The URL can be used to link to this page

251143 o�.i s�citr c�t � � O�RDINANCE �� , � ' COUNCIL FILE NO ��"" PRESENTED BY i ORDINANCE NO.—�� An ordinan�e am�nding �h� Zoning Code, Cha.pters 60 to 6�+, inalusive, of �he �aint Paul begi�lative Code,pertainin� to �Tse DistriQt�, �Ieigh� Di�t�iet� and Rezoning of ct�rtain propertie� in the City of �aint Paul, as amend�d. THE COUNCI�, 4F �HE CI�'Y 4�' SAINT PA�TL DOEa ORDAIAT s Section 1. �hat th� �oning Code, �hapters 60 to 6�, inclu�ive, of �h� ,air�� Paul �egi�lative Code, pertaining ta Use Districts, Height I?i�trict� and Rezoning of aErtair� prop- erti�� in �he City of Sain� Pat�l, a� am�nded, be and the a�ame is hereby fur�her am�nded �o as to rezon� th� following des- cribed property frc�m "AN Residerttt� Distriat to "d�' Residence Distriet, to-wits . . T�ots 8, 9 and 1�, �lock 1, and �ot� 21, ��, �3, 2�+ and 25, Bloek �#, �aw�on�� 5th Addition to the City of Sa3.nt Paul Ram�ey Goun�y Minnesota; I �ots 1 througM 8, Bloak �, and Lot 7, Bloek 1, Daw$c�n�� 5th Addi�ion to the Gity of 3ai�t Paul Ramsey CouMty Minne�ota, �34-29 NW�, �e�tion �0-�g-22; � Lot� l6, 17, 38, 19 and 20, Bloak �F, Daw�ont� 5th Addition to the� City of Saint Pa�1 Ra�.sey Cot�r�ty Minne�o�a; situate on property loaa�ed on the w�st side of Arkwrigh� 5t�eet. extended be�we�n Tas� W��loctk Parkwa� and Soo �ine Railway, arid �he eaat �ide o� Edgen�ont S�treet between Ea�� T�VY��elock Parkway and Ea�t Hoyt Av�nue in �he �ity of Saint Paul. Secation 2. Thie ordinance shall take effeat and be in forae thir�y (�0� day� from and after its pas�age, approval and public�tion. �� ,��r ,::: j -;`��''�'�'�r�?; ' -f }� .�. �- -.f� . . ��,kf `� � �.) �: i1� ` ` ��' � �� f �A y �� sw � .. �. r � �� o��s�/u�: �� ''r��" NOV 2 5 1970 Yeas �°°� � �"f...___ _ . Pagaed by the Counci� . Butler ----- - � Carlson � Levine ` Tn Favor Meredith a C� Againat Sprafka Tedesco NOV 2 5 I��O Mr. President (McCart ) Appro A Ci Clerk Mayor �� • Form a�proved Corpora�ion Counsel By �1�M� PUBLISH�D ,�QV 2 $ 1970 �a a r�.ar � � O� DINAN' CE �� ' COUNCIL FILE NO PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO " ♦II 0s'dia�oe irn�l8g tl�! l.aa3.Ag a"odl, �t�ra 60 tv 6�, iaolasife, o! t�e Ssimt Le�e3t#i�nt a+a�sP�siai�t6 to '#ita , litigh� �iatri+�ta as�f �ese�i� ot •+er#a3�t� Pr�rtits ia t� �.�y ot ssfnt l�strt]►, as aa�ed+sd. 'l"A8 � �` � �iIl�' EiF �' !#�L D�A� #Y1t�AIX s Se�a�3c� 1. '1'�wtt � �iog �o+�, Cbap�trs 6�i to fi4, initlnai�rs, of t1�e �+aiat �'au3. #r�gi�ls�t�re Codt, �S�taiai�g to i�ar Dis�rials, li��et Di�ri�s a��d 'l�sao3a� o! o�stai�► pro�►- srti�s i�t tl� 1�1#� c�! i�tltr� �St�, ��r ��d, 1►r su�d � sa�r� is �l� i1�r�r ar��d so as to �r+�sa� t� in� d�s- orl.'b�d !�r t'ra� � I�s3�da�rr �rtrl.at to�l�esid�o� Di�a , � �r,t�t �s 8, 9 a�d lo, �q,a�e�c 1 snd L�L� ;�i, �, �3s '� a�'! 25, 81c�1c �, D�aa's �th �diti+�t to th� �2t� oi" �iat �s�l l�aas�r Qo�►t� 1t3an�sota; tioats 1 t�► 8, �oQic �, aae! E�art �, B��k 1, �aei��r gth �Additic�a to tl�s �it� +�3' S'�ai� ttdl �It�eT �onatT lli�esota, '43t?-8� �I�f}, ai�ttt�e� FE1-�-22; . I�ts 1i6� 17, 3$, �� md iK?, �lt�lc �, Al�tAt+a�� f�ion to t.l�e Cii� o! �t3�t� l�sl �tsuu�► � #3r�s�ota►# •i�st� o� �r� 3e�at•ad a� tl�e xs��r� s#� at J� ��t �s�a� �e� �st 1�estv�li� larl�iq�r a�d �o tr#��r�,, a�l 6� a�c •� �►f B�d�tt Sta�t b�rt� sit�Rt ti�rt2o�c !a� ssd �t� l�c� �v+�e ia tne �ity of Sa� la�l. �T�� t. �.� ordi�as�e�t �bail t�lce �!!'�� a� D� i� t+o�e d�s frv� aacl atter its �u��e, a�rov�l a� p�cDl3�atiee�a►. NOV 2 5 IJ70 Yeas Councilmen Naya Paeeed by the Counc;� Butler ��On Tn Favor Levine Meredith A�►� T�� NUV 1 7 ��0 Mr. Pre$ident (McCartY) APPmved: Attest: Cfty Clerk Mayor �� ;° Form s�proved Corpor�ion Couneel By _ ., 9 � � r � �`� � ' , 1 BOARD ' OF �'ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL - 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 � PHONE: 223-4151 - October 27, 1970 '" Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Dear Sir: This is written in response to the petitions of Philip W. Fitzpatrick to rezone from "A" to "C" Residence for the purpose of constructing an apartment development properties on the west side of Arkwright Street extended between East Wheelock Parkway and Soo Line Railway, and the east side of Edgemont Street between East Wheelock Parkway and East Hoyt Avenue, and noted in detail by the legal descriptions on file. �j ��V Zoning File �k6984 was first heard on June 4, 1970, at which time it was laid over indefinitely in order to obtain additional information. This petition was heard again on October l, 1970, along with two additional petitions involving adjacent parcels of land. Before a quorum was present, informal discussion took place on the matters. During this time, the sufficiency of the petitions was questioned because of the fact that the land under consideration was divided into three contiguous parcels for petitioning and processing. The staff reported that a legal opinion has been requested from the Corporation Counsel. It was decided to act on the petitions and let the City Council settle the question of sufficiency. When a quorum was present, the staff report was given. It disclosed that a petition is pending to vacate East Idaho Avenue from Edgemont Street to Wheelock Parkway, Arkwright Street from the railroad right.-of-way north to West Idaho Avenue, and the alleys in Blocks 1 and 4, Dawson's 5th Addition. If the vacations are approved, the combined site would have an area of approximately 140,000 square feet, permitting a development of about 140 units under "C" Residence zoning. The staff noted that the original Comprehensive Plan recommended low-density for this area but that this recommendation has been reconsidered because of soil conditions unsuitable for single-family dwellings. The site is vacant lying 5 feet below the grade of Wheelock Parkway, and 15-20 feet below the grade of the railroad right-of-way. Multiple-family structures exist several blocks southwest but single-family houses border the undeveloped area immediately surrounding the subject site. The report noted that a previous rezoning attempt for this property was denied. Mr. 0'Toole, attorney for the petitioner, stated that other apartment projects have been approved for the area and that the soil conditions on the property make the use feasible only for an apartment development. In considering the amendments, the Board noted that the Comprehensive Plan's recommendation for this area had been reconsidered because of the soil conditions. Subsequently, a motion was made to recommend approval of all three petitions subject to the conditions that: 1) the petitions are declared sufficient, and 2) the City Council vacates the streets and alleys. The motion carried unanimously. Very truly yours, � ��'�Z , ��,,,-Z�.�.�C.'Lj'� PETER J. MAI TTA PJM:gaf Secretary, Board of Zoning PLR �l ��l � �r,: L�a� Z. F. �k6984, 7037, and 7038 � �� = O t .. ... . . . . ��..... , , � 1_ �. , E � � ` � �' i � ' , � ' - - 1 . 1 � a • - DEPARTMENt OF FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA 113 CourF House,65102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner � LOUIS H. MeKENNA, Depufy Commissionsr Phone:223-4646 May 7, 1970 , To the Council � City of Saint Paul ' Gentlemen: � I have checked the attached peCition of Philip W. Fitzpatrrick, filed in the matter of rezoning, Lots 1 through 8, Block 4, and Lot 7, Block 1, Dawson's Fifth Addition, 030-29 N.W. �, Section 20, Township 29, Range 22. The property is located west � ' of Arkwright Street between Wheelock Parkway and East Hoyt Avenue, from a Class "A" Residence Distxict to a Class "C" Residence District, and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours very truly, � / i_1 �' . ,� „ ,�.� w . �'_�•4!!vV=`�--';'�-' '`� '� , � f• � 3ames J. Dalglish /=-.�.�v `/Commissioner of Finance Re: X-893 c.c. Mr. Ames N. R. Heiden � Fr.ontage:- 897e Parcels Eligible - 18 � • • Parcels Signed - l.2 or 66-2/3� Needed - 12 or 66-2/3% ..� _..�...,.,--._..e_.._.�.. '__,__ • � - , "" ,�.w._ ,� �� Y_ , '� :, ,. � _.