The URL can be used to link to this page

03-1111�i��o- ./��71� i7� aDO,� Presented By Referred To RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA � ,�, � ,. , ,� :.�;�r--�°`��, �.�;�.�< %' Council File # Q ✓ � � / I / Green Sheet # 3� �$ � �3 Committee: Date WHEREAS, a Notice of Violation was sent on October 29, 2003, to the owner/manager of Twin Star VFW Post 8854 d/b/a Twin Star VFW Post 8854, located at 820 Concordia Avenue in St. Paul (License ID# 0057268) alleging failure to provide a membership and guest log book and in violation of Minn. Stat. § 340A.404, Subd. 1(4) prohibiting a club from selling alcohol to anyone other than a member or bona fide guest; and WHEREAS, the Licensee responded by letter dated November 4, 2003, requesting a hearing before the City Council for a public hearing to argue the penalty recommendation; and WHEREAS, the recommendarion of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection, which was contained in the Notice of Violation sent to the licensee, is for a fine of $1,000.00, with $500.00 of the fine being stayed for a period of eighteen months on the condition that the remainder of the $500.00 fine be paid within thirty days and that the licensee immediately begin keeping membership and guest log books in a readable format, to be approved by the Office of LIEP; now, therefore be it RESOLVED, that Twin Staz VFW Post 8854 d/b/a Twin Star VFW Post 8854, located at 820 Concordia Avenue in Saint Paul (License ID# 0057268) is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $1,000.00 for the failure to provide a,�tne�ership and guest log book and for selling alcohol to someone other than a member or bona fide guest. �tve nun�red dollars-($388:A��"of the fine shall be stayed for a period of eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that *'�° r°�°�-a°- �"'-- °"^^ ^�„� be paid within thiriy days of the passage of this resolution to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection; and 2)that the licensee immediately begin keeping membership and guest log books in a readable forxnat, to be approved by the Office ofLIEP, and 3) that there be no further violations fox a period of eighteen months £xom the date of the original violation. �$ry00.00) � $300.00 Adoption Ce: By: � Approved by By: � Requested by Department of: BY: l �-'°`^"'""^- � ' � 4V`� Adopted by Council: Date �f� _ /�/i �Q -� Form Approved by City Attorney �..F �\ii e1 4 � c� r, � : ; �„�� _� ,��L,�� . ; �e CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL FACSIJZILE TRA\SDIISSION COVERSHEET TO: �. �d�c FROR4: �� Fax#: __ o�y -�./i97 RE: da3 -/// �—_ - l � � L_ � DATE: � �?— c� note: Facsimite operator, please deti��er this transmission to the above addressee. If you did not recei4�e all of the pages in good condition, please advise Janie Lafrenz at (651) Zb6-8560 at yonr earliest convenience. TUank you. CITY HALL 1�[i;11BER OF PAGES (L'�CLL�i\G TIiIS PAGE): eZ THIRD FLOOR � pnnted ort recycletl paper SAINT PAUT.., MIN;�'ESOTA 55102 03 —Illl � Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet �J DepartmenUOffice/council: Date Inkiated: �Q -�;�,�ri��ron�t 2SNOV-03 Green Sheet NO: 3008436 Contact Person & Phone: Deoartment Sent To Person Initial/Date GingOr Palmer 0 icenselins ectioWEnviron Pro 266-87'10 (�5jgn 1 i Attomev Gin er Palmer C1n2 _..__ Must Be on Council qqenda by (Date): Number 2 icense/In ecfion/Environ Pro De artment Direc[or �` -0BUEC-03 For �' �� ROUting 3 a or's OCfice Ma oNAssistant Order 4 �a �� 5 i Clerk Ci Clerk ' Total # of Signature Pages � (Clip All Locations for Signature) Action Requested: That a fine of $1,000.00 be imposed against the licenses held by Twin Star VFW Post 8854 d/b/a Twfn Star VFW Post 8854 for the premises located at 820 Concordia Avenue in St. Paul (License ID# 0057268) for failing to provide a membership and guest log book and in violation of selling alcohol to someone other than a member or bona fide guest. Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personal Service Contrads Must Answer the Following Questions: Pianning Commission 1. Has this persoNfirtn ever worked under a contract for this departmenY? CIB Committee Yes No � Civil Service Commission 2. Has this persoNfirm ever been a city employee? Yes No 3. Does this person/firm possess a skill not nortnally possessed by any current city employee? Yes No Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet Initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why): A narcorics arrest took place at the Twin Staz VFW Post 8854 on May 25, 2003. An invesrigation was done to detemilue whether or no� the man arrested was a member or guest of the VFW. Adverse acrion was initiated by the Office of LIEP for the violarion of faIlure to provide a membership and guest log book and for selling alcohol to someone other than a member or bona fide guest. AdvanWSles If Approved: Compliance with conditions of license. 1 ZECBNED IN LIEP DisadvantapeslfApproved: � NUV � 6 2003 DisadvanWgee If Not Approved: �r��,�s3 ��, .- . Licensee would not take steps to comply with license conditions. � . �� Total Amount of . CosURevenue Budgeted: Transaction: Funtling Source: Activity Number. Financial I nformation: (Explain) 0 3 - !ll� UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER Licensee Name: Address: Council Date: Twin Star VFW Post 8854 d/b/a Twin Star VFW Post 8854 820 Concordia Avenue Wednesday, December 17, 2003 @ 5:30 p.m. Violation: Failure to maintain membership and guest log book; selling alcohol to someone other than a member or bona fide guest Minn. Stat. § 340A.404, subd. l(4) Date of Violation: Place: May 25, 2003 Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $1,000.00 fine with $500.00 of that fine stayed for a period of 18 months on the conditions: 1) that $500.00 of the fine is paid with thirty (30) days; 2) that the licensee immediately begin keeping membership and guest log books in a readable format, to be approved by the Office of LIEP. Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. Police report dated 5-23-03 4. Letter dated June 19, 2003 from Virginia Palmer to Twin Star VFW 5. Letter dated July 26, 2003 from Twin Star VFW to Virginia Palmer w/ membership roster 6. Letter dated August 15, 2003 from Virginia Palmer to Twin Star VFW requesting log book 7. Pages from members and guest log book 8. Letter dated November 4, 2003, from Twin Star VFW to Virginia Palmer requesting public hearing 03-�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Raady C. Ke![y, Mayor November 2Q 2003 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Mnnue[J Centtntes, CiryAtlorney Civil Division 400 Ciry Ha11 I S Wut Kellogg Blvd. Saint P¢ul, A-finnu0ta 55102 Telephone: 651266-8710 Facsimile: 651298-5619 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Owner/Nlanager Twin Star VFW Post 8854 820 Concordia Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104 RE: All licenses held by Twin Star VFW Post 8854 d/b/a Twin Star VFW Post 8854 for the premises located at 820 Concordia Ave. in St. Paul License ID No.: 0057268 Deaz Sir/Madam: Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Public Hearing Agenda for the City Council meeting scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, December 17, 2003 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter in that the facts concerning the failure to maintain a membership and guest log book and for selling alcohol to someone other than a member or bona fide guest have not been denied. Per your request, this matter has been placed on the public hearing agenda portion of the City Council meeting, during which public discussion is allowed. The recommendation ofthe license office is for a$1,000.00 fine with $SOO.OQ of the fine suspended for a period of 18 months on the condition that: 1) you pay a$500.00 fine within thirty (30) days; and 2) that you immediately begin keeping membership and guest log books in a readable format, to be approved by the Office of LIEP. If you have any questions please feel free to contact me at 266-8710. V ery truly yours, ^ ' ,� �u.tC��U L �.