � � r� r rn � � ' o �0 ! c N � ; N � � • ' � `� � -� '� -� k � ur N v E. - � . . • . , . � �' � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PAUL � MINNESOTA I 13 Court Hou:e,5b1o2 ROSALIE L. BUTLER, Commissioner Phons:223-4646 July 23, 1970 To the Council City of Saint Paul Gentlemen: I have examined the attached petition of remonstrance, filed in the . matter of grading and surfacing with bituminous material the E-W alley from the Easterly N-S alley to the Westerly N-S a11ey. and the Westerly N-S a11ey from the E-W alley to Fremont Ave. in Blk. 3, WILD ROSE ADD: also construct a storm sewer in the Westerly N-S alley from the E-W alley to Third St. in the aforementioned Blk. 3. (G-1951), and wish to report as follows: Amount of frontage involved in said improvement - 1,364.70 ft. .Amount signed for on said petition - 982.98 ft. or 72� (Amount required by Charter - 50%) Number of residence owners involved - 29 Number who signed on said petition -23 or 79.3% (Amount required by Charter - 60%) From the above facts you will note that the petition of remonstrance is sufficient. Yours very truly, ��d��+'u-�Gt�� salie L. Butler Commissio�yr��:/"`i�`� e � �� File: 17500 HEARING: July 2$, 1970 cc: Joe Haider Bill Donovan Walter Hurtley Rosalie L. Butler File O � � t ^ • � � � , � AFFIDAVIT OF CI&CULATOR OF PSIZTIOTt STATE OF MINNESOTA ) } SS COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) Marjorie N. Northup , being first duly sworn, deposes and says on oath that she is a resident of the City of Saint Paul, Countq of Ramsey, State of Minnesota; that ahe circulated the attached Petition; that the signatures thereoa are genuine; aad that each signer k�w the contents thereof at the time of the signing of the same. . . Subscribed and sworn to before me this l��ay of _� . 1970. ��vei � � c� �"� c =� r" �� -°m -n c� A r= r�' +-' mv �N � . �o --v ---n �-„ -a- � 4' � �� m c� � , .��.�... � �� . . � PETITION OF REMONSTRANCE . , , � • SAINT PAUL, 1rIINNBSOTA ��,_�c�c��_, 1970. TO T� AONORABLE, THE COUNCIL, CITY OF ST. PAUL, MINNBSOTA Gentlemen: �ie, the undersigned property o�ners bq sEfixing our signatures hereto . certify to your Aonorable Body that we are opposed to having the following improvements made: •. Grade and surface with bituminous material the East-�Test alley from the Easterly North-South alley to the We�terly North-South alley, and the Weaterly North-South alley from the East-West alley to Frem�nt Aveaue in Block 3, GIILD ROSE ADDITION; also, construct a storm sewer . in the Flesterly North-Sonth alley from the Bast-West alley to Third ' . Street in the aforementioned Block 3; also, coudemn and take an ease- ment ia the land necessary �or the slopes, cuts and fills, includiag �„ right of removal of la�eral support from subj�ct la� or remsic�der � � thereof, occasioned by excavation thereof or construction of slope N�, � in conaection with said grading. -+c� -n � � � o _ � � ' �° � y'T .v � • � � . Nq� , LEGAL UESCRIPTION �' S� 9� sq � � � ✓ � /9/.7/ . - ..r �x�L� , � GZ�� G c��a%�G��'✓ � � • �j � �. � O , � (.1/ • �� , ' J , ✓ - /� '� �� — �� . . �� v v . . i .SQ � � - � � � c.J. . , �/ C�� C� d� .� 3 � � ��l� 3 �'� / r l 9� � �, , . � Page 1 AFFIDAVIT OF CIRCULATOR OF PETITION STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) SS COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) Marjorie N. Northup, being first duly sworn, deposes and says on oath that she is a resident of the City of Saint Paul, County of Ramsey, State of Minnesota; that she circulated the attached Petition; that the signatures thereon are genuine; and that each signer knew the contents thereof at the time of the signing of the same. � '/• �"t-�c Subscribed and sworn to before me this ��ay of � , 1970. y �� i'��G� t ( � � ' - ` . " � PETITION OF REMQNSTRANCE . , . ` NA�1E LEGAL DESCRII'TTON !