250262 ._. , .: . , _
... � . ...�_.�. .:w . ._, , . . �
. . . . . � 4 ..;�; .4�- . . . .
1 ^ � . � . . � J � � .. . � . . � . � . . .i����, . .
� � ' ' FINAL ORDER �oUNC�L �� No _
• By
File Na 1T�l�
In the Matter of ���i � �'�" �`�+M► C1�rl�M /►� tr iwMt11�
� �+�jr l�r�t �-0�t) �t�s �ttlow:
_ I��i�t dr�t sa�aS�wd � i�t ist� �lrs witaa i�t�M a�i s+�d�ct t�r t�LrM
ari� i'srr Mwli ltt�wet to �sllta� �Airww�� �e�s�st da +rwtsl,/�r +ert�s<aN �
�� a ti�t���r wKSlal !'iar tYs wtirt l� it ii� 1�#+att r��t�t
stra�t, a11N,� �i �rl�� �; `s��t�et �f�s rrt�rr �t�s !�#litl�s
arr� � alY �lurt w�! �rtiisti i� �� �ri l��+t�tlasl �r e�l� sa�+/ �
�rrt. .
j"
. .�:�
� under Preliminary Order ?+1►731� approvP� �� 1� Z!'I�
�� Intermediary Order aPProv�
A public hearing having been had upon the above improvement upon due notice, and the Council
, having heard all persons, objections and recommendations relative thereto, and having fully conaidered
the same; therefore, be it �
RESOLVED, By the Council of the City of St. Paul that the precise nature, extent and kind of imti;
provement to be made by the said City is
' t� l�s�e � �Y !'�+e� C1s�r3�a�M ar�� t�s itrtl�� S�+�r� (�City ls�rj�et
� �-1130�3 .. t�l�ss
� �wet��ie�1�M ar�
�ewstsirst �► Di��e anr�ar�r !yr ei� �rt►t� l� �t �is t�ae3aet; �nr�r�sts�t
k �tr�t, �lly oi iei�wA�r s�t�ef �rwwrtr.et st� �r i�s� �Lli!l�at
� aM �N a�! etir�at �t �t�t ia �.a�d 3ss��a� to +e�►1� sai�i �+�°-=�--
�.. ��•
and the Council hereby orders said improvement to be made.
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the Commissioner of Public Works be and is hereby instructed and
directed to prepare plans and specifications for said improvement, and submit same to the Council for
approval; that upon said approval, the proper city of�'icials are hereby anthorized and directed to pro-
ceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therewith.
COUNCILMEN ��� SEP 1 19��
Adopted by the Coun��l
Yeas BUTLER Nays SEP 1 19�0
CARLS4N Approv
LEVINE
MEREDITH �n Favor
SPRAFKA - a�,o
TEDESCO � �
McCARTY A�;nst � �
e_se.2� �� a.� PUBLISHED SEP 51970 � "��-
. -•-� ?�r�
; . �:,�
� � � ���&�o����.� � � � ����
�, , �F 9,�� �
� OFFICG OF TIiE C0�7;ISSI��R Or PUBLIC WORiCS '��' '
, ��_ d � 19
. ��, �,�,��� >�
• . �:� �. L'� �.xr
�.� ��� � q;f
'. REPORT TO CONMISSIO�IER OF FTNANCE • m � ` .� -�l
�
�
� ' . � o�� `���
2
' . A�ril 2'�, 19.,Z4__.. �
. ^ • .
i �o tha Coranissioner of Finance of the City of Saint Paul:
t
t • .
. The Corrrmissioner of Public Worka, havin� had under corisideration the pre-
, .
' liminary order of the Council� lmown as Council File No. 21+731�
{
, •
� ap�roved_ Feb. 3 19- 7_0_.__relative to IiI�HLA.�TD PKwY. . '
i
' ' ' F�om Cleveland Ave. to Snelling Ave. (City Pro�ect No. P-0502) '�
�
�
; � •
and having inveatigated the matters and thiags referred to therein, hereby repor�s:
1. The estimated cost thereof is � 137,3� �
2. A plan� profile or aketch of said improvement is hereto attached and made
s part hereof. �
3. Tnitisted by the Commi.asioner of Public Works
� k. Improvement is aeked for upon petition
. �
�
� . Commission of �' r' s
� . ' • . � ,��;��
� , � .
� "`�i� � n � *' �-1 � i1 1 { � �� � .
." � ! . . , . ! . . iJ 1.. . �-�:\ I �i�` �_ � 1 � .,.
, � . . . '. . , . ' . • C/, .. . . . � � � �''�I �� .11/�/1 ....)�i . �,ri� . ` .
. � . � � �.'n,��,`10n -
u0/1� , �.. � ,i � L�. � �����i. ...�.� ..-�r
.. CQi'.�1.��5�'(ii.rr� �.._ � .1 I. J��f�1i��\i�� 11"�� : .., � .;i.�� ��
. .. . ... . � . . . . � ��i.1�of .�iUl f"I
' I .`��C�1 1'. , ,��......� . �, .. J. . . . , .�
��; i.�i
:!��.,,.,�i;�, ;.� . 11�3��5 i :� PUMPIV6 ;;:.,.;I;UTI'.,
.' / •'
,%i
February 11, 1970 -�� �
�i
!-'i. -
-T�
C1audQ L. Thompson '��
Public Works Design EY�gineer f� ` ''`
Room 23l�
City Hall
, �, Re: P-0502 Highland Parkway
� _ � Cleveland Avenue to SSnelli.ng
;
Avenue.
Dear Sir:
In reply to your letter dated January 28, 1970, we reviewed the prelimi.nary
plans and are sending you our plats shawing a11 water mains in the affected
. area, along with a list of service connections with size, type and location.
Costs for new or replacement service connections are as follows:
Size of Service Schedule Charp,e
3/��� (includes replacing concrete base)
�31�5.00
1" � 370.00
l z�� �70.00
� ' , 2" or larger , Actual Cost
This schedule of charges is guaranteed until January, 1972.
� \ Ploase send us a final desi�n plan showing all servi.ce connections and
appurtenances. At that time we will review the final plan and give you the
cost estimates of changes which will be necessary.