-,�y Virgin�D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Mary Erickson, Assistant Council Secretary, 310 City Hall Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Summit-University Planning Council, 627 Selby Avenue, St. Paul, MN 55104 AA-ADA-EEO Employer o3-r�ll OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Mam�e! J. Ceremues, Ciry• Attorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL cr��r�o;��sro„ Randy C. Kefly, Ma}�or 400 Ciry Hal( Telephone: 657 266-8710 IS Nest Ke([ogg B(cd. Farsimile: 65] 293-5619 Saint Pnnl, Ffinnesota 55102 October 29, 2003 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner/Manager Twin Star VFW Post 8854 820 Concordia Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104 RE: All licenses held by Twin Star VFW Post 8854 d/b/a Twin Star VFW Post 8854 for the premises located at 820 Concordia Ave. in St. Paul License ID No.: 0057268 Dear Sir/Madam: The Director of the Office oF License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against your licenses based on the following information: On May 25, 2003, Saint Paul Police Of�cers observed an individual inside of the Twin Star VFW who they believed to be dealing drugs. While investigating, they saw the individual, later identified as Phillip Jermaine Benson, drinking an alcoholic beverage. Benson is not a listed member of the Twin Star VFW. When asked to produce a membership and guest book, the logs appear to be virtually unreadable and contain no real information on the guests, but there is no name corresponding to Mr. Benson's on the guest log. Minn. Stat. § 340 A. 404, subd. 1(4) prohibits a club from selling alcohol to anyone other than a member or bona fide guest. Since this is your first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$1,000.00 fine, with $500.00 of the fine stayed for a period of eighteen months on the condition that you: 1) pay $500 of the fine; and 2) immediately begin keeping membership and guest logs in a readable format, to be approved by the Office of LIEP. If you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a hearing before the Saint Paul City Council to discuss the appropriate penalty, you will need to send me a letter with a statement AA-ADA-EEO Employer Twin Star VFW October 29, 2003 Page 2 0 3 -«� / admitting the violations and requesting a hearin� by Wednesday, November 5, 2003. The matter will then be scheduled before the City Councit for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and make a statement on your own behalf as to the penalty to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearin� will be scheduled before an Administrative Law Jud�e. At that hearin� both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the o[her's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council will ultimately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than November 5, 2003 how you wish to proceed. If you have not contacted me by November 5, 2003, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts and will schedule this matter for a hearing before the City Council for a consent agenda, at which time the recommended penalty will be imposed. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, � `7/�.�(�L-2�GG— U i__ �/'tiS4�`i �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attomey cc: Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Summit-University Planning Council, 627 Selby Avenue, Saint Paul, MN 55104 AA-ADA-EEO Employer 03 STATE OF MIlVNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CL.EMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on October 29, 2003, served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:- Owner/Manager Twin Staz VFW Post 8$54 820 Concordia Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55104 (which is the last known address of said person) United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. same, with postage prepaid, in the Subscribed and sworn to before me this 29th day of October, 2003. `�� `� �� .� Notary Public _� �»�v...�.�.�,�. y � ti,=.:-.,.� �tr�� Rt'�A �9 $3(}SSARD � � {�� NOP�tiC1PULiUC-MINNf_S6fA y. � " AiY COA.I1l::.:5510N ,.... EXP�RES IAN 3t.2CO5 :�,.. �..w�-..a,rw•�»�.y..� � Saint Paul Police' Department New RMS Page , of 4 ORIGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT 03- !/!( Complaint Number Reference C.N. Date and Time of RepoR 03102657 05/25/2003 00:00 Pnmary offense DRUGS-POSS OF C OCAINE PnmaryReportingOfficer. ,JONGRAHEK Nameoflocation/business: Locafion ofincident 820 CONCORDIA AV Pdmarysquad: ST PAUL MN 55104 Secondary reporting officer.