�, � - .f" eu�f a' � �f 6 /00 �3 �, � C 3 / l �, �� l , f V r O �� aa d `�o� / ,��v�� .,�.��-� �� . M �� .5�� . � � r J G' � � r � , v � � O . • . . / J V ^ ... ✓ , � -� �° � � , ' s�- • � � �� o �- . �� o , � . � - 3 � i ' , �, � �o . � �r,� ' " ' / 9a,5� .�t , , , . � Page 2 � � � ;�, AFFIDAVIT OF CIRCULATOR OF PETITION STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) SS COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) Marjorie N. Northup, being first duly sworn, deposes and says on oath that she is a resident of the City of Saint Paul, County of Ramsey, State of Minnesota; that she circulated the attached Petition; that the signatures thereon are genuine; and that each signer knew the contents thereof at the time of the signing of the same. � � U Subscribed and sworn to before me � this l 7 �day of t � �,- , 1970. � � '� � �G' L. � � �- ' • PETITION OF REMONSTRANCE . i � NAA9E LEGAL D�SCftIPTION � � , � , � . �� P � Page 3 . �s � � � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I 13 Court House,65102 ROSALIE L. BUTLER, Commissioner Phone:223-�4646 July 22, 1970 Mr. Harry Marshall City Clerk BUILDING File 175U0, Page 1 Alley in Blk. 3, Wild Rose Add. HEARING DATE: July 28, 1970 Dear Sir: Forwarded here�ith is a letter, with reference to the above pro�ect, for consideration by the City Council. Sincerely, �°��,��`' Rosalie L. Butler Commission f inance ��J"�'Q'��'�/�� cc: Com'r Sprafka 17500 �O �r s �'� 8�t� �'#.+r �`r �# ��'�' �'� �$'�# �cTl�qA �� File 17500, Pa�e 1 � Mra. Hntler: t�d � 8th;, 1�'�? �re� at` 1�1��uq �t ��t a� '��?j� � �► �rd.'��ld '�r 1p�d a�t #i�.+e�r ie �C � �d_�It J�r.il.�� ee �tt �#r�l►.�lt #O � �'s�ll� �d t� QO��+ '�! � � A�9�i�.� �' �i� ��r O�t p1tl�1 +�t �� ll�!' �N �,tii��t � +� � �� '�'� !� � '�At ��.�r aa� +o� � +�+�r,� '.�� poa�sA�1+w� Ia�r�� i� a� � _ ._ _. . .,�.�w� �,�MMIM�r��+� � �t d� �1 �+t�l ,p�► a�rit� � � � � ��: �� #�� . ��i' ,�►�,+�w► � � � �► � �# � �t �►t�'� �e � : �� ,�� +r a`��+ra��s i�a ttu� � �r +� ;ar�a�� s�. �: 1� �r +�+qr�r i� t� d+a�ar+p�r 1� �nr�!da� o� � l�ww�� s�t # � : � ` ''�'�� r � � o�`;,t� �� , = t� 1a�d'��►M y+�` "�611 �s �'#►��#+� Mf � �rtt� . ,; . � t ��►+iraa�,�r # �id� !��¢ � � �� J� �'�`� �Mrr�r 1�O�.r� ��ia�' : H.s�r�tat�► Ct,� �,+�?�pt �r � �.� 1940 Fremont Avenue St« Paul, Minnesota July 31, 1970 Honorable Mayor and Council Members: I am the initiator of and eventually the sole proponent oP an alley in that portion of Block 3 oP Wild Rose Addition which lies between Hazel Street on the West and the extension of Luella Street on the East. On Tuesday, July 28, 1970, I appeared before the Council in behalf of the petition and exhibited pictures showing the condi- tion of the alley, which condition was deplorable, to say the least. There were a number oP opponents of the alley present whose main argument seemed to be that the alley was unnecessary� even though there are four garages opening onto the alley, and despite t he fact that the alley in its present unimproved condition fa a quagmire in the spring and a pesthole. in the summer. In addition to this I am constantly Pighting a losing battle in trying to 3ceep my � garage clean as mud, sand and gravel are con�inu�lly'.