�`�.,�'� - ; _.....�._ �_._ .._...._.._.__..._... _.,..._ � � � � � i/ � ' • CITY OF SAI1�^T PAUL, hiIie?tirESQTA � 'o��` � �� ^�� . ,• �'' i•�m�TT�hj �`� A�tENp C}iAPTEIi.S 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (7.ONING) �CODE �, . �� : Note: The signer should appraise himsel'f of the uses permitted under the new classi- � ' fication before signing this petition. For further information about the . rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) . nate: Februar� 10,19 70 r TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall ' City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of • t�wo-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of SOqo or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) Lots 1 thru 8, Bl�ck 4, and Lot 7 , Block 1, Dawsonts 5th Addition. ,,`Q�t2_-�'?d.�t.:;� '��ec.�(7-'29=2�. `A�p. ,390 East Wheelock Pkwy. from � �t Res i denti al District to t C � Residential District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following; � (describe briefly the proposed facility) FOY' eontruetio:� Of ari apartment building. RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Subject Property; " 7 1 Dawson� s 5th Add. 8,9 " wso � a 5th Ad d. 030 29 AT.Pt. � Sec. 20-29-2� 02J � 1 -29�22 � S a 1 ` � - - . 020 � & S .�:t�, � Se��20-29-22 � � � - _ �i'�- ' 4 Dawson� s 5th Add. ' 9 thr . - �'l�=-' 4 Dawson� s 5th Add. ' � ' 1 , ; w I � � � a � State of Minnesota_ ( � County of Ramsey � ss � � r,Rral r3 T,,, Ok�ne:�k�i being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �png pages• , that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately �ollowing each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of-this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so descr' . Subsci•ibed and sworn to before me <'++'�``� , � � , i s ' ��i? d a y of '� � t y,<� � ,��---�--�- � � � � � G . � �� Address; 64� egt HOy't AVA. � �� '� � � � Telephone No.489-6641 � Not ry' Pub ic, R msey County, Minn. � My commission ex��.res Approved as to form 1/4/65 ? t. , ; r,,�� ;t Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 �attryf F'i' �'��:�:, . •: �ty Mutn P V Comm' ; • . ' 1�. t�'!1 � � ......._._..... . - . � �4 . �+s� ;� f . .. i -.. � �� , ,.....__ -' s�. ._.. - , , ,f`� '� _ ._... .. , �--.- . �y � � ""', � , . _l,�,`�_ ._ �� ,, � , . . . ; � _ �� , _.__ _.._ f . _.__ ____-_ ____ � __ __ �_ ___ � - .. _.._�_ _____. .. _.._...._.__ � _ . .__...__ri.._._.�_..�� c> n ��.l�' � .e,. Y Y � ' , • � . CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA �] r�� ,' , I / ' , PETI�ION TO AMEND CHAP'rERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE _ � c3 !��. � ��, „ Note; The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi -- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. .` (Please type or print) �ate:Feb�'tta r►y 10� 1970 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Purs.uant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) LO t8 8� 9� ].0� Block l, and Lota 2� thru 25, Block 4, Dawson�s 5th Addition App. 1626 Edgemont Street from �A� Residential nistrict to ►�� Residentiel Dxstrict, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) FOT con$truction Of 8II apartment building RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Subject Property; �- �0 t „ t �" , r dd. � e � Vartmann &'8� 3 " " c� Walter J. Vartmann 6' 7 3 " " 1 th ` �, ` ` 5 n a 1 t u �- A s s Lendwa 3 n p . 1 hru - a -� 18 1 n n � 7 n n � rlene A � ers 7 2 " " �� -E.�� .�.�� za,�.�s � 0. A. Asaen �' ' 7 1 " " �Shirle Ann Horri an � ' 8 1 " " � _ �.�� c�' ,, � f.', AUG �� : _.�r ..., l�� i� t� 8t3�r�D - -- _..__�__...__ State of Minnesot��r ssu�� i�n��n. �� , r �t� _�� County of Ramsey ( � �i �.5. 4erald J. Okoneaki being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �ng pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed ' immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed nd sworn be ore me � � t 's �� ay: o . � �, Address: 6 West Hoyt Ave. Telephorie No. 489-6641 Notary Pu lic, R msey County, Minn. My commission ex ires fi��h �r'jt��',) Approved as to form 1/4/65 Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI .�/5/65 w � , 4 ;� � ' ' � „ � �� , ,� , • � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA �� i / PETITION fi0 AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE T� �\ , Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- �� fication before signing this petition. For further information about the : rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date; Februery 10,19 70 TO THE HONORABLE MA�OR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) Lots 1 thru 8, Block 4, and Lot 7, Block 1, Dswsonts 5th AdditiOri. �'Q3€�r�'N.�If.'�. ,-S'e:c�;.''1t7-'29=2�._„'�'pP• ,390 FaBt WheelOCk Pkwy. from tA� Rea�dential District torC� Residential District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) FOI' contruction Of aYi apartment build3.ng. RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BIACK ADDITION Subject Property; ` 7 1 Dawson�s 5th Add. 8,9 " �rs �s 5t Add. 030 29 N.W. Sec. 20-29-22 020 -29�2� � S a 0� & S -29-22 , -�� ____ i� � � /'�'.- ' 4 Dawson� s 5th Add. _ , . - �l�-�' 4 Dawson�s 5th Add. State of Minnesota ( County of Ramsey � ss �'�e,+Al A T,, nkonesk3_ being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of One pages• ► that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so descr' . Subscribed and sworn o bef e me ` is � �� day of � -°� Address: 6 est Hoyt Ave. rt � Telephone No.489-6541 Not ry Pub ic, R msey County, Minn. My commission ex res Approved as to form 1/4/65 FGI 1/5,/65 r'" `' �• D`�!�`'"E Office of the Corporation Counsel yptNy p�• Kams��. �:.nty M�nn c� �Comm,.; s,�.. � r 1�. 19'71 - _,_.�,�.,__,_„w,_,,,,,....,.>_-. _ �... _. . � �'� � --� `" ., rr� �: _ ' � . ' ; ; f , G� U��" "" s r1'\�j �-�, �J � i�,�:s ..�..�2...� . `+i� .._ ?� • `+�'� � 11 � ♦ � • '�/ �F�O� �� • ' � ` � , CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA � �I� �� . . PE{TITION TO�AMEND CHAP'rER,.S 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE � - _ Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- • fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. , (Please type or print) �at e:�`ebm�.a:�g-.I{1}197 0 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Purs.uant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of ' the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) Lots 16 thru 20 Blook 4, Da�aon�s 5th Addition App. 1590 Edgemont Street from tAt Reside '�i�l District to �C� ReRir�Ant District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the�ollgwing: (describe briefly the proposed facility) FOP conatructioa OP 811 apartment building RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BIACK ADDITION Subject Property; 1-8 Phili W F ts a • � - ddition Walter Var a Daw � ddition e _ f ddition -%rz�-�.-�-� _ '3 � ddi t 3 on � 5 3 � ddition �pl� , St. Paul & Ss►ul ,�/..� p20 ` � Di ec �i"Es te R/W • _�9_22 pre ecessor i interest Soo Line Railroad Company The Soo Line is neither f r or against the proposal and si ns onl for the ur ose that the matt r can be brou ht to heari . ` �°,'; _ i s : State of Minnesota ( ��` �' County of Ramsey � ss Geral d T_ n�,n��gi being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of ona pages; that the parties described above are' the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. � Subscribed and sworn to b ore me � t �s � day �o , 1 Address: 649 �te� oy� Ave. Telephorie No. 9_6641 Nota y lic, Ram y ounty, Minn. My commission expi s m'�'�� ,� '\C('�i Approved as to form 1/4/65 Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 �<�Harry E. Morshall �iTY o Albert B. Olson .City/Clerk and ,�.*w�; Counci,l Recorder Commissioner of Re,piatration � f , . , � .