� Approving o�cer. Distnct: �IVBStBff1 Site: Secondary o/fense: AttemptOnly NO CRIME SCENE DESCRIPTORS Crime Seene Processed No Type Descnption Date & time of occurence: 05/25/2003 00:00 to 05/25/2003 00:00 Arrest made? NO Appears to be Gang Re/ated NO Police ONicerAssaulted or Injured No Police ONicerASSisted Suicide �.Jp Metho & Poin o E ntry Force used No Point of entry Method Hid Inside NO SOLVABILITY FACTORS Suspect can be Identified YeS Photas Taken rJp Evidence Tumed In Y8S ey POLICE Stolen Pioperly Traceable NO PropertyTumedln YeS Lab Biologica/Analysis Np FingerynntsTaken No Narcotic Analysis Y0S Lab Comments Crime Scene Processed NO Type Descnption Items Fingerprinted SJp Method & Polnt of Entry Force used NO Point of entry Method Hidlnside No i II�.P COPY A ,��.:+:. p�:vacy Resttictions pyiY �.r � Statute 1�.R2 .� P'SLY y . PQLIC£ Saint Paul Police Department New RMS Page 2 of4 ORIGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT 03 - �l � 1 ComplaintNUmber ReferenceQN. 03102657 Pnmary oNense DRUGS-POSS OF COC AINE Date and Time of Report 05/25/2003 00:00 SOLVABILITY FACTORS Suspecf can be Identlfied rJp Photos 7aken NO Evidence Tumed In No La6 BiologicalAna/ysis (�Jp NarcoticAna(ysis NO Lab Comments By StolenPropertyTraceable No Property Tumed In Np FingerpnntsTaken NO Items Fingerpnnted NO NARRATIVE SQUAD 190 (ARNOLD/DONAHUE) MET WITH A CONFIDENTIAL RELIABLE INFORMANT EARLIER TODAY DURING OUR TOUR IN RESPONSE TO COMMUNITY COMPLAINTS OF NARCOTICS TRAFFICKING IN AND AROUND THE VFW AT 820 CONCORDIA. WE EXPLAINED TO THE CRI THAT WE HAVE BEEN HEARING SEVERAL COMPLAINTS OF PEOPLE SELLING CRACK AT THE BAR AND HAVE NOTICED DRUG ACTIVITY THERE OURSELVES AND REQUESTED THAT THE CRI ASSIST US IN IDENTIFING WHO THE DEALERS ARE AND WHEN THEY MAY BE IN POSSESSION OF C/S. THE CRI AGREED TO HELP US OUT WITH THIS. IN ADDITION TO THAT THE CRI TOLD US THAT A"LITTLE PHIL" WAS IN THE BAR ALL THE TIME AND WAS ALWAYS SELLING CRACK. I HAVE WORKED THE AREA FOR 15 YEARS AND IN THAT TIME I HAVE LEARNED THE NAMES AND NICKNAMES OF SEVERAL OF THE PEOPLE IN THE AREA. THE "LITTLE PHIL" THAT I KNOW THAT HANGS AROUND THE VFW IS BENSON, PHILLIP JERMAINE, 09-14-74. I KNOW HIM TO GO BY THE NAME OF "LITTLE PHIL" AND ALSO "PEE WEE". BUT TO BE SURE WE WERE TALKING ABOUT THE SAME PERSON, I ASKED THE CRI WHAT "LITTLE PHIL" DROVE. HE TOLD ME A GREEN VAN WITH A WHEELCHAIR LIFT OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT IN THE BACK. I KNOW THAT BENSON DRIVES, ALONG WITH HIS WIFE, A GREEN VAN WITH THE LIFT IN THE BACK AS THEY HAVE A CHILD WITH SOME SORT OF HANDICAP. I KNOW THIS BECAUSE I HAVE CITED HIM ON A COUPLE OF OCCASIONS DRIVING THIS VEHICLE. TONIGHT AT ABOUT 0140 HRS WE AGAIN SPOKE TO THE CRI. THE CRI TOLD US THAT BENSON WAS INSIDE THE VFW AND WAS SHOOTING DARTS RIGHT NOW. THE CRI SAID THAT BENSON WAS WEARING A WHITE T-SHIRT AND BLUE JEANS AND ALSO HAD A WHITE HEADBAND ON. THE CRI STATED THAT BENSON WAS DEALING CRACK AND HAD IT ON HIM RIGHT NOW. WE WENT TO THE BAR AND WALKED IN THE DOOR. THE DART BOARD IS JUST INSIDE THE DOOR TO THE RIGHT AND THE PEOPLE THROWING THE DARTS STAND ABOUT 10 TO 15 FT INSIDE OF THE FRONT DOOR. WE SAW SENSOIV STANDING THERE WITH DARTS IN HIS NAND AND IN THE PROCESS OF THROWiNG ONE. HE WAS WEARING A WHITE T-SHIRT, BLUE JEANS, AND THE W I HEADBAND MATCHING THE DESCRIPTION GIVEN TO US BY THE CRI. I APPROACHED _��IM,�$�ClVY�T� �� 'SPEAK TO HIM OUTSIDE OF THE BAR. HE SAID "OK" AND THEN PIC LL TAB BOOTH AND STOOD THERE SIPPING ON IT. AFTER A COUPLE OF�d.II�� HIM TO STEP OUTSIDE SO WE COULD TALK. HE NOW APPEARED TO� � �L �i�US AND SAID " WHAT DO YOUR WANT TO TALK TO ME ABOUT?". I TOLD HIM I WAS'fV�GOING TO TALK TO HIM IN THE BAR THAT HE NEEDED TO COME OUTSIDE WITH US. HE SAID HE WAS NOT GOING TO GO OUTSIDE WITHOUT A LAWYER. I TOLD HIM HE DIDN'T HAVE A CHOICE. HE REPLIED "CAN I DISCUSS IT WITH y T. P.