!�'1ro hyclrunt� ohould bo .�1.old Yocu•Lod to do��orrnino if rol.oca�;ion ia nocassary
All water ma�ins are at a depth of a proximatel 7 feet.
P Y
. � �
If you need ar�y flirther information please ca11 our office at 223-1i1.22. �
' �
t`�
Ve truly,yours, �-:������
,,/ / � �,:, �
..-a
7 ;�_ � ) f l ��`/' G.U ,:�
� �ll:.,.. �.
_ Thomas I�, iKogr�
�`� ' RNS/eh Chief of e Y� '°�
/ - i , �gin eru�g Division �"'.
�`�l � �
1 G i�, '1 �,
a��r� ;, � .
.- �`
t S�p
1��... w..i
p���� ., � 1w r ��,.,tir. ��,�� � � ' ^ --�'-:_. �..-.. � . ,... _ ��,.. �,.� - M•'•{���a:Y� �q"M���,,��,,.r�:-�sr .,.w••a^ql�w.n�.cae��
r .
. � ' . . , � .:�� � , n..
�, �'''�. ��� . � . .., . . � .. . , .� ' . � . � � ,
' �. 1MlLLIAM DONOVAN
�. �,� '. „Valuation Engineer 223-5317
�r j CITY OF SAINT PAUL
4 ,ROY 'F: BREDAHL, Jr.
Ass't Val�ation E�y��ee� BUREAU OF VALUATIONS
186 City Hall
$aint Paul, Minnesote 55102 '
� -�.... '�ii .
Mareh lg, 1970
Mr. Claude Tho�pson
Design En�ineer
Department of Public Works
St. Paul, Minnesota
Re: P=0502 HIGHIrAND PKWY. - Cleveland to Snell.ing
Dear Mr. Thompson:
Pursuant to your request, I ha�ae set farth herein information pertinent to
the property assessment f'or the prop�sed imprcvement described as;
P-0502 Highland Parkway, Cleve3and tc� Snelling
The total estimated amount recoverable by assessment is $40,150.00 based
on the following estimated assessment rates:
Surfar,.ing �inr.lud5.ng curbing)
A & B Resic�ential �4.30�assess. ft.
"C" Residentia,l,Camm. & Ind, property $�.45jassess. ft.
Driveways;
Cc:nc. Drive;� - 6" thick $7.50� sq. yd.
Cc;nc. nr�.v�s - 7" th.icl: $8.50�sq. yd.
Please inco�°por�,i�e �::t:�.e .fal�cwixi� a.�.c�itional costs in the estimated total
e��endi-��zre:s for. t}�°.s i.m�ro��en;er�t:
Val_t,avi_c7n �, !lsse,>.�ment, ;�ervi�es �803.00
��:l.S. �",O:;t;: �7.;��`) r;a.1°C:'..�_S �' �v.jQ� �977.��
Very truly ,-yauT•s,
, :_�_�..
� . �`: ,s.J:,i._<<_ �
r
Ra� E. Bredahl, Jr.��
��.ss"t, Valua:,:�.or. �,n�ir.�eer
cc: R. I,. �tivYa.w�i.er
�'au_�. [iF�,>c:�h �''
Y� Ov ,. ;.a_ .T 7i . . . .. �o�-{`'f.� CONC PO�A ...ti'�=wVC��
C,O UN T R Y w � II�' + '1 � _-_ L onfonll�
• • . ;� �'�� . y�. i 1��iII,��!_,,,_�....�1.--�2/ � � No �rn�v[. � Ilcr�/
�, . , ,..�_ '��2b�
. _.__, -�-cr- jI �� ... � ,i
� '• �.:,�; c z,v s �hi` 14� W ��%���� # c° � ' i
rr \ �► ,�,.R ` �� 2 2 0 `
' ,, rcc�u � p...w, v�`-w • �
(\ � �- 212 ,, c�os xema �a�.��`i'.w. ��:e..., ,'.
.4VE
AK U - - ' a AL G �
"�.�. .a, z � '� �� �� : Sch�..�' � �
� c � �
� . . ;_.,..- �...�� �-�}-u ��
!\ r o '� YL. ,�►L_.1 L E��
. , �'�:
. .> " � , E ,���-�:��,�I I,[ �
�� � � � _��."�;�� l
; �� � S �.o �► f..�`� �r�".._.l�`.;`t�"�1� ��-`""�r—�.�►,.�n� i:-�
��. �°; � �, . � � � � , ;�r , _ 4 __...�., �
� � � ;_'l a �-, ., � g .� � ��„�����„ .�e � F�_--��' �►�;��.
���'��� '� p D� I � �y ^W . ���...
� J�* .���� ON�A . � I QOIIBCO J �..►� � �si+�
•r
• F . ' .l �. �r_V • , AVE—r
� '•� �Y� �0 ND e . �
��.. lO . ° �:-� � IriO . ot �Jwo`3
� �.. � � . . . ..
I� O U .. •' �ire� .. ,� ... �
:_ ' �_� c � �� �
'"� -- VI e � ..■ C'""' .��_:� e_:=�� e� °�U�M°P�l T"�� e:r - _ �--� ca e.=--"r....
. ._ ^___ ___ T- �_.��_...� c .___ ' - ...��
�Seven l�.7 r . � � : � �. �� tem 1 ." � � l.h P�u ... . �`�a�
oval �. ' �' Sch. � .5 �I.
� � 51 '.
' �i �s.P u, �v�. �
.-��� , � . � , � MND---/+ <� +_ • ��_ �
E
� y ■� � E W_ \ �f .�I luth. AVC. �
' „ r w .� �>��p �:'+ �:��. �
� �D �' Kuminnry > q J �' �
V/ '• Q v `J a Lh. I�WUIII�yq AVL�-
.�`...� ,,: �'� i � r � �'- O t;� �l �—1
��'� 2 4 :i �� r �t+ l��y FA�HMW
� ��' . < .3 �' , . �m m� � �/
+ ILuth. � �d_ �y ��,•,' � . p � Ar V • � d m
I F'i ��� .....
