03-486Presented
Refesed To
Committee Date
1 RESOLVED, that the rate ofpay for the classification of Library Training and Organizational
2 Development Coordinator/Supervisor be established at the rate set forth in Grade 13 of Bazgaining Unit
3 09, Saint Paul Supervisors Organization, Salary Schedule, and be it
4 FINALLY RESOLVED, that this resolution shall take effect and be in farce on the first pay period
5 following its passage and approval.
Requested by Department of:
Hum Resources Office
r
� � �
By:
Form App�oved by Ci�Attomey
�
for
�
Approved by y rl Date _�
By: p�i�✓'✓L�q
Council Ftle # Q3 —yg`
Green Sheet # 200111
RESOLUTION ��
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
�
Work�I.�brery 'tmg & OD Caord
Adopted by Council: Date o
Adoprion Cerlified b� Council Secretary 1
�: , . . ,
�„ � _ � � . � ��
µ'µ DEPARTMENT/OFFICElCOUNCII,: DATE INITL4TED GREEN SHEET NO.: LOOI S 1 ' Q� � y�
Human Resowces . 5/2/03
"� CONTACT PERSON & YHONE: A7E IIa17'IaLDATe
John Shockley, 266-6482 , D�,�,,,� D� � , �,,. �o,��,
: . ASSIGNED 24]YAT[ORNEY �R`7/' CiTYCLFRK
, MUST BE ON COUNCII. AGENDA BY (DATE) NUMBER AOR
, ROUTING flrypxQp�SERVDIR fWANC1AI.SERV/ACCfG
. ORDER
. 3MAYOR(ORASSS.)
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES_1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
ncriox xeQuESrEn: Approval of the attached resolution to establish the rate of pay for the new classification titled
' Library Training and Organizarionat Development Coordinator/Supervisor in Grade 13 of B.U. 09, Saint
Paut Supervisors Organizarion, Salary Schedule. "
RECOMMIIJDATIONS: Approve (A) m Reject (R) PERSONAl. SERVICE CONTRACTS MUS? ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUFS710NS:
` ' I. HastLicpersonffmneverwodcedwderacontractfordrisdepamrent?
' PLANNAIG COMb1ISSlON Yes No
-� _CB COMMI7TEE 2. Ffas Utis petsoNfitm ever been a city employee?
., CNIL SERVICE COMMISSION Ya No
� 3. DoesthispersoNSrmpossessas}a7lnotnorsnallyposseuedbyanycimrntcityemployee?
Yu No
4. Is tltis persodfum a tatgekd vendor?
Yw No
— Esplain all yes answers on sepante Sj10Et `dII(1 'dtt`dGtl t0 gl'EEII S�ICQt
INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTiJNITY (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
This action is a result of a classification and compensation study at the request of the Library Director. The study
' was necessary to recognize the additional supervisory responsibilities assigned to the position as a result of the
reorganization of the Saint Paul Public Library. It was deternuned that the SPSO bargaining unit assignment is
appropriate because of the addition of fuil supervisory responsibilities.
nnv�vTncES �F nrrxovEn: Equitable compensation commensurate with the level of dufies and responsibilities of the
- � posifion will be estabiished.
DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED:
There will be an increase in salary, however, the costs aze allotted in the current Library's budget.
�, DISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: EC]ll1t8UlE COIlI]7811S8Y1011 W1II ROY UC CSx3UI1SIle(1.
��.� TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION: COST/REVENUE BUDGETED7 � .
: FLJiVDINGSOURCE: ;..____----- -- ACTIVITYNUMBER: ry� p��
� �
FINANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) � �y�h C�n#�s ��� � � ��
� �,AY 2 � 200� ��.� �!l`Y ,q�'�'�RNEY
'� G:VShared\ClassiflCLASS\Consultant-ShockleyUohn's Class Work�I,iMary Trng & OD Coord Supv Green Sheet.wpd
Og �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Randy Ke[ly, Mayor
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
LIIIa3 WIICOX
Library Public Services Manager
Library
Michele A. Stegall
Human Resources Specialist
Office of Hnman Resources
December 16, 2002
CLASSIFICATION STUDY RESULT
OFFICE OF HUMAN RESOURCES
Angie Nalelrsy Dirutor
400 City Nal! Anrse:
25 Wese Founh Street
Saini Paul, Minrsuota 55702-1631
Telephone: 657-16b6500
Joblirse: 657-266-6502
Farcimile: 657-292-7656
We have completed our study of the job class Library Training and Organizarion Development Coordinator,
Deborah Willms incumbent. We have reviewed relevant job information, interviewed the incumbent,
supervisoi, and compazed the posirion with xelated classes and positions. This study indicates that a new
posirion needs to be created titled Library Training and Organization Development Coordinator Supervisor in
St. Paul Supervisor Organization (SPSO) grade 13.