� ; -=-'r�' �5 ,�s - m ^c OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK � CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS 886 City Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 55102 Attgtist 21., 1970 Zoning Board, Camo�erce Bldg. Gentlemen: The City Council referred to you for reeoanmendation the attached petition of Shirley Ann Horrigan and Philip W. Fitzpatrick to rezone Lots 8, 9 and 10, Block l, and Lots 21, 22, 23, 24 and 25, Block �+, Dawson's 5th. Add.ition, located on the east side of Edgemont St. between Wheelock Parkway and East Hoyt Avenue, to "C" Residence Diatrict. Very ruly yours, `_� , / i I City . ierk hp L� ZpNtN �, FILE � f �;: � � �' *• . - � , � � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE � � CITY OF SAINT PAUL ' MINNESOTA I 13 Court House,55102 _- ROSALIE L. BUTLER, Commissioner Phone:223-4646 �ugast 21, 1970 To the Cot�acil City oE St. Paul Gsatleaea: I have cheeked the attached petitioa of St�irley A�a Horriga�a asd l�ilip Y. Fitzpatriek, filei in the �atter of rezoaing, Lots 8, 9 aad 10, Block 1, aad Lots 21, 22, 23, 24 aad 25, Blmck 4, DaWSOn's 5th Additioa. The proper�y is located oa tlae east side of Edge�oat Street betireea Hheelack Parkway sud Sast Hoyt Aven�e, frou a Class "A" Residence District to a Class "C"' Sesidence District, aad fiad that said petitioa ia sufficient. Youss very truly, , ° �EZ��z.e��l� Aosalie L. Butler Co,ais:iq��aan�� /r � Sc: X-941 c.c. Mr. Mes �,,1� y+- �� +' �: ,�i � � N. R. Heidea t�li �f: !`� _. �. U �ttrs. �utler AUG 2 �— i�7s� Fraatage: 75Z Parcela Eligible -� 23 \' C�� '��N�N� ��Rp Parcels Sigaed - -ll� or 74 � Saint Paui, Minnes�' Needed - 16 or 66-2/3Z �� ;-___ ,.3s. I�.-- � Z � e�� 0 �, ' ` .Harry E. Marshall �,z7 „ Albert B. Olsoo City Clerk and �,�w F; Council Recorder Commissioner of Regtistrattio� �, 2 o a,e::; .� 6 _�:'°�.�F'.� a5 vs ° �r OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK -� CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS S86 Cdty Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 55102 August 27, 1970 Zoning Board Com¢nerce Bld�. St. Paul Gentlemen: The City Council referred to you for recommendation the attached petition to rezone Lots 16, 17, 18, 19 and 20, Block 4, Dawson's Fifth Addition to the City of Saint Paul,located on the east side of Ed�emont St. between E. Idaho and E. Hoyt Aves., to Class "C" Residence District. Very truly yours, ,�- , � , ��y�L City �1 rk G� ng �..C..�;.�`�' . , ,� �4.� ,�--, --- _ _ � � " DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE � � ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL • MINNESOTA I 13 Court House,55102 ROSALIE L. BUTLER, Commissioner Phons:223-4646 Augnst 27, 197A To t�e Co��cil City �f Saint Paul Geatleseg: I have recheaked the atta�h�d petititin af Phili� W. Fitapatricl�, filed in tme m�ter of resonia�, �t: 16, 17, 1�, 19 aad 2A, Bloek 4, Dawson's Fifth Ad�itioa to the City of Saint Pa�l, 8a�ey Coa�t�, �4imneaata. The prolert�t is located �a fihe eaat side mf 8dgeaox►t �tree� betweea Ea�t I�aho and gast Hopt A�saea, froen a Class "A" Re�idenae District to a Clas� "C" Besidenc� Dis• trict, and fiad �hat said petition is sufficieat. Ycara �ery traly, �� salit 1. Butler ��8��'�� File: %94A � a.a. Mr. A�ses 11. Et. Heiden M�cs. Be�tlar Fronta��: l0tt�; Parcels �ligi�le - 23 Parcels �i�n�d - 16 or 6�-1/2X l�eeded - Z6 or i6-2/3x �O ` June 4, 1970 BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION October 1, 1970 nlat ��iap ��32 Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 passed August 22, 1922, as amended to April 6, 1970. 6984 . . �:'';';:ti:�',�dT'S �7A'�1E ; Philip W. Fitzpatrick I—t X-893 . �;LP,SSI"r ICA`I'ION . l A I Amendment 0 Appeal ❑ r'ermit LJ Other Rezone from "A" to "C" Residence for the �' � ' `�k?�''�' ' construction of an apartment buildii�g �+ , L')(:r',;i.��1J ; West side of Arkwright Street extended between East Wheelock Parkway and Soo Line Railway :; . .�i;�;A;. :iF�SC2IPTI0N : Lots 1-8, Block 4, and Lot 7, Block 1, Dawson's 5th Addn. , 030-29, N. W. '�, Sec. 20-29-22. �� P:�LS1;?JT 'LOrJItJG: "A" Residence '7 . PUR�UAN; T!J 7,oning Code Chapter: 64 Section: .06 F�arat�raph: �3 , ;;'I'AI"F ZNVESTIrATIQN � REPORT: Dats: 6/3/70 Bys CLS A. SUFFICIENCY: In a letter dated 5/7/70, the Co�rsnissioner of Finance declared this petition sufficient with the ownera of 89% of the frontage of the rezoned property has signed the petition and the ownera of 12 of a possible 18 descriptions of real estate within 100 feet having aigned. A cursory review of the petition revealed an error in the number of parcela eligible and the percentage of frontages signed for. A recheck by the Department of Finance corrected the figures to read: the petition is sufficient with the owners of 61% of the frontages to be rezoned having signed the petition and the owners of 12 of a possible 17 (70%) of the parcels within the prescribed 100 feet having signed the petition. However, the petition actually has the same signature as the owner of the necessary frontage and the owner of the described parcels necessary for a sufficient petition. B. HISTORY: None for this site. C. PROPOSED USE: Construction of an apartment building. D. AREA: The property consists of three parts totaling about 47,000 square feet. E. AREA ZONING: The immediate area is zoned "A" Residence although the property across the railroad right-of-way from this site is pending "C" Residence. Multiple-family zoning exists one-fourth mile and over to the southwest. r. COMPREIIENSIVE PLAN: The Comprehensive Plan calls for aingle-family use of this site and the surrounding area. G. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is vacant and about 5 feet below the grade of Wheelock Parkway. The railroad right-of-way abutting on the southeast. is about 15-20 feet above the level of this site. H. AREA CONDITIONS: Post-war low-density residences exist north of Wheelock Parkway, along the south edge of the parkway and easterly across the railroad right=of-way. Multiple-family exists farther to the southwest. This immediate area northwesterly of the railroad is largely undeveloped. 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend � Approval � Denial Council Letter Dated: Moved by : McPartlin Yeas Nays 10/27/70 Gedler Date of Hearin Seconded by: Maietta Gauger g X Maietta 10/29/70 Secretary's remarks: x Mansur x Ames - Ch. Council Action x McPartlin (Alt.) Adkins (Alt.) Date Rutzick (Alt.) T30ARD 0�' ZONING REPORT AND ACTION October 1, 1970 '..'lat Map ��32 Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 - passed August 22, 1922, as amended to April 6, 1970. 7038 _ . ,_�i�'�1�d'i'``; NA'�fF:,' , Philip W. Fitzpatrick X-940 ' . , �.:[:'�,;'�T r"ICA'1'ION . [Y�_.. Amendment 0 Appe�l ❑ k'ormit � Other ,� . ; �?�::',J,:�I� ; Rezone from "A" to "C" Residence for the construction of an apartment building 4. L�)CATiON ; East side of Edgemont Street between East Wheelock Parkway and East Hoyt Avenue �. ;.�:!-;^�:. 7I�;CRTPTI�;1 ; Lots 16-20, Block 4, Dawson's 5th Addition -�� P:cLS1::�T ZOt12P1C,: "A" Residence 1 . �'ti'"tSiJA;dT TO 7oning Code Chapter: 64 Section: .06 F�ara�?raph: �.i . �_�'I'ACF� TNVESTI�ATION � R�PORT: Date: 9/9/70 By; CLS A. SUFFICIF.NCY: In A letter dated Auguat 27, 1970 the Commissioner of Finance ec are t e petition sufficient with the owners of 16 of a possible 23 (69�%) descriptions of real estate within 100 feet having signed the petition. B, HISTORY: None for this site. C. PROPOSED USE: Construct an apartment building. D. FRONTAGE AND AREA: This property has a frontage of 200 feet along Edgemont Street and an area of 25,000 square feet. NOTE: There is a petition pending to vacate East Idaho Avenue from Edgemont Street to Wheelock Parkway, Arkwright Street from the Railroad right-of-way north to West Idaho Avenue and the alleys in Blocks 1 and 4, Dawson's 5th Addition. If the City Council vacates these streets and alleys, the combined site would have an area of approximately 140,000 square feet, permit a develop- ment of 140 units if the property is rezoned to "C" Residence. E. AREA ZONING: The immediate area is zoned "A" Residence. Multiple-family zoning exists one-fourth mile and over to the southwest. F, COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: The Camprehensive Plan calls for single-family use of this site and the surrounding area. G. SITE CONDITICN S: The site is vacant and about 5 feet below the grade of Wheelock Parkway. The railroad right-of-way abutting on the southeast is about 15-20 feet above the level of this site. H. AREA CONDITI�IS: Post-war low-density residences exist north of Wheelock Parkw�y, along the south edge of the parkway and eastcrly acr.oss ttic rr�i.lroacl right-of-way. Multiple-family ex�sts farther to the southwest, This immediate area northwesterly of the railroad is largely undeveloped. `�� BOARD ACTION: To Reco�nend �X Approval � Denial Council Letter Dated: Moved by : McPartlin Yeas Nays 10/27/70 Gadler Seconded by: Maietta Gauger Date of Hearing x Maietta 10/29/70 Secretary's remarks: x Mansur x Ames - Ch. Council Action x McPartlin (Alt.) Adkins (Alt.) Date Rutzick (Alt.) MTNtJTES OF THE P[IBL�C HEARING BEF012E THE BOARD OF ZONING ` on Thursday, June 4, 1970, at 2:00 P,Mo PRESENT: Messrs. Ames, McPartlin, Ms�.etta, and riansur of the Board, and k:essrs. Brown and Soxenson, Mrs. Frantzen, and rfiss Sperr of the �taff. Messrs. Gauger and kutzick of the Board arrived for the meeti_ng durin� this m�tCer as noted in the minutes. PHILIP W, FI'PZPAZ'RICIC: A petition to rezone from '4A" to "C" Residence for the construction of �n Apartment buiZding properey located on the west side of Arkwright Street extended betza�en Eas+t Wheelock Parkway and Soo Line Railwsy. Mr. Sorenson noted �hat the petitioner does not own all the nroperty that is included in this rezoning. The Board looked over the pe�ition form. Mr. Sorenson summarized the stafi report noting that a review of ti�e petition revealed an error in the numbex of parcels eligible and the percentage of frontages signed for. �► recheck by the Finance Departmen� indicated the figur�s should read: the geta�ion is sufficient with the owners of 61% of the frontages to be rezoned having sig,nzd the petition and the owners o€ 12 of � pa,sibl2 17 (7�70) oiE the parcels within the prescribed L00 feet h.aving sxgned tt�e petition. Aowever, tl�e petition actu�2ly has the same signstcure �s �he owner of the necessary frontage and the owner of the described parcels necessary far a sufficient pQtiti�ne The property cansisCs of thxee parts to�alin� about 47,000 square feat. The immediate are� is zoned "A" Residence although the property across the railroaci righ+t-of--way from this site has been pending "C-1" Residence. However, at Council this morning that p�tition was denied. Multiple-family 2oning exists one-fourth mile and over to the southwest. The Comprehensive Plsn calls for singLe-family Vse of this site and the surrounrling area. The site is vacant and about 5 feet b�low the grade o£ Wheelock Parltway. The railroad right-of-way abutt3.ng on the southeast ia about 15-20 feet above the Zevel of this si�e. Pos�-war Lasa--density residences exist north of Wheelock Parkway, alnng the south edge of the parkway ar_d easterly across the railroad r�.ght-of-way. �Iultipl��f.amily exists farther to the southwest. This i�aediat� area northwesterly af �he railroad is largely undeveloped. In conclusion, Mre Sorer�son noted that na information has been submiCted on why ehia site caanot be used for single-f$mily residences. This rezoning ca�ld be detrimental to adjacent prop�rties, �nd may lead to future ettempts at rezoning. This rezcr�ing, if granted, would conatitute spot zoning. Mr. Maietta asked wYaether the street w�.il b� graded; Mr, Sorenaon said thst is always a possib�.lity, alth�ugh xt seems unlikely. Ae noted that the smallest af the �hxee parcels aa�uld be large en�ugh only for a sfng?e-family residence. The intent of thas re•z.oreirzg is iail�nawia since twa of the property owners siid not sign the pe�ition. 30-35 units could b� b�ailt on the oth�r parcel, rir. Maietta qnesti.oned the stree� frontage of the propert}� as _�,� PHILIP W, FITZPATRICK (6/4J70) (Continued): required for suyficiency. Mr. Sorenson expa�ined tha� the alley is 20 fe�t wide, and doubted tha� it would constitute frontage. Representing the petirioner was Gerald Qkoneski, whn noted that plans sre to vacate Idaho Avenue; Cherefore, frontage would be to Wheelock Parkway. Part of the property is owned by the State of Mfnnesota, but the pet�tioner wi1Z attempt to acquire that parcei. Mr. Ames suggested t� the repres�ntative that the petitioner would have a much better chance of rezoning this propprty if. all these problems are resolved before the Zoning Iioard has to m�ke a rec�une�dation. Mro Ukoneski replied that he feels �he vacating of Ydah� Avenue wilL �ave no Uesring on the frontage since the froat-age is on Wheelock Parkway. Re noted that the land is not suitable for single-family development since it is a swsmp 1and. The tax b�se on apa�ements would be h�gher �han fo� o�e-family homes. Mr. Maietta concurred that the soil there is t�rrible. r1r. Ames noted that on the site map there is much land maxked "vacant", . Note: T4ra Rut2ick axrived for �he sneeting at this point. In regard to the single-fsm�.ly resident., Mr, Okoneski �oted he spoke to t1�II1 and the resident hg� no ob3ec�ion to �he p�copo�al. He presented a site plan to the Board. Mr< Maietta said he is in doubt as to the frontage �nd street acceas. l;r, P1cPar�lin notied that thexe w�1L be fu�ure $ttempts to rezone propertiy in the vicinity. If tY�is petition is�°r handled correctly in regard to sufficiency, access, etc., it wi1P create a mess fvr tihe future. Mro Sorenson explained that the b�5t procedure may be t� vacate th� alley and street prior to the attempt to rezone. l�eitexatin�, rlr. tJkoneski E�id he doesn't feel any problem wi11 arise �ar vacating Idaha Avenue; this would �tot land-Iock any proQer�y. Mre Maietta suggested ttca� the steff rev9.ew ehis proposai agsin to obtain more inforutation ��garding f;coutageg rezox�ing in three paxcels, +end number of tanits �hat could ac�u�lly *e b�iit thexe. �verythia�; is too vague; there isn't sufficient data at this t3me. He noted tha� to protect the petitioner, the mattcr should be la�Ld over inst��ad of denied at this p�i�i.. Mr. Okoneski noted they hs�e '�59a of �tie px'oge?"Cy; sewe� and water is not in, althongh they have contacted the Public W�rks ]D�partment regarding sewexs. Regardfng �he petitian i�se2f, P�b. rlaiett� sugg�sted that the petiition should be checked for sufficiency since the faront�g� is zn qaestion. In�ress and egress would be questionable ior the prr�po�ed apartment building, and may be against the Fire Dep��tment`s regulatianse -6- , PHILIP W, �'ITZIPATRICK (6/4/70) (Continued): lMro Okoneski said that Zdaho Avenu� wc�ulct be vacated at Edgemont Street. Regarding Wheelock Parkway, Mr, Meistta asked whether that was Co be widened from Edgertan to l�ice Streets; i£ so, that may take away soYne of the subject property. He undQxstands it is "on the books" to be widened. r:r. Mansctr questioned wh�at the petit�o��r shou�.d do n�xt. M�o AicPartlin seid he can try to vacat� the street, etc. He noted this is similar to the Lo I.awrence Anderscsn matter that is �awaiting a street vacation to determine density. Mr. Mafetta said if the se�ee� is widened, a problem cauld arise; it would he a �ime-consum�ng matter. rir. Okonesk�. reiterated they own al.l the pba�erty except that of the State o� Mianesote. He fe�ls this �as na bear�ng on the rezoning. in)ith this, N;r. McPartlin �isagreed. Mr. Tiaietta noted tl�at if �Jheelock �'zarkway is widened, the raiZro�d bridge wilY have to be rel�cat�d. Note: Mra Gauger arrived at this poi�xt. In order to obtain additf.anal �nformation, Mr. MaieCta moved for an indefinite Layover of the matter. The motian was seconded by Mr. McPartlin, aad carried wfth Messrs. �mm�s, Mansui, end Rutzick voting in favor of t�e IayovEr. It was noted tha� the pet;ttioner will be no�ffied when the mstter comes before the Boarci of Zaning fur the second time. Air, Ames told the petitionez to contact Che Public G3nrks Department to start proceedings for a