1 M[u �. 7'� � ��' ��� �j.•��� a�nc to ,� �� o�cEO� .
o �PRINC�1dJ1ON�--�1 �+ v0• � i,.�.�.,...,�:
1,`FI .\\� �m��+ � r�V � M V■ .�A?cOt .
s`` I !d !;r--y�R N� �*�--AVE. � I W i� e
f .����� � r ry �'��f.uth.Ch��,
�R•"� D' • ' S T ,-A-1-R v uiF� ' w
t 1 �
� >
u ��AyE. �----rQEnKK� Ar ��':"� ;�
�
ERKELE[�(�[� � ���
n'DowlmR - • �� �. .,,�
• � YG`� 11 }+ �� � 47�ANFOR (-+AVE7 {°��
� $chooi� : w �� ZI� � •�:t�"�R C���" g [��I�.JW..
.nf t�..we.r �F
_-i � ��q" �^w�
�. ' S' H :� � � � ' WELLES Y AVE �
. ......., .: r
�l:.'�':i:f�'•��S•�. ' ' ,
....•......:. ,; = _ � � ^ •a �
, .. . .s W1V� L� C., . ���..� . �. . �7 EFFER � . _ ...
�I�� rj I� �'i. ., � ... _. �. � .Y��JyI•..ly..�.� �
'� , ; Zi �i - _ � �� � T � ..ii T �� �T��� 3
> > - � ` �....,...R �`� �—_�� � -- -�
. �°;<:_ M,� � ;_ �e b1k..� �, :,,rr^t'eC�;,�.,.. _ r--� :.,���a�-.,-,�-AVE� , ... �., �
1 ' � � � �
o_ WI � 1 � C t;�--,..�_�
¢ � . .. ._, .. , 'AM ��.; �� �.�-�i�!f-AVE"� .
-,� , �3` .. L� �--� _
N y-. C� � N ` L-P r-AVE,�.��",��.. . � Cretin
.� I` , �, �'�E,�� ��;�h I�
I Z - / �p p _ 0 . � ` �I- �`l' � L J p O� 'ch. �
.\ :
, '_ �, ) ,: ,': _
.''" �
� = o�� = z ;~" � � !� 3kPau1 � "'�+ � . ose h �
' m m � � � . St.Catherin0� l�C9d0my • ` ' "• SD'r,han Ke `i9
�"� ` �
.u■r w � ' ,°s, Q � Colloee II .4 � -- ,�"
Arm�■ �", " � = W h �._ _ 1,�—�Y�
. i ,i _ • .. � �' .: J �
�r� ♦ � � V
ttntrrtor �
D �. _�� � " � r.o� k�. � �': ����-----r� �
� , , `.��"°° � ° 1� _� ���
a ���. m # <�;:�,�"� ;j. - �-- �,---��;
� `
r. �
, ;' � _ � • : � ' �.: ��� � � �'"�`�``�
}, � ;�
=a. � : � '�.. c • S " Gy,ao��u.�cn. ;i_t't �
* U y�
i l MIGI
o� �.'. FI �.�,r`, 3 � IGHLAN �RKWY � I L�._.,.
� �� � ; 3 `----yy' �
=' �� a�� ���� �.� , ,:�
�µph'�. ` V G � ; �O f; � ' . .
!� � yl �
2 / � � �� . 3 p ';u� r ,
! `��Y = � •���� FORD PAHKWAY rI�1 't:': , . .`C .
,r �j�MIlATIT Y D4 ��J I 1��0 u I
Cy.� �I ,-++iLLCR� 4r �V' '� ��
��IiA � � ��� � , ..�"-.�-,f� � I U �'. . ` �'
� "' ,.vN.�c� ���uonuNO- -.avE ;�V, �' �,
� ' • � ... �\ \\� +h f, ��� . " tw .
a� P.�i�e- ��F Q �L L�
i
rf�Ytat � -o�.. . ;,,;,, FORD - ` BEE��W� . ,
.
- ' � � \ �� . {' AV L J-.
� � . - �, _ � ��C�
;
� N•, '' TOR C0� 1\J �e� � '�rSAUNUL�}�I ❑16h. .. 1> (�A�v�' , ,�
��� ,,- �,...�«. r . ,
� � � !F'�� Iyy `ii v,�.a�� �l ..�y p'^'���.._.. '--'�AVE.
_ • ;
�, '^
'��� 1Pn•8��ty -�� , � �': ��� Ju� �' �� . . .
; ' .� , f, ,,;,,. ; _ _. .._. �
1•\�.�A�O���e . -__� _..._:_.._-.' . - . .
� ` .4 __ _ 'i��
�/�t;�. � O�� 1 \�: - __ ��Q^/(!% '.6�OCh � � ;
\ � ' � �f en� t � 1
��J � '!�' � . '\y �^ :� � �i.r
,( \�. � ���� .;7/ AV. J'A G�. I '� �.ff._ �I . . .
�, i 4.
} �, , y\ A r._._.'. ,,, }� � c, �_r.si �+,�• �`�,, u� ni��.i r: I
��, ? f/� �� � _t'.S f, � �...` �''r`T�v �� � ti.� . I;.. � �',!v
� \��\^� ,� , :\� I�'� P„ �f F i A��\� t,�� r�� ���I t�'U _ c~ �"l_._ ____
1 � �
� /�-�� � _ � � �� � �-���`, 'C� >�� � � �S��� � J �� •
'S- ' , \ .\ P . ��1 �( � �
1 1 y � � 14 �7 �f �� / 1
7 4+ '� �� ��V''�. . � ,. A�' � �;�o- ri�rc��I.� "' � 5..�.� � '� M:..� '�j � . .
,S IV Z � ` � ._ J - �
� U>'���� � ° y m� , `a� I ,.:� �,� .,'
:' � y,�' . ��` _i�°,-J; ,� 'H��'Y���° ,) \-� ?`` '. �.,,. \ //.
�1.f \� '� �... J��� \ �� �� '�u A�r..d'�I - �� //� .
: 'L `` . ".\�` �`�•. Q�v`vn Jtj���r �-s1uNrS� C;r. 111� k � - -J"iy.//'�', ..i;:
n W F �hC \�� .:`F I - ���' ,�-1-�- �,^. � . �.