Should you choose to implement this acrion, you will need to iniriate a requisition and send it through the
required process.
Clu the incumbent is being paid $ 2,051.76 step nine (PEA), If you chose to implement this action the
incumbent will be paid $2,266.64 step thirteen (SPSO).
If you choose not to implement this, you can undertake offier measures to keep the position at its current level.
The process can be simple or involved depending upon the needs of a particulaz study. It may involve any one
or a combinarion of the following: restructuring the duries of the studied position to reassign higher-level
duties to other posirions, modifying elcisting processes and procedwes, or studying an entire unit iu structure,
functions, and operations - for the possibility of a reorganization.
If you have any questions or need assistance in tlus matter, please call me at 266-6490.
An Affuxnative Action Equal Opportunity ADA Employer
os -�Y�
COMPENSATION STUDY REPORT
CLASS STUDIED:
INCUMBENT:
Library Training and Organizational Devetopment
Coordinator
DATE STUDIED:
PERSONS CONTACTED:
STUDIED BY
Deborah Willms
december 12, 2602
Incumbent and Supervisor
Michele A. Stegail
APPROVAL OF CLASSIFICATION AND COMPENSATION MANAGER:
(Signature)
Backs�round
2-a Z
(Date)
The incumbent, with the approva� of the Library Director, submitted a revised job profile.
Our o�ce was asked by the Libraries to determine the appropriate compensation. The
position was first studied in 1999, since then the Libraries has undergone reorganization.
In the past, the position did not supervise. With the reorganization, the position has
changed and has been assigned the supervisory duties of the retired Office manager.
Studv Comaonents
1.Review ofjob profile
2.Interview with incumbent
3. Interview with supervisor
4.Comparisons
5.QES evaluation and analysis
8. Recommendation
Job Descriotion
The position directs and manages long and short term planning processes for the City
of St. Paul Public Library. Typical duties perFormed include:
➢ Directs and manages personnei functions and activities such as overseeing
scheduling of interviews, and monitoring sick leave usage.
➢ Directs long and short term planning processes such as strategic planning and
strategic initiative process.
➢ Directs staff training and devefopment functions.
➢ Directs and manages the Library budget process.
➢ Serves on the Director's Administrative Workgroup.
➢ Serves as the Library's liaison to the Perrie Jones Library Advisory Committee.
➢ Supervises one Secretary, one Account Clerk, two Payroll Clerks, and two Clerks 11.
a3 y��
Comaarisons
The position was compared to Librarian il, Librarian ili, Library Information Resources
Coordinator, Office Manager, Training and Organizational Development Specialist,
Senior Consultant-Business Consulting Services, and Library Training and
Organizational Development Coordinator job classes. The Librarian II, Library
Information Resources Coordinator, and Library Training and Organizational
Development Coordinator, are in Professional Employees Association (PEA) grades 14,
19 and 10 respectively. The Librarian III and Office Manager are in St. Paul Supervisor's
Organization (SPSO) grades 18 and 10. The Training and Organizational Development
Specialist, is in Classified Confidential Professional (CCP) grade 14 and the Senior
Consultant-Business Consulting Services is in Non-Representative grade 22.
Librarian II: Positions in this job class perform intermediate level professional librarian
work. Additionally, positions in this job class have typical supervisory duties including
supervising the daily operations of a branch library, a small division of the Central
Library, or acts as an assistant supervisor in on of the major divisions in the Central
Library or in an area library. Also, this position supervises, coordinates, and implements
the collection development and maintenance program for a particular library or library
department.
Librarian 111 Positions in this class perForm supervisory and full pertormance professionai
library work in planning, organizing, evaluating and directing the overall operation on an
assigned centra( department of area library, or system wide coilection development.
Librarv Information Resources Coordinator: Positions in this class perform highly
responsible planning and administrative work in directing the operation of the programs
and projects for planning, organizing and developing the information systems for the
Saint Paui Library system, ensuring these are comparable with other City Systems.
Office Manaaer: Positions in this class perform administrative and supervisory work
involving the planning, organization and direction of administrative and or/ clerical work.
Also these positions perform administrative and expert clerical work.
Traininp and Orqanizational Develooment Specialist: Positions in this class perform
skilled pro#essional work in assisting o�ces and departments to determine and meet
theirtraining and organizational development needs, assesses organizational problems
and plans to improve effectiveness. Also these positions design, plan and instruct
management employee training.
Senior Consultant-Business Consultinq Services: Positions in this class provide highly
responsible professional consulting services to members of City departments and offices
in improving their individual, group and organizationai effectiveness. These positions
also assess organizational concems, plans and conducts interventions.