street vacation, and to chec�c with the State of tiinneso�a about their nroperty ad jace�zt. Submitted by: Colon�l La �orexxson Robert Lo Ames, Chairman , _7_ . MINiTTES OF THE PUBLIC HEARING B�FORG� THE BQARD �F ZONIl�IG on Thursday, Uctober 1, 1970, at 34�0 �',M, PRESEY�IT: Messrs. Ames, I�cPartiin, Maiette, and Mansur o€ the Board, and Messzso Brawn, Roset�er, and Sorenson, aaad tirs. Fr.an�zen of the staff. PHILIP W, RITZPATRICK: Three pe�itiona to rezone f.ram "A01 �o "C" Resid�ence for the parpose of construcCing an apar�hnent deveLopment these praperti�s; 1) Weat side of Arkwright Street extended between East t�lheelock Parkwap �nd Sao Line Railway; 2 and 3} East side of Edg�monL- St�cPet between Eae� Whe�lock Parkway and Esst Hoyt Avenue. Mr. Ames sCated that ae Cheirmn of the &oard, he wauld like to ge� the suf£iciency of the petition cleared up by wai.ting ior th� IegaX opiz:ien from Che Corparation Counsel's office. Mz. Ames expiaie�ed to Mr. �I��aur that thi.s m�tter had been "kicked around" for qnite some� t une alresd� at this mee�ing, and explained Che need for the streets and sI1Qy vacation. He suggested that perhaps the Zoning Board should �ct on this as it was originally submitted, and let the City Couaci.l iron orst �he resc. The piece of land ia the middLe that i� possibxy insufficient would have to be corrected. Mrs. Cecelia Vaxtmsan, Orr, Mi.nnesots, was present in appasition ta th�5e rezonings. She owns �0 lots near the subj�ct praperty, and comnented that her atto�neq tald her that if there was anything Co da with sewe�: and wat�er, they shonldn't sign �nything. Mr. Sorenson summarized the s�aff report, a part of the fil€�, no�ti�g that thim portion of the ataff report wauld not cov�r the c{ue�}tic�na o� ��v�fici.ency previausly discussed. He said a petition is pending �o vacF,te Eas� Idaho Avenue from Edgemoat Street to Wheelock Parkway, Arkwright 5t_eet from t�e railroad right-of-way north to West Idaho Aver�ue, anc� the a11.�1�s iz� :�3lacks 1 and 4, Dawson's 5th Addition. ;f the City Council vacates these streets and alleys, the combined site would have an area of ap�aoxfmatelq 14Q,Q0� square feet, end permit a developmenC af about 140 units if *t�e pro�ert;,� is rezoned to "�" Residence. Mro Sorensoxx no�ec� that the o�-iginal C�.�n;�reh�=:as�.�r�e Plan recanenends low-deneity for this ttrea, but tha� coiisidernble ai:tentfan and further study hr�s been given this aret� by d�oth �he stafi snd Plaac�:�ng Board� The site is vacant snd about 5 feet below the grade of Wheelock Partcu�ay. The railroad right-of-way abuttiag on the southeast is about 1Sa20 fee� �bove the level af this site. i'ost-war Iow-density reaid��ces e�cist x�orth �f Wheelock Parkway, along the snuth edge af the parkway and easterly acros� the reiZroad ri�ht-o£-way. ►l�xltiple-£amily exists f�rther �c� tihe c,outhwestw �his iIImnediate area northwesCerly of the ra3.lroad is largely uncievelopeii� In coacluai.on, Mr. Sorenson no�ed th�t s previa�as rezoning attempt for th�s property was denied, an apartment development msy h�ve a de*rimental R£t�ct on the area, and may lead Co f�zture rezo�ing attempta. Ttt� staf£ f_�els �he Zoning Code petition requirements �re bea.n� circumvented. _�.. , PHTLZP W, FITZPATRICK (10/1/70) {con�inu�d): Mro �'Toole, attorney f�� the petitioner, atated that mast of the �partmeats existing in the area are betwe�n the freeway an� West�ninster Street; othcr apartment projects have been approved for the srea. The s�il condition an the aubject property makes �t feasible only for ap�rtment de��Lornnent. He requeste� tha� the Zoning Board recommend approval a� this rezoning so that more land can he placed on the City tax rolls. Mr, M�ietta no�ed that the land in ques�fon used to be a lake. Regarding the size of the bui�dings, Mr, 0'TooLe sa�d they wauld be either. 2 1/2 ar 3 1J2 stories. Mr. Ames no��d that constructinn casts would be consider�bly higher far a 3 1/2-st��y str.uctczre. Mr. Maietta question�� t�� stsff report regard�ng the reco�nend�ti�n of the Com�rehensive Plan far 4he area. He said ehe Plan�ling Eo�rd ch�nged r..hat over a year and a half ago, since �he soi� cnn��tio�s wnuld not b� suitablQ for building of single-family �ames. Mr. �cPartlir moved €ar �pproval of the t�ree rezor.ing petit�ans, �tatin� that the p�anning Board ctianged �he Compr�hensiv� �la� tar t�is area, and the proposecl developme�t s�ems 2ike a go�d use for t�� land� The motion for approval w2s sub�ect to the �on�it�on t�at: Z) tt�e �etiLions �re aeclared safficient, snd 2) the City Council vacate the stre�ts and alleyso Mr, Mansur seconded the �otion, wtiich ��rried nnan�m�uslyo Prior to formal consideration of t�is m�tter, informal discussion �ook place sfnce only three n►embers of the Board w�re pr�sent and a quorwn w�s lackingo The discussion concexrted the sufficaency of the petitians, requested Iegal apiniona, and whether these maCters were ready far Board consideratfon on thia dateo Submitted b�: Coloael L, Sorenson Robert Lo Ames, Chair�an -4- Gity Clerk � ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL - MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE ' 113 Court House 55102 October 16, 1970 File X893, Page You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the Couacil Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the Ci�ty of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on October 29, 1970, on the petition of Philip W. Fitzpatrick to rezone from aa "A" Residential District to a "C" Residential District the property described as follows: Lots 1 thru 8, Block 4, and Lot 7, Bloak 1, Dawson's Sth Addition, 030-29 Northwest �, Section 20, Township 29, Range 22. The property is located West of Arkwxi,ght Street betweea Wheelock Parkway aad the Soo Line Railroad. For further information, contact the Planning Board, Room 1010, Comaerce Building, or telephone 223-4151. This notice of a public hearing has been sent out fran the DeparC• �aent of Finance ic� coamlisnce �ith the Cit�► C�ter. ROSALIE L. BUTLBR Commiasioner of Finance O • • Citq Clerk � CITY OF SAINT PAUL � MINNESOTA . DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE � 113 Court House 55102 October 16, 1970 File X941, Page You are hereby aotified that a public hearic�g will be h�ld in the Council Chatabere of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on October 29, 1970, o�a the patition of Shirley Ana Horrigan and Philip W. Fitzpatrick to rezone fram an "A" Resfdential District to s "C" 8esidential District, the property described as follows: Lots 8, 9 and i0, Block 1, and Lots 2!, 22, 23, 24 and 25, Block 4, Dawson's Sth Addition. The property is located on the East side of Edgemont Street between i�heelock Parkway and East Hoyt Avenue. For further information, contact th� Plaaning Board, Room 1010 Cc�muerce Buildiag, or telephone 223-4151. This notice of a public hearing has been senc out from the �artment of Finance ia cc�apliance, with the CitY Charter. ROSALIE L. BUTLEH Coaunissioner of Finaace O City Clerk ' ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL • MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE � 113 Courf House 55102 � October 16, 1970 File X940, page You are heseby notified that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Caurt House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on October 29, 1970, on the petitfon of Philip W. Fitzpatri�� to rezoae from an "A" Residential Diserict to a "C" Residential District the property descrihed as followe: Lots 16, 17, 18, !9 and 20, Block 4, Dawson's Sth Addition to the City of St. paul, Ramsey County, Minnesota. Tbe property is located on the East side of Edge�ont Street between 8ast Idaha and 8ast Hoyt Avenues. For further infonreation, contact the Planning Board, Roaa 1014 Commerce Buildiag, or telephone 223-4151. This notice of a public hearing has been se�t qut fr__�_,the_ Departtneat of Fiaance i.n compliance with the City Charter. r i ROSALIE L. BU?LER Commissioner of F'it�sace O � , Citq Clerk . . CITY OF SAINT PAUL �� • MINNESOTA f DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE - 113 Court House 55102 October 16, 1970 File X9�4, Page You are hereby aotified that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of t�te City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on October 29, 1970, on the petition of Shirley Ann Horrigan, and others, for the vacation of East Idaho Avenue fzam Edgemount �Co Arkwright, Arkwri�t 5treet fram� the Soo Lfne Right of Way to Wheelock Parkway, AND the alley in Blocks 1 and 4, Dawaon's Sth Addition from the Soo Line Right of Way to Wheelock Parkway. For further information, contact the Valuation Buresu of the Finance Department, Room 286, City Hall and Court House, or telephone 223-5317. This proposed vacation was based on a petition fil,ed in the office of the City Clerk. ' � ROSALIE L. BUTLER Coa�nissioner of Finance O • Area Code 612 , . �lTy �, � � THOMAS J.STEARNS / 223-5121 �w F� ARTHUR M. NELSON (i� '` ,(--r� 'a JEROME J.SE6AL . � � r`�.