.� �.. „ �` .._.
� �/� ... ��
��O Y �--� �� `V� _.._ . .. ..av 6�,._ � '�.�.�.� .� _ ._ . � ,
���-� . .._. ,__.-._ . � .
� � ( _._ ��. ,�rj- •y� .-�"L'-.. .. � ` � � /:
1'--'` � • , ',� - �u > ""� ��.— � o�,.u,; � ��.�_ '�ti�- / ,� �
// �
� �� �
� r�=! ��`� ♦♦ � ���lyG� ` I u`4. � �����-.-.-«+�-+-�-'�--I'��— ��M��wwuKCe ,� ,`�'�f•f�
_
i � �/�7 \, � 1,�. �Y j�- U. GO Ijwauor. av�T" �i\�/ �� � . ..
� \ / I ,�.+--�--�'1
,( �` 1,i F-.rt .a Ijo - �[c �"1't"_�.�c/ �� / '.
i •
1 �• • ,� . �� .
` � � �� • ;}�t '� � ,-� � ! i '�!� s�� ; _}`'
I,� ��� \\�♦ �, �t�`T- • � _.__.._.. .._....._ _ _�,- ; y >
' ��7-saos
�1�NEILL, BURKE AND O'NEILL I..TO.
ATTp R N EYS AT �AW
�50 WEST gpUR'TM STREET
L;A�N'r P�►U{.� MINN�9�]TA S�i105�
JONN B. BURKE, JR. June 16 �.970
J08EPH T. O'NEILL • �
PATRICK M. O'NEILL.
JON R. DUCKOTAD '
Mayor and Council
City of Saint Paul
City Hall
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
� Re: Preliminary Order No. 247313
Improvement Highland Parkway .
City Project No. P-0502
Dear Mayor McCarty, Mrs. Butler and Gentlemen of the Council:
I am enclosing for your perusal prior to the Council
meeting of today's date a copy 'df a petition signed by resi-
dents of the City living on Highland Parkway in the area
generally described in your preliminary order approved Febru-
ary 3, 1970. This petition represents 95� of the affected
homeowners on Highland Parkway, who are against this improve-
ment.
We shall be presenting at the Council meeting today
an orderly discussion of the reasons why this improvement must
be defeated.
Thank you for your consideration in this matter.
Very truly yours, �
� °�o�C �I, 4� �.u.c
Patrick H. O'Neill
PHO:vt
Enc.
.
� , .
� SUI�IARY OF ENGINEERIl�TG RECONA�NDATION �
Tueaday, July l�� 1970
A]7VISABII,ITY AND DESIRABILITY
IMPR(7VE HIGHLAND PI4riY. from Cleveland Ave. to Snelling Ave. (City Pro�ect
P-0502� Widen the roadbed 12 ft. into the media.n islands and reconstruct
the island curba from HoWell St. to Snelling Ave.; reconstruct the
outside curbs and construct a bituminous overlay for the entire length
of the pro�ect; reconstruct street, s11ey and driveway returna;
reconstruct storm water drainage facilities.
The exiating pavement is 3" asphalt and 2�" brick over a 6"
concrete base conatructed in 1.926, and is in rough condition. The
existing surfacing �rill be overlaid wlth 2 3�4" of asphalt.
Traffic is estimated to be 1500 vehicles per day and is expected
to be 3,500 vehicles per d.a.y in 20 y�eaxs. TraPfic volu�es warrant
widening the roadbed to 2 - 20 foot lanes by taking 12 Peet of the
center island for each lane from Snelling to Howell. From Howell
to Clevela.nd the roadbeds axe presently about 20' kide and would be
overlaid only. Sidewalks will be affected only at the quadrants
and driveways will be replaced. Curbing on the island will be
removed and replaced �here the roadbed is widened. Curbing on the
outside of the roadbed is in fair condition, but is only 3 inehea or
lesa in height over the existing surface a.nd will be replaced.
Drainage structures are ad.equate.
The improvement will provide a smoother surface, and the widening
will m4re easily acco�oci,ate,the traffic on this street.
Eatima,ted construction costs are $137,300.00 oP which �40,150.00
are property assessn�ents, $97,150.00 are 1970 Capital Improvement Bonds.
The assessment per front �oot for paving is $�+.30 �or "A" & "B" Residential
and $6.�+5 for "C" Residential, Commercial and Industrial. The
assessment per Pro�t Poot of curbing is included in the above rates.
7�e assessment per 8quare yaxd �or drive�rays 6 inches and 7 inches thick ,
are $7.50 and $8.50 respectPtiil.ly.
It is the Engineering recom�endation that this order 'be agpro�ved.
) •�.�v >f.rr:ar? �-.-� `�-�--+,M-���y--- .
I • ,� �C,O IIN T ii Y W oe�v F Park l�L�'��'_�� � c���`-'���-�� : � ._��
� ��U��.����� l�� coHC ■o�� F ' s��ve _�-- - -_•'
` � l ;�`� �,�� �ti U'��� �o ir �v�. �'nnlu
-f + C L V II i��IJ c'F'�'`r.J Ll:=J 2J/� u��lu�• o � ��wvc �, u.,�
2l2 v " c ��'r ��
� `"� "�. ���`�C���,�`�7� ❑�0 �"� z�z �,
A S _ - ; �M L AVE
�'� � . ���A C1�OO�OOO�J000 �h���' C7
f�\ _ , ` � "� �'�CJOC1�70❑�ooa�"°�o � �c�
0 D �� � LB V W i..�J L�LJ�� �H� :
; � � °�. � 8��,,0��► �0 D�,1�0�o o❑ . E o�o �� �
�> �.J..{• � '�� �D�� a� 'i �� � jJ�����������rd�" A��a ~�
� � TaS-A . � i y� � �V e-ASHUN . _ �-AVE 'i4
/! ' � �rt .,:.:: �..' ;_� ;.]�I�O C�€�C�����l l� ���� �
.