�being':brought into the garage on the tires of my automobile. A question was asked by one of the members of the Council as to whether a partial alley would be acceptable, and, in an attempt to mitigate some of the hostility that has come into being because . I had dared to asK for a long overdue impr�vement, I agreed to a partial alley with a turnaround. I find now that one of the possibilities being considered for the turnaround would take a 4uu square 1'oot section rigat out of the middle of the rear 20 feet of my back yard, ruining the one comfortable, shady spot in the back yard. . I would respectfully reque�t you to consider wnetner a turn- around is really necessary. I do not need �uch a turnaround my- self as it is my austom to drive into the alley past my garage and then .to back into the garage so that it is a simple matter to drive out of the alley wnen I want to leave. Mr. Paul, the neighbor across the alley from me, has his own built-in turnaruund already there . We, Mr. Paul and I, have the last two garages opening on the alley at the westerly end of the alley. Since there alrsady is a sign near t he entrance to the alley indicating that it is a dead•end slley, and, since I am informed that there will be some sort of a barricade at the end of the p aved portion of the alley, it would appear the only use for. a turnar�und would be for the occasional rubbish hauler or garbage truck. I seriou�- ly doubt wnether, because of the situation that exi�ts there in the alley, con�isting of an ab�rupt and steep banx acros� from s . portion of thc� propose,d turnaruund, they would even u�o t�,o turn- �round, but would probably continue to back out oP the alley as - they have done for some 17 or more years. Also, since the city does not plow the allays the turnaround itself would not be plowed and wou3d probably not be usable from sometime in November until April. ' � � , ,,, „�.,,,.� . . . ., .. -2- I would respectfully request that you make a personal visit to this site, view my property and the a11ey itself, and determine • if it would be possible to conatruct the alley witho ut requiring a turnaround on my property. Any consideration you may givelthis request will be deeply appreciated. I will be out oP town on a short vacation on Monday and Tuesday oi' next week but I will willingly meet xith any of the Council porsonaZly concerning this matter aftsr that time ii' you deem it advisable. . RespectPully yours, John L. McKenzie � Bus. phone - 223•1�609 , ' Res. phone - 735-3596 . , ' � 1940 Fremont Avenue - St. Paul, Minnesota 55119 July 31. 1970 Dear A1� I am enclosing a copy of the letter I today delivered to the Mayor and the council a�embers. Because there is a possibility that this letter might be mis- construed � want to offer a word of explanation. I do not mean to imply in u� letter #.l�iat if the turnaround has to be on �r property that I do not want the a11ey. flri the contrary, because I ha.ve put the Ma,,yor and t,he council on the spot in this matter, if there is no alternative then I will accept the turnaround on n�r property. However, I would want this only if there is no other feasible alternative. Personally I do not feel that a turnaround is necessary as I have explained in n�y letter, especially in view of the fact that the rubbish hauler and the garbage trucks now back into the alley as far as they �o. I am dropp�ng this note to you as I am leaving the city for four days for a short vacation and � have not got time to explain n� views by letter to all ' of the council. Walt Hurtley may hane gotten the wrong impression from n�y letter and I do not want the l�ayor and council to get the wrong impression. If this raatter �omes before the Council before I return to work on Wednesday and if they have gotten the wrong impression then I would like � views to be communicated to them. Very truly yours, 7 � ohn McKenzie s . � . � v��, �.