�y� - Pt7LICE Saint Paui Police Department NewRMS Page 3 of4 ORIGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT D3'�l 11 Comp/aint Number Reference QN. 03102657 Primary o�fense DRUGS-POSS OF COCAINE Date and Time of Report 05/25/2003 01:07 MY WIFE FIRST? I SAID NO HE NEEDED TO COME OUTSIDE THE BAR RIGHT NOW WITH US. HE TURNED AND STARTED TO WALK INTO THE LARGE CROWD THAT WAS INSIDE OF THE BAR. I GRABBED HIM BY THE ARM AND STARTED TO PULL HIM TOWARD THE DOOR AND HE WAS GIVING ME SLIGHT RESISTANCE UNTIL I GOT HIM TO THE DOOR WHERE OFFICER DONAHUE WAS STANDING. AS WE WALKED INTO THE ENTRY WAY BENSON TRIED TO REACH INTO HIS BACK POCKET. I PULLED HIS HAND AWAY AND HE THEN STARTED TO REACH lNTO HIS LEFT FRONT POCKET AND I PULLED HIS HAND AWAY AGAIN. NOW OFFICER DONAHUE GRABBED AHOLD OF HIS RIGHT ARM AND I HAD HIS LEFT AND HE BEGAN TO STRUGGLE AND WRESTLE WITH US. HE DID THIS OUT ONTO THE SIDEWALK WHERE OFFICER DARGAY WAS PULLING UP IN HIS CAR AND JUMPED OUT TO ASSIST US WHEN HE SAW US WRESTLING WITH BENSON. WE TOOK HIM TO THE GROUND AND HANDCUFFED HIM. AT THIS TIME I RECOVERED 2 CHUNKS OF MARIJUANA FROM HIS LEFT REAR PANTS POCKET AND A PLASTIC BAGGIE CONTAINING ONE LARGE ROCK AND SEVERAL CRUMBS OF WHAT APPEARED TO BE CRACK COCAINE. IN HIS RIGHT FRONT PANTS POCKET HE HAD $428.00 IN CASH THAT WAS ALSO RECOVERED. OFFICER DARGAY TRAiVSPORTED HIM TO HQ FOR US AS WE WERE ON BIKES. AT HQ THE MONEY WAS TURNED INTO ML #2 HE WAS ISSUED A NOTICE OF FORFEITURE FOR THIS. THE MARIJUANA AND CRACK WAS TURNED INTO NL#65 FOR CS TESTING. W E SPOKE TO THE WATCH COMMANDER, MOORHEAD, AND RECEIVED PERMISSION TO STRIP SEARCH BENSON IN ATTEMPT TO RECOVER MORE NARCOTICS IF HE HAD SOME OTHERS IN HIS POSSESSION. WE DID THIS WITH NEGATIVE RESULTS. BENSON WAS BOOKED INTO THE JAIL ANNEX FOR POSSESSION OF C/S. DURING THE STRUGGLE OFFICER DONAHUES BIKE SHORTS WERE RIPPED. On the above date I, Officer Grahek of the Narcotics Unit reviewed this case. No interview was conducted of Benson, Phiilip Jermaine 09-14-74 due to the fact he referenced wanted to talk to a lawyer before speaking to Officer Arnold. While reviewing the case it was discovered that the seizure notice given to Mr. Benson was for an impaired driver. I reissued the seizure notice on the narcotics seizure form. This notice was given to Mr. Benson at the Ramsey County Jail Annex. While working on the case, Officer Pat Scatt asked me to do a judicial detainer on Mr. Benson. This request was forwarded from the arresting officer - Officer Arnold. Mr. Benson has a long criminal history. Mr. Benson also fought with the officer in a crowded bar in an attempt to avoid being arrested. The judiciai detainer request was left with the Watch Commander for review by the signing Judge. PUBLIC NARRATfVE POSSESSION OF C/S ARREST � 1'��P C� �icdons p'PY'y A a}:.r^va Sta�te 1�R2 ,�, mr,es�'ta � Saint Paul Police Department NewRMS Page 4 of4 ORIGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT 03 1 I Complant Number Reference C.N. Date and Time of Report 03102657 05/25/2003 Oi :07 Pnmary olfense DRUGS-POSS OF COCAINE Please distribute to: _CHF _Hom _Rob _Jw _Oper _PSC _Lab _Rec _Team _Sex _D/C _Burg _Theft _Prop _CAU _F&F _Auto _DAO _CO _Rptr _Vice _Narco _SIU _T&A _Other �IEP CO R��ons AP��Y i} a t:_ P, .V 1C}� ._.. 14 R� Please distribute to: ^ CHF _Hom _Rob _Sex _D/C _Burg _CO _Rptr _Vice _Juv Theft _Narco _Oper _Prop _SIU ` PSC _Lab _CAU _F&F _T&A _Other _Rec _Team _Auto _DAO „� :. _ _ % =� 0 3 - �l � I I � _. jfn ' � _ _ , '- OFFICE OF Tf� CI'PY ATTORNEY ' � - ” • ' � � � - = �s��Manue!✓. Cervantu, CiryAnomey - � CITY OF SAINT PAUL Randy C. Kelly, Mayar Telephone: 651266-87! 0 Facsimile: 657 298-5619 June 19, 2003 Manager Twin Staz VFW Post 8854 820 Concordia Avenue - �` ---- ' " - �- Sainf Paul, Minnesota 55104 RE: Investigarion into 5l25/03 Fossession Of Controlied Substance Arrest � A i <<:. i ; , � � Deaz Sir/Madam: _ � . _ _ _ _ , � . Our office is investigating the narcotics arrest which took place at the Twin Star VFW Post 8854 on May 25, 2003. For our investigation, we are requesting that you provide us with a - complete list of your members as of May 1, 2003 to the present. _ . If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at 266-8710. � SincerelY� .y. . 4 .. � �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistasit� City Attomey` •.� Ctvil Divtston � 400 CYry Hall . !s w�rxerto�atYa. Satnt Paul, Minnerota SSI01 i7: •ir? :."+,C :iL`�;C.'i.(','r.ri: ��:>+ Ii�..� l ^ T � - " .. �... , _, •�sr� :1' a� } •ti l i�i'' . ' ..o , i: . "�:' ..F. . _ � �c6:� - •ci n�.;•;, � r��-,.. ., . ." ".:, . . . .. _: . ' �.`;'... �,.. O ��;::P , . r .. . . -. � .. 1:. .� .. :.c f.` : .i�il� ;' '�t�') �O i 1J�: t�T�G:i7:' - ' �i�'" ..