� �/� �V '✓� � ` ��{�•k�+ ' « J 1 1� ND o���� �r ' � �7�
, :�y, � ��
� e ' ��A .
j�+- • c==•�� c_� aSWN�Ma•T:� � o �c�m °c� �- c�a �,.�
=AN£+
•-` 1.�1 • �. / I � ■�� �8l.P�d'� �
\' � `� , ;��y'° 0 � � � s�h. �� "� Q �51 �� l_J�� �F�.:���
! -:,y' �`::; 18t.Taul �mv�.
-' 1� �i , I �� ' L�Cl�"°�0 C] '�L� ������0
.� < � � r
2 �I .:= L ,
;t � �- n
�� �� � � caw. ve.
✓//J�• ��V i%` seminars �t_J f����� $��r��Y ce. ����
.., , �� ._.
� y �.r 0R7 Ce. � , ����rAv
�\ E� ��RIC�I�OOC� Y � M �
r 1�1uh ��''''/ 3�J q� � � � � � AIRMOU ���
� ��. W FAIR NT ;.A1-�'���-,A V� m I
,' �P t � �'� ����r �'fJ�Ll-.AJW m!�I AVE
`„'jµ� � ��;� �a—i��� � � ° R�NC TO ti � ^ �r U�J U�
� D NC ��� � 4 V p 06�E �..`
���L�J� � � �.�. �
�V� �
. 'f � Y. ro�el�M vk:.::::' �V,�E�. � � M n � y J
�p. � � ��,� �C i;:�7s�n a;r.,::o;;: tyP"'..•.-••.�� � '�� ��l��U
�. ('��'-�1
. :.: �� .�' � ❑�����C��� CiC]O v 1I11►t�'7tY1 11� OOW
�,DowlinR :..:. .4,. • � qI Y�IZ1�1 11�1 rI--A11e'� gI[-n��11f r1 �� II 11y1 11II 11dJ
� �3eh0o1�:,� : �,� Nf � � µ�L�J L��L�,J3 ��.�J O t�J U{�J(,�J� BERKEI!f��
� R:C HrJ. dr �
� =k �I� ��.. � ��,� �� �:::: : ��o �E.� �o 0
:: ��: W�� �f•� " �LJ���L�J L�J L�1 l�J v�a��a D�LJ �a��
.: >.� 'z � "':J E�� � EF.FER N V
� . ,. � ���0�0� ���°��
� �� o� W'� ��' � �E 0 0��� ��� ��.la..J�..Js ��
�ItlLiF,
� �
o= xI . Z �0'L�0�7 C-1��,.� �'({' '''j7. 'I^t���
a �== , o��« ^^ g �
� .� ,iy < ����L��� �� ��LJLJL.�J� •
.ti� a�� �%-� � �
'12~ �� ili �i� rRANqQ L-PH� �''"�VC,�—����'17 �efj
I 'y � i i s� 0 �.J L�J I`'';,�'��_���� `-°-f' � � �� ��� •_if-6ch0O CreRin
Jp'> �!,S UN d �!`—_ � � 4 u �e �p p�. �hb r0
.�` mlm <:F �z -' � 1 i! Stpaul �� p L�
•r� >-ni�ES—�v gt.Cntl►erine� �
.n.k.�� . P� : � � g a���'��' Academy Fs"rut� Fc-isve. .�oseph ,i _,,,.��
Arm� -',�W . r "� Colle�e U� ��� r panage �
, :' ?.'� t � . p A�FSON—AVE. J WA-f50N AVE pk l=1 �J
,.� � �.:.� � _ � � � �"1
� ARTfO CrAyE•. qT{pq yE
,. ;:'' � ��°�:�: ���� �"�0 C]�+7� L� `__7��
> _ . � , ��m y—� YAR �-A�ET�� Q Ha BFe vE �U�U�J D��� �
I � 1
'. � "�, �}$C HEfFE7�u-�A wy� ° �' �C HEFFE V, ~ ����¢�HE�Eq
� . � a �FJ� �3��h. ����°� ����', m �-! 1 U
p��l. ` "1 �,' _�-�F a LEANO =-AV . F ; ELEA�NOR �►V � g YJ LEANO
•t � ... L!' Q��' OIm4WlCh.
' = LJ�
. ` I W ��'��
, �'� �:. 3 IaHLAN [��PKWX H�I GHLi
,:� u� 'q �
'�.: ::.?�� V� �:' � �!`J M(�7��'��:ii'�:�i:'•:':i;r:;:,.��:•i,'.�,.���.::��:;;jry"::��::iq �r—��[xu�t�r+
I Q' g INEHURS VE ��N�� �� ,•1 ►{ • � �- _ . :I
�. ; ��� = PINEHUR VE
� � � � m �a��R
F D PA KWAY � � �� � '!�/
��rf.. wi r��ioo[ a.� . . PARKWA . "" w
bii E$A � •6 0� oi�, q "°
V; �Nlkrlal 7�y� y �• ��M�llt�tl�
���� • I� �Y/.
t �.: : P.G. T' :;.N„�:
��ti�' . � / NI�14 VB
� � . .j .. . .. � .' eox.•
J � i^ �,�'y ��� 80ML-AND- � urf� �
Y Yt'K`` . . • FORD °Y� � � � ���� 7aSen1� ,�
�v Bl M 0
� '�, N:., � M TOR CO ��o� a �' BEECMW00 �v � .�yo ��9
_ . ���'������ ��.:.:;:.. '�_
�. ' �; 'r::;;;'::<:::«�;:�:�:<;::i::.:......... .; � �
� p� I �. �U YiLt�i l � N�� �rSAHNOE� HI h a d�pk'. 'A�. .
. ���°�e�� � Vl o., 11 0.�.,�� s. �— '�W I� • ;.��: � ���$I,,,G H L A N n; 0� . � p;
�T�I+.p � �a � �:'. ii � / =$ E• ":�'•��:?"� .:9y ' . .� �\ `�.
� � /�-� M
. \����\e �� ' _'_ ����J������ ��'�'-'F.'. T i....ti . 166.Houe�,. O .����.