�.-v�, � �- � —� �+9 9�� , . . �� ,�' May 5, 1970 � iViAYOR �F ST. PAUL and � � �� `M E � MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL �M Q}� ?19�Q Gent lemen: �RATIpN �OUNSEL.� `\It is our understanding a petition has be�n filed for the grading of an al�ey betwe�n East 3rd Stre�t and Fremont Street from Luella Street. `A city surveyor �.nd two assistants surveyed the propos�d a1Zey propc�rty April 30. At that time Lhe surveyor zndicated in a conversation that an a11ey was not too practical because of drainage, etc. We can understand th� petitioners problem on the Luella Street end, hawever, we feel more complex problems would result should an alley . be constructed. Therefore, we are listing our reasons against the proposed alley: � � , (1), Sir.c� the natural water shed is west-siauthwest, a drainage problem would result for the property owners in the center-south of the proposed alley. (2) We a11 are awar� of the increase in bxeak-ins, robberies, molestings, etc. , being commi�ed , today. It has been proven an alley is conducive to -�hese crimes and new developments are designed to eliminate alleys. Therefore for these reasons we are not in favor of an alley. (3) A considerable amount of money has been spent in upgrading and beautifying the area with trees, shrubs and, in our case, a terraced rock garden containing about 45 tons of stone with a retaining wall dropping appraximately 8 to 9 feet on the proposed alley side, toppea with a f�nc�. We feel our investment would be jeopardized by the construction of an alley. � , (4) We, who live on 3rd Street alsa wi21 be assessed for the new , bituminous street, construction of which we understand will begin as soon as Ruth Street is complet�d. (5) There is always the cost factor to consider -- both to the city and propert�r. owner. At a considerable savings, we feel the open-end at Luella Street could be upgraded without' installing a compl.ete, through alley as was surveyed. (6) We, as well as others, have no need for an alley since we have ' street-side access to garages. ' We opposing the proposed a11ey are in the process, ot preparing a petition against an alley between 3rd and Fremont Streets. We hope you will consider the above items before 'a decision is made. a' � � Sincerely, . ,. � G� ' �� , Mr. & Mrs. Jack D. Northup 1925 E. 3rd Street � St. Paul, Minnesota 55119 mn � ' �, i� ' � ' , .. , , �. � �, ... � y. ' � , • � �'y '..r � . �'' e iuA �. . . 1'lay 5, .1970 . . �IAY ; 1�7� ' MAYOR OF ST. PAUL and : MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL MAY�#�'�, .'°;r�'�^� Gentlemen: It is our understanding a petition has be�n filed for the grading of an alley between East 3rd 5treet and Fremont Street from Luella Street. A city surveyor and two assistants survey�d the proposed alley property April 30 . At that time the surveyor indicated in a conversation that an alley was not too practical because of drainag�, etc. We can undcrstand the petitioners problem on the Luella Street end, however, we feel more complex problems would result should an alley , be cons�ructed. Therefore, we are listing our reasons against the proposed alley: . : , (1), Since the natural water shed is west-sAUthwest, a drainage problem would result for the property owners in the center-south of the proposed a11ey. (2) We all are awaxe of the increase in break-ins, robberies, molestings, etc. , being committed today. It has been proven an alley is conducive -to these crimes and new developments are designed to eliminate alleys. Thexefore for these reasons we are not in favor of an