Librarv Traininq and Orqanizational Development Coordinator: Positions in this class
perform skilled professional work in assisting senior staff and various elements of the
library system to determine and meet their development and training needs and to
increase individual and organizational effectiveness.
o� -yP'4
The position in question is a hybrid position. It combines the duties of the Library
Training and Organizational Development Coordinator job class with those of Office
Manager job class. The position's duties match those of Library {nformation Resourczs
Coordinator class more than any other Library class of position. However the, Library
Information Resources Coordinator is also a hybrid position that is involved in planning
and administrative work a�d information systems work. The position in question is not
involved with information systems.
The position has similar duties to the Training and Organizational Devefopment
Specialist, and Senior Consultant-Business Consulting Services positions however, both
of those positions have Citywide responsibilities. The position also has duties in
common with Office Manager positions however; the Office Manager job class duties do
not encompass the position's training and organizational development duties.
As mentioned above, the position is responsible for directing and managing the planning
processes for the City's Library. Additionally, the position is responsible for managing
the internal personnel affairs of the library. These are basically the same duties that
were present in 1998, when the position was first studied. The addition of supervisory
responsibility is the major change in the position. The best match for the position is the
current job specification however, with the addition of supervisory responsibilities, it is
necessary that the position be reallocated to a new class and assigned appropriate
compensation level in SPSO bargaining unit.
Q.E.S. Evaluation and Analvsis
In 1998, the Q.E.S. factor analysis total points were 1,920 at that time the position had
no formal supervisory responsibilities. As was mentioned above, the position has
supervisory authority. This increases the total points to 2,055. The Q.E.S. analysis
supports the allocation to grade 13 in the SPSO salary schedule.
Recommendation
it is recommended that the position be allocated to a new class titled Library Training
and OrganizationaV Devetopment Coordinator Supervisor and assigned to grade 13 of
the SPSO bargaining unit salary schedule.
o� -`1rS•
OFfICE OF HUMAN RESOURCES
Ange(a S. Nulezrry, Direaor
CTI'I' OF SAINT PAUL
Randy Kel/}, Mayor
TO: Gina LaForce, Duector
Saint Paul Public Libraries
FROM: John H. Shockley ��� Td �
Office of Human Resources
DATE:
�
February 3, 2003
Twenty Day Notice
400CiryHauAnnes
2S Wesi Foutth Street
SainlPaul,Minnuota 55/01-1631
7e7ephone: 651-1666500
Jobtine: 651-2666502
F¢rcimJe: 651-292-J656
Pursuant to City of Saint Paul, Civil Service Rule 3. (C) this memorandum is to inform
you that the following changes are being made:
• Creation of the class specification titled Library Training and
Organizational Development Coordinator/Snpervisor
• A resolution wil] be processed to establish the rate of pay in St. Paul
Supervisors Organization (b.u. 09), Grade 013
JSltf
Attachments
An Affumative Action Equal Opporhuvty ADA Employer
OfFICE OF HUMAN RESOURCES
Angela S. Na!¢ny, Director
CITY OF SAIIVT PAUL
Rand}� Ke[I}�, Mayor
February 3, 2003
Helga Kessler, President
Saint Paul Supervisors Organization
Regional Water Services
8 4`" Street East, Suite 200
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
Re: Twenty Day Notice
Dear Helga:
400 Ciry Ha11 Annee
25 West Favth Street
Sain:Pavl, Ninnuom 55101-J637
69 _�iF(,
Teleyhone: 651-26665Q0
Jo6liae: 651-1666502
F¢scimHe: 651-192-7656
Pursuant to City of Saint Paul, Civil Service Rule 3. (C) this memorandum is to inform
you that the following changes are being made:
Creation of the class specification titled Lihrary Training and
Organizational Development CoordinatorlSupervisor
A resolution will be processed to establish the nte of pay in St. Paul
Supervisors Organization (b.u. 09), Grade 013
Sincerely,
� �f/ �vl��C2.�.�-�y
ohn H. Shockley vl
Office of Human Resources
JHS/tf
Attachments
An AffirmaTive Action Fqual Opportunity ADA Employer
The City of Saint Paul Class Specification
Proposed Title of Class:
DESCRIPTION OF WO12K
General StatemenE of Dnties:
o� .y�
CODE: 245B
BU: 09
Effecrive:
Performs skilled professional and supervisory work in assisting the senior staff and others within the Saint Paul
Public Library System to detemune and meet their organizational development and training needs; oversees various .
Library System administrarive functions such as budget preparation, accounting, payroll and central human
resources activities; performs other related duties as required.
