246947 ��69��
ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK ' - � ��: t �. �
CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
, COUNCIL RESOLUTION-GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY �/
COMMISSIONE � ` DATF
`J
RESOLVED, �Tpon the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning
Code, by Aaron-Hodroff and So�s I�uneral �hapels, a� owner
of the sub�ec� real es�ate, situate in the City of S�in�
Paul, zon�d in Com�ereial Dis�rict, under the �oning �ode,
and described as Lot 7, 1�a�AFthur Addition, and located on
the southeast corner of Seheffer and South Snelling Av�nues,
�
that the provi�ion� of said Zonin� �ode hereby are dt�termined
�
� and varied as and �o t�ie extent neeessary therefor, and the
❑ � setback requir��nent� from Scheffer Avenue are Y�ereby waiv�d .
�1 �
� g�
< �
� _ ""�.°�,� �
� ta ttereb vea �tat a v��bi�lyc.
� � � ����� �! f�ti
boat � ,the e�� ' ��
� . }'w .,:Q. t$t�l1`
s�G. i�`aui
�'��; �1�8 C4da�. tor re-
�O = � . `b�si��tt of a�
•� . ,�� �QttL sI.6!� "#.�S$C-.
�T O�'. , � � ��.
�� •���.���. ...
/ ��� ��)
�j� 13 1�10
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Nays �� � � �,�Q
Carlson
Dalglish � Approved 19—
Meredith Tn Favor
Peterson
Sprafku �/ Mayor
A gainst
,�_
Mr. President, Byrne
PUBtISHED JAN 171970 �
� N �
' r
` • �OARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 ����� �4�f
.r� ,�,,
December 29, 1969
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
City Clerk
Room 386 City Hall
Dear Mr. Marshall:
This is written in response to the appeal of Aaron-Hodroff and
Sons Funeral Chapels to waive the setback requirements from Scheffer
Avenue on property located on the southeast corner of Scheffer and
South Snelling Avenues. This property is further described as:
Lot 7, MacArthur Addition
The Board of Zoning heard this matter at 'rts meeting on
December 4, 1969. The staff reported that the requir.ed setback
from Scheffer Avenue was two feet and the requested variance was
100 percent. The appellant indicates that to obtain maximum parking
on the narrow lot it is necessary to use the setback area. The
application for a parking lot includes the buffer area, a condition
of the rezoning of this property, and wheelstops to prevent encroachment
onto the public sidewalk.
Subsequently, the Board of Zoning moved to recoimnend approval
of the appeal. The motion carried by a vote of 5-0.
Very tru y yours,
� ��
��>� , /1 c
r �/ `;;✓ / �/�/���_
,�=',,f,,
ti�
��TER J. IETTA
Secretary, Board of Zoning
PJM:gaf
AT B
Z.F. �k6822
�� �,.-.��
�.�`r,�. �_.a�'
(.� �
� ��
8�
--� ,� . , � .
.
. �
..�
b
� �
.� �
Saint Paul, Minnesota
671 So. Snelling Ave.
July 11, 1969
To the Honorable, the City Council
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Gentlemen:
We hereby request permission to relax the 2-foot setback on
Scheffer Ave. in connection with the establishment of a parking
lot for the Aaron-Hodroff and Sons Funeral Home on Lot 7,
MacArthur Addition, described as 658 So. Snelling Ave., at the
___�e�th�a�t corner of So. Snelling and Scheffer Aves. The present
>� use of the property is rental, which building will be razed.
The purpose of the appeal is to facilitate ingress and egress
of parking vehicles. This appeal is made under Chap. 64.03�
Par. i.
ry truly yours,
�,��XX.���C��oc�-o , P�= s
�
Aaxon-HodrofP and Sons Funeral Chapels, Inc.
698-8311
� � `� ��� k �� '� �J
.�U� � ► �����
CITY PLA�NIi�� ���,��
Saint �auf, MiH(1@�F
ZONIIVG �� 6�
LE _..�
� . -
�D�ARD QF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION December 4, 1969 ?'1st Nap_��_