` THOMAS M. MOONEY 6 �A°S..-�?i1�n' y - ° KENNETH J. FInPATRICK ''' � �c PAUL F. MeCLOSKEY,JR. JOSEPH E.CARTWRI6HT CITY OF SAINT PAUL R.SCOTT DAVIFS PIERRE N. REGNIER "_ PAUL J. KELLY DANIEL L. FICKER ' FirstAssistant LEGAL DEPARTMENT KENNETH A.SKRIEN 316 City Hall, St. Paal, Mtnnesota 55102 : DANI.EL A. KLAS Corporotion Counsel Ju l y 1"rj� 19 7� Mr. Paul F. Desch Supervisor of Assessments Department of Finance B U I L D I N G Re: Rezoning of land owned by S. A. Horrigan and 0. A. Assen Dear Mr. Desch: At your convenience, I would like to go over your request of June 19, 1970, with you. Please call me at extension 4630 asto when you can meet to• consider the request. V uly yo s, �� V SEPH E. CARTWRIGHT __ ssistant Corporation Counsel Y JEC:paw , �O Area Code 612 ; ;}T�� ,�F THOMAS J.STEARNS • ,223-5121 �� f-� .,� , /�RTHUR M. NELSON • • . • ;;--_„`' •i JEROME J.SE6AL � ;"�;�� y� THOMAS M. MOONEY KENNETH J. FITZPATRICK � • L5� M '�c PAUL F. McCLOSKEY, JR. JOSEPH E.CARTWRIGHT �IT� OF �AIN�'� PAUL R.SCOTT DAVIES PAUL J. KELLY DANREI L. FlCKER R Firat Assistant LEGAL DEPARTMENT KENNETH A.SKRIEN ' 316 City Hall, 5�. Paul, Minnesota 55102 DANIEL A. KLAS - Corporation Counsel To: Paul F'. Desch Sapervisor of Assessments . DATE: June 23, 1970 Your letter of JUne 19. 1970 concerning the rezoning of land owned by S. A. Horrigan and 0. A. Assen respectively, and Section 63.18 as it relates thereto, has been received. Mr. �oseph E Ca�rtwriqht, dcsic _ant ('nrnnraf.i�., �:�,.;�� of this office has been assigned to the uiatter, and you may direct i'uture inquiries concerni�g the same directly to him. DANIEL A. KLAS Corporation Counsel �O ,��,cm�'k'"'ii��'�:Yi�°� 's��tit,;Yt��,��yq•�'t �'��;��'�t(1��:� .. . . . . . � �.'��*��'�+E',�M i�}'�`��.��M�t'i.1l,�a' rwy3�.a�'{C;iy y��,�tta;�,,: !.: t i r �, � t4,yt.�� t'4 ��' }��. �at�H �� ,�fi � 'w = . " � � � , ,f �i� � , . ' . �� '��BO.ARD� ;�F ��ON�I�NG�,�� CITY OF ST. PAUL � �' � '�� rr ,k . �` °' ,�IOlQ COMMERCE BUILDING�"�`•- ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 � PHONE: 223-4159 �� , a;, 1 . . ' . •�• �, , . June 17, 1970 ,� � Commissioner Rosalie L. Butler Department :of Finance � ` Room 113 City Ha11 Re: Your File No. X-893 , , .' a ' , Our Fi1e.'No. 6984, . � .- t ; . , ,. M,� Dear, Commi�ssioner Butler: � .� � � This is written in response to the petition of Philip W. Fitzpatrick to rezone - from "A" Residence to "C" Residence c2rtain properties located west of the Soo Line Railway, south of Wheelock Parkway and adjoining the intersection of East Idaho � Avenue and Arkwright Street as extended. The legal description of these properties is contained in your File No. X-893. The petition was reported sufficient to the City Council by your department in a Ietter dated May 7, 1970. Subsequently, a recheck of the petition was made - resulting in amended sufficiency percentages. This matter was considered by the Board of Zoning at their meeting on June 4, 1970. Following the staff report, the Board discussed the unusual nature of this petition to sezone; i.e. , an attempt to rezone three parcelS of land separated by streets or a11ey at the request of the owner of only one of the parcels. Resulting problems including the need for street vacations, traffic access, final street frontage for any proposed development, and the use of lands presently owned by the City and State were noted and discussed. Subsequently, the Board of Zoning laid this matter over indefinitely so that more complete information could be obtained including the adequacy of street frontage to qualify this petition as sufficient. We, therefore, request that your office provide further explanation on the sufficiency of this petition including the use of alleys and streets of less than 30 feet width in determining the required frontage. (See Sections 63.18 and 64.06 of the Legislative Code) If we can be of assistance in responding to this request, please contact our office. The original petition and attachments are included for your information. � Very truly yours, �� e�Q �A Nol nd R. eiden Director of Planning NRH:gaf CLS Encl. ,•�a V � ��Q • . . , � � • " BOARD' OF` ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 : June 17, 1970 Commissioner Rosalie L. Butler Department of Finance Room 113 City Hall Re: Your File No. X-893 Our File No. 6984 Dear Commissioner Butler: This is written in response to the petition of Philip W. Fitzpatrick to rezone from "A" Residence to "C" Residence certain properties located west of the Soo Line Railway, south of Wheelock Parkway and adjoining the intersection of East Idaho Avenue and Arkwright Street as extended. The legal description of these properties is contained in your File No. X-893. The petition was reported sufficient to the City Council by your department in a letter dated May 7, 1970. Subsequently, a recheck of the petition was made resulting in amended sufficiency percentages. This matter was considered by the Board of Zoning at their meeting on June 4, 1970. Following the staff report, the Board discussed the unusual nature of this petition to rezone; i.e. , an attempt to rezone three parcels of land separated by streets or alley at the request of the owner of only one of the parcels. Resulting problems including the need for street vacations, traffic access, final street frontage for any proposed development, and the use of lands presently owned by the City and State were noted and discussed. Subsequently, the Board of Zoning laid this matter over indefinitely so that more complete information could be obtained including the adequacy of street frontage to qualify this petition as sufficient. We, therefore, request that your office provide further explanation on the sufficiency of this petition including the use of alleys and streets of less than 30 feet width in determining the required frontage. (See Sections 63.18 and 64.06 of the Legislative Code) If we can be of assistance in responding to this request, please contact our office. The original petition and attachments are included for your information. Very truly yours, � �.• "c. �,-- Nol nd R. Heiden Director of Planning __ NRH:gaf CLS Encl. O . 'Herry E. MarshaU ��T'' oF Albe�# B. Oisoo � ' ' ' City/Clerk and �``� %� Council Recorder Commissioner of Reqistra,ttion � -� . -=_�3 . ��, ^� : OFPICE OP THE CITY CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL � BUREAU OF RECORDS 886 City Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 55i01 May 7, 1970 Zonirig Board, C�erce Bldg. Gentlemen: The City Council referred to you for reco�nmendation the attached petition of Philip W. Fitzpatrick to rezone Lots 1 throu�h 8, Block �+, and I�ot 7, Block 1, Dawson's Fifth Addn., 030-29 N.W.u, Section 20, T. 29, R. 22, located west of Arkwri�ht Street between Wheelock Parkway and East Hoyt Avenue, to "C" Residence District. Very t uly yours, .�}� � City rk � hp ZONi1dV ��L�� .-.� � � � � � � � � �� MAY � l�l[� C,'TY !'LAlVirtivt� �sutinu Sa,int Paul, Minaewts� � . � ' , ' � - , '% - � " . � ., - � • , DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE .- � CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I 13 Courf House,66102 : JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner • LOUIS H.McKENNA, Dspuiy Commiuionsr Phonr 223-4646 May 7, 1970 To the Council City of Saint Paul Gentlemen: I have checked the attached petition of Philip W. Fitzpajrrick, filed in the matter of rezoning, Lots 1 through 8, Block 4, and Lot 7, Block 1, Dawson's Fifth Addition, 030-29 N.W. �, Section 20, Township 29, Range 22. The property is located west of Arkwright Street between Wheelock Parkway and East Hoyt Avenue, from a Class "A" Residence District to a Class "C" Residence District, and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours very truly, __.} % � mes J. � lglis '� /��"� Commissi er of inance Re: X-893 c.c. Mr. Ames N. R. Heiden Frontage: 89% Parcels Eligible - 18 Parcels Signed - 12 or 66-2/3� Needed - 12 or 66-2/3°� � �' r•� � `,�_"��(� *�� j ' � � � � �� ,-.��..o_ �� f = � ` ��s� �� ' DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE �' CITY OF SAINT PAUL � � , t`� �s� MINNESOTA 7 � 113 Court Houss,55102 �,} � �� '� ,� ROSALIE L. BUTLER, Commissioner �hone:223-4646 A�gxat 21, 1970 To the Crmncil City �f �t. Pa�l �eatlese�: I have ahecked the attached petiti�a af Philip W. Fitzpatrich, filed 3.s the aatter o� rezo�i�g, Lots 16, 17, 18, 19 aad 20, Block 4, Dawson's Sth Additios. The prm�erty is located os the �ast aicie �f Bdgeaont Street bet�e�a Bast Idaho aad East Hoyt Avennes, frt� a Class "A" �tesi�ence District to a Class "C~ Resideatial Hi�trict, aad fiad that said petition is iasnfficieat. Yogrs very traly, � - �� a$sii� L. s�tier c�i/�Ao� a� F �� %� t �e. x-9�� c.c. Mr. l�es - Ii. R. Heides Mra. Bgtl�r Fro�tage: 10�Z Pareela 8ligible - 23 Parcels Sig�ed - 15 or 65X l�eeded - 16 or 66-2/3Z t� ��. � . � � � �. 4>``, 4.m. 4 ////�� . �� `��.\xn Y.. � (� �` j � /��JS `� �� t � a � �� , �} Y � °�°� �� T Y�� C�F SA! !� T PJ�►U L -�''' ' �� _� _ ��` � �� ., � ° � �� ! �� ,� .,� Capit�l o�F tti+tinnesot� �� A�i��: � �° � � ;�- , n , � , �� , � _ , .� � . � _ � . . �. ,� �� 1 a�� . F ��:�"�� a ��` �^ �,. � , � � m , . i � � � $�r F�� e�x�f3=e� �a.. � m�: s� i + y.� :, y N� �'� , ��.v.:.. �rt �. � _ � _ � �'i '� J—*s 'V"- � �, y� �. a w YE� 4 e „ �� .;.,.' �,y _. . � � „" - 4 ' . �' ' " � .� � �' �� . f� ::iaL° �� ' .P r' ry��.�� L ��k BUREAU OF PUBLIC BUILDINGS ROBERT L AMES, Ci+y Archi+ec+ 445 City Hall, 55102 223-4212 October 15, 1970 Mayor Charles McCarty and Members of the City Council Re: 899 Iglehart Avenue Gentlemen: The Housing and Redevelopment Authority advises us that the above va�ant building is scheduled for acquisition shortly after May 1, 1971, at which time they plan to demolish the structure. Ve�y t��ly yto�'µrs� �� ; �'�, 4 j �y~ ;�V � ';`v � � I � �'�� Robert L. Ames City Architect RLA/mfs � � �� /"i `.'�� _�.` V ,��I^ , � _ .. i �ti,�; .. V � „ , � � ITY OF SAINT PAU . , �. �. .,� Capital of Minnesota tc�-;1� � . , _ � � � �� ':,._.�_.—_ � ' ' r ' ' , , � � , �.,,. � , ,� . � � �. , : ,�..,_,_ ,,. � .� . _ , � �� - �.� .,, � � � � ' � '� � .�� ” „ 1� _ , ��+,` .; � � � ` -�.. �;�,��,�.�� . . w ., � '� � ,;�,�� y� �� '- � �, ,. � . • �� , �a �. �� . �---, � �, .�, :_� k�, � _ '�`{ ��q}� ,� BUREAU OF PUBLIC BUILDINGS ROBERT L. AMES, City Architect 445 City Hall, 55102 223-4212 October 14, 1970 Honorable Charles McCarty, Mayor and Members of the City Council Re: File No. 2015--899 Iglehart Gentlemen: The Building Department is hereby submitting its report on the condition of the structures at the above location. The owner of record is Harry Doris, and the legal description of the property is Lot 12, Block 1, Fairbanks Addition. A recent inspection indicates the following: Building Classification: Single family frame dwelling. Exterior: Some evidence of decay is in siding and cornice. Basement: Appears structurally sound. First and second floors: Some signs of vand,alism, but in general in good condition. Attic: Signs of vandalism. Plumbing, heating and electrical systems : Intact. Gara e: In poor condition and presents an attractive nuisance. The subject property has been boarded up by the city since September 29, 1970. A letter received from the owner's attorney on :September 10 indicates that the Housing and Redevelopment Authority is negotiating to purchase the property. However, Mr. Del Hoppe of HRA stated in a telephone conversation with Mr. Blue of this office that it would be at least two months before they could. �Y� �ol�.�� • � � � Hon, Charles McCarty, Mayor ' and Members of the City Council -2- October 14, 1970 acquire same. In the meantime, this department is concerned with the fact that this building presents a hazard to its very close neighbors. It is the re commendation of this bureau that this matter be referred to the City Attorney's office for razing and removal through District Court proceedings. V ry uly yours, Rob t L. A es City Architect RLA/mfs cc: Messrs. J. J. Segal D. Norrgran F. Staffenson ,�. ._ o��,W,�,��,� � 250�fi'7 , • . � cinr oF s�. PAUL fl uNC�� NO � � OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK COUNCIL RESOLUTION--GENERAL FORM r�� Victot► J, �Ted�SCO �A.� a!!'��Ml�? 30� 19T0 COMMISSION� � WHEREAS the City Architect has requested the City Council to hold a public hearing to consider the advisability and necessity of the correction or wrecking and removal of the following described buildings, said structures having been reported to constitute a public hazard: Address Legal Description Type of Structure_ 899 Ijlehart Lot lEf Block 1, Faisbaaks Addn. . l�i�ngle t�►mity dvnsllinQ and , gara�s., WHEREAS. it appears that the last known record owners of said buildings E. are' as follows: � ; Harry �ori� , � THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that a public hearing be held by and before the Council of the City of Saint Paul in the Council Chamber' of the Court House in said city at 10:00 a. m. on 'q�edn�td�► Cktebrr ld i$,�� to consider the advisability and necessity of ordering the correction or wrecking and removal of said structures on the above described praperty inasmuch as said structures are reported to constitute a hazard to public health, safety and welfare; be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City Architect, on behalf of the City Council. notify by mail the record owners of the property in question at the last known address, as well as other interested persons of record ; of the date and time of the hearing. SEP 3 0 1�70 COUNCILMEN Adopted by tbe Co»�c3� 19� Yeas NaYe SE' 3 O 1J7O . Butler Carlson ApprovA� 19— Levine Tr Favor Meredith Sprafka (� �� A►gAlriSt Tedeaco Mr. Preaident, McCarty � . . � � I,� � June 19, 1970 Mr. Daniel Klas Corporation Counse� Building Dear Mr. Klas: The attached copy of a petition for rezonin� was suhmitted to the Finance De- partment for a report o€ sufficiency of signatures, was reported sufficient to the City Council and referred to the Board of Zoning for further investigation and report back to the City Council, as provided in Section 64.06 of the Legis- lative Code. The Board of Zoning discussed the proposal during which the question arose as to the legality of the petitioner to request the rezonind of land other than his own, without the other owners joining in the petition. As you will see from the attached plan, the petitioner owns and signed for parcel noted as narcel 1, with parcels designated 2 and 3 being owned by S. A. I�orrig�n and 0. A. Assen respectively, and not si�ned for in the petition. If your answer is in tne affirmative, that the procedure followed by the �etitioner is correct, I will then ask your opinion as to the use of alleys or streets af less than 30 feet in width in determining frontage. (Sections 63.18 and 64.06 of the Legislative Code) . This specific petition is unususl, in that the three parcels are separated from each other by Idaho Avenue on the north and that portion of platted Arkwright Street which is 25 feet in width, whereby Section 63.18 defines "street" as being 34 feet or more in width, and the fact that all of the property in the petition is not signed for. . I will �e happy to ex�Iain this in more detail if you feel that is is necessary. Very truly yours, Paul r. D�sch Supervisor of_ Assessments PFD/dn August 21, 1970 ---___� Mr. Gerald J. Okoneski, 649 w. Hoyt Ave., St. Pa,ul, Minn. Dear Sir: `�, � The Commiasi Fina�c today reported that the petition of Phi . Fi � tric o re2one Lots 16, 17, 18, 19 and 20, ock 4, Da n's . Addition, located on the east side o gemont St t between East Idaho and East Hoyt Aven , to "C" R idence District, is insufficient. For this reason, th Council c ot act further in this ma.tter. Very truly yours, City Clerk hp Oct. , 1q70 �... , Mr. Daniel A. Klas �___ �� ✓ Corporation Counsel - ' Building ��.