� _ . t%'r �� }i� 1y� j�`JL �?i:i Ilii : 7i�'.,i��.i.i' :� �'� ! � , � ,` �I..:.7t46 1. �r.�tJr � �. , . .. ....., .o,•, .._-.-.......�.. . �..!'.� . ,.��....,.�.�.... ..,... . . ., � . . .... . � . ... . ,,.: , ..�..`. i;. '� � :<. ;. i._ :i : . :Il i f ' " s M-ADA-EEQEmployer � � . � � 03-1�� f; �::> VETERANS OF FOREIGN WARS OF THE U.S. TWIN STAR POST N0. 8854 820 Concordia Avenue St. Paul, Minnesota 55104 aui 26, 2003 QuarterMaster Twin Star VFW Post 8854 820 Concordia Avenue RE: Request for Membership Roster Dear Madasn: �� JUL � � 2�03 �i i V ATT�� I apologize for the delay. The Post offers you any assistance you may require so feel free to call if there aze any other questions at 651-221-0374. Sincerely, � �� ^ c-�� ,� � � �� , � . �� Michael K. Skinner sr. QuarterMaster V E T E R A N S O F F O R E I G N W A R S O F T H E U N I T E D S T A T E S hrip://www.vfivkc.orgJmemberquery/memberResults.e II , O� II� � Member Query Results Undeliverable records are in red. t of3 7/10/2003 2:39 P� Number of Records Requested: 134 � http://www.vfwkc.org/memberquery/memberRuults. asp o3-iir� 1119689 58I335 853178 864393 IIO1968 2507136 Jl 24 553 2441 '-- �, - 24_ 51124 _ � 24 5467682 ; 24 4451527 i 24 556 _� 24 589 261 5 _ I 24 5560541 i 24 5 214586 ; 24 23939(6 _� 24 4 214184 ; 24 609567 _� 24 61lli0J_j 23 3498471__: 24 4883750 � 24 3439771 24 6104 ; 24 6039042 .' 24 2644� 24 4451529 _I 24 5315418 J ; 24 5785534 _; 24 5454952 _; 24 5G48781 ' i 24 4786225 _; 24 b??StiiG �� 6104337 ' 24 4704429_' 24 4478300 ! 24 332 338 6 _ i 24 5990095 I� ]75 Holly Ave 3637 3rd Ave S 706 Printice Cn ?2 05 Hazelwood St 517 Clover I.n I586 Sandhurs[ Dr E 7245 Guider Dr Apt 313 5319 70Ut Cir N 592 Tomlinson Ter 1522 Sextan[ Ave E 399 W heelockPkwy W 4520 58th Ave N Apt 123 700 Upton Ave N 119 Getanium Ave I 470 Glen Echo Bay 225 Triton Dr 23 Westem Ave N 77 Hamline Ave N W Lake St Apt 302 00 County Road J w 8 Ly ton PI 318 Oakland Ave 205 Van Buren Ave 554 Cohansey St 0l7 Gentle Rain Wa l49 Laurel Ave 046 Margaret St 8I7 Oakland Ave 98 Carroll Ave 620 Maryibel Cir 0 00 Highway 100 S 397 lampi Rd 45 Galtier St O Boz 65431 324 Fdgemont St 9 8 Mazshall Ave 25 Selby Ave 1 45 Dayton Ave 770 Jackson St 905 Hamline Ave N 626 Oliver Ave N 241ohnson Pkwy 280 COrtland St 9 14 Portland Ave s5 [1��'y 10 342 Fremon[ Ave N Hatch Ave nt Paul 1 Center Y nt Paut 55109 I Life Membcr 55422 j Life Member SS109� Life Member Member Membec Member Paul Paul Paul �s Ci Paul i n V� Paul Paul Paul Paul Paul Paul it eapoli: cia��a 55422 55103 55104 55408 55126 55117 55407 SSL04 SStl3 89117 SS104 55119 55417 55104 A 104 t02 104 ll7 412 104 104 104 117 2 of 3 7/10/2003 2:39 PM http://www.vfivkc.orgJmemberquery/memberResu(ts as 03 -lll I 56352 5237242 5105193 3245764 48I9777 5676483 4563918 3436676 2263409 5878422 4556771 2I2S075 2421760 6100920 5550378 607�382 3117187 60 3237891 24 ��8854 Ghee it Central Ave W � Box 7576 i57 Sander Dr 122 High(ande Dr f 751 W River Hills Di i16 Constantine Ave 76Iglehart Ave pt 106 459 Thomas Ave 7366 Dorset Ln 188 Oxford St N t I S Elway St Apt 312 025 Iake Shore Dr S ! lb 15th Ave S 060 Chazlton Si 525 Counry Road Ee O Boz 2I61 45 Wabasha St N 62l WesVninsterSt 119 Chades Ave # 1 Paul Paul �ille Paul Iake Paul Paul 5311 ',� 24 +L8854 � Thomaz Nathan 5912 P enn Ave S __� Minn eapolis _II�_ I�554t9J UnPaid _, 5 I _24 � 8854 Toliver Anthony 1295 Edmund Ave � Saint Paul � 55104 I UnPaid_ _. 2707085 J 24 � 8854 Tumer Kenneth O�J' 4312 Galenez Way Antioch CA 94531 UnPaid _ 4699746 j 24 8854 Wade HerbM RO 4436 Columbus Ave Minneapolis _� 55407 � UnPaid '�, 3 460� 24 8854 Walkw Donald � 873 Oxford St N Saint Paul O 55103 � U nPaid '�, 5t99355 , 24�8854 Walsh Jon �1829DaytonAve SaintPaul �SS104'UnPaid _�'�; 5769899 _I 24 8854 West Thomas � PO Box 65063 Saint Paul _ � 55165 UnPaid ; 4 603157 I 24 8854 Wi(liams Charles HO3021 WoodbridgeSt Rosevitle �SS113 UnPaid : 62256 � 24 8854 Williams Dennis C� 8454 Sumte� Cir N Brooklyn Park O 55445 , UnPaid ! 4829542 _i, 24 8854 Wingo � JO 1900 Arona St Rosevitle _� 55113 UnPaid ; Chancte Your Password � Return To VFW Home Paqe � VFW Feedback � Logout Best Viewed With f ' �� 1 Lh Intemet.Explorer 5.0 Copyrigh[ m Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States. Ail Rights Reserved. 