alley. , (3) A considerable amount of money has been spent in upgrading and beautifying the area with trees, shrubs and, in our case, a terraced rock garden containing about 45 tons of stone with a retaining wall dropping approximately 8 to 9 feet on the proposed alley side, topped with a fence. We feel our investment would be jeopardized by the construction of an alley. � (4) We, wlzo live on 3rd Street also will be assessed for the new bituminous street, construction of which we understand will begin as soon as Ruth Street is complet�d. (5) There is always the cost factar ta consider -- both to the city and propert�r. owner. At a considerable savings, we feel the opEn-end at Luella Street could be upgraded without installing a complete, , through alley as was surveyed. (6) We, as well as others, have no need for an alley since we have _ street-side access to garages. � We opposing the proposed a11ey are in the process, of preparing a petition against an alley between 3rd and Fremont Streets. We hope you wiZl consider the above items before 'a decision is made. � , Sincerely, J ' _ °� /� ��. � /i�ita. , d�� U . Mr. & Mrs. Jack D. Northup 1925 E. 3rd Street � St. Paul, Minnesota 551I9 mn � . . . ` � j ' j ,�-- 'p"'" F;� :� ! s � ' � 1 ��. � .. _ . ��. a,,';',,',t �=� �,��": Ma�y 14, 1970 ��:�t°'�s''��:; :,��.°"`��"� Honora►ble t�Iayor Hyrne and Me�bers of the City Cour�cil s A petition has been filed to eurface an �l.ley With bituednou� �eateria�7. from Luelle� Street to withia 155 feet of Hasel Btreet with a tee to F�emont and Third Streete. Ye are oppoaed to this resurfaaing and grading for the folloKiag reasonsz 1. The na�tvral draiiaage in this area flotire to the aouthv+eet toward Tlsird Street aad Hazel 8treet. IIaleea atot^e� eer+ere are installed in tl�is proposed alle�, the wa�er flow ia this area cot�ld cause conaiderable damage to our property aad a�djaaeat properties to the west of our property. 2. The cost of �ch a pro�ect r+ith ator� aev►era w�uld cauee hardship on the proparty ormere espe�.ally vdth the Third Street paving asses�eat beiag levied. 3. The eaoa re�oval cr�ateB a problee� for a�l.l. +siuce are do not have aity snow re�oval in alleya. 4. Bia�� oaly a tew homeo�ers aea�r the entrasae of thie propoesed ai].ley a�t Luella 8treet ha�ve need oi this propo�aed alley, we veu3.d request that a tus�a-arovad b� eatablished in this area to alleriate the problems oi our aeighbor8 or surface thia approxi�ate 200 feet aad lea�ve the ba7.amee oY the terrain ia itB ndtural etate. We would appreaiate �our giving this s�atter your ivll�et coasidei-ation aad if tha tia�e permits, taka a look at thie Arsa before �ag your final deci+si.on. Youra traly, � � �,�- ��,. � arasat .K1�tt � � �►elya 8. ICl.ett 1931 �ast Thtrd 13t et �/� 2QOTE: City h�giaeer, Mr Davis, looked orer the e�rea for the proposed alley aiad ie aware of the problea� as atated a�bove. � � , �r 15, 19`rU Hon. Robert F. Feter�an, Cam�r. of P'atbli� Wo�ck�. Attn: . W�1. Hurtley De+sr $i.i�: The City Council x�t"e u tha 4ttsehed copy 03' a lettex ot' Ernest L. t�nd E't*e1y ett in opposi�ion ta tht r�aurfacin,g and g�q � �rom Lue�,� to x55' oi Hssel betw�en l�r s�a Z 8tr . r3► tx'tily Yozu'�, City Cler�. hp � F2(CHARD A. SCHNARR C I T Y O F S A I N � P A U L ANTHONY J. CREA CHIEF ENGINEER DEPUTY COMMISSIONER Capital of Minnesota DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS 234 City Hell & Court House 55102 ROBEBT F. PETERSON Commissione� O �+�`� ��. �3�� `1ano�-.��>'g .l�n�+P.�c .�. k;�ic,! i�� Garrr,n B s�i<rn��r of ��i��r�c� ..� �'I 'u .., :ti�Jr�� ,"�'xa9.�a ��:: !