�„ • � ' ,,.4: - � `�Q-MONTAFJ�--� .., . . ....... ,�w..rrs
,' �0`'7' �.Gi�} t�i;i.7::<.•.•..ti.�; ..•. •.•y
�. • � ��� W 1 c6 r�, �'r::. �. .:
� � Y� J :�m:::':.::::/�•jl
� • ���/'': a�� HIRhI ndPk.,...:' .= y
� •��i " � AV. �: � VO JcN.3.• . :�:
, ...'' o Y c „ .:60�:
� \'� `� _ '� W r ���. .. .�.:` ... . .
\, � i -� ., ,,.- O N .v :e.::
;�\� ' \ ` _ 1 .•�:..:�•.• :;ii -^:; .':.'
�T. . !�. � , p , yi AlRhland Pk .:;::•:� :..•......•.; , t+ .
I �` � � IlMRO �. Br.H 8 �1��
\
i
.� .
z 1 f. 4• "R7"��'�' �t 4
\ 1� N 1� �.
J.3�� . .,;� i � nv. <��O �a y c e�'.,;�. t" ��
r� � - ` ' b' >.f.? `�
r �/� . s
\ �j ��.� oo •. �I = ..
....... ....,.. .
1���'f' � , V i „_ �` �/i�R �. -yr O �� � " � p /
��a��I'����''. I AV H pw° `�� �9�p,� � 0 � - � � r. •��� ^/
L�..1 ` 1, i � `�,• �J^� � I I10. 1 �� 1
s .. . � -o �' r, �� �, �.y • ...: �-O t .
�If1 's 1'
,�A 11 �" ♦ �v wv. � � , ,h���a. t•Y,' y O�.r , ���'k �1 �
yC� �L (l��,Q . �".� ��. ` ___ OB�ONE o li� �E • ` ��; t.
� ' � R T�OYt11M1�� UN`4L �T1���� �/ 1\1... �Y.� J�.
R i
N�MlO -_Q�lES' 1
/��; � , �++1 6� ('�-� GA O�p .w•o' ua A � _ p '
� �C/�V ♦� �m ` Wt . � .� O ST.� s» SP ;�.
� �� EOTEM1-�` � ::�� �
�II �17'7 � • . �y • _....-,,,� ,.....: n ^ �' .n'n::
� ��' ; '�� � :. �I� IEL � AV � omevotir tl Wll�q. !L AUKL6 :�i� . _aA ./ \ �� ':
� • • ` .& t" � u '...f1�.:H.. .;t,.....�.c..,-. �,
.�. �� .
Regaading the letter of 1�a,y 28. 1970, from the Department of �'inance.
' We the undersigned believe that Highland Parkwa� should be reaurfaced as '
was suggested, but we do not feel that it should be widened at any tima J �
� eliminating the need for new curbing, which is now in good condition.
, The beauty of the street would be marred and many beautifvl treea would have
� to ba removed, Widaning thia etreet would only make it a racaway and our �
children would be in danger.
, a � � 7� 7 �, '
/i��L, � ��Z�G�� � - , r
� t r ���� / � ^�
� , � ����.
J � , ����
� �' ���'� ,.
' � �
� W , / � � l r�
� / /�.1�� /7 �S / d
.�,• ° �° < �
,/�, . o� ��-. '� 7 , �7 o s /y � � .
� ,
^w�.�'- - w��' � • � 1 � g � �,�" � J° .
"� �,�'w►-Q � / ?� :����' _
� ` � � � �� ��"i����''�
�`��/[/] ' � �� �`Z:(��"`,
�- .
. �, ` � ' �
`?j.��` �f�-�' ,� �
/� �
, s l� , � j � �� � t �.� �
� ���� ��� ��
��
�1�,�,t,o �- � �.�, � � a , �� � �. P�
�� ��
�� �.\ �-� �`�rs - � � ,�d ��� �� / �� �1�h-./,��`` _
g , r
, / /���/' �
��� . • j�,.�� `
���
/�s_/ '
i��r,V�' ✓O✓r ��r `� ..
.
�s� `?�, , � ��r�.��6�`�'
� � � 1 . .�� P-�
. , � � :� � � ��
� ,� j� ���
- + ��� L�u� � � �
��� � �
� .
�
��Jy � /
,,
. �,
G�,� �� ', '�
� ` y,a
Regarding the letter of May 2g, 1970, from the Departmsnt of �'inance„ _
' We the undereigned believe that Highland Parkway should be reaurfaced ae wss
eu�geated, but we do not Feel that it ah ould be �ridenmd at any time �limina,ting
the naed for new curbing� which ie now in good condition� Tha beauty of th•
etreet would b• marred and many beautiful treee would have to be rsmovsd.
Widening thie street wot�d only make it a raceway and our ahildren sould be in
danger,
.
1T�3��/'.� � o� 7�.�. �2�.��►-0 ��`/ 7,��
�7�2 ��J� . .�i � �-. f��� � `
l 7 � �Q�-� l 7° �
��
!�- . ,� i�� , � �. ,� �
,
j�� Z ��r � �T/l�s �c� �� ,��d f 7 a�.
� 6 �.� -7'�1,� �- �7'�'j,� ,���,� ����
��c�8 ��� ��%�� ,���� 1��'�-
�
�, , ,��?c�.a, � � �.��ti ; - �'G 7�
. � . ����-� � �� �
� �� �° ��s�
�
�,�%��,� ��� , � , . I� ��
�
`�-� �� �1�� /�-��-�. ��� '�� �
a �r�� , -
-�-��• 1� � o , _ C'�r
�%��. �- �� .� � � /6'��� � .
"i,��i� �� o � ` /�o� � �
_ - �-�--t
� fG o 6 .
_ . �, . GO" � ���� t �
�( `r� � . �S�'l � c�
��� �-,�� ���d
�. � �� . � �, * ,� ��--
�;►�, � ��. � �- �rn� �-� _ , l ��� � �� o
� � � -
�- ��'`-° ..�,�.��.�- %��c� ���,�-.�c �
I�� ���
Y
.� � � .`
- `/' / V �' � �I�/ �`��/' `i��c�/"t . .