���
. Actinq under Le�islativ� �ode Chapt�r 60 thru 64
nassgd Au�;ust 22� 1922 as am�ndmd to April 6� 1�6H 6g22
� 1. Ar:�L1CAtt�(''S NA"!� s Aareia-�rotf aad �s �wier�l t�epela, Inc. 6821
2. CI,hSSIPZCATION � u Aw�ndurqt tJ AAP� ❑�e�i! X-a15
p U Oth�r
3� n��p�g� = Rel�x setback rt�ris�nt� i� connection vith
the eatabliaA�est of a park;ag lot
4. L�CATION s Sautheaat core�r of Seutti Satllia; aitd Scheffer Avenuas
5. GEGAL DESCRS�TION s Lot T� Il�cArthqr �i��
6. P:t�SCNT ?ANIMCt Co�escis2
7� PURSUANT 'ib Zoning Cod� Chapt�s b2 S�eslien� .01 ParsRrtph�
8. �TAFP INVESTIGATIOM t REPOATt D�tt�� ll/2�/69
�� ATD
A. ZO[IING ADMINIS?RATOR: llo action.
B. HISTpRY_; Ths froat�ge �Zo�` SoutM sr�sili� �tue�ua to � dopth of 100 feet wao
zoned Ccasrcial. The swiadts o! tlr I,ot Ns r�aos�A to Co�rcial oa 10/25/69.
C. PROPOSED USE: 9ev�lop t!u pcopert� �� + Ntkia� lot for • fnnerNl chspel located
acroee South �nelling Ar�aw.
D. NEED FOR APl'lSAt,; To obtiin �1� Nrki� w• oa th� n�r=pr lot, !t ia n�cesaary
to requea t permta�iou to ��t t1►� MtbKk �=u�
8. P1tESENT STANQARg; The pre��t rtqdtrd r�misN � �rkiag lot •�tback of twa feet
froto Scheff�r wvenu�.
F. VARIANCg; Th� requasted variihte� i• ippx; �id •liwinata th• required �etback.
C. AREA ZONING: The fronta�e �iay S�uth StNlllw� wv��w i• so�aed Co�rcial; the
rest of the area ia zoned "AN Rs�idewe�.
H. SI1E CONDITIONB: � old •in�le-f�ly s��i8asc� i• located to�r�rd the rear of
the leve2 site.
I• ARE�A CONDITIONS: Ad�oiaiy t� t1N �ortM i� a
family resid�cN; �+e�= Co�i�� y���� ��i ���� �O;th aad eaet •i�le-
Council Letter �
9� 30ARD ACTION; To Recomm�nd L ^�Approval �Denial Dated
12/29/69
Moved by; Maietta Ysas Nays Date of Nearin�
X Ames
Seconded bys Cohen x Cohen 12/30/69
Danna (Alt) Council Action
X C',atdlar
X Gauger
Secretary' s r�markss x Mai�tta I�ate
McPartlin (Alt)
Mansur (Alt)
LEGAL I�TICES ON THE BACK 'OF THIS SHEET
. F � � ► _ � �
. � �e �j-, � I 1 r�� � . A .� _'_ . � ,
;. , � � .
; � � �
; . ; ; � ; �..._:___- -:� ," t..� _
,lo;���. � G �410 Q�G'o a�o o� . : . �- ____, , ,
� � � ,�. � _ .
. �. , :�� � o � � �,,. �
, ,
. ' xlq��Fo�O qVe. � � ; ' • o '
��O O O; O � j � I�T' � ,� • �
� I , , O�O O O G O�O�O .O� � ' ` ...�;.� ,O -¢.� _ _Q ,
'_ . �_�__ _ � .1.__ L � I � � �` � � � . __ __ D_ -
� 1---�- -- -r- � .L _ .1 ._�_ � �� '�_, � � .- - -
; 7-- j -r-�(-;�,-= J � � --�
; , --r ;� �.
� ,, � i � � � � ( j ( � -� + �r•) � '���T �-- � .
c, o;o: o ;c- �,;c:�c�;o�o!o�� p�� ` � � � � ___.._ r�_ �
-.-�. Q
� � � — _,C� Q �F 1 __D' L^ .
� R qV�, '
�A A o , . '� 13 -- -a � � �.._ .°- I, -
O (,�.C�'C.? C�iO;G�C+C'�O C�GIQ��i r __ } �-� _ � ,4l t--� �'
� I j � ' � �, �� -v ��� � -�-� � o Q
s-- _ .� 1� �i �_. 1.� �.., ; . .
1 �! -,T- , ,- --�- �_� - ..:� ��. �
_ � -T , ..�..,.r,
:
oi<�,o;� �o��,00�o�o�U�000' - � � o � �� �:� �� � � -
�j , , , �., -�i-
. -�- r o -� b� o �
�
` W SC HEFFC Q qy�� �
„ �,,t h .