�—I�i�] t':';�t" ,.i � ; ; �wr��ss�;r;ti � i,��r�:ad1:�a �ar:�; on�in�ry e�tirccat� .�f �c�� t``�ar �r,�dina and a�'?"�:i��,fi9�:� d,•pt;! �"ex.l�f'+>i'��:�tf� r.t4�tF.',ric�# t�lC': ��°•��F�+�S$ c`6� �4M�' �'1'Glf?1 l.ilC I�c'3$t�fty , 'S;°�:�+.�'°si3Pl��t "7� tN'"' r:3 ��"Sf'°. i°t,''��!`".E"1�' �!C'di"+�4'y...k.�}i��"i ;'� �,"�,�I� a�rReC.� �1tt: �;4'•$LPi'IV � t»ryr�a� :;{:�x.a�.�� ;i �ti�e:� ;�-:�rr+ �.t��: c".a�r«iJ��, �D �¢:y C� t"r°�:!�xara� i�.venue i n f3l.K. 3� ,�'i �,i:� � ',,�'" s x=P a�3�'i��'�; �i�ca c�ri<�t r•u�t �-s st�arm s�e��:r= p� t�$�� d��t��:rt y �orth— :sc�t��`�: �_ °:�:. :'rc,a-, re,..� !"�4r_—�J�st �llf�y ��r� �"�-dirc� ;�r�et �n ��^k; �toreu�enttoned �d.di. `g "a's1P..it?i" . ?� i!'i:fi:F�'± %1C'(jl3J" 4�°O. s.`tta�:?�'3a a��9}?�"C�4r"�L d:,:,��` .:i..i' 6t}JtJ. �:.:�i��i`;�'.�.�S:Q �.:.�C/';i�f'€.tt�$:1 CtPl {.C7S t YJ s�f.�i�•�� i:r�:�dr��:�rin<? F;?�.�t� 3n�;r�c�tion ��?�,r�n Tot�l i:stimated Ca�t 5�,��.t�t3 '?c�urs u�ry t�c;lY. Robert F. Pet�r��n � ' / Ccw�miss i�nsr c,f F'�ab1 f c Worka `� �t�P/l�H:�a� � r��t+�9��t�!!',"11'�5 `;:!'��: . � 1�� ..,. .,:�,•t:, c�: Rich�rd �chnarr . Kan �d�.wvctamb � �. Jn�eph P�!tchel 1 , 's . ,,.� ... �� 3;r ..:� �x 1 ��:�i May 8, 1q70. Hon. Robert �'. Pe�erapn, Camsr. of P4tblic Wc�rkks. graulfng betve�n E. 3rd. Deax Sir: tre+�t Fr�nont 8t. f'ra� LnelZa. St. The encicaed capy o lett F Mr. e�nd Mr�. Jeck D. P�orth�p, 192� E. 3rd. 3t., is y�au f'o�r your info�►tion. The original. haa been pu 31�e tr�e otf`ice cf the City Clerk to be me�de a part a�' no on at the date af pztb�ie hearing; $aid public aring et b��n scheduled. t�,Y Yaur�, City Clerk M'S/hp City of Saint Paul EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT OFFICE OF THE MAYOR 347 CITY HALL AND COURT HOUSE ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 I°iay fl , I 9 7 0 �i��. �nci :°!rs . �Tac1� I:�. �dc�rth�^tz� 1� 25 E. 3rd Str�et Saii�t P�ul, P�,izinesota 55119 De ar N`r. and Mrs. iJorthrup: I hav� receiv�d a r.opy �af your lett�r of i�iay 5 and 11ave s�iit it �c t,lc� City Cler�: so it may 4�e not�:c� �.n t;i� r.i�r�ut�s oi �:��c: ne�t mc�etin�. !`a�;� �f t�:is fi�.r.c , I am un��c�aar�: o� ar;° proc;rar: to accorn;�li�i1 t;:e w�orh� you m�:i7tiori. Ii �� rz�inec�ri.nf; wor}; i� ��oinri; on r.o��, i� would be ;acfo�� ;�c Council some caee:�s in tn�� futur�. D Y�aur 1.�tt��r will be ,�rou�ht to t,��e attr_ntion of t}t�� C�uncil members at th�.t time . Sancerely, THOP�AS R. i3YF.N� TRB:lmp � ec: City Clerk 5fi 1925 E. 3ra St. . . � - -�, ____.._._.___.,_.�. �.�. . , St. Paul, Minn. 55ii9 `�` - ;;� ' �� 1+��•``�' '�� -� : , � � � �� ,-;�� ..��_� . ; � . '� + � .... r , t �i i � y�? j _ .� �,,Y �� ; d�� ; 3�� — ' ,.� ,�� .. � �" KLIK Q.R06EiYElL♦ City Attorney's Office City Hall - W. Kellogg Blvd. & Wa�asha St. St. Paul, Minn. 55102 t^..„� ^ � ti � \ \ ` `,`ti'\ � ��1e ~� � � ' � � � `� N i0 — Y = �` ��"`� Q � .� � �� Q M ' ��+�. ��- _ �� ^� • - f c.-'^�..,,� � � . O ..""� � � �J �� V �� O _ � Q� �Z ��ey.. ♦ � y _ 0 � • � � . --�� .��. _._--- - John L. McKen$ie . .v. _�... . �,�. �; 1940 Fremont Avenue `,��`,,��. � � N� �s st. Paul. Minnesota 55119 � P t� ? „�� - i _ � �A • � � � , ? � � _��_ �,2;auc �,m ,� � � : �s�o DIS�:�J.V�R ANl.., . - ► , ,.� , � ��.�.. Albert Olson - . Office of the City Clerk ' City Hall and Court House 15 W. Kellogg Boulerard . . St. Paul, Minriesota 55102 � (Thi� letter to the attention of) (Mr. Marsl�l]. if Mr. Olson is ) (away from the office ) _ _._ _-.�-..,. OFFICE OF THE MAYOR CITY OF SAINT PAUL � EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT 347 City Hall and Court House Building Saint Paul.Misnesota 55102 � , Mr. Harr.y Marshall City Clerk