�, �� .� '�,� Dear Sir: The City Coezncil tod request F:hat you prepare a resolution orderin� ectio ing and rem�val �f the building at $99 hart Ave. Very truly yours, City CZerk ng -T------•r--- {��' { ` { � � , I , r � . - ��,.—�--_—�-__..�;...�..,,. : ; i� j � � I � �> � , � '� ? C� , � � C � � , . ,., i � „ , , ..__ _ ; � � , ; , ; , , . __ _. � � � � �-- � '� � • 1 ' �� e� - __--� - -- , � � . f �. t � � . � , --�--� �- Q � � � � � , � _--�..____..�_ 1 � �n , /;.�� ' L, �� --__ , . .__ Z - � 6 r ; ,�� , �,�, { ' - ; , I � ' ti I __ �.1 � � W � , j ,, �;_ � �, ��; ' ..�--.-�Y. _'._---) -�.1 .i ... `� - . � � �.__..._.__. � � � Y r.�,��f .:.� � t n --- ---- _ ____ __.-- _�_ -- - - "' r{ �``' � '� ' � � � .. = . � _ � _ . , ' ;� ��j �C , _ � : _-_ -, v -� � � �;i '� '. � z 3 V , � �,� ,� � u ��.,•r , i + �. J"� J � ) � �h "_" I ll � � _"'_ ' _ �. ..�. .... ." ' ____. .. .a ._ ""'� ... , _ . . ` > 3 t' . O ��.4L w .A� ��y,� ; ------- - ' � �� ..l ~ . ..� i: ��a - � _.. _ _. — � I " ' S ~ �, r•�� tr�t�C � l,^ - � 1 � t� 1 +---. � _..` � . �� `J � � `�; tv y� ,1� Q � � _ - ... --� � `. ..`.._ ._ ` l-- � � .'_. �f. r'� .. �;�,N� ��:.:�� ti � ^ L � � �� : � � ( • .t_r._,__ ...� ti_. . ` � � ` . '"_-sr �,�� ,. t +�' � � � �., - - . _- - �� __. �, . ^ �� _ � . �` , ' � .Q - . .. _/ ---�-1 ' `~,. - . .. . l..� . / � � l� �� '1J- . � ` �� '`�e' ''a � �. .. ... - '-- . , r , � -- - � � � - ,� _.. . _ . � -- ��;: _��' �,-� �� ; ; � � . .., . _ . � ` t,, � . �; • . ._ _ �� r � 5� x «� 4 �i . �� -- . __; � . ' y. .__ . �� ____ . : . J , `� �,� - +!c.�.'�f�,sr �•� i _ \ � _ ^1 � i ± ' t,�°T� . �i �.. r -- _ �� +�i' j �- "�—�� r� �� /'� , J-� �- c -- ,\! -._ 1 �, ,� �, � ht, � �a��,�� ' .-�1 1 ..l "�_' ."_. +I.,_..�._ ....'_ "' �" ^` • .. � � ..( .. . w��.. ...^ , y�� tM� � ry1 •„�r �" I `J ' . . ( 1 ' � �i jy / V � � _'_ ...a....�. ' I 1 . � _ ., �-�..�� ar4 , � xtt*°��a�y>� j � _ . , _ _ _ . � - � � �._. r , � ��`a ew,,,.� ��,+��a � , ---- .. _ _ __ _ '� _. � � r� � w,(r�,t�x.�'�� : �� (� ��. �~` -- �,; �.a5 tk-.r '��'��i �/ ; , � , Y �'}y , � � 1 , .-. ____.._ . ,�(� � , . � ' \ �. .. O ,.� O O ' � �_ / i gr4F ��r� y ��f>� �...� ; i .___._. _._ _�. ._. .� . '..'_. ♦ � s 1 r .fi.I�.R.�r� V_�'� q L. .. �J� i I � �� _ __ �' �.tr i��• � i � ��.t�� '�,� �M,�,� ; � �J 1 ' �� .�, � � � ,��,? „�,q "°rii! �I , � i .. .. `� (j�J_ a� F�_ ,�s 5��r�m�3 , � . ._ _' __.__. ._ _ ._ . V � �/ . � � . � - � � � �� r ` r - -L -- � � � „M�'� ��,�,� �"x � �� - , , , ___.� � o ; ; P�P . �, � , _T _ - � �� - � �� #�� : i -__: - - � o- :`" � �;.� ��K�� _�.. , , - � � --� , , � � F . . � a�� N o r� o � � G Q. o w c, W ---- -- Q., -- - � r 4�� k�.�� ._ - --- __ _----- . . _ �\ , _ { � ; ' . . ' � j •� � `-+, �. O ��r . . . ' ` f5£�� T 1 ��x� � � -� i a � i ' � O ,�'/ � T. > ' ' ��"�� , . . , ,`� � --- __ _--. � , __ __._ . p � .._� ��,,� � � •� �. _- -- �_J C� Q �` , • > r � � ' � � ��r � � � __ ___ _. �__ _ �_ ('j � Q`j� `� t� - ��,�� t, � �.• � ' Q �' � ._.�. __ ��`� ,� „��.� ,, i � � n O p \ � Q j ..' ��. � `�� ,�;`; . , +. � � \ n , ! �J _�. � � ,��t � , r �. , ' i __.. _. _ ___.._ ,� , . ti' �4 ' � f • i , , � i _; (� �) ' n ' � / r z" �;�, �� `� . _ __ _ i ` - , I _ _ o ��Y.�� : � . � • --- - - --i --� ----- . . ,::'� ;, � � r :- 2 ��f C Y� y .0 . � . .' . ( �j � �� . \` �y+ �� / . '� /� � �..+ .. k. ��,u�� ,�,��a}� �.��.. �. .__.__� . . . ��" �L � ^'� C`� �� r. i � S „S yl. 7'; / / y� � L � � ` ' �. �./ V :`�O�/ /� , L {./ � . 'F �7'� T� �p �D , � . 1 l� � ,�., � ''. �O \ / �!� f ` I V �f' _'n ',a' ' i�Y t �^'ti+h�"",�'�� ' i � � V �\ 4 t.� 1 ` `'� � __- , , \ _ ^� - , .�,`Yir"„n, n��h+�, �/ �1 ` J \ � I . - � h � X f i � i � � �/ � ; � , �/ - � '� ' �.` �,�� r�� `\ r'' .. \ � ' C �Y O '' � % ' -�-- - ' � O -_, . . c: � '� ��,h� ' . i . � . _ __� 31 7n �.', _ - _-- � -L__�� '� �'�C�d, '�, w n � � � - -. � � � � �� "�� - - - � � -- - .._. �-, 1 r � � , � t�Y' f a � n�,{.,T°��y? .T . `�` ,� � r r : , . � � i � :. � '�:4 ; 1 ' _ � � , 1 1 � ' � ' ` i ' �\ k �1.* � (j I � `'�, \� _. _. - _ _ _-_ Q ' °��r�t� � �i �� A,, � ' , ' � � � � � (�` ,'' ; � I I � I � � . ' 'V�� (� �l Q _. " �, L'�1, - � � i � � � � .'t.� � s` � �t �. r 4x,. � ,,. � `�, J ;. � O,� � ,p - o..� r�;�,� ,; � �" N �d1� �� '' ' ► / / - __ _ -- -- - y� .:: � � ~ �' 7��.(�A+.�uWie�..Sfi,L.eM � � � � " � ` ¢� �"`.�'a.';�:: � ,�+k..��l ,�' �� ;:' �1 �` -- O'"'_ - ----0 ��.-�;V` . � � I 1 - v !'� I � -- _ , � , .r � � �� ` c � f�. " .. - ..,.: .- . � � . I C.J i � ._ � � ''-- . - -. .. _ . - - _ ._'._' ._. . �y if'. ._.O_'._'�-.... + i � i t __L--�- -� � I �'\ ' I - � __ __ V � �r - - - - �. � i ` I 1 i � � � ' t } __—_ _ _. - -� - — .� , O' _ � � � -fl- o ; o > �("�`T ( � . µ� :v , . p 9:- --� _ , - , , �: , � . } _ � , � � �,.�""` _ , � v'vi ,y 'v:viviv .f ' � s ..�"' Q� ., p ' , i �o . . + i __. . I � ;L ' .� � Q� + t p 1 • - ,C? _ F- �- H > � � �_ ' J ' > 1S i,'�`�I Z��I �tj > /� > , � - � - �'� -�r- _� ' - > � � � w � � , � W �' � � l,l„� > - � - - �._ >_ ,i Y � � � .� , �� , � ' -+ __ � , _... _ _. W. _�_ _ ` � . , , � � . ) . ._ k -----T_ T...._�r--r—�-- Q �� ' � � . .__J L� .. . . / � _ . . L-___} '_' .ti. � ' ! ' i ' `,,ac Q _i , � Q - � ' � �� i i ,? � ,,`�'.2 `. j '_ ' " _. -T . �- — ' � t I � I � v i v �a. _, „\ , � . ,�,. I O _ V � '�`" '` �l f � - � " ' . � f-- 1 S --� f- N` - ,.- - _ -; - --;-- -- 1N0W,3JC] 3 * ., . , � � � > > , � � , � � � �p , �; I � '' � . a � � `�, ,:., y ; ' .. ' �1 , ; � � i ' � � � � ) I i �i i i I + ., � ,. !, I � � ; , _� .fi ,_ � � i I � 1 i �i{{j�� )I I 1 ��,.` . ,. ! i . ) _�.__a_J i __ l 1 � J - � -- � '.-.�-_.I..._� . I i_.�..__±._�1_. _1__�._I � � _ . . t `.�. . �+�j� �- � • r. __. 'T "� � T- (, �� . � �t _T_ i �Tj ; � i i --,-- T--; - j � , -T- � � - --�---�---- . L___- - �• � , ' I i' t � i � T- , � � � � i -- --- � .- --'� � � ,� 0 � �, , � � �• � I � � � > > � �� 7 � � � " � • I 'I `� � i � � i � � � O; ; � i � i � � � 'i '�� v� � � � �Iv�wjv � ..� ` �. i � r � q • � i i ., � 1 �� 1 1 � — - - --_--- o t _ � �.�'__' . , `5 . . � I �� ' � ., .�"' ..__. __�_"��_.�_Y._�'�__'_' ' �w- . �___.. ...I ,. _. ..'.:. ._.... __.. .. .... � �� y • ` ,..__"` " �_ .' � . � ; . -r , ; , ; ---- - __ _ . � ; b � � ,'O, )p� Q . ° n �n;� � ; � �, r-, T � _ ' �� _ � I , � , � o o ; � � o � d o a.� " o o_ � , � � i � � , ; � , � ;_ ._ ; i_ 1_1 1_.2__. � � � - - - _�__. , �-� .__ _ ___�. � _ :_ : . _ _.. __ _ ._ ' � _ � ; � _ , • -�-�- T ., , . __ .. _ _ _ _.,_ -'-- � v-'. .o' - • T , 1 .� _j _ _ .__ � � � � , . ��.� � '� ' ! ' � � i � i � ; -+---- --W , - - : � ,,� � i. � � ' > [] v v ,�, , v ' v v v �'' j (_ d , '�p, . � 1 ,`� 1 _ ' ; � , i ! _ - _}: ;,��—_ 1 ' -._i'-1-�� . � ` �C' .L Sr-� f-- 2 -1�-- i ' �, _ `�-' � v � NdO � S ` � - 7 �n i.-:i �_ •__'_� � , __ _ _ _ _ b , , , � > , , . N.� � �I � � '� ,; � 7 - �� ! � � -��, �_ ...O_ � � l� 1 _ �. ; _ N � ' i _ � ^1 i � � - > � �- -- - - _ �' • � , " Y ' � . + - � , - -� I �-- - - ---- _/ �._� ..._ . � , ` , —------_�� \ �� ..___ ----------------� � - - - -_ __ �`_ �� - --- , --� ._ _ , 1 st �� / b - 2nd // /� Laid over to 3rd and app � / � —,4dopted / � Yeas Nays Y.\ Nays Butler �utler Carlson ' �arlson Levine �evine Meredifih �� *� `Meredith v Sprafka �prafka Tedesco `Tedesco Mr. President McCariy �r. President McCarty �O