Sunervision Received:
Works under the general supervision of a division manager or the Library Director.
Sunervision Exercised:
Provides supervision of assigned staff and serves as a project manager/team leader as assigned.
TYPICAL DUTIES
The listed examples may not include all the duties performed by all posirions in this class.
Consults with and surveys managers, supervisars, and employees in order to diagnose problems and detemune
development needs and potential areas of concern; coordinates those needs with the overall planning process and
the visions and goals of the Saint Paul Public Library System.
Facilitates or serves on a variety of training, development and planning committees within the Library, the City,
and external Library associations.
Facilitates interventions focused on problem solving, conflict resolution, strategic planning, and identified concerns.
Designs, administers, and delivers employee training and development programs.
Assesses development needs and priorities; recommends and designs development programs for management,
professionals, and other staff.
Evaluates extemal consultants and recommends their selection; assesses their effectiveness and evaluates the work
product.
Represents the Library as liaison to the Peme Jones Foundation.
Oversees various internal Library human resources actions, such as scheduling of part-time pazaprofessional staff,
new employee selecrion process, orientation, and training.
Serves as the Library System liaison to the City's Office of Auman Resources in such areas as recruitment and
assessment, classification and compensarion, monitoring of sick leave and workers compensation claims, diversity
planning, performance management and staffing, and scheduling.
Oversees the Library System payroll function and supervises assigied payroll staff.
Facilitates the development of the Library System budget priorities and oversees the budget preparation process
and the accounting functions.
COMPETENCIES
LIBRARY TRAINING AND ORGANIZATIONAL
DEVELOPMENT COORDTNATOR/SUPERVISOR
'RAINING AND ORGAIVIZATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR/SI Page 1
Proposed Title of Class:
LIBRARY TRAINING AND ORGAIVIZATIONAL
DEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR/SUPERVISOR
CODE: 245B
su: 09 03 -y�
Effecrive:
Demonstrates an understanding of the full range of theories, principles, practices, and trends involved in the
operarions of a major library system and demonstrates an ability to identify problems and recommend appropriate
resolurion of problems associated with library operations.
Demonstrates an understanding of the full range of theories, principles, practices, and trends of training and
organizational development including needs assessments, change management, team building, group process, adult
learning, and success measurement; demonstrates an ability to idenrify appropriate interventions required to resolve
the full range of problems associated with the work.
Demonstrates an understanding of the full range of strategic planning theories, techniques, and tools, and
demonstrates an ability to resolve the full range of problems associated with the strategic planning process.
Demonstrates an understanding of the full range of modern supervisory and management theory, principles, and
techniques; demonstrates an ability to apply this understanding in providing leadership to a work group.
Demonstrates an understanding of the common principles of budget prepazation and accounring; and demonstrates
an ability to apply this understanding to resolving the common problems associated with the work.
Demonstrates sldll in operating a computer keyboard, mouse and peripheral devices, such as printers, scanners and
duplicaring machines; demonstrates an ability to use a broad range of library job related sofrware such as email,
word processing, spreadsheet, database manager and presentation applications; keeps current on advances in job
related software.
Demonstrates an ability to independently prioritize one's own work and the work of others, be attenrive to detail,
and provide assistance to and coordination of the wark of others.
Demonstrates an ability to plan and manage projects, negotiate and meet time lines and define, measure and
evaluate resulCs.
Demonstrates an ability to gather, analyze, and organize information, conduct comparative analysis, make
recommendations supported by identified facts, and present clear recommendations to management.
Demonstrates an ability to effectively communicate in writing, spealdng, and listening; demonstxates effective
public speaking and presentarion skills; demonstrates an ability to write reports that can be easily understood by the
reader. ,
Demonstrates effective group leadership ability by encouraging individual participation and creativity; is
supportive of others and group decision maldng process; demonstrates an ability to effectively manage conflict.
Demonstrates an ability to identify the service needs of a diverse group of internal and external customers and
effectively respond to those needs.
Demonstrates a commihnent to conrinuously improving customer service; demonstrates an ability to promote
effective customer service through example and coordinate customer service.
MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS
Bachelor's Degree and four years of professional level experience in a public librazy system including at least one
year of supervisory experience; and two yeazs of experience in the following:
1. Conducting assessments of complex organizational problems.
'RAINING AND ORGANIZATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR/SL Page 2
Proposed Title of Class: LIBRARY TRAINING AND ORGANIZATIONAL
DEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR/SUPERVISOR
CODE: 245B
BU: 09
C9 -4E'�•
Effecrive:
2. Planning and conducting interventions to solve complex problems and improve effectiveness.
3. Designing and instructing all levels of employee training.
'RA1NiNG AND ORGANIZATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR/SL Page 3