3 of3 7l10/2003 2:39 P 03 - �11 I CITY OF SAINT PAUL Randy C. Kelly, Mayor August 15, 2003 QuarterMaster Michaei K. Skinner, Sr. Twin Star VFW Post 8854 820 Concordia Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55104 Dear QuarterMaster Skinner: OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Manue! J. Cervantes, Ciry Armmey Civil Division 400 Ciry Ha(1 I S West Kel[ogg Blvd. Saint P¢�d, Minrtesota 55102 Telephone: 651266-8710 Faaimile: 651 298-56( 9 Than you for providing the list of inembers in response to my letter of June 19, 2003. As I previously indicated, we ue looking at a narcotics arrest that took place at the Twin Star VFW on May 25, 2003. The police report regarding the incident indicates that an individual identified as Phillip Jermaine Benson, DOB 9-14-74, was present and drinking in the VPW when he was anested for suspicion of narcotics. As you know, your license only permits the sale or service of alcohol to members and bona fide guests. Because Mr. Benson is not listed as a member, I am writing to ask if you can provide copies of the portion of the log book you keep to record members and guests which would show that he was, in fact, a bona fide guest at the time of his arrest. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions regazding this request. Sincerely, `z � �u2� i '�.„,,,.. VirgintA D. Palmer Assistant City Attomey cc: Christine Rozek, Deputy Director AA-ADA-EEO Employer f 1 " "' i/ "' - . ._ J/ /. J=� _" _ ' _ _ "-_ � .� ' ' _"_"_ _ ' ,-, -� � � � � � � � � � � �� . . , : . -- -- ------ --------- - - -� � - - - �. , c�^�,� --- -- — -- —�-- =----- — - - ------ -- � , . — - , :� -- ------ — -- -� _ _._ __ _ . . . . g ' __ - ; ' r _ � , � ,.. . ` - � , --- � : -- - - --__ � . , ,. . '- -r------L- -�--- -_ __ ------ -------- -- , .. -- = --=----� - ------------------- _ � ::'.'_: --- -- -- _ - -- =- ---- .-- - �-'-`�/ _..__.. -- • =-'--'-_� ^: _= - -- - - --- — - - - - - � .. �,: � � - - _- .. _ _._ _ - -.�1� - ----- --- -- -- __ � � �7� �1 � c 2 .. . . ..-- -- ----- _ . _ .. - -- --�----- ,l',�� 1�!�'� ` �. --- , , . - -------_------ •-- --- - --- --- --- - --- - o"',' �''l� �._ _ CC�. � - �}s�------ - -- — - =------ --- -- — - -- ---- ----- � .. , � , - _-e.�_ -- ' '_"_L.._..�� ._"' _""_'"'" _ ' "�__"'_'_"_'_"-"_'.___'".. " _ ' .... .-= �-._�_ _ . . i /^`//,/� \ ' __ ' ""_'-'�__-..____`"____"- .. __ __ . . - ' __" '_ ' _ _"' _- " ""_'"""_ . ' . ' . v � �" ' , _ _._ _ �-- �� -- "� ----------1- ' - - �- . � --- ' -.z.� _��_- ' --'- - � �- �- � ...: - � - - S, . -- '----- ---'--'------------ _ ---� � �� . � ; . ' � - � - - - - - ------ - - , � \ ,_ . _ �-- -- -- - . -= - -- ----- +----`-- -- �---- -- - - - ---- ----- --- _.. , , �,' � \ � : � � . ,: , ' � - �--'--- -- - -- - -----�-------- -- - _ - -- �_ ' ' - �' -- ---- - ----- -- - -- - ` - � ----- ------- - � - - �--- �� _ , . -- - - - ---- -- - - ------- -- - - � . __- ------- , �- - , � ,� w � , ,, - � �-- ----- --- ---- --- --�-� - ----- --- -- - � , -, - `�` �'� l � - - . � ,. , ---- - - - -- - - _ �� ,r \ ' � '_ _ -' � i�' - _ "_ � . _ . . . . . ' '_ ' ' "'__ ' _' ' __'. _. �� /- ' i ' . _ �� .�� ' . '_.____. ._ ...____ . - . _'_ " -____ __ i _ "_'__ '_ __ ' __" " ' __.. ._ .' _ ' _'.. . , � '_'_ "_ '_'__ ___-_- _ ' - '_ � ' ' ' _ _ _ , ' "_ _ � > . . _" ___ '_' ___ '_' _ _� ,.., . ' - ____-___ _'_'__ ___'_' "_ "f � _'_'__ _'_' _"-' ' ""__-"___'___ __'_'__-"' -_- ' _ 4 r� j� �Q ll� �� , , ✓ " i ;� f . � �� _ --- - ____ _ _ - -- - -�-- , , - _ _ -- � � __ __ -- _ _ _ �r�� -- -- _ ��-� � - - � ��, �- -- - ___ _ -- - ___ .- - , , - - - �.- � , . _ �- , _ - - �� - -� l J -✓� _ = _ _ __ _- - - _- _ .__ __ -� �- _ _ - - , , - __--- -- - _ - ; _, � . _ ____ -- _ _.� . � __ .__ , _ : -- ,� , - , -- � �- ° __ - __ _ --=---- _ -_ - -- .. _-- , � �: _-- ------ ; ___ _ - -- : ;, _- __ _ ___ - _ _ __. , __ . � _, _ _.--- . , : _- - - _- � . _ __- , _- _. __ .f � '.,.-- � / �J ,_ - ��..__" . �f� �. _ , _ .... , Y , �-- _. t/ � - ^"' � --� " " �'GUG�_ _� = - _ \ � " - -- - " � !Ci!'_� -- _ �= ,��; _ - _._�----- _- ��' _ _ -- � -- -- -^--- - � ,� _ _ - � � -- �,1 -� � _ - -- -� __ =--- - �� _ �- - - _ .... _ I a�� n _ .._------ ` — - _ _ - _ — ,,�✓� _.. C� �(/��l�v -\ ._-- _ — � __ __ _... � �"�n' �� - -__-- _ _ .. - _ - ___. _ - __ - _ _ - ._ _ - .__-- - % - . -- - ��..