The URL can be used to link to this page

250454 Osti'�1 to Cib Clerk • � � ORDINANCE � COUNCIL FILE NO ��0� " i `` . -��ir.� /� o PRESENTED BY � ORDINANCE NO +� An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to Use Districts, Height Districts and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, as amended. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to Use Districts, Height Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from "B" Residence District to "C" Residence District, to-wit: North 10 feet of the east g8 feet of Lot 11, and the east 98 feet of Lot 12, Block 9, Edmund Rices first addition to St. Paul; situate on property located on the southwest corner of Burr Street and Case Avenue in the City of Saint Paul. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. � i+s�aazo�r-�o a��seir�s , ., w�� t �+i�-�� ,e�ea�� !I `�au'1��oae; r��; ��1 �� t�be�;�to re�up►ae��1 'E�YB�feet ot Lat 11'. +md t'hs,F�st I 88 tleL` aR• Lert. 1$, Blork 9, Edmund Rices 3'hst Additios�,en kh��f,ttbteat !t.�"�'�' ,�oe��t t�he AC.�ouac�I 'b2 C4�y O! �t PsuY � sxed 'tthpn9�. �o�dcaY 'oF'Septembe�r, 19�JD. at Ca��e�i �latn�ber�3a th�e� Han�os' Wd•T!i'y. and�at sstd tlme and�. f�te Gout�¢!1 t►!dl � a'�1 �� Au ob9ectionG ana�r�ooimm� T�ffittve to said�+�opnsed�' 'T�b�d AuLast 31F. 2fT0. � S�CIR�RY��1'l18��. . (�l�f�..N�74) . SEP 3 0 1910 Yeas Councilmen Nays Pasaed by the Councii Butler � Caxlson Tn Favor � Levine Meredith � � A gainat ` Sprafka Tedeaco sident �� Approved: P 3 � �� At Ci lerk - ay �p� Form ap�roved Corpor�tion Counsel By • l�1TTBLISHED OCT 319�0 n.�.a a r� . . _ R D I 250�� + O NANCE COUNCIL HLE NO. PRESHVTED BY ORDINANCE NQ � � �� Aa ordiaisQe a�s�isa tat� lsaias Code, Ciapt�rr btl to 64, iaclnslre, oi tlte Saist Pael I.�i�iati�e Ca�e, pertaiai.ns to IIs� Distrf�ts, Ssi�t �ia�rict�s aa� B�s�aiaa o! certaia prop�rtio• is tit Cit�r at Ssiat Ps�l, �:�aa+�i�. TSB C4DI�CIL 4!' 'i'IIB EI?'!' OF SAT�T PAIIL BOBS aEH#Il�� Set:tisa I. '1'�it� t1�e �o�ti� Codt, Cfeagtezs fiE1 tt� 6�, ia�el�itr�, ,.; ot t�t� Sa�izt Pwnl La�i�latiTe Cads, psrtaiaia� tv II�e �irt�ri�at,t� H�i�t Histriot�, a� �te�i� at a�rtaia propos►t=as fa t�a Ci�t�► a! 3aiat Pasl, ai �+�d, bt �utd tLe �a�e f• L��r�► tt�rt��r �d�d s+a► ss to r�so�ta tie �oll�ri� deaaribed P�"�P�"�! !r� "B" itssti�t�e � Di�trie� te �C" Yeaidan�te Distrfat, to-ritt xorti� l� ieet oi t,he e�at 98 leet o! Lot 11, a�i �ha ea�t 98 t�et oi Lot 12, Blo�l[ 9, S�s�d liia�ts lir�t sdditioa to St. Faul� sitsat.� aa property located oa �he �oath�rest tsc�raer o! DMS�r �tr�et atid Ca�• A�es�e is the Cit�► oi Saiat Patil. Sectioa 2. T�is oriiaas�e s�il tsice �ii�t aad be is, l+�re� tLirt�r (�1) da�s h�oa a�d alter its pusa�s, a�pro�l asd ��lieatiog. SEP 3 0 1�70 Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Counci� Butler Carlson ;,_In Favor Levine , Meredith � ro�inst s� T�80O o 197A Mr. Preaident (McCarty) APAroved: `�' �P 3 Attsst: City Clerk Mayor #� � Form a�proved Corpo�ion Gouneel By . a � � � � , • ' - ._ , � a . BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 September 9, 1970 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Dear Sir: ��"�'�'� This is written in response to the petition of Frederick J. Blees to rezone from "B" to "C" Residence to continue operating as a tri-plex property located on the southwest corner of Burr Street and Case Avenue, and more fully described as: North 10 feet of the east 98 feet of Lot 11, and the east 98 feet of Lot 12, Block 9, Edmund Rice�s - ,, . ��irst �ddition. - This matter was considered at the August 20, 1970, Board of Zoning meeting. The staff report noted that the City Architect, in a letter dated June 6, 1969, notified the petitioner that the structure, with one apartment on