, ��'o,
� �� v � �i 0; �� �__ Q C`, p; 'j � � Q ,v', Q �? � 'E
i � � ( � �,: �O ' : , �,
� v � � _� G ! � "I . � ' I ,
� �'�- 4 `, ; v o s / -4`' ' �_'-'-' ; _.: :.. �, , �
�', �. ' � � ^-' --- � � � 1 i � � � �+-' r��
. ."�_: �`� \ ' O- � , , ..� . � � ' � � , ��� �� - -
�t � � �
�� ; o �-- � �� � � .� ,, � ; ���c�: �� �� � a � ;c
, {
�� , n � __� ..� _ � ELL 4NOQ, .
`t ' 1� C' � t-� � -' (�� � , �f ,; � �J i�) �.
Q.. � � �, � J �� r , � � w I i ' i !,
y ,
�� � 1 . � � . . , � .f � ,y� �' � i
�... O ♦ .+�.__ 1 '1� �� , l
, ;� r ;.
�, ; . , . . � . ,
, , , , ,� , , ___ � l, , ,
• � � ��' r_) � l„i I�') � Q� � � �� � �� � � ,���i ;
• �
� OIU C
� � � --
. -- -- -- --� F _.___ r� - __--_.---=--_- -- -�#��� �:A�t=.D: -- -.
APPLICANT Aaron-Hodroff and SonS LEGEND
Funeral Chapels, Inc.
PURPOSE Relax setback requirements in LAND UJE
connection with the establishment
PRESENT ZONING of a parking �ot O ONE-FAMILY
�o�ercial -0- TWO-FAMILY
PETITION SIGNERS p� THREE-FAMfLY
FOUR-FAf�ILY
T MULTI-FAMILY
FILE No. 6822 NoRrH � ' • nCOMMERCiAL
� � INDUSTRIAL
u VACANT
St. Paul Planning Board, Date: 11/25/69 �� Proper?y under consideration
�
MINUTES OF THE �'UBLIC HEARING BBFORB 1'HE BQARD OF ZONING
on Thursday, December 4, 1969, at 2:00 PoMo
PRESENT: Messrs. Ames, Cohen, Gsdler, Gauger, and Maietta of the Board and
Messrso Brown and Sorensan and Mrs. Frantzen of the staff.
AARON-HOAROFF AI�ID SONS FITrtERAI� CHAPELS: An eppea 1 to wa ive the setback requirement
from Scheffer Avenue ire eonnection with the es�ablisim�ent of a parking lot on
property located on the aouth�ast corner of Soutiz Snellin� and Scheffer Avenuea.
b;r. Sorensun su�rized the steff report statin.g that to obtain meximum parkfng
use on the nar�ow loL,� the appellant indicates that it is ne�essary to request
permission to use the setbaclt �rea. Ttbe present standard requires a parking lot
setback of two feet from Scheffer Avenue. Therefore, the requested variance is
100�oe An old single-family residence fs lacaCeai toward the rear of Che level
site. `The pa,ck3ng Iat application inclndes the bu£fer tha� was part of the
conditfon wizen the property �wa� rezoned to Commercfala There �a.�uld be wheelstops
to control encroactwene onto the sidewelka
Mr. Gau�ex said the rn�n caho owns the Johnaon Fur_zr.�� Ham� to the south was
unable to be ae th.e meeting sfnce his wife had juat snffered a hearti attack, but
w�as co�cerned nevertheZess �baut ��ie �pp�alo Mr. Gadler aslced if Mr, Johnson
had s2ea the plan4
Mro Leo Ao Aodrof€, x�gresenting ihe appeal, said hi� bro�her, Willism, w�ho hsd
filed the sppeal, h�d died three dsys earlier. He gaid Mr. Johnson had signed
the original petitian far rezaning Che prop�rty.
Mra Mafettr� moved for approvgl of th� appeal, which rasa seconded by Mr, Cohen,
and cerrfed unanimot�sly,
Submftted by: Colonel L� Sor�nson Robert La Nmes, Ct►airman
_It�_
, City Clerk � � r .
" CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
December 16, 1969
File X815, Page
You are hereby noCiffed that a public hearing will be held
in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and C�urt House
in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on Dece�ber 30, 1969,
on the application of Aaron-Hodroff and Sons Funeral Chapels,
Inc. to relax setback requirements in connection with es-
tablishment of a parking lot for visitors on Lot 7, '�MacArthur".
The property is located on the southeast corner of South
Snelling and Scheffer Avenues.
For further information contact the Planning Board, Room 1010
Commerce Building or telephone 223-4151.
JAMES J. DALGLISA
Coamnissioner of Finance
O