!G 3 � '' �'
l ����
,^
' �
,/�',�Zc.�' ��} - ( �o�/ �
� � r� w ����
�-�,�sx„_, 1 —t � , ,� ,,
/i���jJ '
�' �.�r/�- � ! /
. � , ���� ,
�C� �`(�(1�� . � .� + i� �"1 l�
� k
� ���`�- 7 7 /
� °�
� 1��'-� � � 7 1 ��..�-�, ,
v��� �I�� .� ��> �o�S
� �
_�
,
�;� - i�i � � �-�' 4� �� _
_ .
�= . `� � 7 . ��►
227-9505
' O'NEILL, BURKE AND O'NEILL LTD.
ATTO R N EYS AT LAW
6O WE5T FOURTH STREET
SAINT PALJL, MINNE50TA 55102
JOHN B. BURKE, JR. �JLIIIQ 16, 1970
JOSEPH T. O'NEILL f_
PATRICK H. O'NEILL � ��'.
�.{ ;"_
JON R. DUCKSTAD Cn� ,�,,.��
.�.,�.� - �t1
�_� �� �
- � �tl
�'"i 1 � �
'„rr.� :-
:�,-,
' --cl '
-= �"t .
Mayor and Council � �, ,�
City of Saint Paul
City Hall
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
Re: Preliminary Order No. 247313
Improvement Highland Parkway
City Project No. P-0502
Dear Mayor McCarty, Mrs. Butler and Gentlemen of the Council:
I am enclosing for your perusal prior to the Council
meeting of today 's date a copy �of a petition signed by resi-
dents of the City living on Highland Parkway in the area
generally described in your preliminary order approved Febru-
ary 3, 1970 . This petition represents 95� of the affected
homeowners on Highland Parkway, who are against this improve-
ment.
We shall be presenting at the Council meeting today
an orderly discussion of the reasons why this improvement must
be defeated.
Thank you for your consideration in this matter.
Very truly yours,
�"� �. o ��.�.�c
Patrick H. O'Neill
PHO:vt
Enc.
' �0��ITY OF;i
� * - �
4 .i
. O �n ^
? ,,b / ' �
�y� ....:" h0 � z
i
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Capital of Minnesota
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS
234 Ciiy Hall & CourF House 55102
I��
July 27, 1970
Honorable Charles P. McCarty
and Members of the City Council
Room 347
BUILDING
Re: P-0502 HIGHLAND PKWY. -
Cleveland Ave to Snelling Ave.
Rehearing on street improvements.
Gentlemen and Madam:
On July 14, 1970, a public hearing was held on the advisability
of improving Highland Parkway by street widening, new curbs and
bituminous overlay. The Council laid the matter over indef%nitely
to permit the Water Department to investigate the report of low
water pressure and to suggest solutions.
The Water Dept. has completed its investigations and has found
a solution and plans to have the situation corrected by about Oct. l, 1970.
I recommend that the Council schedule a rehearing on these matters
for Sept. l, 1970, and instruct the Finance Department to send new
notices to the affected property owners.
Very truly yours,
�\-...� - .� �' � . n �1�---�
Robert F. Spra�
Commissioner of P lic Works
RFS/CLT/gb
����t.....�
l-
� �
� A1 Olson -
� For your files.
Marie Larson
for Co�emissioner Levine
7/30/70
Iidward J . Gordon
1902 Iii ghland Park�aay
Saint Paul , "�innesota 55116
June 12 , 1�70
])epartment of Finance ,
City of Saint Paul
113 Court ilouse Bldg.
Saint Paul , Tfinn. 55102 P.e : 1'ile 17493 , Page 21
Gentlemen :
I wish to acknowledge your letter of notification dated
'iay 28 concernin� the �roposed improvement of Fii.ghlanc?
Parkway . I presentl.v o�ti�n pr�perty on , anc� reside at
1�02 I(ig}iland Parkiaay.
I ��Trite this letter to state my opposition to the proposal ,
inasmuch as I will not he ahle� to attend the hearing tvhich
is scheduled for June 16 .
It is true that the cost anci temporary incanvenience of the
proposed construction f.orm a part of my objection to the
improvement . I am reluctant to endorse anything wfiicli adds
to the steadily increasing cost of m�intaining my property;
I am not particularly pleased by the prospect of a construc-
tion coripany onerating in my front yard for a month or more .
Yet , vi.et,�eci objectively, T must admit that these are short-
terr,t factors . I am more concernecl by the permanent conse-
quences of the proposed improvement .
Specifically , I opposed the proposal because I anticipate
a clecline in the safety and cauality of the neighborhood in
which I live .
I helieve that i.mprovement of the roadway and widening of
Fiighland Park:��ay will resizlt in a marked increase in traffic
on thi.s street , and in higher speeds . ]3ecause liighland Fark-
way is a pr�tected , one-way thoroughfare soeeds in excess
of posted limits are encour.aged. �'ehicles frec�izently move
on tfiis street at sneeds of 4� mph . and hi�her . i have small
children, and this situation is of great concern to me .
Thizs , tahile I do not <<lelcome an assessment on my property,
or the temporary closing of mv street , I must enter strenuous -
objection to any action by the City which �aill cause my
� Page 2
neighborhood ultimately to become noisier and less safe .
It is my hope that the needs and clesires of those who live
on tli.ghland Park�aav will he served in this case . It was
ti•�ith dismay that I� noted a recent Council a�proval of an
additional liquor license for the IIi�}�land l'illage area - -
despite the apparent ohjections of Ilighland Park residents .
Actions such as this ].end significance to the position of
those who are convinced that government is no lonQer respon-
sive to the needs of peonle �ahom government is meant to serve .
In closing, I ask that t}iis letter be includeci in the re-
cord of }iearin� proceedings on this proposal .
� inc e ly,
.
Fdwa d J. ;ordon
July 2g, 1970
Hon. Mrs. Rosalie L. Butler,
Gommissioner of Fin�ance.
Dear Madam:
The City Counc3l tod.�,y re uled a public
heaxing for Saptember 1., , the 1 Order for the
improvement of Highlan kwa,y m Cl and Avenue to
Snelling Avenue w'hich s laid o inde nitely on J'uly
14, 1q70. Wil1 you p e se send no es to affeeted property
owners?
ery truly yours,
City Clerk
AO�hp
J�ine 16 1970
Hon. Robert: F. Sprafka
Comsr. of P�ablic Worka
Dear S i_r:
The City Co!<ncil today id �ver t ul. th the Final Arder
fo.r i�pr�vement of HI ND PARKWAY ram Cleveland Ave. t�
Snellin� Av�. (City pr ct P-0502), under P.O. 2�+7313 approved
Febru&ry 3, 1�70.