the first floor and two on the second, is in violation of the Zoning Code. The property, with frontages of 98 feet on Case Avenue and 46 feet on Burr Street result in an area of about 4,500 square feet. The surrounding area is zoned "B" Residence except for this intersection which has one lot zoned Commercial and another lot that is used as a gas station. Staff conclusions noted that the structure, although basically sound, may be detrimental to the area because of deteriorating conditions, age, and extreme high density. The potential for other conversions in the area is high, and if this rezoning is granted, an appeal of the density standards with a 35 percent variance would still be required to legalize the use. The staff noted that if the rezoning is to be granted, that a negative easement be attached restricting the "C" Residence use to the life of the present structure, the occupancy of the present owner, and should be conditioned on continuous compliance of all City codes. The petitioner and his wife, Mr. and Mrs. Frederick J. Blees, noted that the house was converted in 1937 and in 1942 bathrooms were installed, as well as gas and electrical service with no restrictions . They reported that nobody has ever complained, and that the neighborhood considers this an apartment building. Mr. Blees felt that the City has an obligation to tell citizens when a conversion should not be made, and that he feels that density is not a factor. Mrs . Blees stated that they bought the home in 1961 and were not told by the attorney or real estate man that it was in violation. The petitioners presented a letter from the Phalen Area Neighborhood Improvement Program which noted no opposition to the rezoning. The Board, in discussing this matter, noted that the City will undoubtedly receive more petitions like this during the course of inspections by the Building Department. �� 1 -1- � � O , . Mr. Harry E. Marshall (continued) September 9, 1970 It was noted that the petitioner could have up to five sleeping rooms with a duplex under the present zoning. The intense hardship to the present owner of this type of structure was again noted, as was the drastic density relaxation that would be required if the use is to continue. It was noted that the requirements of the Zoning Code are fair and reasonable, and that this use is incompatible with the rest of the neighborhood. Subsequently, it was moved and seconded to recommend denial of this petition to rezone to "C" Residence. The motion passed by a 4-1 vote. Very truly yours, PETER J. MAIETTA Secretary, Board of Zoning PJM:ga f CLS Z. F. �k6945 Encl. : Letter from Phalen Area Neighborhood Improvement Program -2- } � .. i':1�",,;��;i�' AR�A NEICII�3��RIIOOD Ii��f�'�i0� ��'��Y�I��' P��CIiAII CiLfJLRi11_ OPFICL f=1NANCIAL ASSIS'I ANCF_- I�EF{qD. OFFICG Ilu:i 1'AVNL' AVC. G77 1'nVNIC qVL. 7/�-U573.74 n1-�� ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 January 8, 1970 �Ir. Pred Blees J�9 i�urr Street St . Paul , �Iinnesota ;5101 1)ear Mr. 131ees : In �°elation to the question of rezoning the above�mentioned nroperty, it is of the considered opinion of myself and the 13uilcling Inspector assigned to this area that the reauest for rezoning of said property would not be detrimental to the neighborhood for the following reasons : 1 . You are in close proximity to two commercial establishments . 2 . It is under5tood that the structure and dwell� irlg units have been maintained as such since the miciclle 1J30 ' s . 3. You have indicated that if and when the afore- mentioned structure is rezoned you fully intend to comply with the Building, Housing and Fire Prevention codes . Very truly yours , � --``,��ti,� � \`(I�M-�c��- � � HAROLD. J, YAl�TNARELLY Project Supervisor �,. ,� �-- -__ � r� l /cJ�rL�,,,.e,�i ART BOTNLN Building Inspector HJY;han .�,;;�`, � . � ' Ha�ry E. Marshall w�ITY oF Alberl� B. Olsoe ' C�lty/Clerk and �`� ; Commissioner of Repistrattion o ,4_,,.,u,a,�;p � Council RecordPrr G �vN�a�a� �, ' vs �c OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS 38B City/Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 5510� March 5, 1970 Zoning Board� Com�nerce Bldg. Gentlemen: The City Council referred to you for recomanendation the attached petition of Frederick J. Blees to rezone to "C" Residence District the following described property: The north 10 feet of the east 98 feet of Lot 11 and the east 98 feet of Lot 12, Block 9, Edmund Rice's First Addition, located on the southwest corner of Burr Street and Case Averiue. Very t�tuly yours, , �� , , . , . �.x,� �- • � C' Clerk hp � ,-;_:, �� - , �� ° � � N1�G s ZC� }�� ' � . � . :..,a � � a.�$ .�. �� • , . . DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA I13 Court House, 5s102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commissioner LOUIS H. McKENNA, Deputy Commissioner Phone:223-4646 March 5, 1970 To the Council City of Saint Paul Gentlemen: I have checked the attached petitioa of F'rederick J. Blees filed in the matt�r of rezoning, the north 10 feet of the east 98 feet of Lot 11 and the east 98 feet of Lot 12, Elock 9, Edmund Rice's First Addition. The property is located on the southwesC corner of Burr Street and Case Avenue. from a Class "B" Residence District to a Class "C" Residence District aad find that said petition is sufficient. Yo a very trxn�y, : ; _ �' . nes J. Da 1 h : � o�nissio r of F� aace Re: 7C-872 c.c. Mr. Aese s N. R. Heiden Frontage: lOUZ Parcels Eligible - 15 Parcels Signed - 10 or 66 2/3°x Aeeded - 10 or 66 2/3'L ZoNi�G FjLE � � `��' 0 , � � , _ � •' . Fred and Angela Blees , ' 959 Burr St. ' St. Paul, Minn. 55101 . . . �� ..��'�'.��a�u� 17� %`�� % / �� `�n�� i .� .� �� .��n - ��Cy G`�� '/� .�--_ .��; �� _ � �� 4 �,? ' � �,�� G%Zfi`?/ �,.�i� ��i�% ' n� L G�� ;,��-t� ,�,fXL� c' �-C�� -�� . " c � � �: . . . �� Cc'-tt-��/' C�J/�� h� � �1h11?1-Cc? �� L1��'��C!'C�'� ��%'L -� .G��'rt�/ �G � Y L�%%!�- � G� ..'LL'-C� ��C ./.LE?t. �G� �'�'"--�%�� , � . `/ � �r 'i ' , �, � q� �,�, y � �1� ��// ��/�� ,^,. /I� '�v' ��l"�j" i(iL'`?,�- �% G"L-G '�7��!(Jf-.v ..y'vK`� C�'�(,"Y � v-(+' GL�K/L�iy��"c� �� `vLJ •-G � ' ' / � ... /� � . / „ '✓ \ �J n�/}�� C)��,.�,/�jl/,�K./�,/� ��i� ✓��%� ..��/w'�.,�-� /"� � /'�f.�,� � ` % C�jG %i�;�l.r� v�i/v �7 ,^ <J � % .l%��K.K � � l` // �'/K-�E�� /��,�� .�� V%V �G� .�'� �1� .� _ C • �. '�� J G4,li�LG'�� .L�L�1G�✓ ��,�';�7j7(,t,�C .!/Yl�- � ��v✓ t '�2= �.e� �f31.G�" �'�'�(.�" t � � � �� % ' . -/ . ,� �� - -�� -j�� ..�`�"�— �r� � l�. C�'��:��s � ��"�-� � � .�� •�� , � . , , , • ,� �� _�_ Q %�/�� L'r?� �Zd/� ��:/ I'�� (•/t�,�' ��' �'��'1 L%� / / L � • � v � a' � ✓fv��v ,�,e(�� ,�G�''L.�- �L4,��G`'t�'��/ ._�G'�-' -�-G' � /_ ` � GC?1 . � � � ` � �hi %�6•'Le'�► ,� ,C�._.�"�'z�cl�G� L°C`'G,�^..��,,d `�,�1 . � �� - � ��-�� °°�� LE +�� ZC��,� a �� Ft BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION _ August 20, 1970 'lat t�lap ��35 � AcZing under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 — , passed August 22, 1922, as amended to April 6, 1970. 6945 - - -•", ,:�'"".�1'['`S TJA'9E , Frederick J. Blees • � ;�,�AS�IL'ICA'I'ION ; 1 n � Amendment 0 A eal ❑ ?ermit PP �Other X-872 ,3 „��,,,��FJ Rezone from "B" to "C" Residence to ` continue operating as a tri-plex '+• L�iCATI.Otd ; Southwest corner of Burr Street and Case Avenue 5 . I�E�,Ai� ��SCRIPTION : North 10 feet of the east 98 feet of Lot 11, and the east 98 feet of Lot 12, Block 9, Edmund Rice's First Addition. %�� P�:L;I;rJT IOPITPIG: "B" Reaidence % - N;IIZ;UA;1T 1'� 7onin�? Code Chapters 64 Section; .06 F�arat�raph s =3 � :�TAE'F T.PIV�STIGATION � REPORT; Date; 8/14/70 Bys CLS A. SUFFICIENCY: The Commissioner of Finance, in a letter dated March 5, 1970, declared the petition sufficient with 10 of 15 (66 2/3%) of the parcels represented by signature. B. HISTORY: No previous zoning files on this site. The City Architect, in a letter dated June 6, 1969, to the owner noted that there exists one apartment on the first floor and two on the second in violation of the Zoning Code. C. PROPOSED USE: The petition proposes to continue the three-plex use, if rezoned . D. FRONTAGE AND AREA: The property has frontages of 98 feet on Case Avenue and 46 feet on Burr Street, reaulting in an area of 4,508 square feet. E. AREA ZONING: The surrounding area is also zoned "B" Residence except for one lot zoned Commercial across Burr Street on the southwest corner of the intersection. F. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: The plan calls for residential use including single-family, duplex, town and row houses at a maximum density of 15 dwellings per acre. G. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is level and 2-3 feet above the grade of adjacent streets and is occupied by an older two-story brick structure. H. AREA CONDITIONS: The surrounding area is occupied by primarily one and two- family residential uses. Retail commercial uses exist across Burr Street and a new consolidated elementary school site is one block to the northwest. 90 BOARD ACTION: To Recommend � Approval �X Denial Council Letter Dated: Moved by : McPartlin Yeas Nays 9/9/70 X Gadler Seconded by: Gadler x Gauger Date of Hearing X Maietta 9/10/70 Secretary's remarks: Mansur Ames - Ch. Council Action X McPartlin (Alt.) it�ic#as �it�t�x� Da t e Rutzick (Alt.) x Doody (Alt.) Jan. 21, l�'j0 ;�� a � K ( � ._ '�...i,. M _._.___w...,.,_w._$ E ,-...�..._,_a ,..__.__, O , — ``•. Nir. F'r�cleric:> J. B:I_ee� - ,�..� g�Q "_=-�tiz�r St. St. T'au�., l�iru�. � , D��r Sir: ',: - _� . 7_'tl:> ��,,' i:T�1.SS1.�27C'a° `J�' �"l j'f,�*.�,�7Z'+E,' i�0�2a� iE'T` ?:'�'*,P(t �� 1'� :'l�iV C+71iC7Cl�{.. l��1A�. ft�+i'tY' �F-.'4_l'fl..'7'll 'i�7."' �i£.'' .'�z?"'a.i'? �t�'�4�,. .1_ r Ci �,`-7:,x. rdJ.ti��'�i 7.� �^f:� Jf� ; � F __ �Oa'i, l�.s FZ"JC�. �+� �':iT1�?��lt) i��Ce P S i''1�'�� .'';L��1 i "; �-%- °I-F,r, F J�'. �.'.�� c..t. �.. .>'Ji, ��li•,t.�'� COZ°I"t�Y' O� r.'�I,UG ",V�. (l�t'': ;�;3.rr �'�.st "�� i,.�i�a,�� r+r` i�?�li�el7wC i)7.S'tY'1C�' is ins�afficient. � ' " ' , � . . , ^ , ,_.�._ , ; �,, �,, _, For thi� rer�sarr, the Cit'�-�CQi�ic31 i.s ixn�.ble t;a ec�x�s5_der t?�.is mattex. ; '. V�r� °�ruly yotxr�, , _.__.._. City Clerk n� . ; � � . . . . 9-�L� ��o � ' � • CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA ��/ . . • PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTER,� 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE b (7' i / Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. FOr further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date; TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property. (legal description and street address) �: ,., , ;n /, . i: .� , j �- .,-.i i� ,:.. � �-�;, .},�� >v_. .,,, '� ii . _ , . ._ , !- , � .ci <,.�� , .r �.. � _ ., � ; . .; r, � W `{l', 1 ^G ,� � � �- � - . �� +� �� .. �- �' . .. �� -_�.�,-_ _ .� f rom r' �,�,Z' �,��, . , - � . �,� `� �°.,,r_, (,�, .�, ,,r District to � , 1.� ,�,.� (, ,t District, for the ;� purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: � � (describe briefly the proposed facility) ! , r -. �• . . _ � . , <z- �> ?4,- ::.,� „ �'��,,',,�; „_, _ ; _ �. �., ' %. _ �". . � .; , ' . _ /, i�_.� , � ' � '?' - • ,- , . , �,. � - . - ,, , , . . r �• �.r. �. y f � �� _ f � ... _i � . _- � . , . � .,<< � .�, RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Subject Property; � /�,:C�UF�'lC'�( 1j,CEES // r � �, - �, � , _ �, ,�,�_ � /��vi n �Es�,� �,6 taeG �:c � _� 9 53' J �` ` �' , t�: , /��'T,Hv/Z �s �'G�.,nT ' J 7 G - �� , e' `��A/Yf� �tC/J / E�, �,�. , , `% - � .�- ,�-- r� ; ✓ c' �: j_, , � C E�R 6 � J��uN�di�� ' � ,i 1/9 2 �a;� �' i ." � � W/?� ��C�i�i ,fti F 4 4 � W /1 , .� � y . �.5-G 1� a'✓ �` _ � r,''/fl /�y" ,�c �, ✓'/ ! l ��. , �r,�k> ' r � �' k'te��_ ��i / �;� " �) ..`/1„2 ./'k i, ,-�:,.j . . _ . , . ,� U' 7 4�/i > ; �'v" /J i 7/L'` ;�� . .c-Z�-- �� ! - � .'f> � � o , /! -� . , ;'L Y � � J� c . T . . c : i :t,' � ��. — , - lKf1 [��S�0/!/ . �� / L . � � � �/�,f� (��/�� ,'/K/1 F= <,S'D/!/' � V ,S� ` �' % .� � �� / (- ,��l� L-• p�f��N�:S!)f°!� /� � / � Ge�1�� -v / �� G� i State of Minnesota � ZONING �fLE -�}�--+-=- County of Ramsey � ss ` being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who rculated the within petition consisting of pages• � that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribfeda�and sworn to efore me x this ,_7/ / day of „�� . c� �_�_ � _ /� Address; Cf'S� ' Telephone No. � 76_ �� N ary Pablic, ftamsey County, Min . My commission expires �/� '/� ��yJ Approved as to form 1/4/65 �� Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/6� �f,;:;r:; ��u':E o. g�,orrERr '� c;o��"�i�sionRamsey J�r,.�tY. Minn. � . I;i� �y��, ',� ExpireS I3.1973. . �j,md''' � �°�:� :t e ► � , •. � , . , � , �D f � ' ; ' � I CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA A • ' PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTER� 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) �'� �� Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-415�: � ,: (Please type or print) _� f � � , /G>/� Date; �;7�i �� TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL l c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50%, or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property: (legal description and street address) W�RU / _ I.aT /.2 and f�ie /�'�"�� /0 �: v� ,L t97" I/ o f ,�LOC K �j ��su�va �e�cr f r 5� f�1J,U/ t/oN f rom � � /I��jy�,�t' District to �� 2��^y�� District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or o er the �follow'ng• (descr'be briefly the pro osed facility) � j � �� ,�K��/.i�� ,�"..r.��' � � � /9��'� • �� ,� a� �,/'� ..�► C^�. /r°E/ �r� .��,,�i �-c r:o�,�� .� ��z� �� z�- �- ��e'�-�-, RECORD OWNER SIGN UR.E LOT BLOCK ADDITION Sub 'ect Pro erty• � �rr'�D 9��`�� .�t.� , /� 9 ,�vtiv�v G�ic� �'�via t��ES7Ei��c � �-- � " 9 �A t� �-�"�%" L�� =u't�+�c k 1��'4 V!U� �fi l Gt� . /��rNU� cs �o� �T � �7 GAs� � // �'1 �D,�lC�/i�',U lG� � CARl� �E �vHivso � ,:�v ,v� ��.,� .� �7�� ,,. � � c .rt L�.. ��j�` t�� - , I� ��1�l�p ,��C� ,.y�qn�x F��i�r�f, ��. �.�� °� ° � l� 9 �p�1UN.n v��r� E � G� ��sE <a G-cc+l�Gt;. r'�'. M�ir3z'�.� ,�� ' b- � — -u� =� �3 r- r = iT�a�l `G�cTG`� XG'Rrs�4JieR � , / . , � G S� ,,,; , l, %� �1>ly�'n/D �� f�� „ �/,s1. TEr� h�L�SE y '__ � � �.�� J�� - _. � �� ip �DI�G��,�p ;:� �c� „ F/�l AN✓�l. iti�ti K/�JS' _ ._ .,,� �.5� �; -�� , 1 � /G �D MuNi� R ��L � �,`)►f�ti N9ti s� a-�-�-�-....� '�'7 � �9 5��' " � � l3 �Ai� v/�ui �i!�RU��y- ,��.�� s� � J.� I 3 �,9 i�VI� � � ARv� v �'�"�I� �� c �s-� /N l3 �A��v�� .�, Eo �A�c�$;c�� " �/91R 1//EW ��.2 �,W�� 1�`° / resc, � � � �Y'��— q ��D MG�h'l� �lC�� sT� N4�R `�a�.�.� `��°-''".' I 0 q �b lYG'!'vU �/ C E State of �innesota ( County of Ramsey � ss � � . ^ '�/ � being first duly sworn,, deposes and states that he is the person wh circulated the within petition consisting of �� page�; tt;at ths Farties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed .and sworn t efore me this � day of �y�y � � ' '0 ddress• -�� A . C/� , � Telephone No. �,� , ��j otary Public, amsey County, Minn. My commission expires Approved as to form 1/4/65 Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 p, �I.A'fTERT `�n. LOU�� y �ounty�M - mb��on ExPires Jeu►.13+1�7'� Motary • MY� �,,� �'' ^.y.,, P`�` � ;�, 'w��ey�', . � MII�NTES OF THE PUBLIC HEARING BEFOR� THE BQARD OF ZOTTING on fihursday, August 20, 1974,. at 2:00 1�qM, PRESBNT: Messrs. 'Doody, Gadler, Gauger, McPartlin, snd Mai.etta of the Board, and Mesars. Brown �n.d Sorenson, and Mrs. Frantzen of the staff. FRSDERIGK J. BLEES* A petitio�x ta rezone from "B" to "C" Residence to a11ow continuation of a tri-plex on property located on the southweet corner of Burr Street and Case Avenue. Mr, Sorenson sumna�ized the sea£f r�port, a part of the file, and noted the following conclusians: this structure, �lthough basically sound, may be detrimental to the �,area bec��ase of age, deteriorating conditions, and estreme high density. The 'potenti�l for other convers�ons in the area ia high, but would prob�bly not �e a problem without a houaing shortage. This property is 357. short of the', minimum are� required by 4:he Code, even if rezoned. Adequate parking ext�sta for only two cars. The property has owner occapancy, and if this is apprQved, ttae use should be restricted to the life of the present atructure, �he occupsncy o£ the preaene own.er, and should be conditiaued on cont�auous compl.iance to all Code requi.rements. If this rezoning is granted,; an appeal would fs�llow since there is a 357a variance. FoZlowing a qu�stiori £rom the Soard, Mr. Sorenson noted that a legel opinion would be needed Co d��etermiae wheCher 3 ar 5 parking spaces would be required, The petitioner, Mr. �'rederick .J, Bleea, noted that the house wasa't buiYt this way; it was con�erted in 1937. In 1942 bathrooms were installed; a gas meter mnd electrical meter were installed with na reatrictiona. He noted that nobody ha$ ever complained; the neighborliood has considered this an apaxtment buildin�. I� ts his beli�e£ that the Cftq has an obligation to tell citizeas when e conversion shuuAd not be made. He noted thst a �+-plex was made aut of g duplex near�y since others already existed in the neighborhaode He stated he daesn't 'feel density ia a factor. Mr. Soreason explained the difference between overcrowding of a strucCure and �overcrowding of the eite es conCrolled by the Zoning Code. The petitionez's wif� noeed f,t w�sn't their faalt sinc� they purchas�ed it the way it is. Mr. Blees said 4 or 5 �,people occupy the apar�ment units. He pxesented a letter from Mr, Hsrold S� YannareLly, Projec� Sup�rvisor of the Phalen Ares Neighborhood Improvemeat Program, w�ho noted no opposftion to th.e rezoning. Mrs. Bleea ststQd thep' bought the �ome in 1�61 snd were not told by the attorney or real es�aCe men that it w�s in violation. The titl.e was brought up-to-date in 1951. Mr. Gauger noted that �he Zaning Board will �nao��a�y rece�tve more petitioas like this when other h�m�s are inspec�ed B�y the Buitdiag Department. -8W FREDERICK J> BLEES (8�20/70) (Continued): Upon a �uestion by Mro Doody, Mr. 5orenson noted that this structure could be a duplex, plus could conCa�� up to five sleeping r�ocna. Mr, McPartlin moved for deniel af t�e petitio�, noting that � drastic densiCy relaxation is required which is absvintely incomp�tible �ith the rest of the neighboxhood. He stated Che Zoning Code fs fair �nd reasonable, and fails to see any hardahip in Chis case. The motion was s�conded by �Sr, Gadler, and carri�d by a 4-1 vote. Mr. Doody voted in �pposition stating it was not the �ault af these people �nd that he would like to eee the asa maintsined. Submitted by: Calanel L, Sorenson Robert Lo Ames, L'hairman -9- . , �ity C�e�k . . , , , , ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 August 28, 1970 File X872, Page You are hereby notified thaC a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on September 10, I970, on the petition of Frederick J. Blees to rezone from a "B" Residence District to a "C" Residence District the property described as follows: The North 10 feet of the East 98 feet of Lot 11, and the East 98 feet of Lot 12, Bl.ock 9, Edmund Rice's First Addition. The property is located on the Southwest coraer of Burr Street and Case Avenue. For further infosmation, contact the Planning Board, Room 1010, Comonerce Building, or telephone 223-4151. This notice of a public hearing has been sent out fra�n the Depart- ment of Finance in compliance with the City Charter. ROSALIE L. BUTLER Coamissioner of Finance O ' ' � . . , . �/'`I � d DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE ��b�� , , ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA 113 Court House,6b102 JAMES J. DALGLISH, Commiuioner LOUIS H.MeKENNA, Dsputy Commiuioner Phone:223-4646 Jau�ar� 21, 1970 Yo th� Connail Cit� of Saiat Paul (:estlar�a: I kav� c�eckei the� attached petitioa of !'rederick J. Bless, filed in the �atter of resoninE, I.mt 12 amd t�e porth 10 feet of Ist ll, Block !, Bdamail 8i�e�s First Additioa. T�e prepe�t� is 10- catai on tbe s�thirest aorn�r ef Caae A�enne au�d s�rr Street, fr�n a Clasa "E� Besiden¢e District te a Clas: "C" $�sidaaee Histriat, ud.find that sai� �etition ia insnffiai�st. Yc�e�rs very trnl�, �. �.,,._. �- a�es J. lglis� ,,�� Coa�issi er of saaae Re: Z•�54 ec: Mr. Ar�s lt. 8. Heidea l�rontage: 1ti� Yaramis Bligibl� - 16 Parcels 3igaed - ! •r S6x Uee�ed - 11 or 66-2/3� �O � - - - - � � ��-- - � -p- -p--- ,.; ) ; 'J � :� J U �.) O O O ��i i i i v v v V v v � p -- - -- -�- -(}�4 _�_- --� � 1i �� r� o �-- � O O -iL- ° � I I i / � ----tl--u- - - - - -- - - � O -0- ' �-- - - - - - - - ' -- ---- ---- — -- �� • � ' ' �-- - --� � ---�- �! --, � � i � � � , 1,v v v v v � � u r---Q- O __ -Q--- - -- ) O Q Q O O U ¢ O� (7 �C� !O � �Oi ' --- — -- - --- � � _ � � � , , -O- O 0 �5 _�,` ,.> gF ----� � � C O o K AVE. � O 7 � ,,,� � ' C,�� •� r:- o �7 � ; - -.. _ � _ __ Q ' -� -- -- . '� ' � �'� i , � ` v �� v � -�--J C.� =0--�� -- ZS__� O - ' � � p -- , E-----�� , � ---�; - „ _�O - - 1 � �`� __ p - --- - �--� �- J� i ---- � 1 ' �-- - ---- - I a �`�� i T --� -O ; -U- _ �- A.-� ----v - - - � �� ' � � � V � i � 0� � �'� � � � � � � �. �.r � •:/1 � io 1 O -�;r �; LAWSOM AV� µ, � � Y �i � � , --� --a- ----< -I E > __ � . � _ � _ ? � d , ,� - � _:�- � , i � i I i � - ---- --- - -- -_a. i i 1 ' i i � i � � C�N.SOC 1 DATE D -p- � Q < O 1 � � �L. _i_ � sc Ho o L - ---� , -- � - ,- �_-_ - O �- < T , T ��? S/ T E ��_--{ �- � - - --- � I I � -�--�-- ' -T- i ' . p � � I � � � , �IO U-� ~ � _� � � __ t' __ �- q �- � � � , � G R A N T -o- --, �- o � ;` ' �`_ �R /C SSDN �� v� v �O � �� J 'J J �J p -- _--� --�- _ —. .. _ {�- ! - ;. � . . � _,; � � - le , O �RN ,C) J t. L �ti c o�. � _ ��--t �--- , ; o i o -o- � o ' ' ' �+ � _ _ � � ---- -- --�_ , - - _ _l�__ __-- - --� -- ---�-- _ -o- �, ; _o- � ' ----� °_ � °-- -; �_ -a- r� ' -1-�1- > � � � � � oio o � o � � � -o `� o , � � -T T � i � �� -- , O 0 U C�; O -� O �.0. , -- _ _.. -- -- _ -_ _ __ _ -- -- � _ ___ _�- �AS� GON►iNFQ�iAL F1V� --- ' ��-� , [� W � 1, i � 0 l.} I � � (�� Q_� j � , F _ 7' - �-- Q l.} ( {� .S=�--� ----- - ___ __ _ Q r--�- ; ---- t} � i � � _ --� -� c;� � � Q � � --� ---- - F- - ----- , i � , �� __ _ - - �--- - ---- -----� "__._. -- -- - - -- � � , V� -�(� i . � ' � •` r----- - ------ '�.., i -Q_ '-'C�"' �tI '..J � ..� 2 Y _� ' i ' -- �.. ____._ _ __---. - L- - �-�-_. C� O -- - - v �_ -- O � _-v- __ � � - �-- -- _ _� _ ^ � I ---� � - --- ^ __ n .� �1 -- _ _ _ . _- ------- - -- - ---- - _ � __o _ a > � _� _ j , � � 3 �?---�--- ---- r �- _ _ ----v �., �v `^ �-- -�-a j i � � � � - - '�..�- � U O � �; _ __- J -- -- ----- ----- -_ p. __.__. _-- - "' - � °� o -� _ c�=_ � o _ _ _ o o �� ..� �q G > �0 < - � � _ ---__ ----- --_ _-- ----- ---- � - _ -- - --- 0 0� � o � c� Q � �- - ---- - ---- --- .�; -o- -o- > < o ; o 0 0 ------- -- _._ — --- __ _ _ - s��5 -__� I� - -o-- o- - _ � o 0 0 � > ' < ' � O ' - - _ -- - - - - , �,-i_ -- - -- - - - -- - - -, � - � ,in � -- � I -� --U- i Q O > \ Q � o,�� c ►c�� , ' -�- ---_ _ _ _ _- - - - ---__ -- ? , �`'; ° ---�- -, -r �- � � - �., o �._ i_ > � o — . _ ; .� V . I - _- . _ti �, _ . . . . _.. . . __ __. . .._ (� _o- ;_ + ,__ ' � r--- _ O / O ��`� �- T � {} t� -_._.- -T- - � t. - _,_ � C� � ,CU I i O -__ .__ _ --I - - -r E 1-- ---_ I � t- 0 � I O � r-- O Q, O F -- �T � ' O � � ' �'% � ; ---� -,-- i---1-=_�- o i �' �o � � o o--, ,�, YORK , AVE. v ' 'p �� p�-=_=__-_�_ 0 _� „ ; o � � - � .. ,. ; � � " � O � iZes�4�N�& --- t- - _.__ __ --- -- - --- - -a _��- _ �---- C1 i � + - O- ' �I � �'-" - _ ._ __ _._ _.. _ - - __. _. �- ----- ' --;---- .. ---/� , . - -1--� -- (n --d O O -� % - y.�� -�- � -O- O O O- � . � -_ � _ _ _--- - --_------- � - _ O ,.---- _ +�- � �J,_ - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -Ct- -. . .�' _ t , , O O I . -- --- s'-. _ ----fi-- � - _t-- - -- -�--- -- - --- , ___ - - -- -- - - __ -- ------- - V �, �, {-;- - - �— O h �-—r < � -O- O > � O - - - -.- - -- - --- - --- — --- ----- � � ---� O 'a C� �- O ,�� ! � � O , - --__� __---_- ---- ,_--- -- --- � G � � s � , � -F-- -- � s�. � S T. -o- o �-- o 0 0 __ --- - --- ,,, -�___- �_ - -- o--- --------- --t ,-_ - —.�_ - �, --a- I o ' ,, o � - - - , � � � ---- --- ---- - - : r q �� ; p. i ---- � �• � -�--� '0'- � � � `� ,---0 _ Cl � E}- -� � ' • � � �s,., �, �, -- ---}-- -1-- -T ��, ---r---T- -�,--�t-- --,-r , t- �-r- �, � � � � , , ' I ! �--�-- -a- , � � 0 � � � _�-�- - � � ,� � � � � � � � �• �� - ' � � o � _ _ j � ',� ' � � �, ,., i � � � � � t-= .�r- � c i I i �-- -- I � � W � ,t� G _ ��,.i i i i ��i i i � G c.� �� (n O � i� � �O � �O �O ;O ��, � O t��0i0 � � �`i � i 4� � � � � � WH ITA�L ST. �-�-�.,_ r--�. c--� F--�--�. r�-� ��-.--�: r---,�+. _ _ .. ,.:...,, � - �� _APPLiCANT F=eae=�� :�, 8�8�8 � �LEGEND � � $ - w �, o ;, � o „ r PURPOSE Rezone from "B". to "C" Reeidence to LAi�D USE J U continue operating as a tri-plex � � O ONE-FAMILY ' Q v � �' ti � - � PRESENT ZONING "s�� Residence �r" TWO-FAMILY � � —'— m -- - � — � _ . � THREE- FAMILY � � i i ' '- -��- FOUR-FAMi LY � -�-�--- ; I PETITION SIGNERS 10 0� a poaeiblo is (66 2/3�) 7 � MULTI- FAMILY -�-- � ---- � -�-- —'� ,�__..— � � i � �---~ --�— --� � 6945 �/\�`� � � C4MMERCIAL � � - --� -}— ==---}---, , � FILE No. nlp�,�rH � • a . -- - -�•___ -1 _ , - • � INDUSTRIAL ;.�-_-. - --�_- - . ---� i v VACANT ,�-_--`�--- -=--=---r--_'__� . __�_ �-_�-____. , r----;- • _�___.__�� I; St. Pau� Plannin Board Date� s/12/�0 - �---.---� _� IL--- _____. 9 , Q� Property under consideration�--T=._�___.__�_ __ _� - a-- - _.- _._ -- �.,�..�- _ -•-_=�--=-t-� � �' ^ � -- .�-�+� � _. . _ .�._ — - - -�--_-�.�c � I �� _ . .- ry�)l,/ �.{ i� ///�, Y �� . �' .. A^�"�-.� �4+5,.,PpS�AGE ." .. � � 1�-.,' � �.. � . i'^`-'°"-s.;W _. - - . . /� / �� ;`� t!�±"i r , __--� � `� � V � �`: �' �/a � r,, ,;� ,. � > -- - � _. � - I� � F�F4NK4N 4R0l� .. • i ... � \I�� ' " - � - w � � _ � : , . ,pCt,. + � � � � � . _, - ' C/� ; , , . __ }� t,''r v� '.. ,� � % c.� - Z �'� . � �� n �� Y �� . 0 _ . � . �v �� a i � Ist � � . . ` 2nd �x Laid over to 9' 3rd and app � _�4dop+ed �� Yeas Nays Yeas Nays Butler � �Butler Carlson ��v=?�>��*,.� \Carlson Levine `Levine Meredith � �eredith Sprafka `. . �Sprafka Tedesco �edesco � � Mr. President McCarty Mr. President McCarty �O