�J--- - --- f `,_ � -- - - - --- _ . - � . _ ---- - � --- , , �_ -_ _ _ � _ � --- _ -_ �:� � --- -- _ ' _ __ _- _ - _ �. C,,2 �J� _ _ - - __ __.. - _ .- _ � .-- ----- . - ] -- � . - -- --� _--- � - f- ,._ . _ � , . _ _ --- _ _ �'; /� -�.. ---- - _--- - � ;= -- - --- - , . -- � , ____-.- /� ` �: . _ " - -- _ _ - (� �/�� - -_- - - - _ r �� . _ , �.- -� . __ _. , __ � -= _ . _ _- - �,�---. � . _ ..:.�:� %��,� -.... , ,_ .- _ ,y y ,! � 03-I11 � , �� ____ �_ _ � -- - - --- - - - - - - - __ . � ---- - --- -- - --- -- - -- _ .-. --- - - �- - ----_ _ - - -- -- - - ,__ . _ � - --- -- -------- --- - - -- _ --t= � - - _� -- . - -- --- ---.- { --- - -- - - - ---- --_. _ __: -_� --��-�-`__ - ` - _-_�- - - -- - - __ - . ----- -- - - - ___ - - ��-- �,.� .�.�,�-< _ _ _ -- --- - . �� ____ _ I �___- - , �-- _____ __ _� ��:__.. �_-- -- - - - _ � �_------ �. -- � _ _ -- . -�---�� -- __. _ _ _ - , �,��,,, , __ i _ ,�.__= _ _ , �� , � �� - --- �"/�c.c,� _._�. �--� �-�- 1 �r-= ' - -�- -- `- �._._. .'�- . .� , - - -� , , - , -.-- ---- �2�,,, , �� - - - �� 03-�� i � �r�s'�� --- ��-�-�" � - - r - - -- , _ . -- - ---- - --- - -- - _ _ .. . _ _ ---- -- - �- � _-- . - ---- - - - � __ __- - - --- -- � -- q � _ --- `/V ----� � � - _._ - -- ~ c �/ �� -� ------ -- - _.._ - ---- - - - - -- -- - - • , ___._.. - --- - �� - --- - - - - - - - - ---- __ `�^-� .. , ._. __ — �..._. _ _ _ _. . . _ - - ---•- - - - - - - -- • - , .._.._ ._ - - - ---- -- -- -- - --- � --- ---- _. �- --' ,� - - - - ; , - _ -- - - --- - --- � - --- - .. . _ . . _ , - -- � — -- - � - ._ -- -- -- _. ------ -- - -- --�,� _ , _.._ __ � � -- -----�`� -- ---- , ..- - -___ __ � _ . �_ ._. - - - � - : � �: '��'Z.i _ ., - - - - -- - ---- --- - % � ��9--�� -- - - - ��' -- - -- - - .. � � --------- -c: - �� _- \ �- _ �- - � � � J , � - -- -- _...__ .-- - - - -� - - „_ � . �� 4 . G /L'� � -- .-- _ -�� G -- '� � ` i i' 1 d , .... - - \ � -11 _r�_ .�� - - - — - �- . � ,. --- � - , - -- -- -- ---_ --- --� j -� -- - - -- — - , , , ✓ -a'-K-�-- ., `�= " - n -- -- ---- ----=- --- - - --- - -- - `' • - , r. -;�, _ � - - -�+�- - ---- ----'------- ---- - -- -- � - '�''- - -, _. . . . ._ ._ ._.___ �,�1 -- + -- �� 1". r"�� :�=7� , _. _ ...- - -�-� -- - - -` --- — - - - -- '` - - -�r�.G'f�� / � � Yr .w'.�2."-C�� ,. - �` - _.1 - ? ��°---- � � ., . _ ._..._ - -----__---- -- ----....` _--- ----- =-_ . i . �":'...- - __ { . _- - ---- -------- -- - -. _.._ . . - -- - :.= r �.. t� 2a y--� , , ; - � - ----- ---- - ----- - �. -�---- - - � �_ - - - - - _ --- --- ---- - - -. . - --- - - - - ------ ----- - -- ---- - - � � _.. 4--- -- - _----.. - -..- � ---_ - -- - - - - - - �� -. . I � } ,� ✓� � �� r, � , �/- �`�--- - ' �`'1`� � � i, �, " Gr.%"� -- � �-- � - - - - - -- -- - -W -- ,�--� _-- _._ . ' _ , _- - ----°---- - --- -- _- ---- -- __ . _ . _ , , . �... � �� . ---- - - -- -- - v • - - - -- - - -- - - - - - -1 - --� _ .. _ - -- -- - - - - -- - -- - - - -- � -- - - - - - - - __ --- - _ _ . , � � �--_. - -- - ---------- -- --, -- -- ---- - �`/�� gl�'t�iGiW.'?�56.' +n+�:..rs=; _ �' - 03-1it1 �- �� , -- _- -- ---- - - -- --,-, -- - -- -- --- --- - Y �- , ,_ .�_-_ - - - ---- ---- ----- =� -- --- � �� ' - ' z- --- -- - --- - - - . �D m�." ✓ ; D3-ll!/ � � G=�� 0 � - '� � -s . __ - _� �- - -. - -- %'� _�� _ _-.-- _ _-__�--��_=- - _� -- - . _ __ _ �Z _ � -�- - - �-�� f �-------_ _ ,_----�-- � -- `-�' �_ -- __ ---- --- - -- f- - . . - - �---- � �-- --- - ----- - - . . _ . .- - - - - ---- "J�� - ------ - - --�- -- -- - . . - ...- -----. - - - _ _. - --...- - -- -- - - - - , . . .l __ .._L _ -----._._ G � - �_ _ . _ ��. � - • ... . _,__' ., ... -- - - .. . - --, __ -1-- . _ - - _ - - - - _ ,.�� - �/ 1_ Y✓ _.._... ., - _ , � -- � , • �_ ' .C � __ ._ .� � _�____ __ � �� _, __-,-,. ' �_" K,�,t�-- - - `�'� � � _ v�-- - -��-`-- . _ ��-- � _ �.��. _ _ _ _ ��\� VETERMIS OF FOREIGN WARS OF THE U.S. iWIN STAR POST N0. 8854 820 Concordia Avenue Si. Paul, Minnesota 55104 �� W �� NOV 04 2�03 ��TY �T�UR�1�� November 4, 2003 Quartermaster Michael K. Skinner Sr. Assistant City Attorney Virgi►zia D. Pa[mes Re: Yourfinerecommendation. Post # 8854 dues request a hearing before the City Council. Quartermaster Michael�'K. S 'nne�LSn ! � � /�� "�`_"_�— D3 /l1 / V E T E R A N S O F F O R E I G N W A R 5 O f T H E U N I T E D 5 T A T E S