Very truly yours,
City Clerk
n�
f�I�HARD A. SCHNARR C I T Y O F S A I N T >P A U L ANTHONY J. CREA
CHIEF ENGINEER � DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Cepita) of Minnesota
DEPARTMENT OP PUBLIC WORKS
234 Ciiy Hell .& Court House .55102
ItOBERT F:-PETERSON
Commissioner` .
O
i����'�:,«'_i.:. `�.'s� a-:�'f��
.�._ ..... ..._. �•f �1�.....! 4 .�dJ.�,�.I�,��.�.�Llu
� . i
� - . .-,. . : .�..:.a .
.. ..: �. . ... ..... L ....._E,'.
.. ....t.. ...,._._....
��,. - f , l�, a tT.�l.'.J ') „
k;c.. —. ��_. � .. � i .
_. ��.w:k, �� ��r�, ��;�_�i '_' !",y-�
.
J�:t.�' . _._.
_.�i. ... a".i:!.ii�i�."�.'LJ. �:1C+;"(;:Sa+'.'.'y.�1'fl tl:"E:' t�e? ���:'�*1:E.Lf'1ft�`;�?' f�8�"k '1i':w+...3 i�. �.�x.. _ r..
.. t. ..x
i.:i ..� ....._<�.L: . ��ULJ . IT;):,....V��:". .•.L�. . .,i..i'_�.. . ..k'��.. �4��..�`�wtir ;�`�"h?.f.'.0..��: .W�..'��.��1�
� - ;
s,z �,. ._'t?a _..�.�_�.... 1�:�C .:;.G �.. ,.;r',�.��..�t 4;�'�°T"�'!�@, �dY�:C�.F:'�'� ��]°C?..,..,,,.s9.�"
,. ,
, . . -.
. . ..ru. .��� i ?--, r.,:�.,r�:,,: .
..'Y�,��rd .. • . ..
> ._ _ ,. � a , �,� "�J,vr .a �_�'I!f.
Lt�i�i�,i.��:i iub��.:
M A,r�
.. ,,, w',.r',l4E.t,-.��_Ost�'yvI`?.:(.vL:�!a 1.41ut",.kf ,?i.t.�.C3.4"i:)
y • ��, '
_., xl;��'�"l lit, +-'"; ���..�;�r..6(,,,�
.Jtc �)E3�.:i..Y _. 'r. � �Y�!'�
. -.
�i.«i��.::: �i.�.2. ,.L. �:,;:i ,r,.. �.�i.i�;.LEa11'i. ."�:..'.. .r'l.';�(;:� :�1��
.�'.:.iE.`. �J�_.l.:."Y '"i. . :3;,..� ,iJ.ti�F:. ., L �:..:t." l;Cj:3'1.,;i �'i�
;i:'?@S' ,. ..:�. ,�+
--.L;��(�_�:1+.�'
�:��i.u��:�.� `��<:�rA<�:i�_.r�:
---_.. .�._ .....__ ,..
±:°;�tt'i-rr?c�ttxc;t i'���^��x-�;� �'�r��e����►,���� ':�,. �.
W!'L�.I�:L�W.I. �.1RfAVi aJT�f�:�C�.i�.�! '..^.JA.:.!„L.FJ � 1..'�rl� l�l� i.�•.,�
_ I
'������y �:'�{i
� _. r ^.
� �
F
..r:i�'a1,7fff3.'�'�C'd: T4PC7��x"�i`i;!�' fiS:9�".'F+.`31�lA'C1f.,'$ f4?"L! �'J�,'w^'E"f�. C"7'v: 1.1:�C*s t'r7t-�.'';� a., a _�
.��'. , .... . � �
;:Y G't�.G:�.I] ��.'" i.��i , C1 i�"� ,:.,�}: ;a�
.._,�5�_ :��....�..._., ..-__...._.
�t=� l�t���t.�ent4a]- � �.3� pex as��$�able �oot� ,
"C„ �?es., G�mmver����. � Ttte�uc��ri�A $6.4� per a��e��a��.e t'�ot .
;
..
Y
July 1�+, 1970
Hon. Robert F. SpraPka
Comsr. of Public Works
Buildin�
Deax Sir:
The City Council tod�y opted a ma an laying ov�r indtfinitely
the Fina1 Order to imp e HIGHI,ANll ARKWAY from Cleveland Ave. to
Snellin� Ave. (City Pro t P-0502 nder P.O. 2�+?313 e�pproved
Feb. 3, 1970.
Very truly yours,
City Clerk
�
_�_
1�3.v�wti�.v�:
c;caz:r,.rete �xiver� (6" thick) �7.;�G per �qu,ax�� ;�a,x•d
uC;:;Cf"G,''�'if'. �'t.VG'`u ���� `�2�.C��S� yi}���1� C1E'.T f3C�'k�c'�LY"'c'' �►'l3,iC�
+°A,�:ta.�.hwd. �.c� a �.�tt�r d.a.t�d. �a'e�. 11, ].97C1 �`rozn the `:�at�x• ��pt �r:i�L.
t�i� �z.:rr�rxt rate�s for wrater service connect�.��as�.
"�'ot�.T'S V�T.y �x"ti�..�r,�
1tO�JEY'�'. �'. ���'��.'�'€3i?:'.
�;C3�CT�SS�.QT1�'P tS.�i' .r'1::;:�,f C 'v<`Oi I°:u
1�.. ,�'�'ii.i;'ii�l>�
��.-L�i�cl�sr�i_�L-;
cc: �usr�h -.:�. ,-ii'tche;l.1
{:.5.. `�:''Iac'����s�z:�
�. �a:�. �:°�nr��rr�
..'i. �:c°rlha:x-c�.
��
�
t."._."_ `:i
,�
. _,�
,�.:,:��-.�,:T�
y..:ws-��
