The URL can be used to link to this page

256251 Oriatnal to City Clerk �-- r � ' �OR� DI �T�TANCE 256251 COUNCIL FILE NO. PRESENTED BY �•�CS1 � ORDINANCE NO �� 1�n ordinaa�e ameadir�g the Zoning Code, Chapt�rs 60 to 64, ia�lusive, of tlae Sau3t Paul �,�qisiative Code, pertaining ta Use Di�tri�t�, 8ei�ht Distri�ts �nd Rezoniag of certa�in propertie� ia the City ot Sa�ir�t Paul, as ameaded. THE C��IL �F "PSE CIq'Y 4F Sl�ID1T P�tT�, DA$3 ��lI1Tz Section l. �at the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, iaclusive, of tbe Sair�t Paul Leqislative Code, pertaining to IIse Districts, Height Districts snd Rezo�ainq of certain properties i� the City of Saint Panl, �s amended, be and th� same is hereby f�rther amended so at� to re�one th� followir�� described property from "!l" �Le�ideuee �istriet to "C" �esidence District, to-wits North '� of the West '� of Lot i8, l�arth � '� of Lots 19, 2�, 21, Blmck 2, Crnick- shaak's 6arden Lots, aad the DTorth � of Lot 22, except the �crth 135 feet thereof, South � of the East � of the - �orth � of Lot 18, Block 2, Cruickshank's Gardes i�c�ts f sitnate oa p=operty located �a the so�th side of York Avenae betwe�a Birmi�gham asd Hazelwaod ia the City of S�iat �+s�l. 3ection 2. Thi�s o=dinaa�e sha�ll tmke effect and be in force thi=ty (30) days froa� and after its p�a�age, mpproval aad p�blication. � : APPRpVED � Asst. Corp r tion Counsel N OV 19 1971 Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council �er � � In Favor � Meredith � D A gainst Sprafka Te'�ese°' 197� Mr. President y) - N OV 19 App . At st: � , "`�''"�..► Clerk a �� Form approved Corporation Counsel By Y �i Z �'�� ' �4iBLtSN�E:: � f . . . � . . • -s� �1 ��3°�; � x�. �,"'°'� � ` ��1.�„ f , . N � o,�G ,�!.-�`- / 8', ' , ' G �� X l � 3 /�� 1 S 7 � ��. •�. ,ti. � � ,��.C. N, �' �.l-� � �' �z � X 3 � 3 � / �� -' G � � -�-fl`•� ,� N. � � -�*-�` � � - �.o - z 1 , 1 2S �.o � -`-�• �" �00 '�31� ' J N. % ,� ,�m-�' � �. ,�c . ,?�. C�I. / 3 S.�' , �oo x � 78 , / 7� 8' o o -�. .�` __ _ :- .:Y , �v �� _ . � v � � � � � ; � �9i� /o� l S7 ��G �� 19as Ga. js. �,�� D �,-�� L�``�,� a�n`�� . S� � O O ��.�. - a�rt p�`; p s 1 7 � $ v Z��.�. % 7 !� � 7 � q . ' � � . CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE n� co� new. ssios September 10, 19�1 City Clerk 386 City Hall Rile X1096, Page You are hereby notified that a public hearing, wiZZ be held in the Council Chambers of the City Ra11 and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on September 23, 19�1 on the petition of Willi�a H. Paul and others for the rezoning from an "A" Residential District ta a "C" Residential District the property described as follows: North � of the West � of Lot 18, North � of Lots 19, 20, 21, Block 2, Crufckshank's Garden Lots, and the North '� of Lot 22, except the North 135 feet tbereof, South � of the East � of the North '� of Lot i8, Block 2, Cruickshank's Garden Lots. The property 1s located oa the South side of York Avenue between Bismingham aad Aazelwood. Far further informatfon, contact the Planning Board, �oom 1010 Coamerce Building or telephone 223-4151. To comply with the City Charter, the Department of Finaace is charged with informing you of this public hearing. If you have any questions, it is recaa�ended that you attend this public hearing to afford you the opportunity to make your views, both pro and con, known to the City Council. ROSALIB L. BTrl'LBIt Cor�issioner of Finance �� f . , • �,ETITION �(] � '}�":. � : . . k � �� y �� x�� St.� �ia ,�o tb; ,�'� e� . s� �i' ;� 18, . 1v �: ° o$f I76t' , 5� =i ' 9 � en. fa, ted� Xork.Ave. Rwe�el Si,�m- : Plezelwood Sts., to ,�•C•• District, the-Counc9l ofl th,e t Paul laas flrted tiie ffi3rd da of ber, ig7i, at ten o'olock 1n� in the Couneii Cha�+nber �+ �oP safd City,_ax� at , t� Cdttncil'w9ll o ee;iond.aud ' s dl�no- ,�" ; � �� "..� : EI� �, 19 f �s � t, . .;.�. . _. _. rr .C%�,�,� W"tL�IAt•i_�f.. PfaUI. RIGHARD C. DRd�I�) (contir�ued) September ?., 297L Mx. Mai�tt;� c�31ed far the questian, and th� motion carried by a 5-0 vote. Sc�ba�iLted �y: Approved by: �'aul T.a �set[er Roi�ert JG� Amea ' . i Harry E.Mars�all � �'T'" °F Aib� d.Olso� City Clerk and �°w�'2 Counoi.l Kecorder Commiaaioner of Regiabration `= e-° � �,;;•°�;;: �� _. - ��` OFRICE OP THE CITY CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS a88 City Hadl St.Pau1,Minnesota 58108 Aug. 17, 1971 Zoning Board� Comm�erce Bldg. Gentlexrnen: The City Council referred to you for recoa�nda,tion the attached pet3tion of William H. H. Paul and others to rezone the follcywing described pxaperty to "C" Residence D3strict: N2 of �he T� of Lot 18, N 2 of Lots 19, 20, 21i B7.ock 2, Cruiekshank's Garden Lots, and the N 2 of Lot 22 except the N 135 feet thereof, S 2 of the E � of the N 2 of Lot 18, Bloek 2, Cruickshank's Garden Lots, lc>cated on the south side of York Av�enue between Birmin�ham and Iiazelwood. Very tr�aly yaurs, �� `-• � -� City Clerk hP �� f� (� C�' � � � [� D - r - -�;#� -� - AUG 17 1971 � � � n , � i 1� / � . �'`��'��`�-'� ��`�� 1�Ir PLANNIf�G BOARD � .. . �..� .� ir.t P��.!: P�"��"�s�t� �z . ' , + + � , CITY 4F SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE � 113 CaM Hows 55102 August 17, 1971 To the Council City of St. Paul Geatlmea: I �ave checked the attaehed petition of ililliam H.H. Paul and others, filed ia the �atter of re$osiag, N� of the W�e of Lc�t j8, N � of Lots 19, 20, 21, Block 2, Cruickshaak's Gard�n Lots, a�d the N�i of Lot 22 except the I� 135 feet thereof, S� of the E� of the H� of Lot 18, Block 2, Cruickshank's Gardea Lots� The property is located oa the south side of York Awenue between Birmingha� aad Hazelwood, . fro� a Class "A" �esidence District to a Glass "G" 8esidential Di�trict, and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours verq truly, i:'��.� �' .� L $osalie L. Bntler �=� Coamiissioner of Fiaance Be: 7C-1096 c.c. Mr. Anes N.R. Heiden Nrs. Butler Froatage: 100� Parcels Eligible - 28 Parcels Signed - 24 or 85-5/7� Needed - 19 or 66-2/3� - ,' ', , .r ��,�j� � - u �;,�+� tl\!1��'7C�'l -� � . .'� � � � � � lJ � D AUG 1 '7 1971 CITY PLANNlNG BOARD� Saint Paut, M6nnesota q�� , , . BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 September 15, 1971 ��2,5� Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk 386 City Iiall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: This is written in response to the petition of William H. Paul (Richard C. Drake) to rezone from "A" to "C" Residence for the purpose of constructing apartment buildings, on property located on the south side of York Avenue between Birmingham and Hazelwood, and noted in detail by the legal description on file. This matter was heard at the September 2, 1971 Board of Zoning public hearing at which time the staff report noted the frontage and area, area zoning, the recommendation of the Comprehensive Plan and the site and area conditions. The staff said that the area of the site would allow 172 dwelling units under "C" Residential zoning. A petition in opposition to the rezoning was acknowledged. The staff noted some of the factors relevant to the rezoning decision. They included other "C" Residential districts in the area, the topography of the site and of the general area and the condition of platted streets in the area. Mr. Terrance 0'Toole, who represented the petition, indicated the topography justifies the rezoning saying the site would require extensive grading. He explained the proposed development stating that it is a definite proposal and that driveways and utilities would come from York Avenue. He said Birmingham Street would soon be opened up providing access to East 7th Street. Several residents of the area appeared in opposition. One stated that if apartments are built, there will be cars parking on the street in front of his home even if off-street parking was provided. He noted the unspoiled nature of the land as it is and said it was not developed because the owner used to live on the land himself before fire destroyed his home. Another noted that homes in the area are all fairly new and said that their values would be diminished if apartments are built nearby because people would then have trouble selling their property. In considering this matter, the Board noted the zoning of adjacent land, the topographical character of this site and highway plans for this area. It was argued that the presence of apartment buildings increases rather than decreases property values and that there is a need for more housing to increase St. Paul's population and tax base. Another argument pointed out that this proposal, O City Clerk -2- September 21, 1971 if successful, would urge other rezonings in the area. Subsequently, the Board heard a motion to recommend approval. The seconding motion noted that Birmingham Street would be built through to East 7th Street. The motion carried by a vote of 5 to 0. Very truly yours, � R . MA I TA Secretary, Board of Zoning PJM:kk PLR Z.F. ��7218 iillv`U�ES OF �:k1E I'U�3T.��C H�RIPiG BLrx OR�'S T[i� �h'JT OI�' ZQ�i�NG ��3 `�'�iURSDL1x, S��SBE�. �, Z971, at ?.:f30 p.m. P�2�S�1T; �ixs. Cochran�; 2+Iessrs. 13enshoof, M�.Partlira, Plaiet�a ar�d M�au�ur �� f th� Boarc�; MF�s�rs. 33��wn nnd �t��3ett�r, �nd �Co Kantc>rowic� o:� �he staf.f. �JI�.�£.'��i I-I., Iyf��;�. _�,.�C�T�.F�]) �, 13.�2AK��: �A p��ition to rezone from '°A►` �0 0°�`� It��XCier_c� ��o�aerty LocaGed mn �he soutt3 sic3e of �.'ork A�venue between B�.'�eing�ir�s� :�r:.d �:ia zc lwood. ?�x. Rose9:ter. sumr�zaxi��d th� s�.af� rePor�, � pa�t o£ the file, �:y sc:�C��ag tT�rat the rs�}�cr�:y under c.on��.ci��afi.ion h�� an irregular sh�pe wi.:h �ro�tag� a�.e►�g �ork L�vpr_ue� Bit�ninghan� Si.reet �ad Stillw��er Avet��se. °�(i,: frontage a�.�ng Yo�k �,vers�a�� is 46?.S :��r��; �tr�ng �iir�ingham SLreet 1478 yzet; ana ��.cx�g StiL�w�ater Avenu� 6?:� fee�. Th� ar.ea is apprcxfmt�tely 1;?.,?49 aqusr� ��et crhach �,ao.�ld all�cu �.7? u�s�t� uuder "�t1 ?t�aideace. The frcntege �long ��sL- 7tn Stree� is zoned Corr•sz��rc;,a�.; ��c of Sirmin�h�ni Stx�ee� is zoned 1°�`" Residence. Northwes� O� ��'i�5 site is mn are� of t9�1Q Resid��ice �ac�ing. To ttie eust �s ;-oned °'A" Itesic?��ace �rith �n� n.�.aer four-unir ap�a.•tmer�t on a "C" Residence ��rcel, ihe Ccm:pr�i��nsive Flan r�camrnends highw�.;� inter��ctio:�s �� t¢�is �ite. '�he �opcsgr��ny o� si�e site is n�s: sevexe. x'he aiea ,��aceur �c� Yor�?: �;ven�L a.s higt2er €:h.an the area adj�cen.t to unimproveci St�.11water AvEnue. Thcp lacicl i3 ��car�t. Yark r�venue is canimproved from B�.i minghaan Street T��s?.:wsrd. Sti�.Iw��cex� ��venue is uriimproved a:� is BirminF;':am Street f�-cnn Xe�rk. Ava�a�ue ta East 7�:h Str.ee�:. t�r,cess f�om �he w�st is 13.miCe3 to C�s� �=�eneie froxn Sailnson �?mrl�,��y to �f.rmingh�m or. �arclay thers soutl to York Avenu�. Yo�_k A�*en.ue p�mti-ides ac�Ass t��r. Wtxite Be�r �venue six blocks t.� �tae ea3st. Mx. 2o�e�ter nd�.ed �he s��f-£ Y_P_C.C.'��@d �a �etS.�ion i� oppasition t, tt�� rezar�im�. P1x, RQSut�er a�o�e�d sam� o� the facr.oxs to be consid�red in t��.s r19aaai�ge H� poin�:ed 4�4 �tie Car�a�rc�.t�s.�� ,�s�ed fzr��.ttr.�e along ��at 7t[: �trEee �nd �rYae 2xisten�e of a "C" Rts�d�?Yir_4 �is�rict just south of ehe sub;ec•. �srcel� H� a�oted the ;��x��din�; �ezoninb b�iore th�� ouncil �hat is ad�acent t� tE�is site. He n�ted tkrat these parc�e3.s hav� a�rect �ccess to �ast 7th S.reet but �thaC t�� sit� under consid�gati.c3n does nat ss Birmi.n�hsm is not ��velop�d. T�e l_og�.c�l xou4:� for tr�tiic �x�o�n �Ch�.� s3.tE would be to use �Cese Av:�ue. AEii�, he ��d, wr�uld t�rin�; car� �arae ��' �he �sme objections ss e��r� hE�rd �� a� last 7ay�.�� "t3osrd me�t;.c�g, naa�e?�r tl:�t t�.�xe sre no sidQ�aalks �x stiz�g elc�ng Csse Avenc�� ar_d t;a�re are � namb2s� uf pedest*fane in th�t �ar�a. �'nexe are many �eop1Q frem tFiL Gr�ex�bri�r Hom� ore thw corner a£ Css� ;zd �Sirming��m 'a�.� us� Einuxxa�Ya��u StraFt fo� y�rd axea. He �s��d if cert�.n :�txe�et� ir� the e�se� guch �s Cs�c� ;aere ��grad�d, the cast wiLl, be sE�arid by a21 L�,nd own�rs �la�J ttze �tse:�ts an a fr�:�t faotage bas;s. �ir. Rcsetter �.a�ed ther� �s a °'C1t ?tesici�;r�ce �i:sL-r3r�: Lz�ausdi�t�l.y sd�Qining the site witi3 � fcaur-iiuit �p�:°L-ment buiidir��;. H� fux�h�x��+_•�d �here fe a "G" a��sidsnc� Dtst�rict �cross �'z•am t��e C=r�erb�iEr Hcme. Tt�Ls property waa r�r.Qn�d ia 196�' mnd this ca�z �e e:v��i �;� cwid;��ce �e:�.�her �or �r r�gains� �he cezo��:g. �n or�� s?nse= ;€L- :r�e�ns tizzs rculcS ►i��r� �he p�te:��i�l of clx�ngirs� tt�.e ch�rr�cter of �he n�ighi��sr.��x�c�c?. :��: c��:�_tl also be a�r�u�d th�t since th� si�e ��fi ��e��a v�canC s�.ncs� ��.e �:eznzz9..�-L, x.�� 9u2, tihere may nat �e � nz�rkec: for �r,+�.l�:�p�E haus�r+Q bn ftlz� .3bE<^�. f•fc. Rc,��ter. :eeported ^h.�a� �:ae �opogrra�:�y of the sitn doe� aaat c;�:�m 4� �ae �o ��z�re r�s to pz�ohibi.� CF� dev�i.opnr:,�t �f ui�gle-f�rn�.L;r (.c::zes. 3S.�rzi.rs��.n S�rQet ��pears trr be n�: gr.ade �cavel ai.r3 i�fluld WII�IAM Iis S'ALtF, RICTrtARI3 Co bRAK�) tcant�r�ued) September ?.., 1971 aot requir� � axeat deal af fill s�ct St�.11taster Avenue is at .ufficient gr�� o be developed. He said th�s fact could also be used to argue either for or against rezonin� eince the development of Stillwatex Avenue could sllow sin,�le-f�m�ly pl�tting siong i�, If Birmxnghsm w�re developed, it �ould als� ease the traffic on Cas� Avencae wfiich w�g ore of the uuijor objections to the rezoning, he said. lanother faetor Mr. I?osetter noted Ls that in the area soue[� of the railroad tracks there is a great d2a1 of vacant Land much of whi�h has severe topography. Thi.s �ay a�rve �s evidence Chat this Iand should be zoned for a m�ore intensive use. There are two ways to hendle land �that has aevere topography: �Develop the lar�d with a more int�asive use, or acquire the lttnd �or ope:�-s��c�. Mr. Maiettca asked in comparir<g the tapogxaphy to �aet 7th Street, whst is the top elevation �f this particul�r piece o,`. property. Mr. Rosetter Yeplied that it doe� seem to rise in r.aE ceneer and �1�ntsslight�y to Birmingham and York; ar the southeast corner, it is e.ven lower. In the cen�er, ft seem� to be sfx f�e� a��ve the {�r�de of York. Mr. Maietta a�lced if there wece taees and brnsh an the area to which Mio Rosett�� repZfed the are� was wooded. Repreaenting th� petitioner was Mr. TErrance Q'Toole, attorney, wha noted that part o3� ttx� are� was not developed becauEe of the topography. He noted the staff s�ate.s these �re noti sev�re topographical conditions existing, but fn: his op§.r�ion �e11 the �.and :nus� hr�v� extens�ve grading. Z"his woul.d ��.e it �oo expensive for singl��family hoiae�, he said. His client proposes to build three apartme�it bu�.�dings; twc� �-unit buiLd:�ngs and one 50-unft t,uild�ng for. m tota�l or 134 eznits. Mr. 0'Toole �t�ted ehis is 30°1', under the maximum �etzsit_y that would be allow�ed on th@ p�operty. Mr. 0'Taole dispLayed � schemati� af ;;he pzoposal to the Boasd. '�t►e entrsnces to th� prap�rty woulci be �rom Ya��k Avenue. 6fff-s�reat parki�►g would exist at the back of the buildings a�nc� betw�en two of rhe buildings. Mr. 0'T�ole said �he apart- ment bui�di�sgs would raoL incoavenience any �f the neighbora and would add to the ta� b�se c�f eta` Gity. This is � worthwhile pro,ject for tne benefit s�f tt�.e taxp�yexs of the City of ��< Paul, h� said. �Sx. I�ia�,etta �slced �ir. Q'Te�ole if the property in its present state is cut down or filled �c� c�r�y way. t�ir. p'Toole rep�.i�:d it was not; �here are i�ills which Px�.st �nd ��ad dacrn tc, gul�.i�s. When Che prAp��ty is grac�ed, thex� w�.11 be excFSSi.ve d�_x� .�nd the ��splicara* will �ro'uably make a desL wirh raho�ever owns �h� Larn�l a�cljacer�t to his propezty to u�e the �lirt Co fiY1 that land. Mr. 0°'�'�aole sta�:ed the only way the property is going to be developed is tc, grade the t�igh spnts t�a th� low spots. Mr, M�nsux asked �f any soil conditrons ar problems were pzesent and if any soil tests h�d been done. �Ir. Q`Toole ��epZied th�t no soil tests had been da�a�e on the scsb�a�c:� pr.operty. Air,. Mafett� stated tie is veYy famil�r �,rith the as�a snd he canno� �anderstsnd �ahy Fing�.�-fa��n3.ty �esideaces heve no� been bail� in the area. There mu�t be � �oad rensat� �aF thi�. Zn samie c,f Ch�se �r�as, s3ngle-family const,:uct�on �.s very ex��n.^,ive. WILLIAM Hs PAUL (RICHARD C� �7I3,�ItE) �c�ntinued) September 2, 197L Mrs. Cachrane asked if tfis same Cyp� of construction does not make it equa2ly expensive for "A" Residence as for "C" Residence, Mr. 0'Too1e re- plied th��. when 134 units ar�e built on an nrea such �s this, much of the money sper�t for. fixing up the site is spresd over 134 units end gained back. If sin�gl�--fmmi�.y homes were buil.ti on the same are�� the cost wouZd be spread over only fo�r or five houses an�3 �(�►ia would cosfi about 5-IO thousand dollars per house, he s�id. Mr. Maietta st�ted thst if � house is l�ui1C where it is very expet�sive, auch as for fiil, one is no� going to get any �erter mortgage from a mortgage company. Mrs. Cochr�n� asked ff Birrningham or 5ti'Zwater will be put throngh. Mr, 0'Toole repl2ed tha�: Birmbnghmm would be put throagh, however, he is not sure abo�� Stil3.wa¢er; �he appliesnt �s not planning to ha�ve it opened upe P9re McPartl3�n asked if the traffic will use East 7th Street or Case Avenuee Mr. 0`Toole said it depe�ds upo� the residents of the apartment buildings. East 7th Street is e through atr�e�; Birmingham will open up soon ta �ast 7th - Street, he ssid. Orhe� rezonings �.n: the area will open up the streets; who- ever is pl�nning the athe�~ rezar�ing wil� want to have Birmingham Street opened up. Mrs. Cochrane asked c,rh��e tt!e areas zon�d "A" R�sidential were located. Mr. Rosetter noted �dj:�cent �o the si�e is one lot that is zoned "C" Residential b�st the arer� e�st c� r.hat ia "A" R�sidential. Mr. Maiet�a aNk�d rir., �'r3'c�ol� if imprc►v�menCs will come fn from East �th St�eet to which he r�plied �h�y wo�ald r.GSne in £rr,m Yorlc Avenue. Mr. Bensh�o� s�ked M�. Q�T�ole if thez°e wexe def�.nite plans to btiild these apertment buildings ore ��x�s �#.t�. �fr. 0`Tcaale staCed Lhis ia a defi�ite proposal. Yf apprav�I �.s «abteine: f�sr the rezonir�g, the app�icant wiYl come forth with an app.'._ics�t��iz io� e parki.ng lot. Speaking in oppositio�. vaas Mr. �i��e� �Guchenbaker, 14?.S York Avenue, who noted he lives katty-cs�r�.er acros� the s�re�t frrnn the snb�ect prapexty. Mr. Kuchenbaker asked wh�tt the m�ax�in� ag "B" Residence was. Mr, Rasett�r uoted this meant the property cauld be de�reloped in one and two-f�mi2y homes. Mr. Kuchenbaker st�ted ?�e �wants the axer� 4�o stay ss it is. If apartments are built across frcam t2is home, cnr� wilZ always be p�rking on �he streeta Mr. AlcPartlin noted ths� �th.e apartmenL• busldings must provide space for off-str�et g�rkin�. Ni;-. Kach��b�ker sai.d resident� of the bufldings will still park on �he s�reee. �'c:rthex�mva:e M�. Kuche�baker said there �r�2 ;�oods ia the are� which contsit�{ bi.rds, pt��ss�r,t,, etc. and this will. slZ be snoi�.ed if apartment besild�x�gs s�e bu3.1t. �ie ssid he r�a�.izes that Mr. PauL muai: have some man�y out of th� pro��rty �s urall. as the City. The reasan it was x�ot built on before, he �ai.cl, was because Bill Paul oomed the sub3ect property cahich w�s his p�r�nts° i�a�a�. ;�Ir. Paul w�ent to the hospitsl a�d fire destroyed the ho�iue� He h€ss since naoved from the area and now �vv�nts to g et rid of �Yae property. WILT,aIAAf Ho P�tTI� ;AIC1EiAR�1 C, DRAI�) �continued) September 2, 1971 Speakin� fn oppos�tion was L�v�lyn ��.t�mpfer, 1420 York Rwenue. She noted the homes in Che ar�a are a1�. t8�rty �ew, having been buflt approximately 13 year� ��o. She lives oiz the corner of Birmingham and Yark. When the Greenbrf.er Hc��e �as built, their pres�serty values �ni� down, she said. If ap�rtme�.t buildf�g� a�re e�Eected i� �he $rea, she stated they will not be �hle to Fzell the�.r homes; �nd r.he srea residen�:s wi11 be hurt fiaancially. Mr. �Iai�tts askecl Mis. Keau�pfer wrh�ti she meant by her statement that the restdents will lose a lot af. ��ney, Sh� stAted they would be finencieZly hurt be�suse th� area is a be�utiful sgUt £or private homes. If the property ia zoned to °tC" Residence, the residents would have trouble selling their property. Mr. M�ietta gaid this is not gn accu�.ate statement, Many, u�eny people are looking for pi.aces to �ive and apartmen�:s are very necessary. Wherever �partmeat bui?dircgs ha�e beer� buiLt thro�ghout the City, property values have gone np anci not dowi�, Mro Maiett� stated. Mr3. �ochraue said she is con��:.rned w�th the other small parcels in ttie area. St�� d st�e fee�s the Bo�sd i s "Y,eggin�'° for rezonings �# these other }ropex��fes. Sh� s�id she do�:� r:�t see how any other r�zoc�ings in the erea �ou1.d I�e den�.ed if this pfr�ce �f �rapr��ty is rezoned. Mr, M�S.etta �tated ther� is �s dem�nd for i�omes. The pop�L��:��n of Sto Paul hms beQn dncre�sing and th� r�� bese is decre�six�g. In Mx, riaietta's opireion, it is a func�.:io� aaf the gov�rr,snenf: to see th�t adequate housiag is provided f or �he peopYe. Tf the�e i.s sn rppAdcstxon for �aor� housing and free enter-- gx�ize is cJi3.�i.r.�a �o r_,�ize th� zisk, h� said he feels the Baard should take tha�se 8s �hey ca*ne. T'rzer.e £:s a n�ce�s�.ey �ar housing fn this area, he con- cluded. Zt was moved by I�ir. �Iai�tt� t� ti�pp�ov� �he r�zoning. The motion was aeco�.de�d by c�x:� Benshoo� �o st��.�c� he is very famiZ�ar F�z,th the area. Even tho��h �t.rmtnghr�m 5�reet as not �inish�d, it is sti11 possible to"drive through on i�. He str�ted that 3irniingham wil1. be :fnished to tie into Ea�t �th Str�Pt. riro B�ns�.oa:� noted �hst at the laat Zanin� Baard meeting he wted agaia�st m diffex��r reznning in tihe �ares bec�use of Che lsck of thraugh �treets. Mr, i�iexisu�^ �sked �.f s �re,poz�s� had been obtafned froan the flighway Depaxtment reg�rding the Hfghwray '?�.2 3.ca��r�[��zag� �hr�. w�s plamned far Che area. Mr. Berssho�f. �o�ed ie w�as brougiTt up at the last Zoning Bost'd meeting. He x�.oted he h�s s�:udied m�ps s�n the sub��cr �nd �hey showed this particulax piece af �s:�:csya�;.ty as not bein� concemec� with 23�. The intersections will stay either e��t: ox we�� of �he property. Tde n�ted that at Che last Zoning F.s*�ard xuee":�n� i��: vutvd �gmin�ti 4�a� r�zmni.ng on Case �ve�sue becsuae that p iecF �of �s�c�.r��:g� wrss �a� �he �3.<z propo��l. Mr, RosMt��- :�ated th�: last tt►�or�r��iaq� the stafE hsd from the Highwgy Beg��r�.r,:en� shc�a, �:I�at s��gttw�g 6�. going naxth wauld be d�veloped west of Bixm�nghsan a�d waul.d in��rch�nb� wi�h 2I2 north of Css� Aven��. He added that this irr�ox�ati�n i� very �en�ata.v�. . ' BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION September 2, 1971 Plat Map ��37 Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 � _� passed August 22, 1922, as amended to January 27, 1971. 7218 I 1 �":"_,i �;i�': S r;:4'iC : William H. Paul (Richard C. Drake) . _� _ 1�---� �'`,I1S5I`'�i;;A"I`I')PJ , �tl�XXy Amendment �_� A��eal � Permit �"�JI �)ther � 3 , ''�iEZ;'��;!; o Rezone from "A" to "C" Residence ` � L'`�;:P;I.�iJ South side of York Avenue between Birmingham and Hazelwood � . LL',•.-:A� ;)�SCRIPTi�N ; See file . . P��SI;i�T L�Ni�1G.;� "A" Residence � ?!J�tS�,1"iT T� ?cninp, Code Chaptara 64 Section; .06 Parap,raph: � - �::'iAlf [t+VF.STI�;ATION � REPORT� TJate; August 25, 1971 By; ATB A. SUFFICIENCY: The Commissioner of Finance in a letter dated August 1�, 1971 declared the petition sufficient with the owners of 24 of a possible 28 (85.71%) tracts having signed the petition. B. HISTORY: None. C. PROPOSED USE: The petition did not state any definite proposal. Multi-family use is permitted under "C" Residence. D. FRONTAGE AND AREA: The property under consideration has an irregular shape with frontage along York Avenue, Birmingham Street and Stillwater Avenue. The frontage along York Avenue is 462.5 feet; along Birmingham Street 178 feet; and along Stillwater Avenue 625 feet. The area is approximately 172,749 square feet. The maximum number of units allowed under "C" Residence is 172. E. AREA ZONING: The frontage along East 7th Street is zoned Commercial; East of Birmingham Street is zoned "B" Residence. Northwest of this site is an area of "C" Residence zoning. To the esst is zoned "A" Residence with one newer four-unit apartment on a "C" Residence parcel. F. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: The Comprehenaive Plan reco�enis highway intersections at this site. G. SITE CONDITIONS: The topography of the site is not severe. The area adjacent to York Avenue is higher than the area adjacent to unimproved Stillwater Avenue. The land is vacant. H. AREA CONDITIONS: York Avenue is unimproved £rom Birmingham Street westward. Still.water Avenue is unimproved as is Birmingham Street from York Avenue to East 7th Street. Access from the west is limited to Case Avenue from Johnson Parkway to Birmingham or Barclay then south to York Avenue. York Avenue provides access from White Bear Avenue six blocks to the east. 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recoc�anend �X Approval � Denial Council Letter Dated : Moved by : Maietta Yeas Nays 9/21/71 Ames - Ch. Date of Seconded by: Benshoof x Cochrane Hearing: x McPartlin Secretary's remarks: X Maiette 9/2/71 x Mansur Co�tncil Action: X Benahoof Dooley Date: Prifrel n4ttaa a rrias.r ' _ OR�DINAI�TCE 25fi � 25� COUNCIL FtLE NO PRESENTED BY ORDIN�►NCE N4 --L��-t-"`- i, �Aa c�rdinar�ce aa�eadinq thie 8oain�g Cod�e, Cha�t�rs 60 tv 64, i�clusive, of tbe Saint Paul b+�q�alative Ce�d�e, p��ctiiriinq to Us� Dis+t�icts, Heiqht Dirt�ric#.s and Re�oniaq of certa�in Properties is �he . City df Sa3.at Paul, a� ar�d. T� �CO�CIL OF' TB8 CITY OF SAI�T PA� IlOSS Q�iD1►Z8: !; gection l. �'hat the Zoniaq Code. Chapta�rs 6� fi.� 6#, faa�i�i?�re, of the Saiat Panl L�gislatiwe Cc�e�e. perta€i8ing to IIee':nis�.tiCts, Height Distrfets a�i l�oni�►q of cett�aia Pro�rties in tl�e City of Saint Panl, aa a�ended, be snd t� sanrl� 'ie� hereby further ane�ded so s� to resone the follo�riaq Be�Yibied p�operty frr� "1�i! Beaideaee Diata�ict to "G" Res;��e�ce Di.�trict, to-wit: '� b7orth 2 og th� w+�st � of Lot 18. �icrth � of Lots 19, 20, 21, Slbek 2, Cruick- shank''a Garden �,ots, aad the DTarth � ''' af Lot 22, except the 8arth 1�5 feet , thereof, Sc�ruth � of the �ast � of th� : Horth '� of Lot 18, �lock 2, Cruick8ha�c•s Gardsa Lots= si�te oa property loc�ted on the s�o�th aid� of Yauk l�venne beb�aea Bisn�inqha� aad Hazel�rood in the C�.ty o€ Saiut Panl. i`; ' S�ation 2. This ordinanee shal,l take •ffect and be in fo�1t thirty (30) days from an�! aft�rr its ps�sa►q�e. apgroval . an� publication. i'. _ �4 aov 1 s ti�71 Yeas Councilmen Nays Paeeed by the Caunc;� B�6w�e��. � '�a Favor a� � -�� . � c�� NOV 19197� Approved: Att�est: . (�ty Clerk �ayor �� For�a roved Co PP rporation �ounael By ._ _ i � , . ',. a , . .. ' � !�� ' , - • CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA / /) �� " PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE * Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. �� ) (Please type or print) / S Date; July 1� 1971 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, ftoom 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota , Pursuant to Section 64.06 af the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50qo or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property• (legal des ription and street address) Aivf{' �S .v i�.. �-�.�- w i� � �-��_ �� , �, 1; B�o�� . c.��;��5� C6 At?l7 cN �C.a`TS'U f�N r� �TIfF N.� or� c a� �� Ex� c Pr rft� �v. / >S--/�`T, i/�r'rt�Cr= �°�r' t� °�Th k �• z �r �t�t N %` af�ol�b',/g��L�Z,, CiC�ickS'/-/b/V� s G�.rF 0�'N 1�75. o �?�S� ,��.0 � District to � ��,5��'/yC� District, for the purpose f instal ing, constructing and/or operating the following; (describe briefly the proposed facility) RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BIACK ADDITION Subject Property; � . �� 1` , ,,� r,. Y Y/' e � tc I S vxc-�� c�YZ. ,�,�.�o.�s� � �� JOHN E. BLOMQUIST� INC. 1 tl�r 18 an Lot 20� J St. Paul; Minnesota -�fes. lk6 ds t r ik �, Rearrangement� � ��: r � ,, � .U/0�- a _ v/�`, i�� A'P� � . � / , � > � � . � af� , La��S �'�� - � i ;'� ,,�,;�;:. State of Minnesota ( ss � County of Ramsey ( �z1GhaTd G. ��t'tk� being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �«;►uT pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said ownets in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and corx�err, sig atures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscrihed ar_� sworn before me /� this ��=� day of J�l , 1��1. �� C�. d�a_L�P — � - - /,% Address��i7� �`�rfi� �,�•i� *:c. Fau1, blinn. �/ Telephone No.7T�i'16;#1 ry ublic, Rams o nty, Min . My issio Gp3xL', Approved as to form 1/4/65 �� Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 Nots�y,p�b�� Ramsey�M,y��. MY Comrr :�:; g �;.rs� N�v. 16, 1977 � � � � � U �, LJ ��!� ' " 1971 CITY FLAE�iVli=!G BOARD Sair± Pal., ^"_,r�.��±, , • , . , . . ' , , . � ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA � ' � � PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE � Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date. . '�� ,- 7 � TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50°J, or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property: (legal description and street address) �� c �� Ze.s-i c�e�e � District from I`es i ci�ev.c c District to , for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) J � �� w � a /-' !v t ! �, � i �, �r 7 H E 1'1�• � � .0 a� % 8 /.31�G�� "� x p �5,�F �-�� .ts {7 Sv ,/z. c t� /1, /z � � , N � T ��,�c�/�r �N� l,�s n/ ��,. �1" t- t7S / `�, 3'`'i �I� (3�lic�C � CcuiC� S �"�AMhS G'dRp �N ° s' RECORD OWNER SrIGNATURE LOT BIACK ADDITION i r�E�lt d F Subject Property; , � � U/Ch S � ' � G- r i 8' .L s � • � K � .� C'�-�r 'T �' U f� h 5 /'( �' ✓ 1 C E' d i °�- !� 1,,,o 'S i G �d, C-o `�E �' D/� � � , � � �, Fa;v�c i<v � �I� I�� ,� -n, , � , ' / � � � 6EME�VT � �is � � � � � � �� ,��c,��K S��kl�s /�� ' � � L.o�S . ✓ s� 5 _ �w �n c�� l3 S/ f� �-- �A �HR R !�rl�M�HT a v� � � �(.�� o � � � �� B " �. �s �� /a,�- � � �. ► oT ' a a �. .` , : JT (�U - � r 3 , �� -�-°-�- �� ° '✓��yc7 � � � /' � � �,c .�.. � ,3 - �. State of Minnesota ( County of Ramsey ( SS ��.".', h1Cl�ird C. I?Z'ilk! being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of pages• , � that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the ots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signature of each and all of the parties so described. Subscr.ibed and sworn to be re me this � day of ��1� � ��C • �� Address�,�78 �A2.� �va� St. PAUl, A�It�ti. / Telephone No. ??B_1831 ary ublic, R Count , Minn. My c ro ssion zxpires Approved as to form 1/4/65 At� R. USG1U�Rp Of�� Q�r��ion Counsel FGI 1/5/65 Notary Public, Ramsey County, Mtnn. U MX Commissbn Explres Nov,16,, 1971 . - AUU �. rl 1971 CITY PLAidP�l;ryl� BOARD Sairt P�':;. �.�;.�noc�� , ,' ; • . . . . ' , � � , , ,,,/"o . � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA �� PETITION TO AMEND CHAP'rER� 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE • Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. FOr further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) , � ,, � ^ � _ � Date: i�u� . TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Ha11 City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners af two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50%, or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) _ TN E' Su v i� %a � G '1iz � ,�'A S T �� a F %�� /Uo R T f� %2 is f' .L G T /S� �la c� .1� d � G R v t c./E S�A iV K'.3 �it iP,�F'� �.a'ts ,�1'�i. rfj�- �' `ec. ��o� i b, l�' � o /� ,,�a f s /y. �� -!•�.o�,�/� a-- GR�� cJ�<S N f+ ►Y �S 6�R D�H �Lv'Ts -r M, yi o i �o?.z� � XCB�T %VI.�STf T��'�Q�'G� from �Q /��'S I ,D�/yC� District to � �%:S t U C'�ly C t Dist�ict, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BIACK ADDITION i Sub ject Property; C/� /'a P•� C/e�/i c h S S / p� c -p� /' r J �Vl!C, rl � � 4 C..d • c -�-' R 1J /i �-C r$ �,� �NA l D G'. f la rv � ` .� " � �i P�r � C�p vi`K s�I.ao s 5 �� r` � �a T ` ' �� -"' '��y • + j�p,�7 C ,P � : c/� r /Y S ' a; � L I A� {� � u . �... N �- d7" F H G• N� L; IY �R R T , o,.,. � ' 'S � �,r' C R�� c K n ,� � � U�;RN � p W�-e � . � c ��:rs � �� f'• T aG ri� �- `, � r�� Cs T�� .. , ✓ . , _ � T ��v` ,`/l�'A ..r�P � � , ,� o�=�, .�. � �-� fs P,�R r � �.�Y L�' o� D/s ib e�. ,,�'' ,gr �,�R r� C Rv% c K s `� C � E R �E ,CG �C oi,9 '� o ._ � �� State of Minnesota � ss County of Ramsey ( F{,ichard C. Drake being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of pau�, pages; that the parties described above a.re the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to be re me this ��day of ul 9?1. ��•,�� Address:l4'i8 York r�ve, St. Paul, Minn. Telephone No. 776-1631 ry P blic; Rams un y, Minn My m ssion ex�ires Approved as to form 1/4/65 MYtY'CL' li. USGAARD Office o the Corpor ounsel FGI 1/5/65 N�tary Pubtic, Ramsey C , Mlnrr. ' 'u' My Commission Exp ..s Nov. 16, 197i ' •' � �'' � �I �� lti�� i 71971 �' �1��"��b'��G' �(T�#�D� �int Pa�s"; �:^i°�nnfia�� , � , . . . ' . , � , . r . � r � � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA •, PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) C'ADE � Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this p�etition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) / Date;�"��- �� ' 7 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL � c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50%, or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) f'�C. S 1�, 3 `f.i` � %��`" w. ��,y" ` o�: � a T' r � 7`�- �'�t . S T i`I, 3 y`3 ' L°7's �' �'- ,2 0 �- 2/ � i� i. I<, � C ji �r��K s J�' � � �'s f�.4 R P FN � 0 7`-�'� S� !�y � f �`,�/�- � �L c� F F.: �/ !/L. n f' /-�7 i S, �(3 �.�c l� L f�� ^ �r Rr� g�_ r��T.rvc � District to C ��y� �EN C� District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) �. 's . YoJ�� Y!�*'r�zr,+�`a. , �O� •,,� ��'Tw��w B i RM i.va�.t�� " '7"" ° N-�4 S�C N'e e�,,a RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE IAT BLOCK ADDITION Subject Property: (Acc rding to tax receipts) Ed��ard E. Parranto Crui kshan 's Garden Lots subj ct �� avenue and except Richard M. Parranto Harvey Bream � e.�. E 10 ft a d except S 180 ft n t e z of Lot 20 , Block 2 . Meyer Bream �) �u-�-�... Subj ct to avenue and except _ 22 , Blac 2 . Subj ct to avenue and except for 1�1 t the E 50 ft of S f Lot 0 Block ✓ Sub ' ct pt S180 ft th S� of Lot 21, Block2: ✓ Subj ct to avenue and except f E 10 ft o 3 � of Lot 20 , State of Minnesota ( County of Ramsey � ss �`A R,ichard C. D rake being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of stfour pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectiveLy of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this aff�.ant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures o ch and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to befo e me � this 3 th day of J , 1971. -��w�=" � � Address: 1478 York Aveq St. Paul, Minn. Telephone No. 776-1631 Public, Rams oun , Minn. My mission expires Approved as to form 1/4/65 Office,,,p�,_t�� o��q� Counsel FGI 1/5/65 R�Y�E'1�. USGA7�Rp ��{ �� U Notary public, Ramsey Coun �h. U� l�' MX Commissbn Euplres v, lfi, 1977 AUG 1 '7 ��9��1 CITY PLA�J�r�l�+l� BOARD_ aaint P��u�1 �ni�,n�sflt� � i �.�v ' . -_ ; , , ' � ;�.�) � I . . ...... ....... � � n. \ { :„ -. , I � _. . . 1 k, � � < < �� c�� ; _------------ • � . , � - --- � 'r----- � i I: � �-`�3 I � , , ,� i � . _ - ., , � e - , I � , �, �w � i� � � � i ; � � . _ � �-, � � i � o �, _ � (. —_'_-.__. � �: v � �� i -i�> j t,r1 - ..� . i; � � . . -..-� , , , ' �..� 1 -: �i . "1 �i . t;i I ' ��.. i� � � � � � ,�� . � �", � . . j t ��. ,. :: 9.r_..f� i ''__� 3 �i . � • ` : � � ;:.� �' �-i 2- ��7 . . . . �'-.'.�__,a "___ ' . .__ . . . . _. . _.� . . . ., . � . ,. , , , . . ,. ' � � � .. r... .. � . j ��. . . . - , � � � I I � 5 t _ ._'� f ;.�_- — �--- _I I� � ,,.� T�J �, - ,'� � '� ,� I cn f 1 � Cr� � `� -- � -- - i �\ .-1 I , �{ �. `- � � "� �: '' I { — �_ "� ' � i � ; - � __ � , ' ; , � i ; i i I � i � �I j _ � � , - '-----___-_'_—� I I � � , , � � � i � �� ` �_ .- -- I__ �� --�--- ; __ _ -- _._'"_ i � . . . . .,.. C..._ .�� ..... �__ .. __ __._ ._"__: �. ..:. ��- � �_ _...—__ .._...""_'_' "___"_' � '. � . _.__ � � ', '_ i , .-.. ^� _ _.._. . � . .�•- ' :.. ._'_"'__."___'"___'" -- ..._"' __' .... __.__'___ '."_ . .._. .. . � 1 �. �f. J, i _.. 1 . __.. ._.. �+ I �y . ..____� ' . _. .. .___—_'—___— ' � � . t' . .�y i�� * i h . � '. i . ♦. (^ � _ � • �. ' ' .. .., \' . . .-: L 1 �.. V ..��. � G 1� ( _ ti �. .._.._'"_:1 •� t .I � � � t ! �.. ' i:i � `. —. ...'_____.__ ..__... cc.' 1 � � . ._—,__-_ ' .. � �r �. . ' ..___'__'____'_'_ ... T.-_. . ' � .__'—' __�__—�, .—.._.__. . r �'`-..:� , .. '. . i � � ' ... , �+ ...._.-��..,r. � V ..i _ ^ . : e ` ` F : � ^ i L� ''y: " , . � � i t � • � � � —_. _._ _.._.... ' s V �- � I � _ -- — � '' � � �--- -- �,,-------ti— `-- �.�, � j� '' "-_y ^J (` n' ~ <.� ":�-- = ! I: = __ ----- _ .__.�..+x:y i I -_ � i �__—_-`_ __�_r. --_ .-. ��_. � .. _. - ��.: i .. p�� ; �--- !� tv c �,t�I O �d � ,—__ � ---- " � � �� iv `c •' � `� I_ /e I +��.91 t�� _ _ –-----� i � � -----� �= � — _ ' -— - -_. � �____ ____ __ ____. , , a. , _ � � � ,�,. , - – ----- _ Y—._ � j € ur ; - �`j�— ; i i I v � i , j i -----� i +� I . � r 1� ! + : � _ � � �f� i � ��, i '�l � i , � �------�-'_ I � . I .._ _��'''� � � i — � ' II" i* -J � �}: � � �V a� C ^J t%.1 I '� V1 � � I '"� , �' � � r s = j b j,, �z i.: � � �<;; G: I j ; I ' i �.. ---�-- --� s �� (a � � � ( � � � � I � I I .J a - � � �� r---- � � � � j , � a 4 0+ J I � .. � � �O ___ a zp if� S�`'-� ti9�3 60 3.3 � `J'G i I I w-^ . ' L _,r � � '' .�......,�.....- �— .O � ,�+i`�"' �f!"..� � ��--'p. - ��'' �"'``�'�r''�'?'� �.`r�'d��''�-�j��' .�-....� . . .. _._-_. i - 3 3 ,_,__, �, ,. _ L_ - - — - - =I r... f .-� � �°" i� 1 r f f i� ti=. -- ---"-- - � �� "�.�k� �.,,�-�„ � d°�Gw.-d-�-�a:��s i ,��.� - � c ' ' ' ��° l 7 ► ' � O N F o� i � � � � ��` � i� a , � � ��t� �� ; o i ; _ N . .tV io �� `i �_._____...—.— - � '^ �U n` � �.a '� ; N + o N''vi � I� ;C,N j � i ° �o� �� J ! '� � I( N N � - i �� ( . o ; 31 � ' o l 1 ' ; I,'I _..___ -� � ' � _� I �� 'r O'. / O� �� ... Q ."�(�� i 1� O ' 0 . • Q' _ ..-- �� . v` 1 � � � .I , - . ` . � � � I i � � � I � ' ' _...: .. . I � � . .�..�._---� ' .� � C�t3 f:•�-.. � �. � ��_ 1--- ._..._..___.._..._. � , � --� _.�'W � � -----� �--� ' 3 i� � i � � � , � s� ' �'�� 7 i ,� ti *� �I �, , , ��: l.� � ', � • . o - . �� : � �� w�+ � n�° ' oj r �� d'�E � ; , _ .,, ,,;� o•,.. O' f; `'�. �C -y � 6� �� .�—,�� -----� �, i ;', � �-� � r'(�ir � � � � 1 } C� � - � � • � i ly'' o c� . -'R. � �r'o ).` ",� �� I ` i�, o y,� lr°�o' �� j s _,� �' °, �\ "�z �' ��l • ,�' c� � � oc �� f o o �; ;, � ;'. � '. �— ,� � � � c � � c .,� � __ N; � � _. , . �� __. _ � ; . _____l.�e _____--__ .—-- _. � _ � C, - � — � ac � I `cr, � � �' : _ _ - - -� � ,G. �;� `�' r'o o J'! 3 �3}� �� .___.'} .! ----- � • � I :' -� � /7-__._•�..__. �J_.�__-�- -- �-- l°J ! 4 � � � --____��i o_ . � , ` . ; o— " ____---J Jl .,L^• �,� � ,-� � p l�� o, { o � ' � o, �l �� —,_ _�� ._' �� _� � � �.� _ : ^ Q?�Q . � �� L� _. __ ___-_ 1 _- _ _ o �; � . '° ,� � , � �,�r, � � � . N �( �1 - '�.�c' �7 �..,��i !� � . p O. ' �� .. � — . c*� - 84 _ ____ � � �, � Y ' I C� o - ?� .c''� l.,�"r 1 i N � W �� ,r�� . . � �� "l t- ,� �- - � ' - � �-.--�--l�-: _ � ___ __._- - - - - - _ -�� i _ � _.- - - �- - � " ,� !�� . � — — — — . i . _ _ , . . : �_ . :.:-��. .�..��t -, •..c.w�..a�..,, •_-.�.._ • �.�:.,_ ,.. .,.. _ . .�a..6_Ct.-'-•� -- - Q � , . . .w.,�o...v..:+....-��s.�a4wr;:m.a►.c-_.....�:L,......�.,�:'!4� a.. a,,,as�i...;+. �,.:.a...e��.� .... . �... . . . . .. .�...� , .., .. .._ �.. . . ,..,.. .:..� '---` . ,. . .� ,,'� .�-..,.�„_.,.,.1s . . " . ' ..'' .r._,.r�.2sS..'a,�+s:�t�e++.s�we,::.iy..as...., _Y - - '- ... _ _. .:......�,.. ._:.�_ _ _ _. . ; . . . . . . _ - � '.��.. ( • � .. ° v + �O 0 p G i � � � tt � 5 __._ � � � p � � ° o 0 0 � °' � ,� --- � . � � '. $� o ° � , o� Z ; o o i o � �--o _ �( f.,. o o , � �,o� C'.�' o � wo � „ � o � o � qV E . , o � ..�- �:::�:::: .. p , ,,.,',�... . .:.-+d......::......:::�::::::::.::.:.:.;:.,.:�-�-"�:'� � \ .' _ , � ; `::��;::,::i .s�- ::�:;. � A f�.� �� ' � :*'��:�•::'..A ...:::.. ...: � Q G Q V 's� ��' � � .� -►� �..,�.,r-��'�- '' i �.� L 0 �y O ��-- ,,r.,� . �:•�:"-`"'�- :�'': �' � � ,ti �} .: ,�,�,a.• � { .� a r ...,+i—+ :,:;. � .v •-^'�' ::.rr�iµ'- M�F J O O O � � V � ��'If _.ry'"'�'�� r . . - i �.ii.i:..:.'�: � w�r� _ � �: ...� � r .� : �. � _ �, �.�.�:�` P o 0 5 2 � �:::�. . v .,r�.`::::;...,�;; ` :t:�. ;`�' -�"' � v � �. .�. . , ��. O l �( �':':::�::::. � �� _ - - -- V I � N" I ....^:.�`,•.:.: `�;::::.:-:�±�"., ;.,. . ..: ::�;'::..::..,,..�'' �f �1 �,� .'✓ � -'� �,.� : �..i�i Z C '�",u .; y � � � • � I �� ./. �+!:'',.'.:.�:t..:. .. ...,.�..,,.:.. . . `'�' � �'<;;..":':::::j, .`.:�,: :.,X:`; :.......... . .::'.';i+ i � . • V � /:`•...:}:::'{.. � � .r �� `•'� I �/�:i.�.'}::�•:•:_.'. '. . : i,,r s , � v Q ir�'�' ` :. �y '� �' i� � I " ,�^ � �r 1 , a- .�s , �..:. .:.:...::;:�:.;::;::��°'`'.::. � � o 0 0' o " o 0 o .�� ..� �� ,: � � � p � :. - - - .�.�. .� :.. ... : :.....: � � r � ..� . .. �...,:. � \ -\ .�"� � ^��.r" � �� \ � ` /�l'4 - - r:��}::.:-:: .::,:�:::,:::. •�' � � O � I t� , , � �,�� o 0 0 0 0;� o 0 0 , � � . ,.. .� �\`� �� . �r �� v � O - - � � � � ,� i � � � . . � tfiT � v � �; � � � �� ' � ( � O , � �,i v j i � � \� �J � F" v � O o � C� \� '� � � ' � � }" _______ • � \ \ _ _.__ � IMS . � � � `, � � -� - S p� . a -�---- --___, � � � --- v -�- C� o � v v � � � �O � � r � . � � � � \ � � p Q O I -i - - � I '- O �� ' v v 1✓ � �� \�C)�� t _ p =p p � O O � , ` � p � p O OOGO � C� O ,, _ A V E . —f . "�' �Z�,�r,�� _� _ � o o ; o 000 � � � � � � � � . � vvvv ; � � � � � I v I v v I . I v -.� � v p - ' � ` � �� —� T- __.---1 � � , p-_ v v v�v v v � i � ` � i I 0 O O -- - � � � I � ; � � v � A��E. i�Q ^ �" ��s,oE . E �� ST �_ 0 0 �' - " _ ' � ► � � c� i ic , � Z --`!-____ � � I v v v � I v v v v i I � W '✓ � � Z _ � � i � OI � I _ - _ _ - � -- v _ � � � _ � ; � � C�_ _ _ _ _ - _ ,_-�--_ _--�- _ �.� ,-_-�. .� - , Q , � _ ; _ i� '� � � �� i�. i I �..� I I • � � ' � OGOUC� pvv ✓ vyv p „ � �� , � OO p � (g • �qsT s�'t��,� sT. G o � �R c i.� G-- `� m � o000 0; T v oo .l o �� , , o 0 0 0 0 - � � �'� vvuv � �� rv _. � _ --�- �,.- _ _ _ _ _ _ -� -- _ _ -o -- - _ ___ __ . _ . . . : _ i � _ _ __ _ �__.._ �- . � o m � T ' � o _ _ _ - �N I William H. Paul (Richard C. Drake) LEGEN D 1y �V � V V �� _ _ o CD � , Rezone from "A" to "C" Residence in order LAND USE � l /-= to construct apartment buildinga d ONE-FAMILY T; p . � � ZONING "A" Res�aence -�- TWO-FAMILY � '�/� �/ �/ � ' � THREE-FAMILY ' v v O I m i SIGNERS 24 of a posaible 2s or 85 5/770 �`}- FOUR-FAMILY i o ► L MULT1-FAMILY i ��:�; v v ��-- \ a e �� COMMERCIAL � O � �Zis �02,-�{ � n �..� I NDUSTRIAL � v . VACANT � O � ' ; � ( anning Boord, Date� A�guet i9, i9�i � Property Under Considerat'ton v� v v v ' p I ! I I I I � � j � �{,;_�- . � � i � � ,I � v__� v_ � T � _ � � i � I I �._ � . . � v v C� i � � �� z ,. � � � x �e � \. � , � � � � '� ~ � d W z � � w '� � a F ►-� • W `. a a � v ' ! � d � \ � � \ � b �; � � � a 0 b d � ' // � // I st � 2nd Laid over to 3rd and app 1 i ��dopfied � ! Yeas Nays Yeas Nays Bu+ler Butler Conway Conway ��. ��s�� ,� Levine �erina••� Meredith �Meredith � Sprafka Sprafka Tedesco �—. Mr. President McCarty Mr. President McCarFy O a a 0 �o R ►C a N � � � � � � � � 0 .:,, y � � . � t�7 � � 'h � y H � � �" t" ' ,; � � �7 � � � �� z � � � � 0 